The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The prisoners should be allowed to maintain their family and social ties. They should also be given an opportunity to solve their personal and family problems and to enable them to maintain their links with society. So far as the apprehensions, which have been expressed, in this case, are concerned, reasonable/ stringent conditions can be imposed, in case, the relief, as claimed in the writ petition, is granted to the petitioner.
17. In view of the above, the rejection order dated 6th August, 2025 (Annexure P-1), does not pass the judicial scrutiny of this Court. As such, the same is quashed and set aside. The prayer, so made in the application (Annexure R-2/3) is allowed and the petitioner is ordered to be released on parole, for a period of 28 days.
18. Accordingly, the present petition is allowed, in the following terms: (i) Order, dated 6th August, 2025 (Annexure P1), rejecting the request of the petitioner for parole, is quashed and set-aside; (ii) Respondents are directed to extend the concession of parole to the petitioner, for a period of 28 days, on his furnishing a personal 2026:HHC:2314 bond in the sum of ₹ 1,00,000/-, with two sureties in the like amount, to the satisfaction of Superintendent of Jail, Model Central Jail, Kanda, District Shimla, H.P.; (iii) It is made clear that the petitioner shall surrender before Superintendent of Jail, Model Central Jail, Kanda, District Shimla, H.P., on expiry of parole period. In case, the petitioner breaches any of the conditions of parole order or creates any law and order problem, then, the respondents are free to cancel the parole and take action against the petitioner, in accordance with law; (iv) In peculiar facts and circumstances, of the case, the respondents are at liberty to impose any other just and reasonable condition(s), in addition to the conditions mentioned hereinabove, if deemed fit and proper, to meet the ends of justice; (v) Violation of any of the above conditions shall be treated as a negative factor for consideration of similar prayer, in future.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:2314
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.
:20372 of 2025
Reserved on :
07.01.2026
Decided on
08.01.2026
Suresh Kumar
:
…Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and others
…Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
: Mr. Saurav Rattan, Advocate.
For the respondents : Mr. Tejasvi Sharma, Mr. Mohinder
Zharaick and Mr. H.S. Rawat,
Additional Advocates General, with
Mr. Rohit Sharma and Ms. Ranjana
Patial, Deputy Advocate General.
Virender Singh, Judge.
By way of the present writ petition, petitionerSuresh Kumar has invoked the extra ordinary writ
jurisdiction of this Court, under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, seeking the following substantive
relief, amongst others:
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:2314
“i) That the petitioner may kindly be granted
parole according to his entitlement as per
rules.”
2.
According to the petitioner, he is undergoing
imprisonment
in
a
complaint
under
Negotiable
Instruments Act and is in judicial custody for the last more
than one year.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that his wife is
residing alone and is not keeping good health.
4.
The petitioner applied for grant of parole,
however, the said application of the petitioner is stated to
have been rejected, on 6th August, 2025, vide Annexure P1, without assigning any justifiable reason.
5.
On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to quash and set aside the order, by virtue of
which, the request of the petitioner for releasing him on
parole, has been rejected. A prayer has also been made to
allow his request for parole.
6.
When put to notice, the State has filed the
reply, mentioning therein, that the petitioner has been
convicted by various Courts in nine different complaints
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, out
2026:HHC:2314
of which, he has completed his sentence in six cases, is
undergoing sentence in seventh case and the sentence in
two cases is yet to be executed.
7.
It has also not been disputed that the petitioner
had applied for grant of 28 days’ parole, on 19th March,
2025 (Annexure R-2/3), in order to meet his family.
8.
According to the respondents, the request of the
petitioner was duly forwarded to the District Authorities,
i.e. District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police,
Hamirpur. In pursuance of the same, District Magistrate,
Hamirpur, has not recommended the prayer of the
petitioner, on the ground that the petitioner is very clever
and cunning person and used to live outside the house and
may abscond if released on parole.
9.
The
other
allegations
have
also
been
controverted by the respondents.
10.
On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to dismiss the writ petition.
11.
As
per
the
Certificate
of
Imprisonment
(Annexure R-2/2), the petitioner was admitted in Model
Central Jail, Kanda, Shimla, on 4th March, 2022, to
2026:HHC:2314
undergo sentence in nine cases, out of which he has
undergone sentence in six cases and presently, undergoing
sentence in seventh case. The petitioner has applied for 28
days’ parole, which was recommended to be rejected by the
District Magistrate, Hamirpur, vide letter, dated 6th August,
2025.
12.
The primary purpose of releasing the convict on
parole has elaborately been discussed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in Asfaq versus State of Rajasthan and
others, reported in (2017) 15 SCC 55. Relevant paras-17
to 24, of the judgment, are reproduced, as under:
“17. From the aforesaid discussion, it follows
that amongst the various grounds on which
parole can be granted, the most important
ground, which stands out, is that a prisoner
should be allowed to maintain family and
social ties. For this purpose, he has to come
out for some time so that he is able
to maintain his family and social contact. This
reason finds justification in one of the
objectives behind sentence and punishment,
namely, reformation of the convict. The theory
of criminology, which is largely accepted,
underlines that the main objectives which a
State intends to achieve by punishing the
culprit are: deterrence, prevention, retribution
and
reformation.
When
we
recognise
reformation as one of the objectives, it provides
justification
for
letting
of
even
the
life convicts for short periods, on parole, in
order to afford opportunities to such convicts
not only to solve their personal and family
2026:HHC:2314
problems but also to maintain their links
with the society. Another objective which this
theory underlines is that even such convicts
have right to breathe fresh air, albeit for
periods. These gestures on the part of the
State, along with other measures, go a long
way for redemption and rehabilitation of such
prisoners. They are ultimately aimed for the
good of the society and, therefore, are in public
interest.
18. The provisions of parole and furlough,
thus, provide for a humanistic approach
towards those lodged in jails. Main
purpose of such provisions is to afford to them
an opportunity to solve their personal and
family problems and to enable them to
maintain their links with society. Even
citizens of this country have a vested interest
in preparing offenders for successful re-entry
into society. Those who leave prison without
strong
networks
of
support,
without
employment prospects, without a fundamental
knowledge of the communities to which they
will return, and without resources, stand a
significantly higher chance of failure. When
offenders revert to criminal activity upon
release, they frequently do so because they
lack hope of merging into society as accepted
citizens. Furloughs or parole can help prepare
offenders for success.
19. Having noted the aforesaid public purpose
in granting parole or furlough, ingrained in the
reformation theory of sentencing, other
competing public interest has also to be kept in
mind while deciding as to whether in a
particular case parole or furlough is to be
granted or not. This public interest also
demands that those who are habitual
offenders and may have the tendency to
commit the crime again after their release on
parole or have the tendency to become
threat to the law and order of the society,
should not be released on parole. This aspect
takes care of other objectives of sentencing,
2026:HHC:2314
namely, deterrence and prevention. This side
of the coin is the experience that great number
of crimes are committed by the offenders who
have been put back in the street after
conviction. Therefore, while deciding as to
whether a particular prisoner deserves to be
released on parole or not, the aforesaid
aspects have also to be kept in mind. To put it
tersely, the authorities are supposed to
address the question as to whether the convict
is such a person who has the tendency to
commit such a crime or he is showing
tendency to reform himself to become a good
citizen.
20. Thus, not all people in prison are
appropriate for grant of furlough or parole.
Obviously, society must isolate those who
show patterns of preying upon victims. Yet
administrators ought to encourage those
offenders who demonstrate a commitment to
reconcile with society and whose behaviour
shows that aspire to live as law-abiding
citizens. Thus, parole program should be used
as a tool to shape such adjustments.
21. To sum up, in introducing penal reforms,
the State that runs the administration on
behalf of the society and for the benefit of the
society at large cannot be unmindful of
safeguarding the legitimate rights of the
citizens in regard to their security in the
matters of life and liberty. It is for this
reason that in introducing such reforms, the
authorities cannot be oblivious of the obligation
to the society to render it immune from those
who are prone to criminal tendencies and have
proved their susceptibility to indulge in
criminal activities by being found guilty (by a
Court) of having perpetrated a criminal act.
One of the discernible purposes of imposing
the penalty of imprisonment is to render the
society immune from the criminal for a
specified
period.
It
is,
therefore,
understandable that while meting out humane
treatment to the convicts, care has to be taken
2026:HHC:2314
to ensure that kindness to the convicts does
not result in cruelty to the society. Naturally
enough, the authorities would be anxious
to ensure that the convict who is released on
furlough does not seize the opportunity to
commit another crime when he is at large for
the time-being under the furlough leave
granted to him by way of a measure of penal
reform.
22. Another vital aspect that needs to be
discussed is as to whether there can be any
presumption
that
a
person
who
is
convicted of serious or heinous crime is to be,
ipso facto, treated as a hardened criminal.
Hardened criminal would be a person for
whom it has become a habit or way of life and
such a person would necessarily tend to
commit crimes again and again. Obviously, if a
person has committed a serious offence for
which he is convicted, but at the same
time it is also found that it is the only crime he
has committed, he cannot be categorized as a
hardened criminal. In his case consideration
should be as to whether he is showing the
signs to reform himself and become a
good citizen or there are circumstances which
would indicate that he has a tendency to
commit the crime again or that he would be a
threat to the society. Mere nature of
the offence committed by him should not be a
factor to deny the parole outrightly. Wherever
a person convicted has suffered incarceration
for a long time, he can be granted
temporary parole, irrespective of the nature of
offence for which he was sentenced. We may
hasten to put a rider here, viz. in those cases
where a person has been convicted for
committing a serious office, the competent
authority, while examining such cases, can be
well advised to have stricter standards in
mind while judging their cases on the
parameters of god conduct, habitual offender
or while judging whether he could be
considered highly dangerous or prejudicial to
the public peace and tranquility etc.
2026:HHC:2314
23. There can be no cavil in saying that a
society that believes in the worth of the
individuals
can
have
the
quality
of its belief judged, at least in part, by the
quality of its prisons and services and
recourse made available to the prisoners.
Being in a civilized society organized with law
and a system as such, it is essential to ensure
for every citizen a reasonably dignified life. If a
person commits any crime, it does not mean
that by committing a crime, he ceases to be
a human being and that he can be deprived of
those aspects of life which constitute human
dignity. For a prisoner all fundamental rights
are
an
enforceable
reality,
though
restricted by the fact of imprisonment. {See –
Sunil Batra (II) v. State (UT of Delhi) (1980) 3
SCC 488 , Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India
(1978) 1 SCC 248 and Charles Sobraj v.
Superintendent Central Jai, Tihar, New Delhi,
(1978) 4 SCC 104.
24. It is also to be kept in mind that by the
time an application for parole is moved by a
prisoner, he would have spent some time in
the
jail. During this
period, various
reformatory methods must have been applied.
We can take judicial note of this fact, having
regard to such reformation facilities available
in modern jails. One would know by this
time as to whether there is a habit of relapsing
into crime in spite of having administered
correctional treatment. This habit known as
“recidivism” reflects the fact that the
correctional therapy has not brought in the
mind of the criminal. It also shows that
criminal is hardcore who is beyond
correctional therapy. If the correctional therapy
has not made in itself, in a particular case,
such a case can be rejected on the aforesaid
ground i.e. on its merits.”
(self emphasis supplied)
13.
2026:HHC:2314
In light of the above decision, this Court would
now proceed to consider the facts as to whether the relief of
parole, as sought in the petition, on the ground to meet the
family members, can be granted to the petitioner and that
the rejection of the petitioner’s prayer, seeking his release
on parole, is sustainable in the eyes of law.
14.
Considering the case of the petitioner, in view of
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Asfaq’s case
(supra), this Court is of the view that the term ‘sufficient
cause’ is to be interpreted, in view of the beneficial nature
of the statutory provisions, in the Act, which are aimed at
reformation and rehabilitation of the prisoners, as well as,
enabling
the
petitioner
to
socialize
with
his
family
members. As such, the same can be said to be a ‘sufficient
cause’.
15.
The ground, upon which, the prayer of the
petitioner has been declined by the respondents, is the
recommendation
Hamirpur.
made
by
the
District
Magistrate,
The said recommendation has been made on
the ground that the petitioner is very clever and cunning
2026:HHC:2314
person and used to live outside the house and may
abscond if released on parole.
16.
The prisoners should be allowed to maintain
their family and social ties. They should also be given an
opportunity to solve their personal and family problems
and to enable them to maintain their links with society. So
far as the apprehensions, which have been expressed, in
this case, are concerned, reasonable/ stringent conditions
can be imposed, in case, the relief, as claimed in the writ
petition, is granted to the petitioner.
17.
In view of the above, the rejection order dated
6th August, 2025 (Annexure P-1), does not pass the judicial
scrutiny of this Court. As such, the same is quashed and
set aside.
The prayer, so made in the application
(Annexure R-2/3) is allowed and the petitioner is ordered
to be released on parole, for a period of 28 days.
18.
Accordingly, the present petition is allowed, in
the following terms:
(i) Order, dated 6th August, 2025 (Annexure P1), rejecting the request of the petitioner for
parole, is quashed and set-aside;
(ii) Respondents are directed to extend the
concession of parole to the petitioner, for a
period of 28 days, on his furnishing a personal
2026:HHC:2314
bond in the sum of ₹ 1,00,000/-, with two
sureties in the like amount, to the satisfaction
of Superintendent of Jail, Model Central Jail,
Kanda, District Shimla, H.P.;
(iii)
It is made clear that the petitioner shall
surrender before Superintendent of Jail, Model
Central Jail, Kanda, District Shimla, H.P., on
expiry of parole period. In case, the petitioner
breaches any of the conditions of parole order
or creates any law and order problem, then,
the respondents are free to cancel the parole
and take action against the petitioner, in
accordance with law;
(iv) In peculiar facts and circumstances, of the
case, the respondents are at liberty to impose
any other just and reasonable condition(s), in
addition
to
the
conditions
mentioned
hereinabove, if deemed fit and proper, to meet
the ends of justice;
(v) Violation of any of the above conditions
shall be treated as a negative factor for
consideration of similar prayer, in future.
19.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any,
shall also stand disposed of, accordingly.
20.
Registry to communicate this order to the
Superintendent of Jail, Model Central Jail, Kanda, District
Shimla, H.P., for compliance.
( Virender Singh )
Judge
January 08, 2026
( rajni )
RAJNI
RAJNI
Date: 2026.01.08
11:14:09 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review