Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
243+251
Date of decision: 05.03.2026
1.
CWP-30248-2025
Harjinder Singh Sidhu
....Petitioner
VERSUS
Municipal Council, Bathinda and another
...Respondents
2.
CWP-38707-2025
Suresh Kumar
..Petitioner
Versus
Municipal Corporation, Bathinda and another
…Respondents
3.
CWP-5998-2026
Harvinder Singh
..Petitioner
Versus
Municipal Corporation, Bathinda and another
…Respondents
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present:
Mr. Abhishek Singla with Ms. Tanya Sehgal, Advocate for the
petitioner(s)
Mr. Sanjeev Soni, Advocates for the respondents in CWP30248-2025.
Ms. Deepali Puri, Advocate with Mr. Arjun Singh Dhaliwal,
Advocate for the respondents in CWP-38707-2025.
Mr. Parminder Singh, Advocate for the respondents in CWP5998-2026.
HARPREET SINGH BRAR, J. (Oral)
1.
This common judgment shall dispose of all the aforementioned
petitions as they arise from a similar factual matrix. However, for the sake of
brevity, the facts are taken from CWP-30248-2025.
2.
The present civil writ petition has been filed under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India for issuance of a writ in the nature of
mandamus directing the respondents to regularize the services of the
petitioner as Clerk-Cum-Data Entry Operator and grant all consequential
benefits, including arrears of pay, seniority, and promotion, since he has
been working on the said post for the last 15 years, without any break in
service, against a vacant sanctioned post.
CONTENTIONS
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, inter alia, contends that the
petitioner is a well-qualified employee with a graduation, a Post-Graduate
diploma in Computer Applications as well as a Master’s degree in Computer
Applications. He was initially appointed as a Data Entry Operator through
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
an outsourcing agency on 07.05.2010 (Annexure P-2). Vide order dated
11.05.2010 (Annexure P-3), he was posted in the office of the Legal
Advisor, Health Department, Municipal Corporation, Bathinda. He further
submits that although the service provider i.e. the outsourcing agency
through which the petitioner was hired, changed over the years i.e. in 2012,
2014, and 2019, the petitioner continued to serve the respondent-Municipal
Corporation on the same post, without any break in service. Thus, he has
been discharging work of perennial nature for the respondent-Municipal
Corporation for over 15 years. Further, the petitioner has been contributing
towards the Employees’ Provident Fund from his salary since the year 2010.
As such, it is evident that the petitioner, though initially appointed through
the outsourcing agencies, has essentially been an employee of the
respondent-Municipal Corporation.
4.
Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner has been
serving against a sanctioned post. He further pointed out that as per the
budget for the year 2025–26, out of 76 sanctioned posts of Clerk-cum-Data
Entry Operator, 40 posts are lying vacant. Further still, the petitioner is also
eligible for regularization under Section 3 of The Punjab Ad Hoc,
Contractual, Daily Wage, Temporary, Work Charged and Outsourced
Employees' Welfare Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as “Act of 2016”), as
he had completed three years of service before the Act of 2016 came into
force. Moreover, similarly situated employees, appointed as Firemen and
Drivers in the year 2013, were regularized vide resolution dated 08.05.2017,
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
which was subsequently approved by the State Government. Despite
submitting representations dated 05.05.2017 and 30.10.2021 (Annexures P-4
and P8, respectively), the claim of the petitioner for regularization has not
been considered. Placing reliance upon the judgments rendered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jaggo v. Union of India 2025 AIR SC 296 ,
Vinod Kumar and others v. Union of India and others (2024) 9 SCC 327,
and Shripal and Another v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 221, learned counsel contends that the State, especially in its role as a
model employer, is duty bound to ensure that the workers employed by it are
provided fair and stable employment, where they do not face any
exploitation. Not only is this such an approach necessary for smooth
functioning of the relevant employer-organisation but it also ensures that the
workers are adequately compensated for the service provided by them. Thus,
considering that the petitioner has rendered uninterrupted service of 15
years, he cannot be deprived of the fruits of his labour, merely because his
initial appointment was through an outsourcing agency. Further, the factual
matrix makes it evident that the petitioner has served the respondentMunicipal Corporation akin to its regular employees and therefore, he must
be considered for regularisation.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
vires of the Act of 2016 were challenged before this Court in CWP No. 4187
of 2017 titled as Anika Gupta v. State of Punjab and others. He further
argues that the Government of Punjab filed an affidavit dated 16.08.2018 in
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
Anika Gupta (supra) which clearly stated that the Act of 2016 has been
repealed by it and shall be replaced with a new bill, which is currently under
process. Thus, the Act of 2016 was never implemented and therefore, the
petitioner cannot invoke it to claim benefit of regularisation. Learned
counsel submits that the petitioner was appointed through an outsourcing
agency and as such, he cannot claim parity with the contractual Firemen and
Drivers of the Municipal Corporation, Bathinda, who had moved CWP No.
11106 of 2021 before this Court. Moreover, the Government of Punjab does
not have a policy which allows for regularisation of outsourced employees.
As such, there is no vested right in the petitioner to claim regularisation and
accordingly, the present writ petition deserves dismissal.
OBSERVATION & ANALYSIS
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon perusal
of the record with their able assistance, it transpires that the petitioner was
initially engaged by the respondent-Municipal Corporation through an
outsourcing agency in the year 2010.
7.
Employer-Employer Relationship
It appears that the outsourcing agencies through which the
petitioner was engaged kept changing over the years. In spite of a change in
outsourcing agencies in the years 2012, 2014 and 2019, the petitioner
continued to work as a Clerk-cum-Data Entry Operator with the respondentMunicipal Corporation, without any break in service since the year 2010 till
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
date, uninfluenced by the said change. Further, the respondent- Municipal
Corporation has issued Experience Certificate dated 25.09.2025 (Annexure
P-9) to the petitioner, acknowledging the qualitative service rendered by him
since 07.10.2010. The factum of issuance of Experience Certificate
(Annexure P-9) to the petitioner by the respondent-Municipal Corporation,
and not the outsourcing agency through which he was engaged, is indicative
of an employer-employee relationship between them.
8.
At this juncture, it may be profitable to refer to the judgment
rendered by a four-Judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Dharangadhara Chemical Works Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra 1956 INSC
71, wherein, speaking through Justice N.H. Bhagwati, the following was
observed:
“14. The principle which emerges from these authorities is that the
prima facie test for the determination of the relationship between
master and servant is the existence of the fight in the master to
supervise and control the work done by the servant not only in the
matter of directing what work the servant is to do but also the
manner in which he shall do his work, or to borrow the words of
Lord Uthwatt at page 23 in Mercy Docks and Harbour Board v.
Coggins and Griffith (Liverpool) Ltd., 1947-1 AC 1, at p. 23.
"The proper test is whether or not the hirer had authority to
control the manner of execution of the act in question."”
Reliance in this regard may also be placed on the judgement rendered the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Workmen of Nilgiri Coop. Mktg. Soc. Ltd. v.
State of Tamil Nadu 2004 INSC 89.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
9.
Further, three-Judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Hussainbhai v. Alath Factory Tezhilali Union 1978 INSC 118, speaking
through Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, opined as follows:
“5. The true test may, with brevity, be indicated once again. Where a
worker or group of workers labours to produce goods or services and
these goods or services are for the business of another, that other is,
in fact, the employer. He has economic control over the worker's
subsistence, skill, and continued employment. If he, for any reason,
chokes off, the worker is, virtually, laid off. The presence of
intermediate contractors with whom alone the workers have
immediate or direct relationship ex contractu is of no consequence
when, on lifting the veil or looking at the conspectus of factors
governing employment, we discern the naked truth, though draped
in different perfect paper arrangement, that the real employer is the
Management, not the immediate contractor. Myriad devices, halfhidden in fold after fold of legal form depending on the degree of
concealment needed, the type of industry, the local conditions and the
like, may be resorted to when labour legislation casts welfare
obligations on the real employer, based on Arts, 38-39-42, 43 and 43A of the Constitution. The court must be astute to avoid the mischief
and achieve the purpose of the law and not be misled by the maya of
legal appearances.
6. If the livelihood of the workmen substantially depends on labour
rendered to produce goods and services for the benefit and
satisfaction of an enterprise, the absence of direct relationship or
the presence of dubious intermediaries or the make-believe
trappings of detachment from the Management cannot snap the
real-life bond. The story may vary but the inference defies ingenuity.
The liability cannot be shaken off.”
10.
A conjoint reading of Dharangadhara Chemical Works
(supra) and Hussainbhai (supra) indicates that in order to establish an
employer-employee relationship, emphasis must be on the substance of the
arrangement rather than its form. As such, the primary test to determine
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
existence of an employer-employee relationship is- whether the principal
employer exercises control and supervision, not only over the work assigned
to the employee but also the manner of its execution. Additionally, the
Courts must also examine if the livelihood and continued employment of the
employee are substantially dependent upon the principal employer. As such,
where the situation satisfies the aforementioned parameters, the Court is
required to lift the veil of contractual arrangements to discern the real nature
of the relationship and not be misled by the ‘legal appearances and
documents.’ An arrangement structured through dubious intermediaries or
layered contractual devices, cannot be allowed to defeat the reality of
employment. Therefore, if, upon overall assessment, the principal entity is
found to have continuous and effective engagement with the workman, the
law disregards such intermediaries as mere conduits and recognizes the
principal employer as the true employer.
11.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present
case, it is evident that the respondent- Municipal Corporation exercises
effective
control
and
supervision
over
the
petitioner’s
work.
Notwithstanding the periodic change of outsourcing agencies in the years
2012, 2014 and 2019, the consistent presence of the respondent- Municipal
Corporation as the principal entity, coupled with the shifting nature of the
intermediaries, clearly demonstrates that such agencies were merely
conduits or paper arrangements. Thus, upon lifting the veil of the
contractual/outsource arrangement in the present case, it is revealed that the
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
real employer-employee relationship subsists between the petitioner and the
respondent- Municipal Corporation, rendering the intermediary agencies
inconsequential in the eyes of law.
12.
In terms of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Bengal Nagpur Cotton Mills v. Bharat Lal 2011 (1) SCC 635, where the
contract between the principal employer and the contractor is found to be a
sham, nominal or a mere camouflage to deny employment benefits, the
industrial adjudicator is empowered to treat the workman as a direct
employee of the principal employer. In the present case, the continuous
engagement of the petitioner with the respondent – Municipal Corporation,
independent of the outsourcing agency, and the element of control and
supervision exercised by it clearly indicates that the outsourcing
arrangement was, in effect, a sham contract which merits piercing the
dubious veil of such intermediary agencies. Reliance in this regard may also
be placed on the judgement rendered by a Constitutional Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Steel Authority of India Ltd. v. National Union
Water Front Workers 2001 (7) SCC 1, which while speaking through
Justice Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri observed as under,
“106. An analysis of the cases, discussed above, shows that they fall in
three classes : (i) where contract labour is engaged in or in
connection with the work of an establishment and employment of
contract labour is prohibited either because the Industrial
adjudicator/Court ordered abolition of contract labour or because the
appropriate Government issued notification under Section 10(1) of
the CLRA Act, no automatic absorption of the contract labour
working in the establishment was ordered; (ii) where the contract
was found to be sham and nominal rather a camouflage in which
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
case the contract labour working in the establishment of the
principal employer was held, in fact and in reality, the employees of
the principal employer himself. Indeed, such cases do not relate to
abolition of contract labour but present instances wherein the Court
pierced the veil and declared the correct position as a fact at the
stage after employment of contract labour stood prohibited; (iii)
where in discharge of a statutory obligation of maintaining canteen in
an establishment the principal employer availed the services of a
contractor and the courts have held that the contract labour would
indeed be the employees of the principal employer.” (Emphasis
supplied)
13.
Application of Act of 2016
Clearly, the petitioner is an outsourced employee. However,
before delving further into the matter, it must be clarified that after
considering similar arguments raised by learned counsel for the respondents
regarding the Act of 2016, this Court in Akash Sharma v. State of Punjab
and others in CWP No.12434 of 2023 decided on 13.02.2026 has
categorically held that the said Act still has the force of law. The relevant
part thereof is reproduced below:
“27. In view of the foregoing discussion, the questions framed above
are answered in the following terms:
a. ‘The Punjab Ad hoc, Contractual, Daily Wage, Temporary, Work
Charged and Outsourced Employees’ Welfare Act, 2016’ has not been
repealed and continues to remain in full force. Since ‘The Punjab
Protection and Regularization of Contractual Employees Bill, 2021’
never attained the assent of the Governor of Punjab, it cannot be said
to have the force of law and Section 14 thereof, cannot be considered
to have repealed the Act of 2016. Needless to say, any person eligible
for the benefits as granted by the Act of 2016 must be extended the
same. Accordingly, the Act of 2016 continues to hold the field.”
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
14.
Moving on, a study of Section 6 of the Act of 2016 is called for,
which reads as follows:
“Section 6.
The outsourced employees recruited through private man
power agency in the service of the State Government or its entities
and working for a continuous period of not less than three years
preceding the date of coming into force of this Act shall be taken on
contract on yearly basis by the competent authority in such service of
the State Government or its entities, subject to the following
conditions, namely:(a) fulfil the eligibility with regard to minimum and maximum
age limit;
(b) possess requisite educational qualification and experience
as specified for the post under the service rules at the time of
initial appointment;
(c) satisfactory verification of antecedents;
(d) have good character and conduct; and
(e) have not been indicted or undergoing any civil, criminal or
departmental proceedings:
Provided that the entities of the State shall consider such
contracts only if such entity is in a financial position to take the
burden of such contract on its own without transferring any liability
to the State exchequer.”
15.
A bare perusal of the aforementioned provision reflects that an
outsourced employee who has worked continuously for a period of three
years, prior to the commencement of the Act, shall be engaged on a yearly
contractual basis by the competent authority. Admittedly, the petitioner has
been working with the respondent-Municipal Corporation since the year
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
2010, while the Act of 2016 came into force on 24.12.2016. Therefore, at
the time of commencement of the Act of 2016, the petitioner had already
completed three years of service as an outsourced employee. As such, the
petitioner was entitled to be taken on contract basis by the respondentMunicipal Corporation. This vested right of the petitioner was crystallised
on 24.12.2016 i.e. the date of commencement of the Act of 2016.
Consequently, this Court finds it appropriate to consider the petitioner to be
a contractual employee of the respondent-Municipal Corporation w.e.f.
24.12.2016.
16.
Since the petitioner has been deemed to be a contractual
employee since 24.12.2016, he deserves to be considered for regularisation
on account of his long service i.e. over 10 years as well as the perennial
nature of his work. On that note, this Court has been constrained to observe
a trend where long term employees are engaged on ad hoc basis, in spite of
the perennial nature of the services rendered by them. The State, being a
constitutional employer, cannot be allowed to exploit its temporary
employees under the garb of lack of sanctioned posts or inability of the
employees to meet educational qualifications for regular posts, when they
have been consistently serving its instrumentality for a significant time
period. Such an approach would be violative of fundamental rights of the
temporary employees enshrined in Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution
of India. Further still, temporary employees cannot be forced to bear the
brunt of lack of financial resources when the State had no qualms about
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
continuously taking advantage of the services rendered with regard to
integral and recurring work of the concerned department. Reliance in this
regard can be placed on the judgements rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Jaggo (supra), Vinod Kumar (supra) and Shripal (supra).
17.
Recently, a two-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Dharam Singh and others v. State of U.P. and another 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 1735, speaking through Justice Vikram Nath, has held as follows:
“11. Furthermore, it must be clarified that the reliance placed by
the High Court on Umadevi (Supra) to non-suit the appellants is
misplaced. Unlike Umadevi (Supra), the challenge before us is not
an invitation to bypass the constitutional scheme of public
employment. It is a challenge to the State's arbitrary refusals to
sanction posts despite the employer's own acknowledgement of
need and decades of continuous reliance on the very workforce.
On the other hand, Umadevi (Supra) draws a distinction between
illegal appointments and irregular engagements and does not
endorse the perpetuation of precarious employment where the
work itself is permanent and the State has failed, for years, to put
its house in order. Recent decisions of this Court in Jaggo v.
Union of India and in Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad have
emphatically cautioned that Umadevi (Supra) cannot be deployed
as a shield to justify exploitation through long-term “ad hocism”,
the use of outsourcing as a proxy, or the denial of basic parity
where identical duties are exacted over extended periods. The
principles articulated therein apply with full force to the present
case....
** ** **
13. As we have observed in both Jaggo (Supra) and Shripal
(Supra), outsourcing cannot become a convenient shield to
perpetuate precariousness and to sidestep fair engagement
practices where the work is inherently perennial. The
Commission's further contention that the appellants are not
“full-time” employees but continue only by virtue of interim
orders also does not advance their case. That interim protection
was granted precisely because of the long history of engagement
and the pendency of the challenge to the State's refusals. It
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
neither creates rights that did not exist nor erases entitlements
that may arise upon a proper adjudication of the legality of
those refusals.
** ** **
17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to recall that the
State (here referring to both the Union and the State
governments) is not a mere market participant but a
constitutional employer. It cannot balance budgets on the backs
of those who perform the most basic and recurring public
functions. Where work recurs day after day and year after year,
the establishment must reflect that reality in its sanctioned
strength and engagement practices. The long-term extraction of
regular labour under temporary labels corrodes confidence in
public administration and of ends the promise of equal
protection. Financial stringency certainly has a place in public
policy, but it is not a talisman that overrides fairness, reason and
the duty to organise work on lawful lines.
18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that “ad-hocism”
thrives where administration is opaque. The State Departments
must keep and produce accurate establishment registers, muster
rolls and outsourcing arrangements, and they must explain, with
evidence, why they prefer precarious engagement over sanctioned
posts where the work is perennial. If “constraint” is invoked, the
record should show what alternatives were considered, why
similarly placed workers were treated differently, and how the
chosen course aligns with Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India. Sensitivity to the human consequences of
prolonged insecurity is not sentimentality. It is a constitutional
discipline that should inform every decision affecting those who
keep public offices running.” (Emphasis supplied)
18.
Outsourcing as an evasion tactic
The common practice of bypassing the regular recruitment
process and resorting to outsourcing, in spite of availability of sanctioned
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
vacant posts, is itself is reflective of the intention of the employers to escape
financial liability that comes with it. Considering that employees are
expected to discharge the same perennial duties, it is rather unsavory to
deprive them of the fruits of their labour including pay scales, increments
etc. A two-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bhilwara Dugdh
Utpadak Sahakari S. Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar Sharma Dead by Lrs 2011
INSC 632, has made the following observations in this regard:
“5. Labour statutes were meant to protect the employees/workmen
because it was realised that the employers and the employees are not
on an equal bargaining position. Hence, protection of employees was
required so that they may not be exploited. However, this new
technique of subterfuge has been adopted by some employers in
recent years in order to deny the rights of the workmen under
various labour statutes by showing that the concerned workmen are
not their employees but are the employees/workmen of a contractor,
or that they are merely daily wage or short term or casual employees
when in fact they are doing the work of regular employees.
6. This Court cannot countenance such practices any more.
Globalization/liberalization in the name of growth cannot be at the
human cost of exploitation of workers.”
(Emphasis supplied)
19.
Outsourcing cannot be allowed to metamorphose into a
convenient veil to sidestep fair engagement practices. Where the principal
employer exercises control and supervision over the manner of work, and
the worker's livelihood is substantially dependent on the principal employer,
the Courts must endeavour to look beyond the façade by lifting the veil
created by the intermediaries and declare the principal employer as the
employer in fact. Further still, the State, being a constitutional employer,
cannot balance its budget on the backs of temporary, contractual, or
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
outsourced employees. In no uncertain terms, it is emphasised that the State
does not get the license to override constitutional safeguards merely for the
reason of financial stringency. Furthermore, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Union of India rep by Government of Puducherry and another v. K.
Velajagan and others in Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 2868/2018, while
upholding the regularization of temporary employees, ordered a vigilance
inquiry to investigate into engagement of staff on ad hoc basis while
sanctioned posts remained vacant. The relevant part thereof is reproduced
below:
“5. Out of 51 sanctioned posts of lecturers in the Polytechnic
College, 45 posts are being manned by incumbents appointed on ad
hoc basis. Of these 45 incumbent lecturers, 15 of them had earlier
moved the Tribunal and had obtained orders for regularization of
their services. Such order was upheld by the High Court. Union of
India had approached this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution
of India in a special leave petition. This Court did not interfere with
the impugned judgment and order of the High Court and disposed of
the said special leave petition on 19th February, 2007 directing as
follows:
“On merits, the petitioners, in our opinion, have no good case.
We have already noticed the prayer asked for by the
respondents before the Tribunal and perused the order passed
by the Tribunal. The Tribunal in our opinion directed the
petitioners herein to frame a scheme for regular absorption of
all casual lecturers or consider all the casual lecturers for
appointment on a regular basis at the time of making regular
appointments. The said direction is ratified by the High Court.
In our opinion, no case is made out for interference with the
direction issued by the Tribunal to frame a scheme and also as
affirmed by the High Court. In fact, it is brought to our notice
by Mr. R. Mohan, learned ASG that the recruitment rules have
already been framed and the same have already been published
in the Supplement to the Gazette No. 42, of the 17th October
2006. Since the direction 6 SLP (Civil) CC No. 7374/2006 3
SLP(C) No. 2868/2018 issued by the Tribunal has already been
complied with, there is nothing further survives in this Special
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
Leave Petition to be adjudicated upon. Accordingly, the Special
Leave Petition stands dismissed. “
6. It is rather unfortunate that despite the aforesaid order of this
Court passed in the year 2007, full compliance thereof is yet to see the
light of the day. The services of the said 15 incumbent lecturers, who
were appointed years back, are yet to be regularized because the
Union Public Service Commission has declined to accede to the
request of the Lieutenant Governor, Puducherry made in this behalf,
raising a plea that the UPSC would not be a party to any illegal
appointee being regularized in service. Audacious indeed, considering
that an order of this Court is subsisting till date.
xxx xxx xxx
13. We, however, do not wish to allow the matter rest here. In the
matter of public employment, the Government is bound to appoint
the best available talent upon issuing advertisements and inviting
applications from interested candidates. The manner in which ad
hoc lecturers have been appointed in the Polytechnic College by the
Government of Puducherry even after the 2006 Rules were
introduced warrants an in-depth inquiry to find out who was
responsible for such illegal appointments. We, accordingly, direct
the Central Vigilance Commission to conduct an in-depth inquiry into
the matter and submit a report fixing responsibility on the person(s)
responsible (either in service or having demitted office) for such
large-scale illegality in the matter of appointment of ad hoc lecturers.
Such report shall be placed before this Court on 14th May, 2025.”
(Emphasis supplied)
20.
On that note, an individual who has been engaged on
outsource-basis, for a substantial period, inevitably acquires the requisite
skill set and efficiency for the job. Such a worker is likely to commit fewer
errors as he possess a deeper understanding of the nature of work. Thus, the
cause of such employees ought not to be abandoned by the Courts.
CONCLUSION
21.
In view of the discussion above, it is clear that not only is the
petitioner an academically well-qualified individual but he has also acquired
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-30248-2025 and two connected matters
an experience of over 15 years, working directly with the respondentMunicipal Corporation. Considering the petitioner is otherwise qualified and
has acquired the requisite skill-set and experience to best serve the interest
of his employer- Municipal Corporation, reason and justice dictate that his
services be regularized, especially since he was engaged on outsource-basis
in spite of availability of vacant sanctioned posts.
22.
Accordingly, all the aforementioned writ petitions are allowed.
The respondents are directed to regularize the services of the petitioners
within six weeks from today. If no order of regularization is passed within 6
weeks from today, they shall be deemed to be regularized.
23.
Registry is directed to place a photocopy of this order on the
paper-books of the connected matters.
24.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
March 05, 2026
P.C
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes/No
Whether Reportable. :
Yes/No
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review