Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. V. BALAKRISHNAN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.A NO. 14 OF 2023
CRIME NO.109/2018 OF Atholy Police Station, Kozhikode
(AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT IN SC NO.598 OF 2018 OF
SESSIONS
COURT
(SPECIAL
COURT
FOR
TRIAL
OF
SC/ST(PA)ACTKOZHIKODE.)
APPELLANT/ACCUSED:
SURESH KUMAR C.P
AGED 61 YEARS
S/O, CHELLAPPAN NAIR, KARAYATTUMEETHAL HOUSE,
NARATH, ULLIYERI P.O. KOZHIKODE DISTRICT, PIN 673620
BY ADVS.
K.SHAJ
A.MOHAMMED
BEENA N.KARTHA
C.IJLAL
RESHMA.P.
JOSEPH MARY DAS
ARUN CHAND
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
VINAYAK G MENON
BHARAT VIJAY P.
MAJID MUHAMMED K.
MINU VITTORRIA PAULSON
RESPONDENT/STATE:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,HIGH COURT OF
KERALA, PIN - 682031
BY ADV PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. RANJITH T R, SR. PP.
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
7.04.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
10/4/2025
DELIVERED
THE
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V,
&
P.V.BALAKRISHNAN,JJ.
-------------------------------------.
Crl.Appeal No. 14 of 2023
--------------------------------Dated this the 10th day of April 2025
JUDGMENT
P.V.BALAKRISHNAN,J
This appeal is filed by the sole accused in SC No.598/2018
on the files of the Special Court for the Trial of SC/ST(PA) Act
Cases, Kozhikode challenging his conviction and sentence imposed
under Section 302 IPC read with section 3(2)(v) of Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
(hereinafter referred to as 'the SC/ST(POA) Act' for short).
Prosecution case
2. Deceased Chandran is a coconut climber belonging to the
Scheduled Caste-Pulayan community. On 10/4/2018, the accused
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
who is not a member of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe,
called
the
deceased
for
plucking
coconut
in
his
property.
After completion of work, the accused offered country liquor to the
deceased. Thereafter, an altercation took place between the
deceased and the accused in connection with the wages to be paid.
Some time between 13.00 hours and 15.45 hours, the accused
with an intention to kill the deceased, took a chopper and aimed at
the neck of Chandran. When he evaded the attack, it fell upon his
jaw causing a deep injury. When Chandran fell backwards, his
head hit the step causing another injury. Thereafter, the accused
repeatedly aimed the neck of the deceased, which was timely
prevented by him using his hands. The accused also repeatedly
kicked the chest and abdomen of the deceased thereby causing
serious injuries to his internal organs, resulting in the deceased
succumbing to his injuries. Hence, the prosecution alleged that the
accused has committed an offence punishable under Section 302
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
IPC r/w Section 3(2)(v)of the SC/ST(POA) Act.
Proceedings in the trial court
3. On appearance of the accused, charge was framed against
him under Section 302 IPC and Section 3 (2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act
to which he pleaded not guilty. Thereafter, from the side of the
prosecution, PW1 to PW29 were examined, Exts.P1 to P40 and
MO1 to MO14 were marked. When examined under Section 313
Cr.P.C., the accused denied all the incriminating circumstances
brought against him in evidence and pleaded innocence. He stated
that the deceased had plucked the coconuts and he collected the
same, and thereafter, he does not know what had happened. Even
though the accused was called upon to adduce evidence, no
evidence was adduced from his side. The trial court, on an
appreciation of the evidence on record found the accused guilty
and convicted him under Section 302 IPC r/w Section 3(2)(v) of
SC/ST(POA) Act. The accused was sentenced to undergo rigorous
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.1,00,000/- under
Section 302 IPC read with section 3(2)(v) of SC/ST(POA) Act. In
case of default, the accused was ordered to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a further period of one year.
Contentions of the appellant
4. The learned Counsel for the appellant Adv.A.Muhammed
by relying on the decision in Ansar V.K. v. State of Ker. (2024
SCC OnLine Kerala 5423 ) contended that since the prosecution
has not proved the entire chain of circumstances to make an
inference of guilt, the conviction as such cannot be sustained. He
submitted that there is no evidence to connect MO1 with the crime
and the prosecution has not proved the origin of the blood found in
it or its ownership. He argued that the last seen theory is also not
attracted in this case since there is no evidence to show that the
deceased and the accused were seen together alive at any point of
time. He further by relying on the decision in Modan Singh v.
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
State of Rajasthan [(1978) 4 SCC 435] submitted that since
there is no convincing evidence to show that the samples taken by
the scientific assistant has reached the court and subsequently to
the laboratory in a tamper proof condition, no reliance can be
placed upon the FSL report. He also submitted that the hair
samples taken from the accused by PW13 on 12/4/2018 had been
planted/introduced as the hair samples taken from the deceased's
palm and produced in court to falsely implicate the accused. He
further submitted that there is delay in producing MO12 before the
Court and chances of it being tampered cannot be ruled out. He
contended that even if the entire prosecution evidence is accepted
as true, the offence under Section 302 IPC will not lie since, PW20,
has not opined that any of the injuries sustained by the deceased
are sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. He
argued that since there is no motive to kill the deceased and since
there was no preparation and the incident has taken place during a
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
scuffle, at the most, the offence which will be attracted is Section
304 Part II. He, by relying on the decision in Nikhil Chandra
Mondal v. State of West Bengal (2023 KHC 6216) argued that
extra judicial confession is a weak piece of evidence and the trial
court has erred in relying upon the alleged confession thus made
by the accused to PW19. Hence, he prayed that this appeal may be
allowed.
Contentions of the Prosecutor
5. Per contra, the learned Public Prosecutor Adv.Ranjith.T.R
argued that the prosecution has proved the entire chain of
circumstances from which an inference of guilt can be safely found
against the accused. He submitted that the accused was found
sitting on the verandah near the dead body with MO1 chopper
containing blood. The hairs of the accused were also found in the
right palm of the deceased. Blood stains were found in the body
and dhothi of the deceased and his blood stained footprint was also
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
detected at that place. Apart from the above, the accused
also
confessed to PW19 regarding his committing the crime and there is
absolutely no explanation forthcoming from his side regarding all
these facts. He submitted that as per Section 106 of the Evidence
Act, a burden is cast upon the accused to explain these
circumstances and failure to do so is fatal. Hence, he prayed that
this appeal may be dismissed.
A conspectus of the material evidence adduced by the prosecution
6. PW1 is a relative of deceased Chandran. He deposed that
at about 3.30 pm on 10/4/2018 he was informed by one Babu that
someone was lying dead in the verandah of the house of the
accused. Subsequently, Babu called him and told him that it was
Chandran who is thus lying dead. He immediately went to the
house and saw the deceased lying in a pool of blood. At that time,
the accused was sitting in the built-in seat of the verandah and a
chopper with blood stains was lying nearby. On the western side of
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
the house, the coconuts plucked were seen piled up and nearby,
the chopper of the deceased was also seen. Thereafter, he went to
the police station and gave Ext.P1 FIS. During cross examination
he stated that, when he along with Jayesh and Babu went to the
spot, only the accused was present there. He also noticed blood in
the steps and the accused sitting in a helpless condition.
7. PW4 deposed that he came to know about the incident at
about 3.45-4.p.m and went to the spot immediately. On reaching
there, he saw the deceased lying in a pool of blood in the verandah
of Suresh's house. The body was lying supine, with the head
pointing towards the steps. The towel and the rope-noose used for
climbing coconut trees belonging to the deceased, along with a
blood stained chopper were also there. He also saw a black mobile
phone in the built-in seat of the verandah. Outside, the plucked
coconuts were seen piled up and the chopper of the deceased was
lying nearby. He identified the chopper which he found on the
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
built-in seat of the verandah with blood stains as MO1, the towel
as MO2, the rope noose used for climbing coconut trees as MO3
series, the other chopper as MO4 and the mobile phone as MO5.
During cross examination, he stated that he had also noticed blood
in the towel.
8. PW7 is the scientific officer, who visited the scene and
collected samples on 11/4/2018. She deposed that she thus
collected six items, packed, labelled and sealed it and handed it
over to the investigating officer, along with Ext.P3 report. She
identified item Nos. 3 to 6 as MO6 to MO9 and stated that the
receipt of the items were acknowledged by the investigating officer
in Ext.P3.
9. PW8 is the fingerprint expert, who examined the scene on
11/4/2018. He deposed that the photograph of a blood foot
impression was taken with the help of the police photographer and
he identified the same as MO10. He also received MO11 specimen
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
of the enlarged thumb of the left leg of the accused . Thereafter,he
made a comparison and found both of them identical and gave
Ext.P4 report. During cross examination, he stated that he could
not find any prints in the weapon and the chance print was found
as one leading into the house .
10. PW12 is the Junior Medical Consultant attached to
PHC,Koyilandy. She deposed that on 10/4/2018 at about 9 pm,
she had examined the accused in this case, who was brought by
the police and has issued Ext.P10 certificate. She found blood
stains on both his legs below the knee joint and an abrasion 3x2
cm below the left knee joint. She also collected blood samples, nail
clippings, hair of the accused and took samples from the blood
stains found in his body. She handed over all these samples to the
investigating officer along with Ext.P9 report.
11. PW13 was the medical officer attached to the Taluk
Hospital, Koyilandy. He deposed that on 12/4/2018 at about 5.15
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
pm, the accused was brought before him for medical examination,
with a requisition for taking scalp hair. He took the scalp hair of
the accused and issued Ext.P11 certificate of examination. He also
prepared Ext.P12 report for forwarding the same for chemical
examination.
12. PW14 was the ASI attached to Atholi police station on
10/4/2018. He deposed that at about 5.15 pm, he registered
Ext.P1(a) FIR on the basis of the statement given by the PW1. At
about 11.30 am, he witnessed the handing over of the samples
(MO6 to MO9) taken by the scientific assistant to the SI and signed
in Ext.P13 mahazar at that time. At about 7 pm, he also witnessed
the SI seizing MO12 dhothi worn by the accused and signed in
Ext.P14 mahazar. During cross examination he stated that he had
seen some stains in MO12 resembling blood stains at that time.
13. PW19 deposed that on 10/4/2018 at about 3 pm, he
came to know about the incident and went to the spot. There he
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
saw Chandran lying in a pool of blood in the verandah and the
accused sitting in the built -in seat of the verandah. When he asked the
accused as to what happened, he replied that "എന ക ഒര അബദ
പറ പപ യത ണ. ഏത യ ല ഞ ൻ ജയ ല ൽ പപ ണ "
14. PW20 is the doctor who conducted the postmortem
examination of the deceased and issued Ext.P17 certificate. He
deposed that on examination, he found 20 ante mortem injuries of
which, injury Nos. 1, to 5 & 17 to 19 were blunt injuries sustained
to head, chest and abdomen, which are the cause of death of the
deceased. He further stated that injury Nos.7 & 11 to 13 which are
sharp cut injuries can be caused by MO1 and injury Nos. 17 to 19
which are blunt injuries can be caused by kicking on that part of
the body. Injury Nos. 1 to 3 are possible due to a strike with the
blunt side of MO1.
15. PW25 is the police officer, who conducted the initial part
of the investigation. He deposed that on getting information, he
went to the spot and saw the deceased and the accused. There
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
was blood in the dresses and legs of the accused and on the belief
that the accused had some role in the crime, took him into
custody. He also prepared Ext.P24 custody memo for the said
purpose. On the next day, he prepared the inquest report and
questioned the witnesses present at that time. Later, he seized the
dresses worn by the accused as per Ext.P14 mahazar and collected
the samples taken by the scientific assistant as per Ext.P13
mahazar. He also seized the samples taken by the doctor, who
conducted the postmortem examination and produced them in the
court as per Ext.P25 property list. The articles seized as per
Ext.P13 were forwarded to the court as per Ext.P26 property list
and MO12 was produced before the court as per Ext.P27 property
list. He also seized MO1 to MO5 from the place of occurrence and
MO 13 and MO14 dresses worn by the deceased and produced
them before the court as per Ext.P29 property list.
16. PW 26 is the Dy.SP who took over the investigation from
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
PW25.
On 25/4/2018, he obtained the accused in custody and
collected his foot prints and sent them to the finger print bureau
and obtained Exts.P4 and P5 reports. He also prepared Ext.P33
forwarding note for sending the material objects to FSL and
obtained Ext.P34 report from the F.S.L.
Thereafter, he received
Ext.P35 report of examination of blood samples and viscera and
after completing the investigation, laid the charge.
17. PW 28 is another officer, who conducted investigation in
this case. He deposed that on 12/4/2018 he visited the scene and
prepared Ext.P8 scene mahazar. Later on that day, he arrested the
accused by preparing Exts.P37 & P38 documents and filed Ext.P39
report. He also seized the hair samples taken by the doctor from
the accused as per Ext.P16 mahazar and produced them before the
court as per Ext.P40 property list.
18. PW29 was the Assistant Director, Biology, attached to the
Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Kannur. He deposed that on
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
25/5/2018, he received 11 sealed packets and after examining
them, issued Ext.P34 report.
Evaluation of evidence
19. The first question to be considered in this case is whether
the cause of death of Chandran is homicidal or not.
While
considering this aspect, the evidence of PW20 coupled with Ext.P17
postmortem certificate assumes much relevance. PW20 noted 20
ante mortem injuries on the body of the deceased, out of which
injury Nos. 1 to 5 and 17 to 19 were blunt injuries sustained to
heart, chest, abdomen which are the cause of death of the
deceased. The evidence of PW20 is very specific and shows that
Chandran has died due to injury Nos. 1 to 5, and 17,to 19 the
description of which are given below:
1. Abraded contusion 3x2x1cm on right side of head, 6 cm vertically above
right ear and 7 cm from midine.
2. Lacerated wound 1.5x0.5x0.5 cm on back of right side of head, 8cm
behind right ear and 13 cm above root of neck. There was surrounding
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
contusion 8x5x0.5 cm around the injury.
3. Lacerated wound 2x0.5x0.5 cm with surrounding contusion 4x3x0.3 cm
over left parietal eminence of head, 8 cm above top of left ear and 4cm
outer to midline.
4. Contusion 10x8x1.3cm over left side of forehead, temple and left eyelids,
upper inner end 3 cm outer to midine and 3 cm above eyebrow.
5. Abraded contusion 5x3x1cm over left side of forehead, lower inner end
3cm outer to midline and 1cm above eye brow.
xxxxxxx
17.Chest contusion 10x6cmx full thickness on left side with underlying
fracture of ribs 7,8, 9 along mid-axillary line. Fracture ribs 4-11 on right
side at multiple sites with surrounding blood infiltration. Multiple
contusions on front of right lung over an area 7x5x0.1-0.5cm
18.Mesenteric contusion 7x5cmx full thickness at mesocolon 6cm distal to
appendix 400ml of fluid blood in the abdominal cavity. Liver laceration,
9x2cmx full thickness, separating right and left lobes with adjoining
areas of subcapsular hemorrhage (7x6cm). Multiple superficial stretch
laceration on right dome of liver over an area 12x8cm
19. Subarachnoid haemorrhage on both side of brain, thicker on right
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
side.”
The doctor also noted a few sharp cut injuries on the body of the
deceased(injury Nos. 7 & 11 to 13) and opined that the same can
be caused by MO1.
He further opined that injury Nos. 17 to 19
can be caused by kicking at that part of the body and injury Nos. 1
to 3 can be caused by striking with blunt side of MO1. PW20
categorically ruled out the possibility of the deceased falling from a
coconut tree with the weapon on a pile of coconuts and sustaining
the injuries as suggested by the defence. Therefore, from the afore
evidence of PW20, it can be safely concluded that death of
Chandran is nothing but homicidal.
20. The evidence on record in the present case shows that
there are no eye witnesses to the incident. The evidence of PW1,
PW3, PW4,PW5 & PW19 reveals that on getting information when
they went to the house of the accused they had witnessed the
body of the deceased lying in a pool of blood in the steps. They
also saw the accused sitting nearby and a chopper containing
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
blood stains lying there. The evidence of PW4 further shows that,
apart from the chopper with blood stains(MO1), he had also
noticed a towel (MO2), nooses made of rope (MO3 series), MO4
chopper and MO5 mobile phone lying there. PW6, the son of the
deceased, identified MO2, MO3 series and MO4 as the articles
belonging to the deceased.
It is very pertinent to note that
absolutely no explanation is forthcoming from the side of the
accused as to how Chandran sustained injuries and died in the
courtyard of his house. It is also to be taken note that the accused
is admitting the fact that Chandran had come to his house for
plucking coconuts and he has no case that there was anyone else
with them during the relevant time.
21. The evidence of PW25 shows that at about 5.15 pm on
10/4/2018, he had received information regarding the incident and
had registered the FIR. His evidence also reveals that immediately
thereafter, he had gone to the place of occurrence and had seen
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
the body of the deceased in a pool of blood and the accused sitting
there, by wearing an ochre coloured dhoti. On noticing blood stains
in the body and dresses of the accused, he took him into custody
and kept him under observation in the police station, after
preparing Ext.P24 custody memo. On the very same day, at about
9 pm, he produced the accused before PW12, the doctor, and
collected samples from the blood stains found on his body and his
nail clippings, hair and blood samples.
Ext.P9 is the report
forwarded with the material objects to be sent for chemical
analysis and the Ext.P10 is the report of examination given by
PW12. The evidence of PW17 would go to show that he has
received the samples, which were kept in sealed covers from the
hospital on 18/4/2018, and has handed over the same to the
investigating officer as per Ext.P16 mahazar. Ext.P34 report from
the FSL confirms the fact that the stain collected from the body of
the accused was blood .
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
22. As stated earlier, the evidence of PW25 reveals that when
he went to the spot he had seen the accused sitting there with
blood on his body and clothes. It also shows that he had detained
the accused thereafter and had seized the dhoti worn by him
containing stains as per Ext.P14 mahazar, on 11/4/2018 at about 7
pm. The evidence of PW14 and PW15, who are the witnesses to
the seizure , also confirms the same and the evidence of PW14
also shows that he had noticed the stains in the dhoti. The dhothi
thus worn by the accused was identified by them as MO12. MO12
was forwarded to the Court as per Ext.P27 property list and from
there to the FSL for examination as per Ext.P33 forwarding note.
Ext.P34 FSL report categorically shows that the blood stains in
MO12 dhothi worn by the accused at the relevant time belong to
deceased Chandran.
23. Apart from the above and most importantly, it is to be
seen that the evidence on record also reveals that the sample hair,
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
which was recovered from the right palm of the deceased by the
scientific officer,belongs to the accused. The evidence of PW7, the
scientific officer, shows that he had visited the scene on 11/4/2018
and had collected six items from there. He had thus collected hairs
from the right and left palms of the deceased, cellophane tape
impressions from both palms, blood stains and hair from the scene
of occurrence. Thereafter, he packed, sealed and labeled them,
and handed it over to PW25, the investigating officer, along with
Ext.P3 report. Ext.P3 also contains the specimen seal thus affixed
by the scientific officer and the acknowledgment of the receipt of
the sealed packets by PW25. The evidence of PW25 shows that he
had seized the afore samples by preparing Ext.P13 mahazar on the
very same day. The said fact is also corroborated by the evidence
of PW14 and PW15, the witnesses to Ext.P13 mahazar. Thereafter,
the samples were forwarded to the court as per Ext.P26 property
list and from there to the FSL as per Ext.P33 forwarding note.
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
Ext.P34 report categorically shows that the hair samples taken
from the right palm of the deceased belong to accused Suresh
Kumar.
24. Be that as it may, the evidence on record also goes to
show that the foot impression taken by PW8 from the scene on
11/4/2018 matches with the foot impression of the accused's leg.
The evidence of PW8 coupled with Ext.P4 report shows that he had
thus collected MO10 blood impression of foot print from the floor in
front of the house and that it tallies with MO11 the right foot
impression of the accused. There is absolutely no explanation
forthcoming from the side of the accused regarding all these
incriminating facts. No explanation is offered by the accused as to
how his hair came to be found in the right palm of the deceased,
as to how his dhoti seen worn at the relevant time contained the
blood of the deceased, as to how blood was found in his body and
as to how his foot impression with blood came in the floor near to
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
the place of occurrence. These facts undoubtedly are specifically
within the knowledge of the accused and the burden is upon him to
give a cogent explanation.
25. The afore evidence let in by the prosecution also gets
support from the extra judicial confession made by the accused to
PW19.
The evidence of PW19 reveals that when he went to the
scene and asked the accused, who was sitting there, as to what
had happened, the accused had replied that a mistake had
happened from his part and anyway he had to go to jail. It is true
that an extra judicial confession is a weak piece of evidence . But,
it is upto the court to assess the credibility of the witness and
determine whether his/her evidence is reliable. If, after a proper
and careful evaluation, the court comes to a conclusion that the
witness before whom the confession was made is credible and the
confession was voluntarily, clear, specific and unambiguous, the
court can very well act upon and a conviction can be based on such
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
evidence. The court must also be satisfied that the extra judicial
confession was voluntarily made, without any coercion or undue
influence.
The extra judicial confession can form the basis of
conviction, if persons before whom it is stated to be made appear
to be unbiased and not even remotely inimical to the accused.
Ultimately, it is for the court to judge the credibility of the witness
and thereafter decide whether his/her evidence has to be accepted
or not.(See Shiva Karam Payaswami Tewari v. State of
Maharashtra [(2009) 11 SCC 262], Nikhil Chandra Mondal v.
State
of
West
Bengal(cited
supra)
and
Pawan
Kumar
Chourasia v. State of Bihar (2023 SCC OnLine SC 259]. In the
present case, it is to be seen that PW19 is not a stranger to the
accused or a person, who is having animosity with the accused. It
is also to be seen that the confession thus made by the accused to
PW19 is voluntarily and without any coercion or undue influence.
The confession thus made was immediately after the commission
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
of the offence when PW19 went to the scene and enquired with the
accused. The substance of the confession is also very clear and
unambiguous, which proves the culpability of the accused. In the
afore circumstances, considering the fact that the extra judicial
confession made to PW19 is also corroborated by the other
evidence on record, we find no impediment in acting upon it.
26.
The
upshot
of
the
afore
discussions
is
that
the
prosecution has proved the entire chain of circumstances leading
this court to safely infer the guilt of the accused. The facts, thus
established, are consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of
the accused and nothing else and shows that the accused has
committed homicide of the deceased. As stated earlier, the
evidence of PW20 coupled with Ext.P17 unerringly shows that the
bodily injuries inflicted on the deceased and especially injury Nos.
1 to 5 and 17 to 19 are sufficient in the ordinary course of nature
to cause death. Therefore, we find no reason to interfere with
Crl.Appeal No.14 of 2023
2025:KER:31268
conviction and sentence passed against the appellant/accused
under Section 302 IPC. Hence, we find that this appeal lacks merit
and the same is only to be dismissed.
In the result, this appeal is dismissed.
Sd/RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V
Judge
dpk
Sd/P.V.BALAKRISHNAN
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review