Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:4896
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Dated-16 June, 2026
Writ Petition Service Single No. 1571 of 2026
Madhu Bala
--Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and others
--Respondents
With
Writ Petition Service Single No. 1573 of 2026
Shubham Kumar Joshi
--Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and others
And
--Respondents
Writ Petition Service Single No. 1574 of 2026
Surendra Singh Chauhan
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and others
--Petitioner
--Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Vivek Kathait, learned Counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. K.N. Joshi, learned Dy.A.G. for the State.
Mr. Shailendra Nauriyal, learned Counsel for UKSSSC
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J. (Oral)
Since the facts of these petitions are the same
and the issue involved is also similar, hence these
petitions are taken up together and decided by this
common judgment.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
Facts
of
the
case
are
that
Uttarakhand
Subordinate Service Selection Commission (hereby to be
referred to as ‘the Commission’) issued an advertisement
dated 26.11.2015 inviting applications for recruitment to
196 posts of Gram Panchayat Vikas Adhikari. The
2026:UHC:4896
petitioners participated in the selection process, appeared
in the written examination conducted on 06.03.2016 and
were
declared
successful.
Subsequently,
complaints
regarding manipulation of OMR answer sheets led to the
constitution of an inquiry committee by the State
Government. On the basis of the interim inquiry report,
the Commission cancelled the entire selection process
vide Office Memorandum dated 16.06.2017. The said
cancellation was challenged before this Court in WPSS
No. 2105 of 2017 (Kamal Bhatt and others vs. State of
Uttarakhand and others), wherein this Court directed for
holding a restricted re-examination for candidates who
had appeared in the original examination. Accordingly, a
re-examination was conducted on 25.02.2018 and a fresh
merit list was prepared. According to petitioners, final
inquiry report dated 04.10.2018, based on forensic
examination of OMR sheets, identified candidates whose
answer
sheets
were
found
tainted,
whereas
the
petitioners were not found involved in any irregularity.
Claiming that they stood exonerated by the inquiry, the
petitioners
asserted
a
right
to
be
considered
for
appointment.
3.
The Commission thereafter issued a fresh
advertisement dated 06.11.2020 for recruitment to the
post of Gram Panchayat Vikas Adhikari. Petitioners,
seeking consideration of their candidature against the
available vacancies, approached this Court by filing WPSS
No.1753 of 2020. The said writ petition was disposed of
on 09.03.2026 with a direction to
the competent
authority to consider the petitioners' claim in accordance
with
law.
Pursuant
thereto,
petitioners
submitted
representations, which came to be rejected by the
Commission vide Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2026.
2026:UHC:4896
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have preferred the
present writ petitions.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that the impugned Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2026
is arbitrary, suffers from complete non-application of
mind and the same has been passed in disregard of the
directions issued by this Court in WPSS No. 1753 of
2020. It was argued that while disposing of earlier writ
petition, this Court had directed the Commission to
consider the petitioners' claim in the light of the issues
raised by them. However, instead of examining whether
the petitioners could be considered against the available
vacancies, despite their exoneration in the inquiry
proceedings, the Commission rejected their claim solely
on the ground that they were not selected pursuant to the
re-examination conducted in the year 2018. According to
petitioners, the Authority completely failed to address the
real controversy and consequently, the impugned order
cannot be sustained in law.
5.
It was further submitted that the final inquiry
report dated 04.10.2018 clearly established that the
irregularities relating to recruitment process were neither
pervasive nor incapable of identification. Learned counsel
contended that the OMR sheets were subjected to forensic
examination and the candidates found to have benefited
from
manipulation
were
specifically
identified.
The
not
amongst
such
petitioners'
names
did
candidates
and,
therefore,
figure
they
stood
completely
exonerated. Once the tainted candidates had been
segregated from the untainted candidates, there remained
no justification for denying consideration to candidates
whose
selection
was
found
malpractice.
to
be
free
from
any
6.
the
2026:UHC:4896
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that
respondents
have
proceeded
on
an
erroneous
assumption that the petitioners are seeking displacement
of candidates who were appointed pursuant to the
subsequent recruitment process. It was submitted that
the
petitioners
do
not
seek
cancellation
of
any
appointment already made nor do they seek removal of
any
serving
employee.
Their
limited
claim
is
for
consideration against existing and available vacancies in
the cadre of Gram Panchayat Vikas Adhikari. It was
contended that accommodating the petitioners against
such vacancies would not prejudice any third party rights
and would merely rectify the injustice allegedly caused to
candidates who were found innocent in the inquiry
proceedings.
7.
It was further contended that the respondents
cannot derive advantage from their own administrative
decisions and delays. According to the petitioners, they
were initially selected in the recruitment process of 2015
and have remained out of employment despite there being
no allegation against them. Learned counsel submitted
that subsequent re-examination and passage of time
cannot extinguish the legitimate claim of candidates
whose candidature was found to be untainted. The
Commission, therefore, acted unfairly in rejecting the
petitioners' representations without giving due weight to
the findings recorded in the final inquiry report. Placing
reliance upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Inderpreet Singh Kahlon v. State of Punjab (2006)
11 SCC 356, Union of India v. Rajesh P.U. Puthuvalnikathu
(2003) 7 SCC and other decisions, learned counsel
submitted that where tainted candidates can be identified
and segregated, wholesale denial of relief to innocent
2026:UHC:4896
candidates is impermissible. It was argued that the
doctrine of proportionality requires the State to adopt a
measure
commensurate
with
the
nature
of
the
irregularity and that innocent candidates cannot be made
to suffer for the misconduct of others.
8.
It was further submitted by the learned counsel
for the petitioners that the action of the respondents is
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
The
petitioners
contend
that
despite
having
been
exonerated by the final inquiry report, their claim has
been rejected on irrelevant considerations while ignoring
the material facts directed to be examined by this Court.
On these grounds, learned counsel prayed that the
impugned Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2026 be
quashed and the respondents be directed to consider the
petitioners
for
appointment
to
the
post
of
Gram
Panchayat Vikas Adhikari against the available vacancies
in accordance with law.
9.
Learned counsel for the respondents submitted
that the petitioners have no vested right to appointment
merely because they had participated in the recruitment
process of 2015. It was contended that the original
selection stood cancelled and, pursuant to the directions
of this Court, a re-examination was conducted in 2018,
whereafter the recruitment process attained finality. The
petitioners were not selected in the said process and,
therefore, cannot claim appointment against vacancies
arising under subsequent recruitment advertisements. It
was further submitted that mere exoneration from
allegations of malpractice does not confer any right to
appointment and that the impugned order has been
passed
after
due
consideration
representations.
of
the
petitioners'
2026:UHC:4896
10.
I have considered the submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
The principal contention of the petitioners is that the final
inquiry report dated 04.10.2018 exonerated them from all
allegations of malpractice and, therefore, they are entitled
to be considered for appointment to the post of Gram
Panchayat Vikas Adhikari against the available vacancies.
This Court is unable to accept the said contention. It is
undisputed
that
the
recruitment
process
initiated
pursuant to the advertisement dated 26.11.2015 was
cancelled on account of allegations of irregularities. The
cancellation was challenged before this Court and,
pursuant to the directions issued in “Kamal Bhatt and
others”, a restricted re-examination was conducted on
25.02.2018. Thereafter, a fresh merit list was prepared
and
the
recruitment process attained finality. The
petitioners admittedly did not secure selection in the said
re-examination.
Once
the
original
selection
stood
cancelled and a fresh selection process was undertaken
in terms of the directions of this Court, rights of all
candidates became subject to the outcome thereof. Mere
exoneration from allegations of malpractice does not
confer any vested right to appointment. The final inquiry
report may establish that the petitioners were not
involved in any irregularity, but it neither revives the
cancelled recruitment process nor creates a right in their
favour to seek appointment against vacancies arising
under
subsequent
recruitment
advertisements.
The
vacancies advertised subsequently constitute separate
recruitment processes governed by independent selection
procedures.
11.
This Court further finds that the order passed
in WPSS No. 1753 of 2020 merely required consideration
2026:UHC:4896
of the petitioners' representations. Pursuant thereto, the
respondents considered the matter and rejected the claim
on the ground that the recruitment process had attained
finality after the re-examination and that the petitioners
were not included in the final select list. The said
conclusion cannot be said to be arbitrary or illegal. The
judgments relied upon by the petitioners regarding
segregation of tainted and untainted candidates do not
advance their case. The issue in the present matter is not
whether the petitioners were involved in malpractice, but
whether such exoneration entitles them to appointment
despite their non-selection in the recruitment process
which ultimately attained finality. In the opinion of this
Court, it does not. Therefore, no ground for interference
with the Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2026, is made
out.
12.
For the reasons aforesaid, all the writ petitions
fail and are accordingly dismissed.
No order as to costs.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
16.06.2026
R.Dang
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review