The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In light of the testimonies of the key witnesses, the prosecution has failed to prove the case against the appellants beyond reasonable doubt. In view thereof, the impugned judgment and order on sentence must be set aside. Accordingly, the present appeals succeed and the appellants are acquitted.
18. The bail bonds furnished by the appellants stand cancelled and their sureties are discharged.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 05.12.2025
: 13.01.2026
: 13.01.2026
CRL.A.1024/2017
SURAJ SINGH
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Mahesh Kumar, Advocate
versus
THE STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Shubhi Gupta, APP for State with
Ms. Yusra, Advocate, with Inspector
B.S. Guliya, P.S. JP Kalan and SI
Naveen Yadav, P.S. Dwarka South.
+
CRL.A.1034/2017
MOHD. NASEEM
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Mahesh Kumar, Advocate
versus
STATE
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Shubhi Gupta, APP for State with
Ms. Yusra, Advocate, with Inspector
B.S. Guliya, P.S. JP Kalan and SI
Naveen Yadav, P.S. Dwarka South.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeals have been preferred by the appellants seeking to
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
assail a common judgment of conviction dated 03.10.2017 and order on
sentence dated 11.10.2017. The appellants were convicted for the offence
punishable under Sections 326/34 IPC and sentenced to undergo RI for 3
years along with payment of a fine of Rs.10,000/- each, in default whereof
they would undergo SI for 3 months each. The benefit under Section 428
Cr.P.C. was granted to the appellants.
2.
As common submissions have been addressed, the present appeals are
being taken up and disposed of vide a common judgment.
3.
The facts in a nutshell are that the FIR in the present case came to be
registered on 23.03.2012 on the statement of the complainant/injured, who
alleged that he was a rickshaw driver. He had gone to take tea at the shop of
one Guru Dev Das, and the complainant’s son, Kundan, was also there. At
about 4.30 pm, four boys came who were loudly talking and abusing and
when the complainant/injured objected to the same, one of them exhorted
others, on which two of them caught hold of him while the third one took a
silver-coloured knife and stabbed into his stomach. His son, Kundan, and
Guru Dev Das, rushed to help him, on which all the four boys attempted to
flee away. Two of them who had caught hold of the complainant/injured
were apprehended at the spot and they disclosed their names as Suraj Singh
and Mohd. Naseem @ Sonu. The other two boys were apprehended later by
the I.O. and discovered to be JCLs. The knife in question was recovered at
the instance of JCL ‘T’.
4.
The appellant was taken for medical examination and on completion
of investigation; charge sheet came to be filed. On 05.09.2012, charges came
to be framed under Section 307/34 IPC.
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants contends that the prosecution has
failed to prove the case against the appellants as the identity of the
appellants has not been conclusively established. He further states that the
person who stabbed the complainant/injured was a juvenile and was tried
separately.
6.
The contentions are opposed by the learned APP for the State, who
submits that both the appellants were apprehended at the spot of the
incident, and that they have been rightly convicted by the Trial Court with
the aid of Section 34 IPC.
7.
During the trial, the complainant/injured was examined as PW-2. He
deposed that on 03.04.2012, he had gone to the tea stall run by his relative,
Guru Dev Das, to take tea, and near the stall, four boys were abusing each
other. When he asked them not to do so, he was stabbed in the abdomen
with a knife. He stated that the boy who had caused the injury was not
present in Court. The witness did not ascribe any role to the present
appellants.
He was cross-examined by the learned APP for the State, in which he
denied having stated to the police that the names of the accused persons
apprehended at the spot were Suraj and Sonu. He volunteered that he could
identify the accused who had stabbed him and that he had done so in the
Juvenile Court where he had gone for deposition. He admitted it to be
correct that the incident took place on 23.03.2012. On a further suggestion
being put that the appellants were the same persons who were the associates
of the accused who had stabbed him, the witness denied the same. Notably,
no suggestion was given as regards the allegation of the appellants catching
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
hold of the witness.
8.
Kundan, son of the complainant/injured, was examined as PW-3 and
narrated a different version of the incident. He stated that on the day of
incident, four boys were beating one boy near the tea stall where he and his
father were taking tea, and upon his father objecting to the same, one of the
said four boys stabbed his father. However, he stated that he could not see as
to which of the four boys had stabbed his father. He identified both the
appellants as being amongst the four boys who were beating the other boy.
When the witness inquired from the four boys as to why they were beating a
person of their uncle’s age, the four boys gave beatings to him. He stated
that while the appellant/Mohd. Naseem held him by the collar of his shirt,
the appellant/Suraj hit him with his fists. The appellants were caught at the
spot by the witness with the help of public persons and his uncle, the
teaseller Guru Dev Das.
In cross-examination by the learned APP for the State, the witness
denied the suggestion that the JCL ‘T’, who had statedly stabbed his father,
was arrested in the presence of the witness and that a knife was recovered
from his possession. He admitted that the sketch of the recovered knife as
well as the seizure memo of the same were prepared in his presence. He
admitted that the other JCL ‘R’ was identified by him before the I.O. as the
one who had instigated his other associates. He stated that he could identify
the seized knife, but upon the recovered knife being produced, he stated that
he could not say whether the produced knife was the weapon of offence.
During cross-examination by the counsel for accused/Mohd. Naseem,
he stated that he cannot tell as to who out of the two accused persons is
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
Suraj and who is Sonu. He did not remember as to which accused held his
father from which side at the time of the incident.
The cross-examination conducted on behalf of accused/Mohd.
Naseem was adopted by the learned counsel for the accused/Suraj Singh.
9.
Gurudev Das, the tea-stall owner was examined as PW-4. His
narration of events also comes with a twist. He stated that the appellants,
along with two associates, were giving beatings to one person, and upon his
fufa (uncle) asking them not to do so, the four boys started beating up his
fufa. He stated that he did not remember which of those persons had held his
fufa, but confirmed that one small person amongst the four had stabbed his
fufa in the stomach
In his cross-examination by the learned APP for the State, he denied
the suggestion that the four boys were not beating another person but rather
quarrelling and abusing each other. He stated that he did not remember the
names of the accused persons who were apprehended by him and PW-3, but
denied that their names were Suraj Singh and Sonu. On the recovered knife
being produced in Court, the witness stated that the produced knife is not the
same which was recovered from the possession of JCL ‘T’.
During cross-examination by the counsel for the accused/Mohd.
Naseem, the witness stated that the four accused persons were verbally
abusing each other and not the complainant.
The cross-examination conducted on behalf of accused/Mohd.
Naseem was adopted by the learned counsel for the accused/Suraj Singh.
10.
The primary witnesses in the present case are the injured
complainant/PW-2; his son and eyewitness, PW-3; and their relative and
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
eyewitness, the teaseller PW-4. As noted above, a perusal of their
testimonies shows that they have all given varying accounts of the incident
in question.
11.
The injured complainant/PW-2 has not ascribed any role to the
appellants. He has not identified the appellants and rather denied that the
names of the accused persons apprehended at the spot were Suraj and Sonu.
He also denied that the appellants were the associates of the person who had
stabbed him. It is also extremely pertinent to note that despite being crossexamined by the learned APP for the State, no suggestion regarding the
appellants herein catching hold of him to enable the concerned accused to
stab him in the abdomen was given to the complainant.
12.
On the other hand, both PW-3 and PW-4 have given a different
version of the incident. PW-3 could not identify as to who had stabbed his
father. He has further deposed that the four boys also gave beatings to PW-3
himself. However, no charge was framed on this aspect. Neither any MLC is
prepared qua this witness. Notably, he did not ascribe to appellants any role
in the stabbing of his father. He was also unable to individually identify the
two appellants insomuch as which one of the two was Suraj, and which one
was Sonu.
PW-4 denied that the names of the two persons who had been
apprehended at the spot by him and PW-3 were Suraj Singh and Sonu. He
stated that the appellants had held the complainant but did not remember
which appellant had held him from which side.
13.
As for the role ascribed to the appellants in the incident in question,
the complainant/PW-2 did not ascribe any role to the appellants; PW-3
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
ascribed to them the role of holding the complainant and of having given
beatings to PW-3 himself; while PW-4 ascribed to them the role of holding
the complainant and giving beatings to him.
14.
In the absence of any detailed testimony on this point, it would be
erroneous to read beyond the record and assume that the appellants shared a
common intention in furtherance of which the complainant was stabbed.
15.
The above conclusion is further supported by the inconsistencies
evident in the versions of the two eyewitnesses as to the actions of the
appellants, with PW-3 stating that the appellants had beaten him up when he
tried to intervene, and PW-4 stating that the appellants had beaten up the
complainant when he had tried to intervene.
16.
It is also worthwhile to note at this stage that it has come out in the
testimony of the complainant that there were 25-30 persons present at the
spot at the time of the incident, yet none of them were examined by the
prosecution to establish the facts of the situation. It is also worth mentioning
that neither PW-3 nor PW-4 identified the recovered knife as the weapon of
offence upon it being produced in Court.
17.
In light of the testimonies of the key witnesses, the prosecution has
failed to prove the case against the appellants beyond reasonable doubt. In
view thereof, the impugned judgment and order on sentence must be set
aside. Accordingly, the present appeals succeed and the appellants are
acquitted.
18.
The bail bonds furnished by the appellants stand cancelled and their
sureties are discharged.
19.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the Trial Court and the
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
concerned Jail Superintendent.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 13, 2026
nb
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
23:35:58
CRL.A. 1024/2017 & CRL.A. 1034/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review