Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 19.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
SUPREME COOPERATIVE GROUP HOUSING SOCIETY LTD
AND ANR
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Raj Panjwani, Sr Adv. with Mr.
Abhishek Puri Adv., Mr. Sahil Grewal Adv.
versus
D.D.A. AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Arjun Pant, ASC with Ms Latika
Malhotra, Adv. for R1
Mr. Anand Prakash, SC with Ms Varsha Arya
Advocate for R2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASMEET SINGH
:
JASMEET SINGH, J (Oral)
1.
This is a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India seeking the following prayers:“a) Issue appropriate Writ, Order of Direction calling for the
records of the case and quash and set aside the
communication dt. 14.9.2012 (Annexure P) demanding
composition fee;
b) Direct that composition fee will be levied by the DDA upto
31.3.1993 in terms of the policy in force on that date;
c) Direct that DDA/MCD will grant all consequential benefits
like C & D Forms, completion certificate etc;
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
d) Allow the present Writ Petition with exemplary costs in
favour of the Petitioners; and”
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner No. 1, a Cooperative House
Building Society registered under the Delhi Cooperative Societies
Act, 1971, consists of practicing lawyers. Pursuant to its application,
on 03.05.1983, the respondent No. 1 i.e., Delhi Development
Authority (“DDA”), allotted and handed over possession of 5 acres of
land to the petitioner No. 1 society for construction of 300 flats for its
members.
3.
Due to failure on the part of members to pay up the call money the
construction was carried out in two phases. In first phase, after
construction of 215 flats a draw of lots was held for allotment of flats.
However, the Registrar Cooperative Societies tried to cancel the draw
of lots and the petitioner No. 1 society challenged the same. A
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 20.09.1990 in Writ
Petition (Civil) No. 2331/1990 held the draw of lots to be valid.
4.
Thereafter, the petitioner No. 1 society made an application for Form
„C‟ and „D‟ to the DDA in respect of 215 flats, however, the DDA did
not grant the same on the ground that the construction was not
complete at that time. As some members did not pay up the call
money, the construction was delayed and the petitioner No. 1 society
had to get the plans revalidated from time to time. During this time,
vide letter dated 10.01.1992, DDA demanded payment of composition
fee of Rs.5,56,462.50/- for the period upto 02.11.1991.
5.
On 17.07.1992, in the second phase the petitioner No. 1 society
completed construction of the remaining 85 flats and again applied for
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
„C‟ and „D‟ forms from the DDA. The Municipal Corporation of
Delhi completed assessment under Section 176 of the Delhi
Municipal Corporation Act, assessing balance 85 flats with effect
from 01.04.1993.
6.
During this period the petitioner No. 1 society got into disputes with
the Contractor/Architect. Subsequently, arbitration was conducted and
the resultant arbitration Award is under challenge before this Court.
7.
The petitioner No. 1 society could not obtain „C‟ and „D‟ Forms and
completion certificate due to objections raised by the DDA. The
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.
10772/1996 vide order dated 09.05.1996 directed Delhi Electric
Supply Undertaking to get the premises inspected and to provide
permanent electric connection to the petitioner No. 1 society.
8.
In the meanwhile the DDA vide letter dated 18.03.1996 raised a
demand of Rs. 46,75,069.05/- including Rs. 44,51,700/- towards
composition fee for the period upto 02.05.1996.
9.
In December, 1997, the petitioner No. 1 society challenged the
demand for composition fee by filing Writ Petition (C) No.
5616/1997. When the writ petition as heard for the first time on
19.12.1997, this Court granted stay on the operation of the demand
letter dated 18.03.1996. The order of interim stay granted on
19.12.1997 was later made absolute vide order dated 25.08.1998.
10. The writ petition filed by the petitioner No. 1 society was disposed of
vide order dated 29.04.2009, wherein paragraph No. 16 reads as
under:-
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
“16. In these circumstances, it is not possible to accept the
plea of the respondent-DDA that the petitioner-Society will be
liable to pay composition fee till today or till the time Forms C
and D are not issued. Accordingly, it is directed that
respondent-DDA is entitled to charge composition fee upto 31st
March, 1993. DDA will compute the said composition fee and
issue letter of demand within four weeks. The petitionerSociety will make payment of the said demand within eight
weeks thereafter along with interest @ 6% p.a. as stipulated in
clause III.”
11. Thereafter, in compliance of the order dated 29.04.2009, the DDA
vide letter dated 25.9.2009 demanded a sum of Rs. 1,19,04,925/- as
composition fee from the petitioner No. 1 Society up to 31.03.1993.
The said letter is extracted below:“F4(556)80/GH/DDA/8144
Dated: 25.9.2009
The Hony. Secretary/President
Supreme CGHS Ltd.
Plot No 14, Patparganj
Mayur Vihar
Delhi 110 091
Sub: Regarding outstanding dues against the Society on
account of composition fee and ground rent etc.
Sir,
In compliance of Hon'ble Delhi High Court's order dated
29.4.2009, wherein DDA has been directed to compute
composition fee upto 31.3.1993. Accordingly, the composition
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
fee has been worked out as per the latest policy dated 4.1.2007
by Accounts Branch. The details of the outstanding dues are as
under:1. Composition fee upto 31.3.93
Rs. 1,19,04,925.00
2. Ground rent upto 15.1.2010
Rs. 7,23,401.12
3. Interest on G.Rent upto 14.7.09
Rs. 5,93,825.30
Total
Rs. 1,32,22,151.42
You are, therefore, requested to deposit this amount through
the bank challan in favour of DDA in SBI/CBI, Vikas Sadan,
New Delhi and third copy of the bank challan be sent to the
undersigned.
It may be noted that if intimation about the depositing of this
amount is not received within eight weeks the interest will be
charged as per the orders of the Hon'ble Court.
Yours faithfully
Sd/Dy. Director (GH) DDA”
12. The petitioner No. 1 society in reply wrote to DDA and brought to its
attention that the composition fee is to be calculated in terms of the
policy in force as on 31.03.1993. However, the DDA insisted on it
demand of composite fee as demanded in the demand letter.
13. The said demand of the DDA was again challenged by some of the
members of the petitioner No. 1 society by filing the Writ Petition(C)
No. 4378/2012, which was disposed of vide order dated 24.07.2012.
The operative portion of the said reads as under:-
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
“In these circumstances, it is deemed appropriate to dispose of
this petition in limini with direction to Respondent - DDA to
effectively deal with the petitioners Representations (Annexure
P-4, Annexure P-5 and Annexure P-8) and pass a speaking
order after giving hearing to the representatives of the
petitioner and the needful be done expeditiously, preferably
within a period of four weeks and intimation of it be given to
the petitioner within two weeks thereafter. Since the
representations are of the Supreme Court Cooperative Group
Housing Society Ltd., so this Society ought to be heard during
the hearing so afforded by the Respondent - DDA.
With aforesaid observations, this petition is disposed of with
no orders as to costs. ….”
14. Pursuant to the said order, the DDA, after giving a personal hearing to
the petitioners, passed the impugned order dated 14.09.2012. The
operative portion of the same reads as under:“I have perused the representations mentioned above as well
as the representation dated 06.08.12 and also heard the oral
submissions of the representatives of the petitioner. The main
contention in all the representations of the petitioner is that
the policy of DDA circulated vide circular dated 04.01.07 is
not applicable to the case of the petitioner on account of the
fact that DDA cannot retrospectively apply its policy dated
04.01.07 to work out the composition fee upto the period
31.03.93:
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
It has also been claimed by the petitioners representative
that the composition fee upto the year 31.03.93 ought to have
been calculated as per the rate applicable as on 31.03.93 and
as per their calculation, the demand of composition fee works
out to Rs. 14,16,450/-.
However, neither the petitioner nor the representative of the
society were able to dispute the fact that they have ever
deposited any amount of composition fee prior to the circular
dated 04.01.07. The contention of the society that the matter
remained subjudice for a period of 12 years does not help the
case of the petitioner for the simple reason that the right of
DDA for recovery of composition fee was never under any
challenge. The only dispute before the Hon'ble Court was qua
the period of composition fee. Therefore, no body prevented
the society or the petitioners to deposit the demanded amount
or at least the admitted amount of the composition fee with the
DDA. The admitted amount of the composition fee was
deposited with the DDA much after the policy dated 04.01.07
came into force. The payment of Rs.22,12,202/- vide challan
no. 13206 dated 14.12.09 is much after the policy dated
04.01.07 that too after raising the revised demand.
The policy dated 04.01.07 itself, provide that in case where
demand has been raised but the payment has not been made as
per the terms of the demand letter, the composition fee shall be
re-worked as per the latest policy. Admittedly no payment was
made either of the admitted amount or the demanded amount
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
or any part thereof prior to coming into force the policy dated
04.01.2007. Therefore, the applicable policy can only be the
latest policy dated 04.01.07 for working the amount of
composition fee. Therefore, the representation and the
contention of the petitioner and the society have no force.
It is also relevant to mention here that in the public hearing
some of the members of the society namely Sh. P.N. Gupta/ flat
no. 245, Sh. Anil Kumar Jha/ flat no. 262, Sh. S.M. Kumar/ flat
no. 109, Sh. Vijay Panjnam/flat no. 69. Sh. A.K. Srivastava/
flat no. 46, and others have submitted that on the basis of
demand raised by the DDA amounting to Rs. 1,36,19,039 vide
letter dated 31.07.12, the Managing Committee of the society
had raised individual demand notice to the members for
Rs.45,397/- as individual proportionate share of members. A
few of the members who wanted to resolve the dispute
deposited their respective contribution with the society.
However, in a subsequent meeting dated 22.07.12, the society
recalled its earlier resolution dated 07.07.12 and decided to
challenge the mode of calculation of composition fee. These
members have submitted that there is no point in withholding
the payment towards the aforesaid demand of DDA when
interest is accruing thereupon heavily which keeps on
multiplying. The aforesaid members have requested for
calculation of their individual share as on, 31.08.12 and
sought permission to deposit the same.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
Therefore, in my opinion, the representation filed by the
petitioner vide Annexure P-4, P-5 and P-8 (Supra) alongwith
their latest representation dated 06.08.12 have no merits and
they are liable to be rejected. The demand raised by the DDA
vide letter dated, 05.07.12 is accordingly re-iterated. In views
of the representations of the individual members who willing
to deposit their proportionate share of the demand alongwith
interest accrued upto the date of payment, liberty is granted to
them to deposit their individual share with accrued interest.
The representations are accordingly disposed. Copies of this
order be provided to the petitioners society & other individual
members who have offered to pay their individual shares.”
15. Hence, the petitioners filed the present petition assailing the impugned
order dated 14.09.2012.
16. Mr. Panjwani, learned senior counsel for the petitioners, states that the
stand taken by DDA amounts to a clear violation of the Order of this
Court dated 24.09.2009 and more particularly paragraph No. 16 of the
said order (reproduced above), which is clear in its ambit and scope.
The said order clearly directed the DDA to charge composition fee
upto 31.03.1993. He further states that it is not the case that the
petitioners were unwilling to deposit the composition fee, but the
petitioners were challenging the quantum of the composition fee
which was leviedon the petitioners by the DDA.
17. Per contra, Mr. Pant, learned ASC for the DDA, draws my attention
to the policy dated 04.01.2007, which is extracted below:-
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
“No.F1(EOT)/05/LSB(I)/I
Dated: 04.1.2007
CIRCULAR
Subject: Rates of Composition Fee for delay in
construction on Residential, Commercial, Institutional and
Cooperative Group Housing Societies Plots.
In supersession to all previous orders/instructions
on the subject, Lt. Governor, Delhi is pleased to revise the
existing rates of composition fee for extension of time for
period of construction on plots as annexed herewith.
2. In cases where demand has been raised but the payment
has not been received as per the terms of demand letter the
composition fee shall be reworked as per the latest policy.
4. With effect from 18.6.2006, as per press notice already
issued by DDA, the maximum permissible period for
construction of various categories of plots allotted or
auctioned by DDA shall be limited to 10 years. In addition,
in all surviving leases, as already circulated vide circular
of even no. dated 21.7.2006 of OSD(Lands), where the
construction has not been undertaken even after the lapse
of 10 years from the date of possession, last opportunity
has been given to complete the construction by 31.12.2007.
Failure to complete construction by 31.12.2007 will result
in determination of lease/resumption of plot by DDA
without any further notice.
5. Other terms and conditions as contained in Circular No.
AO (Proj)/Misc/Composition/Pt-1/36 dated 31.10.1995,
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
24.7.2001
and
No.F2(2)/2005/Cordn/LD/99
dated
22.3.2005 shall remain the same.
6. The revised rate of composition fee will come into force
from the date of issue of this circular.
[PRAHLAD SINGH]
Director (Land Costing)”
18. He states that the demand made by the DDA is in accordance with the
said policy of the DDA. As per paragraph No. 2 of the policy, as no
payment was made either by petitioner No. 1 Society or its members
prior to Policy dated 04.01.2007, the demand would be calculated on
the basis of Policy dated 04.01.2007.
19. I have heard learned counsels for the parties.
20. In the present case, the petitioners duly challenged the imposition of
composition fee in the year 1997 itself when the DDA levied it vide
letter dated 18.03.1996 and the said demand as raised by the DDA
was stayed by this Court vide order dated 19.12.1997.
21. Later, vide order dated 29.04.2009 passed in Writ Petition (C) No.
5616/1997 and more particularly in paragraph No. 16 (reproduced
above), the Court in clear words stated that composition fee upto
31.03.1993 has to be levied. Thereafter, the DDA vide letter dated
25.09.2009 demanded composition fee from the petitioner No. 1
Society up to 31.03.1993 but calculated as per Policy dated
04.01.2007.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
22. The same was also challenged by some of the members of the
petitioner No.1 society by filing the Writ Petition (C) No. 4378/2012,
which was disposed of vide order dated 24.07.2012.
23. After the Order dated 29.04.2009 was pronounced, the petitioner No.
1 society on 14.12.2009 deposited the composition fees in terms of
the policy in force as on 31.03.1993 amounting to Rs.14,16,450/along with other due amounts, as also admitted by the respondent
DDA. This shows that it was not that the petitioners were unwilling to
make the payment for composition fee or were trying to evade the
payment, but the petitioners were challenging the computation of
composition fee as made by the DDA.
24. In view of the aforesaid, the observations in the impugned order that
the demand was raised by the respondent DDA and since payments
were not made, the composition fee will have to be re-worked as per
the latest policy is flawed.
25. In the present matter, the policy as per which the composite fee is to
be calculated is the one in place at the time when the construction was
completed, which is upto 31.03.1993, as also directed in the order
dated 29.04.2009 (reproduced above). When the composite fee is to
be calculated upto 31.03.1993, then the policy for its calculation shall
also be the one in force at that time.
26. For the said reasons, the present petition is allowed and the
respondent shall re-work the amount due and payable by the
petitioners as per the policy prevalent from 31.03.1993 to 31.03.1996.
27. The demand shall be raised within 4 weeks from today and the
petitioners shall deposit the amount, if any, within 4 weeks thereafter.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
28. The petition is disposed of in aforesaid terms.
JASMEET SINGH, J
JANUARY 19, 2026 / (MS)
(Corrected and released on 27.01.2026)
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
19:52:30
W.P.(C) 7220/2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review