Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
(APPELLATE SIDE)
FMA 1842 of 2025
With
CAN 1 of 2025
Suparna Das
Vs
The State of West Bengal & Others
Before:
The Hon’ble Justice Arijit Banerjee
&
The Hon’ble Justice Rishad Medora
For the appellant
: Mr. Sattwik Bhattacharya, Adv.,
Mr. Ashutosh Bhattacharya, Adv.
Mr. Aritra Roy, Adv.
Ms. Reshma Sharma, Adv.
For the Respondent No. 4
: Mr. Amal Kr. Sen, Adv.,
Mr. Bhaskar Nandi, Adv.
Ms. Sahina Sumi, Adv.
For the State
: Mr. Amit Chakraborty, Adv.,
Mr. Phalguni Bandopadhyay, Adv.
Ms. Soma Chakraborty, Adv.
Mr. Kaustav Seal, Adv.
For Orders on
: 09.09.2026
Arijit Banerjee, J. :1.
This appeal is directed against a judgment and order dated
October 28, 2025, whereby a learned Judge of this Court dismissed the
appellant’s writ petition, being WPA 8524 of 2024.
2.
In the year 2014, the appellant had approached a learned Judge
of this Court by filing WP No. 9847(W) of 2014, with the grievance that
her prayer for grant of stage carriage permit in route nos. 215 and
215/1 had been turned down by the Regional Transport Authority on
the ground that there was no vacancy. Learned Counsel for the
petitioner had challenged the finding that there was no existing
vacancy. Learned State Counsel had reiterated that there was no
existing vacancy. However, he assured the Court that the petitioner’s
application will be considered as soon as a new vacancy arises, on
priority basis. The learned Judge disposed of that writ petition by an
order dated June 30, 2014, with the following direction:“I have considered the submissions of the respective parties
and materials on record. I cannot go into the correctness of
the factual finding as to whether there is existing vacancy or
not. Writ petition is disposed of by giving liberty to the
respondent authorities to consider the application of the
petitioner afresh for grant of stage carriage permit in Route
Nos. 215 and 215/1 on a priority basis as and when new
vacancy arises.”
3.
The appellant again approached a learned Judge of this court in
the year 2023 by filing WPA 23015 of 2023 contending that by a notice
dated August 4, 2023, the transport authorities had declared one
vacancy in route nos. 215 and 215/1. The petitioner had made a
representation seeking issuance of permit in her favour on the said
routes in terms of this court’s earlier order dated June 30, 2014. It was
prayed that such representation should be considered at the earliest.
The learned Judge disposed of that writ petition with the following
direction:“In view of the above, the writ petition is disposed of directing
the
2nd
respondent
to
consider
and
dispose
of
the
representation submitted by the petitioner in terms of the
order passed by this Court in WP no. 9847 (W) of 2014 on
30th June, 2014 within two months from the date of
communication of this order upon affording reasonable
opportunity of hearing to all the stakeholders including the
petitioner, in accordance with law.
The petitioner is directed to serve copy of this order along
with a copy of the application for permit as well as
representation to the 2nd respondent at the earliest.
The decision taken by the authority shall be communicated
to the petitioner within a week thereof.”
4.
Once again the appellant approached a learned Judge of this
Court by filing WPA 8524 of 2024, in the present round of litigation.
The appellant challenged a resolution taking by the Regional Transport
Authority, Kolkata in its meeting held on December 19, 2023, rejecting
the application filed by the appellant for issuance of permit in respect of
the single vacancy declared in routes 215 and 215/1. When the
application was moved before a learned Single Judge on May 21, 2024,
the learned Judge called for a report in the form of an affidavit from the
State respondents, annexing to the report all relevant papers. By way of
interim measure, the impugned resolution, in so far as issuance of
permit on route nos. 215 and 215/1 was concerned, was stayed till
July 31, 2024.
5.
Report in the form of affidavit affirmed on July 23, 2024, was
filed by the Secretary, Regional Transport Authority, Kolkata annexing
thereto all relevant documents pertaining to the application of the
present appellant.
6.
The writ petition came up for final hearing before another learned
Judge of this Court on October 28, 2025. By the judgment and order
under challenge in this appeal, the learned Judge dismissed the writ
petition. The operative portion of the order reads as follows:“(11) The legal framework emphasizes public interest and
equitable distribution of permits. In this regard section 71 (3)
(b), (c) and (d) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, are worth
mentioning, which are as follows:“71.
Procedure
of
Regional
Transport
Authority
in
considering
application for stage carriage permit.—
(1) **
**
**
(2) **
**
**
(3) (a)
**
**
**
(b) Where the number of stage carriages are fixed under
clause (a), the Government of the State shall reserve in the
State certain percentage of stage carriage permits for the
scheduled castes and the scheduled tribes in the same ratio
as in the case of appointments made by direct recruitment
to public services in the State.
(c) Where the number of stage carriages are fixed under
clause (a), the Regional Transport Authority shall reserve
such number of permits for the scheduled castes and the
scheduled tribes as may be fixed by the State Government
under sub-clause (b).
(d) After reserving such number of permits as is referred to
in clause (c), the Regional Transport Authority shall in
considering an application have regard to the following
matters, namely:—
(i) financial stability of the applicant;
(ii) satisfactory performance as a stage carriage
operator
including payment of tax if the applicant is or has
been an operator of stage carriage service; and
(iii) such other matters as may be prescribed by the
State
Government:
Provided that, other conditions being equal, preference shall be
given to applications for permits from—
(i) State transport undertakings;
(ii) co-operative societies registered or deemed to have
been
registered under any enactment for the time being in
force;
(iii) ex-servicemen;
(iv) any other class or category of persons, as the State
government may, for reasons to be recorded in writing
consider necessary;
**
**
**
**
**”
(12) Hence, there are statutorily mandated categories of
persons to be given priority in case of grant of stage carriage
permits. Hence, the Court’s order must not be read beyond
the bounds of the statute, as the petitioner has made
endeavour to do in the instant writ petition. Any other case,
to be prioritised has to qualify the first round of hurdles of
being equal in all other conditions, as provided in the statute.
This priority is not absolute but is applicable “when all other
conditions are equal”.
(13) In this case according to the parameters like the financial
stability of the incumbents, their respective experience and
others the petitioner has not emerged as an equal to the other
incumbent.
Rather
the
other
incumbent/respondent
outreaches the writ petitioner. Therefore, the writ petitioner
not being equal in the context of the parameters as prescribed
in the statute, her case could not have been prioritised as
claimed. In that view of the matter, the Court finds no
infirmity or illegality as alleged, in the decision of the Board
vide resolution dated December 19, 2023. Hence, the instant
writ petition should fail.”
7.
Being aggrieved the writ petitioner is before us by way of this
appeal.
8.
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned Advocate appearing for the appellant
has urged three points before us. Firstly, he argued that the earlier
orders of this Court directed the authorities to consider the appellant’s
application for permit on the concerned routes, “on priority basis",
upon vacancy arising on those routes. Therefore, there was no scope for
the authorities to reject the appellant’s application. Priority had to be
given to the appellant as per orders of this Court.
9.
Secondly, learned Counsel argued that the resolution dated
December 19, 2023, was not signed by all the members of the Board of
the Regional Transport Authority, Kolkata Region, who attended such
meeting.
10.
It was thirdly argued that the successful candidate i.e., the
private respondent in this appeal, who was granted permit on the
concerned bus routes, used her same financial and other credentials
for making two separate applications for permits on two separate routes
involved in the present litigation. This is impermissible. Had she broken
up her credentials for the two separate applications, she would have
secured lesser marks than the appellant in the assessment/evaluation
process. In that case, the appellant would have been the successful
candidate.
11.
Mr. Sen, learned Senior Counsel representing the private
respondent submitted that it is absurd to argue that the appellant’s
credentials could not be evaluated vis-a-vis other applicants on the
same bus route and that the appellant had necessarily to be granted
the permit whether or not she qualified in the evaluation process in
terms of the Motor Vehicles Act and the statutory rules.
12.
Mr. Sen then submitted that the broad sheet containing the
evaluation/assessment of the various applicants was signed by all the
members of the Board. He drew our attention to the broad sheet. He
submitted that communication of the result by a letter under the
Signature of the Chairman of the Board or the resolution passed on the
basis of the broad sheet being signed by the Chairman alone, is no
irregularity at all. It is a matter of internal management of the
authority.
13.
In response to the third point argued by Mr. Bhattacharya, Mr.
Sen filed a projected broad sheet showing the relative positions of the
appellant and the private respondent as well as other applicants for
permit on Route 215 and 215/1, after splitting the bank balance and
experience of the private respondent into two equal halves for two
separate applications on two different routes. We have taken such
projected broad sheet on record. A copy was made over to learned
Advocate for the appellant. The correctness of the computations in such
projected broad sheet has not been disputed by appellant’s learned
Counsel. Such projected broad sheet shows that even after splitting of
the bank balance and experience of the private respondent, she would
be the successful applicant.
14.
We have considered the rival contentions of the parties.
15.
We are unable to accept the appellant’s argument that there was
a mandate of this Court directing the respondent authorities to issue
permit on the relevant route in favour of the appellant herein. The
direction was for “consideration” of the appellant’s application “on a
priority basis”, once vacancy arose on the concerned bus routes. In
other words, the authorities were directed to expeditiously consider the
application of the appellant once vacancy arose. The consideration
necessarily had to be in accordance with the concerned statutory
provisions, which has been done in this case. It would appear from the
broad sheet that the appellant’s rank was 3 having obtained 5.269799
marks out of total 35 marks. The appellants rank was 1 having
obtained 10.04081 marks.
Hence, we find no merit in the first
contention of the appellant.
16.
As regards the second contention of the appellant, we find that
the broad sheet has been signed by all requisite members of the Board.
This is the base document. Lack of signature of all the members of the
Board on the minutes of the meeting wherein the Board took the
concerned resolution rejecting the appellant’s application, is neither
here nor there. At the highest, it would be a curable irregularity. It is a
matter of internal management of the respondent authority. We do not
find any substance in the second contention of the appellant also.
17.
The third argument of the appellant is also meritless. Learned
Advocate for the private respondent has demonstrated that even if the
financial and other credentials of the private respondent were equally
split in connection with the two separate applications for permits on
two different routes, the private respondent would still secure highest
mark in the evaluation process following the statutory norms, in so far
as bus route nos. 215 and 215/1 are concerned. Therefore, it cannot be
said that the private respondent has received any undue favour or that
any injustice has been meted out to the appellant by issuance of permit
on the concerned routes in favour of the private respondent.
18.
A factual dispute was sought to be raised by learned Advocate for
the appellant to the effect that if one considers the income tax returns
of the private respondent for the past few years, it would appear that
she has mentioned inflated figures in her application. Disputes of such
factual nature are not to be gone into in a writ proceeding. The writ
court is generally not concerned with the merits of a decision but with
the decision making process. In the present case, no illegality or
impropriety in the decision making process could be demonstrated by
the appellant.
19.
We have considered the judgment and order sought to be
assailed in this appeal. It is a well-reasoned order taking into account
the relevant statutory provisions. The learned Judge has also correctly
interpreted the earlier orders passed by two other learned Judges of
this Court on the two previous writ petitions. We see no reason to
interfere with the order under appeal.
20.
Accordingly, the appeal fails and is dismissed along with the
connected application. There will be no order as to costs.
21.
Urgent certified website copies of this ORDER, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties subject to compliance with all the requisite
formalities.
I agree.
(Rishad Medora, J.)
(Arijit Banerjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review