Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P(S). No. 5833 of 2023
---1.
Sunil Kumar, Aged about 28 years, Son of Sri Dhirendra Prasad Mahato,
Resident of Village: Kanaudi, P.O.: Kariyatpur, P.S.: Daru, District:
Hazaribag, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health SubCentre, Bharajo, P.O.: Jharpo, P.S.: Tati Jhariya, District: Hazaribag.
2. Surbhi Kumari, Aged about 26 years, Daughter of Sri Prem Prakash Prasad,
Resident of Dimna Road, Sankosai, Road No. 1, Near Hari Mandir, P.O. &
P.S.: Mango, Jamshedpur, District: East Singhbhum, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health Sub-Centre, Jalla, P.O. & P.S.:
Patamda, District: East Singhbhum.
3. Nitish Kumar, Aged about 25 years, Son of Sri Rohit Mahto, Resident of
Village: Borobing, Murubanda, P.O.: Barki Pona, P.S.: Rajrappa Project,
District: Ramgarh, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health
& Wellness Centre, Kander, P.O. & P.S.: Gomia, District: Bokaro.
4. Sikandar Prasad, Aged about 27 years, Son of Sri Koleshwar Prasad, Resident
of Village: Tuladih, P.O.: Gadibharkatta, P.S.: Birni, District: Giridih,
presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre,
Bagodih, P.O.: Bagodih, P.S.: Sariya, District: Giridih.
5. Kanchan Kumari, Aged 25 about years, Daughter of Sri Bishnu Mahato,
Resident of Village: Manjura, Tola: Goriyadih, Ρ.Ο.: Manjura, P.S. Kasmar,
District: Bokaro, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Centre, Chapri, P.O.: Chapri, P.S.: Nawadih, District: Bokaro.
6. Mariam Magdalena Soren, Aged about 23 years, Daughter of Sri Nathanial
Soren, Resident of Village: Bhalsungia, Ρ.Ο.: Rajdaha, P.S.: Kathikund,
District: Dumka, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health
Sub- Centre, Kormo, P.O. & P.S.: Gopikandar, District: Dumka.
7. Anita Kumari, Aged about 27 years, Daughter of Sri Lilo Mohali, Resident of
Badgunda, P.O.: Baddiha, P.S.: Giridih Mufassil, District Giridih, presently
posted as Community Health Officer, at Health Sub-Centre, Badgunda, P.O.:
Baddiha, P.S.: Giridih Muffasil, District Giridih.
8. Prasanta Kumar Mahato, Aged about 29 years, Son of Sri Ramrup Mahato,
Resident of Village: Dhipa, P.O.: Barposh, P.S.: Manoharpur, District: West
Singhbhum, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health SubCentre, Patahesal, P.O. & P.S.: Saraikella, District: Saraikella-Kharsawan.
9. Nitu Bedia, Aged about 25 years, Daughter of Sri Shyamlal Bedia, Resident
of Village: Padriya, P.O.: Barka Chumba, P.S.: Giddi ‘A’District: Ramgarh,
presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health Sub-Centre,
Degagadha, P.O.: Narayanpur, P.S.: Penk, District: Bokaro.
10. Uday Kumar Saurav, aged about 25 years, Son of Sri Suman Saurav, Resident
of Village: Dhanaidih, P.O.: Senadoni, P.S.: Giridih Mufassil, District:
Giridih, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness
Centre, Jitpur, P.O.: Handadih, P.S.: Giridih Muffasil, District: Giridih.
11. Pushkar Kumar Gupta, Aged about 25 years, Son of Sri Mahendra Kumar
Gupta, Resident of Village: Bishunpura, P.O.: Kocheya, P.S.: Bishunpura,
District: Garhwa, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
Wellness Centre, Bishunpura Nagar, P.O. & P.S.: Bishunpura, District:
Garhwa.
Pushpraj Kumar Paswan @ Pushpraj Kumar, Aged about 28 years, Son of Sri
Basant Kumar Paswan, Resident of Village: Pandeydih Magzine, P.O.:
Sirsiya, P.S.: Giridih Mufassil, District: Giridih, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health & Welness Centre, Udnabad, P.O.:
Udnabad, P.S.: Giridih Muffasil, District: Giridih.
Pinky Kumari, Aged about 27 years, Daughter of Sri Shakti Ram Bedia,
Resident of Village: Hethbarga, P.O.& P.S.: Barlanga, District: Ramgarh,
presently posted as District: Community Health Officer, at Health Wellness
Centre, Nemra,. P.O. & P.S.: Barlanga, District:Ramgarh.
Bhawani Kumari, Aged about 22 years, Daughter of Sri Bhuwaneshwar
Munda, resident of village: Dulmi, Ρ.Ο.: Lowahatu, P.S.: Sonahatu, District:
Ranchi, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness
Centre, Bagesera, P.O. & P.S.: Palkot, District: Gumla.
Jyoti Baxla, Aged about 25 years, Daughter of Sri Rajbansh Oraon, Resident
of Village: Bethat Niche Toli, P.O.: Hesapiri, P.S.: Bagru, District:
Lohardaga, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Centre, Pojenga, Community Health Centre, Palkot, P.O.& P.S.:
Palkot, District: Gumla.
Anjum Kavita Birua, Aged about 22 years, Daughter of Sri Man Mohan
Birua, Resident of Near I.O.L. Petrol Pump, Village: Baliasai, P.O.:
Bharbharia, P.S.: Manjhari, District: West Singhbhum, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Krishnapur, P.O. &
P.S.: Kharsawan, District: Seraikela-Kharsawan.
Pragya Rupali, Aged about 25 years, Daughter of Sri Govind Mishra,
Resident of Flat No. 103, Deo Sampoorna Apartment, Lowadih, P.O. & P.S.:
Lowadih, District: Ranchi, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at
Health & Wellness Centre, Saraiya, P.O. & P.S.: Hariahrganj, District:
Palamau.
Nitin Kumar, Aged about 25 years, Son of Sri Hemlal Gope, Resident of
Village: Birajpur, P.O.: Chapuadih, P.S.: Bengabad, District: Giridih,
presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health Sub-Centre,
Sihodih, P.O.: Sirsiya, P.S.: Giridih Muffasil, District: Giridih.
Simmi Ekka, Aged about 22 years, Daughter of Sri Erus Ekka, Resident of
Village: Bargari, P.O.: Bargari, P.S.: Mandar, District: Ranchi, presently
posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Sursa,
P.O. Murma, P.S.: Mandar, District: Ranchi.
Raj Malhotra, Aged about 26 years, Son of Sri Nirpati Mahto, Resident of
Village & P.O.: Pesham, P.S.: Birni, District: Giridih, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Kasiotol, P.O.:
Baddiha, P.S.: Hirodih, District: Giridih.
Ashish Ranjan, Aged about 24 years, Son of Sri Santosh Kumar Singh,
Resident of Village: Naudiha, P.O.: Bilaspur, P.S.: Haidernagar, District:
Palamau, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Centre, Pataria, P.O.: Bilaspur, P.S.: Haidernagar, District: Palamau.
Ashish Gorai, Aged about 25 years, Son of Sri Ganesh Ch. Gorai, Resident of
Village: Nawadih, P.O.: Deoltand, P.S.: Ichagarh, District: Seraikela-
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
Kharsawan, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Centre, Sursi, P.O. & P.S.: Kuchai, District: Seraikela-Kharsawan.
Swaraj Kumar Bediya @ Swaraj Kumar, Aged about 24 years, Son of Sri
Suresh Bediya, Resident of Village: Lodhma, P.O.: Chhattar Mandu, P.S.:
Ramgarh, District: Ramgarh, presently posted as Community Health Officer,
at Health Sub-Centre, Dhanaydih, P.O.: Senadoni, P.S.: Gidirih Muffasil,
District: Giridih.
Sonu Kumar, Aged about 28 years, Son of Sri Rajendra Mehta, Resident of
At: Khargara, P.O. & P.S. Haider Nagar, District: Palamau, presently posted
as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Basariya Kalan,
Community Health Center, Chainpur, P.O. & P.S.: Chainpur, District:
Palamau.
Suresh Kumar Rajak, Aged about 27 years, Son of Sri Bibhuti Bhushan
Rajak, Residnet of Aguidangra, P.O.: Kamalpur, P.S.: Patamda, District: East
Singhbhum, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health SubCentre, Poklabera, P.O.: Gobarghusi, P.S.: Patamda, District: East
Singhbhum.
Anjali Gupta, Aged about 26 years, Daughter of Sri Sunil Kumar Gupta,
Resident of Village: Rabda, P.O.: Harinamar, P.S.: Chainpur, District:
Palamau, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Center, Nenuwakhura, P.O. & P.S.: Chainpur, District: Palamau.
Ravi Kumar Verma, Aged about 23 years, Son of Sri Ramdayal Mahto,
Resident of At: Mayapur, P.O.: Kheskhari, P.S.: Suriya, District: Giridih,
presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre,
Kheskhari, Community Health Center, Bagodar, P.O. & P.S.: Bagodar,
District: Giridih.
Ankit Raj, Aged about 26 years, Son of Sri Arjun Prasad Yadav, Resident of
Village: Tehro, P.O.: Basodih, P.S.: Satgawan, District: Koderma, presently
posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Kataiya,
P.O. & P.S.: Satgawan, District: Koderma.
Manju Kumari, Aged about 27 years, Daughter of Sri Sarju Rajak, Resident
of Village: Keshargarh, P.O.: Nadkhurkee, P.S.: Baghmara, District:Dhanbad, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health SubCentre, Sadriadih, P.O. & P.S.: Baghmara, District-Dhanbad.
Karan Kumar, Aged about 26 years, Son of Sri Mihir Pandit, Resident of
Village, P.O. & P.S.: Ahilyapur, District: Giridih, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Fuljhariya, P.O.:
Fuljhariya P.S.: Ahilyapur, District: Giridih.
Amrita Singh, Aged about 25 years, D/o Sri Arvind Kumar Singh, Resident of
Gujrat Colony, Chas, P.O. & P.S.: Chas, District: Bokaro, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Kamalpur, P.O. &
P.S.: Jaridih, District: Bokaro.
Saumya Gupta, Aged about 23 years, D/o Dilip Kumar Gupta, Resident of
Chechariya, P.O. & P.S.: Nagar Untari, District: Garhwa, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health Sub-Centre, Chittvishram, P.O. & P.S.:
Nagar Undari, District: Garhwa.
Roop Shikha Kumari @ Roop Shikha, Aged about 29 years, D/o Nandlal
Prajapati, Resident of Basant Vihar Colony, Ravi Steel, Pandra, P.O.: Kamre,
P.S.: Pandra O.P., District: Ranchi, presently posted as Community Health
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Sagalim, P.O.: Sagalim, P.S.: Panki,
District: Palamau.
Chintamani Kumari, Aged about 24 years, D/o Sri Bishram Oraon, Resident
of Village: Jakjor, P.O. & P.S.: Basia, District: Gumla, presently posted as
Community Health Officer, at Health Sub- Centre, Gara, P.O. & P.S.:
Kamdara, District: Gumla.
Anuj Singh, Aged about 25 years, D/o Sri Kedar Singh, Resident of Vilalge:
Ukamar, P.O.: Chhipadohar, P.S.: Barwadih, District: Latehar, presently
posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Ukamar,
P.O.& P.S.: Barwadih, District: Latehar.
Shristy Rani, Aged about 25 years, D/o Sri Surajdeo Prasad, Resident of
Bachra Bazartand, P.O.: Bachra, P.S.: Piparwar, District: Chatra, presently
posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre, Dulmi,
P.O. & P.S.: Tamar, District: Ranchi.
Madhu Deepika Kerketta, Aged about 27 years, D/o Sri Ratan Kerketta,
Resident of Village: Tiril Kokar, Ranchi, P.O.: Bariatu, P.S.: Ranchi Sadar,
District: Ranchi, presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health &
Wellness Centre, Nawadih, P.O.: Nawadih, P.S.: Gumla, District: Gumla.
Priti Poonam Hansda, Aged about 28 years, D/o Sri Raska Hans dak, Resident
of Village: Joraro, P.O.: Paderkoila, P.S.: Amraapra, District: Pakur, presently
posted as Community Health Officer at Health Sub- Centre, Kunjbona, CHC
Palajori, P.O. & P.S.: Palajori, District: Deoghar.
Anjali Minz, Aged about 25 years, D/o Sri Eliazer Minz, Resident of Jhinjhri
Piper Toli, P.O.: Korambi, P.S.: Mandar, District: Ranchi, presently posted
Community Health Officer, at Health Sub- Centre, Raikera, P.O. & P.S.:
Bharno, District: Gumla.
Nisha Kumari, Aged about 29 years, D/o Sri Dut Singh Munda, Resident of
Village: Bhut, Wiankutoli, P.O.:Bhandra, P.S.: Khunti, District: Khunti,
presently posted as Community Health Officer, at Health & Wellness Centre,
Charakpathar, P.O.: Sini, P.S.: Saraikela, District: Saraikela-Kharsawan.
.......Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
2.
3.
4.
The State of Jharkhand through Chief Secretary, At: Project Bhawan,
Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S.: Dhurwa, District: Ranchi.
The Principal Secretary, Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare
Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Nepal House, P.O. & P.S.: Doranda,
District: Ranchi.
The Director-in-Chief, Health Services, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Namkum,
P.O. & P.S.: Namkum, District: Ranchi.
The Director, Public Health Institution, Govt. of Jharkhand, At: Namkum,
P.O. & P.S.: Namkum, District: Ranchi.
.....Respondent(s)
--CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
--For the Petitioners
: Mr. Amit Kr. Tiwari, Advocate
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
For the Respondents
: Mr. Nidhi Rani, Advocate
: Mr. Kumar Anubhaw, Advocate
: Mr. Md. Shahabuddin, SC-VII
: Mr. Zaid Iman, A.C. to S.C.-VII
---
08/ Dated: 11.09.2026
1.
The instant application has been preferred by the petitioners for the
following reliefs:
i.)
To issue necessary order for the permanent appointment of the
petitioners to the post of Community Health Assistant (in short "CHA") instead of
contractual employment, as per the notification of the State Govt., issued under
the seal & signature of the Principal Secretary, Health, Medical Education &
Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Jharkhand vide Memo No. 554 dated 9th
August, 2017 (Annexure- 4), which is the only guiding effect with regard to
service condition of the petitioners:
ii.)
To issue necessary direction to formulate the appointment rules and the
service conditions by which the petitioners' services shall be guided and in
absence thereof the petitioners' services cannot be said to be a proper, valid &
legal appointment:
iii.)
To issue necessary order/direction to the respondents, to pay the salary/
remuneration even the petitioners are appointed on contract basis the honorarium
as decided vide Memo No. 554 dated 9th August, 2017 (Annexure 4) i.e. the Pay
Band II (9,300 -34,800) + Grade Pay 4200, by the Health, Medical Education &
Family welfare department, Govt. of Jharkhand:
AND/OR
For any other relief/reliefs, for which the petitioners are legally entitled,
in the facts & circumstances of this case, for doing conscionable justice to the
petitioners.
2.
Briefly stated, the petitioners had qualification of Bachelor of Science
in Community Health (Graduate), as prescribed and provided by the State
under the Gazette Notification vide Memo No.554 dated 09th August, 2017.
Vide Letter No. 171(6) dated 13.01.2017 the Health, Medical Education &
Family Welfare Department sanctioned the fund for implementation of three
years Bachelor of Science "Community Health Course".
Thereafter, Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare Department,
Govt. of Jharkhand, Ranchi through its Director-in-Chief, Health Services,
issued an advertisement, seeking the applications for the aforesaid course of
Bachelor of Science, in "Community Health (Graduation)", for the Session
2016 - 17.
Further, Notification dated 10.03.2017, published by the Health,
Medical Education & Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Jharkhand,
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
Ranchi in the Jharkhand Gazette, following the direction issued by the Govt.
of India, earmarked the building at Public Health Institution, Namkum,
Ranchi and Health & Family Welfare Training Center, Hazaribag, for
implementation of the course "Bachelor of Science in Community Health
(Graduation)".
Accordingly, the petitioners on completion of all formalities and
criteria were selected and ultimately were admitted in the said course and
declared successful.
3.
Thereafter, the State Govt. vide Memo No. 554 dated 09th August,
2017 published, in the Gazette Notification of the Govt. under the approval &
direction of the Governor, State of Jharkhand, the guidelines with regard to
the petitioners’ course as well as their employment, the service conditions and
the recognition of the course as well as the selection process, the posting after
completion of the courses, creation of post, Appointment Rules, Service
Conditions as well as the remuneration.
4.
The grievance of these petitioners is that, instead of giving permanent
appointment, the respondent issued Letter vide Memo No. 268 dated
01.08.2023 under the seal & signature of the Director, Campaign, appointing
the petitioners and other similarly situated persons on contract basis and
accordingly the petitioners are allocated the place where they are directed to
join.
Thogh, the petitioners made representation dated 24th July, 2023 for
their permanent appointment, to the Chief Secretary, Govt. of Jharkhand and
the Secretary, Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare Department,
Govt. of Jharkhand; but no decision for permanent appointment has been
taken yet.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that for the purpose of
implementation of Central Government Scheme and also pursuant to the
decision of Central Government, the State Government vide Memo No.554
dated 9th
August, 2017 published a Gazette Notification issuing the
guidelines with regard to petitioners’ posts as well as employment coupled
with the service condition and recognition of course along with post.
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
6.
Ld. Counsel further draws the attention of this Court towards the
Gazette Notification which is at Annexure-4 running page no.55, wherein
there is a categorical statement what is to be done after completion of course.
For brevity, the relevant portion of the Gazette Notification is extracted herein
below:“
कोर्स उपराां त पदस्थापन (Posting
after completion of course
र्भी विद्यार्थी जो र्फलतापूिसक कोर्स को पूरा
करें गे , िह वनदे शक प्रमु ख, स्वा. र्ेिाएँ स्वास्थ्य
वनदे शालय द्वारा गवित स्थापना र्वमवत के
अनु शांर्ा/वनर्स य पर विवभन्न स्वास्थ्य उपकेन्द्ोां में
कम्युवनटी हे ल्थ एर्ीस्टें टर् के पद पर कायस करें गे।
आिश्यकतानु र्ार इनकी र्ेिाएँ प्रार्थवमक स्वास्थ्य
केन्द्ोां में भी ली जाएगी ।
इनका मानदे य Pay Band II (9300-34800) +
Grade Pay 4200 – िेतनमान के प्रारम्भिक प्रक्रम
पर ही िेतन दे य होगा। जो स्वास्थ्य प्रशशक्षर् के पद
के र्दृश्य होगा।
इन्हें वनयोजन हे तु र्मकक्ष पदोां पर छूट दी जा
र्केगी।
पद र्ृजन एिां वनयमािली
वनदे शक प्रमु ख, स्वास्थ्य र्ेिाएँ के द्वारा कम्युवनटी
हे ल्थ एर्ीस्टें टर् के नये स्थायी पदोां के र्ृजन वकया
जायगा तर्था वनयुम्भि वनयमािली बनायी जायेगी ।
वनयमािली में कम्यु वनटी हे ल्थ एर्ीस्टें टर् के र्ेिा
शतों का उल्लेख रहे गा ।
7.
From bare perusal of the aforesaid clause in the Gazette Notification,
it is evident that the Government has categorically taken a decision that all
those students, who have completed their course, they will be posted at their
respective place at primary health Centre and other places in the payment
Band-II (9,300-34,800) + Grade Pay 4200.
8.
When the Government had already taken a decision that any employee
like these petitioners who have completed the course, they would be getting
the payment of (9,300-34,800) + Grade Pay of 4200 and would be posted at
various places including Community Health Assistant Centre, Primary Health
Centre etc.; then, there is no reason, as to why the Government is not paying
this Pay Band to these petitioners.
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
9.
In the said notification; the relevant portion of which has extracted
hereinabove, there was also a decision for formation of rules governing these
types of employees.
Several affidavits (counter-affidavit, first supplementary counteraffidavit and second supplementary counter-affidavit) have been filed by the
State, but save and except, the averment regarding formation of the new rules
has been mentioned; no reason has been assigned as to why the petitioners are
not getting the Pay band-II which was indicated in the Gazette information
dated 09th August, 2017.
10.
Admittedly, the petitioners herein have completed their course, which
is obviously subject to verification of dates as to when the respective
petitioners have completed their course; but, as per the Gazette Notification
itself, the moment the respective petitioner(s) have completed their course,
there was no fun in engaging them in a normal remuneration / honorarium and
not paying the Pay Band-II (9,300-34,800) + Grade Pay 4200).
11.
As aforesaid, there is no reason that has been given in either of the
affidavits filed by the State; Accordingly, this Court is of the firm view that
Gazette Notification dated 09th August, 2017, wherein there is a specific
clause and guideline with regard to posting after completion of course and
formation of rules, the Government is duty-bound by the Gazette Notification.
12.
It is true that the Government has formulated the Rules in 2025, but
perhaps that has not been implemented till date as informed by the Ld.
Counsel for the State upon instruction.
13.
Thus, so far as the issue of making rules concerning the petitioners
has already been notified, as per the Gazette Notification which is at
Annexure-4 running page no.55, it is expected that the same will be
implemented soon.
14.
Nevertheless, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
petitioners are entitled for salary right from the date they have completed their
course, i.e., in the Pay Band-II (9,300-34,800) + Grade Pay 4200) from the
date of completion of the course as per the same Gazette Notification
(Annexure-4).
( 2026:JHHC:28106 )
15.
Having regard to the aforesaid discussion, the instant writ application
stands allowed. The petitioner shall be considered as regular employee and
shall be paid as per the Gazette Notification dated 09th August, 2017. The
relevant portion of the same is extracted hereinabove.
16.
The Respondents are directed to issue necessary order w.r.t. the
respective petitioners within a period of 8 weeks from the date of
receipt/production of copy of this order.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
11.09.2026
Uploaded on
21/09/2026
Nandini/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review