Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on:08.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 9163/2018, CM APPL. 35328/2018 and CM APPL.
13817/2022
SUNIL KUMAR TIWARI AND ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kumar Rajesh Singh & Ms.
Punam Singh, Advs. (M:
9811013515)
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, Standing
Counsel-GNCTD
(Services),
Mr. Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs. for R-1/GNCTD (M:
9313964463)
Mr. B.S. Rawat, CI/DTTE for
R-2 (M: 9868747374)
Ms. Pearl Sharma, Adv. for R3/AICTE (M: 9810961327)
+
W.P.(C) 1696/2019
RAGINI GUPTA & ORS
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms.
Purnima
Jain,
Mr.
Awadesh Kumar, & Mr.
Madhur,
Advs.
(M:
9873211671)
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
Through:
+
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, Standing
Counsel-GNCTD
(Services),
Mr. Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs. for R-1/GNCTD (M:
9313964463)
Mr. B.S. Rawat, CI/DTTE for
R-2 (M: 9868747374)
Ms. Pearl Sharma, Adv. for R3/AICTE (M: 9810961327)
W.P.(C) 2446/2019
SHAHEEDA BEGUM QURESHI & ORS. .....Petitioners
Through: Ms.
Purnima
Jain,
Mr.
Awadesh Kumar, & Mr.
Madhur,
Advs.
(M:
9873211671)
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, Standing
Counsel-GNCTD
(Services),
Mr. Uday Singh Ahlawat, Mrs.
Tania Ahlawat, Mr. Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam
and Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advs. for R-1/GNCTD (M:
9313964463)
Mr. B.S. Rawat, CI/DTTE for
R-2 (M: 9868747374)
Ms. Pearl Sharma, Adv. for R3/AICTE (M: 9810961327)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
The present Writ Petitions, preferred by the Petitioners, assail
the correctness of common judgment dated 20.07.2018 in W.P.(C)
9163/2018 and W.P.(C) 2446/2019 as well as judgment dated
27.07.2018 in W.P.(C) 1696/2019 [hereinafter referred to as
‘Impugned Orders’] passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as the
‘Tribunal’], whereby Original Applications bearing O.A. No.
3545/2017 and O.A. No. 4128/2018 were dismissed.
2.
Since the Writ Petitions arise out of a similar set of facts,
involve identical questions of law, and assail the aforesaid common
Impugned Orders, they are being heard together and are disposed of
by this common judgment.
3.
The Petitioners were appointed as Lecturers by way of direct
recruitment during the period between the years 1989 and 1999 in
various Government Polytechnics/Institutions under the Government
of National Capital Territory of Delhi. Over the years, they earned
career advancements and are presently working as Lecturers
(Selection Grade). It is not in dispute that the Petitioners have been
placed in Selection Grade/Stage-IV and are drawing pay in the pay
band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with Academic Grade Pay (AGP) of
Rs.9,000/-. Admittedly, the Petitioners do not possess a Ph.D. degree.
4.
The grievance of the Petitioners arises on account of the fact
that certain Lecturers, including private Respondents No.4 and 5, who
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
are stated to be junior to the Petitioners in service but who possess a
Ph.D. qualification, have been granted the higher AGP of Rs.10,000/-.
The Petitioners, on the other hand, being non-Ph.D. holders, continue
to draw AGP of Rs.9,000/-. According to the Petitioners, the
prescription of Ph.D. as an essential eligibility condition for placement
in AGP of Rs.10,000/- is arbitrary, discriminatory, and violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
5.
Consequently, the issue which arises for consideration in these
Writ Petitions is whether the prescription of a Ph.D. degree as an
eligibility criterion for consideration of Lecturers (Selection
Grade/Stage-IV), pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with AGP of
Rs.9,000/-, for grant of AGP of Rs.10,000/- is arbitrary,
discriminatory, or otherwise illegal under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India?
FACTUAL MATRIX
6.
To appreciate the controversy involved in these Writ Petitions,
it is necessary to briefly notice the relevant facts as emerging from the
record.
7.
The All India Council for Technical Education [hereinafter
referred to as ‘AICTE’] is a statutory body, initially constituted in the
year 1945 as an Advisory Body to the Government of India. It was
subsequently accorded statutory status under the All India Council for
Technical Education Act, 1987 [hereinafter referred to as ‘AICTE
Act’]. AICTE derives its powers and functions from Section 10 of the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
AICTE Act, which, inter alia, empowers it to lay down norms and
standards for courses, curricula, physical and instructional facilities,
staff pattern, staff qualifications, quality of instruction, assessment,
and examinations. For convenience, the same reads as under:“
10. Functions of the Council. (1) It shall be the duty of the Couneil
to take all such steps as it may think fit for ensuring coordinated and
integrated development of technical education and maintenance of
standards and for the purposes of performing its functions under this Act,
the Council may—
*
*
*
(i) lay down norms and standards for courses, curricula,
physical
and
instructional
facilities,
staff
pattern,
staff
qualifications, quality instructions, assessment and examinations;"
8.
In exercise of its statutory powers, AICTE prescribes the
qualifications, service conditions, and pay scales for teachers in
technical institutions, which include Lecturers, Assistant Professors,
Associate Professors, and Professors in Engineering and other
technical colleges. Pursuant thereto, AICTE issued the AICTE (Pay
Scales, Service Conditions and Qualifications for the Teachers and
Other
Academic
Staff
in
Technical
Institutions
(Diploma))
Regulations, 2010, vide Notification dated 05.03.2010.
The same
reads as under:" ALL INDIA COUNCIL FOR TECHNICAL EDUCATION
(PAY SCALES, SERVICE CONDITIONS AND QUALIFICATIONS
FOR THE TEACHERS AND OTHER ACADEMIC STAFF IN
TECHNICAL INSTITUTIONS (DIPLOMA) REGULATIONS 2010
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi the 5th March, 2010
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
F.No.37-3/Legal/2010-In exercise of the powers conferred
under sub-section (1) of section 23 read with section 10 (i) and (v)
of the All India Council for Technical Education, 1987 (52 of 1987)
the All India Council for Technical Education makes the following
Regulations:1. Short Title, Application and Commencement:
1.1 These Regulations may be called the All India Council for
Technical Education (Pay Scales, Service Conditions and
Qualifications For The Teachers And Other Academic Staff In
Technical Institutions (diploma)) Regulations, 2010.
1.2 They shall apply to technical institutions conducting technical
education and such other courses / Programs and areas as notified
by the Council from time to time.
1.3 They shall come into force with effect from the date of their
publication in the Official Gazette.
General
(i) There shall be designations in respect of teachers in
Polytechnics, namely, Lecturer, Senior Lecturer, and Head of the
Department and Workshop Superintendent.
(ii) The pay of teachers and equivalent positions in Polytechnics
shall be fixed according to their designations in two pay bands of
Rs. 15600-39100 and Rs. 37400-67000 with appropriate
"Academic Grade Pay" (AGP in short). Each Pay Band shall have
different stages of Academic Grade Pay which shall ensure that
teachers and other equivalent cadres covered under this Scheme,
subject to other conditions of eligibility being satisfied have several
opportunities for upward movement during their career.
Revised Pay Scales, Service conditions and Career Advancement
Scheme for teachers and equivalent positions:
The pay structure for different categories of teachers and
equivalent positions shall be as indicated below:
(a) Lecturer in Polytechnics
XXX
XXX
XXX
(ix) Lecturers with completed service of 5 years with the AGP of
Rs. 7000 shall be eligible, subject to other requirements laid down
by the AICTE to move up to the AGP of Rs. 8000.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
(x) Incumbent Lecturers (Selection Grade) who have completed 3
years in the pre-revised pay scale of Rs. 12000-18300 on 1.1.2006
shall be placed in Pay Band of Rs. 37400-67000 with AGP Pay of
Rs. 9000 and shall be continued to be designated as Lecturers
(Selection Grade)
(xi) Incumbent Lecturers (Selection Grade) who had not completed
three years in the pay scale of Rs. 12000-18300 on 1.1.2006 shall
be placed at the appropriate stage in the Pay Band of Rs. 1560039100 with AGP of Rs. 8000 till they complete 3 years of service in
the grade of Lecturer (Selection Grade), and thereafter shall be
placed in the higher Pay Band of Rs.37400-67000 and accordingly
designated as Lecturers (Selection Grade)
(xii) Lecturers (Selection Grade), completing 3 years of teaching
with the AGP of Rs. 8000 shall be eligible, subject to other
conditions, as may be prescribed by AICTE, to move to the Pay
Band of Rs. 37400-67000 with AGP of Rs. 9000.
xiii) Posts of HOD shall be in the Pay Band of Rs. 37400-67000,
with AGP of Rs.9000. Directly recruited HOD shall be placed in
the Pay Band of Rs. 37400-67000 with an AGP of Rs. 9000, at the
appropriate stage in the Pay Band in terms of the conditions of
appointment.
xiv) Head of the Department (HOD), completing 3 years of service
in the AGP of Rs. 9000 and possessing a Ph.D. degree in the
relevant discipline shall be eligible, subject to other conditions of
academic performance as laid down by the AICTE, shall be placed
in Rs.37400-67000 with AGP of Rs. 10000.
(xv) For initial direct recruitment at the level of Lecturers, HOD
and Principal, the eligibility conditions in respect of academic and
research requirements shall be as may be or have been prescribed
by the AICTE, through Regulations.
(xvi) All advancements to higher grade pays in various cadres will
be effected subject to completion of two AICTE approved refresher
programs of not less than two weeks duration each and two one
week each TEQIP sponsored programs".
9.
Subsequently, AICTE, vide Notification dated 08.11.2012,
issued the AICTE (Career Advancement Scheme for the Teachers and
Other
Academic
Staff
in
Technical
Institutions)
(Diploma)
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
Regulations, 2012, providing detailed provisions for promotion under
the Career Advancement Scheme (CAS). The same reads as under:"ALL INDIA COUNCIL FOR TECHNICAL EDUCATION
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 8th November, 2012
All India Council for Technical Education (Career Advancement
Scheme for the Teachers and other Academic Staff in Technical
Institutions) (Diploma) Regulations, 2012
F. No. 37-3/Legal/AICTE/2012.— In exercise of its powers conferred
under sub-section (I) of section 23 read with Section 10(i) and (v) of
the A1 India Council for Technical Education Act, 1987 (52 of
1987), the All India Council for Technical Education makes the
following Regulations;
SHORT TITLE, APPLICATION AND COMMENCEMENT
1.1 These Regulations may be called the All India Council for
Technical Education (Career Advancement Scheme (CAS) for the
Teachers and Other Academic Staff in Technical Institutions)
(Degree) Regulations, 2012.
1.2 They shall apply to all technical institutions approved by the
AICTE imparting technical education and such other
courses/Programs and areas as notified by the AICTE from time to
time.
1.3 They shall come into force with effect from the date of them
publication in the Official Gazette.
Provided that in the event, any candidate becomes eligible for
promotion under Career Advancement Scheme in terms of these
Regulations on or after 5th March, 2010, the promotion of such a
candidate shall he governed by the provisions of these Regulations.
XXX
XXX
XXX
STAGES OF PROMOTION UNDER CAREER ADVANCEMENT
SCHEME OF INCUMBENT AND NEWLY APPOINTED
LECTURER:
XXX
XXX
XXX
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
3.8 Lecturer completing three years of teaching in the grade of
Rs.7000 (stage 3) shall be eligible, subject to the qualifying
conditions and the API based PBAS requirements prescribed by
these Regulations, to move to the Pay Band of Rs.37400-67000 with
next higher grade of Rs.8000 (stage 4) and to be designated as
Lecturer (Selection Grade). However those joining the Service after
5th March 2010 shall have also earned Ph. D in addition to above
mentioned requirements to move in the stage 4.
3.9 Lecturer (Senior Scale) completing three years of service in
stage 3 and possessing a Ph.D. Degree in the relevant discipline
shall be eligible to be appointed and designated as Lecturer
(Selection Grade) and be placed in the next higher grade of Rs.9000
(stage 4) subject to following:
(a) satisfying the required credit points as per API based PBAS
requirements as provided in Tables of Appendix 1; and
(b) an assessment by a duly constituted selection committee as
suggested for the direct recruitment of Head of Department"
10.
On 04.01.2026, AICTE issued the Clarification on certain
issues/anomalies pertaining to Qualifications, Pay Scales, Service
Conditions, Career Advancement Schemes (CAS) etc. for Teachers
and other Academic Staff of Technical Institution (Degree/Diploma),
2016. The same reads as under:"ALL INDIA COUNCIL FOR TECHNICAL EDUCATION
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 4th January 2016
[CLARIFICATIONS ON CERTAIN ISSUES/ ANOMALIES
PERTAINING TO QUALIFICATIONS, PAY SCALES, SERVICE
CONDITIONS, CAREER ADVANCEMENT SCHEMES (CAS) etc.
FOR TEACHERS AND OTHER ACADEMIC STAFF OF
TECHNICAL INSTITUTIONS (DEGREE/DIPLOMA)]
F. No. 27/RIFD/Pay Scale/01/2013-14.—In exercise of the powers
conferred under sub-Section (i) of Section 23 read with Section 10
(i) and (v) of the All India Council for Technical Education Act,
1987 (52 of 1987), the All India Council for Technical Education
makes the following Regulations:Signature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
I. Short title, Applications and Commencement:
(a) These Regulations may be called All India Council for
Technical Education (clarifications on certain issues/anomalies
pertaining to Qualifications, Pay Scales, Service Conditions,
Career Advancement Schemes (CAS) etc. for Teachers and other
Academic Staff of Technical Institutions (Degree/Diploma)),2016.
(b) These shall apply to technical institutions conducting technical
educations and such other courses/ programs and area notified by
the Council from time to time.
II. General
AICTE has received several representations seeking clarifications
on certain issues arising out of implementation of AICTE
Regulations No. 37-3/ Legal/AICTE/2010 dated 05th March 2010
on revised Pay Scales, Service Conditions and Qualifications for
the Teachers and other Academic Staff in Technical Institutions
(Degree & Diploma) Regulations, 2010 (here in after referred as
AICTE Regulations, 2010) and No. 37-3/ Legal/AICTE/2012 dated
8th Nov. 2012 on Career Advancement Scheme for the Teachers
and other Academic Staff in Technical Institutions (Degree &
Diploma) Regulations, 2012 (here in after referred to as AICTE
Regulations, 2012). Some of the issues raised from the AICTE
previous Notifications have also been included.
Clarifications on certain issues/ anomalies pertaining to
Qualifications, Pay Scales, Service conditions. Career
Advancement Schemes (CAS) etc. for Teachers and Other
Academic Staff of Technical Institutions (Degree/Diploma)
The clarifications on certain issues of teachers and equivalent
positions are given below:
XXX
XXX
XXX
CORRIGENDUM
IN
AICTE
REGULATIONS,
(DIPLOMA) IN RESPECT OF PARA-3 AND TABLE 11 (A)
3. Stage of Promotion Under Career Advancement Scheme of
Incumbent and Newly Appointed Lecturer :
Para- 3 of AICTE Regulations, 2012 (Diploma)
XXX
XXX
XXX
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
3.8 Lecturer (Selection Grade) completing three years of teaching
in the grade of Rs.8000 (stage 3) shall be eligible subject to the
qualifying conditions and the API based PBAS requirements
prescribed by these Regulations, to move to the Pay Band of
Rs.37400-67000 with next higher grade of Rs.9000 (stage 4) and to
be re-designated as Lecturer (Selection Grade). However, those
joining the Service after 5th March 2010 shall have also earned
Ph. D in addition to above mentioned requirements to move to the
stage 4 subject to following.
(a) Satisfying the required credit points as per API based PBAS
requirements as provided in Tables of Appendix 1 and
(b) An assessment by a duly constituted Selection Committee as
suggested for the direct recruitment of Head of Department.
3.9 Head of the Department (HOD)/Lecturer (Selection Grade),
completing 3 years of service in the AGP of Rs.9000 and
possessing a Ph.D Degree in the relevant discipline shall be
eligible, subject to other conditions of academic performance as
laid down by the AICTE, shall be placed in Rs. 37400-67000 with
AGP of Rs. 10000 (stage 5)".
11.
The Petitioners, appointed as Lecturers between 1989 and 1999
in various Government Polytechnics under the Government of NCT of
Delhi, have earned career advancements and are presently working as
Lecturers (Selection Grade) with AGP Rs.9,000. They do not possess
Ph.D. qualifications. Their grievance arises from the fact that certain
junior Lecturers, including private Respondents No.4 and 5,
possessing Ph.D. qualifications, have been granted AGP Rs.10,000,
whereas the Petitioners, being non-Ph.D. holders, were excluded.
12.
The Petitioners approached the Tribunal, challenging the
implementation of Clause 3.9 of the AICTE Clarification dated
04.01.2016, seeking placement in Academic Grade Pay of Rs.10,000
on par with Lecturers in Selection Grade who possess a Ph.D.
qualification. The Tribunal, after considering the matter, dismissed
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
their Original Applications. Aggrieved by the Impugned Order, the
Petitioners have filed the present Writ Petitions before this Court.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
13.
Learned counsel representing the Petitioners submitted that the
Notification dated 05.03.2010 (AICTE Pay Scales, Service Conditions
and Qualifications for the Teachers and Other Academic Staff in
Technical Institutions (Diploma) Regulations, 2010), specifically
Clauses (xii) and (xiv) provided that all Lecturers (Selection Grade)
who had completed three years of service in Stage-III were entitled to
be considered for placement in the pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000 with
Academic Grade Pay of Rs.9,000. It was pointed out that under these
Regulations, only the Head of the Department (HOD) who had
completed three years of service in the AGP of Rs.9,000 and
possessed a Ph.D. degree in the relevant discipline was eligible to be
placed in the AGP of Rs.10,000. Learned counsel emphasized that the
subsequent Regulations of 2012 (AICTE Career Advancement
Scheme for Teachers and Other Academic Staff) similarly made no
distinction between Ph.D. and non-Ph.D. Lecturers for advancement
to AGP of Rs.9,000. However, Clause 3.9 of the Clarification dated
04.01.2016 introduced such a distinction, which, according to the
Petitioners, lacks any rational connection with the objectives of the
Regulations and creates an arbitrary classification between Lecturers
who possess a Ph.D. and those who do not.
14.
It was further contended that Ph.D. was not an essential
qualification for appointment to the post of Lecturer at the time when
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
the Petitioners were recruited. Therefore, the differentiation made by
Clause 3.9 of the 2016 Clarification in granting AGP of Rs.10,000
solely to Ph.D. holders, while excluding non-Ph.D. Lecturers from the
same benefit, is arbitrary, discriminatory, and contrary to the
principles of equality enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. Reliance was placed upon the judgment dated
28.01.2025 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Ashok
Kumar vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors., 2025:DHC:621-DB,
wherein it was held that a clarification issued by an expert/statutory
authority cannot be permitted to affect vested rights retrospectively. If
a clarification has the effect of modifying eligibility conditions, such a
clarification cannot be applied to divest rights that have already
accrued under the earlier regulatory dispensation.
15.
Per contra, learned counsel representing the Respondents
contended that there is no discrimination in the treatment of Lecturers,
as the grant of AGP is based on academic standards and qualifications
determined by the statutory expert body, namely AICTE. It was
argued that the differentiation made in Clause 3.9 of the 2016
Clarification is not arbitrary but reflects the AICTE’s considered
determination that a Ph.D. represents a higher level of academic
attainment, which justifies placement in the AGP of Rs.10,000.
Learned counsel emphasized that the law itself recognizes distinct
categories of Lecturers, namely those possessing a Ph.D. and those
without, and that these distinctions fall within the statutory discretion
of AICTE in prescribing pay and promotion criteria. Reliance was
placed upon the judgment in All India Shri Shivaji Memorial Society
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
vs. State of Maharashtra (2025) 6 SCC 605, wherein the Supreme
Court reiterated that while courts have the power of judicial review,
they must be slow and cautious in interfering with academic standards
and qualifications prescribed by expert statutory bodies. Judicial
review in such cases is limited and will intervene only where the
prescribed condition is proven to be arbitrary, irrational, illegal, or
without nexus to the object of the statute.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
16.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions advanced
on behalf of the parties and perused the material on record, including
the relevant AICTE Regulations, the Clarification dated 04.01.2016,
and the case law relied upon by both sides.
17.
At the outset, it is noted that the matter primarily involves the
exercise of statutory discretion by an expert body, AICTE, in
prescribing qualifications and career advancement criteria for teachers
in technical institutions. The issue is squarely covered by the
judgment of the Supreme Court in All India Shri Shivaji Memorial
Society (supra), wherein the Court recognized that distinctions
between teachers possessing Ph.D. qualifications and those without,
for purposes of pay and career progression, fall within the domain of
the statutory expert body, and courts should exercise caution before
interfering in such matters.
18.
It is an undisputed fact that, prior to 15.03.2000, a Ph.D. was
not an essential or mandatory qualification for appointment as
Lecturers or Assistant Professors in technical institutions. The private
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
Respondents, though junior in service to the Petitioners, possessed a
Ph.D. The Clarification dated 04.01.2016 introduced a distinction
between Lecturers (Selection Grade/Grade-IV) with Ph.D. and those
without, for the purpose of grant of Academic Grade Pay of
Rs.10,000. The question arises whether such a distinction is arbitrary,
discriminatory, or violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India.
19.
The original AICTE Regulations of 2010, as well as the Career
Advancement Scheme Regulations of 2012, made no distinction
between Lecturers with or without a Ph.D. qualification for the
purpose of placement in AGP of Rs.9,000. However, the Clarification
of 2016 expressly introduced such a distinction. The rationale, as
submitted by the Respondents, is to encourage higher academic
qualifications among teachers, thereby enhancing academic standards
and the quality of technical education. It is well-settled that courts
must be slow to interfere with decisions taken by expert statutory
bodies in academic matters, including qualifications for appointment,
pay, promotion, or entitlement to higher scales, unless such actions are
shown to be arbitrary, mala fide, or without nexus to the statutory
object.
20.
In AICTE vs. Surender Kumar Dhawan, (2009) 11 SCC 726,
the Supreme Court observed that courts are neither equipped nor
possess the academic or technical background to substitute themselves
in place of statutory experts in matters relating to technical education.
Applying this principle to the present case, the prescription of Ph.D.
qualification for Lecturers working in Selection Grade/Grade-IV for
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
grant of AGP of Rs.10,000 is intended to achieve a legitimate
objective, namely, to provide better quality education to students, on
the assumption that higher-qualified teachers are better equipped to
impart
academic
knowledge
effectively.
Consequently,
such
prescription cannot be held to be illegal, arbitrary, or discriminatory.
21.
The measure is also intended as an incentive to encourage
teachers to pursue higher qualifications. The law itself recognizes
distinct categories of teachers, those with Ph.D. qualifications and
those without, and permits different entitlements accordingly. In fact,
the Supreme Court in All India Shri Shivaji Memorial Society (supra)
upheld a similar distinction in the context of Assistant Professors,
validating the expert body’s discretion to prescribe academic
qualifications for advancement in pay and career progression. The
present case is materially similar, the only difference being that the
Petitioners are Lecturers (Selection Grade) while the Respondents in
the cited case were Assistant Professors with Ph.D.
22.
The judgment in Ashok Kumar (supra), is distinguishable. In
that case, the controversy related to the Petitioners’ entitlement to be
appointed as Lecturers (Selection Grade) in the Department of
Training and Technical Education based on the qualifications they
possessed at the time of promotion. The Court there examined
whether the educational qualifications held by the Petitioners entitled
them to promotion. By contrast, the present case concerns the grant of
advance Academic Grade Pay of Rs.10,000 under the Clarification
dated 04.01.2016. Therefore, the principles laid down in Ashok
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
Kumar (supra) regarding vested rights and retrospective impact of
clarifications are not directly applicable to the issue before this Court.
23.
In view of the foregoing, it is clear that the distinction
introduced by Clause 3.9 of the Clarification dated 04.01.2016 is
rationally connected to the objective of encouraging higher academic
qualifications
and
improving
educational
standards.
The
differentiation between Ph.D. and non-Ph.D. Lecturers for purposes of
grant of AGP of Rs.10,000 is neither arbitrary nor violative of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
CONCLUSION & OPEARTIVE DIRECTIONS
24.
For the reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court finds no merit
in the challenge laid by the Petitioners to Clause 3.9 of the
Clarification dated 04.01.2016 issued by the AICTE. The said
provision, which grants Academic Grade Pay of Rs.10,000 to
Lecturers (Selection Grade) / Heads of Department possessing a Ph.D.
qualification upon completion of the prescribed service, is founded on
a rational classification and bears a clear nexus with the object of
enhancing academic standards in technical education.
25.
The differentiation between Lecturers possessing a Ph.D.
qualification and those who do not cannot be said to be arbitrary,
discriminatory, or violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India. The prescription of higher academic qualifications for
advancement in pay and career progression is a matter falling squarely
within the domain of the statutory expert body, namely AICTE, and
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
does not warrant interference in exercise of the extraordinary writ
jurisdiction of this Court.
26.
This Court is also of the view that the Impugned Orders passed
by the Tribunal do not suffer from any infirmity, illegality, or
perversity warranting interference. The Tribunal has correctly
appreciated the statutory framework governing the field and has
applied the settled principles of law governing judicial review in
academic and policy matters.
27.
Consequently, all the Writ Petitions, namely W.P.(C)
9163/2018, W.P.(C) 1696/2019, and W.P.(C) 2446/2019, being
devoid of merit, are hereby dismissed.
28.
All pending applications also stand dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
JANUARY 20, 2026/sp/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review