Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
The Hon’ble Justice Rishad Medora
WPA 24563 of 2025
Sunil Jaiswal
vs.
Thika Tenancy Department, Howrah and Others
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Tarique Quasimuddin, Advocate
Ms. Sanchita Chaudhuri, Advocate
Mr. Adnan Lodi, Advocate
For the State
:
Ms. Aparna Banerjee, AGP
Mr. Sailendra Kr. Tiwari, Advocate
Mr. Krishnayan Ghosh, Advocate
Heard on
: September 17, 2026
Judgment on: September 17, 2026
RISHAD MEDORA, J.:1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition praying for, inter alia, a writ of
and/or in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to cancel and/or
rescind and/or set aside the order dated July 19, 2024 passed by the Deputy
Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah, being the respondent no. 3.
2.
There is a history to this writ petition. The petitioner had earlier filed WPA
No. 12970 of 2023 before this Court praying for an adjudication of the
petitioner’s application under Section 5(3) of the West Bengal Thika Tenancy
(Acquisition and Regulation) Act, 2001 (hereinafter referred to as “the said
Thika Act”). It was pending adjudication before the Thika Controller, Howrah
since February 10, 2023. By an order dated September 6, 2023, a Coordinate
Bench of this Court was pleased to dispose of the said writ petition by
directing the Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah to allot a number to the
petitioner’s aforesaid application under Section 5(3) of the said Thika Act and
to dispose of the said application expeditiously in accordance with law, upon
giving an opportunity of hearing to all concerned, including the petitioner. The
aforesaid order further recorded that it was expected that such adjudication
would be completed within an outer limit of 3 months from the date of
communication of such order to the Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah.
3.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order dated September 6, 2023, the aforesaid
application filed by the petitioner was numbered as Case No. 02/B/2023. The
said application was thereafter taken up for hearing from time to time on
diverse dates from October 31, 2023 onwards. It appears from the order sheet
in connection with the aforesaid application that the matter was fixed for
hearing on various dates, including 30.11.2023, 18.01.2024, 08.02.2024 and
07.03.2024.
However, on all the aforesaid dates, the learned advocate
representing the petitioner before the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy,
Howrah sought adjournments for the purposes of producing relevant
documents in support of his case, including a registered deed of lease dated
June 25, 1973. When the matter was fixed for hearing on May 17, 2024 before
the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah, the petitioner’s advocate again
prayed for an adjournment and the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah
noted that the willingness of the petitioner in having his application disposed
of was questionable but nonetheless allowed his prayer for an adjournment as
a last opportunity, and fixed the next date of hearing on July 19, 2024 at 2:00
p.m. and it was recorded in the aforesaid order dated May 17, 2024 that the
said proceeding would be completed on July 19, 2024.
4.
From a perusal of the impugned order dated July 19, 2024, it appears that
the petitioner was neither present nor represented when the matter was taken
up for hearing on such date. In such circumstances, the Deputy Controller,
Thika Tenancy, Howrah proceeded with the matter and passed the impugned
order by which the aforesaid application of the petitioner was dismissed. The
impugned order records that it was contended by the petitioner in his
aforesaid application that he was the owner of the property within building no.
1/10, 1/12, 1/16 and 1/18 presently by way of amalgamation numbered as
1/12, Belilious Road together with the property within holding number 2,
Belilious Road, corresponding R.S. Dag No. 61, 63, 64 and 71 under R.S.
Khatian No. 44, Municipal Sheet No. 27 and R.S. Dag No. 62 and 68 under
R.S. Khatian No. 41, Municipal Sheet No. 27 of Mouza Bantra, Police Station –
Bantra, District – Howrah measuring an area of about 1 bigha 4 cottahs with
pucca structure (“the said property”).
5.
The impugned order further records that the petitioner was unable to
provide a copy of the aforesaid registered deed of lease dated June 25, 1973
either in the aforesaid application or at the point of time of various hearings
before the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah. The impugned order
also records that the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah, on
examination of relevant records and registers of its office, found that the said
property / lands were thika-tenanted lands of Mouza – Bantra, J.L. No. 01,
Sheet No. 27, P.S. Bantra, District – Howrah.
Accordingly, the Deputy
Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah came to the conclusion that the said
property, being the subject matter of the aforesaid application filed by the
petitioner before it were thika-tenanted lands and since the petitioner had
failed to produce any document or any corroborative evidence in support of his
claim, the prayers in his application could not be entertained and his
application was thus rejected.
6.
Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, however, contends
that on July 19, 2024, the petitioner was represented before the Deputy
Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah at the time of hearing and the matter was
adjourned for further hearing to July 24, 2024. In support of his contention
that the matter was adjourned on July 19, 2024 and fixed for hearing
thereafter on July 24, 2024, learned advocate for the petitioner relies on the
entries made in the diary maintained by the learned advocate representing the
petitioner before the Deputy Controller, Thika
Tenancy, Howrah and
photocopies of the relevant pages of the said diary have been annexed to the
writ petition.
7.
It is further submitted that, on July 24, 2024, at the time of hearing before
the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah, there was a heated argument
between the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah and the learned
advocate representing the petitioner. According to the learned advocate
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, the matter was not taken up for hearing
thereafter and copies of the orders passed in the aforesaid application on July
19, 2024 or July 24, 2024 were not served on the petitioner or the petitioner’s
advocate.
8.
Learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner also draws the attention of this
court to a written representation dated July 25, 2024 addressed by the learned
advocate representing the petitioner before the Deputy Controller, Thika
Tenancy, Howrah to the President/Secretary, Howrah Bar Association, Howrah
in respect of the events which took place before the Deputy Controller, Thika
Tenancy, Howrah on July 24, 2024 and further submits that the same was
also brought to the notice of the District Magistrate, Howrah by a letter dated
July 26, 2024.
9.
It is the case of the petitioner that in the middle of July 2025, he came to
learn that an order had been passed in the aforesaid application filed by him
before the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah. He thereafter obtained
a certified copy of the entire order sheet and was shocked to discover that his
application had been rejected by the impugned order dated July 19, 2024. He
also submits that the order sheet does not reflect any hearing having taken
place on July 24, 2024.
Being aggrieved by the manner in which the said
application was dealt with by the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah
and being aggrieved by the order dated July 19, 2024, the petitioner has been
compelled to file the present writ petition.
10.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner further submits that the
matter may be remanded to the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah for
a fresh consideration.
11.
Learned Counsel representing the respondents submits that the hearing
was concluded on July 19, 2024 and no hearing took place on July 24, 2024.
Consequently, the question of remand does not arise. It is further submitted
that the petitioner ought to have filed an appeal in terms of the provisions of
the said Thika Act. Learned counsel for the respondents also acknowledges
that the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah had received a letter dated
August 19, 2025 from the petitioner requesting him to recall the aforesaid
order dated July 19, 2024. She points out that the letter was written more
than a year after the aforesaid order dated July 19, 2024 was passed. Learned
counsel for the respondents submits that the writ should be dismissed.
12.
I have heard the rival contentions of the parties and considered the
materials on record. It appears from the averments made in the writ petition
as well as the arguments made by the Learned Advocates for the parties that
there are disputed question of fact involved in the matter. It is also difficult for
this court to believe that the petitioner waited for more than a year before
approaching this court by filing the present writ petition. It does not appear
from the records that the petitioner made any endeavour to make any enquiry
before the Deputy Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah for more than a year
with regard to the procedure and progress of his case, if he was under the
impression that the matter was still pending adjudication before the Deputy
Controller, Thika Tenancy, Howrah. The petitioner did not also approach this
court alleging violation of the aforesaid order dated September 6, 2023 passed
by this court in WPA 12970 of 2023.
13.
The order sheet in the aforesaid Case No. 02/B/2023 speaks for itself. The
same clearly records that the aforesaid Case No. 02/B/2023 was dismissed on
July 19, 2024. The order sheet does not make any mention of the matter
having been listed or heard on July 24, 2024. The impugned order is a wellreasoned order. It is trite law that disputes of a factual nature are not to be
gone into a writ proceeding. The writ court is generally not concerned with the
merits of a decision but is only concerned with the decision-making process. In
the present case, no illegality or impropriety in the decision-making process
has been demonstrated by the petitioner.
14.
In any event, the petitioner had a remedy under Section 12 of the said
Thika Act by filing an appeal against the impugned order. However, such
remedy has not been availed by the petitioner. In my view, there has been no
infraction of law or any statute insofar as the impugned order is concerned.
15.
Accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed. However, the petitioner will be
at liberty to avail any other remedy, if available, including filing of an appeal,
insofar as the impugned order is concerned, in accordance with law. It will be
open to the petitioner to take the benefit of the provisions of Section 14 of the
Limitation Act, 1963, if permissible and in accordance with law. In the event
the petitioner institutes any other proceeding against the impugned order, the
observations made in this order will not be considered to be binding in such
proceeding.
16.
There shall be no order as to costs.
17.
As no affidavit has been called for, the allegations made in the writ petition
are deemed not to have been admitted by the respondents.
18. All parties shall act on the server copy of this judgment and order duly
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
19. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment and order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Rishad Medora, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review