Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~53 to 61
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 28th September, 2026.
Uploaded on: 5th October, 2026.
+
~54
+
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021
FEDERATION OF NEHRU PLACE ASSOCIATIONS .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Pranav Proothi, Ms. Manasi
Chatpalliwar, Mr. Anshveer Singh
Nalwa and Mr. Anany Singh, Advs.
versus
GYANESH BHARTI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. Amit Singh Chaddha, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Sujata Kashyap and Ms.
Ishika Rawat, Advs. for R3-R25
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
W.P.(C) 6823/2017 & CM APPL. 28389/2017, CM APPL.
28390/2017, CM APPL. 29267/2017
PREMVATI AND ORS
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Amit Singh Chaddha, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Sujata Kashyap and Ms.
Ishika Rawat, Advs.
versus
SOUTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND
ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Mr. Anubhav Gupta, Panel Counsel,
GNCTD with Ms. Rashi Aggarwal,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. Amit Singh Chaddha, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Sujata Kashyap and Ms.
Ishika Rawat, Advs.
Mr. Sagar Khanna, SO, RCS.
~55
+
~56
+
W.P.(C) 7307/2017 & CM APPL. 30250/2017, CM APPL.
11548/2026
KANTI DEVI & ANR
.....Petitioners
Through: Ms. Anamika Ghai and Ms. Kirti
Bhardwaj, Advocates.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Mr. Mukesh Gupta, SC for MCD, Ms.
Sneha Roy& Ms. Madhu Yadav,
Advs.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. Lalltaksh Joshi & Ms. Minu
kumari, Advs. for GNCTD.
W.P.(C) 7405/2017 & CM APPL. 30590/2017
VIPIN NARANG & ORS
.....Petitioners
Through: Ms. Anamika Ghai and Ms. Kirti
Bhardwaj, Advocates.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS
.....Respondents
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Through:
~57
+
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. T.P. Singh, SPC for Delhi Police
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Mr. Lalltaksh Joshi & Ms. Minu
kumari, Advs. for GNCTD.
W.P.(C) 9611/2017 & CM APPL. 39135/2017
SUNDRI DEVI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Amit Singh Chaddha, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Sujata Kashyap and Ms.
Ishika Rawat, Advs.
versus
THE STATE & ORS (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI) &
ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anubhav Gupta, Panel Counsel,
GNCTD with Mr. Rashi Aggarwal,
Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
~58
+
W.P.(C) 8430/2021 & CM APPL. 27831/2021, CM APPL.
27833/2021, CM APPL. 3699/2022, CM APPL. 5935/2022, CM
APPL. 10811/2022, CM APPL. 11085/2022, CM APPL.
11125/2022, CM APPL. 11139/2022, CM APPL. 19730/2022, CM
APPL. 29807/2025
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Indira Unninayar, Adv. with Mr.
Kumar Aryan, Advocate.
versus
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Urvi Mohan, Adv.
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Ms. Aakansha Kaul, Mr. Aman
Sohani, Ms. Ashima Chopra ad Mr.
Saptarishi Sharma, Advs. for DJB
Mr. Amit Tiwari, CGSC with Ms.
Ayushi Srivastava Mr. Arpan Narwal,
Mr. Ayush Tanwar and Mr. Kushagra
Malik, Advs. for UOI
Mr. Arjun Pant, Adv. for DDA
Mr. Mohd. Faisal, Adv.
Ms. Mahika Bisht, Adv. for Ms. Urvi
Mohan, Adv. for GNCTD.
Mr. Kamlesh Kumar Mishra, Ms.
Shivani Verma, Ms. Renu & Ms.
Akanksha Priya, Advs.
Mr. Pranav Proothi, Ms. Manasi
Chatpalliwar , Mr. Anshveer Singh
Nalwa and Mr. Anany Singh, Advs.
for Applicant.
Insp Ajay Kumar.
SI Kailash Chand for State.
SI. Ashok Kumar, Pairvi Officer
SI Sonu Nain Traffic KKC Circle
9868083331
~59
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
+
~60
+
W.P.(C) 10880/2020 & CM APPL. 5836/2023
RAHUL KUMAR & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Rushikanta Dash and Mr.
Shubham Dubey, Advs.
versus
STATION HOUSE OFFICER KALKAJI POLICE STATION.
&ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Saket, SPCG, Mr.
Manish Madhukar, Mr. Abhigyan, Ms.
Reya Paul, Ms. Nidhi Singh, Ms.
Amruta Padhi, Advs. for SHO, Kalkaji
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Ms. Vaishali Gupta, Panel Counse(
Civil) GNCTD , Ms. Rashi Aggarwal,
Adv.
W.P.(C) 6221/2022
KALKAJI CIVIL SOCIETY
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Khusboo Kohli, Adv.
versus
GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ANR. .....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. Amit Tiwari, CGSC with Ms.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Ayushi Srivastava, Mr. Arpan Narwal,
Mr. Ayush Tanwar and Mr. Kushagra
Malik, Advs. for UOI
~61
+
W.P.(C) 2183/2026 & CM APPL. 10577/2026
MANUSHI SANGATHAN
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Indira Unniayar, Adv. with Mr.
Kumar Aryan, Advocate.
versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI &
ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Tushar Sannu, Mr. Parvin Bansal
with Mr. Vaibhav Tripathi, Advs. for
DDA.
Mr. Sanjay Poddar Sr. Adv, Ms. Puja
Kalra, Mr. Viren Singh, Mr. Govind
Kumar, Mr. Apurv Kumar, Ms.
Anshika Singh & Mr. Ankit Kakkar
Advs.
Mr. G.M. Akhtar and Ms. Saba M.
Zaidi, Advs. for R3
Mrs. Sangeeta Chandra, Adv.
Standing counsel of SDMC along with
Ms Bhawna, Adv.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT
JUDGMENT
Prathiba M. Singh, J.
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
These are various matters relating to vending and hawking in the Nehru
Place area. Since several years, the Nehru Place area has become a severe
bone of contention for hawkers and vendors.
3.
CONT. CAS(C) 703/2021 has been filed by Federation of Nehru Place
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Association alleging wilful and deliberate disobedience of the directions
issued vide order dated 19th September, 2017 in W.P.(C) 6823/ 2017.
4.
W.P.(C) 6823/2017 has been filed by 23 vendors, inter alia, seeking
directions to the Respondents to allow the Petitioners to peacefully vend from
their vending sites.
5.
W.P.(C) 7307/2017 has been filed by 2 vendors, inter alia, seeking
directions to the Respondents to allow the Petitioners to peacefully vend from
their vending sites.
6.
W.P.(C) 7405/2017 has been filed by 4 vendors, inter alia, seeking
directions to the Respondents to allow the Petitioners to peacefully vend from
their vending sites.
7.
W.P.(C) 9611/2017 has been filed by Ms. Sundri Devi, inter alia,
seeking directions to the Respondents to allow the Petitioner to peacefully
vend from her vending site.
8.
W.P.(C) 10880/ 2020 has been filed by 15 vendors, inter alia, seeking
directions to the Respondents to allow the Petitioners to peacefully vend from
their vending sites.
9.
W.P. (C) 6221/2022 has been filed by Kalkaji Civil Society through its
Chairman, Sh. Khavinder Singh Captain, inter alia, seeking the following
prayer:
“i) Issue a writ nature of Mandamus to direct the
Respondent No.2 not to shift 67 hawkers of the
"Manushi Sangathan" to area opposite Aggarwal
Dharamshala, near Govindpuri metro station, New
Delhi- 110019 or permit them to hawk there as was
granted by Respondent No. 2 by way of the
Administrative Order dated 13.01.2022, bearing
no. AC/CNZ/202211204 passed by the Respondent
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
No. 2 not permit the vendors/hawkers to hawk at
area Opposite Aggarwal Dharamshala, Near
Govindpuri Metro Station, New Delhi- 110019.”
10.
W.P.(C) 2183/2026 has been filed by Manushi Sangathan, which is an
organisation that espouses causes for the urban poor such as street vendors
and cycle rickshaw pullers, inter alia, seeking issuance of an appropriate writ
for protection of Fundamental Rights and for declaring the Nehru Place
District Centre as a ‘Vending Zone’.
11.
One of the first judgments passed by a Division Bench of this Court
regarding the Nehru Place area was Manushi Sangathan v. Delhi
Development Authority & Ors., 2009 (110) DRJ 87 (DB) wherein, the Court
had in paragraphs 38, 39 and 40 recognized the rights of vendors and had
observed that 67 vendors would be permitted to vend in the Nehru Place area.
The said judgment was passed following the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Sudhir Madan and Ors. v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Ors.,
2007 (8) SCALE 334. The relevant portions of the decision in Manushi
Sangathan (Supra) is set out below:“38. The National Policy on Urban Street Vendors
incorporates and proceeds on the basis of the
guidelines and directions issued by the Supreme
Court. Additional safeguards and protection to
vendors and regulations have been provided.
Exercise of discretion is regulated by clear
guidelines and principles to be followed. We have
also quoted above directions of the Supreme Court
in the Order dated 6th February, 2007 in Sudhir
Madan and others v. MCD and others making
reference to the National Policy on Urban Street
Vendors and holding, inter alia, that an existing
allottee can be shifted from one site to another but
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
consistent with the said Policy which provides that
eviction should be avoided, unless there is clear and
urgent public need. It also states that the allottee
before shifting would be given an opportunity to
give his preference. There was no need for such
haste and hurry on the part of the DDA to remove
hawkers under the pilot project. We may also note
here that DDA has not made any allegation that the
appellant-NGO or any of their hawkers had
violated the terms of the pilot project or the
undertakings .given or the said appellant-NGO had
misused or abused the permission for controlled
and regulated hawking in Nehru Place. During the
course of hearing before us, it was pointed out that
DDA took the said action as other hawkers had filed
litigations claiming parity with permission granted
to the appellant-NGO for regulated hawking.
Controlled and regulated hawking under the pilot
project cannot be equated with unregulated
hawking contrary to the terms of the policy/scheme
and directions of the Supreme Court. Scrapping of
the pilot project and removing the Hawkers without
notice and in the manner stated above was
arbitrary.
39. In view of the above findings, it is clear that the
respondents and specially DDA have not followed
guidelines of the Supreme Court, Master Plan of
Delhi- 2021, guidelines laid down in the National
Policy on Urban Street Vendors and the scheme
ofMCD for squatters/hawkers-2007. These aspects
were not examined and considered before evicting
the vendors under the pilot project at Nehru Place.
As already stated above, the decision taken in the
meeting held on 18th April, 2002 does not support
the contention that Nehru place is a non-hawking
Zone. It is also apparent that the respondent-DDA
has acted illegally in removing the hawkers
operating under the pilot project and who were
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
complying with the imposed terms and indulging in
regulated hawking.
40. In view of the above findings, we dispose of the
present Letters Patent Appeal by directing DDA to
continue with the pilot project. Accordingly, 67
vendors (reduced to 67 from 68 as per the statement
made by the appellant-NGO) will be permitted to
hawk in the area which was demarcated by DDA
prior to their removal on 19th April, 2008.
However, it will be open to DDA to examine
whether Nehru Place or the said area should be
declared a non-hawking area and if required,
demarcate vending/non-vending areas in Nehru
Place. Removal/shifting of the hawkers under the
pilot project, if required, will be in terms of the
directions issued by the Supreme Court in the case
of Sudhir Madan (supra). The question whether
Nehru Place should be declared a no hawking zone
and the question of demarcating non-vending areas
will be decided by the DDA after making reference
to the Ward Vending Committee and on the basis of
the directions issued by the Supreme Court and in
terms of the Scheme of the MCD. We may note that
MCD has stated that they had already allotted
alternative site to some hawkers out of the list of 67
street vendors. If any of said hawkers have already
opted for the new site, they will not be entitled to the
benefit of this Order. The Appeal is accordingly
allowed to the extent indicated above.”
12.
Vide Manushi Sangathan (Supra), passed on 17th April, 2009, the
Division Bench permitted 67 hawkers to vend and the Delhi Development
Authority (hereinafter, ‘DDA’) was directed to examine as to whether Nehru
Place area was to be declared as a ‘No-hawking zone’ or not. Accordingly,
the DDA had to take a decision after making a reference to the Ward Vending
Committee.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
13.
This decision was challenged before the Supreme Court by the DDA
wherein vide order dated 25th April 2011 in Petition for Special Leave to
Appeal (Civil) No. 29277/2009 titled ‘Delhi Development Authority v.
Manushi Sangathan & Ors.’, benefit was granted to the said hawkers on the
basis of an affidavit dated 7th December, 2010 filed by Shri S.R. Solanki,
Chief Engineer, South Zone DDA. The said order passed by the Supreme
Court reads as under:“This petition is directed against order dated
17.04.2009 of the Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court, the operative portion of which reads thus:
"In view of the above findings, we dispose of the
present Letters Patent Appeal by directing DDA to
continue with the pilot project. Accordingly, 67
vendors (reduced to 67 from 68 as per the statement
made by the appellant-NGO) will be permitted to
hawk in the area which was demarcated by DDA
prior to their removal on 19th April, 2008.
However, it will be open to DDA to examine
whether Nehru Place or the said area should be
declared a non-hawking area and if required,
demarcate vending/non-vending areas in Nehru
Place. Removal/shifting of the hawkers under the
pilot project, if required, will be in terms of the
directions issued by the Supreme Court in the case
of Sudhir Madan (supra). The question whether
Nehru Place should be declared as no hawking zone
and the question of demarcating non-vending areas
will be decided by the DDA after making reference
to the Ward Vending Committee and on the basis of
the directions issued by the Supreme Court and in
terms of the Scheme of the MCD. We may note that
MCD has stated that they had already allotted
alternative site to some hawkers out of the list of 67
street vendors. If any of said hawkers have already
opted for the new site, they will not be entitled to the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
benefit of this Order. The Appeal is accordingly
allowed to the extent indicated above."
Arguments in the case were heard on different dates
and the judgment was reserved on 26.10.2010.
Thereafter, the parties filed written submissions and
some affidavits. In paragraph 5 of affidavit dated
07.12.2010, Shri S.R.Solanki, Chief Engineer,
South Zone, Delhi Development Authority, has
made the following statement :"5. The Petitioner authority also submits that as an
interim measure and till such time, the ward
vending committee takes a decision on the eligibility
and relocation of the 67 hawkers under the
umbrella of the respondent No.1 and other 85
hawkers sitting under various orders of different
courts at Delhi, the Petitioner authority shall not
take any coercive action to remove these persons.
However, the Petitioner authority also submits that
the same may not been 3 taken as a concession on
behalf of the Petitioner authority to give up its case
of the NPDC being declared as No Hawking Zone
or an admission on the part of the Petitioner
authority for other hawkers to use Nehru Place
District centre as hawking site."
In our opinion, the stand taken in the above
reproduced paragraph of the affidavit of Shri
Solanki is in consonance with the direction given by
the Division Bench of the High Court. Therefore,
the special leave petition is disposed of as
infructuous.
The direction given in I.A.No.4 of 2011 for
imposition of cost of Rs.50,000/- is deleted.”
14.
Thus, the 67 hawkers along with few other hawkers continue to hawk
in the Nehru Place area. The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (hereinafter,
‘MCD’) continued to take objections to hawking in the Nehru Place area
which led to two more orders of this Court i.e., order dated 7th September,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
2017 in W.P. (C) 2566/2017 titled ‘Bachchu Singh & Anr. v. South Delhi
Municipal Corp. & Ors.’ and order dated 2nd April, 2018 in LPA 623/2016
titled ‘Federation of Nehru Place Association (Regd) v. South Delhi
Municipal Corporation Thr its Commissioner & Ors.’.
15.
In Bachchu Singh & Ors. (Supra), the Division Bench of this Court
was concerned with the Petitioners therein who were seeking permission to
vend at the Skylark building in the Nehru Place area. In the said decision, the
Division Bench considered the earlier decision in Manushi Sangathan v.
Delhi Development Authority & Ors. (Supra) and the affidavit filed by the
DDA before the Supreme Court in Delhi Development Authority v. Manushi
Sangathan & Ors. (Supra). In addition, the Division Bench in the said
decision also considered the minutes of meeting which took place post the
judgment passed in Manushi Sangathan v. Delhi Development Authority &
Ors. (Supra).
16.
The said minutes of meeting dated 10th August, 2009 resulted in the
decision of the DDA that Nehru Place District Centre should be declared as a
‘No-hawking zone’. This was also confirmed by the then Lieutenant Governor
of Delhi, who was the Chairman of the DDA. In Bachchu Singh (Supra), the
Court then came to the following conclusions:“21. Taking into consideration the submissions
made by the learned counsel for the parties, we are
of the view that the DDA, erstwhile land owning
agency, and the SDMC, have taken a consistent
stand that Nehru Place District Centre has been
declared as a No Hawking and No Vending Zone,
however, while deciding LPA No.766/2008 a
Division Bench of this Court while disposing of the
LPA directed to continue with the pilot project and
the appellant-NGO Vendors of Manushi were
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
permitted to hawk in the area demarcated by the
DDA. It was left open to the DDA to examine
whether Nehru Place or the said area should be
declared a no hawking area. After the passing of the
order by the Division Bench on 17.4.2009, the
matter was considered by the DDA in the meeting
held on 10.8.2009. The Minutes of the meeting have
been extracted. The minutes were duly confirmed.
Subsequently as stated in the affidavit filed before
the Supreme Court of India, protection was granted
in the LPA only to members of Manushi Sangathan
and certain other street vendors who were enjoying
protection of orders passed by different Courts. The
names of both the petitioners do not find mentioned
in either of the list prepared by Thareja Committee,
1992 or Chopra Committee. Resultantly, we find no
merit in the present writ petition and the same is
accordingly dismissed.”
17.
As can be seen from the above, it becomes clear that in Bachchu Singh
(Supra), the Court put its imprimatur on the decision of the DDA to declare
Nehru Place District Centre as a ‘No-hawking zone’ and ‘No-vending zone.
The said order also came to be affirmed in Federation of Nehru Place
Association (Regd.) (Supra) where the Court concluded as under:“8. In view of the judgment passed in Bachchu Singh
(supra), the impugned order dated 12.09.2016 is set
aside. It is declared that the Nehru Place area is „no
hawking‟ and „no vending‟ zone. The municipal
authorities shall be bound by the stand taken by them
in the case of Bachchu Singh (supra) and the same
would apply to the present case as well. Resultantly,
the appeal is allowed.”
18.
It is also relevant to note that in Bachchu Singh (Supra) itself, the
Petitioners, namely, Bachchu Singh and Rama Kant were held to be not
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
entitled to any relief as their name was not mentioned either in the list
prepared by the Thareja Committee or the Chopra Committee.
19.
These two judgments were challenged before the Supreme Court. The
Supreme Court tagged along SLP(C) No. 023381 - 023382/2018 titled
‘Manushi Sangathan v. South Delhi Municipal Corporation’ with SLP(C)
No. 19192/2018 titled Arvind Gupta v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi wherein had
initially granted status quo on 20th July 2018.
20.
Following the said order in Arvind Gupta (Supra), the Supreme Court
granted status quo initially in SLP(C) No. 023381 - 023382/2018 titled
‘Manushi Sangathan v. South Delhi Municipal Corporation’, however,
after the dismissal of the Arvind Gupta (Supra) on 5th February 2020, the
challenge in SLP(C) No. 023381 - 023382/2018 also came to be dismissed.
21.
Interestingly, in the SLP filed by Manushi Sangathan i.e., SLP(C) No.
023381 - 023382/2018, the issue relating to the 67 vendors was also raised as
a question of law. The same is extracted hereinbelow:
“2. QUESTION OF LAW:
A. Whether is was permissible for the Delhi High Court
to pass the Impugned Judgment and Orders to decare
Nehru Place District Centre (NPDC) as a nohawking/no-vending area and to remove all street
vendors/hawkers and subsequently maintain it as free
from vendors/hawkers, in violation of the prevailing law
The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and
Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014 which has
overriding effect as per S 33 and grants protection to all
street vendors until they are surveyed and given
certificate of vending (S3,4)?
B. Whether the Ld. Court below could have based its
Judgments and Orders on the so-called ‘consistent
stand’ taken by the authorities that the said market
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Nehru Place District Centre (NPDC) is a ‘no hawking’
and ‘no vending’ zone by overlooking the law of the
land?
C. Whether the Ld. Court below could have concluded
that the DDA could decide to declare Nehru Place
District Centre (NPDC) as a no hawking area by merely
conducting a meeting to take such decision, against the
mandate of High Court Judgment dated 17.04.2009 in
766/2008, and Supreme Court order dtd. 25.04.2011 in
SLP (C) 29277/2009, which required the DDA to first
make a reference to the Ward Vending Committee per
Supreme Court directions in Sudhir Madan (per the
than prevailing scheme for vending)?
D. Whether the Court below could have overlooked that
even while it was then left open to DDA to examine
whether the area should be declared non-hawking, such
decision could not have been allowed without the DDA
following the laid down procedure?
E. Whether the Delhi High Court ought to have allowed
the DDA to go behind the back of the Supreme Court
order dated 25.04.2011 in SLP (C) 29277/2007 and the
law in force to rely upon its decision dated 10.08.2009
and the law in force to rely upon its decision dated
10.08.2009 taken prior to Order dtd. 25.04.2011, to
declare Nehru Place as no-hawking? WHETHER the
Ld. Court below could have overlooked that the said
decision was already on the record in SLP(C)
29277/2009 and had been followed by the DDA’s
undertakings in its affidavits dated 20.10.2010 and
07.12.2010 filed in continuance to the above forming
part of Order dtd 25.04.2011, wherein it was required
to first make a reference to the Ward Vending
Committee?
F. Whether the Ld. Court below, could have allowed the
authorities’ erroneous and false position with respect to
the Nehru Place District (NPDC) to conclude and
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
declare it as a ‘no hawking’ and ‘no vending’ zone
against the prevailing statute specially, first Schedule
Clause 3 (e) of The S.V. Act, that expressly prohibits
declaration of any area as a no-vending zone until a
survey is conducted and plan for street vending is
formulated?
G. Whether the Ld. Court below could have arbitrarily
shrunk the extremely wide definition of street vendors
today by relying upon 20 year old schemes to wrongly
conclude that vendors who were not mentioned in the
lists prepared by Thareja Committee 1992 or Chopra
Committee were not “regular” vendors, by overlooking
the subsequent developments in the law since 2009,
including the Supreme Court’s nationwide directions on
09.09.2013 in para 21.1-21.17 of Maharashtra Ekta
Hawkers Union & Anr. Vs Municipal Corporation,
Greater Mumbai & Ors., (2014) 1 SCC 490), Para 20
sub para 4.5.4, directing implementation of The
National Policy of Urban Street Vendors 2009 in all
municipal areas of the country, and for all street
vendors to be registered in accordance with para 4.5.4
of the said Policy, and all existing street vendors
operating across the country to be allowed to operate
till the exercise of regulation
and creation of
vending/hawking zones was completed in terms of the
2009 Policy?
H. Whether the Ld. Court below, could have arbitrarily
shrunk the definition of ‘street vendors’ to so-called
‘regular vendors’ in contravention of the Street Vendors
Act, by limiting the wide definition of street vendors
under S 2(1)(l) of the Act to those listed by Chopra and
Thareja committees under old schemes that are nonexistent today, despite the prevailing law, The Street
Vendors Act 2014, expressly covering every ‘street
vendor’ under its ambit of protection u/S 3(3) of the
Street Vendors Act, 2014?
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
I. Whether the Ld. Court below could have overlooked
the express statutory protection under S 3(3) of The
Street Vendors Act, 2014 which mandates that no street
Vendors Act, 2014 which mandates that no street
vendors shall be evicted or relocated till the Survey of
all street vendors, as defined u/S 2(1)(l), has been
completed and the Certificate of Vending issued to all
street vendors and S 33, which gives the Act overriding
effect?
J. Whether the Ld. Court below could have overlooked
the settled principles of law laid down by this Court in
Sudhir Madan (2009) 17 SCC 579, [dtd 17.5.2007 –
Para 30], Gainda Ram case (2010) 10 SCC 715 [dtd
08.10.2010 – Paras 48, 67], and Maharashtra Ekta
Hawkers Union & Anr. V. Municipal Corporation,
Greater Mumbai & Ors. (2014) 1 SCC 490 – paras
21,21.12] that any administrative action is always
subject to law that may be framed by the competent
legislature; that nothing short of a law can regulate
hawking under Article 19(1)(g) and MCD/NDMC
scheme and even Supreme Court orders that try to
regular hawking are not law?
K. Whether the Ld. Court below could have overlooked
the subsequent mandate in Maharashtra Ekta Hawkers
Union case [(2014) 1 SCC 490] that all existing street
vendors operating across the country were protected to
operate ill the completion and registration and creation
of vending/hawking zones in terms of the 2009 Policy,
until the coming into force of the new law, which law
came into force in 2014 and grants protection to every
street vendor during implementation of the Act?
L. Whether the Impugned Judgment in LPA 623/2016
can be sustained as it was in violation of the principles
of natural justice as well, as vendors were not given a
chance to be heard although they would be affected by
the Impugned Judgments and Orders of the court?
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
M. Whether the Impugned Judgments can be sustained
given its gross violation of Articles 141 & 144 of the
Constitution of India by going contrary to the decision
of the Supreme Court and falling to act in aid of the
orders of the Supreme Court of India?”
22.
A perusal of the above grounds and questions of law would show that
Manushi Sanghatan had argued in the said SLP that the 68 vendors cannot be
disturbed. With the dismissal of the SLP on 6th January, 2022, the rights, if
any, that these vendors had prior to the said judgement in effect also came to
an end. The relevant portion of the order dated 6th January, 2022 reads as
under:
“We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.
At the outset, it is required to be noted that, the present
Special Leave Petitions was tagged with SLP (C) No.
19192/2018. On the basis of the order passed in SLP
(C) No. 19192/2018, in the present matter, this Court
directed to issue notice and directed to maintain status
quo by the parties.
It is reported and it is not in dispute that the said
Special Leave Petition (C) No. 19192/2018 has been
dismissed by the coordinate Bench of this Court, vide
order dated 05.02.2020.
In that view of the matter, the present Special Leave
Petitions also stand dismissed. Ad-interim relief
granted earlier stands vacated.
Pending application stands disposed of. ”
23.
The decisions in Bachchu Singh (Supra) and Federation of Nehru
Place Association (Regd) (Supra) were thus not interfered with by the
Supreme Court in terms of order dated 6th January, 2022. Accordingly, the
declaration of Nehru Place District Centre as a ‘No-hawking zone’ and ‘Novending zone’ having been categorically affirmed in two decisions is also
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
binding for this Court as well.
24.
Thereafter, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court on 13th August, 2021 took
suo moto cognizance of a fire incident reported in building Nehru Place
District Commercial Centre i.e., W.P. (C) 8430/2021 and had passed various
directions as under:“1. Yesterday, an incident of fire has been reported
in a building at Nehru Place, District Commercial
Centre. The said District Commercial Centre has
several high-rise buildings, and in between these
buildings, there is pavement area for circulation of
people. On the said pavement area, over the years,
hawkers and vendors have come to claim the space,
meant for pedestrians. The enormity of the problem
caused by the hawkers and vendors at the Nehru
Place area can be seen from a video circulated on
social media which shows that it was difficult for the
fire tenders to access the building where the fire
broke out. It also shows the complete lack of any
cleanliness or maintenance on the part of the
Municipal Authorities. We are also informed that the
Nehru Place area has been declared as a nohawking no-vending zone.
2. On our query, we are informed by the SHO
Virendra Singh, PS Kalkaji under whose jurisdiction
the Nehru Place, District Commercial Centre falls
that there are several orders of stay granted by the
Courts in favour of the hawkers and vendors – which
is the reason that even though the area has been
declared as no hawking and vending zone, the said
vendors have not been removed. He also states that
the removal drive of the hawkers and vendors is
conducted from time to time but other hawkers and
vendors come back once the drive is over.
3. We find it difficult to understand how any person,
who is not protected by Court orders, can continue
to occupy any space, and hawk or vend without the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
connivance and blessings of the concerned local
authorities.
4. We direct the Delhi Police as well as the SDMC
to ensure, on a daily basis, that there is no hawking
and vending resorted to at the Nehru Place, District
Commercial Centre by any person who does not
have an operative order of protection granted by any
Court. The SHO, PS Kalkaji and the Executive
Engineer concerned of the SDMC under whose
jurisdiction the said area falls, shall be personally
responsible to ensure compliance of this direction,
and failure to do so on their part shall invite strict
action against them by the Court.
5. The SHO has informed us that the re-development
work has been going on in the Nehru Place, District
Commercial Centre for a long time, and the agency
is not completing the work.
6. We direct the SDMC, Delhi Police, and the DDA
to hold a joint meeting, and to place before the
Court, status report(s) with regard to the
implementation of the no-hawking no-vending policy
qua Nehru Place, District Commercial Centre. The
status report should disclose the particulars of all
such agencies employed, and should also disclose as
to which of the authorities, namely DDA or SDMC is
getting the work done.
7. The status report(s) should also disclose all the
orders of stay, as operative, which are claimed to be
the reason why all encroachers, hawkers and
vendors are not being removed from the said area
despite it being declared as no-hawking no-vending
zone.
8. Since it is stated by Mr. Pande, who appears for
the SDMC that the Public Works Department of the
GNCTD may also be getting some works done in the
area, we direct issuance of notice to the PWD,
GNCTD as well. They should also disclose as to why
there is delay in the process of carrying out works in
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
the Nehru Place area by filing a status report before
the next date of hearing.
9. Since we have taken cognizance of this matter as
a PIL, the orders with regard to its listing may be
obtained from Hon’ble the Chief Justice by the office
and, accordingly, the matter may be listed on the
next date before the appropriate Bench.
10. List on 24.08.2021.
11. Looking to the urgency of the matter, it is made
clear that no further time shall be granted for filing
of the status reports to any department. In case, the
status reports are not filed, the Commissioner, Delhi
Police; Commissioner, SDMC; and Vice Chairman,
DDA, as the case may be shall remain present on the
next date of hearing.
12. The detailed status reports be filed before the
next date of hearing.”
25.
Thereafter, a proper fire drill was also directed to be conducted as per
order dated 24th August, 2021 which reads as under:“The Chief Fire Officer, Delhi is directed to ensure
that the local fire station conducts a mock fire drill
in Nehru Place on a working day and identifies the
shortcomings/hindrances.
The recommendations/suggestions mooted by the
Fire Department shall be furnished to this Court as
well as to the Committee headed by the Chief
Engineer, DDA within three weeks. The report of
the concerned Fire Officer as well as the action
taken report by the Chief Engineer, DDA shall be
filed with the Registry of this Court at least a week
prior to the next date of hearing. List on 07th The
order be uploaded on the website forthwith. Copy of
the order be also forwarded to the learned counsel
through e-mail. October, 2021.”
26.
Accordingly, the fire drill was conducted and the ld Division Bench had
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
noticed that the recommendation of the Delhi Fire Service was for removing
all hawkers from the Nehru Place District Centre. The said order dated 7 th
October, 2021 reads as under:“In pursuance to the last order, the Delhi Fire
Services has conducted a mock fire drill at Nehru
Place. During the said drill, the following serious
shortcomings/hindrances were observed:
1. None of the vehicle (Fire Engine, Ambulance)
could reach to the incident place, fire tenders could
only reach up to upper plaza, the lower plaza was
not reachable. The time taken by the first fire unit
was 11 minutes.
2. As the lower plaza was not approachable to fire
units, pitching of rescue vehicles like hydraulic
platforms will not be possible.
3. The time taken by the various agencies was too
high, which indicates that there are significant
hindrances due to heavy pedestrian movement,
heavy traffic, hawkers and parking problems. The
Delhi fire service has made the following
recommendations:
1. All the entries to the upper Plaza as well as
lower plaza should be made clear by removing the
Boom barriers, barricades etc. All the levels must
be approachable to Fire engines by minimum 06m
wide motorable road/ramps.
2. The place may be made hawker free zone.
3. Clear cut 06m wide road shall be ensured, the
side parking should not be allowed.
DDA, Delhi Police and SDMC are directed to
ensure that the recommendations/suggestions given
to this Court by the Delhi Fire Brigade are
implemented at the earliest.
Respondents are also directed to earmark a lane
for emergency services so that the fire brigade and
ambulance can reach Nehru Place at the earliest
without any hindrance/obstruction. DCP (Traffic)
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
will ensure that the said lane is not encroached
upon and is always free for movement for fire
brigade and ambulance.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 2/SDMC
states that despite the specific area being delineated
for hawking, the hawkers are not restricting
themselves to the said area. He further states that
only 95 vendors have interim orders in their favour
from the Apex Court as well as from this Court. He
also states that the hawkers/vendors are not
complying with the terms of Tehbazari/conditions of
vending.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 2/SDMC
states that out of 95 street vendors who have
injunction/interim orders in their favour, 33 have
filed petitions in this Court while 62 street vendors
who are part of Manushi Sangathan have filed
petitions before the Supreme Court. He states that
SDMC shall be filing an application for early
hearing in the Special Leave Petition in which
protection has been granted to 62 vendors, namely,
Manushi Sangathan Vs. SDMC, SLP (C) No.
28875/2018. The said statement is taken on record.
Registry is directed to list the petitions filed by 33
vendors along with contempt petition being CCP
703/2021, subject to orders of Hon’ble the Chief
Justice on 18th October, 2021. The particulars of
the petitions filed by 33 vendors in this Court are as
under:
1. W.P.(C) 6823/2017 (lead matter), Premvati &
Ors. Versus SDMC & Ors. 2. W. P. (C) 7307/2017
3. W. P. (C) 7405/2017
4. W. P. (C) 9611/2017
5. CCP No. 681/2017 in WP(C) No. 6879/2017
6. CCP No. 703/2021 in WP(C) 6823/2017
This Court directs SDMC, DDA and Delhi Police
to ensure that no other individual or entity other
than 95 vendors, hawk in and around Nehru Place.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Even the identities of the 95 vendors shall be
verified and the respondents shall ensure that the
vendors comply with the terms and conditions of
Tehbazari/vending.
This Court also directs Mr. Arjun Pant, Mr. Sanjay
Lao, Mr. Divya Prakash Pande, Advocates along
with members of the committee in particular, Chief
Engineer Project, Additional CP (Traffic),
Additional
CP, South-East
and
Deputy
Commissioner, Central Zone to visit Nehru Place
within the next fortnight at a mutually convenient
date and time and file a status report. The said
report shall be filed at least a week prior to the next
date of hearing.Ms. Sakshi Popli, Advocate
appearing on behalf of Delhi Jal Board is also
directed to file a status report within two weeks.
List on 10th November, 2021.”
27.
As can be seen from the above order dated 7th October 2021, the clear
stand of the Delhi Fire Service was that Nehru Place District Centre has to be
made a hawker free zone.
28.
Today, the Court has heard detailed submissions on behalf of the
hawkers made by Mr. Amit Singh Chaddha, ld. Sr. Counsel, Ms. Indira
Unninayar, ld. Counsel and Ms. Anamika Ghai, ld. Counsel. On behalf of the
Nehru Place Trade Association, Mr. Pranav Proothi, ld. Counsel has made
his submissions.
29.
On behalf of the DDA and MCD, Mr. Sanjay Poddar, ld. Sr. Counsel,
Ms. Puja Kalra, ld. Standing Counsel, Ms. Sangeeta Chandra, ld. Counsel and
Mr. Arjun, ld. Counsel have all made their submissions. Counsels have also
handed over certain photographs taken as recently as Saturday i.e., 26th
September, 2026 from the Nehru Place market. Some of the images handed
over by the Counsels for the parties are extracted below:-
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
30.
A perusal of the photographs handed over both by the Petitioners as
also by the Respondents leaves no manner of doubt in the mind of the Court
that the declaration of Nehru Place District Centre as a ‘No-hawking zone’
and ‘No-vending zone’ deserves to be confirmed. However, a ld. Single Judge
of this Court in order dated 13th October, 2014 passed in a batch of matters
wherein the lead matter is W.P. (C) 6893/2008 titled ‘Prem Shankar Gupta
& Ors. v. DDA & Anr.’ observed as under:
“Present writ petitions have been filed seeking
directions to respondents not to displace/dislocate
the petitioners from their respective squatting sites
at Nehru Place, New Delhi till allotment of
tehbazari sites and to implement the Act No. 43 of
2007.
Mr. Amit Chadha, learned senior counsel appearing
for petitioners states that petitioners are the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
tehbazari holders who are functional as of today.
He, however, states that petitioners have not been
officially allotted tehbazari sites.
Learned counsel for respondent-DDA state that
Nehru Place has been notified as No Hawking Zone
and after development the area has been handed
over to respondent-Corporation.
This Court is of the view that the present writ
petitions have been overtaken by subsequent events
inasmuch as the Street Vendors (Protection of
Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act,
2014 (hereinafter referred to as Act, 2014) has come
into force on 4th March, 2014. The Act, 2014
provides for constitution of a Committee which is to
conduct survey of existing street vendors and frame
a scheme for relocation.
In the opinion of this Court, Section 3(3) of the
Act, 2014 clearly states that no street vendor shall
be evicted or relocated till the survey to be carried
out by the Committee has been completed and
certificate of vending has been issued to all street
vendors.
Consequently, State Government is directed to make
the Town Vending Committee functional within a
period of eight weeks. Petitioners are also
permitted
to
simultaneously
file
their
representations with the Committee within a period
of eight weeks.
Upon the said representations being filed, the
Committee is directed
to decide the same
expeditiously, preferably within six months.
With the aforesaid direction, the present writ
petitions and applications are disposed of.
Order dasti.”
31.
Subsequently, the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and
Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014 was passed and as per the same the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
vendors cannot be evicted until a decision is taken by the Town Vending
Committee (hereinafter, ‘TVC’).
32.
The Court has been appraised by the ld. Counsel for the MCD that the
TVC-II is on the verge of being constituted as the elections to the TVC-II have
already concluded. Under Section 3 of the Street Vendors (Protection of
Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, recognized vendors
cannot be evicted or relocated till the survey is completed or certificates of
vending are issued to the vendors.
33.
The submission on behalf of the Traders Association is that Section
3(3) of the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street
Vending) Act, 2014 protection would not be available for persons vending in
‘No-hawking zone’ and ‘No-vending zone’.
34.
In the meantime, three other writ petitions have been filed which are
being dealt by this Court in the present order being:
● W.P. (C) 6823/2017 filed by 23 vendors;
● W.P. (C) 7307/2017 filed by 2 vendors; and
● W.P. (C) 7405/2017 filed by 4 vendors.
35.
The names of these 29 vendors also appear in the list submitted by Mr.
Solanki in the affidavit filed before the Supreme Court. Accordingly, the same
have been granted protection by this Court till date.
36.
In the meantime, these hawkers were placed in sites which the MCD
had identified. However, the photographs extracted above would show that
even this particular site is totally congested in view of the presence of the
hawkers and fire tenders would not be easily able to move in this area.
37.
Ld. Counsel for the parties have informed the Court that there are more
than 400 vendors who are presently vending in the Nehru Place District
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Centre, most of whom are clearly unauthorized. The only authorized vendors in
the Nehru Place District Centre are:
a)
62 vendors who are part of W.P. (C) 2183/2026 filed by Manushri
Sangathan. There are 5 more vendors who have filed the said writ petition,
however, they are vending outside the District Centre area.
b)
23 vendors who are part of W.P. (C) 6823/2017, out of whom, one
Petitioner is stated to be no longer vending. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners
submit that at present only 22 Petitioners are hawking in the Nehru Place Area
and hence, only those 22 Petitioners, which includes the Petitioner in W.P.(C)
9611/2017, be permitted to vend.
c)
6 vendors who are part of the W.P. (C) 7307/2017 and W.P. (C)
7405/2017.
38.
The list of the said 90 vendors is set out in Annexure A to this order.
39.
Apart from the above, none of the other vendors have any valid vending
right in the Nehru Place District Centre. Especially after the repeated orders
being passed by multiple benches of this Court declaring Nehru Place as a ‘Nohawking zone’ and ‘No-vending zone’. In fact, even these vendors, who have
challenged the matter before the Supreme Court, had lost in terms of order dated
6th January, 2022 passed in SLP(C) No. 023381 - 023382/2018 titled ‘Manushi
Sangathan v. South Delhi Municipal Corporation’.
40.
However, recently, the Supreme Court in the decision dated 9 th April,
2026 in SLP (Civil) No. 21349/2025 titled ‘Malkit Singh and Anr. v. State of
U.T. Chandigarh and Ors.’ observed as under:
“[...]
11. While the efforts carried out thus far have
apparently borne results and are therefore appreciable,
it is a matter of concern for us whether all relevant
efforts have been made to regularize such hitherto
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
illegal vendors, including those who are not before us,
by granting them space in designated vending zones so
as to ensure minimum disruption to their livelihood in
the long term. Any action by the State that disrupts this
livelihood must therefore be carried out with care,
fairness, and a clear sense of responsibility.
If vending zones have already been identified and
designated, it is not enough for the authorities to
simply point to their existence. Removing vendors from
familiar locations, even for legitimate public reasons
such as easing congestion or improving urban order,
creates an immediate need for support. Vending zones
are meant to provide a lawful and workable
alternative, and that purpose is lost if displaced
vendors are left uncertain, uninformed, or unable to
access these spaces in practice. Let the State clearly
clarify the existing information available at the defined
vending zones which in any event have to be acceptable
to all concerned.
12. This kind of assistance is not an act of generosity. It
reflects a basic respect for the right to earn a living and
to carry on a lawful occupation. When vendors are
removed without any real help in relocating, the
hardship caused is out of proportion to the regulatory
goal, and such an exercise risks becoming punitive
rather than orderly. In essence, if vendors are
displaced through encroachment drives and lawful
vending zones are available, the State has a duty to
actively support their transition to these zones in
accordance with the law. Doing so upholds both the
spirit of regulation and the human reality of those
whose lives depend on street vending.
13. It is also to be recognized that forcible shifting or
removal of encroachments, while it may be entirely in
accordance with law, disrupts the customer base that
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
comes with the shop being located at a particular area.
The State is required to undertake efforts to let
residents know that the shops have been shifted, i.e.,
have awareness drives that would divert the customers
to the designated area. Let an affidavit be filed with the
relevant details, within two weeks of this order.”
41.
In terms of the aforesaid decision, if the street vendors are vending in a
‘No-vending zone’, the MCD or the concerned authority has a duty to assist
them in moving from a ‘No-vending zone’ to a vending zone, so as to provide
the street vendors with a workable alternative from where they can earn their
livelihood.
42.
Under these circumstances, bearing in mind that the TVC-II is about to
be constituted and these vendors have been vending in this area for several
years, the above mentioned vendors shall be permitted to vend at Site X
marked in the map below:-
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
43.
The 90 vendors mentioned in Annexure ‘A’ shall move to site ‘X’ by
12th October, 2026. It is made clear that TVC-II after being constituted shall
take a decision as to whether these vendors are entitled to Certificate of
Vending or not and if so, the area where they would be vending. The said
decision shall be taken within two months after the constitution of the TVCII.
44.
Insofar as the Nehru Place District Centre area, except the
identified portion above as marked X, the entire Nehru Place District
Centre is declared as a ‘No-hawking zone’ and ‘No-vending zone’.
45.
After 12th October, 2026, the MCD is free to take action and remove all
unauthorized vendors. After the unauthorized vendors are removed, the Delhi
Fire Services shall conduct an inspection of the Nehru Place District Centre
and file compliance a report only in W.P.(C) 8430/2021.
46.
The TVC-II shall communicate its decision to these vendors, who have
been permitted to vend at Site No. X, in terms of Section 18 of the Street
Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act,
2014.
47.
The Delhi Police shall render all co-operation with the MCD and the
DDA to ensure compliance of today’s order.
48.
In case there are any other vendors whose names are recognised in the
affidavit filed by the DDA before the Supreme Court under signature of Mr.
Solanki, the concerned Assistant Commissioner, MCD shall also
accommodate the said Petitioners, however, the same shall be subjected to
the decision of TVC-II. The said vendors can make the representation to the
concerned Assistant Commissioner, MCD who shall consider the same in
accordance with law.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
49.
In these matters, several applications have been filed on behalf of the
vendors seeking impleadment. The details of the same are as under:
● CM. APPL. 11085/2022 in W.P. (C) 8430/2021
● CM. APPL. 11125/2022 in W.P. (C) 8430/2021
● CM. APPL. 11139/2022 in W.P. (C) 8430/2021
● CM. APPL. 19730/2022 in W.P. (C) 8430/2021
50.
If any of these Applicants are recognised in the affidavit filed by the
DDA before the Supreme Court under signature of Mr. Solanki, the said
Applicants can also make a representation to the concerned Assistant
Commissioner, MCD who shall consider the same in accordance with law.
51.
All the writ petitions are disposed of with these terms. All pending
applications are also disposed of.
52.
A copy of this order be communicated to the Delhi Fire Services by the
Registry.
53.
List for compliance report by the Delhi Fire Service, in W.P.(C)
8430/2021 on 30th November, 2026.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
DINESH BHATT
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 28, 2026/MR/CK
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
Annexure - A
In W.P. (C) 2183/2026
S.
No.
Name
Father’s
Address
Name/Husband'
s Name
R.K. Halder @ H.No. D-2/49, Phese (Phase)-2,
@ R.K. Haldar
JJ Colony, Madanpur Khadar,
Sarita Vihar, South Delhi, Delhi
– 110076
1.
Balram
Halder
Balram
Haldar
2.
Ram Lal
3.
Santosh
Santosh
Kumar
4.
Rajkumar @ Bateshwar
Raj Kumar
Sharma
5.
Imtiaz Ali @
Imtiyaz Ali
6.
Maya Dinn
@ Mayadeen
7.
Tarun
@
Tarun Kumar
8.
Sanjay Puri
Babu Lal
A-1/1020, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar Phase-1, Aali, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
@ Jugal Kishore @ E-21, B Gali No. 2, Jaitpur Extn.
Jugal
Kishor Part-1, Badarpur, South Delhi,
Shrivastav
Delhi – 110044
A-2/ 1202, JJ Colony Madanpur
Khadar, South Delhi, Delhi110076
Mumtaz Ali
P-117/2 and P-117/3,
2nd Floor, Batla House, Jamia
Nagar, South Delhi, Delhi –
110025
Shri Pate @ Patte House No. 493, Block B-1, JJ
Cluster, Madanpur Khadar,
Sarita Vihar, South Delhi, Delhi
– 110076
Badami Lal
B-1/867, JJ Colony Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
K.L. Puri @ E10, B K Dutt Colony, Karbala,
Kherati Lal Puri Lodi Road H.O., South Delhi,
Delhi 110003
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
9.
Sharfudinn @ Hafizudinn
Mohd
Hafij
Sarfuddin
@ H.NO. B/1/416, JJ Colony,
Madanpur Khadar, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110076
10.
Dilip Kumar Dineshwar
@
Dilip Prasad
Kumar Singh
RZ-9/40, Upper Ground Floor,
Gali No. 12, Tugalkabad Extn.
Aali South Delhi, Delhi 110019
11.
Ashwani
Kumar
Jaipal Monga
647-9, Lal Dora, Devli Village,
South Delhi, Delhi – 110062
12.
Deepak Sen
Moolchand
@ B-34, Harkesh Nagar, South
Moolchand Sen
Delhi, Delhi – 110020
13.
Sudhir Singh Dineshwar
@ Suddhir Prasad Singh
Kumar Singh
(Late)
Survived by
Son Rohan
Kumar
RZ-51, Gali No. 6, Tuglakabad
Extn., Delhi South Delhi –
110019
14.
Moolchand
Moolchand
spouse
of
Late
Narmada
Devi
(Mool Chand
expired and is
survived by
his
son
Shanker)
Sita Ram @ Niranjan Singh
Sitaram
Jadon
A2-1812, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi - 110076
15.
H.No. 54 B, Gali No. 2, Block
A, Saurabh Vihar, Jaitpur, P.O
Badarpur, Dist, South Delhi,
Delhi, 110044
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
@ M-7, 4th Floor, Street No. 6,
Joga Bai, Extn. Jamia Nagar,
Okhla, New Friends Colony,
South Delhi, Delhi – 110025
16.
Shamsudinn Hafizadinn
@
Mohd Abdul
Shamsuddin Hafizuddin
17.
Ranjit
Gupta
18.
Divya
19.
Sanjay
Kumar
Nigam
20.
Jitender
Gulati
Jatinder
Gulati
21.
Pooja Narula Late Ram Gopal A-235/1, Phase – 1, Ashok
D/o
Asha Sahini
@Ram Vihar, North West Delhi, Delhi
Rani
and Gopal Shani
- 110052
Late
Ram
Gopal Sahini
@Ram Gopal
Shani (W/o
Mukesh
Narula)
22.
Balbir Ranjan
son of Late
Yogindera
Singh
@Yoginder
Singh
@
Joginder
Singh
Shankar B-70, 3rd Floor, Ganesh Nagar,
Pandav
Nagar
Complex,
Shakarpur, East Delhi, Delhi –
110092
Pradeep Kumar 1458 D, Gali No. 13,
@ Madhav Das
Govindpuri, Kalkaji, South
Delhi, Delhi - 110019
Om
Prakash E-6A/219, Sangam Vihar Devli,
Nigam
South Delhi, Devli, Delhi –
110080
Kr. Daya
Gupta
Pal Late Darbari Lal, J-1/242, 1st Floor, DDA Flats,
@ S/o Late Girdhari Kalkaji, South Delhi, Delhi –
Pal Lal
110019
Late Yogindera
Singh
@Yoginder
Singh @ Joginder
Singh
B-163, Gali No. 6, Pandav
Nagar, Shakarpur, Gandhi
Nagar, East Delhi, Delhi –
110092
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
23.
Ashok
Upender Kumar E-93, Ganesh Nagar, Pandav
Kumar
@ @ Upendra Jha
Nagar Complex, Shakarpur,
Ashok Jha
East Delhi, Delhi – 110092
24.
Ram Gopal Shri
Ram G-80, Jaitpur Extn. Part-1,
@
Ram Bahadur @ Ram Badarpur, Jaitpur, South Delhi,
Gopal Gupta Bahadur Gupta
Delhi – 110044
25.
Rahul Verma
(grandson of
Late
Rukmani
Verma
&
Suraj
Pal
Verma)
Late
Satya
Prakash Verma
@ Satya Prakash
(son of Late
Rukmani Verma
& Suraj Pal)
G-21, T.Camp, Block G,
Khichdi Pur, Chilla Saroda,
Khadar, East Delhi, Delhi 110091
26.
Shanti
@ Suresh Chand
Shanti Devi
D/o Kunwarpal
A1-32, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, Aali,
South Delhi, Delhi – 110076
27.
Umesh
Prasad
28.
29.
30.
Bhola Singh
Saurav Vihar, Hari Nagar Part2, Gali No. 19, House No. 604,
Block N. RMP School,
Badarpur Jait Pur, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110044
Sonu Gupta
Late Om Prakash B-1-381, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Gupta
Khadar, South Delhi, Delhi –
110076
Ram Prasad, S/o Lala Ram
House no C-19, Extanion
survived by
(Extension), Tigri, Dist: South
Kamla Devi,
Delhi, Delhi – 110062
W/o
Ram
Prasad
Sidh
Nath Bansi Lal @ H.NO. 94, Gali No. 7, Block-CSingh
Bansi Lal Singh 1-A, Nangli Vihar, Ext.
Bapraula West Delhi, Delhi –
110043
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
31.
Ram Avtar @ Puran Lal
Ramavtar
(Late)
Survived by
Rahul Kumar
1406-F,
Gali
No.
13,
Govindpuri, Kalkaji, South
Delhi, Delhi - 110019
32.
Ravi Puri @ Kherati Lal Puri
Ravi Kumar
Puri
E10, B K Dutt Colony, Karbala,
Lodi Road H.O., South Delhi,
Delhi 110003
33.
Mahavir Jain
34.
Ramesh
Kumar
35.
36.
37.
38.
P.C. Jain @ B-577, Gali No. 2, Ganesh
Padam
Chand Nagar, Shakarpur, Baramad,
Jain
East Delhi, Delhi – 110092
Hansraj @ Hans H.NO. 72, Gali No. 16, Block –
Raj
H, Sangam Vihar, Pushpa
Bhawan, South Delhi, Delhi –
110062
S.K. Gulati Indir / Indar Raj C-103, 2nd Floor, Dayanand
@
Suresh Gulati
Colony, Lajpat Nagar-4, South
Kumar Gulati
Delhi, Delhi – 110024
Narender Lal Munner Yadav @ H.No. 1436, I-Block, Gali No.
@ Narendra Munnar Yadav
16, Sangam Vihar, Hamdard
Yadav
Nagar, Pushpa Bhawan, South
Delh, Delhi – 110062
Rakesh
Late Shri Om A-112, Third Floor, Back
Gupta
Prakash Gupta
Portion, Near HDFC Bank,
Kalkaji, NCT of Delhi, 110019
Yash Pal @ Late Shri Bihari 34/1119, 2nd Floor, DDA Flats,
Yashpal
Lal
Madangir,
Dr.
Ambedkar
Nagar, Pushpa Bhawan, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110062
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
39.
Mahender
Athari Sahu
Prasad Sahu @ Itwari Sahoo
@ Mahender
Pd. Sahoo
B-1/247, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, Kalkaji,
South Delhi, Delhi – 110076
40.
Raj Ballab @ Deena Nath
Raj Balak S/o
Ram Preet,
(Late)
survived by
Deepak
(nephew)
C-1122, JJ Colony, Madan Pur
Khadar, New Delhi, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, Sarita
Vihar, South Delhi, Delhi 110076
41.
Khem
Bahadur
Moti Ram
B-1/798, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi - 110076
42.
Hira Lal
Late Lala Ram
H. No. C-1253, JJ Colony,
Madanpur Khadar, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110076
43.
Kamal
Kishore
Ram Raj Morya
44.
Mohhamed
Abul Hasan
Aarif @ Arif
Hasan
45.
Rakesh
Ram Lartya
Kumar Gupta
C-1st/988,
Madangir,
Dr.
Ambedkar Nagar, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110062
H.O. A-53, A-Block, Shahin
Bagh, Road, No.- 6, Near
Thokar No. 6, Abulfazal Part -2,
Jamia Nagar, South Delhi, Delhi
– 110025
R-57, Chanakya Place – 2, D.K.
Mohan Garden, West Delhi,
Delhi – 110059
46.
Chandan
Manchanda
Late
Kishan 36/1208 DDA Flats, Madangir,
Manchanda
Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, South
@Kishan Lal
Delhi, Delhi – 110062
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
47.
Chandra Pal Late Hari @ Hari Jav, Jao, Mathura, U.P. - 281403
@
Singh
(Permanent add.)
Chandrapal
48.
Ram Kumar Late Hundi Lal E-35, Ground Floor, Prakash
@
Ram Gupta
Dhaba wali Gali, Ganesh Nagar,
Kumar Gupta
Pandav
Nagar
Complex,
Madangir, Fazalpur, East Delhi,
Delhi – 110092
49.
Shanti
@ Tara Chand
Shanti Devi
H.NO. B/1/480, JJ Colony,
Madanpur Khadar, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110076
50.
Bhawari Devi Ramu
@
Bhoore
Devi
A-134, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
51.
Bhura
@ Gariba @ Gariba H. No. A-2/454 Near Jalebi
Bhure Lal
Das @ Grebu
Chowk, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
52.
Satish
Satish
Chandra
53.
Shambhu @ Shiv Nath Gupta
Shambhu
Nath Gupta
54.
Vimal Kumar Upender Jha @ E-93, Ganesh Nagar, Pandav
Jha @ Vimal Upendra Jha
Nagar Complex, Shakarpur
Kumar
Baramad, East Delhi, Delhi –
110092
Latto @ Lato Atwari Sahoo @ Village Tetariya Salaidih Birani,
Saw @ Lato Atavari Saw
P.O Gando Thana, Birani,
Sahoo
Gando, Giridih, Jharkhand –
825324 (Permanent add)
55.
@ Siya Ram
H. No. 253, Gali No. 2, Shakti
Vihar, Mithapur Extn. Jaitpur
South Delhi, Delhi – 110044
F-221, Harsh Vihar, Hari Nagar
Part-3, Jaitpur Extn. Badarpur,
South Delhi, Delhi - 110044
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
56.
Suraj
Mukhiya
Phaguni Mukhiya 88, Hemkunt Colony, Nehru
@ Late Atwari Place, Greater Kailash, South
Shiv
Delhi,
Delhi - 110048
Choke Lal
H.N-H-17/220, Gali No. 17,
Sangam Vihar, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110062
57.
Narayan Das
58.
Mahesh
Late
Tomar son of Tomar
Late Kishan
Tomar
59.
Shyam
Sundar
Shyam
Sunder
Kishan A-2/1055, JJ Colony, Madanpur
Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
Ram Avtar
@
60.
Syed Abdul Hadish Khan
Karim
@
Abdul Karim
Khan
61.
Jamaludinn
62.
Kalu
A1/59 Face 1 (Phase 1), JJ
Caloney (Colony), Madanpur
Khader, Sarita Vihar, South
Delhi, Delhi – 110076
K-70, Kalkaji, Aali,
Delhi, Delhi – 110019
South
Rahim Baksh
H.No. 16/883, Gali No. 16,
Rajasthani Gali, Sangam Vihar,
Pushpa Bhawan, South Delhi,
Delhi – 110062
Late Mangi Devi B1/1020, JJ Colony, Madanpur
&
Late
Dal Khadar, Sarita Vihar, South
Chand
Delhi, Delhi - 110076
In W.P. (C) 6823/2017
S
Name
Father’s Name / Address
No.
Husband’s Name
1.
Chandrawati W/O Shiv Kumar 1194, Gali No.13, Govindpuri,
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019
2.
Rajesh
Late
Prem 8/48, Dakshin Puri, New
Kumar
Shankar Gupta
Delh110062
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
3.
Shri Dinesh Late Chander Pal A/262, First Floor, Dda Flats
Kumar
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019
4.
Shri Veer Pal Shri Ramswarup
5.
Smt. Savita
6.
Shri Ramesh Shri Ram Lal
Kumar
7.
Sh. Mukesh Late
Prem 8/43, Dakshinpuri,
Babu
Shankar Gupta
Ambedkar Nagar
New Delhi
Survesh
Late
Prem 48, Block-8,
Kumar
Shankar Gupta
Dakshinpuri.
Ambedkar Nagar, New Delhi
8.
9.
10.
W/O
Late A/261, Dda Flats, Govindpuri,
Mukesh Kumar
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019
B-1/171, JJ Colony,
Madanpurkhaddar, Badarpur,
Newdelhi
Shri Rajesh
Late Raghubar 11/51, Dakshinpuri,
Dayal
New Delhi-110062
Shri Amlesh Kapil Dev Tiwari A-100, Madanpur Khadar New
Tiwari
Delhi
11.
Shri Jogender Shri Ram Lal
Kumar
12.
Shri Jagdish
13.
Lal Maharaj Dharamshala,
Kalkaji, New Delhi-110019
B-19, Krishna Park,
Khanpur Road, New
Delhi
Late Raghubar A-2/1266, Madanpur
Dayal
Khadar New Delhi
Shri Sushil Late Raghbuar 11751, Dakshin Puri New Delhi
Mathur
Dayal
14.
Shri Virender Shri Kedar Singh F-154, Harsh Vihar,
Singh
Hari Nagar, Phase-II, Jaitpur
New Delhi
15.
Shri Pardeep Shri
Kumar
Dass
Bhagwan 208, A Iind Floor, Parkash
Mohalla Garhi, East Of
KailashNew Delhi
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
16.
Smt.
Leelawati
Singh
17.
Mrs. Seema W/O Late Rinku House No.B-43, Street No. 4,
Gupta
Gupta
South Ganesh Nagar,
Near Badi Mother Diary,
Delhi East, Delhi- 110092
18.
Mahender
Singh
Late
Shyam
19.
Raj Kumar
Shri.
Dass
20.
Master
Shrivaay
Meena
Khatoon
21.
22.
Kritika
Chauhan
Master
Gagan
Chauhan
W/O Late Sanjay H. No. 154, Block-F, Harsh
Kumar Singh
Vihar, Prince Colony
Jaitpur, P.O. Hari Nagar,
Badarpur
New
Delhi-110044
Radhey C-14, L.I.G, Panchsheel Vihar
Khirki,
New
Delhi
Bhagwan 208, Iii Floor, Prakash Mohalla,
Garhi,
East Of Kailash, New Delhi
Late Raju
G-1020, Jj Colony, Tigri,
New Delhi
W/O Late Shri. A-2/975, Jj Colony, Madanpur
Rashid Ahmad
Khadar
New Delhi
D/S/o
Late A-185, Devli Extension, Deoli,
& Yashwant
South Delhi, Delhi-110062
Chauhan
and
Late
Neelam
Chauhan
Granddaughter/G
randson of Late
Sundri Chauhan
(Petitioner
in
W.P.(C)
9611/2017)
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
In W.P. (C) 7307/2017 and W.P. (C) 7405/2017
S.
No
Name
Father’s name/
Husband’s
name
L.S Narang
Address
1.
Mr. Vipin
Narang
2.
Mr. Preetam
Kumar
Gupta
Kapil Dev
Gupta
B-356, Ganesh Nagar, Complex,
Pandav Nagar, Delhi-110092
3.
Mr V. Saule
Raj
Late Sh. B
Venkatachalam
7-C, J Pocket, 1st Floor Sheikh
Sarai, Phase- II, Delhi-110017
4.
Mr. Rakesh
Kumar
Syamlal
B-46, 1st floor, Indira Park, East,
Uttam Nagar, New Delhi
5.
Smt. Kanti
Devi
W/o Late Sh.
Ram Babu
B-104, Block B, Tigri Extn.
Delhi-110062
6.
Sh.
Jagannath
S/o Sh. Ram
Bharose
C-34,
Deepawali
Ismailpur
Extn.
Haryana-121003
16/8 IIIrd floor, Kalkaji, Delhi110019
Enclave,
Faridabad,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:58:56
CONT.CAS(C) 703/2021 & other connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review