Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010409732024
2026:CGHC:32536-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally
signed by
BABLU
RAJENDRA
BABLU
BHANARKAR
RAJENDRA
BHANARKAR Date:
2026.07.30
18:39:46
+0530
CRA No. 2115 of 2024
1 - Puran Korram S/o Shri Budhnath Korram Aged About 30 Years
2 - Kiras Korram S/o Shri Krirpal Korram Aged About 23 Years
3 - Tilakram Baghel S/o Late Shri Krirsan Ram Baghel Aged About 27
Years
4 - Daulat Korram S/o Shri Daiman Korram Aged About 29 Years
All are resident of Bade Kanera Pavangudhapara Police Station
Kondagaon Revenue And Civil District - Kondagaon (C.G.)
--- Appellants
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Kondagaon Revenue And
Civil District - Kondagaon (C.G.)
--- Respondent
CRA No. 2213 of 2024
1 - Sunder Korram S/o Late Raiypal Korram, Aged About 35 Years
2 - Mahesh Korram S/o Raiypal Korram, Aged About 24 Years
3 - Mayaram Baghel S/o Suktaram Baghel, Aged About 47 Years
4 - Dinesh Korram S/o Krirpal Korram, Aged About 28 Years
All are resident of Bade Kanera, Pawangudapara, Police StationKondagaon, Revenue And Civil District-Kondagaon (C.G.)
---Appellants
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through- The Station House Officer, Police
Station- Kondagaon, Civil And Revenue District-Kondagaon (C.G.)
--- Respondent
For
Appellants- : Mr.Purnendra Khichariya, Advocate in CRA
Puran
Korram,
No.2115/2024
Kiras
Korram,
Tilakram
Baghel
and Daulat Korram
Mr.Satya Prakash Verma, Advocate in CRA
For
Appellants- :
No.2213/2024
Sunder
Korram,
Mahesh Korram,
Mayaram Baghel
and
Dinesh
Korram
For Respondent
: Mr.S.S.Baghel, Government Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice and
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, C.J.
29/07/2026
1. Since the aforesaid two criminal appeals have been filed arising
out of the same judgment, they were clubbed & heard together
and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. These criminal appeals filed by the appellants-accused under
Section 415(2) of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 are
directed against the impugned judgment of conviction and order
of sentence dated 26.10.2024 passed by the Additional Sessions
Judge, Kondagaon, District Kondgaon in Sessions Case
No.98/2021,
whereby
the
appellants-accused
have
been
convicted for offences under Sections 148, 341 read with Section
149, 302 read with Section 149 and 120B of the IPC and
sentenced them to undergo RI for three years and fine of
Rs.500/-, in default of payment of fine to further undergo RI for six
months, SI for one month and fine of Rs.500/-, in default of
payment of fine to further undergo SI for six months,
imprisonment for life and fine of Rs.500/-, in default of payment of
fine to further undergo RI for six months and imprisonment for life
and fine of Rs.500/-, in default of payment of fine to further
undergo RI for six month. The sentences were directed to run
concurrently.
3. The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 27.04.2021, the
complainant,
Amritdas
Kuldeep
(PW-5),
accompanied
by
Puliyadas Manikpuri (PW-3), Sarpanch Sohan Kashyap (PW-1),
Deputy Sarpanch Prakash Churgiya (PW-2), and Sonmati
Baghel, appeared at the Police Assistance Centre, Kondagaon,
Revenue and Civil District Kondagaon (Chhattisgarh), and orally
reported that about one and a half years earlier, he had
developed a love relationship with Jambati Baghel, and the two
had eloped and married. Thereafter, they started living together
as husband and wife. Because of this marriage, Jambati's
relatives, particularly accused No. 1, Sundar Korram, and his
family members harboured resentment against the complainant
and frequently quarrelled with and assaulted him. On 26.04.2021,
the
complainant
Amritdas,
his
mother
Rambha
Kuldeep
(hereinafter referred to as "the deceased"), and his maternal
uncle Puliyadas Manikpuri travelled together by motorcycle to the
house of his uncle Ramesh Manikpuri in village Bade Bendri
between approximately 4:00 P.M. and 5:00 P.M. to collect money.
At about 8:00 P.M., while they were returning home on the same
motorcycle and had reached near the field of Pancham Das on
the tar road before Pawan Gudapara, accused No. 1 Sundar Lal
Korram, accused No. 2 Mahesh Korram, accused No. 3 Mayaram
Baghel, and accused No. 4 Dinesh Korram emerged from the
roadside carrying wooden sticks and attempted to stop them.
Consequently, the deceased and her brother Puliyadas got down
from the motorcycle. Thereafter, all the accused persons
assaulted the deceased with lathis (wooden sticks), inflicting fatal
blows. The complainant abandoned the motorcycle at the spot
and fled with his maternal uncle to save their lives. It is alleged
that Sundar Lal Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel, and
Dinesh Korram struck the deceased on her head, arms, and legs
with wooden sticks, causing fatal injuries that resulted in her
death.
4. On the basis of the aforesaid oral information given by the
complainant, Merg Intimation (Ex. P-25) was recorded, and FIR
(Ex. P-26) was registered against the four accused, namely
Sundar Lal Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel, and
Dinesh Korram, under Sections 341, 302, and 34 of the Indian
Penal Code, as Crime No. 138/2021. During the course of
investigation, Inspector Archana Dhurandhar (PW-16) additionally
invoked Section 120-B IPC.
5. During the investigation, an inquest report (Ex.P-2) of the
deceased was prepared. Dead body of the deceased was sent to
postmortem
to
the
District
Hospital,
Dondagaon,
where
Dr.Nandini Bhandari (PW-14) conducted postmortem over the
body of the deceased and found following injuries:“Lacerated wound was present over right occipital parietal
area 3 cm x 2 cm x 2.5 cm.
Nasal bone was fractured.
Bleeding was present from nose.
Multiple abrasion were present over the back of left thigh 9
x 0.5cm, 7x0.5cm, 6x0.5 cm.”
6. According to the post-mortem report (Ex. P-35), the doctor opined
that death occurred due to hypovolumic shock which occurred
due to excessive bleeding due to lacerated wound over right
occipito parietal area, bleeding from nose and left side rib 3 rd and
5th fractured. After the postmortem examination, the clothes worn
by the deceased, which had been preserved by the doctor, were
seized under seizure memo Ex. P-34. From the place of
occurrence, blood-stained tar soil, plain tar soil, blood-stained
earth, plain earth, two pairs of slippers found at the scene, and
the motorcycle bearing registration CG 27 H 1023 were seized
under seizure memo Ex. P-3. On 27.04.2021, the accused
persons Sundar Korram, Mahesh Korram, Dinesh Korram, and
Mayaram Baghel were interrogated. Pursuant to their disclosure
statements (Ex. P-6, Ex. P-7, and Ex. P-8), one blood-stained
wooden stick allegedly used in the offence and two motorcycles
bearing registration numbers CG 27 H 9819 and CG 17 KD 3568
were recovered from accused Sundar Korram, Mahesh Korram,
and Dinesh Korram under seizure memos Ex. P-11, Ex. P-12,
and Ex. P-13. All four accused, namely Sundar Korram, Mahesh
Korram, Dinesh Korram, and Mayaram Baghel, were formally
arrested on 27.04.2021 and remanded to judicial custody. A
forwarding memorandum relating to the seized articles was
prepared, and the articles were sent to the Regional Forensic
Science Laboratory, Jagdalpur for examination.
7. Subsequently, the complainant submitted a complaint to the
Superintendent of Police, Kondagaon, alleging the involvement of
four additional persons in the incident. To verify the truthfulness of
this allegation, the complainant's statement under Section 164 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was recorded by the
competent
Court
on
29.05.2021.
In
his
statement,
the
complainant alleged that, apart from the four previously named
accused, Daulat Korram, Kiras Korram, Puran Korram, and Tilak
Baghel had also participated in the murder of his mother, the
deceased. On this basis, the supplementary police statements of
eyewitness Puliyadas Manikpuri (PW-3) and other witnesses
were recorded, and the proceedings were videographed. The
complainant also produced certified copies of two previously
registered FIRs relating to earlier assaults committed upon him by
the accused persons, along with the original medical documents,
which were duly seized. The four additional accused Daulat
Korram, Kiras Korram, Puran Korram, and Tilak Baghel were
formally arrested on 21.06.2021 and remanded to judicial
custody. Pursuant to the disclosure statements of Daulat Korram
(Ex. P-9) and Tilak Baghel (Ex. P-10), motorcycles bearing
registration numbers CG 27 J 0339 and CG 17 KB 0383,
allegedly used in the commission of the offence, were recovered
under seizure memos Ex. P-30 and Ex. P-14, respectively. In his
disclosure statement (Ex. P-6) dated 27.04.2021, accused
Sundar Korram stated that at about 8:00 P.M., accused Mahesh
Korram had telephoned him and informed him that Amritdas,
along with his mother and maternal uncle Puliyadas, had left
Bade Bendri. On the basis of this disclosure, requisitions were
sent to the Cyber Cell seeking details of the subscribers of mobile
numbers
9302432969,
7974718968,
8889721465,
and
9362132969, along with their Call Detail Records (CDRs) for the
period prior to 26.04.2021.
8. Upon completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet (final report)
was filed on 07.07.2021 before the Court of Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Kondagaon, against all eight accused persons for
offences under Sections 341, 302, 34, and 120-B of the Indian
Penal Code. The case was registered as Criminal Case No.
307/2021. By the order of committal dated 24.09.2021, the case
was committed to the Court of the Sessions Judge, Kondagaon,
from where the Additional Sessions Judge, Kondgaon received
the case on transfer for trial.
9. The appellants/accused abjured their guilt and entered into
defence that they have not committed any offence and they have
been falsely been implicated in crime in question.
10. In order to bring home the offence, the prosecution examined as
many as 16 witnesses and exhibited 52 documents. The
appellants-accused examined none in their defence, however,
exhibited Exs.D/1 & D/3 in support of their case.
11. The trial Court upon appreciation of oral and documentary
evidence available on record, by its judgment dated 26.10.2024,
convicted the appellants for offence under Sections 148, 341 read
with Section 149 IPC, 302 read with Section 149 IPC and 120B
IPC and sentenced them as aforementioned, against which,
these two criminal appeals have been filed.
12. Mr.Purnendra Khichariya, learned counsel for the appellants in
CRA No.2115/2024 submits that the impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence is contrary to the evidence
available on record and suffers from serious legal and factual
infirmities. It is submitted that the complainant, who claims to be
an eyewitness to the incident, did not name the present
appellants either in the First Information Report or in his
statement recorded under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure. Initially, allegations were made only against four
accused persons. It was only after a delay of approximately one
month and five days that the names of the present appellants
were introduced through a supplementary statement. No
satisfactory explanation has been offered by the prosecution
either for the delay or for such material improvement. Even during
cross-examination,
the
complainant
failed
to
furnish
any
convincing explanation for this omission and subsequent
implication of the appellants. He further submits that the
testimony of the alleged eyewitnesses does not inspire
confidence. PW-3, the brother of the deceased and an alleged
eyewitness, categorically stated that due to darkness he could not
identify the assailants and was declared hostile. The remaining
two witnesses are the daughters of the deceased and sisters of
the complainant, whose evidence is admittedly hearsay in nature.
Most of the independent prosecution witnesses have also turned
hostile, thereby seriously undermining the prosecution case.
13. It is argued that the earliest version of the prosecution, namely
the FIR and the statements recorded immediately after the
incident, implicated only four accused persons and made no
reference whatsoever to the present appellants. The subsequent
introduction of the appellants' names after a considerable lapse of
time, without any explanation, renders the prosecution story
highly doubtful and amounts to an impermissible improvement.
Learned counsel further submits that the Investigating Officer
himself admitted during cross-examination that, during the initial
stage of investigation, the names of the present appellants did not
figure in the case and that only four persons were found to be
involved. This admission strikes at the very root of the
prosecution case against the appellants. It is contended that there
is not even an iota of reliable evidence establishing the
involvement of the present appellants in the alleged offence. In
the absence of any credible evidence connecting them with the
crime, the learned Trial Court gravely erred in recording their
conviction. The finding of guilt is therefore unsustainable in law.
14. Learned counsel contended that the learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate that the prosecution case underwent a substantial
change after the recording of supplementary statements of
certain witnesses, wherein the names of the appellants were
introduced without any justification. Such improved statements
cannot form the sole basis for conviction, particularly when they
are inconsistent with the earliest version of the prosecution. It is
further contended that the Trial Court overlooked the legal
significance of the FIR and the statements recorded by the police
at the earliest point of time, which attributed specific roles only to
four accused persons. These contemporaneous statements carry
greater evidentiary value than the subsequently improved
versions and ought to have been given due weight. He also
contended that the complainant's testimony is inherently
suspicious. According to his own version, the incident occurred
during the night and he had fled from the place of occurrence,
hiding at a considerable distance. In such circumstances, his
claim of having witnessed the entire incident and identified all the
assailants is highly improbable and creates serious doubt
regarding the veracity of his evidence. His conduct throughout the
incident is also unnatural and inconsistent with ordinary human
behaviour. It is emphasized that PW-3, the brother of the
deceased, who was allegedly present at the spot, did not support
the prosecution and was declared hostile. His evidence fails to
corroborate the complainant's version and materially weakens the
prosecution case.
15. Learned counsel submitted that that no wooden stick or any other
weapon allegedly used in the commission of the offence was
recovered from the possession of the present appellants. The
absence
of
any
incriminating
recovery
is
a
significant
circumstance which has been ignored by the Trial Court. It is
lastly submitted that the prosecution has failed to prove any
cogent motive against the present appellants. The alleged motive
is vague, based on an incident said to have occurred nearly two
years prior to the occurrence, and even if accepted, it indicates
hostility towards the complainant rather than towards the
deceased. In the absence of a proved motive and in view of the
otherwise weak and unreliable evidence, the conviction of the
appellants cannot be sustained. Accordingly, learned counsel
submits that the prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the
present appellants beyond reasonable doubt. The conviction
recorded by the learned Trial Court is based on material
improvements, unreliable testimony, and conjectures rather than
legally admissible and trustworthy evidence. It is therefore prayed
that the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence
deserves to be set aside.
16. Mr.Satya Prakash Verma, learned counsel for the appellants in
CRA No.2213/2024 submits that the impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 26.10.2024 are wholly
unsustainable in law as well as on facts. The learned Trial Court
has failed to properly appreciate the evidence on record and has
recorded the conviction on the basis of conjectures and surmises
rather than legally admissible and reliable evidence. It is
submitted that the impugned judgment is perverse, contrary to the
evidence available on record, and suffers from serious errors of
law and appreciation of facts. The findings recorded by the
learned Trial Court are not supported by the evidence and,
therefore, the judgment is liable to be set aside.
17. Learned counsel contends that there is no credible or reliable
evidence on record to establish that the appellants were
responsible for the death of the deceased, Rambha Kuldeep. The
prosecution has failed to produce any cogent evidence proving
the involvement of the appellants in the commission of the
alleged offence. Despite the absence of such evidence, the
learned Trial Court convicted the appellants merely on the basis
of assumptions and conjectures. It is further submitted that the
prosecution has failed to establish that the appellants caused the
fatal injuries to the deceased. There is no direct or convincing
circumstantial evidence connecting the appellants with the
alleged homicidal death. In the absence of such evidence, the
conviction under Section 302 IPC cannot be sustained.
18. It is argued that the alleged incident occurred during the night
when there was complete darkness at the place of occurrence
and no source of illumination has been proved by the
prosecution. In such circumstances, the possibility of mistaken
identity cannot be ruled out. It is quite possible that the deceased
may have been assaulted by some other persons and that the
appellants have been falsely implicated. The learned Trial Court
failed to properly consider this vital aspect while appreciating the
evidence. It is further argued that the prosecution has failed to
examine any independent and trustworthy witness who could
establish the guilt of the appellants beyond reasonable doubt.
The evidence adduced by the prosecution is inconsistent,
unreliable, and insufficient to sustain the conviction.
19. It is contended that the findings recorded by the learned Trial
Court are contrary to the evidence available on record. The Court
below failed to objectively evaluate the testimony of the
prosecution witnesses and ignored material inconsistencies which
create
serious
doubt
regarding
the
prosecution
case.
Consequently, the findings are perverse and liable to be
interfered with by this Hon'ble Court. Learned counsel submits
that the prosecution has failed to discharge its burden of proving
the guilt of the appellants beyond reasonable doubt. The
evidence on record falls far short of the standard required in a
criminal trial, and the benefit of such doubt ought to have been
extended to the appellants. The learned Trial Court committed a
grave error in convicting the appellants despite the existence of
substantial doubts. It is further submitted that the statements of
the prosecution witnesses suffer from material contradictions,
omissions, and improvements on material particulars. These
inconsistencies strike at the root of the prosecution case and
render the testimony of the witnesses unreliable. The learned
Trial Court failed to appreciate the legal effect of these material
discrepancies.
20. Learned counsel contends that the learned Trial Court failed to
consider the oral and documentary evidence in its proper
perspective. Relevant circumstances favourable to the defence
were either ignored or not assigned due weight, resulting in an
erroneous finding of guilt against the appellants. It is submitted
that the conviction and sentence imposed upon the appellants are
harsh, excessive, and contrary to the settled principles governing
criminal jurisprudence. In view of the serious deficiencies in the
prosecution case and the absence of reliable evidence
establishing the guilt of the appellants, the impugned judgment
cannot be sustained. Lastly, learned counsel submits that the
learned Trial Court failed to appreciate that the appellants had
neither the motive nor the intention to commit the murder of the
deceased. Even assuming the prosecution version to be true, the
incident is alleged to have occurred in the course of a sudden
altercation and grave provocation. The prosecution has not
established any premeditation or common intention on the part of
the appellants to commit murder. Therefore, it is a fit case where
the conviction of the appellants for offence under Section 302 of
the IPC can be converted/altered to an offence under Section 304
(Part-I) of the IPC. He relied upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the matter of Talari Naresh v. The State of Telangana,
2026 INSC 486 (paras 3.3, 5, 7.2, 8.1, 8.2 and 10).
21. On the other hand, Learned Government Advocate appearing for
the respondent/State opposes the submissions made by learned
counsel for the appellants and submits that the impugned
judgment dated 26.10.2024 is well-reasoned, based on proper
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence, and calls for no
interference by this Hon'ble Court. The prosecution has
successfully established the guilt of the appellants beyond
reasonable
doubt
through
reliable
ocular
evidence,
duly
corroborated by the medical evidence, recoveries, and other
surrounding circumstances. He further submits that the evidence
of the eyewitnesses inspires confidence and has been rightly
relied upon by the learned Trial Court. Merely because some
witnesses turned hostile does not demolish the prosecution case,
particularly when the testimony of the material witnesses remains
trustworthy and finds corroboration from other evidence on
record. He also submits that minor contradictions, omissions, or
discrepancies in the statements of prosecution witnesses are
natural and do not affect the core of the prosecution case. Such
inconsistencies cannot be made a ground for discarding
otherwise reliable evidence. He submitted that the contention
regarding darkness and mistaken identity is without merit, as the
witnesses were well acquainted with the appellants prior to the
incident and had sufficient opportunity to identify them. The
learned Trial Court has rightly rejected this defence. The
prosecution has proved the motive behind the offence, and in any
event, where there is credible direct evidence of the occurrence,
proof of motive assumes only a secondary significance. He
further submitted that the defence has failed to establish any
plausible reason for the false implication of the appellants. Mere
suggestions put in cross-examination, unsupported by evidence,
do not discredit the prosecution case. The medical evidence fully
corroborates the ocular testimony regarding the nature of injuries
and the manner of assault, thereby strengthening the prosecution
case. He also submitted that the learned Trial Court has
meticulously considered the entire evidence on record and has
assigned cogent reasons for accepting the prosecution case and
rejecting the defence. The findings recorded are findings of fact
based on evidence and do not suffer from perversity or illegality
warranting appellate interference. The conviction and sentence
imposed upon the appellants are commensurate with the gravity
of the offence and are in accordance with law. Accordingly,
learned State Counsel prays that the appeals, being devoid of
merit, be dismissed and the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence passed by the learned Trial Court be affirmed.
22. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties,
considered their rival submissions made herein-above and also
went through the records with utmost circumspection.
23. The first question for consideration would be, whether death of
deceased Rambha Kuldeep was homicidal in nature ?
24. The trial Court after appreciating oral and documentary evidence
available on record, particularly relying upon the statement of
Dr.Nandini Bhandari (PW-14), who conducted postmortem, has
come to the conclusion that death death occurred due to
hypovolumic shock which occurred due to excessive bleeding
due to lacerated would over right occipital area, bleeding from
nose and left side rib 3rd and 5th fracture. After hearing learned
counsel for the parties and after considering the submissions, we
are of the considered opinion that the finding recorded by the trial
Court that death of deceased Rambha Kuldeep was homicidal in
nature is the finding of fact based on evidence available on
record. It is neither perverse nor contrary to record. We hereby
affirm that finding.
25. Now, the next question for consideration would be whether the
accused-appellants herein are the perpetrator of the crime in
question, which the learned trial Court has recorded in affirmative
by relying upon the testimony of Amrit Das Kuldeep (PW-5).
26. Amrit Das Kuldeep (PW-5) in para 1 of his deposition has stated
that he identify all the accused persons present before the Court.
He also identify the absent accused persons, namely Tilak
Baghel, Puran Korram, Kiras Korram, and Daulat Korram, as they
are all residents of his village. The incident took place on the
night of 27.04.2021. On that day, his mother Rambha Kuldeep,
his maternal uncle Puliya Das Manikpuri, and he had gone from
their village Badekanera to the house of his uncle Ramesh
Manikpuri at Bade Bendri at about 5:00 P.M. Thereafter, at
around 8:00 P.M., the three of them were returning to their village.
When they had travelled about one to one and a half kilometres
from Bade Bendri, all the accused persons suddenly emerged
before them on the deserted road, armed with wooden sticks and
axes. He immediately stopped his moving motorcycle, and his
mother Rambha Kuldeep and he started running back towards
Bade Bendri.
27. In para 2 of his deposition, he stated that they had run about 15
metres in the direction from which they had come. While he was
running with his mother, all the accused persons attacked her
with wooden sticks and axes. His mother fell to the ground and
shouted to him, "run, son." As soon as she told him to run, he fled
and hid behind a bush. From there, he witnessed all the accused
assaulting his mother. After beating her, they carried her to
another place and then brought her back to the spot and left her
there. By that time, his mother had died. The accused persons
then placed his motorcycle over his mother's dead body.
Thereafter, he fled from the spot out of fear. He further states that
after killing his mother, the accused persons took his motorcycle
and went in search of him. He had hidden behind a brick kiln, and
thereafter the accused persons left his motorcycle on top of his
mother's dead body and went away. He went to the house of his
uncle Ramesh Manikpuri at Bade Bendri and hid there. He
informed his elder sister Sarita Kuldeep and Jambati Kuldeep
about the incident and told them that the accused persons had
killed their mother. Out of fear, they did not come to the place
where his mother's body was lying.
28. In para 4 of his deposition, he further stated that the next
morning, his elder sister Sarita Kuldeep went to the place where
his mother's body was lying. After seeing the dead body, she
came to him at Bade Bendri. Thereafter, the Sarpanch of his
village Badekanera and his uncle from Bade Bendri, whose name
is Paras, brought him to the place of occurrence. By the time they
reached the spot, the police had also arrived there. The Sarpanch
and the village Secretary had already informed the police about
the incident over the telephone. Thereafter, he accompanied the
police to the District Hospital, Kondagaon, for the postmortem
examination of his mother's body. His grandfather Sarjoo Das
Manikpuri also accompanied him.
29. Amrit Das Kuldeep is also a injured witness. His MLC was
conducted by the doctor at District Hospital, Kondagaon and
found contusion vide Article A-1.
30. The Supreme Court in Balu Sudam Khalde and Anr. v. State of
Maharashtra, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 355 held as under:
“26. When the evidence of an injured eye-witness is to
be
appreciated,
the
under-noted
legal
principles
enunciated by the Courts are required to be kept in mind:
(a) The presence of an injured eye-witness at the
time and place of the occurrence cannot be doubted
unless there are material contradictions in his
deposition.
(b) Unless, it is otherwise established by the
evidence, it must be believed that an injured witness
would not allow the real culprits to escape and falsely
implicate the accused.
(c) The evidence of injured witness has greater
evidentiary value and unless compelling reasons
exist, their statements are not to be discarded lightly.
(d) The evidence of injured witness cannot be
doubted on account of some embellishment in
natural conduct or minor contradictions.
(e) If there be any exaggeration or immaterial
embellishments in the evidence of an injured witness,
then
such
contradiction,
exaggeration
or
embellishment
should
be
discarded
from
the
evidence of injured, but not the whole evidence.
(f) The broad substratum of the prosecution version
must be taken into consideration and discrepancies
which normally creep due to loss of memory with
passage of time should be discarded.
(emphasis supplied)”
31. Puliya Das Manikpuri (PW-3) has stated in para 1 of his
deposition that he know all the accused persons. They are all
from his village. He also know Amrit Das and Rambha Kuldeep.
They had gone to village Bendri and were returning from there at
about 8:00 P.M. At that time, many people were standing on both
sides of the road carrying wooden sticks. On seeing them, three
of them ran away. They assaulted Rambha with wooden sticks,
so he fled from the spot. He did not see Amrit Das and Rambha
Kuldeep being beaten. In para 2 of his deposition, he stated that
he was not assaulted in the said incident. The incident occurred
at night, and due to the darkness, he could not identify who the
accused persons were. The accused were carrying wooden
sticks in their hands. On seeing the crowd of people, he became
frightened and ran away.
32. Sarita Kuldeep (PW-6) has stated in para 1 of her deposition that
she know and recognize all the accused because they are from
her village. The deceased, Rambha Kuldeep, was her mother.
The incident occurred on April 26th, almost two years ago. On the
day of the incident, she was at her home in Badekanera. Her
mother, Rambha Kuldeep, her brother Amritdas Kuldeep, and her
maternal uncle, Puliya Das, had gone to Badebendri to collect
money from her uncle Ramesh. In the evening, they had informed
her to prepare food and that they would be home soon. She
cooked the food and was waiting for them. They did not arrive
until 9-10 P.M. After that, at around 10 P.M., her brother Amritdas
called and told her that 8-10 people had stopped her mother on
the way and beaten her, resulting in her death. She then secretly
came to Badebendri Ramesh uncle's house. In para 2 of her
deposition, she stated that later she went to see her maternal
uncle Puliya Das's house, her maternal uncle had come home,
she told her maternal uncle that you had gone with them, you
came back and why did her brother and mother not come, then
her maternal uncle told her that mother Rambha Kuldeep was
killed with sticks and knives by 8 people Sundar Korram, Mahesh
Korram, Maya Baghel, Tilak Baghel, Dinesh Korram, Puran
Korram, Daulat Korram, Kiras Korram, then she came to her
home from her maternal uncle's house and after some time she
again went to her maternal uncle's house, then she saw that all
the above accused were threatening her maternal uncle
Puliyadas that if he told anyone about killing of Rambha Kuldeep,
they would kill him too and she also saw knives in the hands of
two people, after that she came to her house and saw that all the
accused were coming towards their house.
33. On a careful appreciation of the evidence available on record, it is
evident that the prosecution case against the appellants of
Criminal Appeal No.2115/2024, namely Puran Korram, Kiras
Korram, Tilakram Baghel and Daulat Korram, stands on a
materially different footing from that of the remaining accused
persons.
34. In the present case, the earliest version of the occurrence, as
reflected in the FIR (Ex.P-26) lodged by Amritdas Kuldeep (PW5), specifically named only four accused persons, namely Sundar
Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh Korram.
The names of the present appellants were conspicuously absent
not only in the FIR but also in the initial statements recorded
during investigation. Their names surfaced only after a
considerable delay of more than one month through the
supplementary statement of PW-5 recorded under Section 164 of
the CrPC.
35. It is true that delay by itself cannot be a ground to discard the
prosecution case; however, where the introduction of additional
accused persons is made after a substantial lapse of time and
there is no satisfactory explanation for such improvement, the
Court is required to examine such evidence with great caution. In
the present case, the prosecution has failed to provide any
convincing explanation as to why the names of appellants Puran
Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram Baghel and Daulat Korram did
not find mention in the earliest version of the incident.
36. The testimony of Amritdas Kuldeep (PW-5), though being an
injured witness, requires careful scrutiny insofar as the
involvement of the present appellants is concerned. His evidence,
which is otherwise reliable regarding the occurrence and the
participation of the four accused initially named in the FIR, suffers
from material improvement when it comes to implicating the
present appellants. The subsequent introduction of their names
appears to be an afterthought, particularly in view of the fact that
the initial investigation proceeded only against four accused
persons.
37. The evidence of Puliya Das Manikpuri (PW-3), who was
admittedly present at the spot, also does not support the
prosecution case against the present appellants. He specifically
stated that due to darkness he could not identify the assailants.
Though he stated that several persons were present at the spot
and Rambha Kuldeep was assaulted, he failed to identify the
persons responsible for the assault. His evidence, therefore, does
not provide any corroboration to the subsequent allegations made
against the present appellants.
38. Similarly, the evidence of Sarita Kuldeep (PW-6) is based
substantially on information allegedly received from her brother
and maternal uncle. Her statement regarding the involvement of
appellants Puran Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram Baghel and
Daulat Korram is not based upon direct knowledge of the
occurrence and, therefore, cannot by itself form the basis of
conviction.
39. Further, no incriminating article or weapon allegedly used in the
commission of the offence was recovered at the instance of the
present appellants. The recoveries relied upon by the prosecution
do not establish any direct connection between these appellants
and the homicidal death of Rambha Kuldeep. The prosecution
has thus failed to establish any credible circumstance linking
them with the commission of the offence.
40. In the present case, the prosecution has failed to prove the
involvement of appellants Puran Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram
Baghel and Daulat Korram beyond reasonable doubt. However,
the case of the remaining appellants, namely Sundar Korram,
Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh Korram, stands on
a different footing. Their names were disclosed in the earliest
version of the prosecution case. The FIR was promptly lodged
against them, and their presence and participation have
consistently been stated by Amrit Das Kuldeep (PW-5). The
evidence of PW-5, being an injured eyewitness and a person
closely acquainted with the accused persons, inspires confidence
insofar as these four accused are concerned.
41. So far as the reliance placed by learned counsel for the
appellants on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Talari Naresh (supra), is concerned, the said decision does not
advance the case of the present appellants. In the said judgment,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court dealt with a case where the
prosecution evidence suffered from material inconsistencies,
doubtful
identification,
and
absence
of
reliable
evidence
connecting the accused with the alleged crime. The principle laid
down therein is that conviction cannot be sustained merely on the
basis of suspicion or improved versions of witnesses. However,
the facts of the present case are distinguishable insofar as the
appellants Sundar Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel
and Dinesh Korram are concerned, as their names were
mentioned in the earliest version of the prosecution case, their
involvement has consistently been stated by the injured
eyewitness PW-5, and the ocular testimony finds corroboration
from the medical evidence and other circumstances on record.
Therefore, the ratio laid down in Talari Naresh (supra) is not
applicable to the case of these appellants.
42. The defence contention regarding darkness and mistaken identity
does not carry much force in respect of appellants Sundar
Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh Korram,
as the witnesses were acquainted with them prior to the incident.
The medical evidence also supports the prosecution version that
Rambha Kuldeep died a homicidal death due to injuries caused
by assault. Minor contradictions and omissions appearing in the
statements of prosecution witnesses are natural consequences of
lapse of time and do not affect the core of the prosecution case
against these four accused persons. The learned Trial Court,
after proper appreciation of the evidence, has rightly found their
involvement in the commission of the offence.
43. Consequently, the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court
holding all the eight accused guilty with the aid of Section 149 of
the IPC cannot be sustained in its entirety. Since this Court has
acquitted appellants Puran Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram
Baghel and Daulat Korram by extending them the benefit of
doubt, the unlawful assembly, as found by the learned Trial Court,
no longer survives in the manner held by it. The conviction of the
remaining four appellants with the aid of Section 149 of the IPC,
therefore, requires reconsideration.
44. From the evidence of injured eyewitness Amrit Das Kuldeep
(PW-5), it stands established that appellants Sundar Korram,
Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh Korram had jointly
intercepted the deceased and assaulted her with wooden sticks,
inflicting repeated blows on vital parts of her body. The assault
was concerted, simultaneous and in furtherance of their common
intention. Their participation in the commission of the offence has
been consistently established from the earliest version of the
prosecution case and finds due corroboration from the medical
evidence. Thus, even though the conviction with the aid of
Section 149 IPC cannot be sustained after acquittal of the
remaining four accused, the evidence on record clearly
establishes that these four appellants acted in furtherance of their
common intention within the meaning of Section 34 of the IPC.
45. It is well settled that where the evidence establishes the existence
of a common intention amongst the accused persons and their
participation in the commission of the offence, the conviction can
be altered from Section 149 IPC to Section 34 IPC, provided no
prejudice is caused to the accused. In the present case, the
prosecution evidence from the very inception attributed active
participation to appellants Sundar Korram, Mahesh Korram,
Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh Korram. They were fully aware of
the allegations against them and had ample opportunity to defend
themselves during the trial. Therefore, alteration of their
conviction from Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC to Section
302 read with Section 34 IPC, and similarly from Section 341
read with Section 149 IPC to Section 341 read with Section 34
IPC, does not occasion any failure of justice or prejudice to them.
46. Accordingly, Criminal Appeal No.2115/2024 filed by appellants
Puran Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram Baghel and Daulat
Korram is allowed. The judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 26.10.2024 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Kondagaon in Sessions Case No.98/2021,
insofar as it relates to these appellants, is hereby set aside. They
are acquitted of all the charges levelled against them by
extending the benefit of doubt. They are in jail, they be released
forthwith, if not required in connection with any other case.
47. Keeping in view the provisions of Section 481 of the Bhartiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (corresponding to Section 437-A
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973), appellants Puran
Korram, Kiras Korram, Tilakram Baghel and Daulat Korram are
directed to furnish personal bonds in the sum of Rs.25,000/- each
with two reliable sureties in the like amount before the trial Court,
which shall remain in force for a period of six months, together
with an undertaking that in the event of filing of any Special Leave
Petition against this judgment, they shall appear before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court as and when required.
48. Criminal Appeal No.2213/2024 filed by appellants Sundar
Korram, Mahesh Korram, Mayaram Baghel and Dinesh
Korram is partly allowed. While maintaining the findings of guilt
recorded by the learned Trial Court, their conviction for offence
under Section 341 read with Section 149 IPC is modified to
offence under Section 341 read with Section 34 IPC, and their
conviction under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC is
modified to offence under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
Their conviction under Sections 148 and 120-B IPC is
maintained. The sentences imposed by the learned Trial Court on
the aforesaid appellants for the respective offences, as modified
by this Court, namely: (i) RI for three years with a fine of Rs.500/-,
and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo RI for six
months; (ii) SI for one month with a fine of Rs.500/-, and in
default of payment of fine, to further undergo SI for six months;
(iii) imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs.500/-, and in default of
payment of fine, to further undergo RI for six months; and (iv)
imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs.500/-, and in default of
payment of fine, to further undergo RI for six months, shall remain
unaltered.
49. Registry is directed to send a certified copy of this judgment along
with the original record of the case to the trial court concerned
forthwith for necessary information and compliance and also send
a copy of this judgment to the concerned Superintendent of Jail
where the appellants are undergoing their jail sentence to serve
the same on the appellants informing him that they are at liberty
to assail the present judgment passed by this Court by preferring
an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, if so advised, with
the assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the
Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
Bablu
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review