Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RSA 76/2024, CM APPL. 22721-22724/2024
1.
SUMITRA SONI
W/o. Late Sh. Shambhu Dayal
2.
ROHIT SONI
S/o. Late Sh. Shambhu Dayal
3.
YASHPAL SONI @ MANU
S/o. Late Sh. Shambhu Dayal
4.
RAHUL SONI S/O. LATE SH. SHAMBHU DAYAL
All are R/o 51/52, Gali No.15, Nai Basti,
Anand Parbat, New Delhi.
.....Appellants
Through: Appearance not given.
versus
1.
SMT PREM WATI
W/o Late Dal Chand
R/o 16/560-E, Bapa Nagar,
Padam Singh Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
2.
SMT. HEMA
W/o Late Jagdish
3.
MISS CHANCHAL (MINOR)
D/o Late Jagdish
4.
MISS KINOO (MINOR)
D/o Late Jagdish
5.
MASTER JATIN (MINOR)
S/o Late Jagdish
Respondents Nos.3 to 5 (minor)
through their mother and
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
natural guardian Respondent No.2 Smt. Hema.
6.
SH. VIJAY
S/o Late Dal Chand
7.
SMT. BISHNO
W/o Prem Prakash
8.
SMT. NEELAM
W/o Praveen
All R/o. 16/1560E, First Floor,
Bapa Nagar, Padam Singh Road,
Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
9.
SMT. SHASHI KALA
W/o. Late Sh. Karan Singh
R/o 16/560E, 2nd Floor, Bapa Nagar,
Padam Singh Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
Through: None
.....Respondents
%
CORAM
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
ORDER
19.03.2026
1.
This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (CPC), has been filed on behalf of the Appellants, against
the Judgment and decree dated 23.08.2023 of the learned
Additional
District Judge-03, Delhi in RCA DJ No. 209/2017, whereby the Judgment
and decree dated 26.07.2017 of the learned Civil Judge-08, Delhi, has been
upheld and the Suit of the Plaintiffs/Respondents for Possession, Mesne
Profits/Damages, has been decreed.
2.
The brief facts are, that the Plaintiff/Respondent No. 1, Smt. Prem
Wati, had filed a Suit for Possession and Declaration of documents in the
name of Mr. Shambhu Dayal, husband of Defendant No.1 and father of of
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
Defendant No. 2 to 4, and those executed in favour of Defendant No. 12,
Smt. Shashi Kala by defendant No.1 to 4, as null and void and for Recovery
of Damages, Mesne Profits and Notice Charges etc.
3.
The Plaintiff, Smt. Premwati stated that her husband, Late Sh. Dal
Chand, was absolute owner of the Property bearing No.16/560E, Bapa
Nagar, Padam Singh Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi, (hereinafter referred to
as “Suit Property”), who died intestate.
4.
Late Sh. Dal Chand survived by his wife, his three sons, Mr. Jagdish,
Mr. Vijay and Mr. Hemant, and two daughters, Ms. Bishno and Ms. Neelam,
who had since got married. Mr. Hemant s/o Late Sh. Dal Chand died
unmarried. Mr. Jagdish s/o Late Sh. Dal Chand got married, but he died and
was survived by his legal heirs, who are the Defendant Nos. 5 to 8. It is
claimed that the Plaintiff, wife of Dal Chand and the Defendant Nos. 5 to 11,
are the owners of the property.
5.
The Property had been constructed up to the third floor. The ground
floor was sold by Late Sh. Dal Chand, during his lifetime. The legal heirs of
Late Sh. Dal Chand, therefore, by inheritance, became the owner of the First
Floor, Second Floor and Third Floor of the suit property.
6.
The Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 agreed to purchase First and Second Floor
of the Property, without roof rights from some of the legal heirs of Late Sh.
Dal Chand. The Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 filed a Suit for Permanent Injunction
in the Court of Civil Judge, which was withdrawn on 04.03.2005.
7.
Later, Mr. Shambhu Dayal, husband/father of the Defendant Nos. 1 to
4, filed a Suit for Specific Performance of Contract against some of the legal
heirs of Late Sh. Dal Chand. The Suit was dismissed by the learned
Additional District Judge, vide Judgment dated 15.05.2007. As per the
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
knowledge of the Plaintiff, the Appeal against this Judgment, was filed
either by Sh. Shambhu Dayal, or by his legal heirs/ Defendant Nos. 1 to 4.
8.
Mr. Jagdish, son of Late Sh. Dal Chand, died after the pronouncement
of the Judgment. He had been living on the Second Floor of the property
with the members of his family, who have been arrayed as the Defendant
Nos. 5 to 8. Sometime before his demise, he shifted from the Second Floor
under his occupation and shifted to another place.
9.
Mr. Shambhu Dayal, sometime after the demise of Mr. Jagdish, had
trespassed into the Second Floor and did not vacate despite repeated
requests. The family members of Mr. Jagdish after demise, became busy in
setting up their own house in order. The Defendant Nos. 1 to 4, legal heirs of
Mr. Shambhu Dayal, were requested to vacate the premises by other legal
heirs of Late Sh. Dal Chand, but they refused to do so.
10.
After sometime, the Defendant Nos. 1 to 4, who were in possession of
Second Floor, unauthorisedly and without consent, handed over the
possession to the Defendant No. 12.
11.
A Legal Notice dated 05.09.2009 was issued to Defendant Nos.1 to 4,
who were asked to vacate the property and also to pay the wrongful use and
occupation charges of the premises w.e.f. 01.12.2008 @ Rs. 5,000/- per
month, exclusive of other charges. They also demanded wrongful and
occupation charges per month, but Defendant Nos.1 to 4 failed to respond.
12.
The Suit was accordingly, filed for Possession, for declaring the
documents, if any, executed by Late Mr. Shambhu Dayal, predecessorin-interest in favour of the Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 (his legal heirs), or in
favour of the Defendant No. 12, Smt. Shashi Kala as null and void, and
for Recovery of Damages, Mesne Profits @Rs. 5,000/- per month w.e.f.
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
01.08.2010. Recovery of Notice Charges in the sum of Rs.2,200/- from
the Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 and Defendant No. 12.
13.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 (legal heirs of
Late Mr. Shambhu Dayal), who in their Written Statement took the
preliminary objections that sons of Shri Dal Chand with due consent of
Plaintiff and their sisters, sold their share in the Suit property to the
answering Defendant No.1 in the month of May, 2005 to the knowledge of
the Plaintiffs and had raised „No Objection‟ about the sale consideration.
Therefore, she has no right or locus standi to file the present Suit.
14.
It was asserted that the Suit was bad for mis-joinder and non-joinder
of the necessary parties and the Plaintiff has wrongly impleaded the
Defendant Nos. 5 to 11 in the Suit. Moreover, the Defendant No. 1 has
already sold the Suit Property to the Defendant No. 12 and hence, the Suit is
not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed.
15.
On merits, all the averments made in the Plaint, were denied and it
was stated that the Suit be dismissed.
16.
Smt. Shashi Kala, Defendant No.12, the subsequent purchaser, in
her Written Statement, claimed that the Plaintiff has not come to the Court
with clean hands and suppressed the true facts. The Plaintiff has no
connection with the Suit Property, as the Defendant No. 12 had purchased
the same from the Defendant No. 1 on 14.07.2008, a fact which is in the
knowledge of the Plaintiff. The Defendant No. 1 had purchased this Property
from the sons of Late Sh. Dal Chand in the year 2005, a fact which also is
within the knowledge of the Plaintiff, who had taken her part of the sale
consideration. It is claimed that the Plaintiff has no locus standi to file the
present Suit.
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
17.
On merits, all the contentions made in the Plaint, were denied.
18.
The issues on the pleadings were framed on 03.03.2012, as under:
19.
1.
Whether Plaintiff is entitled for decree of
recovery of possession as prayed for? OPP
2.
Whether Plaintiff is entitled for decree of
declaration as prayed for? OPP
3.
Whether Plaintiff is entitled for decree for
recovery of damage/mesne profits as prayed
for? OPP
4.
Whether suit of the Plaintiff is without cause of
action and Plaintiff has no locus standi to file
the present suit? OPD-1 to 4 & 12
5.
Whether suit of the Plaintiff is bad for nonjoinder and mis joinder of necessary parties?
OPD-1 to 4 & 12.
6.
Whether suit of the Plaintiff is barred by law of
limitation? OPD-1 to 4 & 12.
7.
Relief.
The Plaintiff, Smt. Prem Wati as PW-1, proved the certified copy of
the Judgment dated 15.05.2007 of the learned ADJ as Ex.PW-1/1. The Legal
Notice dated 05.09.2009 exhibited as Ex.PW-1/2 and Postal Receipt, UPC
etc., undelivered cover is exhibited as Ex.PW-1/3 collectively.
20.
The Defendants in support of their case, examined DW-1, Mr.
Sukhbir Sharma, Sub Registrar, who produced the Death Register and
proved the Death Certificate of Smt. Prem Wati, wife of Late Sh. Dal
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
Chand.
21.
DW-1 Ms. Sumitra (sic) tendered her Affidavit Ex. DW-1/A and
supported the contentions as made by her in her Written Statement.
DW-2, HC Raghunath proved the FIR No. 230/2013 under Sections
468/471/120-B/182 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code 1860, registered at
Police Station Prasad Nagar.
22.
DW-4, Mr. Vijay s/o Late Sh. Dal Chand and DW-5, Shashi had
appeared as defence witnesses.
23.
The learned Civil judge, after appreciation of the evidence, observed
that admittedly Sh. Dal Chand, predecessor in interest, was owner of the Suit
Property, who died intestate and thus, all his legal heirs became rightful
owners of the Suit Property. However, alleged documents of sale namely
Agreement to Sell, Will etc. in favour of Defendant Nos.1 to 4, were
executed only by two sons, namely Jagdish and Vijay, who were not
competent to execute transfer documents in respect of the Suit Property. The
Defendants had taken plea that there was family settlement, though there
was no evidence led in this regard and the Plaintiff witnesses denied there
being any family settlement.
24.
Learned Civil Judge further observed that even if these documents
were considered as an Agreement to Sell for the share of Jagdish and Vijay,
then too, Defendant Nos.1 to 4 could only claim partition and should have
filed a Suit for Partition.
25.
Pertinently, the documents, on the basis of which, Defendant Nos.1 to
4 were claiming to have acquired ownership were GPA, etc., which in terms
of Suraj Lamps vs. State of Haryana,183 (2011) DLT 1 (SC), wherein
Supreme Court observed that transactions of the nature of GPA sales were
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
held to be not a valid mode of transfer, and do not convey any title and do
not constitute a valid mode of transfer of immovable property.
26.
Learned Civil Judge held that alleged documents in favour of
Defendant Nos.1 to 4, did not confer any ownership and were therefore, null
and void. Defendant No.12 namely Smt. Shashi Kala, is also claiming title
through Defendant Nos.1 to 4, whose claim to title, also failed.
27.
Consequently, Suit of the Plaintiff for Possession and Recovery of
Damages @ Rs.5,000/- per month was decreed against Defendant Nos.1 to
4 and 12 jointly and severally since 09.08.2010 till handing over of
possession, along with the interest @ 6% p.a. and also held Plaintiff entitled
to Recovery of Rs.2,200/- p.m. from Defendant Nos.1 to 4 and 12 jointly.
28.
RCA DJ No. 209/2017 was preferred against the Impugned Judgment
dated 26.07.2017, which after due consideration of the evidence and the law,
was dismissed vide Judgment dated 23.08.2023, by Ld. Additional
District Judge.
29.
Aggrieved, the present Regular Second Appeal has been filed by
the Appellants.
30.
The grounds of challenge are that learned Civil Judge has
erroneously decided that documents in favour of Defendant Nos.1 to 4, did
not confer any valid right, title or interest in favour of the Appellants,
without appreciating that no document of title was proved or produced by
the Respondents to establish the title of the Suit Property, in favour of Sh.
Dal Chand.
31.
Pertinently, Respondent No.1 / Plaintiff had admitted in her cross-
examination that the Suit Property was not purchased by Sh. Dal Chand, but
it was an encroached land, thereby showing that he had no right, title or
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
interest in the Suit Property.
32.
Therefore, Respondents / Plaintiffs were not entitled to take benefits
of the weakness in the defence of the Appellants / Defendants, but the
Plaintiffs have to stand on their own legs, as has been held by the Supreme
Court in the case of Union of India and Ors. vs. Vasavi Co-operative
Housing Society Ltd. & Ors., 2014 (1) Rajdhani Law Reporter 696, wherein
the Apex Court has held that burden always lies on the Plaintiff to make out
and establish a clear case and weakness, if any, in the case of the defendants
would not be a ground to grant relief to the Plaintiff.
33.
Furthermore, it had been vaguely averred that the second floor of the
Suit Property was trespassed by the predecessor-in-interest of Appellant
Nos.2 to 5, but neither any specific date or year was given, nor relevant
material facts & particulars to the said effect were given, as mandated under
Order VI Rule 4 of CPC. These necessary details are deliberately and
conspicuously absent in the plaint and the impugned Judgment and Decree
suffer from material infirmity.
34.
It has not been considered that while considering the Suit for
Possession, learned Civil Judge was required to record a finding on the
claim of title to the suit land made on behalf of the Plaintiff and was bound
to enquire or investigate into this aspect, before considering other reliefs
sought by the Plaintiff.
35.
It is further contended that learned Trial Court has wrongly placed
reliance on Suraj Lamps vs. State of Haryana,183 (2011) DLT 1 (SC) for the
relief of declaration without appreciating that the same would not affect the
validity of sale agreements and power of attorneys executed in genuine
transactions and would not have retrospective operation.
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
36.
In the present case, GPA executed by the sons of the deceased Sh. Dal
Chand, was for consideration and it was duly stamped & registered in the
Office of the concerned Sub-Registrar and was also accompanied by other
sale documents.
37.
Similarly, GPA executed by Appellant No. 1 in favour of Respondent
No. 9/ Smt. Shashi Kala (defendant no.12) was for consideration, as per
circle rates and as per the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and was duly registered in
the Office of the Sub-Registrar, the execution of which was not disputed
and there is presumption of genuineness being registered, as per Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 and Registration Act,1908.
38.
There is settled presumption that possession follows title, while
Respondent No.1 was unable to rebut the facts and circumstance of the case
and there was not an iota of evidence to establish the trespass in the Suit
Property, by the Appellants.
39.
Learned Civil Judge wrongly held that the documents of purchase of
the Suit Property in favour of Appellant Nos.1 and 2 do not create any right,
title or interest in their favour in the Suit Property or that even if these
documents create any right in their favour by sale and transfer of the
property by Jagdish and Vijay Kumar, Appellants were required to seek
partition of the property. The averments of the Appellants that there was
settlement inter-se all the legal heirs of deceased and his sons who were
competent to execute the sale documents, has not been appreciated by
learned Civil Judge.
40.
Even otherwise, Decree for Possession and collusive Suit were filed
by the Respondent No. 1 / Plaintiff in connivance with other Legal Heirs of
late Sh. Dal Chand, which is evident from the fact that other Legal Heirs,
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
though impleaded as Defendant No.5 to -11 in the Suit, did not file any
Written Statement.
41.
Moreover, Appellants asserted that Respondent No.1Prem Wati was
not wife of late Sh. Dal Chand, which came to the knowledge of the
Appellants from Municipal Records through RTI Application and material
facts were subsequently placed on Trial Court record. These facts could not
be mentioned in the Written Statement, as this information was obtained
subsequently.
42.
Learned Civil Judge should have in fact, framed additional issues, if it
was necessary for determining the controversy between the parties, but no
additional issue was framed, which also speaks of illegality of the Judgment
of the learned Civil Judge.
43.
Moreover, Section 44 of Indian Evidence Act states that if a party
withholds vital document, to deceive and cheat or to secure unfair gain and
an advantage, then it is fraud on the Court and Decree so obtained, is a
nullity and a party is bound to produce all relevant documents. A case,
which is based on falsehood, has to be summarily dismissed.
44.
The Rules cannot be reduced to absurdity to become an engine of
fraud by dishonest litigants, as held by the Apex Court in the case of S. P.
Chengalvaraya vs. Jaganath, 1994 Rajdhani Law Reporter (SC) 102. All
Rules and procedures are handmaids of justice and these should not stand in
the way of dispensing Justice to the parties and honest litigants must receive
assistance of the Courts.
45.
Learned Civil Judge wrongly relied upon the earlier Judgements of
the judicial proceedings instituted by husband of Appellant No.2, as they
were not relevant for determination of the real controversy between the
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
parties to the present Suit.
46.
It has not been appreciated that relief of Declaration ought to have
been sought within a period of three years and this relief was barred by
limitation.
47.
It has been wrongly held that the Suit is not barred by limitation, as
the relief of possession could be sought within a period of twelve years on
the basis of title and possession, without appreciating that the relief of
possession was consequential to the Declaration. If Respondent No.1 was
not entitled to declaration or cancellation of documents sought for, she could
not have claimed relief of possession and other reliefs.
48.
The documents had been executed in favour of Appellant No.2 on
30.05.2005, out of which, GPA was duly registered. As per Explanation I in
Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act 1882, there is due notice on
registered documents, more so, when executed by Jagdish and Vijay, two
sons of late Sh. Dal Chand. Subsequently, attorney in favour of Appellant
No.1, was registered in 2008, while the Suit was filed in July/August, 2010.
The Declaration sought with regard to the documents, was vague and there
has been no specification of any such document, which was sought to be
cancelled.
49.
It is further asserted that monthly damages have been wrongly granted
to Respondent No.1, even though there was not an iota of evidence to this
effect. Respondent No.1 had failed to discharge her burden, despite which
damages have been granted.
50.
It has been wrongly held that Respondent No.1 had locus standi to file
the Suit, without appreciating that she was not able to prove any document
prior to 1996/98, with regard to her identity. Her answers with regards to the
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
dates of her other family members in the cross-examination were evasive
and did not inspire confidence. In the light of her evidence, it was incumbent
upon the learned Civil Judge to fix the identity of Respondent No.1 and
adjudicate upon death of Prem Devi, and also in the light of deposition of
DW-1 and Death Certificate placed on record. Learned Civil Judge wrongly
held that Respondent No.1 was entitled to seek relief of declaration.
51.
Substantial questions of law raised in the present Appeal, are:
“1. Whether Judgement and Decree have been procured by
concealment and playing fraud?
2. Whether the Respondent No.1 / Plaintiff in the Trial
Court had no locus standi to file the present litigation?
3. Whether the appellants are suffering for no fault on part
of Appellant No.1, who had purchased the property in
question vide registered document with sale consideration?
4. Whether despite the Suit Property being encroached by
late Sh. Dalchand, Respondent No.1 is entitled to
declaratory relief and to the possession.?”
52.
A Prayer is therefore, made that Judgment and Decree dated
23.08.2023 as well Judgment dated 26.07.2017 be set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
53.
Plaintiff / Respondent Smt. Smt. Prem Wati, had stated in the Plaint
that Suit Property was originally owned by Sh. Dal Chand, who died
intestate, leaving behind Plaintiff, his wife and Defendant Nos.5 to 11 as his
only Legal Heirs. The Ground Floor of the Suit Property was sold by Late
Sh. Dal Chand, during his lifetime.
54.
The Appellants have asserted that late Sh. Dal Chand himself was an
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
encroacher on the Government Land, as admitted by PW-1 / Smt. Prem
Wati, Plaintiff in her cross-examination. Once, he himself was an
encroacher, he could not have claimed any ownership right in the Suit
Property.
55.
Though, the Appellants had claimed to challenge the title of Late Dal
Chand as being an encroacher, but significantly all the Appellants are
deriving their title from Late Shri Dal Chand, by claiming that they had
purchased the property i.e. the Second Floor from Vijay and Jagdish i.e. two
sons of Late Shri Dal Chand. Once they are deriving their title from
deceased Dal Chand, they cannot question the title of Dal Chand, of being
an encroacher.
56.
In this context, reference may be made to Rame Gowda vs. M.
Varadappa Naidu (2004) 1 SCC 769, wherein the three Judge Bench of the
Apex Court had observed that as far as the Indian law is concerned, the
person in peaceful possession is entitled to retain it, and in order to protect
the possession, he may even use reasonable force, to keep out the trespasser.
A rightful owner who has been wrongfully dispossessed of land, may re-take
the possession, if he can do so peacefully and without use of unreasonable
force. The law presumes that the possession goes with the title unless
rebutted. In the absence of better title, possession of prior peaceful settled
possessor in itself, is evidence of title. It was thus, concluded by the Apex
Court that “in the absence of proof of better title, possession or entire
peaceful settled possession is itself evidence of title”.
57.
Thereafter, in Poona Ram vs. Moti Ram (2009) 11 SCC 309, the Apex
Court endorsed the observations made in Rame Gowda (supra) that legal
remedies thus, appointed for the protection of possession even against
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
ownership, are called possessory, while those available for the protection of
ownership itself may be distinguished as proprietary. The distinction is
expressed in contrasted terms of petitorium (a proprietary suit) and
possessorium (a possessory suit). It was thus, held that the Plaintiff in the
absence of better Title, can claim prior peaceful settled possession which
itself is the evidence of title. It was held that the settled possession must be
(i) effective; (ii) undisturbed; and (iii) to the knowledge of the owner or
without any attempt and concealment by the trespasser.
Moreover, there
can be no straight jacket formula to determine settled possession and each
case must be decided on its own facts. The possession should contain an
element of animus possidendi. It was further observed that in order to claim
possessory title, the Plaintiff will have to prove his own case and also will
have to show that he has better title than any other person.
58.
Herein, as already noted above, admittedly, the Appellants were
deriving their title from Dal Chand by claiming that after his demise, they
had purchased the property through GPA, etc from Jagdish and Vijay, the
two sons of Dal Chand. From the submissions made by the Appellant itself
it is evident that they had accepted the settled possession of the Appellants
and, therefore, the contention of the Appellants that Dal Chand did not have
ownership title or that he was an encroacher, is not tenable. Indisputably, he
had possessory rights, which were claimed to be transferred to the
Appellants.
59.
In this context, it may be pertinent to observe that the Declaration of
Sh. Dal Chand, being an owner, is purely possessory inter se the parties and
not against any third person, who has a superior title or ownership.
60.
When viewed in this context, it has to be held that the conclusion of
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
learned Civil Judge that Sh. Dal Chand was the owner of the Suit Property,
is correct and merits no interference.
61.
Sh. Shambhu Dayal, predecessor in interest of Defendant Nos.1 to 4,
had agreed to purchase the property, i.e. First and Second floors without roof
rights, from Sh. Jagdish and Sh. Vijay, both sons of Late Sh. Dal Chand by
way of Agreement to Sell, GPA etc. dated 30.05.2005. He filed Suit for
Permanent injunction, which got dismissed as withdrawn on 04.03.2005.
62.
Defendant Nos.1 to 4 / Legal Heirs of late Sh. Shambhu Dayal, had
even filed a Suit for Specific Performance of Contract, against the two
Legal Heirs of late Sh. Dal Chand, but this Suit got dismissed by learned
ADJ, vide Order dated 15.05.2007.
63.
Significantly, endeavour of the Appellants to seek specific
performance for execution of Sale Deed on the basis of these documents i.e.
GPA, etc., had got dismissed. There is nothing to show that the said
Judgment ever got challenged or the claim of the Appellants to seek
execution of Sale Deed in their favour, is live or pending.
64.
Once the Suit for Specific performance of the Appellants, has been
dismissed, the Appellants, cannot re-agitate the same issue again.
65.
Furthermore, the Appellants herein were claiming the title on the
basis of GPA etc., which in terms of Suraj Lamps vs. State of Haryana,183
(2011) DLT 1 (SC), do not confer any right, title or interest in the Suit
Property. These documents may give a right to the party, either to get a Sale
Deed executed in their favour or may protect their possession under Section
53A Transfer of Property Act 1882, if these documents are registered.
However, these documents do not create any right, title or interest in the Suit
Property, as has been rightly observed by learned Civil Judge.
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
66.
Appellants having failed to get any Sale Deed in their favour, they
cannot claim any right, title or interest in the Suit Property. Learned Civil
Judge therefore, rightly held these documents to not confer any ownership
rights in favour of the Appellants.
67.
Defendant No.12 / Smt. Shashi Kala is also claiming right, title or
interest in the Suit Property, only through Defendant Nos.1 to 4 / Appellants.
Once the right, title or interest of Defendant Nos.1 to 4 / Appellants itself
has been found to be non-existent, Defendant No.12 cannot assert a better
title, on the basis of documents executed in her favour by Defendant Nos.1
to 4 / Appellants. Her claim in Suit Property therefore, necessarily fails.
68.
The Appellants have also asserted that it has been erroneously
decided that respondent no. 1 had a locus standi to file the Suit, as the
learned Civil Judge failed to properly appreciate her deposition, wherein she
could not produce any identity documents prior to 1996–98 and gave
evasive answers regarding her identity and family details. It is contended
that her cross-examination lacked credibility, and the Court ought to have
determined her identity in light of the evidence on record, including the
deposition of DW-1, the death certificate of Prem Devi, and the FIR
registered pursuant to court directions. Accordingly, the impugned judgment
suffers from material irregularity and is liable to be set aside, or
alternatively, the matter be remanded for proper determination of her
identity.
69.
However, it is a finding on fact and cannot be challenged in this
second Regular Appeal.
70.
Another objection taken was that the Suit was barred by limitation.
The learned Civil Judge, after due appreciation of the evidence, has rightly
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
concluded that the Suit was found to be filed within 12 years of documents
of sale, executed in favour of Defendant No.1, in 2005; Suit was not barred
by limitation.
71.
Therefore, Suit of the Plaintiff for Possession and Recovery of
Damages @ Rs.5,000/- per month was decreed against Defendant Nos.1 to
4 and 12 jointly and severally since 09.08.2010 till handing over of
possession, along with the interest @ 6% p.a. and also held Plaintiff entitled
to Recovery of Rs.2,200/- p.m. from Defendant Nos.1 to 4 and 12 jointly.
72.
Learned District Judge, in RCA had fully agreed and endorsed the
findings of the learned Trial Court.
73.
From the grounds of challenge to the Appeal, it is evident that it is
purely confined to the facts and does not raise any substantial question of
law. Those substantial questions of law, which have been proposed by the
Appellants, are on their face, a challenge to the Judgment on facts and not
on any question of law.
74.
No substantial question of law arises for consideration in this Appeal.
75.
There is no merit in the second Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
Pending Applications are also disposed of, accordingly.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
MARCH 19, 2026/RS/R
RSA 76/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 22/04/2026 at 12:15:58
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review