The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. For the aforesaid reasons, this writ petition is allowed. Respondents, in particular, respondents No.2-5, 2026:HHC:27691 are directed to acquire the land of the petitioners comprised in Khasra No. 945/585/297/1, measuring 4 biswas, situated at Mauza Barog, Tehsil Solan, in accordance with law. This exercise be initiated within a period of four weeks from today and completed as expeditiously as possible, but not later than six months thereafter. The amount of compensation already paid to the petitioners be adjusted from the amount which eventually would be awarded to them. Petitioners are at liberty to seek appropriate remedy for the redressal of their surviving grievances, if any, in accordance with law. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also to stand disposed of. July 9, 2026 R.Atal Jyotsna Rewal Dua Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:27691
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.16318 of 2024
Decided on: 09.07.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Sumitra Devi and Anr.
…..Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and Ors.
.....Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Prem Chand Verma and
Mr. Aakash Thakur, Advocates.
For the Respondents: Mr. Balram Sharma, Deputy Solicitor
General of India, for respondent No.1.
Ms. Shreya Chauhan, Advocate, for
respondents No.2 to 4.
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General
with Ms. Seema Sharma, Deputy
Advocate General for respondents No.
5 to 7.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioners seek direction to the respondents to
acquire
the subject land owned by them
in accordance
with law.
2.
The Case
2(i
Sumitra Devi and Anr. Vs. Union of India
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
2026:HHC:27691
and Ors2 was instituted by the petitioners with the
grievance
that
their
land
comprised
in
Khasra
No.
945/585/297, measuring 0-8 biswas, situated at Mauza
Barog, Tehsil Solan, Hadbast No.801, had been utilized by
the respondents for four laning/widening of National
Highway-22 (Parwanoo-Solan stretch), therefore, they are
entitled to compensation. The writ petition was disposed of
with liberty reserved to the
petitioners to approach the
Committee
the
constituted
by
State
Government
on
08.06.2020, by way of representation. The said Committee
presided by the Deputy Commissioner of the concerned
District (District Solan in the instant case) was constituted
by the State Government to resolve all issues including
issues of assessing the damages caused to private land,
buildings and structures beyond the right of way, due to
construction of four laning of road.
In terms of the
judgment, petitioners’ representation was to be decided by
the Committee within the timeline mentioned therein.
2(ii)
Petitioners
(Annexure P-2).
submitted
their
representation
On record there is office communication
dated 13.09.2023 (Annexure P-4) from the Sub Divisional
Officer (Civil)-cum-Competent Authority Land Acquisition2
CWP No. 2574 of 2022, decided on 03.04.2023,
2026:HHC:27691
respondent No.-5 to the effect, that petitioners’ case did not
pertain to damage to their land on account of construction
of the road; That petitioners’ land was not beyond the right
of way, rather it fell within the right of way and
road
actually traversed over the land in question.
2(iii)
The
Committee
constituted
by
the
State
Government under notification dated 08.06.2020, headed
by the Deputy Commissioner, District Solan, in its meeting
convened
on
07.12.2023
representation and, inter- alia,
examined
petitioners’
noted the stand of the
National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) that it had only
widened the existing road that was handed over by the
State Public Works Department; That it had not utilized
the un-acquired land of the petitioners; That demarcation of
the land though had been conducted by the Assistant
Collector Second Grade, Solan on 29/30.12.2022, but the
NHAI had preferred an appeal against the said demarcation,
therefore, petitioners’ representation be not decided till the
outcome of the appeal.
The Committee accordingly,
deferred the decision of petitioners’ representation, awaiting
the outcome of the appeal preferred by the NHAI against the
demarcation conducted on 29/30.12.2022.
2026:HHC:27691
At this juncture, it would also be appropriate
to
refer
to
the
demarcation report
demarcation
report.
The
aforesaid
has been appended at Annexure P-7.
As per this demarcation report, the land comprised in
Khasra No.945/585/297 measuring 0-8 biswas was owned
by the petitioners in equal shares; Road was in existence
over un-acquired Khasra No.945/585/297/1 measuring 04 biswas;
Road was not constructed over the acquired
land; Khasra No.945/585/297/2 measuring 0-3 biswas
had become
a complete sloppy land parcel, whereas,
Khasra No.945/585/297/3 measuring 0-1 biswa had slided
below the road.
Thus, in terms of
above demarcation report,
road existed over un-acquired Khasra No.945/585/297/1
measuring 0-4 biswas, whereas, the other 0-4 biswas of
land comprised in Khasra No.945/585/297/2 (0-3biswas)
and Khasra No.945/585/297/3 (0-1 biswas) were not in
their original shape and character.
Appeal
filed
by
the
NHAI
against
the
demarcation report was dismissed on 29.08.2024. No
further appeal was carried by the respondent-NHAI. The
demarcation thus, attained finality.
2026:HHC:27691
2(iv)
In view of above, the Committee constituted by
the State Government under notification dated 08.06.2020
under the Chairmanship of the Deputy Commissioner,
District Solan, decided petitioners’ representation
on
07.09.2024, holding that the land measuring 0-4 bighas (4
biswas) belonging to the petitioners
had been utilized by
the NHAI for widening and four laning of NH-22 (now new
NH-05), therefore, petitioners were eligible for compensation
for the same.
On 21.09.2024 the Deputy Commissioner,
District Solan, in his capacity as Chairman of the
Committee, passed the order, awarding Rs. 6 lacs as
compensation to the petitioners for utilization of their land
comprised in Khasra No.945/585/297/1 measuring 0-4
bighas
(4
biswas)
for
construction
of
road.
The
compensation was purportedly assessed on the basis of
award No. 25 dated 31.03.2016 that was in respect of land
acquired in Mouza Barog Hadbast No.801, Tehsil and
District Solan. The compensation as assessed under order
dated
21.09.2024
was
eventually
released
to
the
petitioners pursuant to orders passed in Sumitra Devi and
Anr Vs. Union of India and Ors3. Operative portion of the
decision rendered in this execution petition preferred by the
Ex. Pet No. 555 of 2024 decided on 06.11.2024
2026:HHC:27691
petitioners reads as under:“3. It is not in dispute that the Committee has now decided
the representation of the petitioners vide annexure PB dated 21st September, 2024. Therefore, the order
passed by this Court stands complied with. However,
in case the petitioners are still aggrieved by the said
order, they are at liberty to file substantive petition(s)
qua the same.
4.
However, before parting, it needs to be observed that
the respondents vide order dated 21st September,
2024 have acknowledged that at least four biswas of
land of the petitioners has come in the right of way
and for that, certain compensation has also been
worked out. Therefore, let at least, the admitted
amount of compensation be paid to the petitioners, as
expeditiously as possible and in no event later than
31st December, 2024.
5.
In view of the above, the instant Execution petition
stands disposed of with liberty as aforesaid. Pending
application, if any, shall also stand disposed of.”
2(v)
Petitioners are now with the case that in terms
of Sumitra Devi1 , their representation was to be decided by
the Committee constituted on 08.06.2020 chaired by the
Deputy Commissioner, Solan. The said Committee had
come to the definite conclusion that the respondent-NHAI
had utilized 4 biswas of petitioners’ land comprised in
Khasra No.945/585/297/1 for construction and widening
of the National Highway. Therefore, this land is required to
be acquired in accordance with law and duly compensated
2026:HHC:27691
for.
Vide order dated 21.09.2024
granted
paltry
compensation
to
the Committee had only
the
petitioners.
The
petitioners are entitled to due compensation in accordance
with law for the utilization of their land by acquiring the
same as per legal provisions. Monetary benefits consequent
upon acquisition of land, would also require to be released
in their favour.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the case file.
4.
It
is
an
admitted
position
that
Khasra
No.945/585/297/1 (measuring 0-4 bighas) situated at
Mouza Barog, Tehsil and District Solan,
petitioners in equal shares,
owned by the
has been utilized by the
respondent-NHAI for widening and four laning of
the
National Highway. However, this land parcel has not been
acquired in accordance with law.
Compensation of
Rs. 6 lacs awarded on 21.09.2024 by the Committee
constituted by the State Government on 08.06.2020,
cannot be said to be the award in lieu of acquisition of
petitioners’ land.
The notification dated 08.06.2020, has
been placed on record. In terms of the said notification, the
Committee had been constituted by the State Government
2026:HHC:27691
on 08.06.2020 only for assessing the damages caused to
the structures falling beyond the right of way. Admittedly,
the subject land of the petitioners was not beyond the right
of way of construction of four laning of road. It is not that
being beyond the right of way,
any structure of the
petitioners’ existing over the land had suffered some
damage, which had to be compensated and accordingly the
compensation was assessed by the Committee. Instant is a
case, where 4 biswas land of the petitioners
has been
utilized by the respondent-NHAI for construction of four
lane road, the land in question falls within the right of way.
Thus, it was required to be acquired and duly compensated
for in accordance with law.
The facts are not in dispute.
Utilization of petitioners’ 4 biswas land for widening/four
laning of the road is not in dispute. The land in question
having not been acquired is also an admitted position.
Given this,
there is no escape from conclusion that
petitioners cannot be divested from their 4 biswas of land
save and except in accordance with law.
No other point was urged.
5.
For the aforesaid reasons, this writ petition is
allowed. Respondents, in particular, respondents No.2-5,
2026:HHC:27691
are directed to acquire the land of the petitioners comprised
in Khasra No. 945/585/297/1, measuring 4 biswas,
situated at Mauza Barog, Tehsil Solan, in accordance with
law. This exercise be initiated within a period of four weeks
from today and completed as expeditiously as possible, but
not later than six months thereafter.
The amount of
compensation already paid to the petitioners be adjusted
from the amount which eventually would be awarded to
them. Petitioners are at liberty to seek appropriate remedy
for the redressal of their surviving grievances, if any, in
accordance with law.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
also to stand disposed of.
July 9, 2026
R.Atal
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review