Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1636 of 1999
BETWEEN:SUMANBAI @ DATTA BAI W/O HIRALAL PATIL, AGED 45
YEARS, OCCUPATION HOUSE WIFE R/O BARWANI
DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI V.SINGH, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF M.P. THROUGH P.S. BARWANI DISTRICT
BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI RAJESH JOSHI, GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
Reserved on
:
06.12.2023
Delivered on
:
30.01.2024
This criminal appeal having been heard and reserved for judgment,
coming for pronouncement this day, the Court passed the following:
JUDGMENT
T h e present appeal is filed against the judgment of conviction and
sentence dated 10.12.1999, passed by 2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Barwani,
in Sessions Trial No.74/1999, whereby, the appellant has been convicted under
sections 306 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as 'IPC') and
sentenced to undergo 10 years RI with fine of Rs.3,000/- respectively with
default stipulations by acquitting the co-accused Heeralal, Dilip and Vinayak
from the charges under Section 306/34 of IPC.
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
2. Brief facts of the case are that on 09.12.1998 the deceased Surekha
committed suicide by pouring kerosene oil on herself and setting her ablaze on
fire due to the mental and physical harassment committed by the appellant
alongwith other co-accused Heeralal, Dilip and Vinayak on the pretext of
demand of dowry. Thereafter, she was taken to the M.Y. Hospital, Indore for
treatment, but on 11.12.1998, she died. On the information, a Merg intimation
was registered by the Police. Thereafter, the police during investigation found
that the deceased has committed suicide due to demand of dowry. They were
harassing her and tortured physically and mentally due to which she committed
suicide. Initially, the offence under Section 498-A of IPC against the appellant
and co-accused was registered and after death of deceased offence was
aggravated to Section 306 of IPC.
3. During the investigation, spot map was prepared. Seized articles were
sent to Forensic Laboratory and after recording of statements of witnesses
under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., the police has filed the charge-sheet against the
accused persons under Section 306/34 of IPC before the Chief Judicial
Magistrate and the matter was committed to the Court of Sessions. Thereafter,
accused persons were charged for offence under Section Section 306/34 of
IPC instead of under Section 498-A of IPC. They abjured their guilt and took a
plea that they had been falsely implicated in the present crime and prayed for
trial.
4. In support of the case, the prosecution has examined as many as 10
witnesses namely Madhusudan (PW-1), Rakesh Jaat (PW-2), Dr. Rakesh Jain
(PW-3), Saheb Singh (PW-4), Ramesh Chandra (PW-5), Rangrao (PW-6),
Anant (PW-7), Chatar Singh Damad (PW-8), Dr. H.S. Bhatia (PW-9) Trilok
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
(PW-10), Soram Kishore (PW-11), Ravi (PW-12), Ramnivas Tiwari (PW-13),
Manorama Kosthi (PW-14), Samauddin (PW-15), Ahibaran Singh (PW-16),
Mumtaj (PW-17), Surendra Dube (PW-18), Dr. P.C. Jain (PW-19) &
Krishnapal Prasad Pal (PW-20). No witness has been adduced by the appellant
in her defence.
5 . Learned trial Court, on appreciation of the evidence and argument
adduced by the parties, pronounced the impugned judgment on 10.12.1999 and
finally concluded the case and convicted the appellant for commission of the
said offence under the provisions of Section 306 of IPC acquitting the other coaccused persons.
6. Impugning the findings of conviction and sentence, learned counsel for
the appellant submits that there are only omnibus allegations of demand of
dowry against the appellant alongwith co-accused persons and there is nothing
on record to connect the appellant with the offence. It is further submitted that
the appellant is a lady and mother-in-law of the deceased. The learned trial
Court has committed grave error of law and facts in considering the fact that the
appellant and deceased were living with each other. It is further submitted that
the learned trial Court while considering the evidence has committed error in not
considering that if there was demand of dowry and cruelty, the deceased would
have raised the alarm to anyone, but she has not lodged any complaint against
any person of the family. The appellant was convicted solely on the basis of
omnibus allegations leveled against the appellant learned trial Court has not
found the charges proved under Section 306 of IPC against other co-accused
persons and they have been acquitted by the learned trial Court from the
aforesaid charges.
7. Further, counsel for the appellant submits that most of the witnesses
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
namely are the relatives witnesses of the deceased, therefore, their statements
recorded by the learned trial Court are usually against the appellants and there is
no independent witness in the present case. Hence, they cannot be relied upon.
Therefore, it is prayed that even if the case of the prosecution is accepted at its
face value, the offence shall not travel more than the offence under Section 498A of IPC.
8. Alternatively, learned counsel for the appellant has also expostulated
on the point of sentence and prays that since the appellant has already
undergone approximately one year in jail incarceration out of the 10 years and
looking to the fact that co-appellants have already been acquitted by the learned
trial Court on the same set of allegations, the sentence of the appellant may be
reduced to the period already undergone. It is further submitted that the
appellant deserves some leniency as the appellant already suffered the ordeal of
the trial since 1998 i.e. for a period of 26 years. It is further submitted that this
appeal be partly allowed and the sentence awarded to the appellant be reduced
to the period already undergone.
9. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand supports the
impugned judgment and prays for dismissal of this appeal. It is further
submitted that the learned trial Court has passed the impugned judgement after
considering each and every circumstance of the case and convicted the
appellant rightly. It is further submitted that the the deceased has committed
suicide due to demand of dowry and harassment caused by the appellant.
However, he has not denied the factum of acquittal of the other co-accused
persons namely Heeralal, Dilip and Vinayak.
10. In view of the aforesaid contentions and arguments advanced by
counsel for both parties, the question for determination in this appeal is as to
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
whether the findings of the learned trial Court regarding conviction as well as
punishment of appellant under Section 306 of IPC is correct in the eyes of law
and facts.
1 1 . On this aspect, the prosecution case mainly relied upon the
statements of Shahebsingh (PW-3), father of the deceased Ramesh (PW-5),
Rangrao (PW-6), neighbour of Sahebsingh, Anant (PW-7). In addition to that
the prosecution has also relied upon the dying declaration of the deceased
which has been recorded before the Executive Magistrate, District Khargone.
As per available record, it is undisputed fact that the deceased Surekha was
daughter-in-law of the appellant, she was married to Dilip, son of appellant in
the year 1996. The said incident happened on 09.12.1998 and as a result
thereof, the deceased expired on 11.12.1998. It is also undisputed fact that
initially, she was treated by Dr. Rajesh Jain and thereafter, she was hospitalized
in Badwani. Dr. Rajesh Jain has specifically stated that on 09.12.1998, the
husband of deceased Dilip got the deceased Surekha for treatment and her
condition was not good and smell of kerosene oil was coming from her body.
As per statement of Dr. Rajesh Jain and his MLC Report, the burn of deceased
Surekha was 100% superficial and deep. As per statements of other witnesses,
it is clearly established that the deceased committed suicide by pouring
kerosene oil on her body. On that basis, the appellant alongwith other coaccused persons are made liable to abate the deceased for committing suicide.
12. On this point, the statement of Shaheb Singh is also significant,
wherein he clearly stated that the deceased Surekha came after marriage to his
house, she narrates that her mother-in-law, father-in-law and Vinayak used to
torture her by demanding money of Rs.20,000/- for the business of Dilip the
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
husband of the deceased. She has also stated that her mother-in-law/appellant
comparatively tortured her excessively and did not give her food. The motherin-law and father-in-law used to beat her. Ramesh Chandra (PW-5), uncle of the
deceased, Rangrao (PW-6) and Anant (PW-7) have also deposed similar
statements in their examination-in-chief. Other witnesses Trilok and Kishore
have also been produced by prosecution in support of their case but they have
not supported the prosecution case and have been declared hostile.
13. The statements of these witnesses have not been remained intact in
their cross-examination. However, in this case, a dying declaration was also
recorded by Executive Magistrate Tehsildar, Smt. Manorama Kosthi (PW-14).
Virtually, the dying declaration (exhibit-P/4), is a relevant piece of evidence on
which the appellant was convicted and other co-accused persons have been
acquitted by the learned trial Court.
14. I have gone through the dying declaration wherein on answer of first
question, the deceased stated that her mother-in-law used to beat her
excessively and she was also embarrassed by her father-in-law due to which,
she set her ablaze by pouring kerosene oil. With regard to her father-in-law and
husband, she stated that they did not harass her, although, her father-in-law
scolded her.
15. I have gone through the whole dying declaration but nothing has been
mentioned regarding abetment. Now, the question is as to whether on such type
of dying declaration, the appellant can be ascertained as a main abettor for
committing suicide.
16. Learned Government Advocate for the State has submitted that as
per Section 113A of Indian Evidence Act, when a woman had committed
suicide, the Court may presume having regard to all other circumstances of the
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
case and it it is shown that she had committed suicide within a period of seven
years from the date of her marriage and that her husband or such relatives of her
husband had subjected her to cruelty, the Court 'may presume'. Here, the word
is used 'may presume'. As per section 4 of the Indian Evidence Act, the Court
may presume a fact, it may either regard such fact as proved, unless and until it
is disproved, or may call for proof of it, where all other co-accused including
husband of the deceased have been acquitted by the learned trial Court, the
Court is required to call the proofs for presuming the fact that appellant/motherin-law of the deceased had abetted the deceased to commit suicide.
17. From the face of record, it is crystal clear that the deceased has
committed suicide within seven years of her marriage. As per the prosecution
story, the demand for dowry has not been found proved by learned trial
Court.
18. So far as the presumption regarding abatement is concerned, the law
laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hansraj Vs. State of
Haryana (2004) 12 SCC 257 is worth referring here :" 1 3 . The question then arises as to
whether in the facts and circumstances of the
case the appellant can be convicted of the
offence under Section 306 I.P.C. with the aid of
the presumption under Section 113 A of the
Indian Evidence Act. Any person who abets the
commission of suicide is liable to be punished
under Section 306 I.P.C. Section 107 I.P.C. lays
down the ingredients of abetment which includes
instigating any person to do a thing or engaging
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
with one or more person in any conspiracy for
the doing of a thing, if an act or illegal omission
takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy and
in order to the doing of that thing, or intentional
aid by any act or illegal omission to the doing of
that thing. In the instant case there is no direct
evidence to establish that the appellant either
aided or instigated the deceased to commit
suicide or entered into any conspiracy to aid her
in committing suicide. In the absence of direct
evidence the prosecution has relied upon Section
113-A of the Indian Evidence Act under which
the
Court
may
presume
on proof
of
circumstances enumerated therein, and having
regard to all the other circumstances of the case,
that the suicide had been abetted by the accused.
The explanation to Section 113-A further
clarifies that cruelty shall have the same meaning
as in Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code
which means:"(a) any wilful conduct which is of such a
nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit
suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life,
limb or health (whether mental or physical) of
the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such
harassment is with a view to coercing her or any
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
person related to her to meet any unlawful
demand for any property or valuable security or
is on account of failure by her or any person
related to her to meet such demand".
14. Unlike Section 113-B of the Indian
Evidence Act, a statutory presumption does
not arise by operation of law merely on proof
of the circumstances enumerated in Section
113-A of the Indian Evidence Act. Under
Section 113-A of the Indian Evidence Act the
prosecution has first to establish that the woman
concerned committed suicide within a period of
seven years from the date of her marriage and
that her husband (in this case) had subjected her
to cruelty. Even if these facts are established
the Court is not bound to presume that the
suicide had been abetted by her husband.
Section 113-A gives a discretion to the Court
to raise such a presumption, having regard to
all the other circumstances of the case, which
means that where the allegation is of cruelty
it must consider the nature of cruelty to
wh i c h the woman was subjected, having
regard to the meaning of word cruelty in
Section 498-A I.P.C. The mere fact that a
woman committed suicide within seven years of
her marriage and that she had been subjected to
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
cruelty by her husband, does not automatically
give rise to the presumption that the suicide had
been abetted by her husband. The Court is
required to look into all the other circumstances
of the case. One of the circumstances which has
to be considered by the Court is whether the
alleged cruelty was of such nature as was likely
to drive the woman to commit suicide or to
cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or
health of the woman."
19. On this aspect, a recent decision of Hon'ble Apex Court rendered in
Kashibai and Ors. Vs. State of Karnataka reported in 2023 LawSuit (SC) 840
relying upon the another judgments by Hon'ble Apex Court passed in the case of
Mangatram Vs. State of Haryana reported in (2014) 12 SCC 595 and Hansraj
(supra) viewed as under :-
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
"15. In Mangat Ram Vs. State of Haryana, this
Court considering the provisions of Section 498A
and 306 of IPC in the light of the presumption
under Section 113A of the Evidence Act, observed
as under: “30. We are of the view that the mere fact that
if a married woman commits suicide within a
period of seven years of her marriage, the
presumption under Section 113-A of the Evidence
Act would not automatically apply. The legislative
mandate is that where a woman commits suicide
within seven years of her marriage and it is shown
that her husband or any relative of her husband has
subjected her to cruelty, the presumption as
defined under Section 498-A IPC, may attract,
having regard to all other circumstances of the
case, that such suicide has been abetted by her
husband or by such relative of her husband. The
term “the Court may presume, having regard to
all the other circumstances of the case, that
such suicide had been abetted by her husband”
would indicate that the presumption is
discretionary. So far as the present case is
concerned, we have already indicated that the
prosecution has not succeeded in showing that
there was a dowry demand, nor would the
reasoning adopted by the courts below would be
sufficient enough to draw a presumption so as to
fall under Section 113-A of the Evidence Act.
31. In this connection, we may refer to the
judgment of this Court in Hans Raj v. State of
Haryana [(2004) 12 SCC 257 : 2004 SCC (Cri)
217] , wherein this Court has examined the scope
of Section 113-A of the Evidence Act and Sections
306, 107, 498-A, etc. and held that, unlike Section
113-B of the Evidence Act, a statutory
presumption does not arise by operation of law
merely on the proof of circumstances enumerated
in Section 113-A of the Evidence Act. This Court
held that, under Section 113-A of the Evidence
Act, the prosecution has to first establish that the
woman concerned committed suicide within a
period of seven years from the date of her
marriage and that her husband has subject her to
cruelty.
Even though those facts are established, the
court is not bound to presume that suicide has been
abetted by her husband. Section 113-A, therefore,
gives discretion to the court to raise such a
presumption having regard to all other
circumstances of the case, which means that where
the allegation is of cruelty, it can consider the
nature of cruelty to which the woman was
subjected, having regard to the meaning of the
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
word “cruelty” in Section 498-A IPC.” 2 (2014)
12 SCC 595
16. So far as the evidence adduced by the
prosecution in the instant case is concerned, in our
opinion the prosecution had failed to adduce any
clinching evidence to enable the Court to conclude
that the appellants- accused had abetted the
deceased to commit suicide. In absence of any
satisfactory evidence having been brought on
record, in our opinion both the Courts below had
committed grave error in holding the appellants
guilty of the offence under Section 306 of IPC.
17. In that view of the matter while upholding the
conviction of the appellants under Section 498A,
we acquit the appellants from the charges levelled
against them under Section 306 of IPC by giving
them benefit of doubt. Since the appellants have
already undergone the imprisonment for a period
of two years for the offence under Section 498A
read with Section 34 of IPC, as directed by the
courts below, it is hereby directed to set free the
appellants forthwith."
20. In view of the aforesaid settled principles laid down by Hon'ble Apex
Court, it is crystal clear that even that the deceased was a lady, committed
suicide within a period of seven years from the date of her marriage and her
husband or such relatives of her husband had subjected her to cruelty, the
Court is not bound to presume that suicide has been abetted by her husband
and such relatives of her husband. Virtually, Section 113A of Indian Evidence
Act, gives wide discretion to the Court to raise such type of presumption with
regard to other all such circumstances of the case.
21. In the case at hand, having gone through the whole dying declaration,
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
some facts came that mother-in-law of deceased has subjected her to cruelty
but she never stated anything regarding abetment for committing her suicide.
She never said that the deceased does not deserve to be alive or she should die.
In this case, husband of deceased himself has taken her to the hospital and he
alongwith his parents had tried to save her life. Hence, only on the basis of
presumption under Section 113A of the Indian Evidence Act, the appellant
cannot be convicted for the offence under Section 306 of IPC. Certainly, since
she has committed cruelty with the deceased, she is liable to be convicted under
Section 498A of IPC. Here, it is pertinent to mention that there is no charge
framed against the appellant under Section 498A of IPC but in view of settled
legal position, the appellant may be convicted for the offence under Section
498A of IPC without framing charge.
22. In this regard, another judgment in M. Shrinivasulu Vs. State of
Andhra Pradesh reported in (2007) 12 SCC 443 , wherein Hon'ble Apex
ordained as under :-
"a person charged and acquitted under Section 304B of
IPC can be convicted under Section 498A without that
charge being there, if such a case is made out"
2 3 . Hence, even the charge has not been framed for the offence
punishable under Section 498A of IPC, if the offence is made out against the
appellant, she may be convicted under Section 498A of IPC instead of Section
306 of IPC.
2 4 . Learned counsel for the petitioner has also contended that all
witnesses are relatives and no independent witness has been produced in
support of prosecution case, hence, on the basis of statements of relatives of
the deceased, the appellant cannot be convicted.
25. Here, it is worth to refer that the said incident of appellant was
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
happened in boundary of house/ close premises, hence, no independent person
is expected to support the prosecution case. That apart, it is well recognized
time honoured principle that now independent person does not want to indulge
themselves in others' matters
26. So far as the relatives of deceased is concerned, certainly, the case is
supported by relatives of deceased but only on account of that, the appellant
has not been convicted. There is specific dying declaration in this regard,
placed by the prosecution. The said dying declaration is intact and has not been
controverted by the prosecution. It is pertinent to mention here that while
deposing dying declaration, the deceased has not alleged relatives and other
members of the family. She has alleged against only her mother-in-law which
fortify the sanctity of her dying declaration. That apart, there is sufficient
material to support the said cruelty against the deceased under Section 498A of
IPC in which, she can be convicted for the offence under Section 498A of IPC.
27. So far as the arguments regarding non-availability of independent
witnesses is concerned, it is well settled that no criminal case can be
overboarded due to non-availability of independent prosecution witnesses. In
this regard, the following verdict of landmark judgment of the Hon'ble Apex
Court rendered in the case of Appa Bhai vs. State of Gujarat AIR 1988 SC
696 is worth referring here as under:
"10.......Experience reminds us that civilized people are
generally insensitive when a crime is committed even in their
presence. They withdraw both from the victim and the vigilante.
They keep themselves away from the Court unless it is inevitable.
They think that crime like civil dispute is between two individuals
or parties and they should not involve themselves. This kind of
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
apathy of the general public is indeed unfortunate, but it is there
everywhere whether in village life, towns or cities. One cannot
ignore this handicap with which the investigating agency has to
discharge its duties. The court, therefore, instead of doubting the
prosecution case for want of independent witness must consider the
broad spectrum of the prosecution version and then search for the
nugget of truth with due regard to probability if any, suggested by
the accused......"
28. In upshot of the aforesaid discussion, in entirety and analysis of the
aforesaid legal position, this Court is satisfied that although the prosecution has
miserably failed to establish the offence under Section 306 of IPC, yet the
evidence available on record, graphically justifies that the appellant can be safely
convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 498A of IPC for
committing cruelty with her daughter-in-law/deceased. Hence, the appeal is
liable to be partly allowed to the extent to set aside the conviction and sentence
passed against the appellant under Section 306 of IPC and instead of that she
can be convicted for the offence punishable under Section 498A of IPC.
29. Accordingly, this criminal appeal is partly allowed and appellant is
convicted under Section 498A of IPC. Now, coming to the part of sentence,
certainly due to cruelty, the deceased committed suicide but looking to the fact
that in this case, the appellant was in custody from 10.02.1999 to 10.12.1999
(304 days) and suffered ordeal of the trial since 1998 and also completed
incarceration period more than 10 months. The age of the appellant is more than
70 years. Therefore, she may be sentenced for the period already undergone. At
this stage, while the appellant has completed the age of 70 years, it does not
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
seem to be proper to send her into jail for further period of sentence. Hence,
under the facts and circumstances of the case, she is convicted only for the
offence punishable under Section 498A of IPC with fine of Rs.10,000/- to be
paid by the appellant within a period of one month. which may be recovered
within a period of 2 months.
30. The fine amount, if already deposited, shall be adjusted subject to
deposit of fine amount within aforesaid period, the bail bond of the appellant
shall be discharged after depositing of the fine amount. If the appellant fails to
deposit the fine amount as stipulated above, she will suffer 1 month of simple
imprisonment in default.
31. The order of learned trial Court regarding disposal of the seized
property stands confirmed.
32. A copy of this order be sent to the concerned trial Court for
necessary compliance.
33. Pending application, if any, stands closed.
Certified copy, as per rules.
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
amit
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 2/2/2024
2:39:07 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review