Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
i.ta-r
,
,-i
t
[ 321e I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original J urisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
W.P.No.36845 of 2017
Between
1. SUJANASHRI GAVIRNENI, Wo Satyanarayana Gavirneni Aged 60 years occ
house hold Rio # 105, Reliance Green, Mokila, Shankarpalli(M) R.R. District.
2. M. N. Praveen Kumar, Narsinga Rao Goud, Age 39 years Occ Business Rio
Plot No 21, Vanita Enclave Near Suryahbhagawan Temple Trimulghery,
Secunderabad.
3. T. Anasuya, W/o T. Sivarama Reddy, Aged 62 years Occ Housewife r/o Plot
No,63, MN Reddy Nagar Near Sri Durga Estate, Jeedimetla (V), Hyderabad.
4. Sanju Giria, Wo Vineet Kumar Giria, Aged 40 years, Occ Housewife H.No.71-3317, Shamkaran Road Ameerpet, Hyderabad.
5. Smt. Meenh Grover, Wo late Jagadish Kumar, Age 59 years Occ Business
F.lat No 407, Agraval Chambers, King Koti, opp Neerushow Room, Hyderabad
6. Sagar Grover, S/o late Jagadish Kumar Age 35 years Occ Busineis W/o Late
Jagadish Kumar Flat No 407, Agraval Chambers, King Koti, opp Neerushow
7. Smt. Meena Grover, Wo Late Jagadish Kumar Age 59 years Occ Business
Flat No 407, Agraval Chambers, King Koti, opp Neerushow Room Hyderabad.
8. Girish Grover, S/o Late Jagadish Kumar Age 35 years Occ Business r/o Flat
No 407, Agraval Chamberc, King Koti, opp Neerushow Room Hyderabad
9. VUay Kumar Patanghe, S/o Eshvtiar Rao Pathanghe Age 73 years r/o Pfot No
28, Vanita Enclave, Tirumalagiri, Secunderabad.
10. M. Murali Krishna Rao, S/o late Venkat Rao Age 69 , Occ RbtO employee Flat
No 102, Apex Residency, Anandnagar Colony, Khairatabad, Hyderabad.
11.V. Deepika, D/o Visweswarayya Age 27 years Occ Housewife Rio Plot No14,
Jupital Colony Sick village road, Secunderabad
12.G. Deepthi, D/o G. Pratap Reddy Aged 29 years Occ Housewife Road No.2.
Green Hills Colony RK Puram, L.B. Nagar, Hyderabad.
13.V. Archana, C/o Dr. V Venkataramulu Aged 30 years Occ Private Job Plot
No.108, Dhanalaxmi colony Road No.3, Mahendra Hills Secunderabad
14.Q. Sunittra, W/o.]$. C_halapati. R_ao C/o. Dr V Venkataramaiah Aged 46 years
Occ Housewife Rio Plot No.108, Dhanalaxmi colony noaU flofl f,Aan6nOrJ
Hills Sec.rnderabad.
15.Kalva Sunanda, Wo Kalva Ashok KurnarAge 61 years Occ Housewife R/o
Plot No.15, Manikanta Nilayam Krishnap-uri C5lony, West-frrtirreOpaity
Secunde'abad
16.P. Mlohan Rao, S/o Late P.Nagabhushanam Age 67 years Occ Business r/o
1-8-4813, Krishna Nagar, pG Road Secunderab5d.
17 -T. Venkateswarlu., s/o singjliah Age
_50 years occ Mastry r/o Vanitha
Cooperative Housi ng societyTiruma lg-i ri Secuhderabad.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. PRL SECY, REVENUE DEpr., HyD, Revenue Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad.
2. The comrnissioner,.suryey, setflement and Land Records, survey Bhavan,
Narayanaguda, Hyderabad. State of Telangana.
3. The Distri:t Collector, Hyderabad.
4. The Tahasildar, Tirumalgiri (M), Hyderabad.
5. The comrnissioner t lnsp_ector General of Registration, and stamps, M.J.
Road, Hyderabad -S0009S.
6. The Sub Flegistrar Bowenpally,. Secunderabad.
7. Ihe Telangana State Wakf Board, Rep. by.its Chief Executive Officer, lm floor
Razzak M anzil, Nampally, Hyderabad'-506001
.
8. Anantula Jaikris_hnt s/g A. Ra-ng_a Nqidu, tgea about 71 years, occ
Business ., Rlo 202, Road No.12, Gun Rock E-nclave securiaeralat.
9. 9.t.V: Bh.agyjr,la11ql, !{o Raguramulu, Aged about 43 years,
r - ----t Occ.
Househould, Rl/o 1-7-661, Rairnagar, fiyaEraUiA.
--
i'
I
10.I. {?gln Molran Rao, s/o Late.-T. sylb^a Rao, Aged about 6g years, occ
Retd. Govt. Seruant R/o N.73, p and r euarters,ttrilitiiari"llvi--'
li,
l
HyderabarC.
I
I
t:
11.Pader Srinivas Yiiqy, s{o fa-der Bho_omaiah,, Aged 52 years, occ
F.mptoree, R/o Frat No.302, Lakshmi Resideircy: streei N;.3, Via;vufir
i
NagarColony,Dilsukhnagar,Hyderabad. -"
i:
ii
t:
I
12.lmtt P. Karnya K-umari, wo p. srinivqs vuay, Aged 4g years, occ
I u s i n e_s s, R/o Fr at No. 302, La ks hm i Resi ie'n cvl
" siietet'ru o. e-,' il iiu flr
li'
i
ll,
Nagar Col,ory, Dilsukhnagar, Hyderabad.
l3.Thangallapally Rajender, s/o Laxmrl
Aged
'r.ilgi.,52 years, occ
Emproyee,. R/o Fral c2, ptor No.55, od _ghary,
VaJii,i
1irffi;i.g,i;i
Hyderabacl.
i;x
lir
ill
ili
,
t;
ll
ir
t'
I
'oF,Tf a!,H;f i,f !#6lJv}si??1ft *??f.f *xi$il,"r"r"r!,:t""".:ire,R/o
,
I
I
I
i
i
I
!
l;.
ti,l
liil
tii il
[illt
15.Gujji Vasantha Rao, S/o Satyanarayana Rao, Aged 57 years, Occ
Business R/o H.No.2-6-1 409, Bhavani Nagar, Hanmakonda; Warangal
District
' 16.T. Sambaiah, S/o Late Venkata Ramanaiah, Aged about 56 years, Occ
Business, R/o Flat No.104, Megna Rama Pushpa Apartment, Road No.6,
West Marredpally, Secunderabad-S00028.
:
17.T. VUay Lakshmi, Wo P. Sambaiah, Aged about 53 years, Occ Housewife
Rfo Flat No.I04, Megna Rama Pushpa Apartment, Road No.6, West
Marredpally, Secunderabad-500028.
18.Meera Mohideen, S/o Peer Mohamed,, Aged about 55 years, Occ
business, R/o Padmavathi Mansion,203, 3rd Floor, SCHB Society, Sikh
Village, Secunderabad-500009.
19.Mrs. Zarina Meeran, Wo Meeran Mohideen, Aged about 55 years, Occ
Housewife, R/o Padmavathi Mansion, 203,3rd Floor, SCHB Society, Sikh
Village, Secunderabad - 500 009
20.G. Usha Rani, Wo Vivian Anthony lssac, Aged about 56 years, Occ
Housewife, FUo Plot No.4, Aruna Enclave, Trimulghery Village,
Secunderabad.
(RR 8 to 20 are impleaded as per Court Order dated 01J2.2022 in l.A.No.
2 and 3 of 2019 respectively).
.....RESPONDENTS
' : Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances.stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue writ or direction preferably Wr.it of Mandamus declaring the letter
no.3MPOlKlzl2011 dt.31-10-2011 and Lr. No. M1/54/RR/ProU84-Supply-1 dt.1012-2013 .(communicated under RTI Act vide letter dated 15-9-2017) of the
respondent no.7 and f\4untakhab no.54lM1lTel-l/RR/84 dt.27-3-2OO4 published in
A.P. Gazette no.22 dt.27-5-2OO4 at page no.599 as illegal, arbitrary, contrary to
Section 22 (A) of Registration Act and violative of principles of natural justice and
violative of Art.14, and 300-A of Constitution of lndia and consequently set aside
the said proceedings to the extent it concerns the lands/plots of the petitioners in
Sy. No. 66/1 situated at Trimulgherry, Secunderabad.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2Q17(WPMP. NOt45751 OF 2017r
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, ine Uign Court mai be pleased to
suspend the operation of the letter no.3MPOlKlZ2011 dt.31 -10-2011 and Lr. No.
M1/54/RR/Prot/84-Supplyl dt.1'0-12.2.013 (communicated under RTI Act vide
letter dt.t5-9-2017) of the respondent no.7 and Muntakhab 1no.54/M1ffel-l/RR184
dt.27-3-2}04 published in A.P. Gazette no.22 dt.27- 5-2004 at page no.599 to the
extent it concerns to the lands of the petitioners in Sy. No. 66/1 situated at
Trimulgherry, Secunderabad pending disposal of writ petition in the interest of
justice.
l.A.No:l gF 20 !e
Petition under section 151 cPc
gfying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fired in support of the petition,
Ih" Higr, court may be preased to
. receive the foilr>wing additionar docum;;ir''";;;'of order
in o.s.No.0s of 2016
and o.s.No.
0f
2016,
Letter
oi-'th"
District
^o7
coilector vide
procgs.No.B2r3gg3r2oog,
dated. zs.og.roog, ano proceedings
vide
No. ULC/SBD/G rtl.S. NO. t/41 3/79
_
from th; J;;"* Estates
Office, Secunderabad
Cantonment, in t//.p.No.35845 of 2017.
counsel for the petitioners : sRr poNNAM
AsHoK GouD
counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 6 : Gp
FoR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.7 : SRI M.A.MUJEEB
H#[v,forthelmpread
Respondent Nos.8 to 10 : SRr p.pANDU
counsel for the rmpread Respondent Nos.l
Between:
RANGA
1 to 20:sRr r.suRyA sATrsH
-i
i
I
1i
1. Gali Niranian Rao- and another, p/o vemaiah,
*yff:,,l-'.o'8i;i
about 47 years, occ.
R6""pi;i' r.ro gbl"'ilE;' Aged
Tas,,i Nasar, - Kharkana,
2' Smt.Gari saritha, wo Gari Niranjan Rao,
Ho usewife, R/o piot wo. g g,
abou_t 41 years, occ.
l"; v; J;;i ru"t"dr, Aged.
?HE *, nr, Secundera bad_03
.PETITIONERS
AND
1' The state of rerangana, Minorities werfarev
,
secretary, secretaiiat,-nyoe;6il
Department, Rep by its principar
vspo,,.,
2' The District Cortector, Hyderabad District at Nampafiy.
3' The Revenue Divisionar officer, Secunderabao
oivision.
4. The Tahsitdar, Tir:umalgiri Mandal, Secunderabad.
5. The Sub Registrar, Bowenpaily, Secunderabad.
txecutive Oflicer.
l, Nampally, Hyderabad, Rep.
7. le_cqSderabad Cantonment Bo:
by its Chief
ria^ ^t F_._ , :
5.p-.$;i;Siliuna;;;6il:il66e1,;T.;I,?",S.9gEi;:,11,1%ffSp"no,
(R7 is impleaded as per Court Order dated 2911112021 in |.A.No.312021l,.
.....RESPONDENTS
\,i i_
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ
of mandamus to declare the action of the respondents in placing the land falling in
Sy.No. 66/1 of Tirumalgiri Village, which is part of G.L.R Sy.No.352 belonging to
Vanitha Cooperative Housing Society, admeasuring Acs.5-1Ogts in prohibitory
register uls 22-A (1) (C) of the Registration Act and not al'lowing the petitioners to
sell the open Plot No. 34/A admeasuring 250 Sq. yards in the layout formed by the
Vanitha Cooperative Housing Society over the said land, on the basis of false
claim of the 6th respondent contrary to the judgment of Commissioner Survey
Settlement and Land Records dated 21111/1983 passed in file No.P5/3434181 and
contrary to common judgment dated 0710212017 passed by the Telangana State
Waqf Tribunal in O.S.No. 512016 and O.S.No. 7 12016, violative of th, provisions of
the Registration Act, illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 14, 300-A of the
Constitution of lndia and to pass such other order(s) as are deemed fit and
proper." in the interest of justice and better adjudication of the writ petition.
(prayer is amended as per Court Order dated 2911112021 in |.A.No.3120211.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2021
Petition'Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated'"ih " i,
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent No. 5 to entertain the registrations over the land falling in
Sy.No.66/1 of Tirumalgiry Village of Vanitha Cooperative Housing Society without
reference.to POB registrar, pending disposal of the writ petition.
|.A.NO:2 OF 2021
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent No. 7th to process the application for sanction of building
permissions over the plots in Sy.No.66i1 of Tirumalgiry Village of Vanitha
Cooperative Housing Society without insisting NOC from respondents No. 2 to 4
and 6, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counselfor the Petitioners : SRI T.SURYA SATISH
:
i
Gounsel for the Respondent No.1 : GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE
Counselfor the Respondent Nos.2 to 5 : GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.6 : SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN
Counset for the lmplead Respondent No.7 : SRI K.R.KOTESWAR RAO
-'-r
.J
W.P.NO: 33938 OF 2024
Between:
Sri. Koppolu Verrkata Chanakya, S/o Koppolu Prasada Rao, Aged 46 Years, Occ.Pvt
Service, R/o 7813 SW Frammy Way, Hillsboro, Oregon 97123, USA presently
H.N0.1 0-5-422, Tukaram Gate, North Lalaguda,Secundrabad
....PETITIONER
AND
1. The Stater of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
(Stamps ilnd Registration Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
2. The Commissioner and lnspector General of Registration and Stamps,
Telangana, Hyderabad.
3. The District Registrar, Hyderabad dist,
4. The Sub-R.egistrar, Sanjeeva Reddy Nagar, Hyderabad District.
5. The Sub-tRegistrar, Bowenpally, Hyderabad dist
6. The Telangana State Wakf Board, rep. By its Chief Executive officer, Razzack
.
lVlanzil, H.rz House, Opp. Public Gardens, Nampally, Hyderabad.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying
that in the
circumstances'rstated in the affidavit filed therewith, the Htgh Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Direction more particularly in the nature of W1it of
Certiorari by calling for the records relating to and in connection with the 4th
Respondent's nefusal order communicated vide Letter No.7/R/SR Nagarl2023
dated 30,10.2023 by refusal No.7l2O23 and quash the same and further direct the
4th Respondent to register and release the document No.P.4212022 executed on
08.04.2022 in respect of in respect of the Partition deed presented by the
petitioner and his family members in respect of Plot No.65, in Sy.No.18 having
admeasuring 240.00 Sq.yds situated at Jai Bharath,Co.Operative Housing Society
Ltd, Tirmulghery, Secundrabad Cantonment Hyderabad dist apart from other
properties as illegal, arbitrary and one without jurisdiction and against the
provisions of laur and contrary rights guaranteed under 300-4 of constitution of
lndia.
!.A.NO:2 OF 202t4
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the Hign Court may be pleased to direct
the 4th responclent herein to register and release the Partition deed pending
document No.P,l2l2022 dated 08.04.2022 presented by the petitioner his famity
members in restrect of Plot No.65, in Sy.No.18 having admeasuring 240.00 Sq.yds
situated at Jai Bharath Co.Operative Housing Society LtJ, Tirmulghery,
Secundrabad Cerntonment Hyderabad apart from other properties, without lnJisting
no-objection cerlificate (Noc) from the 6tl respondent herein.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI V.S.R.M.V.PRASAD SANAKA
Counselfor the Respondent Nos.1 to 5 : GP FOR REVENUE
Counselfor the Respondent No.6 : SRI FARHAN AZAM KHAN
The Court made the following COMMON ORDER
tn
IN THE HTGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MADHAVI DEVI
RTT PETIT oN NO.3
oF 2017
WRTT PETITION NO.28496 0 F 2021
AND
WRIT PETITION NO.33938 OF 2024
DATED:
7 .01.2026
W.P.N o.36t145 of 2017
Between
Sujanashri (iavirneni and l6 others
... Petitioners
AND
The State of Telangana rep. by its principal
Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad and 19 others
... Respondents
OR
ER
I
w.P.l{o.36845 of 2017 has been filed seeking a writ of
Mandamus declaring letter No.3/wpo/Krzlz\tl dr.31.10.201
't
I
I
I
I and
.
.
letter No.M I /54lRR/Prot/84-Supply- I dt. r 0.12.201 3 of respondenr No.7
i
I
:
I
ll
ll
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
and Muntakhab No.54lMl/Tel-I/RR/84 dt.27.03.2004 published in A.P.
Gazette No.22 dt.27.05.2004 at page No.599, as illegal and as contrary
to Section 22A of the Registration Act, 1908 and consequently to set
aside the same and suspend the proceedings to the extent it concerns the
Iands/plots of the petitioners in Survey No.66l1 situated at Trimulgherry
Village, Secunderabad, Hyderabad District and to pass such other order
or orders.
2.
Brief facts leading to the f,rling of W.P.No.36845 of 2017 are that
the land in Survey No.62 of Trimulgherry Village was in the name of
Koh-e-Imam Zamin from 1330 Fasli (1920 AD) up to 1339 Fasli (1929
AD) as per the correspondence available in Tahsil's File No.40/11 of
1343 Fasli. In 1,339 Fasli comesponding to 1929 AD, the land was
resumed by the Government from Koh-e-ImamZamin and it was in the
possession of the Government. In 1351 Fasli, i.e., l94l AD, the
Collector, Aatraf Balda District addressed the Letter No.ll29 to the
Tahsildar North that the land should be auctioned under Laoni rules and
accordingly, auction proposals were submitted for his confirmation. It is
stated that a notification for auction of this land falling in Survey No.62
of Trimulgherry was issued and auction was conducted and one Sri
J
-".t
iz
':r,
:it
:q
m
W.P.No.36845 of2017,
W.P.No.28496 of202l &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
Kalika Prasad became the auction purchaser for Rs.250l- and the auction
was confinned by the Collector vide his lerter No.34l dt.04.03 .L352
Fasli, 'i.e., I g42 AD and the possession of land admeasuring Ac.5.0g
guntas was also delivered to Sri Kalika prasad as per the letter of
Moulvi Syed Mustafa Ali Khan, Collector of Hyderabad Districr
addressed to the Tahsildar North and by letter No. 1642 dated 29 Maher,
1352 Fasli, the Tahsildar informed the Maqdam Patwari of Trimulghepy
Village that higher office of Districr through Letter No.34l dared 04
Bahman 1352 Fasli, the land has been finaily auctior-red through the
three times auction in the name of Mr. Kalika prasad for a sum of
Rs.25Ol- anrl that the auction bidder had deposited the said amount in
the treasury of the District at the Ledger Folio No.l54 dated 2"d
Bahman, 1352 Fasli and thatthe possession of the land be delivered to
the purchaser and accordingly, in Jamabandi of 1352 Fasli, the
alienation ol'the patta be caused in the name of the purchaser and the
proceedings be submitted at the time of Jamabandi. However, without
reference to the above documents, on r8.01.1951, Muntakhab No.l3
1951 was issued inrespectof the land falring in Survey No.62 (old)
of
new
survey No.oozt by the commissioner of Atiyat. It is stated that no
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 o,f 2024
notice and no opportunity was given to Sri Kalika prasad who was
i
already in the possession of the property as pattadar much before the
li
il
proceedings of the Commissioner of Atiyat dt.18.01.1951. It is stated
that at Column No.8 of Muntakhab No. l3 of 195 I , it is mentioned that
by order dt.12.12.r950 of the Additional
,collector of Hyderabad
District, the Inam land was restored in the name of Chilla Hazrat Imam
ZaminAli Moos a RazaAle Salaam perperually and that Syed Ali Zaidi
has been appointed and sanctioned the performance of, service. It is
stated that lhe alleged proceedings dt.12.12.r950 of the Additional
Collector restoring the land back to the Dargah are not available and
fu(her that neither the auction that was conducted nor the confirmation
nor the handing over of possession to the auction purchaser was ever
challenged by the institution. It is stated that on 14.10.1952 Syed
Mohammed Ali, stating to be the Trustee of Koh-e-Imam Zamin, filed a
petition before the Collector, Hyderabad under Telangana Land
Revenue Act, 1317 Fasli stating that during 1331 Fasli, the Inam lands
were taken under Government supervision and that on 18.01.1951
Muntakhab No.l3 of 1951 was issued, wherein along with other survey
numbers, even Survey No.66ll was mentioned and he requested that
r
n
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
necessary corrections be made in the settlement records and the
Collector, Hyderabad, without any notice to Mr. Kalika prasad, had
passed an order on 04.11.1951 directing necessary corrections to be
made in S,ethwar and vusool Baqi of Bandobast in view of the
Muntakhab. It is stated that the Collector did not consider the earlier
, .:
resumption. auction, confirmation of auction and giving of possession to
Mr. Kalika Prasad by the very same office of the Collector. It is stated
that in 1353 Fasli, Survey had taken place and the rectification was
ordered on the basis of the said survey. It is stated that the Collector
could have ordered for rectification of survey erors only if the petition
is filed within two years from the date of settlement and if the period
exceeds 2 years, he could not have entertained such petitions and in this
:
:
case, the Cr>llector order of 1952 is after a lapse of l0 years of such
I
i
l
survey. [t is stated that in the meantime, Mr. Kalika Prasad passed away
ti
ilIt
it
il
and in the 1,ear 1972, the son of Kalika prasad, Mr. Munnalal filed a
ii
lir
petition before the Tahsildar Urban requesting to record his name in the
ir
I
I
i
I
revenue recrrrds and the Tahsildar referred the same to the Collector
stating that old Survey No.62 land admeasuring Ac.5.0g guntas was
auctioned in favour of Mr. Kalika Prasad and that the sale was also
.
\\ \\
W.P.No.36845 of 20t7,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021&
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
confirmed by the collector, but his name did not find place in the
records and he requested for guidance of the Collector in this regard.
Mr. Munnalal was accordingly informed to approach the Collector under
section L5(2) of the Hyderabad Record of Rights in Land Regularion,
1358 Fasli as the petition filed by him cannot be entertained.
Accordingly, Mr. Munnalal approached the collector in File
No.E3ll4793176 under Section l5(2) of the Hyderabad Record of Rights
in Land Regulation, 1358 Fasli for correction of entries in the village
records. It is stated that by order dt.10.02. 1977, the collecror,
Hyderabad District passed an order holding that the faisal patti for the
village for the year 1952-53 was verified and found that the other
proposal of the Tahsildar was sanctioned by Nazim E Jamabandi with an
endorsement that implementation be kept pending. But still, the Tahsil
proposals were irregularly implemented and that Survey No.66ll was
recorded in the name of Koh-e-Imam zamin as pattedar in 1953 and in
1954-55, Khasra Pahani, the name of Koh-e-Mahboob Hussain
continued as pattedar and there is no competent sanction for such an
entry in pahani of 1953 as per faisal patti and hence it was irregular and
unauthorised. It was observed that as per the orders of Alwal Talukdar,
1t
,7
W.P.No.36845 of 20t7,
W.P.No.28496 of 202t &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
Atraf Balde, the implementation of the auction should have been made.
Therefore, the collector directed mutation of the name of Mr. Munnalal,
S/o Mr. Kalika Prasad to be implemented in the village records.
3.
[t is stated that one Mr. Henry Harwood filed a petition under the
provisions of Inam Abolition Act for grant of occupancy rights
including fcr the lands falling under Survey No.66ll claiming that his
father was lraving possession of the said lands and Mr. Munnalal, S/o
Kalika Prase:d filed objection petition to the same and after hearing both
the parties. the Revenue Divisional officer passed an order
j
I
I
dt.25.09.1981 dismissing the said claim petition. The Revenue
l
i
Divisional crflficer, in the order No.c4l5664169,, also observed that the
orders of th': Collector directing correction of settlement records are
i
l
valid and thErt the Tahsildar has already issued
l
ryotwari patta in favour
of the Secrerary, Muslim waqf Board. Aggrieved by the order of the
i
I
I
I
t
Revenue Di,risional officer, Mr. Munnalal filed a revision petition
before the c,rmmissioner, survey settrement and Land Records under
section 166(tr) oi'the Land Revenue act and in this petition, IW. Henry
i
Harwood impleaded himself and one sri Ramchandra
implead petition claiming to have entered into agreement
:
Reddy filed
of sale of the
W.P.No.3684 S of 2ot7
W.P.No.2849A of ZOZI
A
W.P.No.3393 8 of 2024
Iand in question. The
and after hearing all
Waqf Board also filed
the parties, the commissioner
order in Fire No.p5/3434/gr
question was resumed
that the same was arso
was further herd that
the order passed by
ordering corrections of
mand4tory provision of
to the
of the rand and further
under the orders of the
confirmed and that the
co,ector and
sare has become finar.
the co,ector in the year
settrement records
due
ceased to be Inam
that there was no charenge
taking back the possession
held that auction was conducted
the rand in
back in l33g Fasri and
Government land and
land' It was further observed
to it
had passed a deta,ed
dt.2r.r.r9g3 hording rhat
by the Government far
to resumption, it has become
resumption orders or
a co unter being a party
It
I
rg52
was in vioration of the
Section g7 0f the Land
Revenue Act and hence
void
4'
In the meantime, due to
behind 5
the death of Mr. Karika prasad
'daughters and a son, the daughters filed
o'S'No.lgg6 0f tggg on
preliminary decree was
are entitred to 1/6'h
a suit for partition in
rhe fire of the I Additionar
Court at Hyderabad and
:contest,
on
who reft
Judge, city civir
by judgm ent dt.29.I2.lggg,
passed hording that praintiffs
share each and praintiff
a
r ," , r*r;;;,
No.7 and defenounrr", to
-
._
:
.4
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.2849 6 ot202t &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
t
I
are entitled to 1/30th share each and the suit was dismissed
against
plaintiffs 6;rnd 8 to 10 and fi,ar decree was passed on 05.02. Lgglon
basis of a c'rmpromise between the parties. It is stated
the
that on the basis
of the abovt: decree, the names of the daughters as weil as the son
were
incorporatec[ in the revenue records and under registered
sale deed
Nos.294 of 1990, l3l6 of rggr, r3t7 of r99r, 1377 of l99r
and r37g
of 1991, M/s. vanitha cooperative Society had purchased an extent of
Ac'4.00 guntas frorn the daughters and thereafter, it converted
the land
into a layoul with the approval of the Secunderabad Cantonment
videresolution CRB (14) dt.13.03.1990 and sold the plots to
Board
individuals.
It is stated that the layout sanctioned by the Secunderabad Cantonment
Board w&s rl')t released due to civil dispute raised by Sri p.Ramchandra
Reddy in o.S.No.1337 of l9g7 and the suit was decreed in parr
25.04.1994 holding rhar P. Ramchandra Reddy would derive
share of Mr. Munnalal and Mr. p. Ramchandra Reddy
on
only 1/6th
thereafter filed
A.S.No.l34 of 1996 and rhen second appeal in s.A.No.9g0 of
2002,
which were both dismissed on 05.03. 2004 and 2r.06.2oo5respectively.
Later, anothe' suit in o.S.No. t2 of zo05 filed by one
and her children with a plea to declare O.S.No.
Mrs. Ganga Devi
1337 ofl9g7 as null and
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
void and to divide the property into 7 shares, was also decreed on
28.01.2008 ex parte, but since the society was not made apafty to the
same, the society filed first appeal in C.C.C.A.No.20L of 2009 before
this Court and the same was allowed on 30.04.2011, against which SLP
(C) Nos.l98l7 of 201 I and 21342 of 201 1 were filed and both were
dismissed on 28.07.2017 .
5.
[t is submitted that the petitioners herein and also respondents 8 to
17 are purchasers of the plots from M/s. Vanitha Cooperative Housing
Society and are in possession of their respective plots and while so, the
Chief Executive Officer of the Waqf Board addressed the impugned
letters dt.31.10.2011 and 10.12.2013 ro the Sub-Regisrrar Office,
Bowenpally not to entertain any registration over the land on the ground
that the said land is Waqf land and to place the said land under
prohibitory list under Section 22A of the Registration Act, 1908. In the
meantime, Muntak{rab No.54 dt.27.03.2004 was issued. The
Government acquired Ac.55.10 guntas of land in Survey Nos.36/1 ,3911.,
3612, 39/2, 45, 43/1, 4312, 4411, 44/2, 4011, 4012
& 4013 for defence
purposes and there is a reference to Muntakhab No.13 dt.18.01.1951
therein and it is further observed that the balance of land under
r
,:
:--.
W.P.No.36845 of 2Ol7 '
ix
W.P.No.28496of 2021&
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
t1
of the Waqf Board' The
Muntakhab Irio.I3 is under the direct control
said Muntaklab was published in official Gazette
The letters o1 the waqf Board dt.31.10.2011
the Gazette notification No.2 2 dt.27.05.2004
No'22 dt'27'05'2004'
and l0'l-t'2013 as well as
are challenged in this Writ
Petition.
6.
W.p.lrlo.2g4g6 of 2021 is fited by two of the
purchasers of the
plots who had approached the Secunderabad cantonment
permission to construct a residential house and
Board for
the petitioners therein
were infornred that the permission cannot be
granted due to the
impugned (iazette notification of 2004 and
therefore, challenging the
actiorr of th,: respondents in placing the tand
falling in survey No'66/1
of Trimulgherry village belonging to M/s. vanitha cooperative
Housing Society admeasuring Ac.5.10 guntas
in prohibitory list under
section 22,\(L)(c) of the Registration Act, and
in not allowing the
petitioners r.o sell the open Plot No.34lA admeasuring
in the layort due to the false claim of the waqf
250 square yards
Board as illegal and
arbitrary,tt,is Writ Petition has been filed'
'arD \r,
'-, i j;
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
t2
7.
similarly, one Jai Bharath cooperative Housing Society Limited,
Trimulghelry, Secunderabad Cantonment had purchased certain extent
of land from one of the daughters of Kalika prasad and a person has
purchased a plot from the society and the said person died subsequently
and her successors partitioned the subject plot and presented the
partition deed before rhe sub Registrar, sanjeeva Reddy Nagar,
Hyderabad District (respondent No.4) for registration, but the same was
refused on the ground that the said property is covered under prohibitory
list as it was claimed by the Telangana state waqf Board (respondent
No.6). Challenging the refusal, the said persons filed w.p.No.3g20g of
2022 which was disposed of vide orders dt.l2.lz.z02z direcring
respondent No.4 therein to process the pending document No.4212022
without insisting for 'no objection certificate' from respondent No.6 and
to complete the process of registration duly complying with the
Registration act, 1908 and the Indian Stamp Act, lg99'and that the
registration of the subject document shall be treated as a provisional one
so far as Schedule B property of the partition deed is concerned and that
the same would also be subject to the result of the main Writ petition. It
is stated that in spite of the directions dt. 12.12.2022 in w.p.No.3g20g of
E
;i
:,
.:
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496of2O2l &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
,.I
.l
,l,;l
',i
I
l3
I
I
2022, respondent No.4 failed to register the partition deed in favour of
the petitioner and other farnily members and therefore, the petitioner
filed a cont.empt petition against respondent No.4 and thereafter,
respondent |1o.4 passed an order dt.30.10.2023 refusing to register the
document. Crallenging the same, W.P.No.33938 of 2024 has been filed.
8.
Since the land in all the 3 Writ Petitions was in new Survey
No.66l1 of Trirnulgherry Village and it was placed in the prohibitory list
under Section 22A of the Registration Act, 1908 on the ground that it is
claimed by the Waqf Board as a waqf land by virtue of Muntakhab
No.54lM1/Tt:l-I/RR/84 dt.27.03.2004 published in Gazette No.22
dt.27.05.20011 at page No.599, all the three Writ Petitions were clubbed
together and were listed before this Court for hearing.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioners, while reiterating the above
submissions which are made in the writ affidavits as recorded above,
also placed rr:liance upon the following judgments
I
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of202l &
W.P.No.33938 of 2O24
t4
(l) B. Gowra Reddy vs. Government of Andhra pradesh,
Revenue Departmentr
(2)Sadiq AIi Topiwala and another vs. state of relangana
rep. by its Principal secretary, Department of Municipal
Administration and urban Development, Hyderabad and
others2
10. He submitted that in the case of B. Gowra Reddy vs.
Government of Andhra Pradesh, Revenue Department (l supra),
this Court has observed that in the absence of a proper survey with
notices to all concerned under Section 4 of the waqf Act, 1954, the
notification of the waqf property is not valid.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioners has further placed reliance
upon the judgment given by the Telangana State waqf Tribunal in
o.s.No.5 of 2016 and o.S.No.7 of 2016 in respect of survey Nos.1g/l
aand l8/2 old Survey No.l7, wherein Muntakhab No.l3 of 1951 was
\
held to be invalid on the ground that since the Survey Commissioner,s
t
zooz 1s1 ALT 439
' W.P.Nos.22876 and 22921 of 2024 dt.04.03.2025
,:7
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
report as c(,ntemplated under Section 4 of the Waqf Act is not furnished,
it cannot b: held that the subject land belonged to the Waqf Board and
therefbre, \ilaqf Tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain the suits. The
learned counsel therefore submitted that the decision in the case of B.
Gowra Reddy Vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh, Revenue
Department (1 supra) would apply to this case as well and since there
was no survey conducted as contemplated under Section 4 of the Waqf
Act, I 954, the Gazette Notification is not sustainable.
12: In all the 3 Writ Petitions, the Waqf Board has filed a counter
affidavit claiming the land to be belonging to the Waqf Board by virtue
of Muntakhab No.54lM1/Tel-l/RR/8
dt.27.03.2004 published in AP
Gazette No.22 dt.27.05.2004 at page No.599. It is further stated that
Nazim-e-Atiyat had issued Muntakhab No.l3 on 18.11.1951 showing
the old survey numbers as service Inam land as ChillaKohe Imam-eZamin and keeping in view of the said Muntakhab containing service
Inam lands of Ac.71.03 guntas situated at Tirumalagiri Village, a
Muthawalli was also appointed to perform the service to the Institutions
vide Board of Revenue (LR & S) AP, Hyderabad vrde No.NA4l499l75
dt.16.09.19,75. Therefore, according to the Waqf Board, Survey
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
Nos'66/1 and 6612 mentioned in the Gazette are confirrned
as Service
Inam lands of the subject institution and was communicated
to the
Collector, Hyderabad District for its implementatibn and as per
Khasara
pahani for 1954-s5, survey Nos.66ll and 66/2 are classified
as Mafi
Inam lands (Service Inam). It is further submitted that the waqf
were acquired by the special Deputy collector, Hyderabad
purpose and cornpensation amount in respect of the said
lands
for Defence
acquired waqf
lands has also been paid to the waqf Board by the sDC L.A (Defence)
Hy$erabad which subsequently came under the administrative
controlof
.
Ranga Reddy District vide reference No.J4lll0l/lg7g dt.ZLo3.19g3
and therefore, it cannot be disputed that the subject service Inam
lands
belonged to the waqf Board. It is further submitted that the name
of
Kohe rmam-e-zamin is also found incorporated in the pahani for the
year 1952-53 by the Revenue Department as Mafi Inam i.e., land
covered by this institution. It is further submitted that the claim
petitioners that the land belonged to Mr. Kalika prasad is
of the
incorrect
because Mr. Kalika Prasad did not appear before the Nazim Atiyat
when
Inam enquiry was conducted and Muntakhab No.13 dt.1g.11.1951
was
issued in the name of the waqf institution and Muthawalli was
::,:
/.77
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
t7
appointed by the then Board of Revenue vide orders dt.16.09.1975. It is
stated that the petitioners are raising the issue after a period of 65 years,
i.e., from 1951 to the date of filing of, W.P,No ,36845 of 2017 on
31.10.2017. As regards the order of the Commissioner, Survey
settlement and Land Records, A.P., Hyderabad dt.2l.ll.r983, it is
submitted :hat though he has declared the auction confirmed by the
Collector as valid but at the same time, the Muntakhab dt.18.ll.l95l
issued by }.lazim Atiyat has not been disturbed. It is further submitted
that the orders dt.21.1i.1983 were passed under a revision petition filed
under the RoR Act, 1971 for correction of entries in Column Nos.13 and
14 of Khasra Pahani for the year I 954-55 and the correction of entries in
Khasra Pahani was not ordered, but simply the auction was confirmed
by the Collr:ctor and therefore, the same is not applicable to and binding
on the waqf Board. It is submitted that Muntakhab No.13 of l95l was
issued under the orders of Nazim E Atiyat and they have become final
under Secti,rn 13 of the Atiyat Enquiries Act, lglz.It is submitted that
M/s. Vanitha Cooperative Housing Society is claiming under t!.
registered srlle deeds executed by 5 daughters of Mr. Kalika prasad and
that the said sale deeds are null and void an initiosince the property was
\
,
,
,
,i :,, 1..:,
,,,, ,,
.;. .... :. .r', t..';i",",#r**.:ilir..i*j:+i,..-;,.
Ii
i:
li
i:
li
ij
ii
il
ii
il
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496of2oT b.
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
i!
I
,i
:i
al
l
:
the Waqf land by virtue of Muntakhab No.13 of 1951 dt.18.01.1951 and
i
:l
the daughters of late Kalika Prasad were having no valid title over the
said service Inam land. As regards the orders in O.S.No. 1886 of 1989 on
the file of the I Additional City Civil Court, Hyderabad, it is stated that
the said decree is in respect of the parties thereto and Waqf Board is not
made a party thereto and therefore, the same is not binding on the Waqf
Board. It is further submitted that as per the observations of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.6336 of 2021 dt.28. 10.2021,
any dispute about the Waqf property has to be agitated before the Waqf
Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Waqf Act, 1995 and
therefore, W.P.No.3 6845 of 2017 is not maintainable. He also refened
to G.O.Ms.No.15, Minority Welfare Department dt.22.09.2020 auro
locking the registration of all the Waqf properties in the State and
prohibited registration of such properties under Section 22A of the
Registration Act, 1908 and also that the Government issued directions to
all the Panchayats and Municipal authorities not to issue any
construction permission in respect of Waqf lands. Further, the learned
Standing Counsel placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Madanuri Sri Ramachandra Murthy
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
vs. Syed Ja lal3. Therefore, the waqf Board prayed for dismissal of all
of these Writ Petitions.
13. Havinll regard to the rival contentions and the material on record,
this Court finds that there is no dispute that initially rhe subject land was
Inam land and subsequently tnam was cancelled and the land was taken
over by the (iovernment and therefore, it became Government land and
the same was put to auction sale by the Go'emment and one Mr. Kalika
Prasad has prurchased the same in public auction and the sale
was
confirmed anrj he was also put in possession of the subject land.
Though
the waqf Bo.rd is claiming that the waqf land was resumed in
the year
1951 and M,ntakhab No.13 dt.rg.0r.r95r was issued, there
proceedings *nder which the said land has been resumed.
Except for
mentioning the date of the document in the impugned Muntakhab
dt.27.03.2004, there is no evidence whatsoever. Further,
learned single: Judge of this court in the case of B.
Gowra Reddy vs.
enquiry under Section 4 of the waqf Act after issuing
'1zotz; ti scc t7r.
No.54
as held by the
Government of Andhra pradesh, Revenue Department (l
concerned pat,:edar or possessor of the subject
are no
supra), an
notice to the
land is necessary and in
t
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
the absence of such an enquiry, the consequent Gazette notification
is
not valid. The relevant paragraphs in the case of B. Gowra Reddy vs.
Government of Andhra Pradesh, Revenue Department (1 supra) are
reproduced hereunder.
*31. If this is con.strued
as the report of the Survey
commissioner, then the purpose of incorporatton of section 4 o.f the
Act ts frustrated. It is only a form prescribed
for registering a u,alc1[
But what is required to be done by the survey commissioner is not to
enter the wakf as such and he is bound to enquire whether the
property is a wakf property or not. He is also empowered to conduct
the enquiry as was obs'erved by the supreme Court in the dercisions
referred to above. Mere filling of columns would not amount to report
of the survey commissioner so as to bind the petitioners. Moreover, it
is not in dispute that no notice was ever given to the occupants, who
were recorded as such in the revenue register. Admittedly, the report
was of 1967 by which ttme the petitioners were not the purchasers.
They came into ptcture at a later point of time. But, even then rhe
enquiry ought to project as to the notice having been given to the
persons. Even according to the reports submitted by the Deputy
Tahsildar and also the remarks made by the survey commissioner
one Lal<shmaiah was in actual cultivation, but according to the
Deputy commtssioner Laxmaiah was in tllegar occupation. Be that as
it may, a notice was necessary to be given to the person who is in
occupation. But, there is no such record forthcoming as to what type
of notice was issued to the porties qnd what type of enquiry was
conducted. The report of the Deputy Tahsildar cannot be construed as
an enquiry report nor the proforma for the survey of wakf properties
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.3393 8 of 2024
2l
can be i'reated as o report of the Survey Commissioner. The report as
such har to conform to the requirements of Section 4 of the Act as has
becn held b1'the Supreme Court in the catena of decisions referrecl to
above. tt is also noticed.from the counter that the subject matter of the
propertu wa,s endou,ed b), the ov,ner of the land one Abbas Ali Khan
into the Wakf Board in the year 1968 and the same was included in
the list of walcf properties and the same was published in the gazettee
dated 9.2.1989 along with other properties endowed by the sante
person. If this if to be accepted, it has to be held that the Wakf u,as
register,;dfor thefirst tirne in l968 and there could not have been any
report cf the Wctkf Cornmissioner in 1967. Further the requirements
under Section 25 oJ- the Wakf Act 1954 have to be complted with.
'I'here is not aven an iota of proof oJ-dedication
by Abbas Alt Khan nor
is there ony Wakf deed. It is very much doubtful whether Abbas Ali
Khan was alive in 1968 as can be seen from the Judgment of II
AclrJirion,al, City Civil Court in O.5.No.368/69 dated 31.3.1982 fited
bS, one z'bdul Qavt against Laxmaiah and others. When such statutory
requirenrcnts ore not followed, the further question that falls for
consideratiort is whether still the petitioners are required to approach
the appropriate Tribunal or they can ogitate under Article of the
Constitutton of India.
32. It is true that under Sectton 83 of the Act any dispute
arising c,ut of wakf properties can he agitated only before the Tribunal
constituted under the Act. But, in the instant cases, the very principal
requirenrent of nottce and conducting enquiry as envisaged under the
Act are .lacking. Therefore, the question of driving the petitioners to
the Trikmal would not arise. Admittedly, the petttioners have made
out their occupation rights from Mr. Rangaiah's possession and
thereafter Mr. Lakshmaiah and they have purchased the land under
W.P.No.36845 of 20ti,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
registered sale deeds and that too after obtoining
permission.from the competent authority and it
i.; arso one of the
contentions of the petirioners that they hat,e acquired
posses.sion. But, I am not inclinecl to adjudicate
appropriate
title by adverse
the same inasmuch as
I am only concerned with the validity of the nori,fication published
the Gazette on 9-2-t989. The decision referred to
counsel for wakf Board that the petittoners have
in
by the rearned
to approach rhe
Tribunal or the civil Court, as the case mu), be, even
afrer the expiry
of one year period after the publication of gazette notification
is n.t
applicable to the present cases, as that situation ,,ould
not arise
inasmuch as when the notice itserf is racking and
no purpose wiil be
served by approaching the Tribunal or civil court.
It is also to be
noted that the report of the survey Commissioner sent
by the
Government to the r{okf Board has no aulomatic acceptance.
requtred to examine such report before publishing the
stqtutory obligattan is also totally lacktng in this case.
violation of statutory provisions is made out, ir is alv,ays
parties to approach this court under Article 226
India. Admittedly, as con be seen
tt is
list. This
wen the
open to the
of the constttution o.f
from various documents fired by
both the parties in these matters, nothing has been established
sustain the contention that the enquiry was conducred
to
as required
under section aQ) of the Act. In such a sttuation, it cannot
be said
that the impugned noti"/ication is binding on the petitioners and
accordingly, the petitioners are entitled to challenge the same
as it is
illegal and not enforceable as far as the petitioners are concerned.
Accordingly, I have to reject the contention raised on beharf
of the
lltakf Board and also the Government in this regard.
33- It is also to be noted in this regard that though the llrakf'
Board has been contending thtat the properry in question is a wakf
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021&
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
:.
property, which was nottfied in the Official Gazette as
early as in
1989,(but)itissurprisingtonotethattilltodaynoactionhasbeen
recovery of
initiarcrJ either for evicting the petitioners or for
possession oJ the wakJ properly and no proceedings
were initiated
befor,z the T'ribunal constitured under the Act. None
of the revenue
recordsevenwhisperaboutthepropertyasbelongingtoWalcfBoard.
the
It appears thot the Wakf Board has filed an appeal only against
orderofgrttntingocalpancyrightstothepetitioners,ondthattoo
afteroneantthalfdecadesv,hichispendingbeforetheappellate
Under
authtlrily ort vuhich I am not inclined to tnake any comments,
that the notdication
these circuntstances, I have to necessarily hold
not valid
publshed by the wakf Board in the Gazette on 9-2-1989 is
sni ,the strme is nol binding on the petitioners. Accordingly, it is set
asidet as far as the petitioners are concerned. so .far
as the relief for
quashing the proceedings pending before the appellate authority
to do
under the lttants Abolition Act is concerned, I am not inclined
respective rights before
so. lt is opett for the por:ri^ to agitate their
the ctpproPriate authoritY. "
14. This judgment has been confirmed by the Division Bench of this
Court in various cases and the Hon'ble Supreme Court also
confirmecL the above position. Therefore, in this case,
has
since there is no
enquiry crtnducted under Section 4 of the Waqf Act prior'to
issuance of
Munthaktrah No.13 0f 1951, the Gazette Notification has to
be held to
be invalicl. Further, even though the Waqf Board was a party before the
Commissioner of Land Records and the Commissioner has held that the
W.P.No.3684 5 of 2017.
W.P.No.28496 ot}}2t &
W.P.No.3393 8 of 2024
auction sare in favour of Sri
therefore, corrections have to
Karika prasad has been confirmed
be made accordingly, the waqf
not chosen to charenge the said
has held that without the survey
under Section 4 of the waqf Act,
have not raised objection, arso
cannot be sustained as the compensation
Housing Society was approved by
Board and but for the letters written
orders of the commissioner, Land
sadiq Ali Topiwara and another
Principal secretary, Department
urban Development, Hyderabad
by
would have been compreted. As the
Records has become final and has
not
Board and this court arso in the case
consideration the rerevant facts
and
in Survey No.66l1. Further the layout
the waqf Board, the registration
been challenged by the waqf
was for land in Survey
43lt? 43/2? 411t, 44,f2, 40/1,40/2
formed by M/s. vqnitha cooperative
the Secunderabad cantonment
1954,
officer has paici compensation to
the waqf Board and that the petitioners
40/3 and no land was acquired
arso
is not varid. The contention of the
waqf Board that the Land Acquisition
Nos.36ll ,39/1, 36/2, 3g/2, 45,
Board has
order. Further, the waqf Tribunal
the notification of waqf property
and
of
vs. state of Terangana rep. by its
of Municipar Administration and
and others (2 supra) has taken into
which are present in this case before
,..',.:..,
i;
:i
iil
ili
tl!
It
iit
il
I
ii I
W.P.No.36845 of 2017,
W.P.No.28496 of 2021 &
W.P.No.33938 of 2024
directing the Municipality to grant building permission to the petitioners
therein, this rlourt is of the opinion that the Waqf Board cannot claim
the property on its own and therefore placing of the subject land in the
prohibitory list under Section 22A of the Registratiol Act, 1908, is not
warranted. The irnpugned orders are therefore set aside.
15. With these observations, these Writ Petitions are allowed. No
order as to costs.
16. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, in these Writ Petitions
shall stand closed.
SD/.C. DEEPIKA
ISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SEGTION OFFICER
\
To
t
to
,-":rtr"i:1, .:.
Kt
t
HIGH COIJRT
DATED i2-,710112026
,'"
\
COMMONI ORDER
WP.Nos.36845 OF 2017,
28496 0F 2021 AND
33938 of 12024
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUTCOSTS.
t1
""e
X6
3 10 rtg tffi
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review