Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/sugunamma-and-ors-vs-the-state-of-karnataka-and-ors-20260203/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Sugunamma and Ors vs The State of Karnataka and Ors

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Karnataka High Court
Date
3 February 2026
Case No.
WP 202133/2024
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Pradeep Singh Yerur
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

-1- ! $ % " "# & ! ! " ' (! !! ! !! NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA ! " ! # $ !! %# & ' $ # ) -2- # $ ())) # # & $ ' ())) ! # ) ) $$ ) ( # $$ ) " $$ ) $ " -3- * $ % & " $ ! $ $ * # ' $ # ' # )) ) ( # # + $ ( $ $ $ , ( ## # # )( ) # # # " ' ) ! $ $ # )( ) ! $ , - $ $ $ ## ( ) # ' $ # $ # # * . . $ $ , ) * * . )! *( $ ) ) ) ) ** . " ) ) $" # / $ " # # # ) ) -4- 012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674=2 244>17? 504 86996@17? =491482 ! "#$ $%$$ ) - . / & "' %# $%$( * +,- ! . ! ! "#$ $%$$ & - . ! - ! 2 3 ! ! "' %# $%$( ! 0 .+ ! 3 " ! ! ! . 0 3 & $"6 7 7 8 "'" " " : ! %" 6'+6#& %) %; "66' 0 3 & ;; 7 0 3 & ;6 7 < . : 1/ 2 3 %( $%""+"$ 2 3 %) $%""+"$ . & $%+"%+$%""/ ! ! ! ! ! ! = 5 12 A BA24 68 94A=74: B6C7249 50A5 345151674=2 A=4 17 34AB48C9 3622422167 BC951DA5167 A7: 47E6<F475 68 504 9A7: ;4A=17? ?C75A2 C=D4< C=D4< . F4A2C=17? * . . F4A2C=17? ! AB=42 A7: ( -5- ?C75A2 ;650 215CA54: A5 17?A7A>0A7A 4=?4=A 6;91 G A7: A1B0C= A7: A?=1BC95C=A9 9A7:2 ;4A=17? C=D4< C=D4< * . F4A2C=17? F4A2C=17? 215CA54: A5 "AF;A9A:1771 A1B0C= 6::1 199A?4 AB=42 ?C75A2 AB=42 !( ?C75A2 199A?4 4=?4=A 6;91 G A7: 7 504 ?=6C7: 50A5 504 2A1: 3=634=5142 A=4 A7B425=A9 3=634=5142 68 345151674=2 04=417 A7: 674 4D1 :AC?054= 68 345151674= ;650 A7: 21254= 68 345151674= A7: ! @06 :14: 17 504 <4A= 04= F6504= 345151674= =F19A )) 94AD17? ;4017: A2 A 94?A9 041= 5 12 504 8C=504= B675475167 68 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674=2 12 50A5 A854= 504 :4A50 68 674 4::< 17 504 <4A= A=A21F0A ** )! 17?A7A>0A7A 6::1 A=A21F0A @06 12 504 0C2;A7: 68 345151674= A7: 8A504= 68 345151674= @199 :A54: ) 4::< 2 6 ** A7: ! ;A24: 67 504 4H4BC54: ;< 01F 504 9A7:2 68 199A?4 ?65 FC5A54: 17 504 7AF4 68 345151674=2 D1:4 * *( :A54: ) ) ** A7: 7AF42 68 504 345151674=2 @4=4 8C=504= B6==4B54: A7: 4754=4: 04=4A854= 7AF4 68 504 -6- 345151674= @A2 FC5A54: 17 504 =4D47C4 =4B6=:2 8C=504= B67547:4: 50A5 674 AD15=AFFA 5 12 :AC?054= 68 A=A<A7A 4::< =421:17? 17 A1B0C= @06 3A224: A@A< 67 ) A5 199A?4 ) ) C7EA7A0A991 9A7:2 68 C=D4< A7: A1B0C= A7: ?65 504F FC5A54: A7: A9147A54: 504 ! A1B0C= :123C54: 504 A7: ( 68 4=?4=A 2AF4 17 504 7AF4 68 674 AFAB0A7:=A 345151674=2 A33=6AB04: 504 ::15167A9 A5 A1B0C= 17 )* 199A?4 4::< 4716= G 47B4 1D19 "C:?4 ))* A7: 6;5A174: A EC:?F475 A7: :4B=44 17 5041= 8AD6C= ;A24: 67 504 @199 ! A7: 5 12 8C=504= B67547:4: 50A5 67 ! =1;C7A9 ) * A1B0C= B67:CB54: 3=6B44:17?2 =49A517? 56 8AF19< 3=634=5142 68 345151674=/2 8A504= A7: 8A504=/2 ;=6504=2 $C=504= B6754751672 A=4 =A124: @150 =4?A=: 56 674 AD15=AFFA @06 12 2A1: 56 0AD4 8194: A76504= A3391BA5167 ;486=4 22125A75 6FF1221674= 504 9A7: =4B6=:2 17 C=D4< A1B0C= C=D4< * A1B0C= 86= FC5A5167 68 * 17?A7A>0A7A 68 "AF;A9A:1771 42367:475 22125A75 199A?4 6::1 G A7: 6FF1221674= -7- 3A224: A7 6=:4= C7:4= 4D47C4 B5 *( 4B5167 !( & ' 68 A=7A5A>A A7: &04=417A854= =484==4: 56 A2 I504 @1506C5 122C17? 7651B4 56 504 345151674= B5J' 56 ! A==A<17? 345151674= 6 ! @150 :4B4158C9 7AF4 17 6=:4= 56 :43=1D4 24=D4 01F 42367:475 7651B4 3=6B44:17?2 A854= 504 :4A50 68 AD15=AFFA 3A224: ) 4==6746C2 6=:4= :A54: # ) A7: * =42367:475 0A2 1F394F4754: 504 2AF4 50=6C?0 FC5A5167 475=142 04 2A1: 1F3C?74: 6=:4= A7: 2C;24GC475 6=:4=2 @4=4 GCA204: ;< 6 6=:17A54 )( ) A7: =4FA7:4: 504 FA554= ;AB> 56 504 =42367:475 56 ;=17? 94?A9 =43=42475A51D42 ) )( 68 9A54 47B0 ) A7: 6C=5 D1:4 6=:4= :A54: AD15=AFA 67 =4B6=: A7: 3A22 A33=63=1A54 6=:4=2 12 8C=504= B67547:4: 50A5 A854= 504 =4FA7: 504 345151674=2 0AD4 24=D4: 504 B63< 68 504 6=:4= 56 =42367:475 1F394F475 504 2AF4 50=6C?0 I 6C=5 B67547:4: 50A5 6 ! 56 6:C94J =42367:475 :481A7B4 A7: 767 B6F391A7B4 68 504 6=:4= 68 5012 6C=5 -8- @1506C5 ;=17?17? 504 94?A9 =43=42475A51D42 68 :4B4A24: 345151674= 67 =4B6=: 3C=2CA75 56 504 A3391BA5167 FA:4 ;< A 501=: 3A=5< + 25A=54: 8=420 3=6B44:17?2 17 =4234B5 68 504 2C;E4B5 3=634=5142 68 504 6=:4= 3A224: 17 ) ( ) 6=:4= 04 345151674=2 04=417 A=4 GC42516717? 3A224: 6FF1221674= D1:4 A7: ;< # ;< =42367:475 =:4= :A54: FA>17? 24D4=A9 )( 6504= 22125A75 ) ! A5 774HC=4 2C;F1221672 B6754751672 A2 3C5 86=50 17 504 34515167 A7: 244>17? 56 245 A21:4 504 6=:4= A7: 86= A FA7:AFC2 56 =4256=4 504 4A=914= 475=142 FA:4 17 504 7AF4 68 504 345151674=2 > ! 94A=74: ::15167A9 6D4=7F475 :D6BA54 =43=4247517? 504 =42367:475 25A54 D404F4759< B67547:2 50A5 504 3=42475 34515167 12 765 FA175A17A;94 741504= @6C9: 15 ;4 2C25A17A;94 17 D14@ 68 504=4 ;417? A7 A954=7A51D4 4881BAB16C2 =4F4:< A2 34= 4B5167 !( &!' 68 B5 ( 4A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 3=1DA54 =42367:4752 A926 FA>42 A 21F19A= 2C;F122167 B67547:17? 50A5 5012 -9- 34515167 @6C9: 765 2C=D1D4 86= B6721:4=A5167 ;650 67 F4=152 A7: 67 9A@ 17 D14@ 68 504 8AB5 50A5 504 6=:4= 50A5 12 GC4251674: A=1242 6C5 68 22125A75 4B5167 6FF1221674= =42367:475 !( & ' 68 504 B5 04=486=4 504 345151674=2 @6C9: 0AD4 56 A33=6AB0 504 A33=63=1A54 86=CF B0A9947?4 6=:4= 6FF1221674= @01B0 12 GC4251674: 04=417 A5 0AD4 345151674=2 04A=: 94A=74: 22125A75 774HC=4 B6C7249 86= 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 3=1DA54 =42367:4752 A7: 504 94A=74: ::15167A9 6D4=7F475 :D6BA54 86= 504 5A54 33A=4759< 15 12 765 17 :123C54 50A5 504 B0A9947?4 17 504 3=42475 @=15 34515167 12 56 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 504 3A224: C7:4= 22125A75 4B5167 12 3A224: C7:4= 6FF1221674= =42367:475 !( & ' 68 504 4B5167 B5 047 A7< 6=:4= !( & ' 68 504 B5 504=4 12 A7 3=6D12167 68 =4D12167 A?A1725 504 2A1: 6=:4= C7:4= !( &!' 68 504 3=6D121672 68 B5 4B5167 5 @6C9: ;4 =494DA75 56 4H5=AB5 504 4B5167 !( 68 504 B5 @01B0 =4A:2 A2 C7:4= - 10 - "(# + ?"@ ! : ?$@ .+ ! * ! ! ?)@ ?#@ 0 ! . ! - "$6 .+ ! ! ! ! ! . A 1 ! . > ! ! - ! 0 ! ! "$6 "$5 *! . . . ! ! . . . ?(@ * 0 ! & - ! = * 04 345151674= 0AD17? 765 B0A9947?4: 504 6=:4= 22125A75 6FF1221674= A7: 6FF1221674= ;486=4 0AD17? 8194: 43C5< 3=42475 34515167 17D6>17? 504 @=15 EC=12:1B5167 C7:4= =51B942 2AF4 672515C5167 7:1A ( A7: @6C9: FA175A17A;94 A2 04 @6C9: 0AD4 56 A33=6AB0 504 6FF1221674= C7:4= 4B5167 !(&!' 68 504 B5 ;4 43C5< ;486=4 - 11 - A33=6AB017? 5012 6C=5 04 :4B12167 68 504 8C99 ;=A7B0 68 6C=5 17 504 BA24 68 =436=54: 17 @150 504 36@4=2 68 504 &!' 68 504 B5 :4A92 4D12167A9 6C=5 C7:4= 4B5167 !( 04 2AF4 @6C9: ;4 A3391BA;94 17 504 3=42475 BA24 67 0A7: ) 04=486=4 :6 765 817: A7< ?66: ?=6C7: 6= B6?475 =4A267 56 1754=84=4 17 504 3=42475 BA24 A2 504 345151674=2 @6C9: 0AD4 56 ;4 =494?A54: 56 504 A33=63=1A54 86=CF 56 B0A9947?4 504 6=:4= 68 504 =42367:475 4A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674= 2C;F152 50A5 17 D14@ 68 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 5012 #4515167 )) 6C=5 17 1D19 6754F35 ) ! A :1=4B5167 @A2 ?1D47 50A5 18 A7 A3391BA5167 @A2 FA:4 @150 504 22125A75 6FF1221674= 86= 122CA7B4 68 B4=51814: B63< 504 2AF4 A=4 56 ;4 122C4: 5 12 2447 50A5 5012 12 765 504 2C;E4B5 FA554= 17 504 3=42475 34515167 5 A334A=2 50A5 504 94A=74: B6C7249 86= 504 345151674=2 12 FA>17? A554F352 56 F1294A: 5012 FA>17? 3=634= 2C;F1221672 6C=5 ;< 765 7:4= 504 B1=BCF25A7B42 5012 - 12 - 6C=5 12 765 1754=D4717? 17 504 6=:4= 3A224: ;< 504 22125A75 6FF1221674= =42367:475 6= 56 FA>4 A7< 8C=504= 6=:4=2 @150 =4?A=: 56 122CA7B4 68 B4=51814: B63< A2 A9=4A:< 504 6754F35 6C=5 0A2 3A224: 2CB0 6=:4=2 @01B0 @199 5A>4 152 96?1BA9 B67B9C2167 4A=74: 3=6:CB4: B6C7249 774HC=4 86= 345151674=2 0A2 A926 B9A1F17? 50A5 504 B4=51814: B63142 68 504 =4B6=:2 A=4 ;486=4 504 22125A75 6FF1221674= A7: 7654 ;496@ 504 2A1: :6BCF475 =4A:2 A2 C7:4= >9 "#$ $%$$ .” ! 5 12 25A54: 50A5 A2 504 345151674=2 A=4 765 3A=5142 56 504 2A1: 3=6B44:17?2 B4=51814: B63142 A=4 765 ?1D47 BB6=:17?9< 3A22 504 86996@17? 012 34515167 12 ))) 3A<A;94 @150 B625 68 :D6BA54J2 - 13 - 226B1A5167 1;=A=< $C7: A=7A5A>A A9A;C=A?1 1?0 6C=5 68 @15017 A 34=16: 68 5@6 @44>2 8=6F 504 :A54 68 =4B4135 68 B63< 68 5012 6=:4= 1;4=5< 12 =424=D4: 56 504 345151674=2 56 A33=6AB0 504 4B5167 43C5< 6FF1221674= C7:4= !( &!' 68 504 B5 56 B0A9947?4 504 6=:4= 68 =42367:475 18 26 A:D124: 6C=5 0A2 765 4H3=4224: A7< 6317167 67 504 F4=152 68 504 FA554= 1D 99 B6754751672 68 504 3A=5142 A=4 >435 6347 ' " !*( ! & " )

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Karnataka HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →