The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. Once the records are reconstructed and papers are supplied, the learned Trial Court shall endeavour to conduct the trial on a day-to-day basis to the extent possible. No unnecessary adjournments shall be granted to either side. The petitioner is explicitly cautioned that any attempt to delay the trial or breach any of the aforementioned conditions shall entitle the State or the CBI to move for the immediate cancellation of bail.
23. The learned CJM, Barasat, shall verify the identification of the sureties and the authenticity of all documents produced for the bail bond before the petitioner is released from the Correctional Home.
24. The applications, being CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024 and CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024, are accordingly allowed with the aforementioned directions. The State is at liberty to move for immediate cancellation of bail in the event of any breach. (Uday Kumar, J.) (Rajarshi Bharadwaj, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1&2
SM
07.04.2026
Ct No.238
(Allowed)
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
Letter of the Prisoner Sudipta Sen
Vs.
State of West Bengal
With
CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
Sudipta Sen
Vs.
State of West Bengal
Mr. Sabir Ahamed
Mr. Sujoy Sarkar
Mr. Prasun Mukherjee
Ms. Indranil Roychowdhury
Ms. Moumita Pandit
… … for the petitioner
Mr. Saryati Datta
.... for the State in CRM(DB) 2551 of 2024
Mr. Joydeep Biswas
Ms. Afreen Begum
.... for the State in CRM(DB) 3548 of 2024
Mr. Amajit De, Special PP, CBI
… for the C.B.I.
1. The Court is seized of these two applications being CRM
(DB) 2551 of 2024 and CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024, for bail
preferred under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (corresponding to Section 483 of the
Bharatiya
Nagarik
Suraksha
Sanhita,
2023).
The
petitioner, Sudipta Sen, Chairman and Managing Director
of the Saradha Group, seeks enlargement on bail in
connection with Barasat P.S. Case No. 901 of 2013 and
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
Barasat P.S. Case No. 937 of 2013, involving allegations
under Sections 420, 406, and 409 of the Indian Penal
Code.
2. Mr. Sabir Ahmad, learned Counsel for the petitioner,
submits that the petitioner has been in continuous
custody for an unprecedented duration of approximately
thirteen years, following his arrest on August 14, 2013. It
is contended that out of 389 cases initiated against him
across the country, including 77 cases investigated by the
Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) under the directions
of this Hon’ble Court, the petitioner has been enlarged on
bail in 387 matters. These two cases remain the sole
impediments to his physical liberty.
3. Learned Counsel invites our attention to a profound
breakdown in the trial process. In Case No. 901 of 2013,
despite the filing of a charge sheet on April 9, 2014, the
mandatory "police papers" required under Section 207 of
the
Cr.P.C.
have
not
been
supplied
to
the
petitioner/accused for over a decade. In Case No. 937 of
2013, the trial has reached a total stalemate as the State
has admitted that the original Case Record is currently
missing. It is argued that the petitioner cannot be made
to
suffer
indefinitely
for
the
State’s
administrative
failures, especially when the trial has become "remote"
and "bleak."
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
4. It is vehemently argued that the petitioner, now 64 years
of
age,
suffers
from
multiple
life-threatening
co-
morbidities and has recently survived a brain stroke. Mr.
Ahmad posits that the petitioner’s pre-trial detention has
already exceeded double the maximum sentence he might
have served upon conviction. He posits that continued
incarceration as "punitive" rather than "preventative,"
asserting that a trial which is "bleak" and "remote"
constitutes
a
direct
violation
of
the
petitioner’s
fundamental rights and such a situation is a direct
affront to the "reasonable, fair, and just" procedure
mandated by Article 21 of the Constitution of India
5. Strengthening his contention on the violation of the Right
to a Speedy Trial, learned Counsel places reliance on a
catena of Supreme Court decisions:
i.
Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb (2021) for the
Constitutional Courts must grant bail when the
right to a speedy trial is violated, as Article 21
overrides all procedural and statutory rigors.
ii.
Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI (2022) for the
contention that "bail is the rule and jail is the
exception," and that prolonged incarceration
without trial is anathema to the Constitution.
iii.
Shaheen Welfare Association v. Union of India
(1996) for the contention that prolong detention
must not be allowed to devolve into "pre-trial
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
punishment" when a trial is unlikely to conclude
soon.
iv.
Hussainara Khatoon to reaffirm that the right to
a speedy trial is an inalienable safeguard of
personal liberty and is an integral part of a "just
and fair" procedure.
6. Mr. Ahmad further submits that the petitioner is no
longer in a position to influence any witnesses or tamper
with evidence or make financial investments. He argues
that the State’s failure to produce the accused for a
decade to supply copies, or to preserve the integrity of
judicial records, cannot be used as a justification to
deprive a citizen of his liberty indefinitely.
7. Therefore, he prays for release of the petitioner on bail in
both
matters,
offering
to
submit
to
any
stringent
conditions, including residential restrictions or digital
monitoring, to ensure his participation in the trial as and
when the records are reconstructed and the procedural
mandates are met.
8. Mr. Saryati Datta, learned Advocate for the State submits
that
the
petitioner’s
role
was
foundational
to
the
deception of thousands of depositors. It is contended that
the Saradha Group’s operations lured investors with
promises of high returns, only to defraud them of their
principal amounts, leading to charges under Sections
420, 406, and 409 of the IPC. However, during the course
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
of the hearing, Mr. Datta candidly admits that the trial in
this specific case is currently an impossibility as the
original Case Record (CR) is missing or misplaced. He
acknowledges that without the reconstruction or recovery
of these judicial records, no further progress can be
rendered in a trial that was initiated over twelve years
ago.
9. While formally registering an objection to the petitioner’s
release, the learned Advocate for the State acknowledges
the "stalemate" caused by the missing records. Coupled
with the petitioner’s failing health, specifically a recent
brain stroke, it is conceded that the trial is unlikely to
conclude in the foreseeable future. The State submits that
should this Court be inclined to grant liberty, such relief
must be contingent upon the most stringent conditions to
prevent the petitioner from absconding or interfering with
the reconstruction of the record.
10. Mr. Joydeep Biswas, learned Advocate representing the
State while emphasizing the grave economic nature of the
"Saradha Scam" and its impact on small-scale investors,
candidly admits to the procedural morass. The State
acknowledges that the trial has remained in a state of
"suspended animation" for over a decade. It is conceded
that the failure to supply copies under Section 207
Cr.P.C. and the failure to produce the accused before the
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
jurisdictional court have created an insurmountable
deadlock.
11. The State fairly admits that the prospects of an early trial
are "remote" and "bleak." In view of the fact that the
investigation was completed in 2014, and considering the
petitioner’s enlargement on bail in 387 other cases, the
State acknowledges that continued custodial detention
raises significant constitutional concerns regarding the
mandate of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
12. Mr. Amajit De, the learned Special Public Prosecutor for
the CBI submits that pursuant to the directions of this
Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the CBI took over
the investigation into the larger conspiracy and money
trail. Out of 389 cases, 77 were transferred to the CBI, all
of which have reached the stage of finality with the filing
of four primary charge sheets (RC 4/S/2014, RC
5/S/2014, RC 6/S/2014, and RC 51/S/2014). The CBI
confirms that the petitioner has been granted bail in all
77 matters and has duly furnished his bail bonds.
13. The CBI clarifies that the two Barasat cases currently
before this Division Bench (901 and 937 of 2013) remain
under the exclusive purview of the State Police. However,
the Agency fairly admits that the prospects of an early
trial in the remaining cluster of cases are "bleak" and
"remote." Given that the investigation attained finality
years ago and the petitioner has endured approximately
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
thirteen years of custody, the CBI does not perceive a
continued necessity for custodial detention, provided the
petitioner remains available for the trial process.
14. We have heard the submissions and perused the
materials on record. We find a profound challenge to the
equilibrium between the gravity of economic offenses and
the sanctity of personal liberty. There appears to be a
systemic collapse of the trial machinery in these two
cases.
In
Case
No.901
of
2013,
the
investigation
concluded in 2014, yet for a decade, mandatory copies
under Section 207 of the Cr.P.C. were not supplied. We
find the State’s plea, that non-supply was due to the
petitioner’s non-production, to be entirely unsatisfactory.
The State failed to demonstrate any effort to seek
production orders, and the Trial Court similarly failed to
exercise its oversight. Where a decade is consumed
merely in the supply of papers, the system has failed the
mandate of speedy justice.
15. In Case No.937 of 2013, the situation is even more
egregious. The State has conceded that the original Case
Record is missing. This reflects a shocking lack of care in
the preservation of records in such a sensitive matter of
such public magnitude. The fact that the system has
remained idle without reconstructing these records for
years is a substantive barrier that renders the petitioner’s
right to a "speedy trial" a dead letter.
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
16. Under Article 21, the right to a speedy trial is inalienable.
When an individual is detained for thirteen years, a
period nearly doubles the maximum sentence for the
offenses charged, the detention shifts from "preventive" to
"punitive." The "Doctrine of Proportionality" and the
principle of Parity further tilt the scales. The petitioner
has been enlarged on bail in 387 out of 389 cases,
including
all
CBI
matters,
without
any
report
of
obstructive conduct. To deny bail now, in the face of a
"stalemate" admitted by the State, would be to sanction
an indefinite life sentence without conviction.
17. Consequently, the prolonged detention, the admitted
administrative
failures,
and
the
petitioner’s
critical
medical condition necessitate judicial intervention. We
are of the firm opinion that the petitioner has made out
an exceptional case for bail. The applications are allowed.
The petitioner shall be released on bail subject to
conditions, ensuring his availability to the law as and
when the records are reconstructed and procedural
defaults are rectified.
18. Accordingly, we direct that the petitioner, Sudipta Sen, be
released on bail in connection with Barasat P.S. Case No.
901 of 2013 and Barasat P.S. Case No. 937 of 2013, upon
furnishing a bond of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand
only) with two sureties of like amount each, one of whom
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
must be local, to the satisfaction of the learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Barasat, North 24-Parganas.
19. Recognizing the magnitude of the underlying financial
scam and the necessity to safeguard public interest, the
following conditions are hereby imposed:
(i) The petitioner shall surrender his Passport to
the Trial Court (if not already in the custody of
any other agency). He is prohibited from leaving
the territorial limits of the State of West Bengal
without the prior written permission of this
Court. He shall provide his fixed place of
residence to the Officer-in-Charge (O/C) of the
Barasat Police Station and shall not change his
residence without prior intimation to both the
Trial Court and the O/C.
(ii) The
petitioner
is
strictly
restrained
from
promoting, managing, or acting as an agent or
consultant for any financial entity, Collective
Investment
Scheme
(CIS),
or
Multi-Level
Marketing (MLM) firm. He shall not solicit or
accept any deposits from the public, directly or
indirectly. Any violation shall result in the
immediate cancellation of bail.
(iii)The petitioner shall not contact, influence, or
intimidate any person acquainted with the facts
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
of
the
cases,
specifically
the
de-facto
complainants and prosecution witnesses. Any
substantiated report of witness tampering shall
result in the suo motu cancellation of this bail.
(iv) The petitioner shall maintain an active mobile
phone number, which must be shared with the
Investigating Officer (IO) of the Barasat Police
District and the Trial Court. This device must
remain "ON" at all times, and the petitioner is
directed to keep the "Live Location" sharing
feature enabled 24/7 for the IO’s continuous
verification.
(v) The petitioner shall report to the O/C of the
Barasat Police District once a month between
11:00 AM and 1:00 PM.
(vi) The petitioner shall attend every date of the trial
via virtual mode or physical production as
directed by the learned Court below. He is
further directed to fully cooperate with the court
in the process of reconstructing the missing
records.
20. We further direct the learned Court below to take
immediate and urgent steps for the reconstruction of the
missing records in Case No. 937 of 2013. The learned
CJM shall submit a status report regarding the progress
of such reconstruction to the Registrar (Judicial Service)
CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024
& CRM (DB) 3548 of 2024
of this Court within four weeks from the date of this
order.
21. In respect of Barasat P.S. Case No. 901 of 2013, the State
is directed to ensure that the mandatory "police papers"
under Section 207 of the Cr.P.C. are served upon the
petitioner within three weeks from the date of his release.
We emphasize that the supply of these copies must be
concluded no later than four weeks from today.
22. Once the records are reconstructed and papers are
supplied, the learned Trial Court shall endeavour to
conduct the trial on a day-to-day basis to the extent
possible. No unnecessary adjournments shall be granted
to either side. The petitioner is explicitly cautioned that
any attempt to delay the trial or breach any of the
aforementioned conditions shall entitle the State or the
CBI to move for the immediate cancellation of bail.
23. The learned CJM, Barasat, shall verify the identification
of the sureties and the authenticity of all documents
produced for the bail bond before the petitioner is
released from the Correctional Home.
24. The applications, being CRM (DB) 2551 of 2024 and CRM
(DB) 3548 of 2024, are accordingly allowed with the
aforementioned directions. The State is at liberty to move
for immediate cancellation of bail in the event of any
breach.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
(Rajarshi Bharadwaj, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review