Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment Reserved on: 20.07.2026
Judgment delivered on: 28.07.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 28.07.2026
CM(M) 1936/2025 & CM APPLs. 62657/2025, 62659/2025
SUDHIR KUMAR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Rakesh Mittal, Mr. Ajay
Harshana and Ms. Yamini Mittal,
Advs.
versus
MONIKA MAKKAR & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikas Kakkar, Mr. Charanjeet
Khatana, Mr. Abhishek Baghel, Mr.
Sanskar Nagaich, Ms. Anchal Kakkar,
Mr. Bharat Kumar and Mr. Arijeet
Barooah, Advs. for R-1 and 2
Mr. Chaitanya, Mr. Shubhanshu
Gupta, Mr. Kartik Pant and Mr. Srijan
Sonkar, Advs. for R-3
+
FAO (COMM) 279/2025 & CM APPL. 61177/2025
SUDHIR KUMAR
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rakesh Mittal, Mr. Ajay
Harshana and Ms. Yamini Mittal,
Advs.
versus
MONIKA MAKKAR & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikas Kakkar, Mr. Charanjeet
Khatana, Mr. Abhishek Baghel, Mr.
Sanskar Nagaich, Ms. Anchal Kakkar,
Mr. Bharat Kumar and Mr. Arijeet
Barooah, Advs. for R-1 and 2
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
Mr. Chaitanya, Mr. Shubhanshu
Gupta, Mr. Kartik Pant and Mr. Srijan
Sonkar, Advs. for R-3
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J.
1.
These connected proceedings arise out of order(s) passed in CS
(COMM) No. 379/2025 instituted by the Appellant/Petitioner for recovery
of outstanding dues under two (2) purchase orders pertaining to the
execution of structural fabrication and installation works for the construction
of a studio project at FC-7, Sector-16A, Film City, Noida, Uttar Pradesh.
2.
Vide order dated 07.08.2025, the learned District Judge (Commercial-
06), South-East District, Saket Courts, [‘Trial Court’] held that the Courts at
Delhi lacked territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit over the transaction
pleaded in the suit. Consequent thereto, by a subsequent order dated
23.08.2025, while dealing with the Appellant’s application under Order VII
Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [‘CPC’] seeking fixing of
date of appearance of parties before the Court of District Judge (Commercial
Court), South District, Saket Courts [‘South District, Saket’] the Trial Court
rejected the said application and directed return of the plaint under Order
VII Rule 10 CPC.
3.
Aggrieved thereby, the Appellant instituted FAO (COMM) 279/2025
under Order XLIII Rule 1(a) CPC read with Section 13 of the Commercial
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
Courts Act, 2015 [‘Act of 2015’] assailing the order dated 07.08.2025
[‘impugned order dated 07.08.2025’], and CM(M) 1936/2025 under Article
227 of the Constitution of India challenging the consequential order dated
23.08.2025 [impugned order dated 23.08.2025].
Noticing that both proceedings emanate from the same suit and
involve interrelated questions concerning the correctness of the finding on
territorial jurisdiction and the consequential return of the plaint, this Court,
vide order dated 08.12.2025, directed that the appeal and the petition be
listed and heard together.
FACTS
4.
The facts, as set out in the appeal and relevant to adjudicate the
present dispute is as under: 4.1
The Appellant is the proprietor of M/s Vijay Iron Works, carrying on
business from Sangam Vihar, New Delhi. Respondent No. 3 entrusted the
work of construction of a studio project at FC-7, Sector-16A, Film City,
Noida, Uttar Pradesh to Respondents No. 1 and 2. In connection with the
said project, it is contended that Respondents No. 1 and 2 issued two
purchase orders, both dated 12.08.2021, in favour of the Appellant for
supply of structural material and execution of installation and fabrication
works. The Appellant claims that Respondents No. 1 and 2 represented
themselves to be acting jointly and assured payment of the amounts due
under both purchase orders.
4.2
According to the Appellant, the purchase orders were issued from
Delhi, the materials were supplied from Delhi, and payments towards the
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
executed work were remitted by Respondent No. 1 through RTGS into the
Appellant’s bank account maintained at HDFC Bank, Saket Branch, New
Delhi [‘HDFC Bank, Saket’]. The Appellant further asserts that the invoices
raised upon the Respondents contained a clause stipulating that disputes
would be subject to the jurisdiction of the Courts at Delhi.
4.3
The Appellant alleges that after completing the contracted works,
including certain additional works undertaken on the instructions of the
Respondents, substantial amounts towards the principal dues remained
unpaid. It is also alleged that certain tools, machinery and scrap belonging to
the Appellant continued to be retained by the Respondent No. 3.
Consequently, after issuance of a legal notice, the Appellant instituted CS
(Comm) No. 379/2025 before the Trial Court, seeking recovery of
Rs. 32,80,065/, comprising the alleged principal outstanding together with
interest.
4.4
The Respondents contested the maintainability of the suit, inter alia,
on the ground that no part of the cause of action had arisen within the
territorial jurisdiction of the Courts at Delhi. Respondent No. 1 further
contended that it has already instituted a suit for recovery of money against
the Appellant before South District, Saket and the Appellant suppressed the
details of the said suit in its plaint.
4.5
As noted above, by impugned order dated 07.08.2025, the Trial Court
held that the Courts at Delhi lacked territorial jurisdiction to entertain the
suit. Thereafter, by order dated 23.08.2025, the Trial Court rejected the
Appellant’s application under Order VII Rule 10A CPC seeking fixing of a
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
date of hearing before the South District, Saket and directed return of the
plaint under Order VII Rule 10 CPC.
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE RAISED BY THE APPELLANT
5.
Appellant submitted that the Trial Court exceeded its jurisdiction by
not only holding that it (i.e., South-East District) lacked territorial
jurisdiction but also recording a finding that no Court in Delhi possessed
territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit. It is submitted that once the Trial
Court concluded that it lacked jurisdiction, it could neither adjudicate upon
the jurisdiction of other competent courts nor reject the Appellant's
application under Order VII Rule 10A CPC. It is argued that Rule 10A does
not empower the returning Court to determine whether the Court before
which the plaint is proposed to be presented possesses territorial jurisdiction.
5.1
The Appellant further submitted that multiple circumstances gave rise
to a part of the cause of action within Delhi. It is submitted that the purchase
orders were issued from Delhi, the contracts were entered into at Delhi, the
goods were supplied from Delhi, and substantial payments amounting to
approximately Rs. 66.26 lakhs were remitted by Respondent No. 1 through
RTGS directly into the Appellant’s bank account at HDFC Bank, Saket. The
invoices also stipulated that disputes would be subject to Delhi jurisdiction.
5.2
The Appellant also assailed the factual findings recorded in the
impugned orders as being contrary to the record. It is submitted that the
Trial Court incorrectly observed that the Appellant had concealed the
pendency of the earlier commercial suit, although the said fact had been
disclosed in the application under Section 20(b) CPC filed before service of
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
summons. Similarly, the Trial Court is stated to have erroneously recorded
that none of the defendants resided in Delhi despite acknowledging
Respondent No. 2’s Sarita Vihar address. The Appellant further submits that
the application under Section 20(b) CPC was filed merely as a matter of
abundant caution pursuant to the Trial Court’s observations and not as an
admission that Delhi lacked jurisdiction.
5.3
The Appellant contended that receipt of payments at Delhi constitutes
part of the cause of action, and that the scheme of Order VII Rules 10 and
10A CPC does not permit the returning Court to adjudicate upon the
jurisdiction of the Court before which the plaint is proposed to be presented.
It is contended that due to the receipt of the payments in the HDFC Bank
account, the South District, Saket has the requisite territorial jurisdiction.
SUBMISSIONS BY RESPONDENTS
6.
The Respondents contended that the Appellant has suppressed
material facts and is attempting to improve upon the original plaint through
the appeal. The Respondents pointed out that while Respondent No. 2 was
shown as having a Noida address in the suit before the Trial Court, the
Appellant has altered the address to Delhi in the appeal proceedings, thereby
attempting to create an artificial basis for jurisdiction.
6.1
The Respondents further submitted that the Trial Court had expressly
kept the issue of territorial jurisdiction open from the inception of the suit, as
reflected in the order dated 07.05.2025 and after considering the pleadings
and objections raised by the defendants, the Trial Court correctly examined
the question of territorial jurisdiction and, upon finding that no jurisdiction
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
lay in Delhi, returned the plaint under Order VII Rule 10 CPC.
6.2
According to the Respondents, the entire cause of action arose in
Noida, Uttar Pradesh. The Appellant himself pleaded that he was engaged
for work at the site of Respondent No. 3 in Noida, that the work was
executed there, and that the purchase order required billing at the Noida
address of Respondent No. 2; therefore, any alleged default and the
corresponding cause of action could only arise in Noida. It was further
argued that Respondent No. 1 is based in Gurugram, Respondent No. 2 has
its relevant subordinate office in Noida, and Respondent No. 3 is situated in
Noida; consequently, even under Section 20(a) and (b) CPC, jurisdiction
would lie only in Noida.
6.3
It is further submitted that while considering an application under
Order VII Rule 10 CPC, the Court is confined to the averments contained in
the plaint; the Appellant, after conclusion of arguments on territorial
jurisdiction, sought to rely on bank statements annexed to written
submissions in an attempt to establish Delhi jurisdiction of South District
Saket. It is submitted that the Trial Court rightly refused to consider such
material, as it constituted an impermissible attempt to improve the plaint and
create jurisdiction after arguments had concluded.
6.4
The Respondents contended that the Trial Court correctly appreciated
the pleadings and documents and recorded findings that the work was
performed in Noida, none of the defendants resided in Delhi, the purchase
order was issued from the Noida office, and no part of the cause of action
arose in Delhi.
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
7.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record.
8.
The Trial Court vide the impugned order dated 07.08.2025 held that it
(i.e., South-East District) lacked territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit
and further proceeded to record a finding that no Courts in Delhi possessed
territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute. This finding was returned by
the Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Order VII Rule 10 CPC.
The Trial Court passed a detailed order on 07.08.2025 wherein at
paragraphs 1, 2, 29 and 30 it returned the following findings: “1. Vide this order, I shall decide if this Court has territorial jurisdiction
in the present case to try the present suit.
2. Vide order dated 07.05.2025, while directing for issuing summons of
the suit, this Court had specifically observed that the issue of territorial
jurisdiction is left open.
…..
29. As Courts in Delhi have no jurisdiction over the transaction in
question, jurisdiction clause mentioned in the invoices is of no avail to
the Plaintiff.
30. In light of these observations, it is held that that this Court lacks
territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present suit.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
The Trial Court by a separate order dated 07.08.2025, granted liberty
to the Appellant to file an appropriate application under Order VII Rule 10A
CPC. The relevant portion of the order reads as under: “Vide separate order, it has been held that this Court lacks territorial
jurisdiction to entertain the present suit. In view of holding that this court
lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present suit, prayer of
plaintiff for granting leave to sue Defendant no. 1 and 3 in this court is
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
not maintainable. Therefore, application of the Plaintiff under Section 20
(b) is dismissed.
Further, in view of holding that this court lacks territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the present suit, the plaint is liable to be returned under Order
VII Rule 10 CPC. The Plaintiff may, if it so desires, move an appropriate
application under Order VII Rule 10 A CPC within a week from today
with copy to opposite counsel.
List for further proceedings on 23.08.2025.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
8.1.
The Appellant in terms of the aforesaid liberty filed an application
under Order VII Rule 10A CPC stating that the plaintiff proposes to present
the plaint, after its return, before the South District, Saket and accordingly
sought a direction for fixing a date of appearance. This application was
however dismissed by the Trial Court vide order dated 23.08.2025 and this
order has been impugned in CM(M) No. 1936/2025. The Trial Court, on
23.08.2025, issued a simplicitor direction for return of the plaint, along with
the original documents and court fees under Order VII Rule 10 CPC.
Though, it is not expressly recorded in the order dated 23.08.2025, it
appears on perusal of the contents of said order that the Trial Court was of
the opinion that since, as per the averments in the plaint and the documents
filed in support thereof, no part of the cause of action had arisen in Delhi,
therefore the prayer seeking fixing a date of appearance before the South
District, Saket was not maintainable. Learned counsel for the Respondents
also confirm this conclusion drawn by this Court.
9.
Before us, learned counsel for the Appellant has submitted that the
Appellant is not disputing the finding of the Trial Court, in order dated
07.08.2025, that the Court of the learned District Judge (Commercial-06),
South-East District, Saket Courts, lacked territorial jurisdiction to entertain
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
the suit. The limited grievance urged is that the Trial Court exceeded the
scope of its jurisdiction under Order VII Rule 10 CPC by recording a
conclusive finding that no Court in Delhi possessed territorial jurisdiction. It
is contended that once the Trial Court concluded that it (i.e., South-East
District) lacked territorial jurisdiction, it ought to have confined itself to
returning the plaint, leaving the question whether any other Court in Delhi
possessed territorial jurisdiction to be examined, if necessary, by the Court
before which the plaint was subsequently presented.
The Appellant contends that in view of the fact that payments were
received by it from Respondent No. 1 at HDFC Bank, Saket, part of cause of
action has arisen within the territorial limits of South District, Saket.
10.
Respondents have disputed the submissions of the Appellant and
contended that no pleading with respect to receipt of payments in the bank
account at HDFC Bank, Saket were pleaded in the plaint and this plea was
sought to be raised, for the first time on the date when the impugned order
was pronounced on 07.08.2025. Respondent No. 3 has averred that
Appellant has no cause of action at all against it and it has been dragged into
the suit malafide to arm twist the Respondent No. 1 to settle the claims
raised in the separate suit filed by Respondent No. 1.
11.
As noted above, the finding of the Trial Court in its order dated
07.08.2025 that suit was not maintainable within the territorial jurisdiction
of South-East District, Saket is not being contested by the Appellant and has
thus, attained finality. The only issue, in these proceedings, is with respect to
the effect of the impugned order dated 07.08.2025 on the territorial
jurisdiction of the Court at South District, Saket or any other Court in Delhi.
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
12.
We find merit in the limited contention of the Appellant that Trial
Court, on 07.08.2025, was competent to return a finding only on its
territorial jurisdiction (South-East District) and not the jurisdiction of the
other Courts at Delhi.
Before we return a finding on this submission, we, however, have a
caveat on the conduct of the Appellant herein, which itself invited the
finding of lack of jurisdiction of Courts at Delhi, from the Trial Court. The
said finding was returned by the Trial Court on the basis of the facts placed
before it in the plaint, by the Appellant, and the documents filed along with
the plaint. The pleadings and the documents filed before the Trial Court led
it to conclude that no cause of action had arisen with the jurisdiction of
Courts at Delhi. The fact of the receipt of payments at HDFC Bank, Saket
was not pleaded in the plaint and no document filed before the Court when
this issue was decided. It was in these facts that the Trial Court returned its
findings on the lack of territorial jurisdiction of Courts at Delhi, in its order
dated 07.08.2025.
13.
At the same time, we are also unable to overlook the mischievous
conduct of the Appellant. The Appellant had been served with summons in
the commercial suit1 filed by Respondent No. 1 before learned District
Judge (Commercial Court)-05 South District, Saket. The Appellant, as per
his own case, could have instituted its claims by filing a suit in the same
district on the basis of the averments of having an account with the HDFC
Bank, Saket. However, Appellant consciously elected to not rely on the
existence of its bank account and filed the suit in the different district, i.e.,
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CS(COMM) 476/2024
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
South-East and also failed to disclose the receipt of the summons of
Respondent No. 1’s suit. The finding of suppression drawn by the Trial
Court in its order dated 07.08.2025 is therefore meritorious. This conduct of
the Appellant gives the distinct impression that it was seeking to delay
adjudication of the suit filed by Respondent No. 1.
14.
However, reverting to the legal issue raised by the Appellant as
regards the modification of the finding in the impugned order dated
07.08.2025 to be limited to the Courts at South-East District, Saket, we hold
that the legal enquiry before the Court while considering return of a plaint
under Order VII Rule 10 CPC is confined to determining whether the said
Court before which the suit is instituted possesses territorial jurisdiction or
not. Upon arriving at a conclusion that it lacks such jurisdiction, the said
Court is required to return the plaint, to the plaintiff, for presentation before
the proper Court and it cannot render a conclusive adjudication on the
territorial jurisdiction of every other Court to which the Plaintiff proposes to
approach. To that limited extent, the observation in the impugned order
dated 07.08.2025 that no Courts in Delhi has territorial jurisdiction cannot
be sustained and is hereby modified to be read as Courts at South-East
District, Saket has no territorial jurisdiction in this case.
15.
The Appellant contends that in view of the fact that Respondent No. 1
made part payments to it in its bank account held with HDFC Bank, Saket,
the Appellant can institute the returned plaint before South District, Saket. It
is submitted that the Appellant therefore proposes to present the plaint
before South District, Saket. Respondents have contested that even the said
Courts does not have territorial jurisdiction.
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
16.
In view of our finding that the order of the Trial Court can only be
construed as a binding opinion as regards to the territorial jurisdiction of the
Courts at South-East District, Saket, FAO (COMM) 279/2025 is allowed to
the limited extent that the finding recorded by the Trial Court in the
impugned order dated 07.08.2025 to the effect that no Court in Delhi
possesses territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit is hereby modified to be
read as Courts at South-East District, Saket. It is clarified that the finding
that the Court of the learned District Judge (Commercial-06), South-East
District, Saket Courts lacked territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit is
affirmed.
17.
We find no ground to interfere in the impugned order dated
23.08.2025. The plea of the Petitioner that Courts at South District, Saket
would have territorial jurisdiction on the plea that payments were received
by the Petitioner in its bank account held in HDFC Bank, Saket is not set out
in the plaint as it stands. The Petitioner would necessarily have to amend its
pleadings to make this averment before it can file the plaint before the said
Court. We therefore, find no ground to interfere in the impugned order dated
23.08.2025 passed by the Trial Court. The said order does not affect the
ability of the Petitioner to file the plaint in the Court of appropriate
jurisdiction.
18.
It is clarified that this Court has expressed no opinion on the question
whether any other Courts in Delhi, including South District, Saket possesses
territorial jurisdiction. The question whether the Court in South District,
Saket or any other Court before which the plaint is proposed to be presented
by the Appellant/Petitioner possesses territorial jurisdiction shall be
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
determined independently by that Court in accordance with law.
19.
The rights and contentions of the Respondents on the issue of
territorial jurisdiction of Courts at Delhi are left open.
20.
The appeal FAO (COMM) 279/2025 is allowed partially in terms of
the clarification given at paragraph nos. 14 and 16 of this judgment.
21.
CM(M) 1936/2025 is hereby dismissed.
22.
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
JULY 28, 2026/hp/AM
Digitally Signed
By:RASHMI DABAS
18:00:15
CM(M) 1936/2025 & FAO (COMM) 279/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review