Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ananya Bandyopadhyay
W.P.A. 27459 of 2017
Sudhanshu Chakraborty & Ors.
-VsThe Union of India & Ors.
For the Petitioners
: Mr. D.N. Roy, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Biswarup Nandy,
Mr. Rajesh Kumar Shah,
Mr. Sourav Halder,
Mr. Gourav Sarkar
For the Respondents/UOI
: Mr. Bhudeb Chatterjee
For the Respondent Nos. 3 to 7
: Mr. Partha Ghosh
Mr. Madhu Jana
Judgment on
: 07.09.2026
Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.:1. The writ petitioners seek consideration of their claim for regularisation of
service in the S. N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences, Kolkata
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Centre’). The claim arises from their
engagement as casual labourers and the subsequent conferment of
Temporary Status under the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary
Status and Regularisation) Scheme, 1993 of the Government of India.
2. The petitioners have served the Centre for several years. Temporary
Status was conferred upon them at different stages in accordance with
the governmental scheme. Their services thereafter continued to be
utilized by the Centre in the discharge of its functions.
3. The Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status and Regularization)
Scheme dated 10th September 1993 came into force with effect from 1st
September 1993. The Scheme contemplated conferment of Temporary
Status upon eligible casual labourers without reference to the creation or
availability of regular Group ‘D’ posts. It also prescribed the conditions
governing their eventual consideration for regular appointment.
4. Paragraph 4(iv) of the Scheme makes it clear that conferment of
Temporary Status does not by itself amount to permanent appointment.
A CL-TS employee could enter the permanent establishment upon
selection through the regular selection process prescribed for Group ‘D’
posts. Paragraph 8, however, contemplated that two out of every three
vacancies in Group ‘D’ cadres in the respective offices where casual
labourers worked would be filled, in accordance with the extant
recruitment rules and the instructions of the Department of Personnel
and Training, from amongst casual workers possessing Temporary
Status.
5. The Scheme thus occupies a position between casual engagement and
regular appointment. Temporary Status does not confer a right to
permanent appointment by itself. It does, however, place the employee
within a defined governmental regime which contemplates consideration
for regular appointment against vacancies subject to the conditions
prescribed therein.
6. The later Office Memorandum dated 26th February 2016 reiterates the
relevant
features
consequences
of
the
attached
to
Scheme
prolonged
and
service
records the
after
service
conferment
of
Temporary Status. The petitioners' claim consequently falls to be
examined not merely by reference to the terms of their original casual
engagement but within the governmental framework which governed
their subsequent status.
7. The administrative correspondence assumes significance in that context.
By Letter No.SNB/FA-2-002/14/15/1153 dated 28th November 2014, the
Centre forwarded the particulars of its CL-TS personnel to the
Department of Science and Technology under Ministry of Science and
Technology
in
the
context
of
the
DoPT
Office
Memorandum
No.49014/3/2014-Estt (C) dated 16th October 2014. By email dated 26th
March 2015, the Registrar again forwarded the relevant material and
sought advice concerning regularisation.
8. The communication vide Letter No.F.No.AI/10/9/PG/2015 dated 9
March 2016 records that the Government had authorised the respondent
institution to decide the claim for regularisation, the matter being within
its jurisdiction. The claim thus remained pending before the institution
as a matter requiring an administrative decision.
9. The controversy thereafter came before this Court in W.P. 16543(W) of
2016. By order dated 9th March 2017, the Governing Body was directed
to take a decision upon the claim within the period prescribed by the
Court and, if the claim were declined, to furnish reasons and
communicate the same. The order did not itself adjudicate the
substantive entitlement of the petitioners. The responsibility of taking the
decision rested with the competent authority.
10. The Governing Body considered the matter at its meeting dated 23rd
March 2017.
The proceedings record that regularisation required
availability of posts and that the Centre did not possess sufficient Group
‘C’ posts carrying the requisite grade pay. The Governing Body also
considered the applicability of the DoPT instructions and the question of
age relaxation. It further sought sanction of suitable Group ‘C’ posts so
that the claims of the CL-TS personnel could be considered.
11. The Centre communicated that position to the Department of Science and
Technology by letter dated 6th April 2017. The letter specifically sought
intervention of the Department for sanction of suitable Group ‘C’ posts for
regularisation of the CL-TS personnel.
12. The sequence of these communications is material. The Centre itself
treated the petitioners' claim as a matter requiring consideration under
the
governmental
framework
relating
to
CL-TS
personnel.
The
correspondence also shows that the question of availability of posts had
been placed before the governmental authority competent to deal with
that issue.
13. A Reasoned Order bearing Order No.SNB/20.2/17-18/0026 dated 16 th
May 2017 was thereafter issued. Subsequently, by communications dated
14th August 2017, the Centre initiated a process for filling existing
vacancies through selection amongst the CL-TS personnel. The Selection
Committee considered the minimum educational qualification prescribed
by the DoPT Office Memorandum No.49014/3/2014-Estt (C) dated 16 th
October 2014 and the requirement of three years' continuous service after
conferment of Temporary Status. Since the Centre did not possess its own
Recruitment Rules, reference was also made to the model Recruitment
Rules vide Office Memorandum No.AB-14017/6/2009-Estt. (RR) dated
30th April 2010.
14. The proposed selection included a written and skill test. The petitioners
did not participate in the test. Their advocate, by communication dated
22nd August 2017, recorded the reasons for such decision and questioned
the applicability of the recruitment instructions relied upon by the Centre.
The
petitioners
contended
that
the
instructions
could
not
retrospectively govern their existing claim for regularisation and that the
proposed process did not address the claim arising from their Temporary
Status and prolonged service.
15. The Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the writ
petition arises from a claim for regularisation of service pursued by
persons who have remained in employment of the respondent Centre for a
prolonged span of years after being accorded Temporary Status under the
schemes of the Central Government. The grant of Temporary Status by
the respondent Centre and the petitioners’ continued engagement
thereafter constitute matters borne out by the administrative record. Such
status carried with it a prescribed scale of remuneration corresponding to
the scale applicable to Group-D employees of the Central Government,
subsequently placed in the Group-C category, whereas regularisation has
not followed despite the long duration of service.
16. The submission proceeds further on the basis that the respondent Centre
had, on earlier occasions, regularised casual employees with the approval
of the Central Government even after the pronouncement in Secretary,
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) (2006) 4 SCC 1. Against such
administrative history, the petitioners contend that the claim for
regularisation could not have been discarded without examining the
circumstances in which persons similarly engaged had obtained regular
status and without applying the principles emerging from the later
decisions of the Supreme Court.
17. The Learned Counsel submits that the order passed by this Court on 9th
March 2017 furnished a clear direction for examination of the claim for
regularisation. Instead of addressing the claim within the legal framework
governing Casual Labourers with Temporary Status, the respondent
authorities proceeded to fill only two posts through a selection exercise,
shortlisted
candidates
and
proposed
a
written/skill
test,
without
according absorption to the petitioners. According to learned counsel,
such a course did not answer the substantive claim placed before the
authority.
18. The further submission is that the petitioners have continued to
discharge duties for the respondent Centre over a prolonged period and
that the work entrusted to them bears a continuing and perennial
character. The engagement, according to learned counsel, cannot be
characterised as one intended for a fleeting requirement or a brief
exigency. The continuing utilisation of the petitioners for the functioning
of the institution, coupled with the conferment of Temporary Status under
the governmental scheme, is relied upon as a circumstance warranting
substantive consideration of the claim for regularisation.
19. The Learned Counsel submits that the subsequent attempt to subject the
petitioners to a fresh selection process on the basis of the Recruitment
Rules/instructions dated 16th October 2014 cannot govern a claim which
had arisen much earlier under the Temporary Status Scheme. The
submission is particularly directed against retrospective application of the
said recruitment framework to the petitioners’ claim for regularisation or
permanent absorption. According to learned counsel, a recruitment
instruction framed subsequently
cannot erase the status already
conferred upon the petitioners or displace a claim which had entered the
administrative process before such instruction was invoked.
20. The petitioners further contend that, where substantive vacant posts were
required for regularisation, the respondent authorities could approach the
competent governmental authority for sanction of suitable posts. The
written submissions specifically refer to creation of supernumerary posts,
where necessary, with the approval of the Department of Science and
Technology, Ministry of Science and Technology, Government of India.
The argument, therefore, is not confined to existing vacancies but extends
to the administrative obligation to place the requirement before the
authority competent to consider sanction of appropriate posts.
21. A separate grievance has been raised concerning medical facilities.
Learned counsel refers to Office Order No. R1/Admn./Office Order/202425/716, by which only outpatient medical treatment has been extended to
the staff, while inpatient treatment has not been made available in the
same manner. According to the petitioners, the alteration in the medical
facility has deprived the staff and family members of a form of medical
protection previously available and has created serious difficulty in
circumstances requiring hospitalisation or other substantial medical
intervention. The petitioners accordingly seek extension of benefits
available to regular employees, including medical facilities, leave salary,
Leave Travel Compensation and allied service benefits.
22. The legal submission is supported by reliance upon the following
authorities:-
i. Biswajit Goswami v. Secretary (Municipal Affairs), 2025 SCC OnLine
Cal 393;
ii. Jaggo v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826;
iii. Ushaben Joshi v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2277;
iv. Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. v. Brajrajnagar Coal Mines Workers' Union,
(2024) 19 SCC 345;
v. Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, (2024) 9 SCC 327;
vi. Sheo Narain Nagar v. State of U.P., (2018) 13 SCC 432; and
vii. Narendra Kumar Tiwari v. State of Jharkhand, (2018) 8 SCC 238.
23. The Learned Counsel relies upon the aforesaid decisions to contend that
prolonged service, the continuing nature of the work, the manner in
which the employer has treated the engagement and the existence of a
governmental scheme governing Temporary Status require a substantive
examination of a claim for regularisation. The submission is that Umadevi
cannot be read as a prohibition against every form of regularisation of
long-serving employees; rather, the distinction between an illegal
appointment
circumstances
and
an
irregular
surrounding
the
appointment,
engagement
together
and
the
with
the
applicable
governmental scheme, must inform the decision.
24. The petitioners therefore contend that the selection exercise proposed by
the respondent Centre, particularly the attempt to confine consideration
to two posts, cannot by itself dispose of a claim for regularisation which
had arisen under the earlier Temporary Status regime. The refusal to
participate in the written/skill test, communicated through the advocate’s
letter dated 22nd August 2017, is placed in the context of the petitioners’
legal objection to the process and is said not to constitute abandonment
of the claim for regularisation.
25. The ultimate submission on behalf of the petitioners is that the
administrative record, read with the governing Central Government
schemes and the authorities cited before the Court, calls for substantive
consideration of the petitioners’ status, length of service, nature of duties,
availability
or
sanction
of
appropriate
posts
and
entitlement
to
regularisation, rather than determination of the claim solely through a
subsequent selection process devised for existing vacancies.
26. The Learned Counsel appearing for respondent Nos.1 and 2 submits that
the controversy, as emerging from the writ petition and the petitioners’
notes of argument, centres upon a proposition that the conferment of
Temporary Status under the Government’s 1993 Scheme should, by itself,
preserve a mode of regularisation de hors the subsequent recruitment
framework contained in the Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014.
Such a proposition, according to learned counsel, does not accord with
the scheme governing Casual Labourers with Temporary Status.
27. The submission proceeds with reference to paragraph 8 of the 1993
Scheme. The provision contemplated that two out of every three vacancies
in Group-D posts would be filled, in accordance with the applicable
recruitment rules, from amongst casual workers possessing Temporary
Status. The Scheme further stipulated that a casual worker would not
enter the permanent establishment unless selected through a regular
selection process. Temporary Status, therefore, did not itself translate into
permanent appointment; the Scheme preserved a selection mechanism as
the gateway to entry into the regular establishment.
28. Learned counsel further submits that the service structure underwent a
subsequent change after implementation of the Sixth Central Pay
Commission. The erstwhile Group-D posts came to be placed in Group-C,
carrying Pay Band-1 and Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/-. Recruitment to the
corresponding Group-C posts thereafter came within the prescribed
selection framework, including recruitment through the Staff Selection
Commission. Consequently, regularisation of the petitioners could not be
effected by the concerned Department merely by reference to the 1993
Scheme, without conforming to the recruitment regime governing the
posts as they existed thereafter.
29. According to the Learned Counsel, the proper manner of giving continuing
effect to the 1993 Scheme, read with the changes brought about after the
Sixth Central Pay Commission, was to regulate a selection procedure
through which Casual Labourers possessing Temporary Status could
participate for appointment against the posts available for such purpose.
The concerned Department accordingly devised a selection process and
invited the CL-TS personnel to participate. The petitioners, however,
elected not to enter the selection process and instead pursued the present
writ proceedings.
30. The submission on behalf of the respondents proceeds further on the
circumstance that the petitioners have not mounted any substantive
challenge to the Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014. No
declaration has been sought that the said instruction is constitutionally
invalid, nor has the selection process initiated pursuant to the prevailing
recruitment regime been specifically assailed on such ground.
31. The Learned Counsel therefore submits that, so long as the Office
Memorandum dated 16th October 2014 and the selection procedure
framed pursuant thereto remain operative, the petitioners cannot seek a
direction permitting regularisation by bypassing the recruitment process.
The legal consequence of Temporary Status, according to the respondents,
has to be gathered from the Scheme itself: Temporary Status preserved
the petitioners within the category of casual workers entitled to
consideration against specified vacancies, while permanent entry into the
establishment remained dependent upon selection in accordance with the
applicable recruitment rules.
32. It is further submitted that the petitioners were afforded an opportunity to
participate in the selection process. Instead of availing themselves of that
opportunity, they chose to question the process through the present writ
petition. The respondents contend that a person who elects not to
participate in a selection process cannot thereafter seek appointment
through a route which dispenses with the very selection contemplated by
the governing scheme and the subsequent recruitment instructions.
33. The Learned Counsel accordingly submits that the petitioners’ case
cannot rest upon the mere passage of time or upon the conferment of
Temporary Status. The 1993 Scheme itself contemplated selection before
entry into the permanent establishment. The subsequent alteration of the
post structure after the Sixth Central Pay Commission and the
recruitment framework applicable to Group-C posts reinforce the
requirement of selection. The petitioners’ claim for direct regularisation,
without participation in the prescribed selection procedure, therefore
lacks support within the governing administrative framework.
34. The respondents accordingly seek dismissal of the writ petition,
contending that the petitioners have neither challenged the validity of the
Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014 nor established any legal
basis for setting aside the selection procedure framed pursuant to the
prevailing recruitment regime.
35. The Learned Counsel appearing for respondent Nos.3 to 7 submitted that
the petitioners were accorded Temporary Status by the Satyendra Nath
Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences in accordance with the rules
governing such engagement and upon acceptance of the terms and
conditions prescribed by the Centre from time to time. The record referred
to the letters dated 22nd July 1999 addressed to petitioner Nos.1, 3, 5, 6,
7, 8 and 9 and the letter dated 21 June 2000 addressed to petitioner
No.10. Each such communication stipulated the wages payable with
reference to the basic pay of the corresponding Group-D post, together
with DA and other admissible allowances, the benefits entitled during the
period of Temporary Status and the condition that the service could be
brought to an end upon one month's written notice. Having accepted the
respective terms and conditions the petitioners entered service on that
basis. A copy of the relevant letters has been produced as RN-1.
36. The Learned Counsel submits that the present claim for permanent
status has to be examined against the character of the engagement which
the petitioners themselves accepted. The record further shows that
petitioner No. 2 has already retired from service after receiving the
applicable retiral payments and pensionary benefits, while petitioner Nos.
4 and 11 have expired, with the benefits arising upon death having been
received by the respective dependants.
37. It is next submitted that the Centre has never regularised a casual
employee in the absence of a sanctioned post. At the relevant point of
time, two vacant posts carrying Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/- were available.
The Centre initiated a process for filling such vacancies from amongst the
twelve personnel holding Temporary Status. Three petitioners were
shortlisted from amongst the twelve candidates in accordance with the
applicable
recruitment
parameters
and
the
instructions
of
the
Department of Personnel and Training. The shortlisting process proceeded
upon the minimum educational qualification of Matriculation or ITI pass,
as prescribed by DoPT O.M. No. 49014/3/2014-Estt.(C) dated 16 October
2014.
38. The Learned Counsel further submits that the petitioners were afforded
an avenue for consideration against the available vacancies, yet did not
participate
in
the
recruitment
advertised
vacancies
in
the
process.
Group-C
The
Centre
category
subsequently
arising
upon
superannuation and, according to the respondents, none of the writ
petitioners submitted an application against such vacancies. The Centre
possesses only 24 sanctioned administrative posts, and recruitment
against such posts is carried through open advertisement in accordance
with the applicable recruitment regime.
39. The further submission is that the Centre, being an autonomous research
institute under the Department of Science and Technology, Ministry of
Science and Technology, Government of India, functions in accordance
with governmental rules, norms and directions transmitted through the
Department of Science and Technology, together with its own Bye-Laws
approved by that Department for administrative and academic purposes.
The Centre does not possess authority to create posts on its own.
Requests have, according to the Learned Counsel, repeatedly been
addressed to the Department of Science and Technology seeking creation
or sanction of additional posts, but no fresh posts have been sanctioned
by the Ministry. Consequently, regularisation cannot be directed in
disregard of the sanctioned strength of the establishment.
40. The Learned Counsel places particular reliance upon the order dated 9th
March 2017 in W.P. No. 16543(W) of 2016, Sudhanshu Chakraborty &
Others v. Union of India & Others, by which the Learned Single Judge
directed the Governing Body of the Centre to take a decision upon the
petitioners'
prayer
for
regularisation
within
eight
weeks
from
communication of the order. The order contemplated that, if the
Governing Body considered the petitioners entitled to regularisation,
necessary consequential orders would follow; if the claim was not
accepted, a reasoned order was to be passed and communicated
individually within two weeks thereafter. Learned counsel stresses that
the Court expressly refrained from entering into the merits of the claim
and recorded that the order was not an expression of any opinion
regarding entitlement to regularisation. A copy of the order was annexed
as RN-2.
41. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, the Director placed the matter before
the Governing Body on 23rd March 2017. The Governing Body thereafter
directed that the existing vacancies carrying Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/- be
filled through a selection process amongst personnel holding Temporary
Status. The Centre accordingly proceeded with shortlisting in accordance
with the applicable DoPT instructions and recruitment parameters. The
respondents maintain that the selection exercise was therefore not an
administrative
device
devised
to
defeat
the
petitioners'
claim;
it
represented the mode adopted for filling sanctioned vacancies in
compliance with the governing recruitment framework and the order of 9 th
March 2017.
42. The Learned Counsel disputes the petitioners' contention that the Centre
had introduced a fresh or arbitrary avenue of recruitment under the guise
of regularisation. The Centre, according to the submission, followed the
recruitment procedure prescribed by the DoPT and acted upon the
decision of its Governing Body after the High Court had directed the
competent authority to decide the claim. The petitioners were afforded
participation in the selection process, but chose not to appear. The
respondents accordingly contend that the petitioners cannot assail a
selection process which they declined to enter.
43. With regard to the character of the duties performed by the petitioners,
learned counsel submits that the work relates principally to cleaning,
housekeeping and gardening. According to the Centre, such activities are
capable of being outsourced and have, in fact, been outsourced from time
to time, having regard to the size of the campus and the expansion of
institutional activities. At the same time, the Centre has adopted a
sympathetic approach
towards the
petitioners
by assigning
them
responsibilities in different administrative sections in addition to cleaning,
gardening and allied work, so that they remain meaningfully engaged
during working hours.
44. On the question of creation of posts, the Learned Counsel maintains that
the Centre cannot itself generate sanctioned posts merely because a claim
for regularisation has been raised. The Centre has approached the
Department of Science and Technology on several occasions for additional
posts, but no such posts have been sanctioned. The respondents therefore
submit that the Court may not direct absorption against posts which do
not exist within the sanctioned establishment.
45. The Learned Counsel also addresses the petitioners' grievance concerning
medical facilities. Reference is made to Clause 3(c) of the Contributory
Medical Scheme, under which a member of the family of a deceased
employee who was in permanent employment and was a member of the
Scheme, upon continuation of the prescribed contribution by the family
member residing in Kolkata, remains eligible for medical reimbursement.
The Centre states that, having regard to the social-security dimension of
the matter, medical reimbursement facilities had been extended to the
petitioners and their family members during service and that medical
reimbursement facilities were also extended to the petitioners after
retirement.
46. In this connection, reliance is placed upon the minutes of the Medical
Committee
meeting
No.R1/Admn./Office
dated
July
and
Office
Order
Order/2024-25/716
dated
16th
August
2024,
collectively marked RN-3.
25th
The
Medical Committee
considered
the
possibility of extending OPD treatment reimbursement to staff holding
Temporary Status and examined the position concerning medical facilities
for dependants of deceased personnel and retired personnel holding
Temporary Status. The Committee recorded the existing position under
Clause 3(c) of the CMS and recommended that, after retirement,
personnel
holding
Temporary
Status
could
be
considered
for
reimbursement of medical claims, while reimbursement to dependent
family members would not extend beyond the permissible scope of the
Scheme.
For
emergency
hospital
treatment
of
personnel
holding
Temporary Status, reimbursement was proposed to be considered on a
case-to-case basis, subject to approval of the competent authority and
supporting medical records.
47. Finally, the Learned Counsel submits that the decisions of the Supreme
Court cited on behalf of the petitioners do not operate upon the present
controversy in the same manner. The petitioners, according to the
respondents, are already in service under Temporary Status and receive
increments, pay revisions corresponding to successive Pay Commission
recommendations and other leave-related benefits, including medical
reimbursement facilities. The factual and service conditions considered in
the authorities cited by the petitioners are, therefore, said to be materially
different from the circumstances obtaining in the present proceedings.
48. The submission on behalf of respondent Nos. 3 to 7, in its essence, is that
Temporary Status does not itself confer permanent appointment;
regularisation has to operate within the sanctioned establishment and
through the recruitment procedure governing the post concerned; the
Centre has no independent authority to create posts; the petitioners were
afforded consideration against the two sanctioned vacancies but did not
participate in the selection; and the order dated 9th March 2017 required
a decision by the Governing Body in accordance with law, without
expressing
any
determination
entitlement to regularisation.
upon
the
petitioners'
substantive
49. The petitioners are persons who have served the Satyendra Nath Bose
National Centre for Basic Sciences, Kolkata, for prolonged periods as
casual labourers with Temporary Status. Their grievance concerns the
failure of the respondent authorities to carry their cases to their logical
administrative conclusion despite the conferment of Temporary Status,
the length of service rendered thereafter and the repeated consideration of
the issue of their regularisation at the institutional and governmental
levels.
50. The petitioners assert that their engagement did not remain confined to
any transient or sporadic requirement. They continued to discharge
duties entrusted to them by the Centre over several years. Temporary
Status was conferred upon them at different points of time and the service
relationship thereafter continued for considerable periods.
51. The petitioners rely upon the scheme framed by the Department of
Personnel and Training by Office Memorandum dated 10 th September
1993 concerning Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status and
Regularisation). The scheme contemplated conferment of Temporary
Status upon qualifying casual labourers without reference to the creation
or existence of regular Group-D posts. Paragraph 8 of the scheme
contemplated filling two out of every three vacancies in Group-D cadres,
in accordance with the extant recruitment rules and the instructions of
the Department of Personnel and Training, from casual workers
possessing Temporary Status.
52. The scheme also made it clear that conferment of Temporary Status by
itself did not place a casual worker on the permanent establishment.
Regular appointment was to follow the prescribed selection process. The
scheme, therefore, created a structured relationship between Temporary
Status, the existence of regular vacancies and the process prescribed for
regular appointment.
53. The subsequent evolution of the Central Government establishment
altered the nomenclature and recruitment structure of the posts
concerned. Following the Sixth Central Pay Commission, the erstwhile
Group-D posts were placed in Group-C, Pay Band-1 with Grade Pay of
Rs.1,800/-. The minimum educational qualification and the mode of
recruitment consequently came to be regulated by the subsequent
instructions governing such posts.
54. Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014 issued by the Department of
Personnel and Training assumed significance in this context. The
memorandum recorded that the 1993 Scheme was not an ongoing scheme
and stated, in express terms, that regularisation of Casual Labourers with
Temporary Status could not be undertaken by Ministries or Departments
on their own and required relaxation of paragraph 8 of the Appendix to
the Office Memorandum dated 10th September 1993. The memorandum
further required Ministries and Departments to examine the position of
the remaining Casual Labourers with Temporary Status and to place
consolidated proposals before the competent governmental authorities.
55. The administrative record demonstrates that the Centre did not treat the
matter as closed. A communication dated 28th November 2014 was
addressed to the Department of Science and Technology forwarding
particulars concerning the Casual Labourers with Temporary Status. An
email dated 26th March 2015 also emanated from the Registrar in
connection with the question of regularisation. The Centre thereby placed
the question before the governmental hierarchy rather than treating the
status
of
the
petitioners
as
a
matter
confined
to
the
internal
administration of the Centre.
56. A communication dated 9th March 2016 further records the position that
the Government had entrusted the respondent institution with authority
to decide the claim relating to regularisation, the matter being within its
jurisdiction. The subsequent proceedings, however, demonstrate that the
Centre
itself
considered
the
question
of
sanctioned
posts
and
governmental approval to be material to any final course of action.
57. The petitioners had earlier approached this Court in W.P. 16543(W) of
2016. By order dated 9th March 2017, the Court directed the Governing
Body of the Centre to take a decision within the stipulated period. The
direction contemplated a decision in accordance with law and procedure.
A consequential order was to follow if the petitioners were held entitled to
relief; in the event of a contrary conclusion, a reasoned order was required
to be passed and communicated.
58. The order dated 9th March 2017 did not adjudicate the substantive
entitlement of the petitioners to regularisation. No declaration of a vested
right to permanent appointment was made. The administrative authority
was required to undertake the decision-making exercise in accordance
with the governing legal framework.
59. The Governing Body considered the matter at its meeting held on 23 rd
March 2017. The deliberation assumed significance because the Centre
recorded that regularisation depended upon the existence of suitable
Group-C posts and that the Centre did not possess a sufficient number of
such posts. The Governing Body also considered the question whether the
instructions of the Department of Personnel and Training could be
implemented against the posts existing at the Centre and whether
appropriate age relaxation could be extended.
60. The Centre thereafter addressed the Department of Science and
Technology by letter dated 6th April 2017, bearing No. SNB/FA-2-002/1718/024. The communication referred to the proceedings in W.P. 16543(W)
of 2016, the order dated 9th March 2017 and the deliberations of the
Governing Body dated 23rd March 2017.
61. The letter dated 6th April 2017 recorded, inter alia, that the Centre lacked
a sufficient number of Group-C posts carrying Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/for regularisation of all the concerned personnel. The Centre sought
advice
concerning
implementation
of
the
relevant
Department
of
Personnel and Training instructions against the posts existing at the
Centre and the question of age relaxation. More importantly, the Centre
requested the Department of Science and Technology to sanction suitable
Group-C posts so that the incumbents could be considered for
regularisation.
62. The communication dated 6th April 2017 thus bears directly upon the
controversy. The Centre itself perceived the question of regularisation as
requiring consideration at the level of the governmental authority
concerned
with
its
establishment.
The
administrative
process
contemplated by the Centre had consequently travelled beyond a mere
internal determination by the Governing Body.
63. The Reasoned Order dated 16th May 2017 was thereafter passed. The
order proceeded upon the premise that the question of regularisation had
to be examined in the context of the posts existing at the Centre and the
prevailing recruitment instructions.
64. The subsequent letters dated 14th August 2017 show that the Centre
proceeded to fill existing vacancies through a selection process amongst
personnel possessing Temporary Status. The Selection Committee had
been constituted pursuant to the decision of the Director. The Committee
met on 9 August 2017 and considered the qualifications of the twelve
personnel possessing Temporary Status.
65. The letters dated 14th August 2017 referred to the minimum qualification
of Matriculation or ITI prescribed by the Department of Personnel and
Training Office Memorandum dated 16 th October 2014. The letters also
referred to three years' continuous service after conferment of Temporary
Status as one of the criteria. Since the Centre did not have its own
Recruitment Rules for the posts concerned, the model Recruitment Rules
contained in Office Memorandum dated 30th April 2010 were relied upon.
66. A written and skill test was fixed for 23rd August 2017. The petitioners,
through their advocate's communication dated 22nd August 2017,
declined to participate in the proposed test. The communication
specifically questioned the legal basis of applying the recruitment regime
contained in the Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014 to persons
whose claims for regularisation had arisen from their earlier conferment
of Temporary Status and prolonged service.
67. The petitioners also contended in the communication dated 22nd August
2017 that the Reasoned Order dated 16th May 2017 had not addressed
the continuity of their service in the manner contemplated by the earlier
proceedings. They further asserted that the recruitment instructions of
16th October 2014 could not retrospectively determine their claim for
regularisation or permanent absorption.
68. It
is
imperative
to
replicate
the
following
Orders/Notifications/Circulars/Correspondences to assess the instant
disputations.
69. The Office Memorandum dated 16th October, 2014 issued by the Director
(Estt.), Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions, Government
of India is replicated as follows:“OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Regularization of Casual Labour with Temporary Status(CLTS)-Proposals from Ministries/Departments on -regarding.
The undersigned is directed to say that Casual Labourers (Grant
of Temporary Status & Regularisation). Scheme of Government of
India, 1993, circulated vide DOPT OM No. 51016/2/90-Estt(C) dated
10.09.1993, stipulated conditions for grant of temporary status and
regularization of services to the persons recruited on daily wage basis
in the Central Government Offices as on 10.09.1993. It was held in the
Mohan Pal Case SLP (Civil) No. 2224/2000 that the Scheme of 1-9-93
is not an ongoing Scheme and the temporary status can be conferred
on the casual labourers under that Scheme only if they were in
employment on the date of the commencement of the scheme and they
should have rendered continuous service of at least one year i.e. at
least 240 days in a year or 206 days (in case of offices having 5 days
a week). The Scheme inter-alia provided for regularization of CL-TS
against Group 'D' posts.
2. Following the acceptance of the recommendation of the 6th
CPC, all Group D posts have been upgraded to Group C posts.
Recruitment to erstwhile Group 'D' posts placed in Group 'C'. PB-1,
Grade Pay 1800/- (non technical as MT Staff) is now made only
through
Staff
qualification
Selection
for
Commission
appointment
is
and
minimum
Matriculation
or
educational
ITI
pass.
Regularisation of CL-TS therefore cannot be done by the Ministries/
Departments on their own and requires relaxation of para-8 of the
Appendix to the O.M. dated 10.09.1993.
3. This Department vide O.M No. 49011/31/2008-Estt(C) dated
17th February, 2009 had requested all Ministries/ Department to
provide information relating to CL-TS on their rolls. Information relating
to 231 CL-TS was received from 29 Ministries/Departments which
were processed. Since then this Department has been receiving
proposals piece-meal from different Departments.
4. Department of Expenditure have now advised this Department
that in order to avoid piece-meal examination of such proposals, a
consolidated proposal for regularization of all such remaining CL-TS
who were on the rolls of the Ministries/Departments on 10.09.1993
and yet could not be regularized may be forwarded to them for further
consideration/examination. Therefore, all Ministries/Departments are
requested to review the position at their establishments and send a
consolidated proposals for regularization of services of such remaining
CL-TS on their rolls (including attached/subordinate and autonomous
bodies), if any, latest by 30.11.2014 to this Department in the enclosed
format. It may be ensured that complete information in respect of the
Ministry/Department and its Attached/Subordinate Offices is sent.
The information may also be sent by e-mail(in MS Word) at dse@nic.in.
……….”
70. The Office Memorandum dated February 26th, 2016 issued by the Director
(E), Ministry of Personnel, Public Girevances and PG, Department of
Personnel and Training, Establishment Division stated as follows:“OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Casual Labourers with temporary status-clarification
regarding contribution to GPF and Pension under the old pension
scheme
Undersigned is directed to refer to this Department's OM No.
51016/2/90-Estt (C) dated the 10th September, 1993 vide which a
scheme for grant of temporary status to the casual employees was
framed. The scheme applied to those casual labourers who were in
employment on the date of the issue of the OM and had rendered one
year of continued service in Central Government offices, which meant
that they must have been engaged for a period of at least 240 days
(206 days in the case of offices observing 5 days week). The scheme
did not apply to Departments of Telecom & Posts and Ministry of
Railways.
2. As per the scheme, after rendering three years' continuous
service after conferment of temporary status, the casual labourers
were to be treated at par with temporary Group 'D' employees for the
purpose of contribution to the General Provident Fund. Further, after
their regularisation, 50% of the service rendered under temporary
status would be counted for the purpose of retirement benefits.
3. As per para 8 of the scheme, two out of every three vacancies
in Group 'D' cadres in respective offices where the casual labourers
have been working would be filled up as per extant recruitment rules
and in accordance with the instructions issued by Department of
Personnel and Training from amongst casual workers with temporary
status.) However, regular Group 'D' staff rendered surplus for any
reason will have prior claim for absorption against existing/future
vacancies. In case of illiterate casual labourers or those who fail to
fulfill the minimum qualification prescribed for post, regularisation will
be considered only against those posts in respect of which literacy or
lack of minimum qualification will not be a requisite qualification. They
would be allowed age relaxation equivalent to the period for which
they have worked continuously as casual labourer.
4. Vide the O.M. No.49014/1/2004 -Estt (C) dated the 26th April,
2004, the above scheme was reviewed in the light of introduction of
New Pension Scheme in respect of persons appointed to the Central
Government service on or after 1.1.2004 as under:
(i) As the new pension scheme is based on defined contributions,
the length of qualifying service for the purpose of retirement
benefits has lost its relevance, no credit of casual service, as
specified in para 5 (v), shall be available to the casual labourers
on their regularisation against Group 'D' posts on or after
1.1.2004
(ii) As there is no provision of General Provident Fund in the new
pension scheme, it will not serve any useful purpose to continue
deductions towards GPF from the existing casual employees, in
terms of para 5 (vi) of the scheme for grant of temporary status.
It is, therefore, requested that no further deduction towards
General Provident Fund shall be effected from the casual
labourers w. e. f. 1.1.2004 onwards and the amount lying in
their General Provident Fund accounts, including deductions
made after 1.1.2004, shall be paid to them.
2. The existing guidelines contained in this Department's OM No.
49014/2/86-Estt.( C) dated 7.6.88 may continue to be followed
in the matter of engagement of casual workers in the Central
Government Offices.
5. The OM dated 26th April, 2004 has been quashed by various
benches of CAT/High Courts who have decided that the scheme could
not be modified retrospectively. The SLPs filed in the Hon'ble Supreme
Court have been dismissed by the Apex Court in UOI & Ors v
Rameshwar Singh, CC 1829/2014, UOI & Ors v Ramsaran & Ors, SLP
(C) No. 25360-25362 of 2008, SLP 17358/2008, SLP 25360-62/09,
Union of India etc v Ajay Kumar & Ors, SLP No.19673-19678/2009.
6. The position has been reviewed in the light of the Court
judgements in consultation with the Department of Expenditure. It has
now been decided that the casual labourers who had been granted
temporary status under the scheme, and have completed 3 years of
continuous service after that, are entitled to contribute to the General
Provident Fund.
7. 50% of the service rendered under temporary status would be
counted for the purpose of retirement benefits in respect of those
casual labourers who have been regularised in terms of para 8 of the
OM dated 10.09. 1993.
8. It is emphasised that the benefit of temporary status is
available only to those casual labourers who were in employment on
the date of the issue of the OM dated 10th September, 1993 and were
otherwise eligible for it. No grant of temporary status is permissible
after that date. The employees erroneously granted temporary status
between 10.09.1993 and the date of Hon'ble Supreme Court
judgement in Union Of India And Anr vs Mohan Pal, 2002 (3) SCR 613,
delivered on 29 April, 2002, will however be deemed to have been
covered under the scheme of 10.09.93.
9. Ministries/Departments are also requested to identify cases
where temporary status has been granted wrongly to those not
covered under the OM dated 10.09.1993 and fix responsibility for the
same.
……….”
71. The Office Memorandum dated 28th July, 2016 of the Director (E),
Ministry of Personnel, P.G. & Pensions, Department of Personnel &
Training, Government of India, stated as follows:“OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Casual labourers with temporary status clarification regarding
contribution of GPF and Pension under the Old Pension Scheme.
The undersigned is directed to refer to this Department's OM of
even number dated 26th February, 2016 on the above subject and to
say that some references have been received in this Department from
various Ministries/Departments seeking a clarification with regard to
the Para 7 of the referred OM.
2. The OM was issued in consultation with Department of
Expenditure and the Department of Pension and PW. It was clarified
vide that OM that this Department's O.M dated 26th April, 2004 had
been quashed in a series of Orders/Judgements. The OM dated 26th
February, 2016 restores the provisions of the Scheme as it existed
prior to the OM dated 26th April, 2004. The benefit of GPF and Old
Pension Scheme is applicable to all those casual labourers who are
covered under the Scheme of the 10th September, 1993 even if they
have been regularized on or after 01/01/2004.
3. As the benefit of Old Pension Scheme and GPF is admissible
only to those Casual workers who are covered under the Scheme of
1993, all Ministries/ Department may strictly ensure that it does not
lead to demand by regularly recruited fresh employees appointed on or
after 1.1.2004for similar benefit in place of NPS.
4. This issues with the concurrence of Department of Expenditure
vide their 1.D.No.1(15)/E-V/2015 dated 27.07.2016
……….”
72. The
Communication
No.SNB/FA-2-002/15-16/1035
dated
16 th
November, of the Registrar, addressing to Dr. M. Prithviraj, Ninistry of
Science & Technology, Department of Science & Technology, replicated as
follows:“Sub: Regularization of casual labour with Temporary Status (CL-TS)
Dear Sir,
This is in reference to your letter no. SG/AI/Misc/B1/2015 dated
27.10.15 regarding the above subject matter.
Please note that the Centre has 12 persons on payroll in the
Temporary Status, the details of whom were provided to DST vide
letter no. SNB/FA-2-002/14-15/1153 dated 28 November 2015 (copy
enclosed). Shri. Nimai Naskar's details is mentioned in S1 No. 12 of the
above referenced letter. A reminder to this letter was also given vide email dated 26 March 2015 (copy enclosed).
The Centre will be happy to provide you any specific information
that you may require in this respect
Thanking you,
……….”
73. The Communication No.SNB/FA-2-002/17-18/024 dated 06 th April, 2017
of the Registrar, addressing to Dr. Praveer Asthana, Scientist-G, Head (AI
and Mega Sc. Div.), Ministry of Science & Technology, Department of
Science & Technology, is stated as follows:“Sub: Regularisation of Casual Labour with Temporary Status (CL-TS)
of SNBNCBS, Kolkata,
Re: W.P.16543 (W) of 2016 in the matter of Mr. Sudhanshu
Chakraborty & Others vs Union of India & Others.
Dear Sir,
As you may kindly recall the matter of regularisation of CL-TS
employees of the Centre was reported in the 53rd Governing Body
meeting held on 23 March 2017 under "Any Other Item' with respect to
an order passed by Dr. Sambuddha Chakrabarti, Hon'ble Judge High
Court dated 09.03.2017 which was placed in the meeting. You were
also present in the meeting as a nominee of Secretary, DST. During the
course of discussion in the meeting, the Governing Body made the
following observations:
(i) Any regularisation would require post availability. At present
the Centre does not have sufficient positions in the Group 'C'
grade pays. If such positions are available, in the advise is
sought as to whether the guidelines of DOPT (marked as
Appendix)
be
implemented
for
regularisation
of
CL-TS
employees against these positions. Also, advice as to whether
age
relaxation
can
be
permitted
in
the
age-limit
for
regularisation of such incumbents.
(ii) Till the time, all the other positions become available with the
Centre, they have to wait.
(iii) The Centre also requests DST to sanction suitable positions in
the Group 'C' grade pays so that all the incumbents can be
regularised against them.
(iv) Also, it may kindly be noted that the steps taken by the Centre
in this regard are also to be appropriately informed to the
Hon'ble High Court, as directed in the order dated 09.03.2017
and also to the incumbents within 8 to 10 weeks from the date
of communication of the order,
The Centre thus seeks the intervention of DST for providing
suitable positions in the Group 'C' grade so that the CL-TS employees,
who have long being associated with the Centre, are regularised. A
copy of the judgement (Annexure A) dated 09.03.2017 and a detailed
description of the 12 employees who are in TS status (Annexure IB) is
enclosed herewith for kind perusal
Other relevant documents
regarding communication with DST regarding TS employees are
enclosed (Annexure C) for your kind perusal.
……….”
74. The principal question arising for determination is not whether a Court
exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 can itself create Group-C posts
or direct the conversion of the existing cadre. Such a course would travel
beyond the judicial function. The question is whether the respondents
completed the administrative exercise required for consideration of the
petitioners' claim after the Centre itself identified the requirement of
suitable posts and formally sought governmental intervention for that
purpose.
75. The distinction is material. Creation, sanction, abolition or restructuring
of posts ordinarily belongs to the executive establishment and financial
authorities entrusted with such matters. Judicial review, however,
extends to the legality of the decision-making process, the consideration
of relevant statutory and administrative norms and the performance of a
duty which the authority has undertaken to discharge.
76. The principle governing regularisation cannot be stated without reference
to Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1. The
Supreme Court drew a distinction between appointments which were
illegal and appointments which were irregular, while recognising a onetime measure for duly qualified persons who had rendered ten years or
more of service in duly sanctioned vacant posts, subject to the conditions
stipulated by the Constitution Bench.
77. Official Liquidator v. Dayanand, (2008) 10 SCC 1, also requires due regard.
The Supreme Court reiterated the limits of judicial intervention in matters
concerning
creation
regularisation.
The
of
posts,
judgment
recruitment,
cautions
cadre
against
structure
judicial
and
directions
compelling the executive to create supernumerary posts for the purpose of
absorbing temporary or daily-rated employees.
78. The present adjudication does not require departure from either of the
aforesaid principles. No direction is warranted for creation of a post by
judicial fiat. No supernumerary post is being created by this order. No
appointment is being made by the Court. The executive authorities
remain responsible for determining the number, nature and sanction of
posts in accordance with the governing governmental procedure.
79. The later decisions of the Supreme Court, however, demonstrate that
Umadevi (supra) cannot be read as a rule by which prolonged service in
an enduring institutional requirement becomes legally irrelevant in every
circumstance.
80. In Sheo Narain Nagar v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2018) 13 SCC 432,
paragraph 9, the Supreme Court applied the principle of one-time
regularisation to employees who had rendered prolonged service and
whose cases fell within the parameters identified in Umadevi (3) (2006) 4
SCC 1.
81. In the case of Sheo Narain Nagar v. State of U.P. 1, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court made the following observation:
“9. The High Court dismissed the writ application relying on the decision
in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006
SCC (L&S) 753] . But the appellants were employed basically in the year
1993; they had rendered service for three years, when they were offered the
service on contract basis; it was not the case of back door entry; and there
(2018) 13 SCC 432
were no Rules in place for offering such kind of appointment. Thus, the
appointment could not be said to be illegal and in contravention of Rules, as
there were no such Rules available at the relevant point of time, when their
temporary status was conferred w.e.f. 2-10-2002. The appellants were
required to be appointed on regular basis as a one-time measure, as laid
down in para 53 of Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] . Since the appellants had completed 10 years
of service and temporary status had been given by the respondents with
retrospective effect from 2-10-2002, we direct that the services of the
appellants be regularised from the said date i.e. 2-10-2002, consequential
benefits and the arrears of pay also to be paid to the appellants within a
period of three months from today.”
82. In Narendra Kumar Tiwari v. State of Jharkhand, (2018) 8 SCC 238, the
Supreme Court cautioned against an interpretation of Umadevi which
would permit prolonged temporary engagement to become a means of
perpetual denial of regular status where the circumstances otherwise
attracted the governing regularisation framework.
83. In the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari v. State of Jharkhand2, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court made the following observation:
“6. The concept of a one-time measure was further explained
in Kesari [State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari, (2010) 9 SCC 247 :
(2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826] in paras 9, 10 and 11 of the Report which
read as follows: (SCC pp. 250-51, paras 9-11)
“9. The term “one-time measure” has to be understood in its proper
perspective. This would normally mean that after the decision
in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 753] , each department or each instrumentality
should undertake a one-time exercise and prepare a list of all
casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees who have been working for
more than ten years without the intervention of courts and tribunals
and subject them to a process verification as to whether they are
(2018) 8 SCC 238
working against vacant posts and possess the requisite qualification
for the post and if so, regularise their services.
10. At the end of six months from the date of decision in Umadevi
(3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC
(L&S) 753] , cases of several daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees
were still pending before courts. Consequently, several departments
and instrumentalities did not commence the one-time regularisation
process. On the other hand, some government departments or
instrumentalities undertook the one-time exercise excluding several
employees from consideration either on the ground that their cases
were pending in courts or due to sheer oversight. In such
circumstances, the employees who were entitled to be considered in
terms
of
para 53
of
the
decision
in Umadevi (3) [State
of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] ,
will not lose their right to be considered for regularisation, merely
because the one-time exercise was completed without considering
their cases, or because the six-month period mentioned in para 53
of Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 753] has expired. The one-time exercise should
consider all daily-wage/ad hoc/casual employees who had put in
10 years of continuous service as on 10-4-2006 without availing the
protection of any interim orders of courts or tribunals. If any
employer had held the one-time exercise in terms of para 53
of Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 753] , but did not consider the cases of some
employees who were entitled to the benefit of para 53 of Umadevi
(3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC
(L&S) 753] , the employer concerned should consider their cases
also, as a continuation of the one-time exercise. The one-time
exercise will be concluded only when all the employees who are
entitled to be considered in terms of para 53 of Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] ,
are so considered.
11. The object behind the said direction in para 53 of Umadevi
(3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC
(L&S) 753] is twofold. First is to ensure that those who have put in
more than ten years of continuous service without the protection of
any interim orders of courts or tribunals, before the date of decision
in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
SCC
(L&S)
753]
was
rendered,
are
considered
for
regularisation in view of their long service. Second is to ensure that
the departments/instrumentalities do not perpetuate the practice of
employing persons on daily-wage/ad hoc/casual basis for long
periods and then periodically regularise them on the ground that
they have served for more than ten years, thereby defeating the
constitutional or statutory provisions relating to recruitment and
appointment. The true effect of the direction is that all persons who
have worked for more than ten years as on 10-4-2006 [the date of
decision in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] ] without the protection of any interim
order of any court or tribunal, in vacant posts, possessing the
requisite
qualification,
are
entitled
to
be
considered
for
regularisation. The fact that the employer has not undertaken such
exercise of regularisation within six months of the decision
in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 753] or that such exercise was undertaken only in
regard to a limited few, will not disentitle such employees, the right
to be considered for regularisation in terms of the above directions
in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 753] as a one-time measure.”
7. The purpose and intent of the decision in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] was
therefore twofold, namely, to prevent irregular or illegal appointments
in the future and secondly, to confer a benefit on those who had been
irregularly appointed in the past. The fact that the State of Jharkhand
continued with the irregular appointments for almost a decade after
the decision in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006)
4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] is a clear indication that it believes
that it was all right to continue with irregular appointments, and
whenever required, terminate the services of the irregularly appointed
employees on the ground that they were irregularly appointed. This is
nothing but a form of exploitation of the employees by not giving them
the benefits of regularisation and by placing the sword of Damocles
over
their
head.
This
is
precisely
what Umadevi (3) [State
of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]
and Kesari [State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari, (2010) 9 SCC 247 :
(2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826] sought to avoid.
8. If a strict and literal interpretation, forgetting the spirit of the
decision
of
the
Constitution
Bench
in Umadevi
(3) [State
of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] , is
to be taken into consideration then no irregularly appointed employee
of the State of Jharkhand could ever be regularised since that State
came into existence only on 15-11-2000 and the cut-off date was fixed
as 10-4-2006. In other words, in this manner the pernicious practice of
indefinitely continuing irregularly appointed employees would be
perpetuated contrary to the intent of the Constitution Bench.
9. The High Court as well as the State of Jharkhand ought to have
considered the entire issue in a contextual perspective and not only
from the point of view of the interest of the State, financial or otherwise
— the interest of the employees is also required to be kept in mind.
What has eventually been achieved by the State of Jharkhand is to
short circuit the process of regular appointments and instead make
appointments on an irregular basis. This is hardly good governance.
10. Under
the
circumstances,
we
are
of
the
view
that
the
Regularisation Rules must be given a pragmatic interpretation and the
appellants, if they have completed 10 years of service on the date of
promulgation of the Regularisation Rules, ought to be given the benefit
of the service rendered by them. If they have completed 10 years of
service they should be regularised unless there is some valid objection
to their regularisation like misconduct, etc.
11. The impugned judgment and order [Anil Kumar Sinha v. State of
Jharkhand, 2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2904] passed by the High Court is
set aside in view of our conclusions. The State should take a decision
within four months from today on regularisation of the status of the
appellants. The appeals are accordingly disposed of.
12. We may add that that it would be worthwhile for the State of
Jharkhand to henceforth consider making regular appointments only
and dropping the idea of making irregular appointments so as to short
circuit the process of regular appointments.”
84. In Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, (2024) 9 SCC 327, the Supreme Court
examined prolonged service and the manner in which initial procedural
circumstances should be assessed against the subsequent course of
employment. The judgment recognised that the substance of the
employment relationship cannot always be reduced to the terminology
used at its inception.
85. In the case of Vinod Kumar v. Union of India3, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court made the following observation:
“7. The judgment in Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3),
(2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] also distinguished between
“irregular” and “illegal” appointments underscoring the importance of
considering certain appointments even if were not made strictly in
accordance with the prescribed Rules and Procedure, cannot be said to
have been made illegally if they had followed the procedures of regular
appointments such as conduct of written examinations or interviews
as in the present case. Para 53 of Umadevi (3) case [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] is
reproduced hereunder : (SCC p. 42)
“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where
irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as explained
(2024) 9 SCC 327
in S.V. Narayanappa [State of Mysore v. S.V. Narayanappa, 1966
SCC OnLine SC 23] , R.N. Nanjundappa [R.N. Nanjundappa v. T.
Thimmiah,
(1972)
SCC
409]
and B.N.
Nagarajan [B.N.
Nagarajan v. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 507 : 1980 SCC
(L&S) 4] and referred to in para 15 above, of duly qualified persons
in duly sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the
employees have continued to work for ten years or more but without
the intervention of orders of the courts or of tribunals. The question
of regularisation of the services of such employees may have to be
considered on merits in the light of the principles settled by this
Court in the cases abovereferred to and in the light of this judgment.
In that context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their
instrumentalities should take steps to regularise as a one-time
measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who have
worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under
cover of orders of the courts or of tribunals and should further
ensure that regular recruitments are undertaken to fill those vacant
sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases where
temporary employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The
process must be set in motion within six months from this date. We
also clarify that regularisation, if any already made, but not sub
judice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but there
should be no further bypassing of the constitutional requirement and
regularising or making permanent, those not duly appointed as per
the constitutional scheme.”
(emphasis in original)
8. In light of the reasons recorded above, this Court finds merit in the
appellants' arguments and holds that their service conditions, as
evolved over time, warrant a reclassification from temporary to regular
status. The failure to recognise the substantive nature of their roles
and their continuous service akin to permanent employees runs
counter to the principles of equity, fairness, and the intent behind
employment regulations.
9. Accordingly, the appeals are allowed. The judgment [Vinod
Kumar v. Central Administrative Tribunal, 2016 SCC OnLine All 4489]
of the High Court is set aside, and the appellants are entitled to be
considered for regularisation in their respective posts. The respondents
are directed to complete the process of regularisation within 3 months
from the date of service of this judgment.”
86. In Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. v. Brajrajnagar Coal Mines Workers' Union,
2024 SCC OnLine SC 270, the Supreme Court considered prolonged
engagement in work of a regular and perennial character and declined to
sustain a distinction which lacked a rational basis in the actual nature of
the work and service rendered.
87. In the case of Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. v. Brajrajnagar Coal Mines
Workers' Union4, the Hon’ble Supreme Court made the following observation:
“27. A tabulated representation of the above description is as follows:
Site of
No. of
No. of workers
No. of workers
work
workers
who were
not regularised
who
regularised
executed
works
Bunker
Coal
—
handling
plant
Railway
siding
Total
28. The above-referred facts speak for themselves, and that is the
reason why the Tribunal has come to a conclusion that the denial of
regularisation of the 13 workmen is wholly unjustified. As stated
(2024) 19 SCC 345
previously, we do not find any grounds in the artificial distinction
asserted by the appellant. However, as the case was argued at length
we thought it appropriate to give reasons for rejecting the appeals.
What we have referred to hereinabove are all findings of fact by the
Tribunal as affirmed by the High Court. In view of the concurrent
findings of fact on the issue of nature of work, the continuing nature of
work, continuous working of the workmen, we are of the opinion that
there is no merit in the appeals filed by the appellant.
29. This
is
a
case
of
wrongful
denial
of
employment
and
regularisation, for no fault of the workmen and therefore, there will be
no order restricting their wages.
30. With respect to payment of back wages, we are of the opinion that
the workmen will be entitled to back wages as observed by the
Industrial Tribunal. However, taking into account, the long-drawn
litigation affecting the workmen as well as the appellant in equal
measure and taking into account the public interest, we confine the
back wages to be calculated from the decision of the Tribunal dated
23-5-2002. This is the only modification in the order of the Tribunal,
and as was affirmed by the judgment of the High Court.
31. For the reasons stated above, the appeals arising out of the final
judgment and order [Mahanadi Coalfields v. Brajrajnagar Coal Mines
Workers' Union, WP (C) No. 2002 of 2002, order dated 11-1-2017 (Ori)]
of the High Court in WP (C) No. 2002 of 2002 and order [Mahanadi
Coalfields Ltd. v. Brajrajnagar Coal Mines Workers' Union, 2021 SCC
OnLine Ori 2488] in Review Petition No. 77 of 2017 are dismissed with
the direction that the workmen concerned shall be entitled to back
wages with effect from 23-5-2002. There shall be no order as to costs.”
88. Ushaben Joshi v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2277, also
illustrates the significance of the actual duties performed and the
treatment accorded to similarly situated personnel. Nomenclature by itself
cannot supply a sufficient basis for differentiation where the factual and
service circumstances point in the same direction.
89. In the case of Ushaben Joshi v. Union of India5, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court made the following observation:“16. Evidently, the decision to regularise the services of Smt. K.M.
Vaghela and in appointing her as an MTS was an independent
decision of respondent-Department uninfluenced by the CAT's order.
Hence, the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant that she has been discriminated vis-à-vis Smt. K.M. Vaghela
who has been given the benefit of regularization is substantiated and
established from record.
17. The respondents have not indicated anything in the affidavit filed
in pursuance of the order dated 27th February, 2024, that the nature
of duties or the hours of work being performed by Smt. K.M. Vaghela
were any different from that of the appellant. Thus, the defence taken
by the respondents for their decision not to confirm the appellant in
services that she was only performing duties as a contingency
worker(water woman) for four hours a day is not substantiated from
any acceptable material on record. Indisputably, the appellant
continuously served the Department for more than three decades as a
contingency ‘water woman’. Keeping in view the fact that an employee
similarly placed but inducted in service after nearly six years from the
date of employment of the appellant with the respondent-Department
has been conferred the benefits of confirmation in service by way of
appointment to the post of MTS, the appellant is entitled to claim the
same benefits.
18. The prevailing circulars applicable to the Posts and Telegraphs
Department mandate that a temporary employee who has worked in
the Department continuously for more than 240 days in the preceding
12 months would be entitled to claim the relief of regularisation under
the extant rules and regulations.
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2277
19. In view of the foregoing discussion, the impugned orders are set
aside. The respondents are directed to treat the appellant at par with
Smt.
K.M.
Vaghela
and
shall
pass
the
order
of
regularisation/appointment as MTS in favour of the appellant, on
similar terms as was done in the case of Smt. K.M. Vaghela. The order
of regularisation will be effective from the date on which, Smt. K.M.
Vaghela was appointed as MTS with all consequential benefits.
Compliance of this order shall be effected within a period of three
months from the date of this order.
20. The appeal stands allowed accordingly.”
90. In Jaggo v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826, the Supreme Court
examined the position of long-serving workers engaged in continuing
functions. The judgment explained that the constitutional prohibition
against
back-door
appointments
does
not
furnish
a
reason
for
disregarding every claim arising from prolonged service in posts or
functions which form a continuing component of governmental activity.
The distinction between an illegal appointment and an irregular
appointment remains decisive.
91. In the case of Jaggo v. Union of India6, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
made the following observation:
“26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) sought to curtail the
practice of backdoor entries and ensure appointments adhered to
constitutional principles, it is regrettable that its principles are often
misinterpreted or misapplied to deny legitimate claims of long-serving
employees. This judgment aimed to distinguish between “illegal” and
“irregular” appointments. It categorically held that employees in
irregular appointments, who were engaged in duly sanctioned posts
and had served continuously for more than ten years, should be
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826
considered for regularization as a one-time measure. However, the
laudable intent of the judgment is being subverted when institutions
rely on its dicta to indiscriminately reject the claims of employees, even
in cases where their appointments are not illegal, but merely lack
adherence to procedural formalities. Government departments often
cite the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) to argue that no vested right to
regularization
exists
for
temporary
employees,
overlooking
the
judgment's explicit acknowledgment of cases where regularization is
appropriate. This selective application distorts the judgment's spirit
and purpose, effectively weaponizing it against employees who have
rendered indispensable services over decades.
27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion, it is imperative for
government departments to lead by example in providing fair and
stable employment. Engaging workers on a temporary basis for
extended periods, especially when their roles are integral to the
organization's functioning, not only contravenes international labour
standards but also exposes the organization to legal challenges and
undermines employee morale. By ensuring fair employment practices,
government institutions can reduce the burden of unnecessary
litigation, promote job security, and uphold the principles of justice and
fairness that they are meant to embody. This approach aligns with
international standards and sets a positive precedent for the private
sector to follow, thereby contributing to the overall betterment of labour
practices in the country.
28. In view of the above discussion and findings, the appeals are
allowed. The impugned orders passed by the High Court and the
Tribunal are set aside and the original application is allowed to the
following extent:
i. The termination orders dated 27.10.2018 are quashed;
ii. The appellants shall be taken back on duty forthwith and their
services regularised forthwith. However, the appellants shall not
be entitled to any pecuniary benefits/back wages for the period
they have not worked for but would be entitled to continuity of
services for the said period and the same would be counted for
their post-retiral benefits.”
92. The recent decision in R. Iyyappan v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 431,
illustrates a
different
circumstance.
The
Supreme
Court
directed
regularisation after taking account of an earlier binding judicial order
which had specifically required formulation of a scheme and creation of
the requisite posts for permanent engagement. The force of that decision
lay substantially in the prior adjudication which had attained finality.
93. The order dated 9th March 2017 in W.P. 16543(W) of 2016 did not declare
the petitioners entitled to regularisation and did not direct creation of
posts. The decision in R. Iyyappan therefore cannot be transplanted to the
present matter as though the earlier order in the present proceedings
contained an equivalent mandate.
94. The decision in Biswajit Goswami v. Secretary, Municipal Affairs, 2025
SCC OnLine Cal 393, also requires factual application rather than
mechanical extension. The Court there considered the position of similarly
placed daily-rated employees against the background of earlier absorption
of other employees and the circumstances concerning sanctioned and
supernumerary
posts.
The
decision
reinforces
the
importance
of
examining the administrative history of the particular establishment
rather than treating the duration of service as a solitary determinant.
95. The respondents contend the petitioners were invited to participate in the
selection process against two existing Group-C posts carrying Grade Pay
of Rs.1,800/- and declined to participate. Reliance is also placed upon the
petitioners' failure to challenge the Office Memorandum dated 16 October
2014 and upon the contention that the Centre cannot regularise
employees in the absence of sanctioned posts.
96. The submissions are persuasive to the extent they recognise the statutory
and administrative limits upon the Centre. A person possessing
Temporary Status does not thereby acquire an automatic right to
permanent
appointment.
The
existence
of
sanctioned
posts,
the
prescribed qualifications, the applicable recruitment rules and the
governmental
approvals
required
by
the
relevant
scheme
are
indispensible.
97. The respondents' case, however, does not conform to the significance of
the Centre's own communication dated 6th April 2017. The Centre did not
merely state that no posts existed and terminated the issue. It sought
intervention from the Department of Science and Technology for sanction
of suitable Group-C posts so that the concerned personnel could be
considered for regularisation.
98. The administrative record therefore reveals two distinct aspects. One
concerns selection against existing sanctioned vacancies. The other
relates the broader claim of the CL-TS personnel and the request
addressed by the Centre to the governmental authority for suitable posts
and requisite administrative guidance.
99. Selection against two existing vacancies could validly address only the
first aspect. Such selection cannot, by itself, be treated as a final
adjudication of the second aspect, particularly when the petitioners had
already raised a written objection before the date fixed for the test and
when the Centre itself had sought governmental intervention regarding
the larger question.
100. The petitioners' refusal to participate in the proposed test cannot be
treated as an automatic forfeiture of every claim arising from their earlier
Temporary Status and prolonged service. The legal consequence of the
refusal must be considered in the context in which the denial occasioned.
The communication dated 22nd August 2017 records a specific legal
objection to the process and was issued before the scheduled test.
101. A different consequence would follow if a petitioner had secured
appointment through the selection process or had voluntarily accepted a
new appointment carrying conditions inconsistent with the earlier claim.
The present record, as placed before the Court, does not disclose such a
circumstance.
102. The
office
memorandum
dated
16th
October
itself
stated
regularisation of CL-TS personnel cannot be undertaken by the concerned
Ministry or Department on its own and requires relaxation of paragraph 8
of the Appendix to the Office Memorandum dated 10.09.1993 Scheme.
The Centre, consequently, could not have lawfully resolved every aspect of
the petitioners' claim by an internal order if the governmental relaxation
or sanction contemplated by the memorandum remained necessary. It
also specified forwarding of a consolidated proposal for regularisation of
all
such
remaining
CL-TS
who
were
on
the
rolls
of
the
Ministries/Departments on 10.09.1993 and yet could not be regularized
for further consideration and examinations.
103. The administrative process required by the memorandum therefore
assumes significance. The Centre had already taken the first substantive
step by communicating with the Department of Science and Technology
on 6th April 2017. The record placed before the Court does not
demonstrate a final governmental determination upon the request
contained in the said communication.
104. The absence of such determination cannot be converted into a final
rejection of the petitioners' claim merely by treating the subsequent
selection exercise as its complete substitute. Such a course would not
attain finality of the administrative issue which the Centre itself had
raised before the Department of Science and Technology.
105. The Court does not determine whether the Department of Science and
Technology must sanction the posts sought by the Centre. Nor does the
Court prescribe the number or category of posts. The Court does not
direct relaxation of the recruitment rules or the 1993 Scheme. Such
decisions belong to the competent executive authorities.
106. The Court can, however, require the administrative process already
initiated by the Centre to reach a reasoned conclusion. A governmental
authority which has been approached by its subordinate or autonomous
institution for a decision bearing directly upon the latter's statutory and
administrative capacity to deal with a class of employees cannot leave the
request without a final administrative determination and thereafter treat
the absence of such determination as a complete answer to the
employees' claim.
107. The communication dated 6th April 2017 shall therefore be treated as a
material part of the administrative record. The Centre shall place and
pursue the request contained therein before the Department of Science
and Technology. The Department of Science and Technology shall
examine the request in accordance with the governmental procedure
governing sanction of posts, relaxation of the applicable recruitment
framework and regularisation of CL-TS personnel.
108. Any concurrence, approval or examination by another competent
governmental authority, including the Department of Personnel and
Training or the Department of Expenditure, where required by the
applicable rules or instructions, shall be obtained through the prescribed
authority. No direction contained in this order shall be construed as a
command to any such authority to sanction a post, grant relaxation or
approve regularisation.
109. Upon completion of the aforesaid governmental process, the Centre shall
reconsider the claim of each petitioner separately. The exercise shall take
into account the date of initial engagement, the date and source of
conferment of Temporary Status, the length and continuity of service, the
duties performed, the qualifications possessed, the nature of the post
against which consideration is sought, the applicable recruitment rules,
the 1993 Scheme to the extent applicable to the individual petitioner, the
Office Memorandum dated 16th October 2014 and every subsequent
governmental instruction governing the matter.
110. The authority shall also take into account the distinction between an
existing sanctioned vacancy and a post requiring fresh governmental
sanction. The first category may be dealt with within the Centre's lawful
recruitment framework. The second category requires action through the
competent governmental establishment and financial authorities.
111. The individual claims shall not be rejected solely on the ground that the
petitioners did not participate in the written or skill test held pursuant to
the process initiated in August 2017.
112. The Reasoned Order dated 16th May 2017 cannot survive in its present
form to the extent it brought the petitioners' broader claim to an end
without completion of the governmental process which the Centre itself
had initiated by its communication dated 6th April 2017. The said
Reasoned Order is accordingly set aside to that limited extent.
113. Nothing contained in this order shall be construed as a declaration that
every petitioner possesses an immediate or vested right to regular
appointment. The adjudication proceeds on the narrower but legally
material conclusion that the petitioners' claims require a complete
administrative determination after consideration of the governmental
process expressly invoked by the Centre itself.
114. The respondents shall complete the part of the process falling within their
respective jurisdiction expeditiously. The Centre shall place and pursue
the matter before the Department of Science and Technology within four
weeks from communication of this order seeking necessary sanction of
post for regularisation including appropriate financial approval. The
Department of Science and Technology shall take the request for
consideration in accordance with the applicable governmental procedure
and communicate its decision to the Centre.
115. Following such decision, the Centre shall undertake the individual
exercise contemplated above and pass a reasoned order in respect of each
surviving claim within three months thereafter.
116. The exercise shall not result in creation of any post by judicial direction.
No supernumerary post is directed to be created by this Court. No cadre
is directed to be altered. No recruitment rule is waived by this order. The
competence of the executive authorities concerning establishment,
finance, recruitment and sanction of posts remains intact.
117. The ancillary grievance concerning medical facilities shall be examined
separately in accordance with the applicable Medical Scheme, the Office
Order dated 16th August 2024 and the status of each concerned person.
The fact that certain petitioners have retired or that the dependants of
deceased petitioners receive benefits shall be taken into account while
determining the nature of any consequential claim. The Court expresses
no concluded determination on the extent of medical reimbursement or
post-retiral medical entitlement in the absence of a complete adjudicatory
record on that distinct issue.
118. The directions contained herein preserve the distinction between judicial
review and executive administration. The Court requires completion of a
process which the respondents themselves initiated; it does not assume
the statutory function of sanctioning posts or relaxing governmental
rules.
119. The writ petition consequently succeeds to the extent indicated above.
120. There shall be no order as to costs.
121. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review