Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LUCY Digitally
signed by
GURU LUCY
GURUMAYUM
MAYU Date:
2024.06.18
12:48:30
M
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Cril. Petition No. 12 of 2014
1. SudeepThakore, ex-Vice President, Marketing of M/s Mekaster
Engineering Limited, having its registered Office at Plot No. 32,
Sector 1, Parwanoo Industrial Estate, Solan District, Himachal
Pradesh – 173220, residing at G-101, 1st Floor, Galada Towers,
Begumpet, Hyderabad- 500016.
…. Petitioner
- Versus 1. M/s Coastal Projects Limited, Imphal East, Mantripukhri, Second
Floor, near CRPF Camp, Manipur 795001, having its registered Office
at 237, 2nd Floor, Bapuji Nagar, Bhubaneswar, Orissa and its
Corporate office at Plot No. 303-O, Film Nagar, Jubilee Hills,
Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh- 500033.
Represented by Shaik Moulali, aged about 41 years, S/o John Shab
of Coastal Projects Ltd., BikashBhavan, 2nd Floor, flat no. V and VI
Palace Compound Agartala- 799001, Tripura now serving as Regional
Head (NE).
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For the petitioner
:
Mr. H. Kenajit, Advocate
For the respondent
:
Mr. T. Rajendra, Sr. Advocate
Date of hearing
:
04.04.2024
Date of order
:
14.06.2024
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. H. Kenajit, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. T. Rajendra, learned sr. counsel appearing for the
respondent.
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 1
[2]
The present petition has been filed under section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 for quashing/ setting aside the
impugned order dated 06.05.2014 passed by the Ld. Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Imphal East, Manipur in connection with a complaint
case which is registered as Cril. (C) Case No. 55 of 2014 (cognizance
of offences under section 417, 419,420 read with section 34 of the
IPC is taken) and further proceedings of the said complaint case with
the following prayers;
i.
To quash the impugned order dated 06.05.2014
(Annexure-C/5) and further proceedings of the
Cril.(C) Case No. 55 of 2014; and
ii.
For passing ex-parte interim order for staying the
order dated 06.05.2014 of the Ld. Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Imphal East, Manipur and to recall the
warrant of arrest issued to the petitioner and also
to stay the further proceedings of the Cril. (C)
Case No. 55 of 2014 before the Hon’ble Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East, Manipur during
the pendency of the present petition.
[3]
According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
Ld. CJM, Imphal East has failed to apply its judicious mind while
issuing warrant of arrest against the petitioner/accused person in the
complaint case filed by the respondent/complainant which was
registered as Cril. (C) Case No. 55 of 2014 (cognizance of offences
under section 417, 419, 420 read with section 34 of the IPC) taken
against the petitioner. Since then the criminal proceedings against
the petitioner is going on in full swing.
[4]
Chequered history of the petitioner leading to the filing of
this petition u/s 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 is as
follows:-
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 2
As the petitioner was working as a Vice-President,
Marketing of M/S Mekaster Engineering Pvt. Limited (in short MEL),
of a Company registered under the Company Act, 1956 having its
registered Office at Plot No. 32, Sector 1, Parwanoo Industrial
Estate, Solan District, Himachal Pradesh- 173220. The petitioner has
submitted his resignation on 12-03-2014 which was accepted by the
MEL on 23-04-2014.
The respondent company and MEL was having its
business relations over a decade for placing orders and MEL was
supplying the orders placed by the respondent company. On
07.12.2012,
the
respondent
Company
and
M/S
Mekaster
International Private Ltd. (one of the Mekaster Group of Companies)
entered into an agreement in Andhra Pradesh for placing a purchase
order for the supply of Road Header Machine, Model T 3.2Q to be
delivered to its Rangit Hydro Electric Project at Sikkim and an
advance payment of Rs. 5 Crore only was made by the respondent
company vide Cheque No. 279207 dated 07-06-2011. Further, it was
agreed in its agreement that instead of cash refund of Rs. 4.40
Crore, the respondent company agreed to place an order for supply
of three (3 Nos.) Shotcrete Machines PM 500 to the Second party.
Again on 20.12.2013, the respondent Company and the
MEL entered into an amendment agreement in Andhra Pradesh
thereby amending the terms and conditions of the agreement dated
07.12.2012. Original signed copy of the agreement is with the
respondent Company.
The respondent filed a complaint case before the Ld.
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East and the Ld. Court took
cognizance and registered it as Cril. (C) Case No. 55 of 2014 and
issued warrant of arrest against the petitioners vide order dated
06.05.2014.
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 3
[5]
According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
Ld. Court of CJM, Imphal East had erred in taking cognizance u/s
417, 419, 420 read with section 34 of the IPC and issued warrant of
arrest against the Petitioner without any jurisdiction and evidence
that the petitioner had either deceived or cheated on which the
complainant is relying that cheating had been caused to him.
[6]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted
that the respondent/complainant had filed the complaint case before
the Ld. CJM, Imphal East for cheating by relying on certain
agreement but the said agreement were executed in Andhra Pradesh
and the document which the complainant is relying for jurisdiction of
the Ld. Court is a purchase order placed by him to one
PutzeisterIberica, S.A. Camino de Hormigueras, 173, 28031- Madrib
which is not the company of the petitioner.
[7]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted
that the Ld. Court while taking cognizance, it has recorded statement
of 2 (two) witnesses including the complainant and no where the
witnesses have stated that the petitioner have deceived or cheated
him. Inspite of wanting more evidence to take cognizance of the
complaint, the Ld. Court had taken cognizance under section 417,
419, 420 read with section 34 of the IPC and registered it as a Cril.
(C) Case No. 55 of 2014 and issued a warrant of arrest to the
petitioner vide order dated 06.02.2014 in a routine manner.
[8]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further mentioned
that there is no ingredient/ or any act of the petitioner which would
make his act liable to book him under the said provision. As the Ld.
Court had committed an error in taking cognizance and issuing the
warrant of arrest to the petitioner u/s 417, 419, 420 read with
section 34 of the IPC. Having no alternative the petitioner has
approached this Hon’ble Court to quash/ set aside the impugned
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 4
order dated 06.05.2014 passed by the Hon’ble CJM, IE whereby a
criminal complaint case is continuing against the petitioner.
[9] The petitioner has filed the present petition on the following
grounds;
a) The impugned order dated 06.05.2014 passed by the
Hon’ble CJM, IE is bad in the eyes of law;
b) The Ld. Court had taken cognizance and issued warrant of
arrest under section 417, 419, 420 read with section 34 of
the IPC without applying its judicious mind;
c) The complaint case has no materials to take cognizance u/s
417, 419, 420 read with section 34 of the IPC against the
petitioner;
d) The impugned order dated 06.05.2014 passed by the
Hon’ble CJM, IE have help the complainant to harass the
petitioner without any valid reason;
e) The impugned order passed by the CJM, IE is contrary to the
letter and spirit of the intention for which the legislature had
enacted the IPC;
f) The complainant had approached the Hon’ble CJM, IE just to
harass the petitioner by dragging in criminal case;
g) The complainant is abusing the process of law to harass and
torture the petitioner mentally, physically and financially.
[10]
Mr. T. Rajendra, the learned counsel for the respondent
filed Counter Affidavit on behalf of the respondent, in that the
respondent submitted that “Except those which are specifically
admitted therein the Respondent/Complainant denies all the
allegations made in the petition filed by the petitioner/accused
person.
Brief
fact
as
per
the
respondent
is
that
the
respondent/petitioner made an order for supply of 01 (one) Road
Header was placed with M/s Mekaster Engineering Limited (in short
MEL) on 22-03-2011, for which advance payment of Rs. 5 Crores
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 5
(Rupees five crore) has been made and as per provision in the
purchase order, M/s MEL shall take back the machine in case of nonperformance of the machine as per the pre-determinated norms
after installation at the work-site and it was mutually decided that
MEL has to refund Rs 4.4 Crores (Rupees four point four crores) on
taking back the under-performed machine. He further submit that
subsequently
under
the
agreement
dated
07.12.2012,
the
complainant is to place supply order to purchase 03 (three)
shotcrete machines from M/s MEL instead of refunding Rs 4.40
Crores which was to be refunded by M/s MEL. As per the agreement,
one machine is to be supplied in December, 2012 and two in
January, 2013 and that the balance amount of Rs. 2.84 Crores
(Rupees two point eight four crore) remains after delivery of 01(one)
shotcrete machine.
[11]
The learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that after the supply of the first machine, by an agreement dated
20.11.2013, it was agreed mutually to supply two machines by the
MEL and a further amount of Rs. 1 (one) Crore only was released by
the complainant to MEL and that the delivery schedule of the first
unit was within eight weeks on or after the receipt of advance
payment from the complainant and the second unit was within eight
weeks on or after the receipt of advance payment from the
complainant. According to the learned counsel for the respondent,
the said approach of the accused was with a criminal mind and with
an intention of deceiving the complainant.
[12]
The learned counsel for the respondent next submitted
that on 20.11.2023 the complainant placed a supply order for two
machines to the manufacturer i.e. M/s Putzmeister Iberica, Madrid
directly as requested for by the MEL and the accused on their
statement that it is required to carry out High Sea Sales to make
invoice in favour of the complainant Coastal Projects Limited.
Subsequently, on 17-12-2013, the Vice President of MEL namely
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 6
Sudeep Thakore informed that the first unit of the shotcrete machine
will be delivered by December, 2013 and the second unit will be
delivered in January, 2014, but has failed to deliver the machines
within the stipulated period.
[13]
The learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that finding delay tactics of M/s MEL for delivery of machines and
suspicious of the real intention of the MEL on the issue, legal notice
was served on 21-03-2014 intimating appropriate legal steps against
M/s MEL in case of failure to dispatch 02 (two) shotcrete machines
within 7 (seven) days indicating specifically that the legal action to
be launched may include criminal prosecution as well as civil suits for
which M/s MEL shall be further liable for the cost and consequences
of the litigations. But no response was received from Shri Sudeep
Thakore, Vice President (Marketing) and also finding the delay
tactics of MEL, the complainant company has taken up the matter
with the manufacturer directly to ascertain the factual position. The
manufacturer M/s. Putzmeister Iberica, by a letter dated 06.08.2014,
replied that they have not been informed or involved in any
negotiation and discussions that the complainant may have had with
the MEL with regard to the requirement of delivery of two machines
and that they have not received any payment with regard to the
above order. As a result, the complainant has filed the Criminal
complaint case against Shri Sudeep Thakore, Vice President of M/s
MEL and one other on 06-05-2014 before the Hon'ble Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Imphal East, Manipur against which non-bailable warrant
was issued by the court on 06-05-2014 by taking statement of the
complainant and one witness.
[14]
The
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent
further
argued/submitted that warrant of arrest was issued not for
convicting the accused, but only the first step of the criminal
proceeding and due trial of the case by producing evidence by both
sides and the accused has enough chance to prove their case. Since
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 7
the Chief Judicial Magistrate has got vast/ample power to take
cognizance of the offence and accordingly, after following the
procedure, the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate has taken
cognizance of the offence and therefore, there is no infirmity in it
and there is no necessity to invoke the provisions of Section 482
Cr.P.C to quash the said criminal proceedings initiated by the
respondent.
[15]
The learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that a person is said to be cheated by another person if he/she by
deceiving that person fraudulently and dishonestly induces the
person so deceived to deliver any property, to any person or to
consent that any person shall retain any property or intentionally
induces the person so deceived to do or omit to do anything which
he would not do or omit if he was not so deceived and which act or
omission causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person
in body, mind, reputation or property. Further whoever cheats and
thereby dishonestly induces the person deceived to deliver any
property to any person or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any
part of a valuable security or anything which is signed or sealed and
which is being capable of converted into a valuable security is said to
be cheated and dishonestly induces delivery of property. The
Petitioner/respondent along with another namely Shri Mohit Khanna
are the Vice President and CEO (Chief Executive Officer) of M/s
Mekaster Engineering Ltd. The petitioner and the said Mohit Khanna
fraudulently and dishonestly induces the complainant to make
payment of a big amount running in crores which is morefully
explained in the Complaint petition for the supply of the said
machines. The Petitioner/respondent and the said Mohit Khanna had
the clear intention of deceiving and dishonestly compelling the
complainant to make the said payment even though they had the
clear intention of not supplying the machines so promised to be
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 8
delivered. In fact, the acts of the accused person fulfills the
ingredients of the offences for which cognizance was taken.
The learned counsel further mentioned that the supply orders of
the said machines are to be delivered at Mantripukhri Imphal within
Imphal East District, Manipur. Therefore the act of deceivement has
been undisputedly confirmed as the said machines are not delivered
at the said address of Imphal. Therefore the deceivement by the
petitioner and Mohit Khana is a continuing one including at Imphal
where the said machines are to be delivered. Being so the Ld. Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East under whose jurisdiction at
Mantripukhri the machines have to be delivered have ample
jurisdiction to entertain the complaint petition.
[16]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further filed Reply
affidavit on behalf of the petitioner to the Additional Affidavit filed by
the Respondent in which he denies all the allegations/averments
made in the additional affidavit except those which are specifically
admitted therein and he further contented that the submission of the
respondent in the Additional Affidavit is afterthought and making
improvement of his case which is not valid in the eyes of law.
Accordingly, the present Criminal Petition No. 12 of 2014.
[17]
After hearing both the learned counsels at length and on
perusal of the materials placed before me, it is seen and emerged
the following;
I)
The agreement mentioned by the parties were
executed between the petitioners’ company i.e M/s Mekaster
Engineering Limited and the respondents’ company i.e M/s Coastal
Projects Limited.
II)
The company of the petitioner was not made
parties in the complaint case.
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 9
III)
The petitioner was Ex-Vice President of the
company but already resigned from his post and the resignation was
accepted by the company.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
allegation against the petitioner in the complaint petition was that he
was the Vice President of the company but the mentioned
agreements were entered into between the respondent company
and petitioner company and all payment have been made by the
respondent company to the petitioner company. Further, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submitted that instead of filing the criminal
proceeding civil case should be filed against the petitioner’s
company, in the circumstances no case is made out against the
petitioner, as such the continuation of the criminal complaint against
the petitioner is totally abuse of process of law. In Sharad Kumar
Sanghi Vs Sangit Rane, (2015) 12 SCC 781, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court at para 11 observed that;
“11. In the case at hand as the complainant’s initial statement would
reflect, the allegations are against the Company, the Company has
not been made a party and, therefore, the allegations are restricted
to the Managing Director. As we have noted earlier, allegations are
vague and in fact, principally the allegations are against Managing
Director. When a company has not been arrayed as a party, no
proceeding can be initiated against it even where vicarious liability is
fastened under certain statues. …”
In this situation it is observed that except for stating that the
petitioner had lied to the complainant no details have been
mentioned either in the complaint or in the statement given by the
said two witnesses made before the learned CJM, Imphal East to
attract the criminal jurisdiction for taking cognizance simply
recording the statement of the complainant is not enough but there
must be some concrete satisfaction of the Court concerned for taking
cognizance.
In the circumstances issuance of warrants either bailable or
non-bailable with proper scrutiny of mind. The Hon’ble Supreme
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 10
Court in Inder Mohan Goswami and another v. State of Uttarachal
and others, (2007) 12 SCC 1 at para 54 observed that;
“54. As far as possible, if the court is of the opinion that a summon
will suffice in getting the appearance of the accused in court, the
summon or the bailable warrants should be preferred. The warrants
with bailable or non-bailable should never be issued without proper
scrunity of facts and complete application of mind, due to the
extremely serious consequences and ramifications which ensue on
issuance of warrants. The court must very carefully examine whether
the criminal complaint or FIR has not been filed with an oblique
motive.”
In the present case the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
after taking cognizance issued warrant of arrest against the
petitioner and co-accused even though the complainant failed to put
forth its case in proper perspective and involved in the said
agreement has not been made a party. In the facts and
circumstances the CJM, Imphal East ought not to have issued the
warrant of arrest.
[18]
On further perusal of the materials placed before me, it is
evident that the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East when
taking cognizance examined two witness namely Shaik Moulali
(Complainant) and Prem Kshetrimayum, it is seen and evident that
both the witnesses didn’t mentioned about the mischief and
wrongdoing of the petitioner in the execution of delivery of the
materials mentioned in the agreement but only about the company.
[19]
Further as per the submissions made by both the learned
counsels the relationship between the petitioners’ company and
respondents’ company are doing business for more than a decade
the respondent failed to mention the non-execution of agreement
between the parties prior to the present agreement. This shows the
trust between the two companies in execution of their business.
[20]
Out of the three shotcrete machines order, the petitioner
company have already supplied one machine, in the process it is
found that the petitioner have already resigned from the company
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 11
and his resignation was already accepted by the company. Since, the
allegation of the complainant was solely on the company not the
petitioner individually the complainant atleast should made the
petitioners’ company a party in the complaint case.
[21]
On further perusal of the rival contention made by the
parties and with the materials placed before me, it is evident that
the litigation if any it should be between the petitioners’ company
and the respondents’ company as the allegation against the
petitioners’ company is purely on account of breach of contract
between the two companies. In Sarabjit Kaur Vs Station of Punjab
and Anr (2023) 5 SCC 360, the Hon’ble Supreme Court at para 13
observed that;
“13. A breach of contract does not give rise to criminal procesution
for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right at
the beginning of the transaction. Merely on the allegation of failure to
keep up promise will not be enough to initiate criminal proceedings.
From the facts available on record, it is evident that Respondent 2
had improved his case ever since the first complaint was filed in
which there were no allegations against the appellant rather it was
only against the property dealers which was in subsequent complaints
that the name of the appellant was mentioned. On the first
complaint, the only request was for return of the amount paid by
Respondent 2. When the offence was made out on the basis of the
first complaint, the second complaint was filed with improved version
making allegations against the appellant as well which was not there
in the earlier complaint. The entire idea seems to be to convert a civil
dispute into criminal and put pressure on the appellant for return of
the amount allegedly paid. The criminal courts are not meant to be
used for settling scores or pressurize parties to settle civil disputes.
Wherever ingredients of criminal offences are made out, criminal
courts have to take cognizance. The complaint in question on the
basis of which FIR was registered was filed nearly three years after
the last date fixed for registration of the sale deed. Allowing the
proceedings to continue would be an abuse of process of the Court.”
[22]
Learned counsel for the respondent as submitted above
narrated/explained about the meaning of cheating and submits that
the petitioner cheated the respondents’ company by not delivering
the agreed material to the respondents’ company, but it is admitted
position of fact that the petitioner is the EX-Vice President of MEL
and the said agreement was executed by the petitioners’ company
and the respondent and subsequent development between the two
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 12
companies, it is the company answerable to the subsequent
development post the said agreement, as such, there is no question
of cheating committed by the petitioner.
In Vijay Kumar Ghai Vs State of W.B (2022) 7 SCC 124,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court at para no. 35 to 39 observed that;
“35. To establish the offence of cheating in inducing the delivery of
property, the following ingredients need to be proved:
i)
The representation made by the person was false.
ii)
The accused had prior knowledge that the representation
he made was false.
iii)
The accused made false representation with dishonest
intention in order to deceive the person to whom it was
made.
iv)
The act where the accused induced the person to deliver
the property or to perform or to abstain from any act which
the person would have not done or had otherwise
committed. ”
36. As observed and held by this Court in R.K. Vijayasarathy Vs. Sudha
Seetharam, the ingredients to constitute an offence under Section 420 are
as follows:
i)
a person must commit the offence of cheating under Section
415; and
ii)
the person cheated must be dishonestly induced to:
a) Deliver property to any person; or
b) Make, alter or destroy valuable security or anything signed
or sealed and capable of being converted into valuable
security. Thus, cheating is an essential ingredient for an act
to constitute an offence under Section 420 IPC.
37. The following observation made by this Court in Uma Shankar Gopalika
v. State of Bihar with almost similar facts and circumstances may be
relevant to note at this stage: (SCC pp. 338-39. paras 6-7)
"6. Now the question to be examined by us is as to whether on the
facts disclosed in the petition of the complaint any criminal offence
whatsoever is made out much less offences under Sections 420/120B IPC. The only allegation in the complaint petition against the
accused persons is that they assured the complainant that when they
receive the insurance claim amounting to Rs 4,20,000, they would
pay a sum of Rs 2,60,000 to the complainant out of that but the
same has never been paid.... It was pointed out on behalf of the
complainant that the accused fraudulently persuaded the complainant
to agree so that the accused persons may take steps for moving the
consumer forum in relation to the claim of Rs 4,20,000. It is well
settled that every breach of contract would not give rise to an offence
of cheating and only in those cases breach of contract would amount
to cheating where there was any deception played at the very
inception. If the intention to cheat has developed later on the same
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 13
cannot amount to cheating. In the present case, it has nowhere been
stated that at the very inception that there was intention on behalf of
the accused persons to cheat which is a condition precedent for an
offence under Section 420 IPC.
7. In our view petition of complaint does not disclose any criminal
offence at all much less any offence either under Section 420 or
Section 120-B IPC and the present case is a case of purely civil
dispute between the parties for which remedy lies before a civil court
by filing a properly constituted suit. In our opinion, in view of these
facts allowing the police investigation to continue would amount to an
abuse of the process of court and to prevent the same it was just and
expedient for the High Court to quash the same by exercising the
powers under Section 482 CrPC which it has erroneously refused."
38. There can be no doubt that a mere breach of contract is not in itself a
criminal offence and gives rise to the civil liability of damages. However, as
held by this Court in Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma v. State of Bihar, the
distinction between mere breach of contract and cheating, which is criminal
offence, is a fine one. While breach of contract cannot give rise to criminal
prosecution for cheating, fraudulent or dishonest intention is the basis of
the offence of cheating. In the case at hand, complaint filed by Respondent
2 does not disclose dishonest or fraudulent intention of the appellants.
39. In Vesa Holdings (P) Ltd. v. State of Kerala, this Court made the
following observation: (SCC pp. 297-98, para 13)
"13. It is true that a given set of facts may make out a civil wrong as
also a criminal offence and only because a civil remedy may be
available to the complainant that itself cannot be ground to quash a
criminal proceeding. The real test is whether the allegations in the
complaint disclose the criminal offence of cheating or not. In the
present case, there is nothing to show that at the very inception
there was any intention on behalf of the accused persons to cheat
which is a condition precedent for an offence under Section 420 IPC.
In our view, the complaint does not disclose any criminal offence at
all. Criminal proceedings should not be encouraged when it is found
to be mala fide or otherwise an abuse of the process of the court.
The superior courts while exercising this power should also strive to
serve the ends of justice. In our opinion, in view of these facts
allowing the police investigation to continue would amount to an
abuse of the process of the court and the High Court committed an
error in refusing to exercise the power under Section 482 CrPC to
quash the proceedings.”
[23]
For the aforesaid reasons and in view of the findings of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court the facts and circumstances of the
present case and it is observed that the complaint made against the
petitioner, the complainant failed to make out the offence of
cheating against the petitioner.
[24]
Since there is no merit in taking cognizance of the offence
against the petitioner by the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate and in
view of the liquidation complaint case of the respondent having
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 14
become
infructuous,
the
decisions
relied
upon
by
the
respondent/complainant are not applicable to its case. In any event,
the allegations levelled by the respondent in its complaint case can
only be ascertained on the basis of the evidence and documents by
a Civil Court of the competent jurisdiction and not by way of criminal
complaint.
[25]
Even if all the allegations made in the complaint are taken
to be correct, the case for prosecution under Sections 417, 419, 420
and 34 IPC is not made out against the petitioner herein. To prevent
abuse of the process of the Court and to secure the ends of justice, it
becomes imperative to quash the Criminal Complaint Case No.55 of
2014 pending on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East
and any further proceedings emanating therefrom in respect of the
petitioner.
[26]
In the result,
(a) this Cril. Petition No.12 of 2014 is allowed;
(b) the Criminal Complaint Case No.55 of 2014 pending
on the file of the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal
East and any further proceedings emanating therefrom in
respect of the petitioner is quashed. No costs.
[27]
Send an extract copy of this order to the Court of
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East, Manipur.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lucy
Cril. Petn. No. 12 of 2014
Page 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review