The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. In the result, while being inclined to grant bail to petitioner Balaram Bisoyi in BLAPL No.3948 of 2025, this Court does not consider it proper to grant bail to rest of the petitioners namely Pabana @ Prabhakar Sahu @ Pabana Sahu, Bipini Sahu & Baya Sahu in BLAPL No.9883 of 2024; Juria @ Rajendra Sahu in BLAPL No.9885 of 2024; Sudam Mallik in No.12570 of 2024; Surendra Mallik and Rama Mallik in BLAPL No.3926 of 2025 and Purna Chandra Sahu & Rabi Sahu in BLAPL No.4553 of 2025.
10. Hence, the bail application of the Balaram Bisoyi in BLAPL No.3948 of 2025 stands allowed and he be allowed to go on bail on furnishing bail bonds of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand) with two solvent sureties each for the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Court in seisin of the case on such terms and BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases conditions as deem fit and proper by it with following condition:(i) the petitioner- Balaram Bisoyi in the course of trial shall attend the trial Court on each date of posting without fail unless his attendance is dispensed with. In case the Petitioner-Balaram Bisoyi fails without sufficient cause to appear in the Court in accordance with the terms of the bail, the learned trial Court may proceed against the Petitioner for offence U/S.269 of BNS, 2023 in accordance with law.
11. Accordingly, all these BLAPL Nos.9883, 9885, 12570 of 2024 & 3926, 3948, 4553 of 2025 stand disposed of. (G. Satapathy) Judge OrissaSAHOO High Court, Cuttack, Reason: Authentication Dated the 6th day of January, 2026/Kishore Location: High Court of Orissa BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
BLAPL Nos. 9883, 9885, 12570 of 2024 & 3926, 3948, 4553 of 2025
(In the matter of applications under Section 483 of the
BNSS).
Pabana @ Prabhakar Sahu @
Pabana Sahu and others
(In BLAPL No. 9883 of 2024)
Juria @ Rajendra Sahu
(In BLAPL No. 9885 of 2024)
Sudam Mallik
(In BLAPL No. 12570 of 2024)
Surendra Mallik and another
(In BLAPL No. 3926 of 2025)
Balaram Bisoyi
(In BLAPL No. 3948 of 2025)
Purna Chandra Sahu and
another
(In BLAPL No. 4553 of 2025)
-versus-
…
State of Odisha
… Opposite Party
For Petitioners
Petitioners
: Mr. B.K. Raj, Advocate
(In BLAPL Nos. 9883 & 9885 of
2024)
Mr. R.N. Rout, Advocate
(In BLAPL No. 12570 of 2024)
Mr. A. Tripathy, Advocate
(In BLAPL No. 3926 of 2025)
Mr. S.K. Pradhan, Advocate
(In BLAPL Nos. 3948 & 4553 of
2025)
For Opposite Party
: Mr. M.R. Patra, Addl. PP
CORAM:
JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING : 11.12.2025
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 06.01.2026
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
G. Satapathy, J.
1.
Since these six bail applications arise out of one
and same case record, the same are heard together and
disposed of by this common order with the consent of the
learned counsel for the parties.
2.
These are six bail applications U/S.483 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (in short, “BNSS”) by
the petitioners for grant of bail in connection with K.
Nuagaon PS Case No.252 of 2024 corresponding to ST
Case No. 467 of 2024 (GR Case No.383 of 2024) being
charge sheeted for commission of offences punishable
U/Ss.61(2)/110/274/123/275/103(1)/118/3(5)
of
BNS
r/w Sections 52(a)/59/62 of the Odisha Excise Act, 2008
pending in the file of learned 1st Additional Sessions
Judge, Berhmapur, Ganjam and learned JMFC, Patrapur
(BLAPL Nos. 9883 & 9885 of 2024) respectively.
3.
The present case arises out of an FIR lodged by
SI Ranjit Mohapatro of K.Nuagaon PS on 20.08.2024 at
2AM
that
on
9.30PM
on
19.08.2024
he
received
information from the local source that around 15 and
some more persons of village Jenapur, Maundapur &
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
Karabalua have been admitted to CHC, Chikiti and
undergoing treatment for consumption of spurious liquor
and on enquiry, he found Pradeep Behera, Kalu Sethy,
Bulu Sethy, Siba Sethy, Dayanidhi Sahu, Jura Behera,
Kama Behera of village Jenapur and Jena Sethy of village
Maundapur, Bairi Sethy, Bhubani Sethy, Khalia Sethy of
village Karabalua to have consumed liquor by purchasing
it from petitioner Baya Sahu and his two sons Bapini
Sahu and Pabana Sahu. Similarly, petitioner Rabi Sahu
and his brothers Purna Sahu and Juria Sahu being
assisted
by
village
Headman-cum-petitioner
Balaram
Bisoyi had also sold liquor to some other persons, but the
person consuming liquor had become serious and they
felt head-reeling and severe stomach pain and vomited
frequently and, therefore, they had been brought to CHC,
Chikiti individually by their family members for their
treatment, however, after preliminary treatment, all the
above referred persons have been referred to MKCG,
MCH, Berhampur for their better treatment. On this
report, K. Nuagaon PS Case No.252 of 2024 was
registered and the matter was investigated into, but
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
unfortunately five persons namely Pradip Behera, Laxman
Behera, Baya @ Bairi Sethy, Jura Behera and Lokanath
Behera have expired for consumption of spurious liquor.
On
completion
of
investigation,
charge-sheet
was
submitted against the petitioners and some others.
4.
Heard, Mr. Bikram Keshari Raj, learned counsel
for the petitioners in BLAPL Nos.9883 & 9885 of 2024;
Mr. Rajendra Narayan Rout, learned counsel for the
petitioner in BLAPL No.12570 of 2024; Mr. Amitav
Tripathy, learned counsel for the petitioners in BLAPL
No.3926 of 2025; Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pradhan, learned
counsel for the petitioners in BLAPL Nos.3948 & 4553 of
2025 and Mr. M.R. Patra, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor in these matters and perused the record.
4.1.
In the course of argument, all the counsels
appearing for the respective petitioners have submitted in
equal tones that the deceased having died due to some
other reason, but not for consuming any liquor which was
confirmed by the Forensic Report of the viscera of the
deceased as submitted by the CFSL, Kolkata and the
petitioners have had no role in the death of the deceased
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
persons and they being innocent may kindly be granted
bail. In addition, learned counsel for the petitioner
Balaram Bisoyi has submitted that the petitioner Balaram
Bisoyi has no role either in selling the liquor to anybody
or in any way in this case, but he having entangled in this
case by falsely showing him to be assisting co-accused
petitioners for selling the liquor, he may kindly be
granted bail.
4.2.
On the other hand, Mr. M.R. Patra, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, however, by placing strong
reliance on the report of the concerned doctor has
submitted that the cause of death of the deceased could
be probably due to multi organ failure and as a result of
ingestion of certain toxic and noxious substances and the
ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulphate found in the
samples of spurious liquor seized from the house of the
petitioner Baya Sethy, a prima facie case is made out
against the petitioners for selling spurious liquors to
general public and, thereby, allowing the deceased
persons to consume such spurious liquor at cheap price
and, therefore, the petitioners being found responsible for
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
the death of five innocent persons, their bail applications
may kindly be rejected. Mr. Patra has also submitted that
the petitioner Balaram Bisoyi having provided protection
to co-accused for selling spurious liquor is equally
responsible for the death of the deceased and, therefore,
he being equally responsible, his bail application may
kindly be rejected.
5.
After having considered the rival submissions
upon perusal of record, this Court before dwelling upon
the facts involved in the present case reminds that the
statutory provisions of bail confers wide discretion on the
Court either to grant or refuse bail to the applicant, but
such exercise of discretion should not be arbitrary or dehors
the
basic
principles
laid
down
by
different
constitutional Courts in a catena of decisions. The
parameters under which discretion has to be considered
has been well elucidated by Apex Court in Prasanta
Kumar Sarkar Vrs. Ashis Chatterjee & Anr : (2010)
14 SCC 496, wherein the Apex Court in Paragraph 9 has
held as under:-
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
“9. However, it is equally incumbent upon the
High Court to exercise its discretion judiciously,
cautiously and strictly in compliance with the
basic principles laid down in a plethora of
decisions of this Court on the point. It is well
settled that, among other circumstances, the
factors to be borne in mind while considering an
application for bail are:
(i) Whether there is any prima facie or
reasonable ground to believe that the
Accused had committed the offence;
(ii) Nature and gravity of the accusation;
(iii) Severity of the punishment in the event
of conviction;
(iv) Danger of the Accused absconding or
fleeing, if released on bail;
(v) Character, behavior, means, position
and standing of the Accused;
(vi) Likelihood
repeated;
of
the
offence
(vii) Reasonable apprehension
witnesses being influenced; and
being
of
the
(viii) Danger, of course, of justice being
thwarted by grant of bail.”
Additionally, in Jagjeet Singh & Ors. Vrs.
Ashish Mishra & Ors.; 2022 9 SCC 321, while
emphasizing
the
duty
of
the
Court
and
relevant
consideration for bail, the Apex Court at Paragraphs 27
and 33 has held as under:“27. We may, at the outset, clarify that power to
grant bail under Section 439 of the Cr.P.C., is one
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
of wide amplitude. A High Court or a Sessions
Court, as the case may be, are bestowed with
considerable
discretion
while
deciding
an
application for bail. But, as has been held by this
Court on multiple occasions, this discretion is not
unfettered. On the contrary, the High Court or
the Sessions Court must grant bail after the
application of a judicial mind, following wellestablished principles, and not in a cryptic or
mechanical manner.
33. Before dealing with the case at hand, we
may, at the cost of repetition, emphasise that a
Court while deciding an application for bail,
should refrain from evaluating or undertaking a
detailed assessment of evidence, as the same is
not a relevant consideration at the threshold
stage. While a Court may examine prima facie
issues, including any reasonable grounds whether
the Accused committed an offence or the severity
of the offence itself, an extensive consideration of
merits which has the potential to prejudice either
the case of the prosecution or the defence, is
undesirable. It is thus deemed appropriate to
outrightly clarify that neither have we considered
the merits of the case nor are we inclined to
comment on the evidence collected by the SIT in
the present case.”
6.
In considering the case of the petitioners on the
backdrop of the principle laid down by the Apex Court in
the decisions referred to above, it is quite clear that detail
analysis of evidence and meticulous examination of
documents on merit should be avoided at the time of
consideration of bail, but at the first instance, the Court
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
has the duty to consider prima facie case or reasonable
ground to believe that the serious allegations levelled
against
the
accused
constitute
the
commission
of
offences or not. In this case, it is disclosed in the chargesheet that the deceased persons had been admitted to
hospital after consuming liquor stated to be spurious by
purchasing it from some of the petitioners and eventually
losing their lives. Further, there is allegation against the
petitioners Sudam Mallik, Surendra Mallik and Rama
Mallik for manufacturing and supplying liquors to coaccused persons.
7.
Besides, the gravity of accusations is evident
from the death of five innocent persons in this case. It is
also alleged that liquors were seized from the house of
co-accused Baya Sahu, Rabi Sahu and other co-accused
persons. It is also stated in the charge-sheet that urea
which is a fertilizer has been recovered from the house of
co-accused. It is no doubt advanced for the petitioners
that the viscera reports of the deceased
persons as
submitted by the CFSL, Kolkata do not reveal the
presence of any poisonous and toxic substances/drugs,
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
but the CE report of the sample collected from the seized
liquors from the house of the co-accused Baya Sethy
reveals
the
presence
of
ammonium
nitrate
and
ammonium sulphate and it is opined by the doctor
conducting PM report that such compounds can cause
death of the deceased by causing multi organ failure,
however, this Court does not consider it proper to enter
into the arena of analysis of the reports submitted by the
CFSL,
Kolkata
and
SFSL,
Rasulgarh,
Bhubaneswar
together with the opinion of the doctor at this stage,
which is impermissible at the time of consideration of
bail. What is relevant at this stage is that five persons
suffered death and some persons suffered illness after
consuming liquor sold by the co-accused persons and
there is allegation against the petitioners for either selling
the liquor to some of the villagers without any authority
or
supplying
the
same
to
vendors-cum-co-accused
persons for selling it. On the other hand, there is
allegation against the petitioner Balaram Bisoyi for
assisting some of the co-accused to sell liquor as a village
head man, but there is no direct allegation against him
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
for selling any liquor to the villagers. Besides, co-accused
petitioners Bapini Sahu, Baya Sahu, Juria @ Rajendra
Sahu and Rabi Sahu are having criminal antecedents in
matter relating to ID liquor, which assumes significance
in the present context of facts. Besides, number of other
persons
had
also
been
admitted
to
hospital
after
consuming liquor by allegedly purchasing it from some of
the petitioners. Apart from the aforesaid facts, none of
the petitioners are having any license or authority to sell
any liquor.
8.
In
view
of
the
discussions
of
facts
and
considering the role of each of the petitioners together
with tragic death of five innocent persons and number of
persons suffering from illness after consuming liquor
allegedly sold by some of the petitioners and taking into
account the impact of death of innocent villagers after
consuming liquor on the society and trial having not yet
commenced, it would not be proper to grant bail to the
persons who are allegedly selling or supplying the liquor,
but there being no direct material against the petitioner
Balaram Bisoyi for selling liquor to any of the villagers
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
and he having no criminal antecedent of similar nature
and taking into account the only allegation against him
for assisting co-accused in selling the liquor, but not
being clarified as to the manner in which he was assisting
the co-accused, this Court considers his case positively.
9.
In the result, while being inclined to grant bail to
petitioner Balaram Bisoyi in BLAPL No.3948 of 2025, this
Court does not consider it proper to grant bail to rest of
the petitioners namely Pabana @ Prabhakar Sahu @
Pabana Sahu, Bipini Sahu & Baya Sahu in BLAPL No.9883
of 2024; Juria @ Rajendra Sahu in BLAPL No.9885 of
2024;
Sudam
Mallik
in
BLAPL
No.12570
of
2024;
Surendra Mallik and Rama Mallik in BLAPL No.3926 of
2025 and Purna Chandra Sahu & Rabi Sahu in BLAPL
No.4553 of 2025.
10.
Hence, the bail application of the Balaram Bisoyi
in BLAPL No.3948 of 2025 stands allowed and he be
allowed to go on bail on furnishing bail bonds of
Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand) with two solvent
sureties each for the like amount to the satisfaction of the
learned Court in seisin of the case on such terms and
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
conditions as deem fit and proper by it with following
condition:(i) the petitioner- Balaram Bisoyi in
the course of trial shall attend the
trial Court on each date of posting
without fail unless his attendance is
dispensed
with.
In
case
the
Petitioner-Balaram Bisoyi fails
without sufficient cause to appear
in the Court in accordance with
the terms of the bail, the learned
trial Court may proceed against
the Petitioner for offence U/S.269
of BNS, 2023 in accordance with
law.
11.
Accordingly, all these BLAPL Nos.9883, 9885,
12570 of 2024 & 3926, 3948, 4553 of 2025 stand
disposed of.
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
Digitally Signed
Signed by: KISHORE KUMAR
OrissaSAHOO
High Court, Cuttack,
Reason: Authentication
Dated
the
6th day of January, 2026/Kishore
Location: High Court of Orissa
Date: 06-Jan-2026 18:45:20
BLAPL Nos.9883 of 2024 along with other cases
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review