Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
30.09.2026
Court No.10
DL/Item No.–2
[Milan]
WPA 27912 of 2026
SUBODH KUMAR
VS
COAL INDIA LIMITED & ORS.
Mr. Swapan Kumar Datta, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Sambuddha Dutta,
Mr. Puranjan Pal,
Ms. Sushmita Dutta
….for the Petitioner
Mr. Shiv Shankar Banerjee,
Mr. Siddthartha Chamria,
Mr. Adhip Narayan Banerjee,
Mr. Aspujan Singh
….Coal India Ltd.
1.
Affidavit of service filed in Court today is taken on record.
2.
The petitioner has challenged in the present Writ Petition
the Order of Transfer dated 08.09.2026 wherein the petitioner
has been promoted from Chief Manager (Mining) in E7 Grade
to the post of General Manager (Mining) in E8 Grade in the
scale of pay of Rs. 1,20,000/- to Rs. 2,80,000/- and has been
posted to a remote area of North Eastern Coalfield, Assam.
3.
The
Learned
Counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner
submits that the petitioner is a Mining Engineer and was
initially appointed as Management Trainee (Mining) on or
about 13.02.1997 by the Chairman, Coal India Ltd. (Govt. of
India Enterprise). The petitioner was thereafter promoted as
Assistant Manager (Mining) in 1999, under Manager (Mining)
in 2002, under Senior Manager (Mining) in 2005, Senior
Manager (Mining) in 2015 and Chief Manager (Mining) in
2021. The petitioner has unblemished service record of 29
years.
4.
The
petitioner
while
working
as
Senior
Manager,
Rajmahal area was charge-sheeted vide Memorandum bearing
Ref. No. CCL/Vid/RDA-02/21/2021/167 dated 21.06.2021
under Rule 30 of the Coal India Executive Conduct, Discipline
and Appeal Rules (Amended up to18.01.2021) (hereinafter
referred to as the CDA Rules) on some baseless and frivolous
charges. Over some of the charges mentioned in the
Memorandum dated 21.05.2021, a full-fledged Departmental
Enquiry was held against the petitioner, inflicting upon him a
major penalty of reduction of two stages lowering time scale of
pay for a period of six months. Being aggrieved thereby, an
appeal was preferred by the petitioner against the Major
Penalty which was reduced to censure by the Appellate
Authority.
5.
The petitioner further challenged the entire disciplinary
proceeding by filing a Writ Petition before this Hon’ble Court.
Thereafter by an Order dated 02.05.2025 this Court was
pleased to dispose of the Writ Petition by setting aside the
order of censure.
6.
Subsequent thereto, the petitioner received an order of
transfer to a remote area to NEC at Assam. After receiving the
said order of transfer the petitioner made representation dated
15.09.2026
before
the
competent
authority
for
its
consideration. It is submitted that the said representation is
required to be disposed of expeditiously in accordance with
law. However, the same remains pending for consideration
without any decision. As a result of which such representation
deserves to be disposed of expeditiously.
7.
It is further submitted that the order of transfer to a
remote area is aftermath of the litigation in which the
petitioner has been successful. Posting of the petitioner to
NEC at Assam is to be counter bias and malafide, made due to
his
success
in
litigation
relating
to
the
disciplinary
proceedings initiated against the petitioner. The transfer is
punitive in nature and in violation of Article 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
8.
It is further submitted that as per Clause 9(a), Clause
9(b) read with Clause 9(d) of the Promotion Guidelines of CIL,
it is mandatory to transfer the Executive with relatively higher
length of completed years of service in a subsidiary for
manpower rationalization. As per the Policy of Coal India Ltd.
(CIL), a transfer to new subsidiary is not optional, transfer on
promotion of Executive from E7 to E8 Grade is need-based.
However, in the present case, there is no General Manager
available in the parent subsidiary for running the same. It is
further submitted that the petitioner has been transferred
whereas similarly situated candidates promoted as General
Manager in Mining Sector have been retained at the parent
subsidiary (CIL) which is discriminatory and inviolation of
principles of natural justice.
9.
Per
contra,
the
respondent
authorities
vehemently
opposes the submission made by the petitioner and submits
that transfer is a condition of service and the employees are
required to comply with the transfer order.
10. It is further submitted that the petitioner has been
serving the CIL for last 29 years and has not been transferred
to any other subsidiary of the CIL. The petitioner’s contention
with regard to the retention of a similarly situated candidates
being promoted as General Manager Mining Sector is not
sustainable, since unlike the other candidates, the petitioner
has never been transferred to another post despite serving CIL
for the last 29 years. A long stay at one place itself requires
manpower rationalization.
11. It is further submitted that the right to transfer is not a
vested right. It is an administrative policy taken by the
company for administrative purposes. Transfer is an incident
of service. No employee can claim retention at one place as a
matter of right. The post of General Manager in various
sectors in a subsidiary is a single post. Therefore, when
petitioner is promoted from E7 to E8 he has to be posted
against a vacancy in another subsidiary.
12. The Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent
authorities raises an objection to the intent and purport of the
petitioner’s representation dated 15.06.2026 wherein the
petitioner has specifically, in the garb of a representation,
directed the authority to obtain an approval for retention of
the petitioner, which is not permissible.
13. Having heard the Learned Counsel for the parties and
upon perusing the materials available on record, this Court
have taken judicial notice of all the relevant documents
annexed to the writ petition and is of the considered view that
the
representation
dated
15.09.2026
requires
effective
adjudication of the issues involved herein i.e. as to whether
the petitioner being promoted to General Manager (Mining)
can be retained in its parent subsidiary company despite
being transferred to a different subsidiary company, where
there is no General Manager left for running the subsidiary.
14. It is a Trite Law that the transfer is an incident of service
and cannot be lightly interfered with.
15. It is a well settled proposition of law as held in Shilpi
Bose Vs. State of Bihar reported in AIR 1991 Supreme
Court 532, that “court should not interfere with the transfer
order in public interest and for administrative reason unless
made in violation of mandatory statutory a Rule or on ground
of malafide. Government service holding transferable post has
no vested right to remain posted at one place”.
16. It is also observed in the case of Sk. Naushad Rahaman
Vs Union of India reported in (2022) 12 SCC 1 and has held
that transfer policy is only guideline not legally enforceable,
does not confer indefeasible right.
17. In the case of State of U.P vs. Gobardhan Lal reported
in (2004) 11 SCC 402 and Abani Kanta Ray vs. State of
Orissa reported in 1999 Supple (4) SCC 169 where is has
been held that the transfer cannot be interfered with unless
clearly arbitrarily is being vitiated by malafide.
18. A judgment passed by this Court in WPA 16132 of 2021
Raju Didar Singh Gill vs. Coal India Ltd. & Ors. and WPA
17774 of 2019 wherein it has been held that the CIL
Promotion Policy from E7 to E8 is based upon merits cum
seniority and the Court cannot interfere into such policy
matter inasmuch as the writ court cannot intervene in any
policy matter.
19. In the present case the petitioner has already served CIL
for 29 years without inter subsidiary transfer. As per Clause
9A, 9B read with 9D of promotion Guideline, transfer of
executive with higher length of service is mandatory for
manpower rationalization. Transfer of the promotee from E7 to
E8 is need based. Allegation of malafide, being aftermath of
disciplinary proceeding the disputed question of facts require
adjudication by competent authority after hearing.
20. This Court is not inclined to interdict the transfer order
dated 08.09.2026 at this stage. However, to balance equities
and for ends of justice, the representation of the petitioner
dated 15.09.2026 should be decided on merits to arrive at a
logical and a conclusive finding with regard to the retention of
the petitioner at the parent subsidiary (CIL). Thus, the
respondent No. 2 being the competent and superior authority
is directed to consider the representation of the petitioner
dated 15.09.2026 within a period of four weeks from the date
of communication of this order and shall pass a reasoned and
speaking order in accordance with law upon affording
opportunity of personal hearing and communicate such
decision within a week thereafter.
21. The petitioner is directed to join at NEC, Assam within
two weeks from date. Such joining shall be without prejudice
to his representation. In the event, respondent no. 2 allows
retention, the petitioner shall be repatriated to parent
subsidiary within one week from date without further
reference. Till such decisions, status of petitioner’s lien in
parent company shall be maintained.
22. With the above observations and directions, the Writ
Petition is disposed of without going into the merits of the
case. No order as to costs.
23. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance of all necessary
formalities.
(Smita Das De, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review