Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:1259
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No. : 2990 of 2025
Decided on : 05.01.2026
Subhash Chander
…Applicant
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
…Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the applicant
: Applicant in person Mr. Vijender
Katoch, Advocate.
For the respondent : Mr. H.S. Rawat, Mr. Tejasvi Sharma,
Additional Advocates General, with
Mr. Rohit Sharma & Ms. Ranjna
Patial, Deputy Advocates General,
assisted by ASI Sanjeev Kumar,
Police Station Sadar Kullu, District
Kullu, H.P.
Virender Singh, Judge (Oral)
Applicant – Subhash Chander, apprehending
his arrest, in a case arising out of FIR No.76 of 2023,
dated 17.03.2023, registered, under Sections 420, 467,
468, 469, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code
(hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’), with Police Station,
Sadar Kullu, District Kullu, H.P., has filed the present
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:1259
application, under Section 482 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter referred to as ‘BNSS’).
2.
this
By way of the present application, indulgence of
Court
has
been
sought
to
direct
the
Police/
Investigating Officer of Police Station Sadar Kullu, District
Kullu, H.P., to release him on bail, in the event of his
arrest, in the above noted case.
3.
The relief, as claimed, in the application has
been sought on the ground that the applicant is innocent
and has falsely been implicated, in this case, by the Police.
4.
According to the applicant, he has no concern
whatsoever with the crime, in question and he is ready to
abide by, in case, any direction is issued to the Police
under Section 482 of the BNSS.
5.
The applicant has tried his luck by moving
similar application before the Court of learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Kullu, District Kullu, however, the said
application has been dismissed on 20.12.2025.
6.
Apart from this, learned counsel appearing for
the applicant, has given certain undertakings, on behalf of
the applicant, for which, the applicant is ready to abide by,
2026:HHC:1259
in case, any direction is issued to the I.O./Police, under
Section 482 BNSS.
7.
The applicant, in addition to this, has pleaded
that two other cases have already been registered against
him, bearing FIR No.289/2010, dated 27.10.2010, under
Sections 420, 457, 468, 471 and 120-B of the IPC, and FIR
No.187 of 2021, dated 18.07.2021, under Sections 420,
465 and 120-B IPC with Police Station Sadar Kullu,
District Kullu, however, he has not been convicted in any
of the cases.
8.
On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to allow the application.
9.
When put to notice, the police has filed the
status report, on 22.12.2025, disclosing therein, that on
17.03.2023, a complaint has been received from the office
of Town and Country Planning, Kullu District Kullu,
mentioning therein about the following facts:“To the SHO, Police Station Kullu, H.P. Subject:Register an FIR and conduct enquiry against
Shri Munee Suri C/o, P.O. Bandrol, Tehsil &
Distt. Kullu, H.P. Sir, This is in reference to
above cited subject it is intimated that the above
named person got to his resorts building by
producing fake NOC (photocopy attached), as
this department not issued any type of NOC for
2026:HHC:1259
electricity connection to his above said resort.
You are therefore, requested to register an FIR
against the above named person and investigate
the matter at the earliest, please Yours
faithfully. Sd/- Town & Country Planner,
Divisional town Planning Office. Kullu Distt.
Kullu HP.”
10.
On the basis of the above facts, the FIR, in
question, has been registered and the criminal machinery
swung into motion.
11.
Thereafter, ASI Jai Singh, Police Station Sadar
Kullu, has obtained record from the Town and Country
Planner, Divisional Town Planning Office, Kullu regarding
installation of electricity connection in the name of
Neeralaya Resort at Nangabag Vihal and issuance of fake
NOC and recorded the statements of the witnesses.
12.
Thereafter, the I.O. associated Muneer Suri, in
the investigation, who has disclosed to the police that in
his Resort namely Neeralaya, a contract for establishment
of electricity transformer and transmission line and
installation of meter, was given to one Subhash Electrical,
Proprietor Jagannathi Construction.
In this regard, oral
agreement was entered into between the parties.
13.
2026:HHC:1259
During investigation, specimen hand writing of
seven suspicious persons/dealing hands were obtained
and sent to RFSL Dharamshala, from where, the result has
been received.
As per the result, on the fake NOC, the
signatures on the stamp of Planning Officer, were put by
Lokender Rana, employee of contractor Subhash Sharma.
14.
During investigation, it has been found that
contractor Subhash Sharma, has obtained the work of
installation of transmission line to the transformer to be
installed at Neeralaya Resort owned by Muneer Suri.
Subhash Sharma has got prepared the file from his
employee, and thereafter, the same was submitted to the
TCP Office, by replacing the original NOC, with fake NOC.
15.
On the basis of the fake NOC, the Electricity
Department installed the transformer in Neeralaya Resort,
in the year 2017, whereas, the TCP Office has granted NOC
in the year 2018, online.
16.
It is the further case of the police that on
16.12.2025, accused Lokender Rana, was associated and
was arrested. On 17.12.2025, he was produced before the
learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Court No.2, Kullu,
2026:HHC:1259
from where, he was remanded to Police custody for four
days.
17.
Lastly, it has been stated that as per the
investigation, Contractor Subhash Sharma, applicant has
hatched a conspiracy and he has deposed a fake NOC as
Original NOC with the Electricity Department.
18.
Considering the said status report, interim
protection was granted to the applicant, vide order dated
22.12.2025, and the matter was adjourned to 29.12.2025.
19.
On
29.12.2025,
the
police
has
filed
supplementary status report, disclosing therein, that the
applicant is a clever person and in case, the interim order
is made absolute, he may coerce the witnesses. Thereafter,
the matter has been adjourned for 05.01.2026.
20.
On
05.01.2026,
the
police
has
filed
the
supplementary status report, disclosing therein, that the
applicant has joined the investigation, but, he is not
disclosing anything about the fake NOC, as such, his
custodial interrogation is required.
21.
On the basis of the above facts, it has been
apprehended that the applicant is a clever person and in
2026:HHC:1259
case, the interim order is made absolute, he may tamper
with the evidence, as such, a prayer has been made to
dismiss the application.
22.
Heard.
23.
In this case, the applicant has joined the
investigation. However, according to the police, he is not
disclosing
anything
about
the
fake
NOC
and
not
cooperating with the investigation of the case.
24.
Merely, the protection, not to take any coercive
action, does not preclude the police to get the recovery
effected from the applicant as, in view of the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia &
Others versus State of Punjab, (1980) 2 Supreme Court
Cases 565, a person, having the protection under Section
438 Cr.PC (482 of the BNS), is deemed to have surrendered
himself, if a discovery is to be made. Relevant paragraph
43 of the judgment, is reproduced, as under:43.
During the last couple of years this Court,
while dealing with appeals against orders
passed by various High Courts, has granted
anticipatory bail to many a person by imposing
conditions set out in Section 438(2)(i), (ii) and (iii).
The Court has, in addition, directed in most of
those cases that (a) the applicant should
surrender himself to the police for a brief period
2026:HHC:1259
if a discovery is to be made under Section 27 of
the Evidence Act or that he should be deemed to
have surrendered himself if such a discovery is
to be made. In certain exceptional cases, the
Court has, in view of the material placed before
it, directed that the order of anticipatory bail will
remain in operation only for a week or so until
after the filing of the F.I.R. in respect of matters
covered by the order. These orders, on the
whole, have worked satisfactorily, causing the
least inconvenience to the individuals concerned
and least interference with the investigational
rights of the police. The Court has attempted
through those orders to strike a balance
between the individual's right to personal
freedom and the investigational rights of the
police. The appellants who were refused
anticipatory bail by various courts have long
since been released by this Court under Section
438(1) of the Code.
25.
Similar view has again reiterated by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case titled as Sushila Aggarwal and
others versus State (NCT of Delhi) and another, (2020)
5 Supreme Court Cases 1. Relevant paragraph 92.8 is
reproduced as under:“92.8. The observations in Sibbia regarding
“limited custody” or “deemed custody” to
facilitate the requirements of the investigative
authority, would be sufficient for the purpose of
fulfilling the provisions of Section 27, in the
event of recovery of an article, or discovery of a
fact, which is relatable to a statement made
during such event (i.e. deemed custody). In such
event, there is no question (or necessity) of
asking the accused to separately surrender and
2026:HHC:1259
seek regular bail. Sibbia (supra) had observed
that
“19...if and when the occasion arises, it
may be possible for the prosecution to
claim the benefit of Section 27 of the
Evidence Act in regard to a discovery of
facts made in pursuance of information
supplied by a person released on bail by
invoking the principle stated by this Court
in State of H.P. v. Deoman Upadhyaya.”
26.
In the status report, the prayer, as made in the
bail application, has been opposed mainly on the ground
that applicant is not disclosing anything about the fake
NOC. The alleged refusal/non-cooperation of the applicant,
to the considered opinion of this Court, could not be the
ground for dismissal of the application, as no one can be
compelled to be the witness against himself, as the same is
violative of Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India.
27.
If the facts and circumstances of the present
case are seen in the light of the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah
versus Kamal Dayani & Others, (2025) 1 Supreme
Court Cases 753, the applicant is entitled to the relief, as
claimed, in the application.
Relevant paragraph 43 of
judgment, are reproduced, as under:-
2026:HHC:1259
“43. We are of the firm opinion that noncooperation by the accused is one matter and
the accused refusing to confess to the crime is
another. There would be no obligation upon the
accused that on being interrogated, he must
confess to the crime and only thereafter, would
the Investigating Officer be satisfied that the
accused has cooperated with the investigation.
As a matter of fact, any confession made by the
accused before a police officer is inadmissible in
evidence and cannot even form a part of the
record.”
28.
Considering the fact that investigation is almost
complete and the case is based upon the documentary, as
well as, scientific evidence, this Court is of the considered
opinion that no useful purpose would be served by
dismissing the present application, which would result into
the police/judicial custody of the applicant.
29.
So far as the registration of the other cases
against the applicant, are concerned, in none of those
cases, conviction has been inflicted by the competent Court
of law. As such, merely, on the basis of the registration of
the other cases, adverse inference cannot be drawn against
the applicant.
30.
The applicant is permanent resident of District
Kullu, as such, it cannot be apprehended that in case the
2026:HHC:1259
interim order is made absolute, he may not be available for
the trial.
31.
The role attributed to the applicant would be
proved during the trial and rejection of the bail would be
nothing, but pre-trial punishment, which is prohibited
under the law.
32.
Considering the totality of circumstances, this
Court is of the view that the interim protection, granted to
the applicant, is required to be made absolute.
33.
Considering all these facts, the interim order
dated 22.12.2025, passed by this Court, is hereby made
absolute.
Therefore, it is ordered that the applicant be
released on bail, in the event of his arrest, in case FIR
No.76/2023,
dated
17.03.2023,
registered,
under
Sections 420, 467, 468, 469, 471 and 120-B of the IPC,
with Police Station Sadar Kullu, District Kullu, on his
furnishing personal bond, in the sum of ₹50,000/-, with
one surety of the like amount, to the satisfaction of the
Investigating Officer. This order, however, shall be subject
to the following conditions :
2026:HHC:1259
a) That the applicant shall join the investigation of
the case, as and when, called for, by the
Investigating Officer, in accordance with law;
b)
That the applicant shall not leave India, without
prior permission of the Court;
c)
That the applicant shall not, directly or indirectly,
make any inducement, threat or promise to any
person, acquainted with the facts of the case, so
as to dissuade him/her from disclosing such facts
to the Investigating Officer or the Court; and
d) That the applicant shall regularly attend the trial
Court on each and every date of hearing and if
prevented by any reason to do so seek exemption
from appearance by filing appropriate application.
34.
Any of the observations, made hereinabove,
shall not be taken as an expression of opinion, on the
merits of the case, as these observations, are confined,
only, to the disposal of the present application.
35.
It is made clear that the respondent-State is at
liberty to move an appropriate application, in case, any of
the bail conditions, is found violated by any of the
applicant.
( Virender Singh )
Judge
January 05, 2026 (ps)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review