Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 749 of 2025
Subhash Kumar Das, S/o Shri Dilip Das, R/o Kanke Road, Tangra
Toli, Hatma, P.O.-Ranchi University, P.S.-Gonda, District-Ranchi
….. Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand, through the Chief Secretary, Ranchi
2. The Chairman, Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission, Ranchi
3. The Secretary, Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission, Ranchi
4. The Examination Controller, Jharkhand Staff Selection
Commission, Ranchi
….. Respondents
----CORAM
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellant:
Dr. (Mrs.) Vandana Singh, Advocate
Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Karamdeo, Advocate
For the Res.-JSSC:
Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, Advocate
Mr. Prince Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Jay Prakash, Advocate
Mr. Rakesh Ranjan, Advocate
----06/04.05.2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
This appeal is directed against the learned Single Judge’s order
dated 03.11.2025 dismissing the petitioner’s/appellant’s W.P. (S)
No. 5930 of 2025 by which the petitioner was in fact, seeking
condonation of delay for document verification in the context of
Jharkhand Laboratory Assistant Competitive Examination, 2023
in terms of Advertisement No. 01/2023.
3.
The petitioner belongs to the reserved category (SC), and there
is no dispute that the petitioner was declared successful in the
competitive examination. By notice dated 03.09.2024, he was
called upon to attend on 13.09.2024 for document verification.
The notice, in addition to being published on the Jharkhand Staff
Selection Commission (JSSC) portal/website, was communicated
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
to the petitioner by e-mail. Even the petitioner has not disputed
this position.
4.
Further, the notice dated 03.09.2024 provides that if, for any
reason, the petitioner is unable to attend on 13.09.2024, he
would attend on 18.09.2024 between 11:00 AM and 4:00 PM for
document verification.
5.
Clause 3 of the notice dated 03.09.2024, in clear and categorical
terms, provides that if the petitioner/appellant fails to remain
present for document verification either on 13.09.2024 or on
18.09.2024, no further extension of time would be granted, and
further, the candidature of the petitioner would be cancelled.
6.
The
petitioner’s
case
is
that,
between
13.09.2024
and
17.09.2024, his sister was ill and was admitted to the hospital.
Therefore, he could not attend the document verification
scheduled on 13.09.2024 and on 18.09.2024. He, however,
pleaded that he attended the document verification on the next
day, i.e., on 19.09.2024.
7.
Dr. (Mrs.) Vandana Singh, learned counsel for the appellant,
submits that the case of the petitioner should be governed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s decision rendered in the case of
Shreya Kumari Tirkey vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors.
[S.L.P. (Civil) No. 27139 of 2024 decided on 04.09.2025],
wherein it has been held that the procedure should not be
allowed to term the substantive rights of the parties. She also
points out that the JSSC, in this case, had kept one seat
reserved for SC candidates suo-moto. Therefore, no prejudice
would be occasioned if an extension of a day was granted to the
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
petitioner for document verification. For these reasons, she
submits that the appellant’s writ petition should have been
allowed and relief as prayed for in the same granted.
8.
Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, learned counsel for the respondent-JSSC,
submits that the JSSC has gone by the terms of the
advertisement and the notices issued to all the candidates. He
submits that there was no provision for relaxation, and that
more than sufficient opportunities had already been granted to
all the candidates, including the petitioner. He submits that the
notice/advertisement clearly provides the consequences of not
attending the document verification. He submits that Shreya
Kumari Tirkey’s case (supra) is distinguishable because no
consequences for not attending the medical examination were
specified in the advertisement or in the notice, and further, there
was no matter concerning the crucial aspects of document
verification.
9.
Mr Sanjoy Piprawall further submits that if any relaxation is
granted to the petitioner based on the alleged individual
hardships
projected,
there
are
several
other
candidates
belonging to the reserved category, who have, in fact, secured
higher merit positions than the petitioner, but were not
considered for their failure to attend the document verification.
10. Mr Sanjoy Piprawall submits that the case of the petitioner is
covered by the decision of a coordinate Bench rendered in the
case of Nirmal Pahan and Ors. vs. the State of Jharkhand
& Ors. [L.P.A. No. 143 of 2024 & other analogous cases]
and the decisions of Bedanga Talukdar vs. Saifudaullah
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
Khan and Others reported in (2011) 12 SCC 85; State of
Uttar Pradesh & Others vs. Pankaj Kumar reported in
(2022) 1 SCC 335 and Jharkhand Staff Selection
Commission & Others vs. Ashok Kumar Ram & Others
[L.P.A. No. 601 of 2018 decided on 13.11.2019].
11. For all the above reasons, Mr Sanjoy Piprawall submits that this
appeal may be dismissed.
12. The rival contentions now fall for our determination.
13. As noted earlier, in this case, there can be no dispute that the
appellant, vide notice dated 03.09.2024, was called upon to
attend the document verification on 13.09.2024 between 11:00
AM and 1:30 PM, and between 2.30 p.m. and 5.00 p.m. This
notice gave the petitioner an additional opportunity to attend on
18.09.2024, between 11:00 AM and 4:00 PM, if the petitioner
was unable to attend on 13.09.2024.
14. The
notice
dated
03.09.2024
was
published
on
the
website/portal, which was accepted as the valid mode of
communication. In addition, the counter-affidavit filed by the
JSSC states that this notice was sent by email on 10.09.2024 to
the petitioner. Even this position has not been disputed by the
petitioner or his learned counsel.
15. Despite two opportunities, there is no dispute that the petitioner
failed to attend the document verification either on 13.09.2024
or on the extended date, i.e., 18.09.2024.
16. Clause-3 of the notice dated 03.09.2024, in clear terms, provides
that if any candidate fails to attend the document verification on
the appointed dates, no further extension would be granted and
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
his/her candidature would stand cancelled. Thus, apart from
providing two opportunities, the notice dated 03.09.2024 clearly
provides the consequences for failure to attend the document
verification.
17. In the case of Nirmal Pahan (supra), a coordinate Bench, in a
very similar circumstance, held that, in such matters, there was
no scope to consider individual hardships that the candidates
might project. The Court reasoned that any such consideration
would introduce an element of uncertainty, thereby undermining
the integrity of the selection process.
18. In the case of Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission
(supra), another coordinate Bench noted that if exceptions were
made on an individual basis, the sanctity of the recruitment
process would be vitiated, as there would be no end to the
extension of time, whether it be a few hours, a few days, or
even a few months. Co-ordinate Bench has held that in such a
case, the Single Judge ought not to have taken upon itself the
task of condoning the delay in adherence to the time schedule
provided by the Commission.
19. In both decisions, reference was made to several precedents of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the subject. In similar facts, the
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court are applicable in the
cases of Bedanga Talukdar (supra) and State of Uttar
Pradesh (supra).
20. At this stage, we do not propose to go into the issue of whether
the reasons cited by the petitioner warrant acceptance.
However, even if we assume that the reasons cited were
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
genuine, we still fail to understand why, after the discharge of
his sister, the petitioner, who has not claimed any ignorance of
the notice dated 03.09.2024, could not attend the document
verification on 18.09.2024.
21. In any event, in the absence of any clear power to relax and the
presence of a clause setting out in clear terms the consequences
of not attending, we agree with Mr Sanjoy Piprawall’s submission
that the petitioner’s case is covered by the decisions relied upon
by him, rather than the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Shreya Kumari Tirkey (supra).
22. In the case of Shreya Kumari Tirkey (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court was concerned not with the issue of verification
of documents, but with the issue of attending the medical
examination. In paragraph No. 9, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
emphasized that the advertisement had not mentioned the
consequences for non-appearance, intentional or otherwise, in
the medical examination. In paragraph No. 10, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court noted that the press advertisement was itself not
quite clear because it mentioned that the medical examination of
the candidates, who had participated in the interview, was “fixed
for the next day”.
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court noted that since the very beginning,
the case of the appellant was that she was under the impression
that “next day” meant the day following the last day on which
the interview was scheduled i.e., 17.05.2022, she could not
appear on the next day of her interview and after she appeared,
she was informed that the medical examination process stood
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
concluded on the previous day. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
noted that the wording of the advertisement would give rise to a
genuine doubt as to what day the candidate was expected to
appear in the medical examination. Accordingly, the benefit of
such ambiguity was extended to the candidate.
24. None of the above facts even remotely arises in the present
matter. Here, there is no dispute about the petitioner having
knowledge about the notice dated 03.09.2024. This notice, in
clear and unambiguous terms, had called the petitioner to attend
the document verification on 13.09.2024. Further, the notice
provides that if, for any reason, the petitioner fails to attend on
13.09.2024, he may avail another chance on 18.09.2024. Even
the consequences of not attending the document verification
were specified in the notice. There was not the slightest element
of ambiguity; none was pleaded or even argued. Therefore,
based upon the case of Shreya Kumari Tirkey (supra), the
petitioner cannot claim any relief in this appeal.
25. The circumstance that one seat was kept vacant by the JSSC
does not entitle the petitioner/appellant to claim any relief as a
matter of right in this appeal. Besides, as it was pointed out in
the counter affidavit of the JSSC, if such a relaxation is granted,
by the same logic, relaxation would be demanded by other
reserved category candidates, who had better merit position
than the petitioner, but could fail to attend the document
verification and therefore their candidatures were cancelled.
26. Moreover, in the precedents of the Hon’ble Supreme Court relied
upon by Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, including the decision rendered in
2026:JHHC:13205-DB
the case of State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. vs. G. Hemalathaa
& Anr. reported in (2020) 19 SCC 430, it has been held that
the instructions issued by the Commission are mandatory,
having force of law and need to be strictly complied with. In
these matters, the Hon’ble Supreme Court did not approve the
approach
of
the
High
Courts
in
relaxing/modifying
the
instructions by exercising powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution. The Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to the wellknown adage that hard cases make bad law, acknowledged and
held that the grant of relaxation based on individual hardships
would disturb the sanctity and integrity of the selection process,
introducing undue uncertainties.
27. For all the above reasons, we are satisfied that no case is made
out to warrant any interference with the view taken by the
learned Single Judge in the impugned order.
28. The present appeal is accordingly dismissed without any order
for costs.
(M. S. SONAK, C.J.)
(RAJESH SHANKAR, J.)
04.05.2026
Satish/Vikas/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review