Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 08.01.2026
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
SUB/MAJ HANUMAN SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr Manoj Kumar Gupta, Advocate.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr Amit Tiwari, CGSC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition has been filed with the following prayers:
“A. Quash and set aside the Impugned Orders pass by the Ld.
AFT in OA/2892/2020 dated 03 Sep 2024 as well as
RA/54/2024 dated 16 Oct 2024, being non sustainable in
ten11 of settled law and contrary to the policy in vogue;
and/or
B. Issue a writ of Mandamus or any appropriate order/ writ
directing the Respondents to grant the petitioner disability
element @ 40% rounding off to 50% being entitled in term of
Para-53 of Pension Regulation 2008 and GM0-2008, by
treating the disabilities as attributable and aggravated to
Military service, duly broad banded (if required) in terms of
Law upheld in Ram Avtar Case; and/or
C. Direct the respondents to pay the due arrears of disability
pension with interest @10% p.a. with effect from the date of
retirement with all the consequential benefits, and/or Pass
such other order or orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
and proper in the facts and circumstances of this case, in the
interest of Justice.”
2.
The petitioner in this case, Ex Subedar Major Hanuman Singh
enrolled in the Army on 01.08.1983 and was sent to the Artillery Centre
Nasik Road Camp for basic military training. After this the petitioner served
with various units/establishments.
3.
The facts surrounding the present petition are that the petitioner, while
serving with 148 Light Air Defence Regiment (Composite) located at
Suratgarh (Rajasthan) (Modified Field), was downgraded to low medical
category
‘S1H1A1P3(T-24)E1’
for
diagnosis
“PRIMARY
HYPERTENSION” (“PH”) and “DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE-II” (“DM
Type-II”) for a period of six months with effect from 17 Mar 2016 to 01 Sep
2016. On review, the petitioner was downgraded to permanent low medical
category
‘SlHlAlP2(Permanent)El’
for
diagnosis
“
PRIMARY
HYPERTENSION” and “DIABETES MELLITUS TYPE-II” for a period of
two years with effect from 05.07.2016 to 07.07.2018. Thereafter, he was
granted sheltered appointment with effect from 05.07.2016 to continue in
service in the public interest as per Additional Directorate General of
Manpower/MP-3 (PBOR), Integrated Headquarters of Ministry of Defence
(Army).
4.
On completion of the terms and engagement of service, the petitioner
was
discharged,
vide
Army
Air
Defence
Records
Letter
No.
469/JCO/CUO/89/CA- l, dated 28.07.2016, from service with effect from
28.02.2017 by mentioning as under:
“Transferred to pension establishment on completion of service
age/ tenure limit as laid down in Para 163 of Regulations for
the Army (Revised Edition)-1987 as modified vide Government
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
of India, Ministry of Defence letter No 14(3)/98/D(AG) dated
03 Sep .1998 finder the item 1 (i) (a) of table annexed to Rule
13 (3) of Army Rule 1954.
5. It is submitted that since, the Petitioner was in permanent
low medical category, he was brought before a duly constituted
Release Medical Board held at 184 Military Hospital on 10 Sep
2016 to assess the cause, nature and degree of disablement.
Release Medical Board after physically examined the
Petitioner, opined his disabilities as under:
Disability
Attributabl
e to or
Aggravate
d
by
service
Percen
tage of
disable
ment
(a)
Primary
Hypertension
No
30%
Composite
Assessment
for
all
disabilities
with
duration
40%
(b)
Diabetes
Mellitus Type-II
5.
No
20%
Net
Assessment
qualifying
for
disability
pension with
duration
Nil for life
Detail
Justification
Disability is
on set in
peace area,
as per Para
43 of GTMO
(Military
Pension2008)
Disability is
on set in
peace area,
as per Para
26 of GTMO
(Military
Pension2008)
Hence, the petitioner was discharged from service under Rule 13(3) of
the Army Rules, 1954 and granted service pension vide PCDA (Pension),
Allahabad Pension Payment Order No.S/19982/2017 (Army) dated
06.04.2017. Thereafter, on receipt of the Release Medical Board (RMB)
opinion, an Adjudication Board was constituted to adjudicate the case of the
petitioner. The overall onset assessed by the RMB is 40% (30% and 20% for
PH and DM Type-II respectively). The Board agreed and opined that the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
disabilities-PH and DM Type-II was developed by the petitioner be regarded
as Neither Attributable to Nor Aggravated (NANA) by military service and
assessed disabilities at 40% compositely and net assessment qualifying for
disability pension ‘Nil for Life’ on the basis of AFMSF-16 (Ver-2006).
Hence, the petitioner was disentitled for the grant of disability pension by
the Air Force Authority, being metabolic disorder with strong generic
preponderance. This was communicated to him by the Army Air Defence
Records vide letter No.AAD/JC-299771Y/DP/Pen dated 25.05.2017.
6.
Pursuant to this, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the
Appellate Committee on First Appeal (ACFA) on 28.05.2017. The appeal
was rejected by the ACFA by stating that both PH and DM Type-II are
idiopathic/ metabolic disorders with strong genetic preponderance and
aggravation is conceded only when onset occurs in field/CI – Ops /HAA
areas.
7.
Further, aggrieved with the decision of ACFA, the petitioner preferred
a second appeal dated 08.09.2021 before the Second Appellate Committee
on Pension (SACP), which was also rejected by stating that the onset of the
disease was in peace area, and both the disabilities lacked any casual nexus
with military service and no aggravation occurred as the petitioner continued
to remain posted in the same peace station until discharge.
8.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner filed an Original Application
(OA) No.2892/2022 before the Armed Forces Tribunal (Principal Bench),
New Delhi (AFT) on 30.11.2022, to grant him 40% disability element as
assessed by the RMB, as attributable and aggravated by Military Service and
pay him the due arrears of disability pension with interest @ 10% per annum
with benefit of rounding off to 50% in terms of the decision of the Supreme
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
Court in the case of Union of India v. Ram Avtar,2014 SCC Online SC
1761. However, this too, was dismissed on merit and on the ground of delay
vide order dated 03.09.2024 (impugned order) passed by the AFT. Even the
Review Application No.54/2024 preferred by the petitioner before the AFT
was dismissed vide order dated 16.10.2024 (impugned order).
9.
Both these orders of the AFT have been assailed before us. The AFT
in the order dated 03.09.2024 has observed that at the time of onset of the
disease, the petitioner was overweight with an actual weight of 83Kgs as
against the ideal weight of 67.5Kgs. It observed that even though, such
weight was within permissible limit at the time, i.e., below 77 Kgs, the same
fact of the petitioner being overweight cannot be ignored. It concluded that
the PH and DM Type-II were attributable to the petitioner being overweight,
added by the interplay of metabolic and lifestyle factor(s), which could have
been managed by regular exercise, diet restriction, failure of which signified
that the petitioner himself invited the disabilities.
10.
Mr. Manoj Kumar Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
states that the petitioner has served for 39 years in various places - in peace
and field areas. It was during his posting at Suratgarh (Modified Field) that
he has diagnosed with the disability - PH and DM Type-II. He states that his
disability element was rejected by treating origin in peace area, being
contrary to policy. His claim was wrongly rejected by stating the same to be
metabolic disorder with strong genetic preponderance completely ignoring
the field area onsets of disability. It also ignored that PH and DM Type-II
can be influenced / aggravated by stress, unique demands of military service,
improper diet, staying away from family etc., which indirectly affects their
lifestyle.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
11.
He has relied upon para 53(a) of the Pension Regulations 2008, which
reads as under:"(a) An individual released/retired/discharged on
completion of term of engagement or on completion
of service limits or on attaining the prescribed age
(irrespective of his period of engagement), if found
suffering from a disability attributable to or
aggravated by military service and so recorded by
Release Medical Board, may be granted disability
element in addition to service pension or service
gratuity from the date of retirement/discharge, if the
accepted degree of disability is assessed at 20
percent or more".
12.
He states that the petitioner is fulfilling both the criteria of the getting
disability pension as per the Pension Regulation 1961 and 2008 for the
Army and entitlement Rules 2008 and para 423 of the Medical Regulation
for the Armed Forces 2010.
13.
As per him, the law is settled in view of the decision of the Supreme
Court in Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India & Ors., 2013 (7) SCC 361,.
Union of India v. Rajbir Singh, 2001 SCC Online SC 995 decided on
13.02.2015. However, this was not dealt with by the AFT. Moreover, he is
placing reliance on the following judgments of the AFT, which were also
produced before the AFT for consideration, viz, Sub Ashok Kumar Malik
(Retd) OA no.470/2022 and WO Pawan Kumar (Retd) in OA 282/2021.
The view in these cases was further taken by the larger bench of the AFT in
Hav Rajkumar OA no.57/2020 dated 12.04.2023.
14.
He has also placed reliance on the judgment in the case of in Bijender
Singh v. UOI, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 895, UOI & Ors vs. Maj Gen Rajesh
Chaba 2025 SCC Online Del 4635 which directed for disability element for
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
the soldiers afflicted with diseases such as obesity, PH, DM and CAD,
referred to in the decision of UOI v. Col Balbir Singh (Retd) & Ex Sub
Gawas Anil Madso, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 2018, which emphasised that
unless RMB establishes clear evidence, the claim of the petitioner cannot be
refuted.
15.
He has also referred to the decision of the Supreme Court Veer Pal
Singh v. Sec MoD, 2013 8 SCC 83 to state that the judicial / quasi judicial
forums entrusted with the task of deciding disputes related to pre mature
discharge from the Army must not refuse to examine the record of the
medical boards for determining whether or not the conclusion reached by it
is legally sustainable.
16.
He heavily relies upon the decision of this Court in the case of
Dropadi Tripathi v. UOI & Ors, 2025, DHC:8709-DB wherein this Court
held as under:“11. The law relating to disability pension is well settled by
the judgments of the Supreme Court in Dharamvir Singh
and Bijender Singh v Union of India, 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 895,the judgment of a coordinate Bench of this Court
(authored by one of us, C. Hari Shankar, J.) in Gawas Anil
Madso and the judgment of a coordinate Division Bench of
this Court in Union of India v Balbir Singh, Judgment
dated 1 July 2025 in WP C 140/2024.
12. In all these decisions, the common considerations
which are to govern any plea for disability pension now
stand authoritatively crystalised. The Court is first to see
whether, at the time of induction into military service, any
note had been entered to the effect that the candidate was
suffering from the disability or ailment from which she, or
he, was later found to be suffering and on account of which
the candidate was invalided or released out of service. If
not, the Court has to see whether there is any noting that
stage to the effect that the ailment was one which could not
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
have been detected or whether the absence of noting was
on account of any concealment of information by the
candidate by herself/himself. If these considerations do not
apply, there would be a presumption that the ailment or
disability is attributable to military service, unless the
RMB or Specialist who examined the officer attributes the
ailment or disability to some other cause.
13. In our decision in Gwas Anil Madso, we have also
noted in this context the regulations of the respondents
themselves, particularly Rule 9 of the Entitlement Rules for
Casualty Pensionary Awards, 1982, in which it is
specifically noted that the onus to prove a causal
connection between the disability and military service is
not on the candidate but on the administration.
14. It is for the medical board to ascertain and identify the
cause, other than military service, to which the ailment or
disability can be attributed. If no such causal connection is
found to exist by the medical board, or even by the
specialist who has examined the candidate, the plea for
disability pension cannot be rejected.
15. In Bijender Singh, the Supreme Court has advocated an
expansive view in such cases, and has cautioned against
unjustified rejections of pleas for disability pension.
***
***
***
20. Thus, even the specialist who has examined the
petitioner has only noticed that the petitioner was suffering
from obesity and primary hypertension but has not come to
any conclusion that the latter was on account of the former
or that there was any causal connection between the two.
21. It is well known that every obese person does not suffer
from hypertension, and every person who suffers from
hypertension is not necessarily obese.
22. The impugned order passed by the Tribunal, therefore,
is ex facie contrary to the law laid down in this regard.
The Tribunal, in our respectful opinion, was not justified
in drawing, of itself, a causal connection between the
hypertension and the obesity form which the petitioner was
suffering, where no such causal connect is noticed either
in the opinion of the RMB or even in the opinion of the
specialist who had examined the petitioner.
23. Applying the law laid down in Dharamvir Singh,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
Bijender Singh, and Gawas Anil Madso, the petitioner
would be entitled to disability pension as sought by her.”
17.
The decision in the case of Dropadi Tripathi (supra) has also been
followed by this Court in the case of WG CDR Eswara Raghuraj (Retd) v.
Union of India & Others, 2025:DHC:10767-DB.
18.
Mr Gupta also relies upon the paragraph 423 (a) of Regulation For
the Medical Services of the Armed forces-2010 (Revised Version) which
categorically provides that “For the purpose of determining whether the
cause of a disability or death resulting from disease is or is not attributable
to service, it is immaterial whether the cause giving rise to the disability or
death occurred in an area declared to be a Field Service/ Active Service
Area or under normal peace conditions”.
19.
Further Rule-7 of Entitlement Rules for Casualty Pensionary Awards-
2008, provided that ordinarily the claimant will not be called upon to prove
the condition of entitlement. Rule 10 (b) (iii) of Entitlement Rules 2008, is
clear, that if the disability arose during the service, then it shall be presumed
that the same is because of the service unless this presumption is rebutted,
the onus lies on the organization and not the individual. The aforesaid rule is
reproduced as under: "If nothing at all is known about the cause of disease and
the presumption of the entitlement in favor of the claimant
is not rebutted, attributability should be conceded on the
basis of the clinical picture and current scientific medical
application"
20.
Rule-11 of Entitlement Rules 2008, mandates that a disability shall
be considered aggravated; if its onset is hastened or the subsequent course is
worsened by the specific condition of military service, such as posted in
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
places of extreme climatic conditions, e.g., fields, operation high altitudes
etc., but it does not mean that the disabilities arising during peace postings
cannot be held as attributable to or aggravated by military service. In this
regard it is most relevant to mention that AFT has observed in large number
of cases that, peace stations have their own pressure of rigorous military and
associated stress and strain of the service and that such a discrimination
between postings in peace area or Field/HAA/CI Ops areas to say that there
is no stress and strain of service for the purpose of granting disability
pension. It may also be taken into consideration that most of the personnel
of the armed forces, during their service, work in the stressful and hostile
environments, difficult weather conditions and under strict disciplinary
norms. Further, Rule-4(a) of Entitlement Rules for Casualty Pensionary
Awards 2008, lays down that “disability element will also be admissible to
personnel who retire or are discharged on completion of terms of
engagement in low medical category on account of disability attributable to
or aggravated by military service, provide the disability is accepted as not
less than 20%”.
21.
He states the AFT has rejected the petitioner’s disability claim by
emphasising his weight and underplaying the significance of his service
related conditions. The presumption under Section 173 is that the disabilities
arising in services are linked to military unless proven otherwise. The
weight alone would not negate the service connection to the petitioner’s PH
and DM Type-II. His condition was diagnosed while he was stationed in
Suratgarh.
22.
Reliance was also placed by him on Regulation 81 and 82 that
recognize the field areas that are extreme, with enduring conditions that can
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
exacerbate or lead to disabilities and according to him, Suratgrah was one
such area. He states that the medical assessment was conducted by qualified
authorities, who did not attribute the petitioner’s condition to his weight.
Hence, the tribunal’s emphasis on weight contradicts the medical finding.
23.
He further states such denial of disability pension is inconsistent with
the Army’s Welfare Doctrine which mandates that a service member’s
health impacted by service must be supported by adequate pension. The
AFT’s decision disregards the realities of field service and violates the
principles of equality enshrined under Section 14 of the Constitution.
24.
Contesting the above submissions of Mr Gupta, Mr Amit Tiwari,
learned CGSC appearing for the respondents submits that the present
petition seeks to overturn the findings of all the authorities and
fundamentally mischaracterises the medical and administrative record. As
per him, the RMB determination that the disabilities are NANA is final
unless shown to be perverse, arbitrary or unsupported by medical science.
In the present case, no such infirmity has been demonstrated. The petition
solely proceeds on an erroneous premise that mere presence of disability at
the time of discharge automatically entitles an individual to disability
element, which is contrary to the scheme of the statute.
25.
He further submits that the disability pension jurisprudence is highly
fact specific, dependent on the nature of onset, location of posting, causal
nexus and service conditions. The RMB in this case has expressly negated
any causal connection and the onset of the disabilities being in the peace
station, the said fact also not being disputed by the petitioner, the judgments
relied upon by the petitioner are inapplicable to the facts of this case.
26.
It is also his submission that the Entitlement Rules 2008 [Rule 7,
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
10(b) (iii), 11, 14] require a link between the disability and the service.
Even though, the composite assessment for the petitioner is 40%, the
rounding off to entitlement arises where the disability element is otherwise
payable. However, since the net qualifying disability was assessed at NIL
for life, the question of rounding off to 50% does not arise.
27.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, the issue which falls
for consideration is whether the petitioner is entitled to the disability element
of the pension. The AFT rejected the OA filed by the petitioner by stating in
paragraph 6 onwards as under:“6. On the careful perusal of the materials available on
record and also the submissions made on behalf of the
parties, we are of the opinion that it is not in dispute that
the extent of disabilities was assessed to be above 20%
which is the bare minimum for grant of disability pension
in terms of Regulation 53 (a) of the Pension Regulations
for the Army, 2008, (Part-I).
7. It is pertinent to note that at the time of the onset of the
disease, the applicant was overweight, with an actual
weight of 83 Kg as against an ideal weight of 67.5 Kg. We
have taken note of the fact that the weight of the applicant
was within permissible limit at the time of RMB at 77 Kg.
However, even if that is so, we cannot ignore the fact that
the applicant was overweight at the time of onset of the
disabilities thus bringing us to the conclusion that the
Primary Hypertension and Diabetes Mellitus Type-II are
attributable to his being overweight rather than the stress
and strain of service, as asserted by the applicant.
Therefore, we hold that the organization cannot be held
liable for the applicant's personal health choices and
actions.
8. We cannot shy away from the fact, that the disabilities,
i.e., Primary Hypertension and Diabetes Mellitus Type-II
are due to interplay of metabolic and lifestyle factors and
failure in maintaining the ideal body weight which can be
managed by regular exercise and restricting diet, and the
fact that the applicant being overweight signifies that he
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
has remained obese over a period of time, thereby, himself
inviting the disabilities, and in such a case, it would be
grossly unjustified for us to ignore the aforesaid facts.
9. Applying the above parameters to the case at hand, we
are of the view with respect to disabilities, i.e., Primary
Hypertension and Diabetes Mellitus Type-II, there is no
denial from the fact that if the claimant is ·himself not
responsible enough to control the factors which are well
within his voluntary control, he cannot be allowed to
garner benefit of such beneficial schemes and provisions.
10. Therefore, in view of our analysis, the OA is liable to be
dismissed both on the ground of merit and delay.
11. Consequently, the OA 2892/2022 and MA 3997/2022
are dismissed.”
28.
The AFT noted that the disabilities were assessed to be above 20%, in
terms of the Regulation 53(A) of the Pension Regulations for the Army,
2008; that on the onset of the disease, the petitioner was overweight, with an
actual weight of 83 Kg as against an ideal weight of 67.5 Kg; that the weight
of the petitioner was within permissible limit at the time of RMB, 77 Kg and
drew the conclusion that the PH and DM Type-II are attributable to his
being overweight rather than the stress and strain of service, to hold that the
organization cannot be held liable for the petitioner’s personal health
choices and actions.
29.
The relevant portion RMB opinion is in the following manner:-
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
30.
It is also important to reproduce the opinion of the medical specialist
as under:-
31.
The RMB does not opine that it is because of the obesity that the
petitioner had developed issues like PH and DM Type-II. The law relating to
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
the disability pension is well settled by the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Dharamvir Singh (supra), Bijender Singh(supra) and the judgment of
the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Gawas Anil Madso (Supra) and
Union of India v. Balbir Singh, (Supra).
32.
The common consideration in these judgments shall govern the grant
of disability pension. It has to be examined whether at the time of induction
into military service, any note had been entered to the effect that the
petitioner was suffering from any disability or ailment, No note had been
entered that the petitioner was suffering from any disability or ailment, from
which he was later found to be suffering and on account of which the
candidate was invalidated or released out of service. If not, the Court has to
see whether there is any finding to the effect that the ailment was one which
could not have been detected or whether the absence of noting was not on
account of any concealment of information by the candidate herself /himself.
If these considerations do not apply, there would be a presumption that the
ailment or disability is attributable to military service, unless the RMB or
specialist who examined the officer attributes the ailment or disability to
some other cause.
33.
In the case of Gwas Anil Madso (supra) the Coordinate Bench of this
Court had noted in the context of the regulations of respondents, particularly
Rule 9 of the Entitlement Rules for Casualty Pensionary Awards 1982 in
which it is specifically noted that the onus to prove a causal connection
between the disability and military service is not on the candidate but on the
administration.
34.
It is for the medical board to ascertain and identify the cause, other
than military service, to which the ailment or disability can be attributed.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
The Supreme Court in Bijender Singh (supra), has reiterated this view in
such cases.
35.
The claim of the petitioner in this case is on the basis of the
disabilities on account of PH and DM Type-II. We have already reproduced
the relevant conclusions drawn by the RMB.
The RMB does not give
reasons for it to say that the disabilities are not connected with the service.
In other words, the RMB does not record any specific causal link between
the PH and DM Type-II with metabolic and life factors or genetic
preponderance. Thus, while disabilities are not attributable to service, they
are also not attributed to any cause by the RMB/Specialist.
What is
important is that the AFT itself independently drew a connection between
PH and DM Type-II with lifestyle factors and failure in maintaining ideal
body weight, which can be managed by regular exercise and restricting the
diet. Thus, the inference drawn by the AFT cannot be consistent with the
view taken by this Court in para no.12 of the decision Dropadi Tripathi
(supra), as reproduced above.
36.
During the course of the submissions, the learned counsel for the
respondents would highlight the fact that the petitioner had preferred an
appeal before the ACFA, which was rejected by stating that PH and DM
Type-II
are
idiopathic/metabolic
disorders,
with
strong
genetic
preponderance and aggravation is conceded only when onset occurs in
field/CI–Ops /HAA areas. It was also highlighted that in the second appeal,
preferred by the petitioner before the SACP, which was rejected by the said
committee by stating that onset of the disease was in the peace area and both
the disabilities lacked any causal nexus with military service and no
aggravation occurred as the petitioner continued to remain posted in the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
same peace station until discharge.
37.
Again we find that neither the ACFA nor SACP have connected the
diseases – PH and DM Type-II’s cause not to the military service. So, the
impugned order passed by the AFT is also not consistent with the
established legal position in view of the absence of any causal link
established by the RMB or the Specialist. Surely, from the decisions in the
case of Gawas Anil Madso (supra), Dharamvir Singh(supra) and Bijender
Singh (supra), the petitioner would be entitled to disability pension.
38.
In view of our aforesaid discussion, we find that the AFT was not
justified in rejecting the claim of the petitioner for disability pension.
Moreso, there was no finding of the RMB that the disabilities suffered by
the petitioners are attributable to some other cause other than the military
service.
39.
On the aspect of delay, the second appeal of the petitioner was
decided in terms of the communication dated 26.09.2022, and the OA was
filed on 30.11.2022, which was within limitation. Hence, the conclusion of
the Tribunal rejecting the OA on delay is also untenable.
40.
The petitioner herein is seeking disability pension on the basis of PH
and DM Type-II, which have been assessed at 30% and 20% for life
respectively, overall 40%. The petitioner shall be entitled to rounding off of
the disability pension at 50%, in view of the decision in Ram Avtar (Supra)
41.
Accordingly, the impugned order passed in OA No.2892/2020 dated
03.09.2024 and review order dated 16.10.2024 are quashed and set aside.
Consequently, the petitioner is entitled to disability pension element from
the date of his retirement, i.e, 27.02.2017. The arrears shall carry interest @
9% per annum till its payment.
This exercise be carried out by the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
respondents within a period of twelve weeks from today.
42.
The petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANURARY 08, 2026
M
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
15:23:37
W.P.(C) 16100/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review