Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 08th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 12th February, 2026
RFA 897/2024
+
1.
Ms. Stuti Singh
2.
Sh. Shohit Chaudhry
Both presently residing at –
6/2, Ground Floor,
Kalkaji Extension
New Delhi – 110 019
Email: shohitc@gmail.com
+91 9999091964
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Samrat Nigam, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Siddhant Kumar Singh,
Advocate.
versus
Mr. Deepak Luthra
E-165, East of Kailash,
New Delhi – 110 065
Email: dcmfam@gmail.com
+91 9810269159
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Syed Aquib Ali and Mr. Syed
Azhar Ayaz, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
1.
The present Appeal has been filed under Section 96 read with Order
XLI Rule 1 and Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
(hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) against the Order dated 01.10.2024
passed by the Ld. District Judge-07, New Delhi, whereby the Plaint in CS
DJ No. 3194/2024, was rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC for
non-disclosure of cause of action.
2.
Briefly stated, the Respondent, Mr. Deepak Luthra, is the owner of
the Suit Property, E-165, East of Kailash, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to
as „Suit Property‟). Appellant No. 1, Ms. Stuti Singh, was the
Communications Consultant working with a Public Relations Consultancy.
Appellant No. 2, Mr. Shohit Chaudhry, is a lawyer practicing, in the Courts
of Delhi.
3.
The Appellants jointly in the year 2020-21, took the first floor of the
Suit Property of the Respondent up to 31.08.2021, on a monthly lease
amount of Rs. 45,500/- and paid an interest-free security deposit of Rs.
91,000/- to the Respondent, vide Lease Agreement dated 19.09.2020.
4.
It is submitted that during the tenancy, the Respondent and his wife,
Mrs. Chandani Luthra, repeatedly harassed the Appellants, by frowning and
commenting on visits by guests, visitors, and delivery personnel and by
making inquiries from the Appellants’ maids regarding happenings inside
the Appellants’ house. The Appellants further alleged that the Respondent
placed trunks, luggage, junk and scrap material on the staircase from the
rented floor to the terrace and on the landing, where the Appellants’ power
inverter was installed, thereby obstructing free movement of the Appellants,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
their maid and other staff such as electricians, from the said floor to the
terrace.
5.
It is asserted that on 08.01.2021, when a guest of the Appellants,
namely Mr. Pankaj Agarwal, entered the Suit Property to visit the
Appellants, the Respondent’s wife allegedly misbehaved with him, claiming
that he had not properly locked the gate of the Suit Property and made him
apologise for the incident, before allowing him to access the staircase to
reach the tenanted floor.
6.
The Appellants also plead an incident dated 02.09.2021 wherein the
Respondent is stated to have misbehaved with Mr. Kartikey Mahajan and
Appellant No. 2 regarding parking outside the Suit Property.
7.
Further, on 06.09.2021 the Respondent’s wife, who was allegedly at
home most of the time, switched off the common light in the stairwell when
she saw the Appellants using the staircase, and that she repeated this conduct
on several other occasions, until the Appellants vacated the Suit Property.
8.
It is submitted that upon two-month renewal of the tenancy on
31.08.2021, the Respondent attempted to make unilateral changes to the
Agreement, restricting use of the Suit Property to the residential purposes of
self and one domestic help, whereas earlier use by immediate family
members was permitted. However, the Appellants prevailed upon the
Respondent and the Clause pertaining to immediate family members, was
retained.
9.
The Appellants further submitted that at the time of vacating the Suit
Property and handing over possession on 31.10.2021, the Respondent and
his wife created a hue and cry and took about two hours to accept possession
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
of the vacant floor, checked each electrical and water fitting and raised
allegedly frivolous issues, such as the geyser not providing warm water and
one air-conditioner not cooling properly, though the Appellants state they
eventually satisfied all concerns.
10.
It is also submitted that the Respondent and his wife initially declined
to refund the full security deposit, made allegedly illegal deductions towards
outstanding electricity and gas bills, but eventually refunded the balance
amount, on 10.11.2021.
11.
On these averments, the Appellants claim to have suffered mental
agony, trauma and harassment and instituted Civil Suit, CS DJ No.
3194/2024 titled “Stuti Singh & Anr. Vs. Deepak Luthra” seeking damages
of Rs. 15,00,000/- along with interest @ 12% per annum from the
Respondent, for alleged harassment and violation of their right to peaceful
and quiet enjoyment of the tenanted property.
12.
The Plaint was rejected by Ld. District Judge-07, New Delhi, under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC, by observing that the Suit did not disclose a cause
of action against the Respondent/Defendant. The Ld. Trial Court held that
the Appellants’/Plaintiffs’ allegations of misbehaviour by the Defendant’s
wife, could not fasten liability on the Defendant as she was not a party, and
the claim founded on the incident dated 08.01.2021, was barred by
limitation since the Suit was filed on 24.08.2024.
13.
The Appellants have challenged the rejection of the Suit, inter
alia, on the grounds that the Ld. Trial Court exceeded the limited scope of
Order VII Rule 11(a) and undertook a “roving enquiry” of the merits of
allegations. It was further contended that if on a plain reading, the Plaint
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
discloses any cause of action “howsoever trivial”, the court ought to proceed
to trial, rather than dismiss the Plaint at a preliminary stage.
14.
The Appellants further agitated that the Ld. Trial Court erred in
treating the claim arising from an incident dated 08.01.2021 as time-barred.
The Appellants contend that there exists a continuing cause of action till
their vacation of the Suit Property dated 31.10.2021 and the Suit is within
the limitation period, in view of the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s Order in Suo
Moto Writ Petition No. 3 of 2020, which, inter alia, excluded the Covid-19
period for limitation from judicial proceedings.
15.
The Respondent in his Reply to the Appeal, has submitted that he is
a senior citizen, aged about 78 years, and the Appellants vacated the Suit
Property on 31.10.2021. The Suit for Rs. 15 lakhs, which is more than two
and a half times the total rent paid, was filed nearly three years after
vacation, with the intent to exert undue pressure and amounts to abuse of
process. The Respondent claimed that the plaint is manifestly vexatious and
contains general allegations without material particulars.
16.
It is further submitted by the Respondent that the matter is barred by
limitation and predominantly targets acts attributed to the Respondent’s
wife, who is not a party and not pleaded to have acted at the Respondent’s
behest. Even the incident involving the Appellants’ guest on 02.09.2021 is
pleaded as a dispute about a vehicle parked outside the Suit Property, which
cannot be made a basis to claim “mental harassment” and consequent
damages against a Landlord.
Submissions heard and record perused.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
17.
Essentially, the case pertains to a tenancy dispute founded on alleged
misbehaviour of the Respondent with guests of the Appellant; inconvenience
due to articles on common staircase and landing; disagreements during
renewal negotiations; an altercation regarding a guest’s vehicle parked
outside the Suit Property, and delayed return of security deposit.
18.
The main issue before this court is: whether the Suit of the
Appellants disclosed a cause of action.
19.
First, a substantial part of the averments pertains to alleged
misbehaviour by the Respondent’s wife, Mrs. Chandani Luthra, towards the
Appellants’ visitors and turning off of the common light. The Respondent’s
wife is not impleaded as a party, and the Plaint does not plead foundational
facts to fasten civil liability for damages upon the Respondent for the
independent conduct of his adult spouse. In the absence of such pleadings,
the Appeal fails to disclose how the Respondent, in law, became liable to
pay damages for alleged acts committed by another.
20.
Second, as regards the placing of articles like trunks, luggage, junk
and scrap material on the staircase, it is claimed by the Appellants that their
maid got injured due to sharp edges of material lying in the staircase.
Moreover, on two occasions an electrician along with Appellant No. 2
himself, sustained similar injuries while tending to the power inverter.
21.
The Pleading, however, contains averments which are generalized
assertion of inconvenience and isolated incident of injury and do not state
the material particulars, the dates or circumstances of the alleged injuries to
the maid, electrician and Appellant No. 2, nor does it plead specific medical
expense, loss of work, or quantifiable pecuniary loss attributable to the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
Respondent, to substantiate a cause of action for civil claim for damages.
Such vague averments with no specific details, do not disclose any cause
of action.
22.
Additionally, from the photographs filed by the Appellants as part of
their pleadings, there appears to be no major obstruction on the
staircase/landing, for the Appellants to access their premises. At best, such
incidents may reflect some inconvenience, but did not deprive the
Appellants from absolute enjoyment of the tenanted property.
23.
Third, the grievance regarding renewal of tenancy terms, and for
retaining the clause permitting immediate family members, does not disclose
any breach resulting into a legal injury, for which damages may be claimed.
It was merely a negotiation of terms during renewal which, as admitted,
ended in the Appellants’ favour and the term was retained, as desired by the
Appellants. The negotiations of terms for continuation of Lease for two
months by no parameter of law, can be termed as harassment.
24.
Fourth, the incident dated 02.09.2021 relating to an altercation about
a vehicle parked outside the Suit Property, as pleaded, is not shown to have
resulted in any legally actionable interference with the Appellants’
possession of the tenanted Suit Property, to ground a claim for damages for
breach of quiet enjoyment. The Pleading, read as a whole, reflects a
neighbourhood parking discord, rather than an interruption of the
Appellants’ lawful occupation and quiet enjoyment of the demised Suit
Property.
25.
Fifth, the allegations that the Respondent and his wife took time to
accept possession and to check the fittings and appliances at the time of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
vacating, do not disclose any legal wrong; such verification, as pleaded, is
consistent with ordinary inspection practices at the time of handover and in
the security deposit was eventually settled between the parties on
10.11.2021.The Respondent may have been cautious, in ensuring that all
bills were cleared and there was no damage to the fittings and fixtures, but
that would be done by any Landlord and cannot be termed as an act of
harassment or interference in peaceful enjoyment of Suit Property or
harassment of the appellants. Admittedly, the security amount was returned
to the Appellants.
26.
It is well-settled law that for the purposes of Order VII Rule 11(a), the
Court must read the plaint as a whole to determine whether it discloses a
cause of action; the averments in the plaint are assumed to be correct for this
limited scrutiny.
27.
Equally, the existence of a “cause of action” is not a matter of form:
the plaint must plead the material facts which, even if accepted in entirety,
disclose a legal right in the Appellant and a corresponding legally actionable
wrong by the Respondent, giving rise to a right to sue for the relief claimed.
A plaint that narrates general vague averments without specifics as to
the incidents or without pleading the essential constituents of a claim
for damages, cannot be permitted to proceed as a trial. It is well settled
that such a Suit, which is bereft of any cause of action, cannot be taken up
for trial; the frivolous litigation needs to be nipped in the bud.
28.
The Appellants have placed reliance on Izzat Ali vs. Muhammad
Sharafatullah Khan, AIR 1917 All 355, Liverpool and London S.P. & I
Asson. Ltd. vs. M.V. Sea Success I and Ors., (2004) 9 SCC 512, Mayar
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
(H.K.) Ltd. and Ors. vs. Owners and Parties, Vessel M.V. Fortune Express
and Ors., (2006) 3 SCC 100, and C. Anantha Baskaran vs. S. Venkatesan
and Ors., (2022) 4 MLJ 242, to contend that even a trivial cause of action,
must go to trial.
29.
However, where the averments made in the Plaint even if accepted as
true, fails to disclose the essential material facts constituting even a trivial
triable issue/ cause of action, it does not warrant a full trial.
30.
The Appellants have invoked the implied covenant of quiet
enjoyment under Section 108(c) of the Transfer of Property Act. The
jurisprudence on quiet enjoyment recognises that actionable interference is
of a nature that deprives the tenant of the beneficial enjoyment and use of the
property, akin to a constructive eviction in appropriate cases.
31.
On the Appellants’ own showing, they continued in possession
during the term and vacated upon expiry of the Lease Agreement; the
Pleadings, even if accepted, do not set out material facts indicating any
deprivation of beneficial enjoyment of the demised property that would
sustain a money claim of 15,00,000 with interest @12% per annum for
damages, against the Respondent.
32.
The Respondents took an objection that the Suit, even otherwise, was
barred by limitation. The Suit Property was taken on rent on 19.09.2020 and
vacated on 31.10.2021. The Suit was filed on 09.08.2024; the Appellants are
entitled to the benefit of the COVID exclusion, from 15.03.2020 till
28.02.2022. The Suit cannot be held as barred by limitation.
33.
For the foregoing reasons, there is no ground to interfere with the
Impugned Order dated 01.10.2024 rejecting the Plaint under Order VII Rule
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
11(a) CPC, on the ground of non-disclosure of a legally enforceable cause of
action.
34.
The Appeal is accordingly, dismissed.
35.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 12, 2026/N
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:01:01
RFA-897/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review