Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 06th November, 2025
Pronounced on: 05th February, 2026
%
CRL.A.1563/2025
+
STATE
Through Secretary,
GNCT of Delhi
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State.
versus
RITU RAJ THAKUR
S/o Sh. Anand Thakur,
R/o Flat No. 655, Pocket-5,
Mayur Vihar, Phase-1,
New Delhi-110091
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Tanveer Ahmed Mir, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Chandra Shekhar
Anand and Mr. Daksh Sachdeva,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Appeal under Section 378 (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (hereinafter referred to as „Cr.P.C‟), has been filed on behalf of the
Appellant/State against the Order dated 10.02.2017 of learned ASJ-04,
Delhi whereby the Respondent/Ritu Raj Thakur, has been acquitted
under Section 498A/306 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
referred to as „IPC‟) in FIR No. 36/2011, registered at Police Station
Pandav Nagar.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
2.
The brief facts are that Ms. Sharmistha and Accused, Ritu Raj
Thakur, got married on 06.03.2010, according to Hindu Rites and Rituals.
Ms. Sharmistha committed suicide on 01.02.2011 by hanging herself with a
bed sheet with the ceiling fan at her matrimonial home/rented
accommodation at H. No. 655, Pocket-V, Mayur Vihar, Phase-I, Delhi,
leaving a suicide note in her diary.
3.
The incident was recorded vide DD No. 32A dated 01.02.2011 at
22:50 hours in the Police Station Pandav Nagar, on receipt of telephone call
from LBS Hospital wherein it was recorded that she was brought dead due
to strangulation by her husband for which MLC No. 1025/11 was prepared.
The investigations were taken over by SI Sehdev Singh, who collected the
MLC from the Hospital. The proceedings under Section 176 Cr.P.C were
conducted by SDM, Preet Vihar, who tried to contact Ms. Ranjeeta Sharma
and Ms. Sharbani Kaushik, sister and mother of the deceased on their
telephones but they did not respond. The Crime Team also visited the spot
and conducted the investigations. Mr. Hukam Singh, the SDM, Preet Vihar
reached the spot on 02.02.2011, on receiving information from SI Sehdev
Singh.
4.
IO/SI Sehdev Singh conducted investigations and made enquiry from
the neighbours, seized the exhibits from the spot and also the diary
containing suicide note, mobile phone, dry blood and also earth control from
the spot. On 03.02.2011, the mother, sister and other family members of the
deceased, came to Delhi. Statement of Ms. Ranjeeta Sharma, the mother was
recorded and on the basis of which, FIR No. 36/2011, Police Station Pandav
Nagar, was registered.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
5.
After completion of investigations, the Charge-Sheet was filed in the
Court on 26.04.2011 for the offence under Section 498A/304B IPC.
6.
The
Charges
were
framed
on
19.11.2011
under
Section
498A/304B/306 IPC.
7.
The Criminal Revision Petition No. 135/2012 was preferred before
this Court whereby the offence under Section 304B IPC, was set-aside. The
Respondent/Accused faced the trial for the offence under Section 498A/306
IPC.
8.
The Prosecution in support of its case, examined 21 Prosecution
witnesses.
9.
PW-1, Ms. Sharbani Kaushik and PW-4, Ms. Ranjeeta Sharma,
sister and mother of the deceased, deposed that she had been subjected to
physical and mental harassment by her husband and in-laws for dowry
demands and expressed their suspicion against the Respondent. They also
proved the note book, Ex.PW-1/B containing handwriting of the deceased
and the diary, Ex.PW-1/C in which, the deceased had written a suicide note.
10.
PW-3, Hukam Singh, SDM, Preet Vihar, deposed that he had
conducted the enquiry from the neighbours as no family member was
available at the spot on 02.02.2011. He deposed about the articles as were
found lying on the spot, which were seized by the Police. He conducted the
inquest proceedings Ex.PW-3/B. In addition, he recorded the Statement of
Ms. Ranjeeta Sharma, Mr. Anang Bhattacharya, Ms. Namita Dutta and also
of the Accused/Respondent, Ritu Raj Thakur.
11.
PW-5, Rajeev Lochan Sharma, maternal uncle of the deceased,
corroborated and supported the allegations of harassment by the Respondent
of the deceased.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
12.
PW-9, Probindra Nath Sharma, paternal uncle of the deceased also
corroborated the allegations of harassment of the deceased by the
Respondent.
13.
PW-6, HC Ram Divya registered FIR No. 36/2011, Ex.PW-PW-6/A.
PW-7, Constable Satbir remained associated with the IO from 01.02.2011
till 03.02.2011 with PW-16, SI Sehdev, IO, for the investigations. PW-8
Constable Vinod Kumar took the exhibits from the Police Station and
deposited them with the FSL Rohini.
14.
PW-10, SI Vinod Kumar seized the Complaint dated 10.11.2010 in
the handwriting of the deceased against her husband in addition to treatment
papers, receipt of dowry articles, printout of SMS etc. PW-11, Constable
Jagbir Singh was a photographer, who took the photographs of the scene of
crime, which are Ex.PW-11/A1 to Ex.PW-11/A6 and the negatives are
Ex.PW-11/A7 to Ex.PW-11/A11.
15.
PW-12, Johnson, Assistant, SBI Bank, Mayur Vihar Branch,
identified the entries of Bank Account No. 31533119953 maintained by the
deceased with State Bank of India, which is Ex.PW-12/A.
16.
PW-13, Mahesh Kumar was a Draftsman, who has prepared the
scaled Site Plan, Ex.PW-13/A.
17.
PW-14, Constable Amit Gulia had joined the investigations with the
IO on 04.02.2011 when the Respondent was arrested vide Arrest Memo,
Ex.PW-14/A and his personal search memo is Ex.PW-14/B. PW-15,
Chander Shekhar, Nodal Officer, Bharti Airtel, proved the Customer
Application Forms, Ex.PW-15/A and Ex.PW-15/B in respect of Telephone
Nos. 9810507214 and 9810407414 in the name of the Accused/Respondent
and also the CDR Records between 01.08.2010 to 01.02.2011.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
18.
PW-16, SI Sehdev Singh was the Investigating Officer, who deposed
about the investigations conducted by him.
19.
PW-17, Dr. Rajni Lohia, LBS Hospital, had examined the deceased
when she was brought to the Police Station and prepared the MLC, Ex.PW17/A and also proved the Death Certificate, Ex.PW-17/B, which was issued.
20.
PW-18, Ms. Farzi Ahmed deposed that he and the deceased had
studied in the same school and he had attended her marriage. She had
remained in contact with her and she had observed marks of beatings on her
body, on account of demand of money by the Respondent. She also
disclosed about the disturbing features at matrimonial home during her
lifetime as per disclosed to her by the mother of the deceased.
21.
PW-19, Ms. Prachi was together with the deceased in the Hostel in
Mumbai while they were pursuing MBA course and she also narrated about
the facts as per her knowledge about the deceased and also about her life
after marriage. She also had attended her wedding and had remained in
contact with her.
22.
PW-20, HC Rajinder Kumar was working as Malkhana Muharir,
who proved the Register No.19 as Ex.PW-20/B. PW-21, Inspector Bharat
Meena took over the inspection from PW-16, SI Sehdev Singh and on
completion of investigation, filed the Charge-Sheet in the Court.
23.
The Statement of the Respondent under Section 313 Cr.P.C was
recorded wherein he denied all the incriminating evidence. He stated that it
was a dowry less marriage. He asserted that they used to go for outing and
everything was fine except that she often remained lost. Initially, the
Respondent felt that it was on account of the marriage and things would
normalise in due course of time. However, in around May-June, 2010, he
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
found some photographs and video clips stored in the laptop of Ms.
Sharmistha wherein she was seen in the company of a person in a room,
whose name was disclosed as Jitender Bhandare with whom she was in
contact and she wanted to marry and she had an affair with him prior to
marriage. When these facts were brought to the notice of Ms. Ranjeeta
Sharma and Ms. Sharbani, the mother and sister of the deceased, they
hesitated to accept but later, they admitted these facts and the relationship
turned sour. He tried to convince the deceased to forget the past and to
change her mindset but to no result. He was in Assam from 22.01.2011 to
30.01.2011 and during this period, Ms. Mompy Sharma @ Monu stayed
with her. On 30.01.2011, on the eve of her birthday, they went out for dinner
to TGIF, Great India Palace Mart, Noida. Unfortunately, she committed
suicide on 01.02.2011 out of sheer depression as she could not forget her
past with Mr. Jitender Bhadare, with whom she wanted to live and was still
in love.
24.
The Respondent examined DW-1, Mr. Dipak Mitra, Deputy Manager,
State Bank of Travancore, R.K. Puram Branch, New Delhi, who proved his
Bank Account Statement, Ex.DW-1/2 for the period from 01.01.2010 to
31.03.2011 in regard to various transactions.
25.
DW-2, Ms. Mompy Sharma, wife of Mr. Ankur Phukkan deposed
that her husband, Ankur Phukkan and the Respondent were friends and they
had family relationships. She further deposed that while the Respondent was
away from 22.01.2011 to 30.01.2011, she stayed with the deceased at her
house in Mayur Vihar and Ms. Sharmistha had disclosed to her about her
past prior to her marriage and her affair with Mr. Jitender Bhandare besides
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
that she got married because of her mother and sister and that she was
leading a dual life.
26.
DW-3, Mr. Rajdeep Saxena, Deputy General Manager, M/s Ajnara
India Ltd., proved the allotment letter dated 05.10.2010, Ex.PW-3/A in
respect of Flat No. G-603. Plot No. GH-03, Sector-16B, Greater Noida,
District Gautam Budh Nagar, U.P., in the joint name of the deceased and
the Respondent, which had been booked by them on the eve of demise of
Ms. Sharmistha, another supplementary letter dated 10.05.2013, Ex.PW-3/2
was issued to the Respondent.
27.
DW-4, Mr. Ananga Bhattacharya, who was also living in the Mayur
Vihar, Phase-1, deposed that the Accused was the real brother of his wife
and deposed about the cordial relationship between the deceased and her
husband.
28.
Learned ASJ after appreciation of the entire evidence as produced on
the record, acquitted the Respondent vide Judgment dated 10.02.2017.
29.
Aggrieved by the Judgment of acquittal, the Appeal has been
preferred by the State. The grounds of challenge are that the consistent
testimony of the public witnesses in regard to the cruelty inflicted upon the
deceased by the Respondent, which drove her to suicide, has not been
considered by the learned ASJ in the right perspective.
30.
It has not been appreciated that the testimony of all these witnesses,
was consistent. The minor contradiction and improvement did not affect the
prosecution Case and should not have been made a ground for acquittal. If
there was any contradiction, it was a simple natural variation, which is
bound to occur. Also, the contradictions highlighted by the learned ASJ in
the Judgment of acquittal, did not go to the root of the Prosecution Case so
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
as to render it, not believable. Reliance is placed on Mohd. Shahid vs. State,
(2002) 7 AD (Delhi) 27.
31.
The Trial Court has heavily relied on the Suicide Note, but has
ignored the testimony of the witnesses and other material on record
including the Complaint dated 10.11.2010 of Domestic Violence,
Ex.PW4/A. The defence of the Accused that the deceased was in
relationship with Mr. Jitendra Bharndare and he had seen the Lavasa
photographs and video of the deceased, was not substantiated by him as he
failed to produce any video clips or photographs in his defence, though they
were in his possession.
32.
The testimony of PW-4/Complainant, Ms. Ranjeeta Sharma had
coherently deposed about how the deceased was beaten and mentally
tortured by the deceased, which was consistent with her Statement, Ex.PW4/A made to the SDM, which has not been considered. The learned Trial
Court fell in error in not appreciating the testimony of PW-1, sister of the
deceased, who had deposed about the exchange of messages showing that
the Respondent used to advise her sister to take high dosage of Episonin and
sleeping tablets and also that respondent used to beat her regularly.
33.
Likewise, testimony of PW-5, PW-9, PW-18 and PW-19, who have all
deposed about the acts of cruelty committed by the Respondent on the
deceased, were not considered. It is submitted that there was overwhelming
evidence to establish that the deceased had been subjected to cruelty during
her married life.
34.
On the aspect of the offence under Section 306 IPC, it is submitted
that from the evidence on record, it is clearly evident that she had been
instigated to commit suicide.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
35.
The Impugned Judgment is bad in law and is liable to be set-aside.
36.
Written Submissions have been filed on behalf of the
Respondent, who has controverted all the assertions made in the Appeal.
37.
He has referred to Section 498A IPC and the testimony of the
respective witnesses, to argue that no offence of harassment and cruelty
under Section 498A, was established. The learned ASJ had rightly noted the
inconsistencies in the Statement of PW-4/Smt. Ranjeeta Sharma. The
demand of dowry viz-a-viz receipts of purchase of articles, were not proved.
The allegations of transfer of Rs.1,40,000/- to the deceased by PW-4, was
never proved as the Statement of Account, Ex.PW-12/A did not show any
entry of Rs.1,40,000/-. The allegations of beating were without any specific
instances.
38.
The two Suicide Notes exonerated the Applicant. There is no
evidence to establish any act of the Respondent, which could amount to
abatement or instigation to commit suicide. No witness stated that the
incident of December, 2010 reflected any intention or instigation.
39.
It is further stated that the scope of interference in a Judgment of
acquittal is limited and it is not to be interfered except under substantial and
compelling circumstances.
40.
Reliance is placed on Chandrappa vs. State of Karnataka, (2007) 4
SCC 415; State vs. Sanjay & Ors., 2011 SCC OnLine Del 2781; State vs.
Vinod Kumar Yadav, 2015 SCC OnLine Del 9960; Ghurey Lal vs. State of
Uttar Pradesh, (2008) 10 SCC 450; Umedbhai Jadavbhai vs. State of
Gujrata, 1978 1 SCC 228 and Smt. Habiba vs. State of U.P., Application
under Section 378 No. 54/2017.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
41.
It is quite an unfortunate case where a young girl lost her life to
suicide on 01.02.2011. On the Complaint of hapless and distraught mother,
the Respondent/Ritu Raj Thakur, husband of the deceased had been charged
with the offences under Section 498A/306 IPC on account of alleged dowry
harassment and abetting his wife to commit suicide.
Allegations under Section 498A IPC:
42.
To prove an offence under Section 498A IPC, the Prosecution must
establish:
(i)
that the woman was subjected to cruelty or harassment by her
husband or his relatives;
(ii)
such cruelty must either be with a view to coerce her to meet
unlawful demands for property, or on account of failure to meet
such demands; or
(iii)
such cruelty must be of a nature that is likely to drive the
woman to commit suicide or cause grave injury to her life, limb
or health.
Inherent Contradictions and Improvements in the statements of PWs:
43.
The Prosecution relied primarily on the testimony of PW4/Smt.
Ranjeeta Sharma (mother), PW1/Ms. Sharbani (sister), PW5/Mr. Rajeev
Lochan Sharma (uncle), to PW18/Ms. Farzi Ahmad (friend), and PW19/Ms.
Prachi Khangde (friend).
44.
To prove cruelty or harassment, the most material witness examined
by the Prosecution is PW4/Smt. Ranjeeta Sharma, mother of the
deceased who deposed that Sharmistha Kaushik her daughter, got married to
the Respondent on 06.03.2010 at Tinskia, as per Hindu rites and ceremonies.
After the marriage, they both stayed for 24-28 days at the house of their in-
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
laws at Jorhat, Assam and thereafter, they went to Delhi and started residing
at Mayur Vihar.
45.
After about two months, Respondent started torturing her daughter,
as he was of suspecting nature. In the month of May, 2010 the daughter
telephonically informed that she was badly beaten up by the Respondent,
after questioning her about one Jinendra. She tried to talk to the
Respondent, but he got agitated and stopped talking to her. She was not
allowed to even talk to her daughter, by the Respondent. She came to Delhi
on 03.07.2010 to meet her daughter without informing anyone and stayed at
Assam House.
46.
On the next day i.e. 04.07.2010 she went to the house of the
Respondent at Mayur Vihar. After a long while, her daughter came out and
she saw the swelling on her lip and black marks on her cheeks. There was a
swelling on two fingers on her left hand which had got blackish. At that
time, one of her colleagues was also present with her. Therefore, the
deceased did not tell her anything except that she had received injuries due
to fall. After taking dinner, while she was resting with her daughter in her
room, she again enquired as to what had happened and how she had received
the injuries. She broke down and told her that on the previous night she was
badly beaten up by the Respondent by confronting her with the Telephone
Bill of August, September and October, 2009 wherein a lot of calls had been
made on a particular number. She took the daughter back to Assam on
07.07.2010 and got her treated in Assam. She got the X-ray of her fingers
also done.
47.
PW-1/Ms. Sharbani, sister of the deceased has deposed on similar
lines, but has admitted that all this was told to her by the mother.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
48.
From the comprehensive reading of the testimony of the two
witnesses, what emerges is that the deceased had started complaining about
torture at the hands of the Respondent, because he was of suspecting nature.
A significant aspect which has come forth in the testimony of PW-4 is that
in May, 2010 she was told by the deceased that she was confronted by the
Respondent with the Telephone Bills of August, September and October,
wherein calls were repeatedly made on a particular number, which was of
one Jinender, and she was beaten on this account. The mother tried to
counsel, but thereafter she was not allowed to talk to the daughter.
49.
Again, there is no cogent evidence in this regard about the
Respondent torturing the daughter in relation to the boy, Jinender. Even if it
was to be accepted, it reflects that there was some unease on account of
frequent calls to the deceased, by one Jinender. The Respondent may have
confronted the deceased about it, but that in itself cannot be termed as an act
of cruelty.
50.
To further claim that deceased was being tortured, PW4, Smt.
Ranjeeta Sharma has relied on the incident of 04.07.2010, when she had
found her daughter with injury marks and had taken her back to Johrat for
her treatment. Pertinently, aside from the bald assertions, there is no specific
details in regard to any of these incidents. There is neither any Medical
record or any other cogent evidence, to support the assertion that the
deceased was being physically tortured by the husband. She and the
deceased alone were living in the Mayur Vihar house and there is no cogent
evidence to show that she was being harassed by the Respondent.
51.
PW4/Smt. Ranjeeta Sharma further deposed that while the deceased
was with her in Johrat, the Respondent then started calling her daughter and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
pleaded guilty and swore that he would not commit the mistake again. He
pressurized her daughter to accompany him to his parent‟s house in Jorhat.
She was further told by the daughter that at times, the Respondent used to
become ferocious. She requested the parents of the Respondent to counsel
him. She further deposed that her daughter was ill-treated at her matrimonial
home and was made to work like a servant. She returned to Delhi on
28/29.07.2010, after the Respondent was counselled by his parents. After a
few days, he again started physically and mentally troubling her daughter, as
was told to her by the daughter on the telephone. Her younger daughter,
Sharbani informed her in August, 2010 that the Respondent had sent a slang
message to her.
52.
Admittedly, the PW4 had come to Delhi on 03.07.2010 and she
claimed that when she went to the house of the Respondent on 04.07.2010,
she found the injury marks on the face and fingers of the daughter and had
told her initially that she had suffered a fall. She brought her back to Assam
on 07.07.2010 for her treatment and the daughter had told that she was badly
beaten by the Respondent and she had got her treatment done and also the
finger X-rayed. However, no medical record has been placed on record to
corroborate that the deceased was beaten or that her mother had got her
treated in Assam.
53.
PW4, the mother (as well as PW-1, the sister) further deposed that
in October, 2010 the Respondent took her daughter to his parents house at
Jorhat, but she was not allowed to visit her house on the death anniversary of
her husband, on 21.10.2010. The parents of Respondent asked her deceased
daughter to take an oath in a temple that she would not keep any relation
with the mother and with her family members. They did not allow her to talk
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
to the mother. The daughter was physically and mentally tortured at Jorhat,
by the Respondent and his parents. They both returned to Delhi.
54.
Again, aside from bald assertions, there is nothing to corroborate that
such acts tantamount to cruelty, of the kind, envisaged in Section 498A IPC.
Rather, it may reflect some difference of opinion, inter se the families and
some adjustment issues, but cannot be termed as acts of cruelty.
55.
PW4, Smt. Ranjeeta Sharma, further deposed that the Respondent
had asked her daughter, to bring money for the purchase of furniture. She
deposited about Rs.1.40 lacs on different occasions, in the account of the
daughter, for the purchase of furniture or for meeting other requirements.
He did not give any money to her daughter for her maintenance, as was told
to her by her daughter on telephone. She had borne the expenses of learning
French language, by her daughter.
56.
Her testimony that she had given money for purchase of furniture to
the deceased or that she had been told about it by her daughter, did not find
mention in the two Statements, recorded by SDM/Police. The PW-4, in her
cross-examination, was unable to give the exact amount that was paid by
her.
57.
There is no Bank statement or any other document produced to show
that she had given in all Rs.1.40 lacs, on different occasions. Even if it is
accepted that she had been giving money from time to time to her daughter,
there is nothing to show that it was at the behest of the accused or there were
any kind of demands or that she was being harassed by the Respondent to
bring the money. It cannot be over looked that the Respondent and the
deceased were living independently in Mayur Vihar and even if it is
accepted, though not proved, that the mother had given some money from
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
time to time to her daughter, there is no evidence to relate it to the demands
or harassment of the deceased on this account.
58.
She deposed that in November, 2010, the daughter also sent a SMS to
Respondent by claiming that he had married her only for financial support.
However, she admitted not having told about the SMS written by the
daughter to the Respondent in November, 2010 about him having married
her only for financial support, in her statements to the police/SDM.
59.
Further, on 2nd and 4th November, 2010 the daughter sent an SMS
requesting to take her back, as she was not able to suffer the torture or else
something may happen to her. She, then along with her younger daughter,
Sharbani came to Delhi on 08.11.2010, to take back the deceased and stayed
at a lodge. She gave telephonic information about their coming to Delhi, to
the daughter. The Respondent was not letting the daughter to meet them.
60.
On 09.11.2010, the deceased had to appear in French language
examination. She and the younger daughter went to the examination venue,
where they met the deceased. When she returned to the house, she informed
the Respondent on the telephone, while he was in his office that she had met
the daughter. The Respondent warned her daughter to choose between him
and her mother. The deceased tried to counsel the Respondent, but he told
her to leave the house, before he returned.
61.
PW4 went to the house of the Respondent on 10.11.2010, to take back
Sharmistha with her to Assam. At that time, brother of the Respondent was
also present in the house. The deceased told the brother of Respondent that
Respondent consumes too much liquor everyday and used to come home
late in the night. The deceased requested the brother of the Respondent, to
not allow the Respondent to do so and to counsel him. She then took the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
daughter to her house, in Assam. She took the mobile phone of her
daughter, because of tension in the family. She also asked the daughter to
end the relationship with Respondent, if she was not finding it comfortable.
62.
PW1, the sister also corroborated in her evidence, that in November,
2010, the deceased had complained to the mother on telephone, about
physical and mental torture meted out to her and requested the mother to
take her back. Accordingly, she and the mother came to Delhi and stayed in
the Guest House. During the night, the deceased wanted to stay with them,
but the Respondent told her that if she went to stay with the mother and the
sister, she would have to leave the matrimonial home. On the next day, they
took her back to Assam.
63.
PW4 further deposed that on 25.11.2010, Respondent telephoned the
daughter, to tell her that the jewellery was not at home. Hearing this, the
daughter became upset and started crying. The Respondent asked the
daughter to come back to Delhi and search for the jewellery. The daughter
prepared a Complaint about the loss of jewellery and came to Delhi. She
informed the mother on telephone that on seeing the Complaint wherein it
was mentioned that she had left the house while the brother of the
Respondent was present at the house, Respondent told her that he was
having her jewellery with him.
64.
Again, aside from making generalized and vague allegations of the
deceased having been subjected to physical and mental torture, there are no
specific incidents which have been narrated to corroborate these assertions.
Moreover, no independent and cogent evidence has been led to support
these assertions. All the acts deposed above by PW4, again are not of the
kind that can be termed as cruelty of harassment, under Section 498A IPC.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
65.
PW4 further deposed that the daughter got a job in Delhi in the
Company Impact in December, 2010. She was hopeful that the things would
get sorted out, but the situation did not improve. She was informed on
telephone by the daughter “theek hai theek hai tum tension mat lo”, but she
noted that her daughter was not in a jolly mood. The Respondent had gone
to Jorhat on 22.01.2011, leaving the deceased alone in the house.
He
returned back to Delhi on 30.01.2011. In the absence of the Respondent, she
found the daughter alright, whenever she contacted her on telephone.
66.
On 01.02.2011, while she called her daughter, she was alright and was
going to her office. She called her again at lunch time and was told that the
daughter was busy, as the two colleagues were on leave on that day and she
was looking after their work as well. She asked the mother to call at around
6 P.M. The mother called her at 7 P.M. while she was in Metro. At about
08:00/08:10 P.M when she again called her by which time she had already
reached her house, she started crying and told that she has got injured. She
said that she was not in a mood to talk and would call later. Again, she
called her daughter at 9 P.M, but none picked up the phone. At about 10 P.M
when she gave a call to her, her phone was switched off. Next day, on
02.02.2011 at about 07:30 A.M she gave a call to the Respondent to enquire
why the mobile phone of the daughter was switched off, on which he
informed her that she has committed suicide. Her brother and brother-in-law
came from Duliajan to Delhi, by Air. On 03.02.2011 she gave a statement to
the Police which is Ex.PW4/A (earlier marked as Mark PW3/PA).
67.
Pertinently, PW4 in her cross-examination stated that her statement
was recorded twice, by the Police. She admitted that she did not tell to the
SDM in her statement that after about 2 months Accused/Respondent started
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
torturing the daughter as he was of suspecting nature. She further admitted
that she did not tell the SDM that in the month of May, 2010 her daughter
had telephonically told her that she was beaten up by the Respondent after
questioning her about a boy named, Jinender or that she tried to counsel him,
but he got agitated and even stopped talking to her. She admittedly, had told
not to the SDM as well as to the Police that on 04.07.2010 when she went to
the house of the Respondent at Mayur Vihar, she saw her daughter with
injuries on her face and two finger of left hand. In the statement under
Section 161 Cr.P.C Ex.PW4/D1, where it was only recorded that she had
noticed swelling on the face of the deceased due to beatings. She further
admitted that she had no proof of her stay at Assam house or the tickets to
prove her visit to Delhi on 03.07.2010. She reiterated that the daughter did
not tell her anything as her colleague had accompanied her, except that she
had received injuries in a fall, but again these facts are not mentioned in the
two statements of the witness.
68.
Her further statement that her daughter after the dinner while they
were resting, informed her of being beaten badly by the Respondent by
confronting her with the telephone Bills reflecting lot of calls been made on
one number, but again these averments were missing from both the
statements except that the daughter told the PW4 while weeping that her
husband was torturing her very much.
69.
This witness further admitted that in her two statements, it has not
been recorded that she got the daughter treated in Assam or had got the Xray of her finger done. Again, her testimony that the Respondent started
calling the daughter or pleaded guilty and swearing in the name of the
parents that he would not commit the mistake again, but the aspect of the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
Respondent swearing in the name of his parents was not mentioned in the
statement Mark PW4/D1.
70.
She did not state that the name of the colleague of her daughter, was
Sangeeta Burasagosain who had accompanied her to Delhi from Assam, but
her presence was not recorded by the Police. She further admitted in her
statement that the allegations that daughter was physically and mentally
tortured at Jorhat by the Respondent and his parents, was not mentioned in
her Statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C.
71.
PW4 has tried to explain that she was unable to state so, as she was
not in a fit condition at that time and was under pain and trauma, but she
stated so in her statement recorded subsequently by the Police under Section
161 Cr.P.C. However, when she was confronted with the Statement under
Section 161 Cr.P.C Ex.PW4/D1, these facts were not recorded therein, as
well.
72.
These material improvements and omissions in PW4‟s testimony, are
not minor discrepancies attributable to lapse of memory or natural variation
in narration. They constitute the introduction of entirely new facts, specific
incidents of violence, medical treatment, X-rays, demands for money, all of
which were never mentioned to either the SDM or the police, during
investigation, especially when the events were fresh in her mind. Such
embellishments cast serious doubt on the veracity of her testimony.
73.
The other material witness who has corroborated the testimony of
PW4, the mother is PW1/Ms. Sharbani sister of the deceased who
deposed on similar lines, that after 2-3 months of the marriage of her sister
to the Respondent, she started complaining about physical and mental
harassment for dowry demands and suspicion by the Respondent and her in-
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
laws. She used to tell the mother to bring her back. They used to talk daily
on telephone 2-3 times, but she used to be scared to talk during the presence
of the Respondent at home. In July, 2010, her mother had gone to the house
of the deceased and found bruises on her face and finger. She brought the
daughter back. Later, she was informed that she was given beatings by the
Respondent. Her sister used to complain on telephone that the Accused used
to drink liquor, come late and abuse and beat her. She also used to inform
that after taking liquor, he used to talk about her illicit affair with another
girl. He was not contributing anything for the expenses of the family and all
the expenses were borne by the mother. The Respondent used to ask for a
Sofa set, Dining set and other furniture articles from the mother. The
mother used to transfer the money to the account of the deceased from
which the Respondent had got the furniture. He used to scold the deceased
for watching TV and for this reason the deceased had stopped watching TV.
Prior to the marriage the deceased was working in Mumbai, but after
marriage, she came to Delhi. She has to leave her job. The deceased was
not getting any salary and the Respondent purposely removed the maid from
the house and the deceased was made to do the household work.
74.
PW1 further deposed that the accused then contacted the sister on
telephone and emotionally blackmailed her by apologizing and stating that
he would be a reformed person and would stop drinking and abusing. On the
assurance of the Respondent, her sister returned to Delhi in December, 2010.
Even thereafter, she made Complaints that the Respondent had not reformed
himself. On 02.02.2011, they received the information about the deceased
having committed suicide.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
75.
The testimony of the sister of the deceased is essentially about the
communication between the mother and the deceased. She had not been
personally witness to the alleged demands, harassment or to such
communications. Even if her testimony is accepted, it is only corroborating
what has been deposed by the mother, which does not establish any
harassment of the deceased by the Respondent or his parents or of she
having been subjected to cruelty which would have driven her to commit
suicide.
76.
The other witness examined by the Prosecution is PW18/Ms. Farzi
Ahmad who deposed that she knew the deceased as they both studied
together in the same school. She attended the marriage of the deceased with
the Respondent in March, 2009. The deceased was very excited about the
marriage and had shown her the photographs of the Respondent. She had
visited the house of the deceased in April or May and she looked happy.
She again visited her house in July, when she had noticed marks on her face
and she was told by the deceased that the Respondent had beaten her
because of demand of money. She also told that the Respondent had broken
her laptop, which was gifted to her by her father. Because of the family
disturbance, the deceased went back to the parental home in Assam. She
returned to her matrimonial home in December, 2010 with her mother and
sister. The mother of the deceased had asked her in December, 2010 when
she met her in Khan Market, if she knew about her problems on which she
told her about her visit to the house of the Sharmistha and what she had told
her. Later she came to know that deceased had passed away.
77.
The testimony of PW18 is as vague as it can be; though she narrated
that in July when she visited the house of the Respondent, she found some
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
marks on her face and was told that she was beaten by the Respondent
because of demand for money. This aspect of testimony is contradictory to
the testimony of PW1, PW4 who had narrated that she had been beaten up
on account of some person Jinender. She further deposed that deceased
came back because of family disturbances in Assam and returned in
December, 2010. Again, she has given vague date of the visit of the
deceased to her parental home and it does not establish any kind of
harassment at the hands of the Respondent. The testimony of PW18, does
not in any way proves that the deceased was physically or mentally harassed
by the Respondent.
78.
The next material witness of the Prosecution was PW19/Ms. Prachi
Khandge, who deposed that she was knowing the deceased since 4-5 years
prior to her death, as they stayed together in a hostel in Mumbai. At that
time, the deceased was doing MBA while she was also working. She was
not happy with her marriage with the Respondent. She had spoken to the
deceased three times after marriage, but she did not tell her the reason for
being unhappy. As and when she asked for a reason, she told that she would
tell later.
79.
Pertinently, PW19, Ms. Prachi Khandge, in her cross-examination
admits that after few months of marriage, deceased had told her about the
Respondent suspecting her character. She, however, denied that the
deceased had told her that she was abused and beaten by the Respondent.
She admitted that the deceased her told her that Respondent used to take
liquor and abused her, but stated that she did not remember if she was ever
told that Respondent used to beat her or that she ever stated this to the Police
in her statement Mark PW19/A. She further denied that the deceased had
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
told her that Respondent refused to give her money for expenses or that she
was getting money for her monthly mobile bills and her expenses from her
mother. She further denied that the deceased was hold her that she was not
allowed to meet her mother or sister, by the Respondent.
80.
The testimony of PW19 also does not prove that the deceased was
being harassed, abused or tortured or any money demands were being made
by her.
81.
The comprehensive reading of the evidence of all the Prosecution
witnesses reveals that the Prosecution has miserably failed to prove that
there was any cruelty committed on the deceased, which could have driver
her to kill herself or was harassed, as contemplated under Section 498A IPC.
Inadmissibility of the SMSs retrieved by PW5:
82.
The Prosecution heavily relied upon SMS messages allegedly
exchanged between Sharmistha Kaushik and her mother, as well as
messages between Sharmistha and the Respondent/accused, to establish a
pattern of cruelty and harassment. These messages were retrieved and
translated by PW5/Rajeev Lochan Sharma on 04.02.2011, Ex.PW5/A,
Ex.PW5/B, Ex.PW5/C, and Mark PW5/A1. However, the entire foundation
of this electronic evidence crumbles, upon scrutiny of its legal admissibility.
83.
PW5/Rajeev Lochan Sharma deposed that the SMS from the mobile
of Sharmistha were retrieved by the police and reduced in physical form,
which also bears his signature. He stated that he had translated some of the
SMSs from Assamese to English.
84.
At the outset, it is pertinent to refer to Anvar P.V. vs. P.K. Basheer,
(2014) 10 SCC 473, wherein the Apex Court had clarified that electronic
records cannot be proved through oral testimony alone and must be
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
accompanied by a Certificate meeting the stringent requirements of Section
65B(4) of the Evidence Act. This Certificate must identify the electronic
record, describe the manner of its production, furnish particulars of the
device used, confirm compliance with conditions under Section 65B(2), and
bear the signature of a person occupying a responsible official position in
relation to the operation of the relevant device.
85.
In the present case, none of these requirements were satisfied. PW5,
who retrieved the SMS data, was admittedly not a Forensic expert. No
Certificate under Section 65B Evidence Act was produced at any stage. The
mobile handset, from which the messages were allegedly retrieved, was
released to the PW4/Complainant on 08.03.2011, a mere month after
seizure, thereby destroying any chain of custody and eliminating any
possibility of authenticating the contents, thereafter.
86.
Moreover, PW21, the IO himself acknowledged that he knew the
Data should have been sent to forensic expert, for analysis qua the
authenticity of the contents of the deceased‟s phone, but inexplicably failed
to do so. He deposed that he had no knowledge of the Assamese language.
He did not take any assistance of any expert in the Assamese language, for
the purpose of verification and correctness of the reproduced/translated
messages, Ex.PW5/A, PW5/B and PW-5/C. He further stated since the
mother of the deceased was well-educated, he reproduced the messages
pursuant to translation/dictation given by her. He admitted that the mobile
phone of the deceased was not produced, at the first juncture before him. It
was produced and seized by the other SI and later on he had examined the
mobile phone regarding its contents.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
87.
This conduct of PW21, IO
was not merely a procedural oversight,
but a fundamental abdication of investigative duty that renders the entire
corpus of SMS evidence legally flawed and thus, inadmissible to assist the
Prosecution case.
Inadmissibility of the Statement of Accounts:
88.
Another
aspect
for
the
Prosecution‟s
case
is
that
the
Respondent/accused made unlawful demands for money, claiming that the
Complainant provided Rs.1,40,000/- to her daughter Sharmistha for
furniture following demands from the accused and his family.
89.
The Bank Account Statements of Sharmistha Kaushik, were produced
by PW12/Sh. Johnson, Asstt. at SBI, Ex.PW12/A
and Mark 10/C, the
Complainant‟s account statement. PW12 deposed that the statement of
accounts with respect to the deceased had been printed by using the system
of the printer of the Branch. Admittedly, the Statement of Account of the
deceased, Ex.PW12/A was certified merely by PW12, but does not bear the
stamp of the bank on any page. Moreover, the period and date was also not
mentioned.
90.
The Statement of Accounts, produced by PW12, are the computer-
generated electronic records, that were not proved in accordance with the
mandatory requirements of Section 65B of the Evidence Act. The statement
though produced through the SBI official, lacked any proper certificate
under Section 65B. The Certificate notation written by PW2, stating it was
“brought from SBI printer”, is not as per the requirement under law.
91.
Moreover, even if these Bank Statements may be read, they
affirmatively failed to support the Prosecution‟s claims. The statement
Ex.PW12/A does not show any transfer of Rs.1,40,000/- from the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
Complainant to Sharmistha‟s Account, after the alleged demand for
furniture in October, 2010.
Defence evidence:
92.
The accused‟s own Bank Statement, Ex.DW1/2, while also
technically deficient under Section 65B, was never effectively contradicted
by the Prosecution and suggested that payments for the Flat came from the
accused‟s own funds.
93.
DW3/Rajdeep Saxena, Deputy General Manager of M/s Ajnara India
Pvt. Ltd., deposed that one flat was purchased in October 2010, booked
jointly in the names of both Sharmistha Kaushik (deceased) and Ritu Raj
Thakur (accused), with both signing as allottees.
94.
This arrangement is fundamentally inconsistent with the Prosecution‟s
theory of dowry demand. If the accused were engaged in harassment and
demands for money to purchase property, it defies common logic that he
would ensure his wife‟s name appeared as joint owner with equal rights.
95.
The learned ASJ has rightly held that the offence under Section
498A IPC was not proved against the Respondent.
Allegations under Section 306 IPC:
96.
The second Charge against the Respondent is under Section 306 IPC
for having abetted the deceased to commit suicide.
97.
Section 306 IPC requires proof of abetment as defined in Section 107
IPC, which means the accused must have either:
(i)
instigated the suicide,
(ii)
conspired to cause it, or
(iii)
intentionally aided it.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
98.
The term “instigate” means to actively provoke, incite, or urge
someone toward the act. Crucially, mere cruelty is insufficient, there must
be proof of mens rea (guilty intention) and a direct connection between the
accused‟s conduct and the suicide.
99.
The offence under Section 306 IPC deals with abetment of suicide. It
provides that if any person abates the commission of suicide, he shall be
punished with the imprisonment as provided therein. Therefore, the most
essential ingredient required to be established for bringing home the offence
under Section 306 IPC, is abetment.
100. The term „abetment‟ is defined under Section 107 IPC, according to
which, a person would abate if he instigates, encourages or enters into a
conspiracy for doing a thing or if he intentionally aids by any act or illegal
omission for doing that thing.
101. Section 114 IPC is an explanation or clarification to Section 107 IPC.
It provides that whenever any person is absent but was present when the
offence in consequence of abatement is committed, he shall be deemed to
have committed such an act or offence and would be liable for punishment
as an abetter.
102. The Apex Court in Ramesh Kumar vs. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9
SCC 618, held that the term „instigate‟ means to goad, urge, provoke, incite
or encourage to do „an act‟. For instigation, it is not required that the actual
words must be used to that effect or the words should be specifically
suggestive of the consequences. To satisfy the requirement of the
„instigation‟ it is important that the act/omission or by the continued course
of conduct, a situation is created, where the deceased is left with no other
option except to commit the suicide. A word uttered in a fit of anger or
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow cannot be
said to be „instigation‟.
103. In Chitresh Kumar Chopra vs. State (NCT of Delhi), (2009) 16 SCC
605, relying upon Ramesh Kumar (supra), the Apex Court has held as under:
In other words, in order to prove that the accused abetted commission of
suicide by a person, it has to be established that:
(i) the accused kept on irritating or annoying the deceased by
words, deeds or wilful omission or conduct which may even be a
wilful silence until the deceased reacted or pushed or forced the
deceased by his deeds, words or wilful omission or conduct to
make the deceased move forward more quickly in a forward
direction; and
(ii) that the accused had the intention to provoke, urge or
encourage the deceased to commit suicide while acting in the
manner noted above. Undoubtedly, presence of mens rea is the
necessary concomitant of instigation.
104. In Amalendu Pal vs. State of W.B., (2010) 1 SCC 707, the Apex Court
has observed that for an offence under Section 306 IPC, it is also to be
borne in mind that in cases of alleged abetment of suicide there must be
proof of direct or indirect acts of incitement to the commission of suicide.
Merely on the allegation of harassment without there being any positive
action proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused which
led or compelled the person to commit suicide, conviction in terms of
Section 306 IPC is not sustainable.
105. Similarly in Rajesh vs. State of Haryana, (2020) 15 SCC 359, the
Apex
Court
has
refused
to
convict
an
accused
under
Section 306 and 107 IPC on the allegation of harassment without there
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
being any positive action proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of
the accused which led or compelled the person to commit the suicide.
106. In the light of the aforesaid judgments, it is abundantly clear that to
constitute abetment, there has to be instigation, encouragement or aid in
committing of an act, which leads to commission of suicide.
107. In the present case, the Prosecution presented only general, vague
allegations that the accused drank heavily, beat his wife, told her to take
pills, and suspected her character. However, not one specific instance was
proved with dates, details, or corroboration. No incident of December 2010
or January, 2011 (the crucial period before death) was established. These
remain bald allegations without substance, insufficient to prove deliberate
instigation.
108. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the accused intended or desired
Sharmistha to commit suicide. As held in Mahendra Singh vs. State of M.P.,
AIR 1998 SC 601, harsh words spoken in anger during marital disputes do
not constitute mens rea for abetment. Without proof of wilful conduct
designed to drive her to suicide, Section 306 cannot be sustained.
109. The chronology of events destroys the theory of proximate causation.
The accused was in Assam from 22-30.01.2011, during which the deceased
stayed with her friend DW2/Mompy Sharma. The accused returned on
30.01.2011, and they celebrated the birthday of the deceased with dinner
that evening. The suicide occurred on 01.02.2011.
110. Significantly, the preliminary suicide note Q-1 (“The worst part
about this b‟day - a day after it... I can‟t live anymore”) was written a day
prior to the suicide, suggesting she had already decided to die, while the
accused was absent or immediately after the birthday celebration. As rightly
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
noted by the learned ASJ, there is a time gap between the suicide note and
the previous note, which appears to have been written when the accused was
in Assam.
111. In Sanju vs. State, AIR 2002 SC 1998, it was held that when suicide
occurs days after alleged incidents with intervening events, proximate
connection fails. The week-long physical separation and the intervening
event (birthday dinner) breaks any chain of causation between alleged prior
conduct and the suicide.
112. DW2/Mompy Sharma also stated that during the aforesaid period
when the deceased stayed at her house, the deceased seemed to her a bit lost
and depressed, which was noticed by her on 22.01.2011 itself. Upon her
persistent asking, the deceased disclosed about her past affair with Jinender
Bhandare and expressed unhappiness about her marriage choice. The
deceased had also told DW2 that all her family members were aware of this
fact and had purposely asked her not to disclose the same to the accused.
Furthermore, the deceased felt like she was living a dual life as she loved
somebody else and got married to somebody else and was feeling guilty
about it.
113. The suicide note Q-2, confirmed to be in Sharmistha‟s handwriting,
states, “No one is to be blamed for my death ... I am in great depression. ...
No one - not a single person is to be blamed for my this action. ...” She
apologized to her husband, mother, and sister for not meeting their
expectations.
114. In Gurucharan Kumar vs. State of Rajasthan, (2003) 2 SCC 698, the
Supreme Court held that when a suicide note explicitly exonerates everyone
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
and attributes the act to the deceased‟s own will, it becomes nearly
impossible to prove abetment unless other evidence is overwhelming.
115. Furthermore, the Prosecution‟s reliance on note Q-1 (“he does not
like when I am a human”) fails, because it names no one. The pronoun “he”
could refer to Jitender Bhandare (her past relationship with a married man,
as disclosed to DW2/Mompy Sharma) or someone else, which is unclear.
Such an ambiguity, cannot override the clarity of the final note.
116. Both sides agreed Sharmistha suffered depression they differed only
on the cause. Section 113A Evidence Act permits (not mandates) a
presumption of abetment when: (i) suicide occurs within seven years of
marriage, and (ii) cruelty is proved.
In the present case, while death
occurred within one year of the marriage, cruelty itself was not proved
beyond reasonable. Even if cruelty were assumed, the court must consider
“all other circumstances”, which here includes the suicide note, the timeline
showing premeditation during the accused‟s absence, and alternative causes
for depression of the deceased. These circumstances compel the court to
refrain from drawing any presumption.
117. To sum up, the Prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable
doubt: (1) any specific act of instigation, (2) mens rea or intent to cause
suicide, (3) proximate causation between alleged conduct and death, or (4)
conduct going beyond ordinary marital discord.
118. Thus, the accused has been rightly acquitted under Section 306 IPC.
Conclusion:
119. In light of the above observations, the impugned Order dated
10.02.2017 acquitting the Respondent under Section 498A/306 IPC, is
upheld.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
120. There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is accordingly
dismissed.
121. Pending Applications(s), if any, are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEB RUARY 05, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:38:54
CRL.A.1563/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review