Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 24th November, 2025
Pronounced on: 09th February, 2026
%
CRL.A. 1640/2025
+
STATE
Govt of NCT of Delhi
Through Standing Counsel (Crl.),
Delhi Police, Delhi.
....Appellant
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State with
Inspector Proshun, ATP/PS Ananad
Vihar Railway Station.
versus
AMIT KUMAR
S/o Sh. Inder Pal,
R/o Village Jalalabad,
District Ghaziabad, UP
Through:
....Respondent
Mr. Biswajit Kumar Patra, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The Appeal under Section 378(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.PC’), has been filed on behalf of the
Appellant/State against the Judgment dated 04.10.2016 whereby the
Respondent, Amit Kumar has been acquitted by the learned ASJ, Delhi, for
the offence under Section 394/397/411/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’) in FIR No. 08/2014 dated 01.02.2014,
Police Station Anand Vihar Railway Station.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
2.
The brief facts are that on 31.01.2014 at about 08:00 p.m., the
Complainant, Mr. Tej Singh Bhati Singh was going to old Railway Station
Anand Vihar from the side of Platform No. 1, when three boys confronted
him enroute and tried to snatch his bag. A physical altercation took place
between them and the Complainant was pushed to the ground and beaten
with a stone, resulting in the injuries on his nose, hand and head. The
assailants took away his Samsung Mobile Phone, as well as the purse
containing several cards, documents and Rs.9,000/- in cash.
3.
The Complainant went to GRP from where he was taken to LBS
Hospital in Ambulance and thereafter, shifted to Max Hospital, Patparganj,
Delhi. He was treated in the hospital till 03.02.2014.
4.
The Statement of the Complainant was recorded on 01.02.2014, on
the basis of which, FIR No. 08/2014 under Sections 394/34 IPC, was
registered.
The
Investigating
Officer/SI
Joy
Kumar,
during
the
investigations, collected the MLC wherein the injuries suffered by the
Complainant, were certified as grievous in nature.
5.
The IO made the analysis of CDR of the Mobile Number and IMEI
number of stolen mobile and traced it to the Accused, Amit Kumar. He was
arrested on the basis of secret information and was found to be in possession
of robbed Mobile, without any SIM Card. The TIP proceedings were
conducted in which he was identified by the Complainant. The ChargeSheet under Section 394/411/34 IPC thereafter was filed in the Court on
19.05.2014.
6.
On 01.07.2014, Charges under Section 394/411 IPC were framed
against the Respondent, to which he pleaded not guilty.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
7.
On 31.07.2014, a Supplementary Charge-Sheet under Section 397
IPC was filed by the Investigating Officer. The Charges under Section
397/411 IPC were framed against the Respondent on 02.01.2015, to which
he pleaded not guilty.
8.
The Prosecution in support of its case, examined 13 Prosecution
witnesses.
9.
PW-2 is the Complainant, who proved his Complaint, Ex.PW-2/A.
10.
PW-3, Head Constable Devender Singh registered the FIR, Ex.PW-
3/B.
11.
PW-13, ASI Surender Singh, the Investigating Officer, who was
accompanied by PW-4, Head Constable Maharaj Singh to the hospital
from where the MLC of the injured, was collected.
12.
The medical record of the injured were proved by PW-1, Dr.
Virender Kumar and PW-5, Dr. Harjinder Singh Bhatoe, who had
examined the Complainant in the Emergency in the Max Hospital. The
summary of treatment is Ex.PW-5/A and the copy of Discharge Summary is
Ex.PW-5/B.
13.
PW-8, Pawan Singh Nodal Officer, Idea Cellular, proved the cell ID
Chart of Mobile No. 9540721499, which had been obtained on the I-card of
Smt. Sushma as Ex.PW-8/D.
14.
PW-9, the learned Metropolitan Magistrate proved the TIP
proceedings of the Respondent as Ex.PW-9/A and Ex.PW-9/B.
15.
PW-13, ASI Surender Singh, the first IO, conducted the initial
investigations and got the FIR registered.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
16.
PW-12, Retired SI, Joy Kutty was the second Investigating Officer,
who was joined by PW-6, Constable Nitin in conducting the further
investigations. He filed the Charge-Sheets against the Respondent.
17.
PW-11, Harsh Bhargava, brought copy of Statement of Account of
the Complainant, Ex.PW-11/B.
18.
PW-7, Smt. Anuradha Malik, In-charge/Head of Primary School,
gave a certificate regarding DOB of the Respondent, Ex.PW-7/A.
19.
The Statement under Section 313 CrPC of the Accused, was recorded
wherein he denied the entire evidence. He admitted that SIM
No.9540721499, obtained in the name of his mother, was being used in the
Samsung Mobile Phone. He stated that he had purchased the said Mobile for
Rs.1,000/- from one passenger, who did not have the money to pay the auto
fare. At that time, he was working as a conductor in a shared auto plying
between Anand Vihar Bus Stand and Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad. He used his
SIM card on that Mobile Phone for about 30-40 days and thereafter, sold
this Mobile Phone to one Dhoban because his vehicle had met with an
accident.
20.
The Respondent denied knowing any Kamal Khan, but admitted that
he was arrested from Anand Vihar Railway Station. He denied the recovery
of Samsung Mobile Phone from his possession at the time of his arrest.
During his interrogation, he informed the Police about selling of this Mobile
Phone to one Dhoban, who met them and Police brought Dhoban along with
the Mobile Phone to the Police Station. While dhoban left, he was
implicated falsely in this case. He admitted that the TIP was conducted in
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
Tihar Jail but was not aware of his identification in the TIP proceedings, by
the Complainant.
21.
The learned ASJ, on appreciation of evidence, found that before the
TIP of the Respondent was conducted, he was taken on Police Custody
remand for two days. Though, the Respondent admitted that he was kept in a
muffled face on the day of arrest, but he was produced before the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate on 23.03.2014 when the Police remand was granted
for three days. There was no mention of his face being muffled, in the
remand papers.
22.
Furthermore, from the testimony of PW-6 and PW-12, it emerged that
though allegedly a phone was recovered from the Respondent on 22.03.2014
when he was apprehended, but it was produced in the Court in a stapled
envelope, thereby establishing that the phone had not been kept in a sealed
cover. Moreover, this Mobile Phone was never identified by the
Complainant; rather the Complainant in its testimony had deposed that he
had visited the Police Station on 29.03.2014, where he identified his Mobile
Phone. He was unable to tell the exact date of his visit to the Police Station,
for such identification. The Mobile Phone was recovered on 22.03.2014 i.e.
a week prior to the TIP of the Accused. PW-2 could have identified his
Mobile Phone on any date between 22.03.2014 to 29.03.2014 but it was not
so done. Furthermore, there was no evidence to show that there was
sufficient light at the time of commission of offence, for the Complainant to
have identified the Respondent. Therefore, benefit of doubt was given to
the Respondent, who was acquitted of all the offences.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
23.
The State aggrieved by the acquittal, has filed the present Appeal
wherein the Judgment of acquittal has been challenged on the grounds that
the evidence especially of the Complainant, PW-2, has not been considered
in the right perspective.
24.
The Respondent himself had admitted in his Statement under Section
313 CrPC that his face was duly covered, which fact has been overlooked by
the learned ASJ. The Complainant had correctly identified the Respondent
in the TIP proceedings. It has been erroneously presumed that there was no
source of light at the time of commission of offence, for the Complainant to
have identified the Respondent. It has also been wrongly presumed that no
robber would use the robbed mobile phone himself. It all clearly reflects that
the conclusions are conjectural and based on presumptions. The entire case
of the Prosecution stood established by the testimony of the witnesses
examined by the Prosecution.
25.
Hence, a prayer was made that the Impugned Judgment be set-aside.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
26.
The case of the Prosecution is that on 31.01.2014 at about 08:00 p.m.,
the Complainant, Mr. Tej Singh Bhati was robbed by the Respondent, Amit
Kumar along with two other persons, and was given severe beatings. On his
Statement, the FIR Ex.PW-3/B was registered. On completion of
investigations, the Charge-Sheet under Section 394/411/34 IPC, was filed.
A Supplementary Charge-Sheet for the offence under Section 397/411 IPC
was filed.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
27.
The Charges were framed under Section 394/411 and under 397 IPC
on 01.07.2014 and 31.07.2014, respectively, to which the Respondent
pleaded not guilty.
28.
The first main aspect for consideration is about the manner of the
recovery of stolen Mobile phone of the complainant. According to the
Complainant, his purse and mobile were stolen and he was beaten by the
assailants. He suffered serious injuries, and was taken to the hospital, while
the assailants escaped.
29.
According to PW-13, ASI Surender Singh, IO, he made an
Application dated 07.02.2014 to DCP Railway for obtaining the CDR and
CAF of Mobile No.8826992658 vide Application, Ex.PW-13/C. Pertinently,
though this CDR and CAF was the main starting point for the tracing of the
Respondent, but the same has neither been summoned nor proved on record.
30.
On analysis of the CDR and CAF, he found that the Mobile phone
was used with the SIM No.9540721499, which was admittedly of the mother
of the Respondent/Accused.
31.
The investigations in between, were taken over by PW-12, Retd. SI
Joy Kutty, who was joined in the investigations by PW-6, Constable Nitin.
PW-12 deposed that from the analysis of the call details of Mobile No.
9540721499, Ex.PW-8/A, several calls were made by him to the phone
numbers, to which the call had been made from this number. On 22.03.2014,
he along with the PW-6, Constable Nitin, had gone to the parking of Anand
Vihar Railway Station, where he made a phone call to a person, who
disclosed his name as Kamal Khan. He called him to the taxi stand and on
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
enquiry, he told that this number was being used by one Amit Kumar (the
accused/Respondent).
32.
Here, it is pertinent to note that PW-6, Constable Nitin, who had
joined investigations with PW-12, Retd. SI Joy Kutty, had given the name
of the person, to whom the call was made and who was called, as Qamrool.
There is discrepancy about the person, to whom the call was made by the
Investigating Officer and who came to the Railway Station.
33.
Pertinently, according to both, PW-12, SI Joy Kutty and PW-6,
Constable Nitin, such person disclosed that the Mobile was being used by
one Amit Kumar, resident of Ghaziabad and that he used to run a TSR.
Thereafter, they went to the main gate of Railway Station and started
checking the TSRs at the entry of Railway Station. Interestingly, they met
one secret informer who pointed out to a person, who was apprehend and his
name was found to be Amit Kumar i.e. the Respondent. A search was made
from him and one White Colour Samsung Mobile was recovered from his
right pocket. Interestingly, they both deposed that the Mobile Phone was
without the SIM card.
34.
In this context, it is significant to refer to the defence of the Appellant,
who claimed that he had sold this Mobile Phone to one Dhoban and the
Police had called this Dhoban to the Police Station, who handed over the
Mobile Phone. It was claimed by him that the recovery of Mobile Phone, has
been planted by him.
35.
This defence seems plausible because according to PW-13, ASI
Surender Singh, as well as, PW-12, SI Joy Kutty, the tracing of the Mobile
Phone was done through the CDR and CAF records of the Mobile Phone
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
through the SIM Card No. 9540721499. Had the Respondent been using this
Mobile Phone, then there is no reason why the SIM Card would not have
been found in the Mobile Phone. The very fact that the SIM Card was
missing from the Mobile Phone when it was recovered from the Respondent
clearly, lends credence to the explanation given by the Respondent about the
Phone having been sold by him to Dhoban, who was called to the Police
Station and he handed over the Mobile Phone, seems plausible.
36.
The Respondent had admitted that he had purchased this Mobile
Phone for Rs.1,000/- from one passenger, who could not pay the Auto fare
and after using it for about 30-35 days, he had sold it to another person,
namely Dhoban. The defence taken by the Respondent/Accused, therefore, is
plausible from the manner of recovery of Mobile Phone and also it having
been recovered without a SIM Card.
37.
The next aspect, which needs discussion, is about the identity of
the Appellant.
38.
According to PW-12, Joy Kutty after being arrested on 22.03.2014,
his Police remand was taken for two days. He was then produced in the
Court on 25.03.2014. The Investigating Officer had deposed that he was
produced in muffled face before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate.
However, it has been observed by the learned Trial Court in the impugned
Judgment,
that
the
remand
papers
did
not
reflect
that
the
Appellant/Respondent had been produced in muffled face.
39.
The next significant aspect is that the complainant, PW-2 had
deposed that after the recovery of Mobile Phone was made, he was called
to the Police Station where he identified his Mobile Phone. It has been noted
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
by the learned ASJ that while this Complainant remembered all the dates of
incident and of TIP, he interestingly did not remember the date on which he
went to the Police Station, for identifying his Mobile Phone.
40.
The possibility of the Complainant having gone to the Police Station
while the Accused was in the custody of the Police, therefore, cannot be
ruled out. This aspect assumes significance as the incident took place on
31.01.2014, but the TIP was conducted on 29.03.2014, when he identified
the Respondent. The chances of him having been shown to the Complainant,
cannot be over-looked.
41.
It is difficult to believe that the Complainant, who got traumatized by
the incident of robbery, would have such clear photographic memory to
have been able to identify the Respondent on 29.03.2014 i.e. after almost
two months. No specific features of identification have been disclosed by
the Complainant. In the Complaint as well, there was no description given of
the assailants. The identification of the Respondent in the TIP proceedings,
is thus, not beyond reasonable doubt.
42.
In the end, it may be observed that though, it was an undisputed fact
that the Mobile Phone had come into the possession of the Respondent at
some point of time which, he had used for about 30-45 days on a SIM Card,
obtained in the name of his mother, but such circumstances by itself, are
insufficient to conclusively establish either his involvement in the
commission of the robbery or his conscious possession of stolen property
with knowledge of its illicit origin.
43.
The recovery of the mobile phone without a SIM card, the lack of
unimpeachable evidence regarding its seizure, the gaps in the chain of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
custody, the doubtful circumstances surrounding the identification of the
Respondent - all collectively create serious infirmities in case of the
Prosecution.
44.
Thus, the benefit of doubt, has been rightly extended to the
Respondent by the learned ASJ while acquitting him under Section
394/397/411/34 IPC.
45.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
The pending Applications are disposed of, accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 09, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
Crl.A. 1640/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review