Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Dated: 12/02/2026
Coram:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.VELMURUGAN
and
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.JOTHIRAMAN
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
State represented by
The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras - 104.
(Thiruvannamalai East P.S.,)
(Crime No.691 of 2011
...
Appellant
...
Respondents
Vs.
1.A.Ravi
2.K.Devadoss
3.M.Ammurose
4.K.Ranjan
5.A.Venkatesan
6. K.Manjunathan
7.K.Karunanithi
8.V.Suryaprakash
9.P.Raja
Prayer: Criminal Appeal is filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C. to call for
records and set aside the judgment dated 21.12.2017 made in S.C.No.111 of
2014 by the learned District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvannamalai and convict
the respondents / accused 1 to 9.
1/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
For Appellant
: Mr.A.Damodaran
Additional Public Prosecutor
For Respondents : Mr.R.Sankarasubbu
For Mr.P.Pugalenthi
*****
JUDGMENT
P.VELMURUGAN, J.
This Criminal Appeal has been preferred by the State challenging the
judgment of acquittal dated 21.12.2017 passed in S.C.No.111 of 2014 by the
learned District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvannamalai, whereby the
respondents/accused (A1 to A9) were acquitted of the charges under
Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 read with 149 IPC.
2. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows:
2.1. Due to previous enmity between the parties, on 14.01.2011, the
defacto complainant Vathukaran @ Elumalai (P.W.1) was attacked and
sustained injuries at the hands of certain persons belonging to Adaiyur
Village. In connection with the said incident, cases and counter cases were
registered between both groups, which further worsened the dispute between
them.
2/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
2.2. In the above background, on 23.04.2011, Ramesh, son of P.W.1,
demanded repayment of a sum of Rs.3,000/- due from Lokesh, a resident of
Adi Annamalai Refugee Camp. As the amount was not repaid, Ramesh took
a two-wheeler bearing Registration No.TN-03-SE-509, which had earlier
been given to Karthikeyan, son of Ravi, first accused. On coming to know of
the same, the accused developed further enmity against Ramesh. On
24.04.2011 at about 10.00 a.m., A1 to A3 came to the house of P.W.1 and
criminally intimidated him and his son Ramesh with dire consequences.
2.3. On 25.04.2011 at about 5.30 p.m., when P.W.1 and his son
Ramesh went to a digital banner shop situated at Tiruvannamalai Nagar, all
the accused, due to previous enmity and with the common intention of
murdering Ramesh, formed themselves into an unlawful assembly armed
with deadly weapons such as aruvals, knives and swords. On seeing the
accused, P.W.1 and Ramesh attempted to escape. However, the accused
chased and attacked Ramesh indiscriminately with deadly weapons. Due to
the said assault, Ramesh sustained grievous injuries. Ramesh was
immediately taken to the Government Hospital, Tiruvannamalai, where he
was declared brought dead.
3/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
2.4. Based on the complaint lodged by the father of the
deceased / P.W.1, a case was registered in Crime No.691 of 2011 for the
offences under Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 IPC against A1 to A9. After
completion of investigation, the police altered the provisions of law into
Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 read with 149 IPC and filed a final report
before the learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, Tiruvannamalai. The learned
Magistrate, after complying with Section 207 Cr.P.C., committed the case to
the Court of Session, as the offences were exclusively triable by that Court.
The case was thereafter taken on file by the learned District and Sessions
Judge as S.C.No.111 of 2014.
2.5. During the course of trial, on the side of the prosecution, 20
witnesses were examined as P.W.1 to P.W.20, 42 documents were marked as
Exs.P1 to P42 and 16 material objects were produced as M.O.1 to M.O.16.
2.6. After completion of the examination of the prosecution witnesses,
the incriminating circumstances appearing in evidence were put to the
4/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
accused under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C., which they denied as false. No oral
or documentary evidence was adduced on the side of the defence.
2.7. Upon full-fledged trial and on appreciation of the entire oral and
documentary evidence, the learned District and Sessions Judge, by judgment
dated 21.12.2017, acquitted all the accused holding that the prosecution
failed to prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt.
3. Aggrieved by the said judgment of acquittal, the State has preferred
the present Criminal Appeal.
4. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would submit that the
judgment of the trial Court acquitting the respondents/accused (A1 to A9) of
the offences under Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 read with 149 IPC is
against law, the weight of evidence and the overall probabilities of the case.
According to him, the trial Court has not properly appreciated the evidence
available on record and has erroneously acquitted all the accused, resulting
in miscarriage of justice. He would further submit that the trial Court failed
5/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
to take note of the sufficient and reliable evidence available on record to
establish the offences under Sections 147 and 148 IPC. The materials placed
by the prosecution clearly prove that all the accused formed themselves into
an unlawful assembly, armed with deadly weapons, and acted in furtherance
of their common object. The trial Court also failed to properly appreciate
that all the accused shared a common object and that the prosecution has
proved the same through consistent and cogent evidence, thereby attracting
Section 149 IPC.
5. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would further contend
that there is clear evidence to show that the deceased was wrongfully
restrained by the accused prior to the occurrence and, therefore, the offence
under Section 341 IPC has also been established by the prosecution.
However, the trial Court failed to consider the same in the proper
perspective. It is his further submission that the prosecution has proved its
case beyond reasonable doubt through sufficient oral evidence, documentary
evidence, medical evidence and scientific evidence. The trial Court failed to
cumulatively assess these materials and instead adopted a hyper-technical
approach in discarding the prosecution case. He would also submit that
6/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
merely because a few witnesses turned hostile, the entire prosecution case
cannot be rejected. It is a settled principle that the reliable portion of the
evidence of hostile witnesses can be relied upon. The trial Court failed to
apply this settled principle while appreciating the evidence on record.
6. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would draw the attention
of this Court to the evidence of P.W.1, who has clearly spoken about the
participation of each of the accused, the deadly weapons used by them, the
formation of unlawful assembly, the wrongful restraint of the deceased and
the overt acts committed by each accused which resulted in the death of the
deceased Ramesh. The trial Court failed to properly appreciate the said
evidence. He would further submit that the trial Court failed to consider the
Post-Mortem Report, Chemical Analysis Report and Serology Report in
their proper perspective. A proper appreciation of the said medical and
scientific evidence would clearly establish the prosecution case. The failure
to do so has resulted in serious miscarriage of justice. It is also contended
that the trial Court failed to consider the admissible portions of the
confessional statements of A6 Manjunathan, A7 Karunanithi, A8
Suryaprakash and A9 Raja @ Raman and the recovery of incriminating
7/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
articles pursuant thereto, which clearly connect all the accused with the
commission of the offence and establish their liability under Section 149
IPC. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would further submit that the
evidence of P.W.1 clearly reveals that all the nine accused participated in the
commission of the murder of the deceased Ramesh and, therefore, all the
accused ought to have been convicted and punished by invoking Section 149
IPC. The trial Court erred in acquitting all the accused, including A6 to A9,
despite there being sufficient evidence against them. He would also submit
that the trial Court failed to consider the settled legal position that refreshing
the memory of witnesses is permissible under the provisions of the Evidence
Act and has wrongly disbelieved certain witnesses on untenable grounds.
Further, the evidence of P.W.1, P.W.16 and other material witnesses has not
been properly appreciated, which has resulted in miscarriage of justice.
Hence, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor contends that the judgment
of the trial Court is bad in law, perverse and liable to be set aside, and
therefore prays that the appeal be allowed.
7.
Per
contra,
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents/accused submitted that the judgment of the trial Court acquitting
the accused is sound, well reasoned and based on a proper appreciation of
8/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
the entire evidence on record. According to him, the trial Court has analysed
both the oral and documentary evidence in detail and rightly came to the
conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond
reasonable doubt. Hence, the judgment of acquittal does not call for any
interference by this Court. He would further submit that the evidence of the
prosecution
witnesses
suffers
from
material
contradictions
and
inconsistencies. Several important witnesses have not supported the
prosecution case and have turned hostile. In such circumstances, the trial
Court was justified in viewing the prosecution case with caution. The
evidence of the alleged eye-witnesses is not wholly reliable and lacks
sufficient corroboration from independent sources. Therefore, the trial Court
rightly extended the benefit of doubt to the accused. The learned counsel
also contended that the prosecution has failed to establish the essential
ingredients required to constitute the offences under Sections 147, 148, 341
and 302 read with 149 IPC. The prosecution has not satisfactorily proved the
formation of an unlawful assembly, the existence of a common object or the
specific overt acts attributed to each of the accused. In the absence of clear
and convincing evidence, the trial Court rightly held that the charges were
not proved.
9/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
8. The learned counsel would further submit that the alleged
recoveries and confessional statements do not inspire confidence and have
not been proved in the manner known to law. The medical and scientific
evidence also do not conclusively support the prosecution version. The trial
Court, after considering all these aspects, rightly held that the prosecution
failed to establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. It is his
final submission that the view taken by the trial Court is a reasonable and
possible view based on the evidence available on record. In an appeal
against acquittal, unless the findings of the trial Court are perverse or wholly
unsustainable, the appellate Court ought not to interfere. Since no such
ground is made out in the present case, he prayed that the appeal be
dismissed.
9. Heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the materials
available on record.
10/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
10. The specific case of the prosecution is that due to previous enmity
between the parties, an earlier occurrence had taken place in which P.W.1 /
the defacto complainant / father of the deceased Ramesh, was attacked by
the accused party and sustained injuries. In connection with the said
occurrence, cases and counter cases were registered between both groups
and the enmity between them continued. As a consequence of the said cases,
both groups were required to sign periodically before the police station as
part of the bail conditions. In the said background, a further dispute arose
between the parties relating to repayment of a sum of Rs.3,000/-. As the
amount was not repaid, the deceased Ramesh took a two-wheeler which had
earlier been given to one of the persons connected with the accused. On
coming to know of the same, the accused developed further enmity against
the deceased and his family and subsequently criminally intimidated P.W.1
and his son with dire consequences. According to the prosecution, on the
date of occurrence, when P.W.1 and his son Ramesh had gone to the police
station and signed in compliance with the bail conditions and were
proceeding towards the town, all the accused, due to previous enmity and
with the common object of murdering the deceased Ramesh, formed
themselves into an unlawful assembly armed with deadly weapons such as
11/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
aruvals and knives. On seeing the accused, the deceased attempted to escape
from the spot. However, the accused chased him, wrongfully restrained him
and attacked him indiscriminately with deadly weapons, causing multiple
injuries all over his body.
11. In order to substantiate the charges, the prosecution examined 20
witnesses as P.W.1 to P.W.20, marked 42 documents as Exs.P1 to P42 and
produced 16 material objects. Based on the complaint lodged by P.W.1, a
case was registered in Crime No.691 of 2011 for the offences under Sections
147, 148, 341 and 302 IPC. After completion of investigation, final report
was filed for the offences under Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 read with
149 IPC and the case was committed to the Court of Sessions and taken on
file in S.C.No.111 of 2014.
12. The prosecution mainly relies upon the evidence of P.W.1, who is
the defacto complainant, father of the deceased and an eyewitness to the
occurrence. P.W.1 has deposed that he is residing at Aadaiyur village and
that the deceased Ramesh is his son. He has stated that he knows all the
12/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
accused and that there was previous enmity between both groups even prior
to the present occurrence. He has spoken about an earlier incident in which
his younger brother was assaulted near the Mariamman Temple at Aadaiyur,
and about the subsequent attack on him at his residence, during which he
sustained knife injuries to his stomach and thigh and was treated at the
Government Hospital, Puducherry. In connection with the said occurrence,
he lodged a complaint and the opposite party also lodged a complaint,
resulting in cases and counter cases. Both parties were thereafter required to
sign periodically before the police station as part of the bail conditions.
P.W.1 has further deposed that on the date of occurrence, he and his son
Ramesh went to the police station and signed in compliance with the bail
conditions and thereafter proceeded towards the town. When they were near
the bank situated next to the Corporation shop, A1 Ravi came there and on
seeing him, the deceased Ramesh started running out of fear. The accused
chased him and P.W.1 also followed them and witnessed the entire
occurrence.
13. P.W.1 has clearly spoken about the overt acts committed by each
of the accused. According to him, A2 Davadoss attacked the deceased with a
billhook and inflicted cut injuries on the left and right side of the neck. A1
13/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
Ravi attacked the deceased with a chopper and slashed him on the head. A9
Raja also attacked the deceased with a chopper and caused further cut
injuries on the head. A6 Manjunathan stabbed the deceased on the chest with
a knife. A3 Amburose stabbed the deceased on the right side of the chest
with a knife. A4 Ranjan stabbed the deceased on the thigh with a knife. A7
Karunanithi stabbed the deceased on the right thigh with a knife. A8
Suryaprakash stabbed the deceased on the stomach with a knife. As against
the fifth accused/Venkatesh, P.W.1 has clearly stated in the Ex.P1 complaint
that he participated in the attack and assaulted the deceased with a deadly
weapon.
14. According to P.W.1, all the accused formed themselves into an
unlawful assembly, armed with deadly weapons and attacked his son
indiscriminately. Due to the repeated attack by all the accused, the deceased
sustained multiple cut and stab injuries all over his body and fell down at the
place of occurrence. Immediately thereafter, an ambulance was called and
the injured Ramesh was taken to the Government Hospital, Tiruvannamalai,
where he was declared brought dead. P.W.1 then went to the Tiruvannamalai
Taluk Police Station and lodged a complaint regarding the occurrence and
the police registered a case and conducted investigation.
14/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
15. P.W.1 has also spoken about the motive for the occurrence by
stating that his son had given a sum of Rs.3,000/- to a Sri Lankan refugee
and, as the amount was not repaid, his son had taken a vehicle connected
with them, which led to further enmity and threats from the accused. The
evidence of P.W.1 is consistent with the complaint given by him
immediately after the occurrence, in which the names of the accused and the
overt acts attributed to each of them have been clearly mentioned. The crossexamination has not elicited any material to discredit his testimony. His
presence at the place of occurrence is natural and probable since he had
accompanied his son from the police station after signing in compliance with
the bail conditions. Merely because he is the father of the deceased, his
evidence cannot be discarded on that ground alone. His testimony is cogent,
consistent and trustworthy and inspires confidence. Thus, the evidence of
P.W.1 clearly establishes the motive for the occurrence, the formation of
unlawful assembly by the accused, their participation in the attack, the overt
acts committed by each of them and the resultant death of the deceased
Ramesh.
15/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
16. Though some of the witnesses, namely P.W.2 to P.W.10, have
turned hostile, and there was already a pending rivalry case between the
parties which may have influenced the witnesses not to support the
prosecution, the same is not fatal to the case. The fact that certain witnesses
have turned hostile does not affect the credibility of the prosecution’s case,
as the offence has been established through other consistent and cogent
evidence. It is well settled that the quality of evidence is more important
than its quantity. If the testimony of a single eyewitness is found to be
reliable and trustworthy, a conviction can be safely based upon such
evidence. Merely because certain witnesses have turned hostile, the entire
prosecution case cannot be rejected. The Court is always entitled to rely
upon the credible and reliable portion of the evidence on record.
17. P.W.11 has deposed regarding the occurrence, though he could not
state the specific weapons used. The incident occurred in 2011, while his
evidence was recorded only in 2017, after a considerable lapse of time.
Minor discrepancies or the inability to recollect minute details are bound to
occur due to the passage of time and cannot be treated as material
contradictions affecting the core of the prosecution case.
16/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
18. P.W.16, Dr. Kamalakannan, deposed that on receipt of requisition
from the Inspector of Police, Tiruvannamalai East Police Station, he
conducted the postmortem on the body of the deceased Ramesh, aged about
34 years, at the Government Hospital, Tiruvannamalai.
As per the
postmortem certificate (Ex.P27), he noted the following external injuries on
the body of the deceased:
1. A cut injury extending from right neck 2 cm below
right ear and 10 cm from midline to left side of neck 5 cm from
midline wound crossing the midline of neck, Trachea exposed
and cut.
2. Incised (punctured) wound on the right shoulder
measuring 3 cm × 2 cm × 3 cm.
3. Incised (punctured) wound on the right chest below the
right clavicle measuring 3 cm × 1 cm × 3 cm.
4. Incised wound on the right chest, 1 cm from midline,
measuring 3 cm × 2 cm × 3 cm.
5. Incised wound on the right abdomen, 2 cm from
midline, measuring 3 cm × 2 cm × 3 cm.
6. Incised wound on the right thigh measuring 3 cm × 2
cm × 3 cm.
7. Incised wound on the left abdomen measuring 3 cm ×
2 cm × 3 cm.
17/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
8. Lacerated wound on the right back measuring 6 cm × 2
cm.
9. Lacerated injury on scalp from right parietal region to
right occipital region measuring 5 cm × 2 cm.
10. Cut injury on the back of neck extending from below
right ear to left ear measuring 10 cm × 4 cm, bone depth.
On internal examination, he found fracture of the skull in the right parietal to
occipital region. The trachea was exposed and cut. The cervical structures
were exposed. The liver showed lacerated injuries, including one in the left
lobe measuring about 2 cm × 1 cm and multiple lacerations in the right lobe.
Other organs were pale. Viscera, including blood, stomach and its contents,
intestines, liver, kidneys and hyoid bone, were preserved and sent for
forensic and chemical examination. The forensic report revealed that no
poison was detected. The doctor opined that the deceased would appear to
have died about 12 to 18 hours prior to the postmortem due to haemorrhage
and shock as a result of the multiple injuries sustained by him. The
postmortem certificate issued by him was marked as Ex.P27. The medical
evidence thus clearly establishes that the deceased sustained multiple cut and
stab injuries on vital parts of the body, including the head, neck, chest,
abdomen, back and thighs, and that the death was due to shock and
18/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
haemorrhage resulting from those injuries. The nature, number and location
of the injuries, as spoken to by P.W.16, fully corroborate the evidence of the
eyewitness regarding the manner of attack and the use of deadly weapons by
the accused.
19. The defence has not seriously disputed the injuries sustained by
the deceased. Their principal contention is that the specific weapons were
not shown to the doctor and that the witnesses were unable to identify which
accused used which weapon. Having regard to the lapse of time between the
occurrence and the recording of evidence, such minor omissions cannot be a
ground to reject the otherwise reliable and cogent testimony of P.W.1.
20. Though some of the witnesses to the confession and recovery have
turned hostile, they have admitted their signatures. Even assuming that the
recovery has not been fully proved, the same is not fatal to the prosecution
case when there is clear and reliable eyewitness evidence duly supported by
medical evidence.
19/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
21. The next question that arises for consideration is whether the
respondents caused injury to the deceased. From the evidence of P.W.1, the
eyewitness and father of the deceased, along with Exhibit P1, it is clear that
the respondents actively attacked the deceased and caused the injuries from
which he died. P.W.1’s testimony is consistent and is fully supported by the
medical and forensic evidence. It shows that A1 to A9 came together as an
unlawful assembly, armed with deadly weapons, and jointly assaulted the
deceased. All the accused were present at the scene and participated in the
attack, which resulted in multiple injuries to vital parts of the body,
ultimately causing death. Considering the evidence as a whole, the
prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that all the accused are
guilty under Sections 147, 148, 341, and 302 read with Section 149 IPC. The
evidence of P.W.1, together with the medical reports, is reliable and
trustworthy.
22. The trial Court, however, failed to properly appreciate the
evidence of P.W.1 and the supporting medical evidence, and gave undue
importance to minor contradictions and the hostility of certain witnesses.
Such an approach is perverse and contrary to the evidence available on
20/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
record. The judgment of acquittal passed by the trial Court is therefore liable
to be set aside.
23. Accordingly, this Criminal Appeal is allowed and the judgment of
acquittal dated 21.12.2017 passed in S.C.No.111 of 2014 by the learned
District
and
Sessions
Judge,
Tiruvannamalai,
is
set
aside.
The
respondents/accused (A1 to A9) are found guilty and are hereby convicted
for the offences punishable under Sections 147, 148, 341 and 302 read with
Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code.
24. Since this is an appeal against acquittal resulting in reversal, this
Court, in the interest of justice, is inclined to hear the accused on the
question of sentence, taking into consideration the mitigating circumstances
involved in this case, before pronouncing the sentence. Accordingly, while
setting aside the judgment of the trial Court and convicting A1 to A9 /
respondents 1 to 9 for the offences charged, this Court directs the Registry to
post the appeal on 18.02.2026 for hearing the accused on the question of
sentence to be imposed on them.
21/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
25. Post the Criminal Appeal on 18.02.2026 under the caption “For
Question of Sentence”.
[P.V.J.,]
[M.J.R.J.,]
12 / 02 / 2026
Speaking Order
rns
22/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
Crl.A.No. 456 of 2019
P.VELMURUGAN, J.
AND
M.JOTHIRAMAN, J.
(Judgment of the Court was made by P.VELMURUGAN, J.)
This Court, by judgment dated 12.02.2026, found the respondents/
accused (A1 to A9) guilty of the offences punishable under Sections 147,
148, 341 and 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code and
convicted them accordingly. Since it is a reversal judgment and the accused
have to be heard on the question of sentence in respect of the mitigating
circumstances, the matter was directed to be listed on 18.02.2026 for hearing
on sentence.
2. Pursuant to the direction of this Court, today, respondents/A1 to A9
appeared before this Court.
3. Upon questioning, (i) the first respondent/A1 stated that he is in no
way connected with the case and that, on the date of occurrence, he was not
23/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
present at the place of occurrence, as he was working elsewhere, and that a
false case has been foisted against him; (ii) the second respondent/A2 stated
that he has not committed any offence and that a false case has been foisted
against him; (iii) the third respondent/A3 has stated that a false case has been
foisted against him and that, at the time of occurrence, he was undergoing a
surgical operation and was not present at the place of occurrence; (iv) the
fourth respondent/A4 stated that he has not committed any offence and that a
false case has been foisted against him; (v) the fifth respondent/A5 stated
that P.W.1 has not disclosed his name during trial and that no specific overt
act has been attributed against him; (vi) the sixth, seventh and ninth
respondents/A6, A7 and A9 stated that they are no way connected with the
case and that a false case has been foisted against them; and (vii) the eight
respondent/A8 stated that he was not present at the place of occurrence on
the date of occurrence, as he was in the hospital assisting A3, who was
undergone surgery.
4.
This Court has considered the submissions made by the
respondents/A1 to A9, on the question of sentence.
24/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
5. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and the
grave nature of the offence, this Court finds that the prosecution has proved
that respondents/A1 to A9 committed the offence punishable under Sections
147, 148, 341 and 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code.
Accordingly, for the offence under Section 302 read with Section 149 of the
Indian Penal Code, respondents/A1 to A9 are sentenced to undergo life
imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- each; in default of payment of
fine, they shall undergo rigorous imprisonment for a further period of six
months. Since the respondents have been awarded the sentence of life
imprisonment for the major offence, this Court is of the view that, in order to
meet the ends of justice, no separate sentence is required to be imposed for
the offences under Sections 147, 148 and 341 of the Indian Penal Code.
6. Since it is a reversal judgment and having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case, this Court directs the substantive sentence of
imprisonment imposed on respondents/A1 to A9 alone is suspended till the
expiry of the period prescribed for filing an appeal, so as to enable them to
prefer an appeal. It is made clear that, if respondents/A1 to A9 have not
25/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
preferred any appeal within the stipulated period or obtained any order of
suspension, the appellant/State shall take necessary steps to secure them to
undergo the sentence of imprisonment imposed by this Court.
[P.V.,J.]
[M.J.R.,J.]
18.02.2026
ms
Note :
(i)Registry is directed to issue copy of the judgment by today itself (i.e,
on 18.02.2026).
To
1. The District and Sessions Judge, Tiruvannamalai
2. The Public Prosecutor, High Court of Madras.
Copy to: The Superintendent of Jail, Central Prison,Vellore.
26/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
P.VELMURUGAN. J.
and
M.JOTHIRAMAN, J.
rns
Judgement in
Crl.A.No.456 of 2019
12 / 02 / 2026
27/27
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review