Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reportable
Judgment reserved on: 23.12.2025
Judgment delivered on:10.01.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Misc. Single No.1482 of 2022
M/s Kanhaiya Lal Polytechnic, Roorkee
--Petitioner
Versus
Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Haridwar & Ors.
–Respondents
With
Writ Petition Misc. Single No.1538 of 2022
State of Uttarakhand
--Petitioner
Versus
Naresh Kumar & Ors.
–Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. Siddhartha Sah, learned counsel for petitioner-Institution in WPMS No.1482 of
2022.
Mr. M.C. Pant, learned counsel for the private respondents.
Mr. K.S. Mehta, learned Additional C.S.C. for the State of Uttarakhand/respondent
No.7 in WPMS No.1482 of 2022 and petitioner in WPMS No.1538 of 2022.
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J. (Oral)
Since in both the writ petitions, common question of
law and facts are involved, hence, they are being taken up
together and are being decided by this common judgment.
However, for the sake of brevity, the facts of WPMS No.1482 of
2022 are taken into consideration alone.
2.
Both the writ petitions have been filed by the
petitioner(s) challenging the legality, propriety and correctness
of the award dated 03.01.2022 passed by learned Presiding
Officer, Labour Court, Haridwar in Adjudication Case No.21 of
2012 Naresh Kumar and Others Vs. M/s Kanhaiya Lal
Polytechnic and Another, whereby, learned Labour Court has
directed
the
regularization
of
services
of
the
respondents/workmen under the Uttarakhand Regularization
Rules, 2011, with effect from 01.11.2011.
3.
The petitioner(s) assails the impugned award on the
ground that learned Labour Court has exceeded its jurisdiction,
misapplied
the
statutory
rules,
ignored
binding
judicial
precedents and has passed the award in teeth of the settled
legal position governing regularization of temporary, daily wage
and contractual employees in aided educational institutions.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that M/s Kanhaiya Lal
Institute is an aided Polytechnic institution, governed by the
statutory framework namely The Uttar Pradesh Technical
Education
Institution
(Receiving
Grant-in-Aid
from
the
Government) Regulations, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Regulations of 1996”). As per the said Regulations, the power of
creation of posts, sanction of vacancies and recruitment vests
with the Director, Technical Education, whereas the Principal of
institution
is
merely
the
signing
authority
and
has
no
independent power to create posts or regularize services of
employees. The respondents-workmen were engaged at different
points of time as daily wagers, contractual or ad hoc employees,
primarily for duties connected with the hostel and institutional
premises, such as Watchman and Safai Karamchari. It was
submitted that no government-sanctioned posts exist for the
hostel; the hostel is not a government-aided unit; the salaries of
such workmen are paid either from student hostel fees or other
internal resources of the institution and no grant-in-aid is
received
from
the
State
Government
for
the
hostel
establishment.
5.
Earlier,
the
private
respondents-workmen
had
approached this Court by filing WPSS No.2309 of 2001 Naresh
Kumar & others vs. State of Uttaranchal, seeking regularization
of their services. The said writ petition was dismissed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment and order dated
14.08.2006, wherein it was categorically held that respondents/
workmen had no legal right to claim regularization. The said
judgment attained finality and operates as res judicata between
the parties. Subsequently, private respondents raised an
industrial dispute, which was registered as Adjudication Case
No. 21 of 2012 Naresh Kumar and Others Vs. M/s Kanhaiya Lal
Polytechnic and Another, before learned Labour Court, Haridwar.
During the pendency of proceedings, petitioner-Institution
brought on record various communications issued by the
Director, Technical Education, Uttarakhand and the State
Government, including letters dated 19.09.2013, 15.12.2015,
and
27.02.2016,
clearly
stating
that
the
Regularization
Regulations, 2013 and similar schemes were not applicable to
daily wagers, work-charged, contractual, fixed salary, part-time
and ad hoc employees of Kanhaiya Lal Polytechnic and no
proceedings for regularization were permissible. It was also
submitted that under the Regulations of 1996, recruitment to
Class-IV posts can be undertaken only against sanctioned
vacancies after prior approval of the Director, Technical
Education and the Principal has no authority to appoint,
regularize, or remove employees independently. Despite this
settled position, learned Labour Court relied upon certain
Government Orders issued in respect of other institutions, such
as G.B. Pant Engineering College, proceeded to apply the
Regularization Rules, 2011 to the respondents-workmen.
6.
Learned Labour Court vide impugned award dated
03.01.2022 held that respondents-workmen were entitled to
regularization under the Regularization Rules of 2011 w.e.f.
01.11.2011 and directed petitioner-institution as well as the
State authorities to regularize their services. Learned Labour
Court
further
recorded
findings
holding
the
petitioner-
institution responsible for recruitment and control of Class-IV
employees and brushed aside the binding effect of earlier
judgments and statutory regulations. Aggrieved by the said
judgment and award, petitioner(s) has approached this Court.
7.
Learned
counsel
for
petitioner-institutuion
submitted that the impugned award dated 03.01.2022 is wholly
illegal, perverse and without jurisdiction. It was contended that
learned Labour Court has ignored the binding judgment of
Coordinate Bench of this Court dated 14.08.2006 passed in
WPSS
No.2309
of
2001,
whereby,
the
very
claim
of
regularization raised by respondents-workmen stood rejected
and had attained finality. The said issue could not have been
reopened in collateral proceedings, and the award is therefore
barred by the principles of res judicata.
8.
He further submitted that learned Labour Court has
grossly exceeded its jurisdiction by issuing a positive direction
for regularization, a power which vests exclusively with the State
Government and the competent authority under the statutory
rules. Even a Coordinate Bench of this Court, in the earlier
round of litigation, had not granted such relief. Learned Labour
Court could not have exercised a jurisdiction which it does not
possess, particularly in the absence of sanctioned posts and
statutory authority.
9.
It is further contended by him that learned Labour
Court has wrongly applied the Uttarakhand Regularization
Rules, 2011 to respondents/workmen, who were admittedly
engaged as daily wagers, work-charged, contractual, fixed
salary, part-time and ad hoc employees, largely in connection
with the hostel. Official communications issued by the State
Government and the Director, Technical Education, including
letters dated 19.09.2013, 15.12.2015 and 27.02.2016, clearly
stipulate that the Regularization Rules are not applicable to
such categories of employees of petitioner-institution. These
binding instructions were completely ignored by learned Labour
Court. It was also submitted that the petitioner institution is
governed by The Uttar Pradesh Technical Education Institution
(Receiving Grant-in-Aid from the Government) Regulations,
1996, under which the power to create posts and make
recruitment lies solely with the Director, Technical Education,
while the Principal is merely the signing authority. Learned
Labour Court erred in law in holding the Principal fully
responsible for recruitment and control of Class-IV employees,
in clear disregard of Regulations 4, 15 and 39 of the 1996
Regulations, and contrary to the judgment passed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court on 04.07.2019 in WPMS No.
2894 of 2016.
10.
Learned counsel for petitioner also submitted that
respondents-workmen were engaged mainly for duties relating
to the hostel, which is not a government-aided unit, receives no
grant-in-aid, and has no sanctioned posts. Salaries are paid
from hostel fees or other institutional resources. In such
circumstances, no legal right to regularization can accrue.
Learned Labour Court committed a manifest error by relying
upon Government Orders issued in respect of other institutions
such as G.B. Pant Engineering College and by treating alleged
institutional vacancies as hostel vacancies, thereby misapplying
the statutory framework.
11.
It was also submitted that the findings recorded by
learned Labour Court are based on conjectures and surmises
and ignore material facts, including misrepresentation by one of
the respondents regarding his date of joining and the dismissal
of another respondent on account of misconduct. The direction
to grant regularization retrospectively from 01.11.2011 is
arbitrary and wholly unsustainable in law. The impugned award
is thus contrary to statutory provisions, binding judicial
precedents and settled principles laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court and is liable to be set aside.
12.
Learned
counsel
for
respondents-workmen
submitted that the writ petition is wholly misconceived, legally
untenable and an abuse of the extraordinary jurisdiction of this
Court. It is contended by him that the impugned award dated
03.01.2022 passed by learned Labour Court is a well-reasoned
adjudication rendered pursuant to a valid statutory reference
under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and therefore, does not
warrant interference in writ jurisdiction. Learned Labour Court
after due consideration of the material on record, has rightly
held that the continued non-regularization of respondentsworkmen
is
illegal,
arbitrary
and
unjustified
and
has
accordingly directed regularization under the Regularization
Rules, 2011 with effect from 01.11.2011.
13.
It was further argued by learned counsel for the
respondents-workmen that the plea of petitioner(s) is merely
that temporary or contractual employees are a mere play on
nomenclature and devoid of substance. It was submitted that
the respondents have been working continuously for decades as
an integral part of the institution, discharging perennial duties
under the administrative and disciplinary control of the
petitioner, receiving wages through institutional mechanisms.
Learned Labour Court has rightly held that such long,
uninterrupted
service
cannot
be
reduced
to
“temporary”
employment merely by labeling it so. Reliance was placed upon
the statutory force of the Model Standing Orders, which override
any contractual arrangement to the contrary and it was
contended that a workman who has completed 240 days of
service is entitled to be treated as permanent, irrespective of
artificial
breaks.
Learned
counsel
also
relied
upon
the
judgments of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bhartiya Kamgar
Karamchari Mahasangh vs. M/s Jet Airways Ltd. (2023
INSC 646) and Union of India vs. K. Suri Babu (2023 SCC
OnLine SC 1591) to submit that standing orders have statutory
mandate and cannot be diluted by executive or contractual
devices.
14.
He
lastly
submitted
that
petitioner(s)
has
deliberately delayed the regularization of respondents-workmen
despite repeated recommendations and has approached this
Court belatedly only to deprive the respondents, who are on the
verge of retirement, of their legitimate service and retiral
benefits. Denial of regularization at this stage would amount to
grave injustice, arbitrariness and inhumanity. It was contended
that learned Labour Court had full jurisdiction to adjudicate
upon the issue and even to mould relief in the interest of
industrial justice, as recognized by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Bharat Bank Ltd. vs. Employees of Bharat Bank Ltd.,
AIR 1950 SC 188. Both the writ petitions, being devoid of merit
and filed only to stall compliance of a lawful award, deserve to
be dismissed with exemplary costs.
15.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material placed on record. The challenge in these writ
petitions are to the award dated 03.01.2022 passed by learned
Labour Court, whereby the services of respondents-workmen
have been directed to be regularized w.e.f. 01.11.2011 under the
Regularization Rules, 2011. The principal contention of the
petitioner(s) is that learned Labour Court lacked jurisdiction to
issue such a direction and the respondents-workmen were
engaged on temporary/ad-hoc basis without sanctioned posts.
This Court is unable to accept the aforesaid contention. The
record clearly reflects that the dispute was referred for
adjudication by the State Government itself under the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947. Once a valid statutory reference is made,
any
objection
relating
to
maintainability
fades
into
insignificance.
16.
Furthermore, learned Labour Court has rightly
appreciated the statutory framework governing the petitionerinstitution. The Uttar Pradesh Technical Education Institutions
(Receiving
Grant-in-Aid)
Regulations,
1996,
particularly,
Regulation 39 r/w Regulation 2, clearly recognize the authority
of Principal in respect of engagement and continuation of such
workers. The plea sought to be raised by petitioner(s) that the
hostel is a separate entity from the institution is purely artificial.
The hostel is an integral part of the aided institution and cannot
be treated as a distinct establishment so as to deny the
respondents benefit of statutory protection. The Regularization
Rules, 2011 expressly apply to Government institutions and
there is no material on record to exclude the respondents from
their ambit. It is also undisputed that the respondents have
rendered long, uninterrupted service spanning several decades.
The State Government itself issued guidelines for regularization
of such employees, and having done so, it is not open either to
the petitioner-State or to the petitioner-institution to take a Uturn. The doctrine of promissory estoppel squarely applies.
Administrative authorities cannot approbate and reprobate to
the detriment of employees who have structured their lives
around a legitimate expectation created by governmental policy.
Learned Labour Court has correctly relied upon the statutory
force of Model Standing Orders, which override contractual or
nomenclatural devices adopted by employers to perpetuate
temporary status. Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held
that
continuation
of
workmen
on
ad-hoc,
daily-wage
or
temporary basis for long periods is arbitrary, exploitative and
violative
of
constitutional
principles.
Recent
judgments,
including those referred to in Bharatiya Kamgar Karamchari
Mahasangh vs M/s Jet Airways Ltd., 2023 INSC 645,
strongly deprecate such practices and affirm the obligation of
employer to regularize eligible employees. The impugned award
is fully aligned with this settled jurisprudence.
17.
The reliance placed by petitioner on the decision in
B. Srinivasa Reddy v. Karnataka Urban Water Supply &
Drainage Board Employees’ Association has been rightly
distinguished by learned Labour Court. That case arose out of a
dispute raised by members of an unrecognized union, whereas
in the present case State Government itself initiated the
reference and framed regularization guidelines. The factual and
legal foundation of the said judgment is therefore inapplicable to
the present controversy. This Court is also mindful that the
right to livelihood forms an integral part of Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. Denial of regularization to employees who
have devoted the prime of their lives to the institution would
result in grave injustice and arbitrariness, particularly when
many of the respondents are on the verge of retirement. The writ
jurisdiction of this Court cannot be invoked to unsettle a just
and equitable award merely on technical objections raised
belatedly. At the same time, it is clarified that in the event
sanctioned posts are created or arise in future and the services
of respondents are required, liberty shall remain with the
petitioner-institution to process such cases afresh in accordance
with law and applicable rules. The impugned award does not
foreclose such statutory consideration.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court finds
no perversity, jurisdictional error or illegality in the impugned
award dated 03.01.2022 passed by learned Labour Court.
19.
Both the writ petitions, being devoid of merit, are
dismissed.
The
impugned
judgment
and
award
dated
03.01.2022 passed by learned Presiding Officer, Labour Court,
Haridwar, in both the writ petitions, are affirmed.
20.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
PN
10.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review