Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
State of Odisha
…….
Appellant
-VersusArtatran Mallick
.……
Respondent
Advocates appeared:
For Appellant
: Mr. Siba Narayan Biswal,
Additional Standing Counsel
For Respondent
: Mr. P.K. Mishra,
Advocate
CORAM :
MR. JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MISHRA
Heard and Disposed of on 10.04.2026
JUDGMENT
By the Bench;
1.
State of Odisha as the Appellant seeks to assail the order dated
29.11.2022, passed by this Court in WP(C)(OA) No.1589 of 2018 in
this Intra Court Appeal.
2.
Mr. Biswal, learned Additional Standing Counsel representing
the Appellant submits that the Respondent was an accused in
commission of offence involving moral turpitude. Hence, Capital P.S.
Case No.101 of 2005 under Sections 467/ 468/ 471/ 420/ 167/ 120-B
of IPC was instituted against the Respondent when he was working as
Tahasildar at Jagannath Prasad in the District of Ganjam.
3.
The criminal case was set in motion by the Crime Branch. The
Respondent was arrested. Since the Respondent remained in custody
exceeding 48 hours, he was placed under suspension w.e.f. the date of
arrest, i.e., 20.02.2010 vide order dated 25.03.2010 by the disciplinary
authority.
4.
Subsequently, the Respondent filed O.A.No.3309(C) of 2011
before the State Administrative Tribunal (for brevity ‘the Tribunal’)
for revocation of the order of suspension.
5.
The said O.A. was disposed of vide order dated 03.01.2013
with a direction to the State-Appellant to consider the case of the
Respondent for revocation of the order of suspension in terms of Rule
12(5) of the Orissa Civil Services (Clarification, Control & Appeal)
Rules, 1962, (for brevity, ‘the OCS (CCA) Rules’). Pursuant to the
direction of the Tribunal, the Respondent was reinstated in service
vide order dated 19.03.2013 passed by the Revenue & Disaster
Management Department, Government of Odisha. A Disciplinary
Proceeding vide D.P. No.6 of 2013 was also initiated against the
Respondent under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules. The articles of
charges levelled against the Respondent vide Memo No. IIIE-PD-III33/2012/671/R (CS), dated 19.03.2013 are as under:1. Misutilisation of power beyond jurisdiction with mala
fide intention.
2. Manipulation, forgery, fraudulent activities and
framing incorrect records.
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
3. Illegal recording of Government land in favour of
private persons which leads to future litigations for
Government.
4. Doubtful integrity.
5. Misconduct.
6.
The Additional District Magistrate, Bhubaneswar was
appointed as the Enquiry Officer to enquire into the charges. The
Enquiry Officer submitted his report on 25.05.2015 recommending
exoneration of the Respondent from all the charges levelled against
him. However, the report was not accepted by the Disciplinary
Authority and a fresh enquiry was directed. After fresh inquiry, the
Enquiry Officer submitted his report on 01.12.2015 holding as
under:"I am therefore to submit that the Delinquent
Officer Sri Artatran Mallick had verified the
Yaddasts and disposed the same on verification
of records & reports. I find no infringement of
procedure has been caused by him in disposing
the land records."
7.
However, the Disciplinary Proceeding initiated against the
Respondent was not concluded on the basis of such fresh report of the
Enquiry Officer. Hence, the Respondent moved the Orissa
Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.2036 of 2016, which was
disposed of vide order dated 18.05.2017 with a direction to complete
the Disciplinary Proceeding in all respect within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of the said order. But, the
Disciplinary Proceeding could not be concluded within the stipulated
period.
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
8.
Mr. Biswal, learned Additional Standing Counsel further
submits that cognizance in the Criminal Case initiated against the
Respondent was taken by the learned S.D.J.M., Bhubaneswar on
17.07.2013. However, the said Criminal Proceeding has been stayed
by this Court vide order dated 23.06.2015 filed by one Nisamani
Sahoo, a co-accused, in CRLMC No.2761 of 2015.
9.
Subsequently, the Respondent filed O.A. No.1589 of 2018 to
quash the memorandum of charges issued against him on 19.03.2013,
with a further prayer to regularise his period of suspension and to
release pay as per 7th Pay Commission recommendation. On abolition
of the Tribunal, the said O.A. was transferred to this Court and was
registered as WP(C)(OA) No.1589 of 2018.
10.
This Court, however, taking note of the facts and
circumstances of the case, vide order dated 29.11.2022 disposed of
the said writ petition by quashing the Departmental Proceeding and
further directed to take all effective steps to regularise the period of
suspension and to release the financial benefit as due and admissible
in favour of the Respondent including the benefit of promotion, if he
is otherwise eligible. Learned Single Judge also directed to complete
the entire exercise within a period of four months from the date of
receipt of the said order. The State of Odisha, being aggrieved by the
said order, has filed this Writ Appeal.
11.
Mr. Biswal, learned Additional Standing Counsel submits that
since the charges levelled against the Respondent in the Disciplinary
Proceeding are serious in nature, learned Single Judge should not
have quashed the Departmental Proceeding. In support of his case, he
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
relied upon the case of Deputy Registrar, Cooperative Societies,
Faizabad Vs. Sachindra Nath Pandey and others reported in (1995)
3 SCC 134, wherein, it is held as under:“7. On a perusal of charges, we find that the
charges are very serious. We are, therefore, not
inclined to close the matter only on the ground
that about 16 years have elapsed since the date
of commencement of disciplinary proceedings,
more particularly when the appellant alone
cannot be held responsible for this delay. So far
as the merits are concerned, we regret to say
that the High Court has not dealt with the
submissions- and facts in support of the
submission of the appellant- that in spite of
being given a number of opportunities the first
respondent has failed to avail of them. If the
appellant's allegations are true then the
appellant cannot be faulted for not holding a
regular inquiry (recording the evidence of
witnesses and so on). The High Court has
assumed, even without referring to Regulation
68 aforesaid that holding of an oral inquiry was
obligatory. Indeed, one of the questions in the
writ petition may be the interpretation of
Regulation 68. On facts, the first respondent has
his own version. In the circumstances, the writ
petition could not have been allowed unless it
was held that the appellant's version of events is
not true and that the first respondent's version is
true. In the circumstances, we have no
alternative but to set aside the order under
appeal and remit the matter to the High Court
once again for disposal of the writ petition
afresh in the light of the observations made
herein. Since the matter is a very old one it is
but appropriate that the matter is dealt with
expeditiously. Perhaps, it would be appropriate
if the Court looks into the records relating to the
disciplinary proceedings also.”
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
12.
He, therefore, submits that learned Single Judge committed
gross error in quashing the Disciplinary Proceeding and exonerating
the Respondent from all charges levelled against him. He, further,
submits that once a Disciplinary Proceeding is initiated, it should
meet its logical end. In the instant case, although two consecutive
Inquiry Reports were filed exonerating the Petitioner from the
charges levelled against him, but the same were not accepted by the
Disciplinary Authority. Further, the Criminal Proceeding initiated
against the Respondent has been stayed by this Court at the instance
of a co-accused namely, Nisamani Sahoo. In such scenario, the
learned Single Judge should not have quashed the Disciplinary
Proceeding and should have allowed it to be concluded in accordance
with law.
13.
Mr. Mishra, learned Counsel for the Respondent vehemently
objects to the same. It is his submission that although Disciplinary
Proceeding was initiated on certain charges, but the Additional
District Magistrate, Bhubaneswar was appointed as the Enquiry
Officer. On a thorough enquiry following due procedure, he
submitted report recommending that the Respondent should be
exonerated from all the charges levelled against him. Being not
satisfied, the Disciplinary Authority directed for fresh inquiry into the
charges levelled against the Respondent. But the Enquiry Officer
submitted his report opining that the Respondent cannot be held
guilty for the alleged irregularities. Hence, the Enquiry Officer on
fresh enquiry also recommended for exonerating the Respondent
from all the charges levelled against him in the Disciplinary
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
Proceeding. Stay of the Criminal Proceeding should not stand as a bar
or bottleneck for the Disciplinary Authority to conclude the
Disciplinary proceeding within reasonable period, more particularly
when the Tribunal vide order dated 18.05.2017, while disposing of
O.A. No.2036 of 2016, directed to complete the Disciplinary
Proceeding in all respect within a period of three months from the
date of receipt of said order. But, neither the Disciplinary Proceeding
was concluded within the said period nor was any prayer made for
extension of time to conclude the Disciplinary Proceeding.
14.
After submission of two consecutive enquiry reports
exonerating the Respondent from all the charges, the Disciplinary
Authority had no other option than to drop the Disciplinary
Proceeding. If he was not satisfied with the report of the Enquiry
Officer, he could have recorded reasons for the same and proceeded
accordingly. But, he failed to act in accordance with law.
15.
Further, since frivolous charges were levelled against the
Respondents, he suffered mental agony due to protracted Disciplinary
Proceeding without any basis. The Respondent had no contribution
for not concluding the disciplinary proceeding within a reasonable
period.
16.
Learned Single Judge while quashing the disciplinary
proceeding also relied upon the case law in State of A.P. Vs.
Radhakishan reported in (1998) 4 SCC 154, wherein it is held as
under:“19. It is not possible to lay down any
predetermined principles applicable to all cases
and in all situations where there is delay in
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
concluding the disciplinary proceedings.
Whether on that ground the disciplinary
proceedings are to be terminated each case has
to be examined on the facts and circumstances in
that case. The essence of the matter is that the
court has to take into consideration all the
relevant factors and to balance and weigh them
to determine if it is in the interest of clean and
honest administration that the disciplinary
proceedings should be allowed to terminate after
delay particularly when the delay is abnormal
and there is no explanation for the delay. The
delinquent employee has a right that disciplinary
proceedings against him are concluded
expeditiously and he is not made to undergo
mental agony and also monetary loss when these
are unnecessarily prolonged without any fault on
his part in delaying the proceedings. In
considering whether the delay has vitiated the
disciplinary proceedings the court has to
consider the nature of charge, its complexity and
on what account the delay has occurred. If the
delay is unexplained prejudice to the delinquent
employee is writ large on the face of it. It could
also be seen as to how much the disciplinary
authority is serious in pursuing the charges
against its employee. It is the basic principle of
administrative justice that an officer entrusted
with a particular job has to perform his duties
honestly, efficiently and in accordance with the
rules. If he deviates from this path he is to suffer
a penalty prescribed. Normally, disciplinary
proceedings should be allowed to take their
course as per relevant rules but then delay
defeats justice. Delay causes prejudice to the
charged officer unless it can be shown that he is
to blame for the delay or when there is proper
explanation for the delay in conducting the
disciplinary proceedings. Ultimately, the court is
to balance these two diverse considerations.”
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
17.
In the aforesaid case law, Hon’ble Supreme Court confirmed
the order of the Tribunal in quashing the charge memo leveled against
the Respondent therein. In the instant case, delay in disposal of the
disciplinary proceeding was not explained by the State in spite of
consecutive reports of the Enquiry Officer exonerating the Respondent
from the charges leveled against him. No Counter Affidavit was filed
by State-Appellant either before the Tribunal or before this Court
explaining the delay in concluding the disciplinary proceeding in spite
of direction of the Tribunal. In that view of the matter, Mr. Mishra,
learned counsel for the Respondent submitted that no illegality has
been committed by learned Single Judge in quashing the disciplinary
proceeding.
18.
Heard learned Counsel for the Parties.
19.
Perused the materials placed before us along with the case law
relied upon.
20.
Criminal proceeding was initiated against the Respondent for
alleged commission of certain offences under Sections 467/ 468/ 471/
420/ 167/ 120-B of IPC. Cognizance of the offence alleged against the
Respondent was also taken by learned S.D.J.M., Bhubaneswar.
However, the said criminal proceeding has been stayed by this Court
in CRLMC No.2761 of 2015 filed by one Nisamani Sahoo, who is
also a co-accused in the said criminal proceeding.
21.
From the submission made by Mr. Biswal, learned Additional
Standing Counsel, it appears that disciplinary proceeding was also
initiated against the Respondent alleging serious misconduct. The
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
Additional District Magistrate, Bhubaneswar being the Inquiry Officer
submitted his report on 25.05.2015 recommending exoneration of the
Respondent from all the charges leveled against him. Being not
satisfied, the disciplinary authority directed for fresh enquiry, who
submitted report stating that the Respondent has no role to play in the
alleged creation of fraudulent records and misconduct. In spite of the
same, the disciplinary authority did not proceed with the matter to
conclude the disciplinary proceeding either by conducting a fresh
enquiry or by dropping the disciplinary proceeding.
22.
The Respondent had also filed O.A. No.2306 of 2016, which
was disposed of by the Tribunal vide order dated 18.05.2017 directing
the State Government to conclude the disciplinary proceeding in all
respect within three months from the date of receipt of the said order.
The State-Appellant neither prayed for extension of time by filing
appropriate application for conclusion of disciplinary proceeding nor
concluded the disciplinary proceeding in compliance with the
aforesaid direction. The said order passed by the Tribunal was also not
challenged by the State-Appellant.
23.
Finding no other alternatives, the Respondent filed O.A.
No.1589 of 2018 to quash the charge memo and to regularize his
services. He also prayed for releasing his financial service benefit. The
O.A. was subsequently transferred to this Court after abolition of the
Tribunal and was registered as WP(C)(OA) No.1589 of 2018.
24.
Learned Single Judge taking note of the above and relying
upon the case law in State of A.P. Vs. Radhakishan (supra) directed
to quash the disciplinary proceeding.
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
25.
There is no material on record to show that the Respondent
had attributed to the delay in disposal of the disciplinary proceeding.
There is also no explanation by the State-Appellant in concluding the
disciplinary proceeding within a reasonable period. In the case of
State of A.P. Vs. Radhakishan (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has
categorically observed that while entertaining the application for
quashing a disciplinary proceeding, the Court should take into
consideration the gravity of offence alleged as well as the conduct of
the party.
26.
In the instant case, there is no allegation by the State-
Appellant that the Respondent had contributed for delay in disposal of
the
disciplinary
proceeding.
The
Enquiry
Officer
submitted
consecutive reports exonerating the Respondent from all the charges
leveled against him in the disciplinary proceeding. Moreover, the
Tribunal vide order dated 18.05.2017, while disposing of O.A.
No.2036 of 2016 directed to complete the Disciplinary Proceeding in
all respect within a period of three months from the date of receipt of
said order. But, neither the Disciplinary Proceeding was concluded
within the said period nor was any prayer made for extension of time
to conclude the Disciplinary Proceeding. Order of the Tribunal in
O.A. No. 2036 of 2016 was never challenged and thus attained its
finality. Further, the case law relied upon by Mr. Biswal, learned
Additional Standing Counsel in Deputy Registrar, Cooperative
Societies (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court did not interfere on the
ground that delay in disposal of the disciplinary proceeding was due to
the Respondent therein. Thus, the said case law is of no assistance to
the case of the Appellant.
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
27.
Taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the
case as stated above and the case laws, learned Single Judge came to a
categorical conclusion that the disciplinary proceeding should be
quashed. We find no infirmity in the said order.
28.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal being devoid of any merit
stands dismissed in the facts and circumstance of the case there shall
be no order as to cost.
Urgent certified copy of this judgment shall be granted as per
rules.
(K.R. Mohapatra)
Judge
(S.K. Mishra)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
Dated 10th April, 2026/Banita
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BANITA PRIYADARSHINI PALEI
Designation: SR. STENOGRAPHER
Reason: AUTHENTICATION
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 15-Apr-2026 17:01:28
W.A. No. 2589 OF 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review