The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. Considering that the prosecution came out with two versions of the incident, the Trial Court held that the evidence on record is not inspiring confidence and is full of inconsistencies and contradictions. It further held that it has not been proved that the shot which caused injury to the complainant was fired by the respondent. Accordingly, the respondent was acquitted of the charges under section 307 IPC and section 27 of the Arms Act.
24. In view of the facts and circumstances noted hereinabove, we are of the considered opinion that the view on the evidence taken by the Trial Court is possible and plausible view. The version of PW-5 complainant stands contradicted by the version given by an independent witness i.e. PW-4 Nand Kishore, who stated that the shot got fired in the on-going scuffle after 4-5 persons had snatched the pistol from the respondent-accused. The statement of PW-4 is further corroborated to an extent by another public witness PW-9 Mayank Lakhani, who stated that the respondent-accused was trying to snatch his gun back from Vicky. The other three public witnesses i.e. PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 did not support the case of the prosecution at all. There is thus, no perversity in the judgment of the Trial Court. We, therefore, do not find any valid or substantial reasons to interfere with the acquittal of the respondent.
25. The appeal lacks merit, therefore, the same is dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 12th August, 2026
Uploaded on: 17th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011642572013
+
CRL.A. 1354/2013
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Aashneet Singh, APP.
versus
SURINDER SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Darpan Sachdeva, Adv.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
VIKAS MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the State of NCT of Delhi being
aggrieved by the acquittal of the respondent-accused i.e. Surinder Singh vide
impugned judgement dated 03.10.2011 passed by the ASJ-02, South East,
Saket Courts, New Delhi in Sessions Case No. 95/08, FIR No. 39/08, under
section 307 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter ‘IPC’) and section 27 of
the Arms Act.
3.
Briefly put, the case of the prosecution is that on 12.01.2008, the
complainant i.e. Vivek Chhabra [PW-5] along with some people visited the
Indo-Chin Bar, Lado Sarai at around 1:30 AM. Later, the complainant and
those persons went to the parking area of the bar, and the complainant sat on
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
the bonnet of the car and due to the same, the driver of the car who was
sitting inside misbehaved with him and pushed him. Thereafter they started
abusing each other and the driver of the car threatened to kill him and also
took out a pistol from his pocket and fired on his leg. The driver of the said
car was identified as Surinder Singh, the respondent herein, by the owner of
the car namely, Mayank Lakhani [PW9].
4.
Upon receipt of DD No. 31, ASI Devender went to the place of
incident where the statement of the injured complainant was recorded and
the rukka was sent, which led to the registration of the FIR under section
307 of IPC and section 27 of Arms Act.
5.
The investigation was assigned to SI Aishvir Singh who visited the
spot and arrested the respondent-accused, pursuant to which his disclosure
was recorded, and seizure of the pistol along with 5 live cartridges, as well
as license of the pistol, was made.
6.
The injured complainant was taken to Safdarjung Hospital where he
received treatment for his injuries. Dr. Satyendra Prakash [PW7] examined
the injured and as per the MLC, the injury suffered by the injured was
opined as ‘grievous’.
7.
After investigation, the chargesheet was filed by the Police under
section 173 CrPC. Vide order dated 23.04.2009 charges were framed against
the respondent for offences under section 307 IPC and section 27 of the
Arms Act, to which the respondent pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
8.
The prosecution examined as many as 16 witnesses, out of
which PW4 Nand Kishore, PW-5 Vivek Chhabra (injured/complainant) and
PW-9 Mayank Lakhani, have given the eye-witness account.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
9.
After the conclusion of prosecution evidence, the statement of the
respondent was recorded under Section 313 CrPC, but he did not lead any
defence evidence. The Trial Court upon appreciation of the evidence led by
the prosecution held that the evidence on record is not inspiring confidence
and is full of inconsistencies and contradictions. Accordingly, the
respondent was acquitted of the charge for the offence under Section 307
IPC.
Likewise, the respondent was also acquitted of the charge under
Section 27 of the Arms Act on the ground that the prosecution has failed to
prove that the shots from the licensed fire arm were fired by the respondent.
10.
We have heard Mr. Aashneet Singh, ld. APP for the State, as well as,
Mr. Darpan Sachdeva, ld. Counsel for the respondent and have also perused
the record.
11.
Before proceeding further, it would be useful to advert to the
approach to be adopted while deciding an Appeal against acquittal by the
Trial Court. In a recent decision in H.D. Sundara and others vs State of
Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581, the Supreme Court reiterated the principles
which will govern the exercise of appellate jurisdiction while dealing with
an appeal against acquittal under Section 378 CrPC and summarized the
same as under:
“8. …… The principles which govern the exercise of
appellate jurisdiction while dealing with an appeal
against acquittal under Section 378 CrPC can be
summarised as follows:
8.1. The acquittal of the accused further strengthens
the presumption of innocence;
8.2. The appellate court, while hearing an appeal
against acquittal, is entitled to reappreciate the oral
and documentary evidence;
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
8.3. The appellate court, while deciding an appeal
against acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is
required to consider whether the view taken by the
trial court is a possible view which could have been
taken on the basis of the evidence on record;
8.4. If the view taken is a possible view, the appellate
court cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the
ground that another view was also possible; and
8.5. The appellate court can interfere with the order
of acquittal only if it comes to a finding that the only
conclusion which can be recorded on the basis of the
evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused
was proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no other
conclusion was possible.”
(emphasis supplied)
12.
Additionally, the Supreme Court also underscored that in many cases
the Trial Judge who eventually passes the order of acquittal has an
advantage of looking at the demeanour of witnesses and observing their
conduct in the Court, especially in the witness box. The relevant observation
reads thus:
“10. There is one more aspect of the matter. In many cases, the
learned trial Judge who eventually passes the order of acquittal
has an occasion to record the oral testimony of all material
witnesses. Thus, in such cases, the trial court has the additional
advantage of closely observing the prosecution witnesses and
their demeanour. While deciding about the reliability of the
version of prosecution witnesses, their demeanour remains in
the back of the mind of the learned trial Judge. As observed in
the commentary by Sarkar on the Law of Evidence, the
demeanour of a witness frequently furnishes a clue to the weight
of his testimony. This aspect has to be borne in mind while
dealing with an appeal against acquittal.”
(emphasis supplied)
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
13.
Now reverting to the facts of the case, we note with the assistance of
learned APP as well as the learned counsel for the respondent, that only
three out six eye-witnesses cited by the prosecution, testified having
witnessed the incident. The said three witnesses are PW-4 Nand Kishore;
PW-5 Vivek Chhabra (complainant) and PW-9 Mayank Lakhani.
14.
The other three public witnesses namely, PW-1 Kuldeep Tiwari
(Bouncer at Indo-chin Bar), PW-2 Saurav Batra, PW-3 Sahil Batra have not
testified having seen the incident, thus, they did not support the case of
prosecution. PW-1 stated that he came out of the Bar after hearing a noise
of the firing. Likewise, PW-2 and PW-3 also testified that when they came
out of the club they found one person in an injured condition, whose name
they later came to know as Vivek Chhabra. So none of these witnesses had
seen the incident.
15.
The Trial Court noted on the basis of the evidence on record, that the
prosecution has come out with two different versions of the incident. We
have examined the testimonies of the three eye-witnesses, and find the
conclusion of the Trial Court to be correct.
16.
The first version has come on record through the testimony of PW-5
Vivek Chhabra, the injured/complainant, who stated that he along with his
friends namely, Sahil Batra, Vaibhav Arora and 2-3 other friends had gone
to Indo-chin Club at Saket, New Delhi. After the club closed, he came out
along with his friends at about 02.00 A.M. The respondent was sitting in a
car outside the club and they were standing by taking support of his car. The
respondent came out of the car and had some verbal duel with him and Sahil
Batra. When he intervened, the respondent first fired in the air and then fired
a shot on his leg.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
17.
The second version has been narrated by an independent witness i.e.
PW-4 Nand Kishore, who was the security guard in the Indo-chin Bar. He
deposed that at about 01.30 A.M, 4-5 persons came out from the bar and
then were again re-entering the bar. He asked them not to go into the bar as
the bar had closed but they insisted to go again to have drinks. Two of them
fetched some glasses from one car and then they stood near a big car and
started having drinks by keeping the drinks on the bonnet of the said car.
When the person sitting in the said car objected to this, first those boys
dragged the said person on the side and one of the boys exhorted other to
beat the said person who was objecting them from drinking on the bonnet of
the big car. The person in the big car was having a pistol with him, he took
out the same but it was snatched by those 4-5 boys. In the on-going scuffle a
shot was fired from the said pistol, and thereafter he saw one of the boys out
of those 4-5 boys having an injury on the foot which was bleeding. Within
4-5 minutes, the police had arrived at the spot. The person who was injured
had already gone from the spot, while the police took the person who was
objecting the boys from drinking, to the police station.
18.
The testimony of PW-9 Mayank Lakhani, the owner of the big car and
the employer of the respondent, is closer to the version given by PW-4 Nand
Kishore, inasmuch as he stated that Vicky was grappling with the
respondent, and the respondent was trying to snatch his gun back from
Vicky.
19.
The witness PW-3 Sahil Batra, who as per PW-5 Vivek Chhabra, had
a verbal duel with the respondent-accused, rather feigned complete
ignorance as to who had caused the bullet injuries to Vivek Chhabra, and
stated that when he and his brother Saurav Batra came out of the club, they
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
found Vivek Chhabra in an injured condition.
20.
On the basis of the above two contradictory versions, the Trial Court
concluded that the evidence led by the prosecution is too uncertain and
ambiguous to point out towards the guilt of the accused, rather it would
suggest that the true facts have not been brought before the Court.
21.
In his statement PW-7 Dr. Satyendra Prakash, who prepared the
MLC, Ex. PW7/A, of injured Vivek Chhabra, initially said that the injuries
suffered by the complainant were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary
course of nature, but when questioned by the Court as to the basis of such
observation, he deposed that he had given the statement considering the
situation where the injury had caused a fracture as well as crushed the bone.
He stated that in such situations, air embolism can occur which may cause
death. On further specific query of the court whether injury in this case was
of the nature which could have caused death, he responded in the negative.
In this backdrop, the Trial Court held that PW-7 has in a very casual manner
stated that the injury was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of
nature. We also note that even the MLC does not record that the injury was
sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature, rather the injury is
below the knee, on lateral side and posterior, which is not a vital part of the
body.
22.
The relevant extract from the Trial Court judgment are set out
hereinbelow for the ease of reference:
“ 10.
Now PW-5 Vivek Chhabra has also deposed
in his cross examination that after the incident,
Mayank Lakhani had also come out of the Bar. It may
be mentioned here that Mayank Lakhani was the owner
of the car in which the accused was the driver/PSO.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
PW-5 deposed that Mayank Lakhani talked with the
accused Surinder Singh and then he came to know that
he was the driver of Mayank Lakhani. The statement of
PW-5, thus, shows the presence of Mayank Lakhani on
the spot. This leads to the statement of PW-9 Mayank
Lakhani who deposed that at about 1.15 am, he came
outside the Bar in the parking and saw the accused
standing near his car. Four boys were also standing
near him. Two of them had caught hold the accused
Surinder Singh. One of the boy out of those four, was
sitting on the bonnet of his car and one of them
perhaps Vicky was grappling with the accused and the
accused was trying to snatch his gun back from Vicky.
He further deposed that he heard the sound of a
gunshot. He deposed that the accused had ran away
from the spot and he called the accused on his mobile
phone but the accused did not pick up the phone. He
deposed that he went near his car and found some
pieces of glass lying there and a bottle of alcohol
containing very little alcohol in it near the bumper on
the front side. He took his car and left the place. He
could not find accused Surinder Singh at that time.
Now this witness states about some glass pieces lying
near the car and a bottle of alcohol containing very
little alcohol in it. This would lead to the statement of
PW-4 Nand Kishore who was the security guard in the
Indo-chin Bar and Restaurant, Saket, New Delhi.
11.
He deposed that at about 1.30 am, 4/5
persons came out from the Bar and they were again reentering the Bar. He asked them not to go into the Bar
as the closing hours were over but they insisted to go
again and to have drink. Two of them fetched some
glasses from some car and they stood near a big car.
He deposed that they started having drinks by keeping
the drinks on the bonnet of the said car. He further
deposed that one person sitting in the said car objected
to this. He further deposed that first those boys
dragged the said person on the side and one of them
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
boy exhorted the others to beat the said person who
was objecting them to drink on the bonnet. That person
in the big car was having a pistol with him, he took out
the same, but it was snatched by those 4/5 persons. In
the on going scuffle, fire was shot from the said pistol.
He further deposed that he had seen one of the boy out
of those 4/5 persons having an injury on the foot which
was bleeding. He further deposed that within 4/5
minutes, the police had arrived at the spot. The person
who was injured in the scuffle had already gone from
the spot.
12.
Now this statement of PW-4 Nand Kishore is
again contrary to the prosecution case. He has been
very categorical in his statement that the fire was shot
when there was a scuffle between the accused and the
other persons who had snatched his pistol. This
statement of PW-4 Nand Kishore is the positive
statement on behalf of the prosecution which is
contrary to its own version. Thus, prosecution itself
has come out with two versions of the incident. In the
first version, the accused had fired shot at Vivek
Chhabra. In the second version, there was a scuffle in
which the fire was shot and the pistol was snatched
from the accused before the fire was shot.
13.
The statement of PW-9 Mayank Lakhani,
who also deposed that he had seen the incident is
much closer to the version given by PW-4 Nand
Kishore. He had deposed that Vicky was grappling
with the accused and the accused was trying to snatch
his gun back from the Vicky. It means that the pistol
of the accused was snatched by the complainant
Vivek Chhabra from him.
14.
This is the statement of the public witnesses
who have deposed contrary to each other making the
prosecution version of the case highly doubtful. ….
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
17.
Thus, the evidence by the prosecution is too
uncertain and ambiguous to point out towards the
guilt of the accused rather it would suggest that the
true facts have not been brought before the Court and
the investigation is not done in a proper manner.
18.
Before parting with the judgment, I would
also refer to the statement of PW-7 Dr. Satyendra
Prakash who prepared the MLC of injured Vivek
Chhabra. In his cross examination, he deposed that the
injuries in this case were sufficient to cause death in
the ordinary course of nature. On what basis he said so
was a matter of query for the Court. Therefore a court
question was put to him, as to whether the injury in this
case was of such a nature to cause death to which he
replied that the injury was of such a nature as to cause
death. He was questioned, on what basis he had opined
the injury in this case sufficient to cause death. He
deposed that he had given the statement as per the
situation where the injury had caused a fracture as
well as crushed the bone. The reason why he said that
the injury was sufficient to cause death, is that in such
a situation air embolism can occur which "may" cause
death. There is a subtle but significant difference
between an injury which is "sufficient" to cause death
in "ordinary" course of nature and an injury which
"may" cause death. As per statement of PW-7, death
might occur if "air embolism" occur in the crush
bone. So injury by itself could not have caused death.
He has in a very casual manner stated in the Court
that the injury was sufficient to cause death in the
ordinary course of nature.
19. Thus, the evidence on the record is not inspiring
confidence and is full of inconsistencies and
contradictions. Therefore, the accused deserves the
acquittal in this case for the offence U/s 307 IPC. As
regard the charge U/s 27 of the Arms Act, it is the
case of the prosecution that the accused was having a
valid license but he used the firearm in contravention
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
of Section of the Arms Act. Since the prosecution has
even failed to prove that the shots were fired by the
accused from his firearm, there is no question of his
using the "firearm" in contravention of Section 5 of
the Arms Act. Hence, he deserves an acquittal for the
offence U/s 27 of the Arms Act as well. The accused
Surinder Singh is hereby acquitted of the charges U/s
307 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act. He is on
bail. His bail bond stands cancelled and surety stands
discharged. Documents of the surety, if any, be
returned to him on proper receipt and identification.”
23.
Considering that the prosecution came out with two versions of the
incident, the Trial Court held that the evidence on record is not inspiring
confidence and is full of inconsistencies and contradictions. It further held
that it has not been proved that the shot which caused injury to the
complainant was fired by the respondent. Accordingly, the respondent was
acquitted of the charges under section 307 IPC and section 27 of the Arms
Act.
24.
In view of the facts and circumstances noted hereinabove, we are of
the considered opinion that the view on the evidence taken by the Trial
Court is possible and plausible view. The version of PW-5 complainant
stands contradicted by the version given by an independent witness i.e.
PW-4 Nand Kishore, who stated that the shot got fired in the on-going
scuffle
after
4-5
persons
had
snatched
the
pistol
from
the
respondent-accused. The statement of PW-4 is further corroborated to an
extent by another public witness PW-9 Mayank Lakhani, who stated that the
respondent-accused was trying to snatch his gun back from Vicky. The other
three public witnesses i.e. PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 did not support the case
of the prosecution at all. There is thus, no perversity in the judgment of the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
Trial Court. We, therefore, do not find any valid or substantial reasons to
interfere with the acquittal of the respondent.
25.
The appeal lacks merit, therefore, the same is dismissed.
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
AUGUST 12, 2026
nsa
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:55:19
CRL.A. 1354/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review