Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 25th March, 2026
Pronounced on:24thApril, 2026
Uploaded on: 24th April, 2026
+
CRL.A. 600/2017
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ashmeet Singh, APP for State
SI Sunil Khokhar.
versus
SURAJ @ SANJAY & ANR
.....Respondents
Through:
Ms. Anu Narula (DHCLSC), Mr.
Robin Sun, Mr. Brajraj Sharma,
Advs.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present appeal has been preferred by the Appellant/State of NCT
of Delhi under Sections 377/378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
(hereinafter ‘Cr.P.C’), assailing the judgment dated 7th May 2016 and the
order on sentence dated 23rd May 2016, passed by ld. ASJ-03, Patiala House
Courts, New Delhi, in Sessions Case No. 63/2014 titled State vs. Suraj @
Sanjay & Anr., arising out of FIR No. 173/2013 registered at P.S. Naraina.
2.
By way of the impugned judgment, the ld. Trial Court convicted the
Respondents for a lesser offence under Sections 308/34 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (hereinafter ‘IPC’) instead of Sections 307/34 IPC. Thereafter,
vide order on sentence dated 23rd May 2016, the Respondents were released
on probation of good conduct for a period of three years upon furnishing
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
personal bonds in the sum of Rs. 10,000/- each with one surety in the like
amount. Additionally, Respondent No. 1, Suraj, was directed to pay
compensation of Rs. 10,000/- and Respondent No. 2, Ajay, Rs. 5,000/- to the
victims. The relevant portion of the conclusion of the Trial Court is set out
below:
“28. In the case in hand, it has categorically come
on record in the deposition of PW2 Akash Kumar
- injured that on the night of 28.07.2013 accused
Suraj was under the influence of liquor and it was
late in the night therefore, parents of Smt.Chanda
were refusing to send her with Suraj. Accused
Suraj was abusing and threatening that he would
take Chanda with him at all the consequences. At
about 01:30 AM when they were asleep accused
Suraj along with his brother Ajay and his sister
Laxmi (juvenile) again come to the house of
Chanda. There were loud noises and abuses being
hurled by the accused. Mother of PW2 went
upstairs to know the reasons as to why accused
was giving abuses. But accused Suraj and his sister
began abusing her too saying that "why she is
interfering". Despite many requests accused
persons did not stop. PW2 also went upstairs and
objected the accused. Thereafter, accused Ajay and
his sister Laxmi (juvenile) caught hold of PW2
Akash and accused Suraj caused knife blows to
PW2. In this scuffle PW3 Vidya also suffered knife
injury. Testimony of PW2 has duly been
corroborated by the testimonies of PW1 Ankit
Kumar, PW3 Vidya, PW5 Sunil Prasad and PW8
Phoolo Devi. All these witnesses have correctly
identified the accused persons as culprits who
caused knife injuries to the victims namely PW2
Akash and PW3 Vidya. MLCs of injured persons
namely PW2 Akash and PW3 Vidya have also been
proved on record vide deposition of PW7 Dr. Ajay
Sharma and MLC Ex. PW7/A (of injured Vidya) &
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
MLC Ex.PW7/B (of injured Akash). PW10 Dr.
Abhishek Gupta has opined the nature of injuries
sustained by Vidya as grievous and injuries
sustained by Akash as dangerous. Other witnesses
as well as police officials are formal in nature.
Taking all these facts and circumstances into
consideration, I am of the view that question arises
whether ingredients of section 307 IPC are met out
or not. Section 307 of IPC spells out about attempt
to murder. The act done by accused must be with
such intention or knowledge, and under such
circumstances that, if he by that act caused death,
he would be guilty of murder. In the case in hand,
it has categorically come on record in the
deposition of PW2 Akash that accused Suraj was
under the influence of liquor, meaning thereby that
he was not in his sound sense. Apart from this, it
has also come on record that the injuries were
caused to the injured persons with a vegetable
cutting knife, which indicates that weapon of
offence was not dangerous. Moreover, to prove
intention or knowledge for the offence u/s 307 IPC,
there must have been some connections of prior
meeting of mind to cause injuries to the victim
persons. Circumstances of the case clearly indicate
that victim persons themselves reached at the spot
to pacify the quarrel between accused Suraj and
his in-laws and at that time accused Suraj was
under the influence of liquor. Therefore, in these
facts and circumstances, I am of the view that
prosecution has miserably failed to prove the
ingredients of section 307 IPC that accused
persons had intention or knowledge to cause death
to the victims. However, it has categorically
proved on record that accused Suraj had caused
knife injuries on the persons of PW2 Akash and
PW3 Vidya and this act of accused persons was
done with such intention or knowledge and under
such circumstances that, if he by that act caused
death, he would be guilty of culpable homicide not
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
amounting to murder. Therefore, I am of the view
that prosecution has successfully proved its case
beyond reasonable doubt for the offence u/s 308 /
34 IPC precisely for the reasons that accused Ajay
and his sister caught hold of PW2 Akash and
accused Suraj gave knife blows to PW2 Akash
Jain. He has also caused knife blow injury to PW3
Vidya.”
Factual Matrix
3.
On 29th July, 2013 vide DD No. 6A and 7A, a call regarding an
incident which occurred on the intervening night of 28th and 29th July, 2013
at premises bearing No. WZ-421, Naraina Village, New Delhi was received
at P.S. Naraina, and FIR No. 173/2013 was registered.
4.
The Respondent No. 1, Suraj @ Sanjay (hereinafter, ‘Suraj’) was
married to Smt. Chanda in the year 2011 and had a minor son, who at the
time of incident was about 8/9 months old. As per the Prosecution case, on
28th July 2013, Suraj visited the house of his in-laws around 3 P.M. along
with his wife Smt. Chanda. At about 10 P.M., he insisted on taking his wife
back to the matrimonial home the same night. However, his father-in-law,
Sunil Prasad (PW-5), requested them to stay the night and leave early the
next morning, considering it was late at night and whatever food Suraj
wanted, would be cooked as per his wish, however, Suraj insisted on taking
Chanda along with him. Thereafter, Suraj demanded Rs.100 from Sunil
(PW-5), however, Sunil (PW-5) expressed his inability to give the same.
Suraj was given Rs. 100/- by his mother-in-law and thereafter, he went
outside to drink. Thereafter, he returned at about 10:30 P.M. and was
adamant to return to his house and at about 11-11:30 P.M., Suraj returned to
his house alone.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
5.
At about 1:30 A.M. on 29th July 2013, Sunil (PW-5) testified that
Suraj returned to the said premises along with his brother Respondent No.
2/Ajay (hereinafter ‘Ajay’) and his sister Laxmi, who was a juvenile at the
time and insisted on taking Chanda back to their residence and started
quarrelling. He further testified that upon hearing noises of the quarrel, the
neighbours residing at the lower floor of their residence, namely, Smt. Vidya
w/o Vijay Kumar and her kids, namely, Akash and Ankit, came out from
their residence and Smt. Vidya asked the Respondents not to abuse and
quarrel. This annoyed the Respondents and the Respondent Ajay and his
sister, Laxmi caught hold of Akash and Respondent Suraj took out a
vegetable knife, which he was carrying and stabbed the abdomen of Akash
and when Vidya tried to rescue her son, Respondent Suraj stabbed her also
and thereafter, when Laxmi tried to intervene in the scuffle, she also
received injuries on her mouth. Sunil (PW5) further deposed that both the
Respondents had also assaulted them with kicks and fists and in the
meantime Sunil’s (PW-5) another neighbour, Abhishek made a call at 100
number. The PCR came and both were handed over to the PCR Official.
Meanwhile, Akash was taken to hospital by Ankit (PW-1) using a borrowed
scooter and Vidya went on foot to the nearby hospital and thereafter after
receiving first aid, they were shifted to Deen Dayal Upadhyay Hospital,
New Delhi (hereinafter ‘DDU Hospital’). Meanwhile, Sunil along with his
daughter Chanda and his wife went to the police station and narrated the
facts to the police official present there.
6.
On the basis of the statement of Ankit Kumar (PW-1) recorded at the
hospital, a rukka was prepared and the present FIR was registered. The
investigation was initially conducted by SI Mukesh Rana (PW-13) and later
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
taken over by Inspector Rajesh Kumar. The site-plan was also prepared by
Rajesh Kumar (PW-16) at the instance of Ankit Kumar (PW-1).
7.
During the course of trial, the Prosecution examined 17 witnesses to
establish its case. The same has been reproduced hereinbelow:
“To prove and substantiate its case the prosecution
examined 17 witnesses namely PW1 Ankit Kumar eye witness; PW2 Akash Kumar - another eye
witness; PW3 Vidya - victim; PW4 HC Vijay
Singh - duty officer; PW5 Sunil Prasad - eye
witness of the incident; PW6 HC Radha Krishan formal witness being MHC(M) at PS Naraina;
PW7 Dr. Ajay Sharma, Medical Officer, DDU
hospital; PW8 Phoolo Devi - [mother in law of
accused Suraj] - another eye witness; PW9 Ms.
Chanda - wife of accused Suraj [she turned
hostile]; PW10 Dr Abhishek Gupta, Sr. Resident
Surgery, DDU hospital; PW11 HC Vikram Singh duty officer from 8 p.m. to 8 a.m. on intervening
night of 28/29.07.2013; PW12 SI Ami Chand formal witness he had taken injured persons to the
hospital on receipt of DD no.6A and 7A; PW13 SI
Mukesh Rana - initial IO of the case; PW13 Dr.
Abhishek - he gave the report on x-ray of Vidya;
PW15 Ct. Ram Raj - he joined in the investigation
with IO; PW16 Ins. Rajesh Kumar - 2nd IO Of the
case; and PW17 Ms. Monika Chakravarty, Sr.
Scientific Asstt. FSL, - formal witness.
8.
During investigation, both the Respondents Suraj and Ajay were
arrested on 29th July, 2013 vide their arrest and personal search memos
Ex.PW15/B, Ex.PW15/C, Ex.PW15/B-1 and Ex.PW15/C-1 respectively.
Their disclosure statement were recorded vide Ex.PW15/B-2 and
Ex.PW15/C-2 respectively. The third accused Lakshmi was found to be
Juvenile in conflict with law and accordingly ASI Manju was called from
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
the Police Station, and she carried out necessary proceedings against JCL
Lakshmi. It was found that the clothes which Respondent Suraj was wearing
were blood stained and were taken into possession by Ct. Ram Raj. Ct. Ram
Raj (PW-15) also took the blood stained clothes of JCL Laxmi into
possession with the assistance of Lady Ct. Komal. Separate proceedings qua
JCL Lakshmi were carried out which are not being repeated herein for the
sake of brevity. Thereafter, both the Respondents were produced in the court
and one day Police Custody remand was obtained for Respondent Suraj.
9.
On 7th October, 2013 the Exhibits were deposited in FSL Rohini and
the opinions pertaining to the nature of injuries on the MLC of Akash and
Vidya Devi were obtained. The MLC report of the victims, clearly opined
that the injuries sustained by Vidya were “grievous” in nature, whereas
those sustained by Akash were “dangerous”. The relevant portions of MLCs
Ex. PW10/A and Ex. PW10/B of both the victims is reproduced hereinbelow
for ease of reference:
MLC Ex. PW10/A of Vidya:
“As per MLC
Pt admitted in xxx 202 ↓ Dr. A K Mongia unit
for further management
Nature of injury -grevious”
MLC Ex. PW10/B of Akash
“As per MLC
Pt admitted in xxx 202 ↓ Dr. A K Mongia unit
for further management
Nature of injury- dangerous”
(emphasis supplied)
10.
The MLCs of the victims was supported by the deposition of Dr.
Abhishek Gupta (PW-10), Sr. Resident Surgery, DDU hospital. The ld. Trial
Court has discussed it as under: Signature Not Verified
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
“ 13. PW10 Dr. Abhishek Gupta had identified the
handwriting and signatures of Dr. Anupam, who
had examined Vidya and Akash on dated
29.07.2013. As per MLCs Ex.PW10/A and
Ex.PW10/B the opinion as to the nature of injuries
sustained by Vidya is grievous and the nature of
injuries as per the MLC of Akash is dangerous.”
11.
The MLCs of victims was further supported by the deposition of Dr.
Ajay Sharma (PW-7), Medical Officer, DDU Hospital. The ld. Trial Court
has discussed it as under: “10. PW7 Dr. Ajay Sharma, had identified the
handwriting and signature of Dr. Anurag, who had
examined Vidya brought to the hospital with
alleged history of physical assault and observed a
stab wound present over left side of chest lower
aspect and was referred to surgery emergency
after giving first aid. As per the MLC Ex.PW 7/A
the patient had suffered from sharp injuries. He
further identified the signatures and handwriting of
Dr. Sana Khanam, who had examined Akash, who
was brought to the hospital with alleged history of
physical assault and he observed a stab wound
present over just below umbilicus and right side of
back flank about hip joined and the patient was
referred to surgery emergency after giving first
aid. As per MLC Ex.PW7/B the patient has suffered
from sharp injuries. PW 7 Dr. Ajay Sharma, had
also identified the handwriting and signature of
Dr. Anurag, who had examined one Ajay who was
brought to the hospital with alleged history of
physical assault. As per MLC there was a CLW
right parital region and the patient was discharged
after giving first aid. As per the MLC Ex.PW7/C
the patient suffered from simple blunt injuries.”
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
12.
Both the Respondents had also sustained injuries during the quarrel,
and they were also medically examined in DDU Hospital. Charges were
framed by the Trial Court vide order on charge dated 9th January, 2014,
under Sections 307/34 IPC.
13.
After recording the prosecution evidence, statements of the
Respondents were recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., wherein they
pleaded innocence and stated that they have been falsely implicated. They
did not lead any evidence in their defence.
14.
After considering the evidence on record, the ld. Trial Court held that
the Prosecution had successfully proved its case beyond reasonable doubt
and converted the conviction of the Respondents under Sections 308/34 IPC
and released the Respondents on probation of good conduct and directed the
Respondents to furnish personal bond in the sum of Rs. l0,000/- each with
one surety in the like amount for 3 years subject to the condition that
Respondent Suraj shall pay Rs. l0,000/- and Respondent Ajay shall pay
Rs.5000/- as compensation, which is to be paid to the victims.
Submissions on Behalf of the Appellant/State
15.
Mr. Ashmeet Singh, ld. APP appearing for the State has vehemently
submitted that the charge under Sections 307/34 IPC, as originally framed,
stood fully proved beyond reasonable doubt. It is submitted that the
Prosecution case rests on cogent, unequivocal, consistent, and reliable
testimonies of material witnesses, namely Ankit Kumar (PW-1), Akash
Kumar (PW-2) (injured witness), Vidya (PW-3) (injured witness), Sunil
Prasad (PW-5), and Phoolo Devi (PW-8). The said witnesses have identified
the Respondents in Court as the perpetrators who inflicted knife injuries
upon the victims during the incident in question.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
16.
He submits that the ld. Trial Court errored in holding that, since Suraj
was under the influence of liquor at the relevant time, the said Respondent
neither harboured the requisite intention nor could knowledge be attributed
to him that the injuries were likely to cause the victim’s death. Intention,
being a non-corporeal faculty of the mind of the Respondent, is to be
gathered from the facts and circumstances, the Respondent having returned
to his wife’s parental home at 1:30 A.M. in the night, by premeditation
carrying a knife, and the situs and multiplicity of injuries on vital parts of the
body, establish the requisite intention to commit murder. Without prejudice,
Respondent Suraj is, at the very least, attributable with knowledge that
inflicting multiple stab injuries on vital parts was likely to cause death. He
further submits that the ld. Court erred in holding that Respondent Suraj,
being under the influence of liquor, was not in a sound state of his senses,
there being no material on record in support thereof. He submits that as per
law, a person acting in a state of intoxication shall be dealt with as though he
possessed the same knowledge as he would have possessed had he not been
intoxicated, unless such intoxication was without his knowledge or against
his will, which circumstance is wholly absent in the present case. The ld.
Trial Court, thus errored in extending the benefit of intoxication to the
Respondent on this count.
17.
Mr. Ashmeet Singh, places strong reliance upon the medical evidence
on record. He submits that the MLC report of the victims, clearly opined that
the injuries sustained by Vidya were “grievous” in nature, whereas those
sustained by Akash were “dangerous”. It is submitted that the situs of the
injuries and their number were not considered by the ld. Trial court in the
correct perspective while assessing what offence was made out in the facts
of the present case.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
18.
He further submits that the sentence awarded to the Respondents even
under Section 308 IPC was too lenient and wholly not in proportion with the
gravity and magnitude of the offence. The release of the convicts on
probation of good conduct is a wholly inadequate and inappropriate exercise
of discretion. The considerations weighed by the ld. Trial Court in awarding
a lighter sentence were not relevant to the question of sentencing. He further
submits that it is settled law that the sentence must be in proportion with the
gravity of the offence, which manifestly was not in the present case. No
adequate consideration was accorded to the perspective of the injured
victim, and the aspect of grant of compensation under Section 357 Cr.P.C.
has not been considered in its correct perspective or with the adequacy that
the provision demands.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondents
19.
Per Contra, Ms. Anu Narula, ld. Counsel for the Respondents,
submits that the incident dated 29th July 2013 arose out of a domestic dispute
at the parents’ home of Respondent No. 1’s wife, which escalated into a
sudden scuffle involving the wife’s parents, their neighbours and the
Respondents. She further submits that the incident was not pre-planned and
there was no prior animosity between the parties, and that the victims had
intervened in the dispute. She further submits that there was no intention on
the part of the Respondents to inflict injuries, and the incident occurred in
the heat of the moment.
20.
Further, Ms. Narula submits that Respondent No.1, Suraj, has
undergone nine months of incarceration, whereas Respondent No. 2, Ajay,
remained in judicial custody for about twelve days during the Trial, and that
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
the Respondents have already been subjected to detention and punishment to
a certain extent.
Analysis and Findings
21.
The Court has heard the parties and considered the matter.
22.
This Appeal raises an issue as to whether the conviction of the
Respondents under Sections 308/34, IPC, and their subsequent release on
probation by the ld. Trial Court is valid or not.
23.
Before going into the merits of the Appeal, it is necessary to set out
the statutory provisions which are to be considered. Sections 307 IPC and
308 IPC read as under:
“307. Attempt to murder.—Whoever does any act
with such intention or knowledge, and under such
circumstances that, if he by that act caused death,
he would be guilty of murder, shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to ten years, and shall also be
liable to fine; and if hurt is caused to any person
by such act, the offender shall be liable either to 1
[imprisonment for life], or to such punishment as is
hereinbefore mentioned.
308. Attempt to commit culpable homicide.—
Whoever does any act with such intention or
knowledge and under such circumstances that, if
he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of
culpable homicide not amounting to murder, shall
be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to three
years, or with fine, or with both; and, if hurt is
caused to any person by such act, shall be
punished with imprisonment of either description
for a term which may extend to seven years, or
with fine, or with both.”
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
24.
Sections 307 and 308 IPC are similar in the sense that both require
presence of intention or knowledge and consideration of the consequence
had the death ensued. The difference lies in the nature of the offence that
would follow.
25.
Under Section 307 IPC, the act must be such as would amount to
murder under Section 300 IPC. Whereas under Section 308 IPC, it would
fall short of murder by reason of circumstances which bring the case within
the exceptions to Section 300 IPC. The determination depends upon the
surrounding circumstances, including whether the act was premeditated or
had occurred during a sudden quarrel, the nature of the weapon used, the
part of the body targeted, the number of injuries inflicted and the manner in
which the assault took place.
26.
In the present case, the incident arose out of a sudden dispute between
Respondent No. 1 and his in-laws. There is no material on record to indicate
any prior enmity between the Respondents and the victims, namely Akash
(PW-2) and Vidya (PW-3). On the contrary, the evidence indicates that the
said victims were neighbours who had intervened only to pacify the
situation. Their presence at the spot was thus incidental and not pursuant to
any pre-existing animosity or planning.
27.
It is also not in dispute that Respondent Suraj was under the influence
of liquor at the time of the incident. While intoxication is no defence in law,
it is a relevant circumstance in assessing whether the act was premeditated
or had occurred in the course of a sudden altercation. Section 86 IPC
attributes knowledge notwithstanding intoxication, however, intention must
be gathered from the surrounding facts and circumstances. In the facts of the
present case, the conduct of Respondent Suraj appears to be a result of a
sudden escalation of a domestic dispute rather than a deliberate or planned
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
act. This distinction is well-supported by the Supreme Court’s reasoning in
Tukaram Gundu Naik v. State of Maharashtra, (1994) 1 SCC 465. The
relevant portion of the same is reproduced hereinbelow for ease of reference:
“7. …No doubt this witness was treated hostile but
his evidence would show that it was dark and there
was a scuffle. Further, the doctor's evidence would
show that none of the vital organs was injured.
Under these circumstances, a doubt arises whether
the accused intended to commit murder and thus
made an attempt. In our view the accused can be
attributed only knowledge that by inflicting such
injuries he was likely to cause death and an
attempt to commit such an offence would be one
punishable under Section 308 IPC. Section 308
lays down that such an offence is punishable with
imprisonment which may extend to three years or
with fine or with both and if hurt is caused, the
assailant can be punished with imprisonment of
either description which may extend to seven
years or with fine or with both.
8. Having given our earnest consideration and
having regard to the age of the appellant and the
suddenness in which the whole occurrence took
place during the scuffle, we are of the view that
the offence is one punishable under Section 308
IPC. Accordingly, we set aside the conviction of
the appellant under Section 307 IPC and sentence
of five years' RI awarded thereunder. Instead we
convict him under Section 308 IPC and sentence
him to undergo 1 1/2 years' RI and to pay a fine
of Rs 1000 in default of payment of which to
undergo further RI for three months. Accordingly
the appeal is partly allowed. The appellant, who is
on bail, shall surrender and serve out the
remaining period of sentence, if any."
(emphasis supplied)
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
28.
Respondent Suraj does not appear to be a dangerous or hardened
criminal but rather a person who acted under provocation during a sudden
quarrel. He was clearly swayed by emotions as he wanted his wife to
accompany him back to the matrimonial home-even in the middle of the
night. The parents of the wife suggested that she can go in the morning, and
this triggered the entire incident. The Supreme Court in Hari Kishan and
State of Haryana v. Sukhbir Singh, (1988) 4 SCC 551 has observed that
where offenders are not habitual criminals and the occurrence is the result of
a sudden flare up, the benefit of probation may be extended. The relevant
portion of the same is reproduced hereinbelow for ease of reference:
“8. …Many offenders are not dangerous criminals
but are weak characters or who have surrendered
to temptation or provocation. In placing such type
of offenders, on probation, the court encourages
their own sense of responsibility for their future
and protects them from the stigma and possible
contamination of prison. In this case, the High
Court has observed that there was no previous
history of enmity between the parties and the
occurrence was an outcome of a sudden flare up.
These are not shown to be incorrect. We have
already said that the accused had no intention to
commit murder of any person. Therefore, the
extension of benefit of the beneficial legislation
applicable to first offenders cannot be said to be
inappropriate.”
29.
The weapon used in the present case to commit the offence was a
vegetable cutting knife. There is no material on record to show that the same
was carried with any pre-planned intent to cause fatal injuries. The incident
occurred during a sudden scuffle when the neighbours intervened. There is
nothing on record to suggest that the Respondents had any intention to cause
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
the death of the victims or they had taken undue advantage of the situation.
Though the injuries have been described as grievous and dangerous by Dr.
Abhishek Gupta (PW-10), such medical opinion, while relevant, is not
conclusive of the intention or knowledge required under Section 307 IPC.
The intention has to be gathered from the totality of circumstances,
including the manner of assault and the surrounding facts.
30.
Having regard to the material on record, this Court concurs with the
finding of the ld. Trial Court that the ingredients of Section 307 IPC have
not been established beyond reasonable doubt. The act in question, having
occurred in the course of a sudden domestic altercation, without
premeditation, and without any prior enmity, would more appropriately fall
within the ambit of Sections 308/34 IPC. The view taken by the ld. Trial
Court is a plausible view based on appreciation of evidence and does not
suffer from any perversity or illegality warranting interference. Accordingly,
the conviction of the Respondents under Sections 308/34 IPC is upheld.
31.
On the question of sentence, it is noted that Respondent No. 1 Suraj
has undergone about nine months of incarceration, whereas Respondent No.
2 Ajay remained in judicial custody for a limited duration, about twelve
days, during the Trial. The incident arose out of a domestic dispute and no
prior criminal antecedents have been brought on record. The ld. Trial Court
has also directed payment of compensation to the victims, i.e., the
Respondent Suraj shall pay Rs. 10,000/- and Respondent Ajay shall pay Rs.
5000/-, which has already been deposited by the Respondents. The object of
the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 is to promote reformation and
rehabilitation of offenders who are not hardened criminals. The same has
been reiterated by the Supreme court in Lakhvir Singh v. State of Punjab,
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
(2021) 2 SCC 763. The relevant portion of the same is reproduced
hereinbelow for ease of reference:
“ 6. We may notice that the Statement of Objects
and Reasons of the said Act explains the rationale
for the enactment and its amendments: to give the
benefit of release of offenders on probation of good
conduct instead of sentencing them to
imprisonment. Thus, increasing emphasis on the
reformation and rehabilitation of offenders as
useful and self-reliant members of society without
subjecting them to the deleterious effects of jail life
is what is sought to be subserved.”
The sentence as awarded has already been undergone by the Respondents
and does not warrant interference.
Conclusion
32.
In view of the above discussion, the impugned judgment of conviction
and order of sentence is hereby upheld and the Appeal is dismissed.
33.
The directions regarding payment of compensation to the victims
shall remain in force.
34.
The Personal Bonds and Surety Bonds of the Respondents are
cancelled.
35.
Pending applications, if any, are also disposed of.
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
APRIL 24, 2026/Av
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 600/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review