Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 13th November, 2025
Pronounced on: 29th January, 2026
%
CRL.A.1595/2025
+
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State with
SI Mohan Lal.
versus
1. BHAGAT
S/o Sh. Narender Dev
R/o Village Kaniyan,
P.S. Kandhia, District Muzaffar Nagar,
Uttar Pradesh.
....Respondent No.1
2. ASHWANI KUMAR @ KAKA
S/o Darshan Kumar,
R/o Flat No. 923, PKT-7,
Sector-A-6, Narela,
Delhi.
....Respondent No.2
3. RAMBIR
S/o Sh. Harji Ram,
R/o E-184, Yadav Nagar,
P.S. S.P. Badli, Delhi.
....Respondent No.3
Through:
Mr. Vishesh Wadhwa, Mr. Jatin
Sharma, Mr. Hemant Singh and
Mr. Aditya Singh, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
1.
Criminal Appeal under Section 378(1) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 193 (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C.”) has been filed against
the Judgment dated 09.11.2020, whereby the learned Additional Sessions
Judge has acquitted the Respondents, namely, Bhagat, Ashwani Kumar @
Kaka, Rambir under Sections 328/392/397/411/34 Indian Penal Code, 1860
(hereinafter referred to as “IPC”) and 25/27/54/59 of the Arms Act, 1959
in FIR No. 0251/2013, P.S. Alipur.
2.
The brief facts are that the Complainant/Injured, Shatrughan
Prasad, used to drive his own Champion vehicle bearing registration
number DL 1LJ 5485 and load copper from Damodar Park, Shahdara and
unload it at the Factory at 2057, I-Block, Narela, Delhi.
3.
On 28.05.2013, he left his house and got the copper loaded from
Damodar Park, in his Champion vehicle and was heading towards Narela.
As he reached near Nanagali Puna, Lower GT Karnal Road, a “golden” car
which was coming from behind, started blowing the horn, on which he gave
a signal to the vehicle to pass. The said golden car after crossing the
Champion vehicle of the Complainant, suddenly stopped in front of his
vehicle and three boys came out while the driver remained sitting in the
golden car.
4.
All the three persons were armed with pistols in their hands and they
pulled him out of his Champion. The Accused Rambir caught hold of his
collar, while the Accused Bhagat Singh caught hold of his left hand with
his one hand and put the pistol on the left side of his chest. The third
Accused, Ashwini caught hold of his right hand and put the pistol on the
right side of his head. They all pushed him in the golden car and made him
lie down in the car and they sat on him. The Accused persons forcibly made
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
him drink maaza. After 5 to 7 minutes, he became unconscious and regained
his consciousness in the hospital at Pooth Kalan.
5.
According to the Prosecution, on 28.05.2013 at about 08:21 AM, a
PCR call was received about kidnapping of an auto wala by vehicle No. DL
2 CAD 6039 and DD No. 10A was recorded. It was informed by the caller
that he had seen 3-4 persons come in the said car. Inspector Sudeep Punia
along with Constable Bhagwan Lal reached near nala, Buddhpur Village,
but he found neither the caller nor the eyewitness present.
6.
During investigations, it was found that the kidnapped person was
admitted in Maharishi Valmiki Hospital, Pooth Khurd. Inspector Sudeep
Punia along with Constable Bhagwan Lal, went to the Hospital wherein the
Doctor mentioned in the MLC about consumption of some unknown
substance. The injured was declared unfit for statement and the Doctor
informed that the injured had consumed some stupefying substance. There
was no external injury on the body of the injured. The MLC was collected
by the I.O. In view of the MLC, offence under Section 365/328 IPC was
registered.
7.
During the investigation, the statement of the injured was recorded.
The stolen Champion vehicle of the Complainant was recovered on
26.06.2013. The Accused Rambir was arrested in FIR No. 0184/2013
under Section 332/353/307 IPC and 25/54/59 Arms Act, in which he made
a disclosure statement about his involvement in the present case.
8.
On 29.06.2013, the I.O. collected the documents and DD No. 11A
P.S. Narela regarding the arrest of co-accused, Ashwini @ Kaka and Bhagat.
On 28.07.2013, the I.O. formally arrested the Accused persons, namely,
Rambir, Bhagat and Ashwini with the permission of the Court.
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
9.
On 19.07.2013, Accused Hasmuddin was arrested on the disclosure
of the other accused persons. On 23.07.2013, he was released for want of
any concrete evidence.
10.
Accused Rambir got recovered the RC of the vehicle No. DL 8CN
6585 and DL of Priyanka. Accused Bhagat got recovered original RC of DL
1LJ 5485, Certificate of Fitness, Cylinder Test Report and Insurance Papers
from his residence.
11.
The site plan of the place of recovery was prepared and Section 411
IPC was added.
12.
The investigations were completed after which the Chargesheet
was filed under Sections 328/392/394/397/411/34 IPC and 25/27/54/59
Arms Act, in the Court of learned MM. After the FSL result was obtained
and the permission under Section 39 Arms Act was given, the
supplementary Chargesheet was filed.
13.
The charges under Sections 365/328/394/34 IPC were framed
against the accused Bhagat, Ashwini Kumar @ Kaka and Rambir. An
additional charge of Section 394 read with Section 397 was framed against
the Accused Rambir, to which they all pleaded not guilty.
14.
The Prosecution in support of its case, examined 24 witnesses in
total.
15.
The Complainant, Shatrughan Prasad was examined as PW-1 who
proved his Complaint.
16.
PW-2, Ved Prakash was the owner of the Champion vehicle who
had made a call to the PCR at No. 100.
17.
PW-3, Ravinder was the Supervisor of the factory where the
Complainant used to deliver the goods.
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
18.
PW-6, Deepak Chawla was the owner of the stolen golden car
(Verna car) which was released to him on superdarinama, Ex. PW-6/A. The
RC of the car and the DL of his daughter Priyanka Chawla were recognized
by him and exhibited as PW-6/B and C.
19.
PW-10, Sachin Gupta, MM, proved the TIP proceedings of the
Accused Bhagat, Ashwini Kumar @ Kaka and Rambir as Ex. PW-10/B, C
and D.
20.
The PW-12, Insp. Karamvir Singh, had arrested the accused
Rambir in FIR No. 0184/2013 and had recorded the disclosure statement Ex.
PW-12/A.
21.
The investigations were undertaken by PW-7, HC Jasbir Singh, PW-
11 Ct. Ashok, PW-13 Ct. Subhash, PW-16 Ct. Shankar, PW-17 HC Vishnu
and the I.O. PW-23 Inspector Sandeep Punia had joined the investigation
with the IO at different stages of investigation.
22.
PW-24, Dr. Linga Raj Sahoo, proved the FSL Report, while the
MLC of the Complainant was proved by PW-4 Dr. Hakim Ali Qanoon,
M.B. Hospital, Pooth Khurd, Delhi.
23.
The learned ASJ considered the entire prosecution evidence with
special emphasis on evidence of the Complainant, PW-1 to observe that the
Complainant had not seen the car number of the alleged golden Verna, used
for committing the offence by the Accused persons. Though he corroborated
about the incident of having been administered the maaza, but he further
stated that he lost consciousness and regained it in the hospital at Pooth
Kalan. He was unable to give the details of the incident or identify the
Accused.
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
24.
Insofar as recovery of Champion vehicle was concerned, the
testimony of PW-8, SI Satish Kumar Pandey and PW-11, Ct. Ashok and PW15, HC Manoj Kumar was considered and held that the recovery of the
Champion vehicle, was not pursuant to the disclosure statement of any
Accused person or at their instance. Mere recovery of Champion vehicle at
some unknown place, could not be linked to the Accused persons. Insofar as
evidence in regard to the identification of the Accused persons, reference
was made to the testimony of PW-1 who had deposed that after about 25
days, he went to P.S. Alipur and had identified the Accused persons. Such
identification after 25 days of the alleged incident, was disbelieved.
25.
After appreciation of the entire evidence, it was held that there was
no incriminating evidence against the Accused persons, who were given the
benefit of doubt and were acquitted.
26.
Aggrieved by the said acquittal of the Respondents, the State has
preferred the present Appeal on the grounds that the testimony of the
Complainant as PW-1, who was the most material witness, has not been
appreciated in the correct perspective.
27.
The incident of robbery was reported to the PCR on which DD No.
10A was recorded. The subsequent admission of injured in the hospital,
corroborated the contents of DD No.10A about a person having been
kidnapped. The testimony of Complainant was fully supported by the Police
officials. There were no material contradictions in the testimony of the
Complainant or the other Police witnesses. PW-2, Ved Prakash had proved
that the Number plates of his Accent car bearing No. DL 2CAD 6039 had
been stolen from outside his house, on 26.05.2013 which had been
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
subsequently used by the Accused persons, on the vehicle used at the time of
incident.
28.
PW-6, Deepak Chawla had duly proved that this car had been stolen
from the possession of his driver Rinku, in respect of which FIR No.
215/2013 under Section 392 IPC had been registered. The documents of the
vehicle were subsequently recovered, at the instance of Accused Rambir.
29.
The recovery of the documents of vehicle bearing No. DL 1LJ 5485,
i.e. Champion vehicle was recovered at the instance of accused Bhagat
which has again not been considered.
30.
The identification by the Complainant of the Accused persons, was
done in the Police Station since the Accused had refused to get their TIP
done. All three Accused had refused to join the judicial TIP and were
subsequently identified by the Complainant in the Police Station. He, in his
testimony, duly identified the Respondents.
31.
PW-24, Dr. Linga Raj Sahoo had proved that the gastric lavage of
the Complainant was found containing Lorazepam, which corroborates the
statement of the Complainant of being compelled to drink stupefying maaza.
32.
The oral and documentary evidence as adduced by the Prosecution,
proved the case beyond reasonable doubt. The Respondents have been
wrongly acquitted.
33.
The prayer is, therefore, made that the judgment of acquittal dated
09.11.2020 be set aside and the Respondents be convicted and sentenced.
Submissions heard and record perused.
34.
The Respondents had been charged for the offence under Section
365/34 IPC for having kidnapped the Complainant/Shatrughan and
administering him with some stupefying substance and thereby committing
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
offence under Section 328/34 IPC. While committing robbery of the Tempo
Champion and his purse containing Rs.5,200/- and other documents, they
had caused hurt to him and thereby committed offence under Section 392/34
IPC.
35.
The first aspect for consideration is regarding the vehicles
involved in the commission of the alleged offence.
36.
The first star witness of the Prosecution was PW-1, Shatrughan
Prasad, who had deposed that on the date of incident i.e. 28.05.2013, after
getting his Tempo Champion loaded with the copper from Damodar Park,
Shahdara, he was enroute to deliver the goods at Narela. At about 07:00 PM
while he was driving the Champion, he was waylaid by a golden vehicle
from which three persons came out and at the gunpoint abducted him and
put him on the floor of the car. They administered stupefying substance
maaza to him because of which he became unconscious. On gaining reconsciousness, he found himself at hospital at Pooth Kalan.
37.
Though, the witness was cross-examined but nothing contradictory
emerged in his cross-examination.
38.
Pertinently, some third person, who was a witness to the incident of
abduction, was a witness to the incident and called the PCR on which DD
No. 10A, Ex.PW-9/A, was recorded by PW-9, Head Constable, Shivendra
Pal. The said DD recorded that the Wireless Operation came to the Duty
Officer Room and informed that one vehicle No. DL 2CAD 6039 has
kidnapped the autowala near a Nala, Budhpur Gaon, ahead of Alipur.
39.
The testimony of the Complainant that he was kidnapped, is thus
confirmed from the immediate information that was conveyed and recorded
at about 08:21 AM on 28.05.2013. Though the informant could not be
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
traced, but the number of the Car in which the kidnappers were travelling,
got confirmed.
40.
PW-6, Deepak Chawla, owner of this vehicle DL 8CN 6585, which
was used by the offenders, deposed that in the evening hours of 11.05.2013,
his nephew, Gaurav had borrowed his Verna vehicle for some urgent work.
On 12.05.2013, he was informed that the vehicle has been robbed from the
possession of his driver. FIR No. 215/2013 under Section 392 IPC was
registered at P.S. Alipur.
41.
PW-6 further deposed that he got information from the Police that his
car has been recovered. He along with his nephew, Gaurav went to the
Police Station Alipur where they found the car standing from which the RC
and the DL of his daughter, Priyanka Chawla, was recovered. He got the
vehicle released on superdari.
42.
While PW-6, the owner of Verna car, had identified the Car in the
Police Station where it was parked after recovery, but there is no evidence
whatsoever of how and from where this Verna car was recovered. The
Charge-Sheet is absolutely silent in this regard and even PW-23, Inspector
Sudeep Punia, the Investigating Officer has not deposed a word about the
recovery of this Verna Car.
43.
In this context, it may be pertinent to refer to testimony of PW-2, Ved
Prakash, who had deposed that on 26.05.2013 while his vehicle DL 2CAD
6039 was parked outside, in the morning, he found the number plates of the
vehicle stolen, about which he had made a PCR Call.
44.
What thus, emerges is that the golden vehicle used in the commission
of the offence, had the actual number of DL 8CN 6585, but at the time of
commission of the offence, the number plate No. DL 2C AD 6039 was
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
installed, which were stolen from another vehicle. The DD No.10A gave the
number as 6039.
45.
There is again a huge lacuna as to how the Verna car has been traced
as the offending vehicle, when it had the stolen number plates. The
involvement of this Verna car, which is claimed to be the offending vehicle,
has not been explained in the entire Prosecution story. All that has emerged,
is that one car, in which the four offenders were present, had been used by
them for committing the offence of abduction.
46.
The next aspect of relevance is the identification and arrest of the
accused persons.
47.
PW-23, Inspector Sudeep Punia has deposed that on 28.06.2013, he
received information from the P.S. Kundli that they have arrested one person
Rambir in FIR No. 184/2013 P.S. Kundli wherein he had made a
disclosure about his involvement in the present case. The Investigating
Officer formally arrested Rambir, in the present Case.
48.
Further, PW-23 has deposed that on 29.06.2013, he received
information from SI Mahabir Singh of P.S. Narela, regarding the arrest of
Accused, Bhagat Singh and Ashwani Kumar @ Kaka in FIR No.
424/2013 wherein they both made a disclosure about their involvement in
the present case. These two accused were also formally arrested in the
present FIR.
49.
The question which thus, confronts the Prosecution, is to establish the
identity of these three Accused. Pertinently, the Application for getting the
TIP proceedings conducted of the three accused persons, who were
produced in the court in muffled face, but they all refused to participate in
the TIP proceedings. Thereafter, as per the testimony of I.O., the three
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
Accused were identified by the Complainant in the Police Station on
23.07.2013. The I.O. explained in his cross-examination that he got the three
accused identified from the Complainant in the Police Station, as the three
accused had refused to get their TIP conducted.
50.
In this context, it would be relevant to note that the alleged incident
had happened on 28.05.2013 at about 07:30 PM, while their identification
was done in the Police Station on 23.07.2013 i.e. after nearly two months.
The Complainant had also not given any description of the accused persons.
It is difficult to comprehend how he was able to identify them after about
two months and that too in the Police Station. The identification of the three
accused by the Complainant is, therefore, not beyond suspicion.
51.
The next significant aspect is the alleged recoveries made from the
three Accused.
52.
PW-23, Inspector Sudeep Punia had deposed that during the police
custody remand, Accused Bhagat had led the police team to the house of
Sunil Kumar, Tika Ram Colony, Kundli and from Room No. 10, he got
recovered the RC of vehicle bearing No. DL 1LJ 5485 i.e. the Champion
(which was being driven by the Complainant), Fitness Certificate, Cylinder
Test Report and insurance, which was seized vide Memo Exhibit PW-16/D1.
53.
Some glaring aspects emerge; firstly, the recovery is from the house
of Sunil Kumar and not from the house of Accused Bhagat. Secondly, the
recovery from the house of Sunil Kumar, at the instance of Accused Bhagat,
may impute his knowledge about the documents being in the house of Sunil
Kumar, but it cannot be held beyond reasonable doubt that the said
documents were in his possession or that were recovered from his
possession. It has not been explained as to who this Sunil Kumar was and
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
what connection he had with Bhagat Singh and why were the documents in
the house of Sunil Kumar instead of Bhagat Singh.
54.
It is also worth mentioning that while the vehicle Champion had been
recovered abandoned by SI Satish, P.S. Alipur on 02.06.2013, is not
explained as to how the documents came in the possession of Accused
Bhagat. Moreover, it is highly unlikely that while abandoning the Champion
vehicle, the documents would be conveniently taken out to show them as
recovered at the behest of Accused Bhagat. The documents have no
monetary value and the recovery so shown to have been made by Bhagat
Singh, leads to only one inference that these documents have been planted
only to establish some incriminating evidence against the Accused Bhagat.
The alleged recovery of the documents of Champion vehicle at the instance
of Accused Bhagat, is highly improbable and lacks complete prudence. The
recovery cannot be held to have been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
55.
Likewise, PW-23, Inspector Sudeep Punia, while Accused Rambir
was on police remand, pursuant to his disclosure, took him to Sighu Village
near water tank and he got recovered the documents pertaining to Vehicle
No. DL 8CN 6585 i.e. RC, Driving License in the name of Priyanka, which
was seized vide Memo Ex.PW-16/C.
56.
Again, it is in comprehendible as to why innocuous documents like
RC and DL, would be stolen by the Accused or by hidden by him in a Water
Tank in Sighu Village, especially when such documents have no monetary
value. As noted above, it is evident that the recovery of documents has been
planted, only to collect some incriminating evidence against Rambir so as to
link him with the present offence.
57.
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
There is admittedly no recovery from the Accused Ashwani.
CRL.A.1595/2025
58.
Aside from this alleged recovery of documents from Rambir and
Bhagat, which is held to be not genuine, there is not an iota of evidence
against any of the three Accused.
59.
The last aspect is the inconsistency in the testimony of PW-
1/Complainant and PW-23/Inspector Sudeep Punia.
60.
The learned ASJ has rightly referred to the testimony of PW-
1/Complainant, who deposed on 13.10.2014 that
after
regaining
consciousness in the hospital, he went back to the factory where police
officials met him and took him to P.S. Alipur. Such conduct of PW-1 is
inherently improbable. A person who has just regained consciousness after
being kidnapped and administered a stupefying substance, would naturally
return to his home to inform his family about his well-being and safety,
rather than proceed directly to the factory. No explanation has been offered
for this unusual conduct.
61.
Furthermore, the Complainant deposed that he had left the hospital
without intimating the doctors or police officials, which is corroborated by
the endorsement on MLC, Ex.PW-4/A. It defies logic that a victim who had
suffered the trauma of kidnapping and forcible administration of drugs,
would abscond from the hospital without informing the police or seeking
their assistance.
62.
As per the testimony of PW-23, Inspector Sudeep Punia, he went to
the house of the Complainant, after two days i.e. on 30.05.2013, when he
recorded the Statement of the Complainant. Here also, it is not
understandable as to what prevented the Investigating Officer to
immediately contact the Complainant on getting information in the hospital
that the injured had been admitted in the Hospital. Pertinently, PW-23 had
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
deposed that when he reached the hospital, he found the victim in
unconscious state of mind. He remained in the Hospital for about two hours
and thereafter, left the Hospital at about 12:15 PM. There is no clarity of
when the Complainant gained consciousness and when he left the Hospital.
63.
As per the endorsement on the MLC, the Complainant had left on the
same night i.e. on 28.05.2013. There are material contradictions in the
manner of conducting the investigations, which does not inspire much
confidence. Definitely, it cannot be said that the case of the Prosecution, has
been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Conclusion:
64.
From the aforesaid discussion, it is evident that the Prosecution failed
to prove its case against the Accused/Respondents beyond reasonable doubt.
The learned ASJ correctly appreciated the lacunae in the evidence and
rightly gave the benefit of doubt to the Respondents. There is no infirmity in
the impugned Judgment warranting interference by this Court.
65.
The Appeal is therefore, dismissed. Pending Application(s), if any,
are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 29, 2026
N/RS
KUMAR BHATT
16:45:13
CRL.A.1595/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review