The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. With this observation, petition is allowed and stands disposed of.” A plain reading of the impugned judgment and order reveals that the learned Single Judge, while issuing directions as contained in the impugned judgment and order, failed to take into consideration a relevant fact that the respondent/writ petitioner himself had volunteered to refund the amount of Rs.5,38,297/- by means of making payment in monthly instalments @Rs.5000/-, even before the concerned Deputy Commissioner had directed deduction of a sum of Rs.20,000/- per month from the salary of the respondent/writ petitioner. The actual reason why a sum of Rs.20,000/- per month was required to be deducted from the salary of the respondent/writ petitioner, in terms of the direction of the Deputy Commissioner, is apparent from the brief facts of the case, as stated hereinbefore. It was clearly the responsibility of the family of the deceased (being the father of the respondent/writ petitioner) to have paid a sum of Rs.5,38,297/- to NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati, after having received the same amount from the State of Meghalaya on account of reimbursement for medical treatment rendered to the late father of the respondent/writ petitioner, who succumbed to burn injuries at NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati, where he was being treated. That apart, the learned Single Judge, without any basis whatsoever, increased the ex-gratia pay…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.04
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.6/2019
Date of Order: 25.02.2021
State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Vs.
Sanjay Das
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H Abraham, GA
: None
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The instant writ appeal has been preferred by the State of
Meghalaya against the judgment and order rendered by a learned Single
Judge on 26th February, 2019 in WP (C) No.24 of 2018 (Shri Sanjay Das
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors).
The respondent/writ petitioner remains unrepresented at the time
of call.
In order to avoid prolixity, the impugned judgment and order is
setout hereinbelow in its entirety:“1. Heard Mr. S.C.Chakrawarty, learned Sr. counsel assisted by
Mr. J.Tigga, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner as well as
Mr. H.Abraham, learned GA on behalf of the respondents.
The brief facts of the case is that:
“In the month of November, 2013, while the state of
Meghalaya was witnessing a movement for the
implementation of Inner Line permit (ILP) the father of the
Petitioner, Late Bisheswar Das, was a victim of arson,
having been subjected to physical attack by way of being
burnt with petrol.
The late father of the Petitioner succumbed to his burnt
injuries at NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati, where he was
being treated. The Government of Meghalaya had taken
the liability to bear all the financial expenses that would be
incurred for the late father of the Petitioner. The father of
the Petitioner succumbed to the injuries on 04.12.2013 at
Guwahati.
On 24.10.2014, Officials of the Office of the Deputy
Commissioner, East Khasi Hills District, Shilong visited the
mother of the Petitioner and handed over 2 cheques
amounting to Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh) only and
Rs. 5,38,297/- (Rupees Five Lakh Thirty Eight Thousand
Two Hundred Ninety Seven) only to the mother of the
Petitioner.
The mother of the Petitioner was never informed that the
cheque amounting to Rs. 5,38,297/- (Rupees Five Lakh
Thirty Eight Thousand Two Hundred Ninety Seven) only
was to be paid to NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati, while
handing over the same.
Sometime during the month of February 2017, the
Petitioner was called upon by the Office of the Deputy
Commissioner and to his utter shock was directed upon to
return the sum of Rs. 5,38,297/- (Rupees Five Lakh Thirty
Eight Thousand Two Hundred Ninety Seven) only or pay
the same to NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati.
The Petitioner, on expressing inability to return the said
amount, immediately volunteered to pay the said amount on
a monthly installment basis at the rate of Rs. 5000/(Rupees Five Thousand) only, on which the Deputy
Commissioner directed the Commandant to deduct a sum of
Rs. 20,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand) only per month
from the salary of the Petitioner.
The Petitioner is employed as a Guardsman, Border Wing
Home Guard Battalion, Meghalaya, Shillong and draws a
monthly take home salary of less than Rs. 28,000/- (Rupees
Twenty Eight Thousand) only and has 6 dependants upon
him. The deduction of Rs. 20000/- (Rupees Twenty
Thousand) only, per month shall subject the Petitioner and
his family to dire financial constraints for survival.
The directive issued by the Deputy Commission is bad in
law, arbitrary and against the principles of natural
justice.”
2. Learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner submits that the ex-gratia
payment made to the petitioner is inadequate though a separate
cheque was given to the victim’s wife for medical expenditure to
the tune of Rs. 5,38,297/- (Rupees Five lakhs, thirty-eight
thousand, two hundred and ninety seven) only, without informing
the victim’s wife i.e. the mother of the petitioner. He also submits
that the income of the petitioner is hardly Rs. 20,000/- (Rupees
Twenty thousand) only and it is very difficult to survive with this
amount as the petitioner had also lost his shop.
3. On the other hand, Mr. H.Abraham, learned State counsel
submits that the ex-gratia payment to the victim’s family at the
tune of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One lakh) only, was sufficient
because in addition to that, medical expenses was also given at the
tune of Rs. 5,38,297/- (Rupees Five lakhs, thirty-eight thousand,
two hundred and ninety seven) only.
4. After hearing the submission advanced by the learned counsels
for the parties, I am not inclined to accept the submission
advanced by the learned State counsel. I have also given an
opportunity to the State to rethink and settle the matter by giving
proper compensation vide my order dated 14-11-2018. However,
nothing concrete has come up. Therefore, taking into
consideration the fact that the victim died for no fault of his as he
was sitting in his shop and some goons or miscreants came,
poured petrol and set fire to the victim.
5. I make it clear that to maintain law and order is the sacred duty
of the government and they are to secure safety to each and every
citizen of this country. Therefore, they just cannot wash their
hands by giving Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees One lakh) only and some
medical expenses.
6. Therefore, considering the principle of natural justice, principle
welfare state and considering the fact that the victim died due to
law and order problem caused by some miscreants, his family
members should not suffer. It is appropriate that the government
should pay Rs 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten lakhs) only, minus Rs.
1,00,000/- (Rupees One lakh) only which was already paid and
the medical expenses which was given is to be waived off.
7. Therefore, government is directed to pay another Rs 9,00,000/(Rupees nine lakhs) only to the victim’s family and not to press
for recovery of the medical expenses from the salary of the
petitioner. Payment to be made within 2(two) months from the
date of this order.
8. With this observation, petition is allowed and stands disposed
of.”
A plain reading of the impugned judgment and order reveals that
the learned Single Judge, while issuing directions as contained in the
impugned judgment and order, failed to take into consideration a
relevant fact that the respondent/writ petitioner himself had volunteered
to refund the amount of Rs.5,38,297/- by means of making payment in
monthly instalments @Rs.5000/-, even before the concerned Deputy
Commissioner had directed deduction of a sum of Rs.20,000/- per
month from the salary of the respondent/writ petitioner. The actual
reason why a sum of Rs.20,000/- per month was required to be deducted
from the salary of the respondent/writ petitioner, in terms of the
direction of the Deputy Commissioner, is apparent from the brief facts
of the case, as stated hereinbefore. It was clearly the responsibility of the
family of the deceased (being the father of the respondent/writ
petitioner) to have paid a sum of Rs.5,38,297/- to NEMCARE Hospital,
Guwahati, after having received the same amount from the State of
Meghalaya on account of reimbursement for medical treatment rendered
to the late father of the respondent/writ petitioner, who succumbed to
burn injuries at NEMCARE Hospital, Guwahati, where he was being
treated.
That apart, the learned Single Judge, without any basis
whatsoever, increased the ex-gratia payment to the victim’s family from
Rs.1 lakh to a sum of Rs.10 lakhs. The learned Single Judge in paragraph-6
of the impugned judgment and order invoked the principle of natural
justice, principle of welfare state and issued a direction upon the
Government to pay Rs.10 lakhs minus Rs.1 lakh (which was already paid)
and the medical expenses to be waived off. Such a direction was issued by
the learned Single Judge notwithstanding the fact that the respondent/writ
petitioner himself had agreed to pay monthly instalments @5000/-, which
was required to be deducted from his salary. In paragraph-7 of the
impugned judgment and order, the Government after being directed to pay
another Rs. 9 lakhs to the victim’s family was further directed not to press
for recovery of medical expenses from the salary of the respondent/writ
petitioner.
In our view, on a plain reading of the impugned judgment and
order, it is clearly evident that it suffers from palpable infirmities and
perversities since Article 226 of the Constitution of India does not permit
any writ Court to issue directions on such ad hoc basis, which are clearly
not in accordance with law.
In the facts of the instant case, such ad hoc directions for payment
to be made out by the State of Meghalaya in favour of the respondent/writ
petitioner as well as the victim’s family are not supported by any firm legal
basis or following any well-established Constitutional principles, which
could be applied in the facts of the instant case. We, therefore, have no
hesitation to set aside the impugned judgment and order dated 26 th
February, 2019 and dismiss the writ petition holding the same to be devoid
of any merit or substance.
The writ appeal is accordingly allowed and miscellaneous
application, being MC (WA) No.13 of 2019, stands disposed of.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
25.02.2021
“Lam AR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review