The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. By promotion from amongst the Grade IV = 23 posts = 3 posts = 3 posts Out of the 3 (three) posts as per the quota for the Typists, 2 (two) are the existing vacancies due to superannuation of the previous incumbents and 1 (one) vacancy resulting from the above recommendation for promotion, the Committee therefore, after scrutinizing the documents of all the incumbents in the select list, recommended Smti Sukmondoris Sohlang, Smti Salibon Muthoh and Smti Daritimai Lyngdoh for promotion to the 3 (three) vacant posts of Lower Division Assistant from the quota of Typists.” On 23rd June, 2021, the same DPC reversed the promotion of the respondent and reverted her to the original post by the following resolution: 2025:MLHC:311-DB “It was also brought to the notice of the Committee that the recommendation of the previous DPC meeting held on the 30 th November, 2020 needs to be reviewed. It may be mentioned that as per decision of the earlier DPC meeting, Smti Daritimai Lyngdoh was recommended for promotion to the post of Lower Division Assistant from the quota of Typist as per provision of Rule 9(2) of the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial) Service Rules, 2010. However, provision as laid down in the Government’s OM No.SAE.178/86/211-A dated 16.03.2006 was not referred to. As laid down in the OM above, at 5(a) and (c), a typist who opts for Grade System shall not be eligi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:311-DB
Serial No.01
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.68/2024 with
MC (WA) No.68/2024
Date of CAV
: 04.04.2025
Date of pronouncement : 23.04.2025
1. The State of Meghalaya, represented by the Secretary to the Government
of Meghalaya Public (Road & Buildings) Department, Meghalaya.
2. The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads), Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3. The Assistant Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads),
Meghalaya, Shillong.
….. Appellants
Vs.
Smti. Daritimai Lyngdoh
Coram:
..... Respondent
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
For the Respondent
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA
: Mr. S. Sen, Adv with
Ms. E. Blah, Adv
F
2025:MLHC:311-DB
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
No
Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the
composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting
this judgment/order.
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This is an appeal from a judgment and order dated 31 st July, 2024
made by a learned single judge of this Court in the exercise of his writ
jurisdiction allowing the writ petition.
The State of Meghalaya is in appeal before us from that judgment
and order.
The facts shortly are these. The respondent was appointed as typist
(Grade-III) by a regular selection process through the Meghalaya Public
Service Commission (MPSC). On 1st December, 1989, she joined service in
the office of the Chief Engineer, PWD (Roads) Meghalaya, Shillong.
The Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) at its meeting held
on 30th November, 2020 recommended her to be promoted to the post of
2025:MLHC:311-DB
Lower Division Assistant (LDA). Accordingly, on 10th December, 2020, she
was so promoted and joined the post. Incidentally, prior to this she had
appeared for a speed test in typing but failed to qualify.
Great disappointment was caused to her by the office order dated
2nd July, 2021 by which she was reverted to her original post. The reason
advanced was that the promotion had been effected by mistake not having
considered the Office Memorandum dated 16th March, 2006. This Office
Memorandum provided that a typist who opted for the grade system would
not be eligible for the post of LDA.
At this stage, enumeration of the relevant rules is very important.
First, the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial) Service rules,
2010 is reproduced below:
Rule-9 (unamended)
“9. Lower Division Assistant: Appointment to the post of L.D.
Assistant shall be made:
(1) By direct recruitment on the result of the competitive
examination conducted by the Commission.
(2) By selection on the basis of merit from amongst Typists of the
respective Directorate who have rendered not less than 4 years of
continuous service on the first day of the year in which the
selection is made.
2025:MLHC:311-DB
(3) By selection on the basis of merit from amongst the Grade IV
staff of the respective office who have passed the H.S.L.C.
examination or any examination declared equivalent thereto and
have rendered not less than 7 years of continuous service on the
first day of the year in which selection is made.
(4) The quota to be filled up in the cadre of Lower Division
Assistant in any year accordingly to sub-rules (1), (2) and (3) above
shall be in the ratio of 8:1:1 respectively. This means that 80
percent of recruitment of Lower Division Assistants shall be by
direct recruitment, 10 percent by selection from amongst the
Typists and 10 percent by selection from amongst the Grade IV
staff. In the event of sufficient qualified or suitable persons not
being available in either of categories (2) or (3), the balance shall
be made up from category (1), i.e., through direct recruitment. The
quota shall be determined on the basis of strength of staff both
permanent and temporary in the Lower Division Assistant cadre.”
Rule 11 as amended on 05.12.2012
“Rule 11 (1) Typist (Grade-III) – Appointment to the post of Typist
(Grade III) shall be made by direct recruitment on the result of the
competitive examination conducted by the Commission.
(2) Typist (Grade II) – Typist with minimum 3 (three) years of
qualifying service in Grade III shall be eligible for appearing the
Speed Test of 45 words per minute to be conducted by the
Meghalaya Public Service Commission and their placement in the
Grade shall be subject to passing the Speed Test.
(3) Typist (Grade I) – Typist with minimum 3 (three) years of
qualifying service in Grade II shall be eligible for appearing the
Speed Test of 60 words per minute to be conducted by the
Meghalaya Public Service Commission and their placement in the
Grade shall be subject to passing the Speed Test.”
2025:MLHC:311-DB
The Office Memorandum dated 16th March, 2006 is also
reproduced below:
“GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
SECRETARIAT ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT
ESTABLISHMENT BRANCH
No.SAE.178/86/211
Subject:
Dated Shillong, the 16th March, 2006.
Promotion Scheme for Typist.
The undersigned is directed to say that in pursuance of
the Government decision on the Recommendation of the 3rd
Meghalaya Pay Commission, announce in Resolution
No.F(PR.150/98/7), dated 21.12.1998, the Governor of Meghalaya
is pleased to decide placement of Typist into 3 (three) grades as
indicated below:
1. (a) Typist Grade I: Rs.4250-110-4910-EB-120-5870-130-7170/- PM
(b) Typist Grade II: Rs.3725-90-4265-EB-100-5065-110-6165/-PM
(c) Typist Grade III: Rs.3100-70-3520-EB-80-4160-90-5060/-PM
2. The placement of the Typists in the three grades on their options
shall be subject to the following conditions:(a) Grade-I: Typists with a minimum of 3 (three) years of
qualifying service in Grade-II shall be eligible for appearing
the Speed Test of 60 words per minute, to be conducted by
Meghalaya Public Service Commission and their placement
in the grade shall be subject to passing the Speed Test.
(b) Grade-II: Typists with a minimum of 3 years qualifying
service in Grade-III shall be eligible for appearing the Speed
Test of 45 words per minute, to be conducted by Meghalaya
Public Service Commission and their placement in the grade
shall be subject to passing the Speed Test.
2025:MLHC:311-DB
(c) The existing Ordinary Grade Typist shall henceforth be
categorized as Grade-III Typists.
3.
Existing ordinary Grade Typists who have already passed
the Speed Test of 45 w.p.m. shall be eligible to be placed
directly in Grade-II and those who have already passed the
Speed Test of 60 w.p.m. shall be eligible to be placed
directly in Grade-I provided that they have rendered a
minimum of 3 years of qualifying and satisfactory service in
the Ordinary Grade.
4.
With the introduction of the three tier system in the Typist
Grade the advance increment(s) hitherto admissible shall
cease to operate.
The existing system of having Selection Grade Typists shall
henceforth stand abolished. However, the existing Selection
Grade Typists shall remain categorized as such and shall be
allowed to draw the corresponding Revised Scale of pay as
personal to them until they vacate the post or cease to draw
pay in the scale.
5.
(a) A Typist who opts for the Grade System shall continue as
such and he/she shall not be eligible for promotion to the
post of L.D. Assistant irrespective of his/her Seniority in the
Cadre/Service.
(b) The appointment to L.D. Cadre shall be open only
to the Cadre of Grade-III Typists until he/she is
eligible for such promotion as per the Provision of the
Service Rules and on promotion to the post of L.D.
Assistant shall continue as such and shall not be
eligible to the Grade Scales in future.
(c) The Option once exercised is final.”
The DPC on 30th November, 2020 made the following observations
and recommendations:
2025:MLHC:311-DB
Agenda No.5: Promotion to the rank of Lower Division
Assistants (LDA):
The Department has 29 (twenty nine) sanctioned posts of Lower
Division Assistant. As provided in Rule 9(2), Typists who have
rendered not less than 4 (four) years of continuous service on the
first day of the year in which the selection is made can be
recommended to the rank of LDA and as provided in Rule 9(3)
selection can also be made from amongst the Grade IV employees
of the Directorate who have passed HSLC Examination or any
examination declared equivalent thereto and have rendered not less
than 7 (seven) years of continuous service on the first day of the
year in which the selection is made. As provided in Rule 9(4) the
quota to be filled in the cadre of LDA in any year shall be
according to sub-rule (1), (2) and (3) in a ratio of 8:1:1, i.e. 80% by
direct recruitment, 10% by promotion from amongst the typist and
10% from amongst the Grade IV employees. Taking this into
consideration, the break up for the 29 (twenty nine) posts in the
Department will be as follows:
1. By direct recruitment
2. By promotion from amongst the Typist
3. By promotion from amongst the Grade IV
= 23 posts
= 3 posts
= 3 posts
Out of the 3 (three) posts as per the quota for the Typists, 2 (two)
are the existing vacancies due to superannuation of the previous
incumbents and 1 (one) vacancy resulting from the above
recommendation for promotion, the Committee therefore, after
scrutinizing the documents of all the incumbents in the select list,
recommended Smti Sukmondoris Sohlang, Smti Salibon Muthoh
and Smti Daritimai Lyngdoh for promotion to the 3 (three) vacant
posts of Lower Division Assistant from the quota of Typists.”
On 23rd June, 2021, the same DPC reversed the promotion of the
respondent and reverted her to the original post by the following resolution:
2025:MLHC:311-DB
“It was also brought to the notice of the Committee that the
recommendation of the previous DPC meeting held on the 30 th
November, 2020 needs to be reviewed. It may be mentioned that as
per decision of the earlier DPC meeting, Smti Daritimai Lyngdoh
was recommended for promotion to the post of Lower Division
Assistant from the quota of Typist as per provision of Rule 9(2) of
the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial) Service
Rules, 2010. However, provision as laid down in the Government’s
OM No.SAE.178/86/211-A dated 16.03.2006 was not referred to.
As laid down in the OM above, at 5(a) and (c), a typist who opts
for Grade System shall not be eligible for promotion to the post of
Lower Division Assistant irrespective of his/her Seniority in the
Cadre/Service and the option once exercised is final. Therefore, the
Committee decided to revert back the service of Smti Daritimai
Lyngdoh as a Typist.”
The rules are statutory being framed in exercise of legislative
powers. The Office Memorandum dated 16th March, 2006 is just an
administrative instruction and cannot supplant or override the statutory rules.
The stipulation in clause 5(a) of the said Office Memorandum dated 16th
March, 2006 that a typist who opted for the grade system shall continue as
such and would not be eligible for promotion to the post of LDA could not
override the right to promotion under Rule 11(2). In my opinion, the learned
judge has rightly held that Rule 9 as amended by Rule 11 on 5 th December,
2012 will have primacy over the government Office Memorandum dated 16th
March, 2006. Therefore, the learned judge was absolutely right in holding
2025:MLHC:311-DB
that reversion of the respondent to her original post in terms of the Office
Memorandum dated 16th March, 2006 when there was no such stipulation in
the rules was not binding on her. The withdrawal of promotion of the
respondent has been most unfair and unjust.
For the reasons above, I affirm the impugned judgment and order
and dismiss the appeal.
MC (WA) No.68 of 2024 is disposed of.
No order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
23.04.2025
“Lam DR-PS”
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2025.04.23 05:49:20 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review