Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.04.28 16:54:08 +05'30'
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022
Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017
1. The
State of Manipur represented by the
Commissioner/Secretary (Power), Government
of Manipur, Secretariat Complex, Babupara, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, District Imphal West, Manipur795001.
2. The Manipur State Power Distribution Company
Limited through its Managing Director, MSPDCL
having its Office at 3rd Floor, New Directorate
Building near 2nd MR Gate, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
District Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
…. Review Petitioners/
Respondents in Writ Petition
-VersusShri Moirangthem Indrakumar Singh, aged about
40 years, S/o M. Uttam Singh of Leimaram
Awang Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Nambol, District
Bishnupur, Manipur-795134.
... Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. S. Nepolean, GA
For the Respondent
::
Ms. L. Sillori, Advocate
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
31.03.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
25.04.2023
::
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This review petition has been filed by the review
petitioners to review the order dated 3.5.2018 passed in W.P.(C)
No.365 of 2017.
2.
W.P.(C) No.365 of 2017 has been filed by the
respondent for issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the
review petitioners herein to pay a sum of Rs.30 lakh as
compensation on the ground that the petitioner sustained 70%
disability leading to amputation of his right arm due to the
negligence on the part of the review petitioners. The said writ
petition was allowed on 3.5.2018 directing the review petitioners
to pay a sum of Rs.10 lakh as compensation to the respondent
within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order. Alleging that there is an error in the said order, the
review petitioners have filed this review petition.
3.
Mr.
S.
Nepolean,
the
learned
Government
Advocate appearing for the review petitioners submitted that the
writ petition was disposed of without the affidavit-in-opposition of
the review petitioners and, as such, relevant documents which
were directly or indirectly related with the case could not be
placed before this Court, resultantly, the writ petition was decided
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |3
in favour of the respondent. He would submit in the event the
review petitioners were allowed to file their affidavit-in-opposition
by giving one more opportunity before the writ petition was
disposed of, the order dated 3.5.2018 might have been negative
because of the fact that as per the records of the State
Government, the electrical accident was never reported either by
the respondent or by his family members. As per the enquiry
report
submitted
by
the
Deputy
General
Manager,
Churachandpur Division, MSPDCL who is the competent
authority to do so and who has conducted the enquiry as per
verbal report given on 4.7.2016 by one Utam Singh of Leimaram
Village who is the father of the respondent, the electrical accident
took place on 13.6.2016 at around 1.00 p.m. while the
respondent was repairing the mobile telecommunication gadget
on the roof top of SBI Tuibong Branch building.
4.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the accident took place because of the victim accidently touched
the High Tension conductor stringed adjacent to the building with
his head while climbing down from the roof. It is stated in the
enquiry report that the said SBI building was once the control
room of 33/11 KV Tuibong Sub-Station and although it was RCC
roofing, there was no steps or upstairs to climb the roof top as it
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |4
was initially designed for control room. The existing 11 KV lines
were also the same line which was used when the control room
was functioning. However, the victim used a private ladder to
climb the roof top for the purpose of his own private works without
any prior information to the concerned authority. Therefore, the
electrical accident which took place on 13.6.2016 might not have
happen if either the respondent or the Linquest Telecom Limited
or the authorities of SBI for whom the respondent was on duty
have given notice in writing of his intention to the supplier and to
the Inspector as required under Rule 82 of the Indian Electricity
Rules, 1956, which is mandatory as it has penal provision under
Rule 140 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956.
Since the
respondent or his employer or the authorities of the SBI have not
given any notice in writing, the respondent or his employer or the
authorities of SBI have violated the mandatory provision of Rule
82 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956 and, as such, the review
petitioners cannot be held responsible for the electrical accident.
5.
Adding further, the learned senior counsel for the
review petitioners submitted that the writ petition is not
maintainable for non-joinder of necessary parties. Since the
electrical accident took place while the respondent was on his
official duty as directed by the employer for installation of
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |5
Monopole attached ODU to it for the SBI, Churanchandpur
Branch, the respondent should have impleaded the Linkquest
Telecom Limited i.e. his employer and the SBI, Churachandpur
Branch for whom he was executing the work. Furthermore, the
decisions relied upon in the order are not directly or indirectly
applicable with the facts of the present case. Since the impugned
order is a clear case of an error apparent on the face of the record
and non-consideration of relevant documents, the same is to be
reviewed. In support, the learned senior counsel placed reliance
upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Rajender Singh v. Lt. Governor, Andaman & Nocobar
Islands, (2005) 13 SCC 289.
6.
Supporting the impugned order, the learned
counsel for the respondent submitted that there is no error on the
face of record and the order impugned is well considered order
and, therefore, no review is warranted. He would submit that no
report has been filed with the company or the police regarding
the incident. Be that as it may, the issue cannot be considered
is the error apparent on the face of the impugned order dated
3.5.2018. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the review
petition.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |6
7.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
8.
The respondent has filed the writ petition claiming
compensation of Rs.30 lakh alleging that he joined the service as
Engineer on 10.11.2014 in Linquest Telecom Limited, which is a
privately owned telecommunication company, with an initial pay
of Rs.24,000/- per month.
The Linquest Telecom Limited is
working in partnership with the Bharti Airtel Limited along with
some other private telecom companies. The Bharti Airtel Limited
is providing all telecom services to the State Bank of India with
the help of those private companies including Linquest Telecom
Limited.
On 13.6.2016, the respondent was on duty at SBI
Tyibong Churachandpur for installing a Monopole and attach on
ODU to it on the roof top of the SBI building which would be
connected with one IDU in the server room of the bank. After
completing the work on the roof top, the respondent got electric
shock suddenly from the HT power line on the neck and fell down
on the ground unconscious. Thereafter, the respondent was
admitted in Raj Medicity for treatment on 14.6.2016 and
subsequently he was further given treatment to Downtown
Hospital at Guwahati on 2.7.2016.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |7
9.
As his condition aggravated, the right arm of the
petitioner was amputated below the ankle to save his life in that
hospital. In the meantime, the respondent was transferred to
Bihar Jharkhand Circle on 30.11.2016. However, due to physical
condition, the respondent did not join new place of posting and,
accordingly, the service of the respondent was terminated by an
order dated 14.12.2016. Stating that he would have led a normal
life more than an additional 40 years if the accident was not
happened and taking the monthly salary at Rs.24,000/- for
another 24 years, the respondent calculated the loss of earning
at Rs.49,12,000/-. Since the respondent suffered 70% of the
disability, he claimed compensation of Rs.30 lakh from the State
respondents. This Court, upon considering the arguments of
both
sides,
directed
the
State
respondents
to
pay a
compensation of Rs.10 lakh to the petitioner.
10.
The review petitioners sought to review the order
dated 3.5.2018 mainly on the ground that the writ petition was
disposed of without the affidavit-in-opposition of the review
petitioners and if the review petitioners were allowed to file their
affidavit-in-opposition, the order dated 3.5.2018 might have been
negative because of the fact that as per the records of the State
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |8
Government, the electrical accident was never reported either by
the respondent or by his family members.
11.
As far as non-providing of opportunity to the review
petitioners for filing affidavit-in-opposition is concerned, on a
reading of the order dated 3.5.2018, this Court recorded that
despite a number of opportunities being granted to the review
petitioners, no counter affidavit has been filed on their behalf and
therefore, the averments made in the petitioner shall be deemed
to have been admitted by the review petitioners in terms of a
catena of decisions rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
this regard.
12.
The non-filing of the affidavit-in-opposition to the
writ petition by the review petitioners is the fault on the part of the
review petitioners and if really, they are interested in contesting
the writ petition, the review petitioners ought to have filed their
counter affidavit within a time and failure on the part of the review
petitioners in not filing the counter affidavit is not a ground to
review the order dated 3.5.2018 passed in the writ petition.
Though no counter affidavit filed on behalf of the review
petitioners, on their side, learned Additional Advocate General
argued the matter extensively by raising the maintainability issue.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
Page |9
13.
This Court, after referring to the decisions relied
upon by the learned Additional Advocate General in the cases of
Chairman, Grid Corporation of Orissa Ltd. and others v. Smt.
Sukamani Das, (1999) 7 SCC 298 and SDO, Grid Corporation
of Orissa Ltd. V. Timudu Oram, (2005) 6 SCC 156 and the
decisions in the cases of Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar and
others, (1983) 4 SCC 141; Nilabati Behera (Smt) alias Lalita
Behera v. State of Orissa and others, (1993) 2 SCC 746 and
D.K.Basu v. State of West Bengal, (1997) 1 SCC 416, held that
the High Court in exercise of power under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is competent to award compensation in
cases where the fundamental rights guaranteed in the
Constitution have been infringed by the State authorities. This
Court, by relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the cases of MP Electricity Board v. Shail Kumari and
others, (2002) 2 SCC 162 and Raman v. Uttar Haryana Bijli
Vitran Nigam Ltd., Civil Appeal No.11466 of 2014, decided on
17.12.2014, observed as under:
“[8] In view of and in terms of the decisions, as
referred to hereinabove, relating to payment of
compensation in the cases arising out of
incidents of electrocution due to the negligence
on the part of the State authorities, this court is
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 10
of the view that the instant writ petition deserves
to be allowed by this court.
Therefore, the
question that arises for consideration by this
court is as to what amount of compensation
would be just and reasonable in the facts and
circumstances of the present case. In Raman
case (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court was
confronted with a question as to how the just
and reasonable compensation be determined in
a case and after examining its earlier decisions,
it came to the conclusion that it is difficult for any
court to lay down rigid tests which should be
applied in all situations and that in the Indian
context,
various
factors
like
educational
qualification, nature of job, past performance,
scope of higher salary, the expenditure that the
claimant has incurred and is likely to incur,
family dependence, inflation etc. should be
taken into consideration. While determining the
compensation, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
emphasized the need to strike a balance
between
the
inflated
and
unreasonable
demands of a victim and the equally untenable
claim of the opposite party saying that nothing
is payable.
In view of tis earlier decisions
referred to therein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
was of the view that the compensation awarded
at Rs.60 lakhs in the judgment of the learned
Single, out of which Rs.30 lakhs were to be
deposited jointly in the name of the appellant
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 11
represented by his parents as natural guardian
and the Chief Engineer or its nominee
representing the respondents in a fixed deposit
till he attains the age of majority, was just and
proper but set aside the portion thereof as
mentioned in its para 19 of the judgment and
order and modified it accordingly.
But the
Hon’ble Supreme Court rejected the use of
multiplier system as the only basis for purpose
of
determining
the
just
and
reasonable
compensation in such cases like the present
one.”
14.
In this review petition, the review petitioners
contended that while the respondent was repairing the mobile
telecommunication gadget on the roof top of the SBI Tuibong
Brach building, the accident took place because of the
respondent accidently touched the high tension conductor
stringed adjacent the building with his head while climbing down
from the roof. Since the respondent or his employer or the
authorities of the SBI have not given any notice in writing, the
respondent or his employer or authorities of SBI have violated
the mandatory provision of Rule 82 of the Indian Electricity Rules
and, as such, the review petitioners cannot be held responsible
for the electrical accident.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 12
15.
On a perusal of the order dated 3.5.2018, it is seen
that the issue to hold a person liable for tort, the negligence on
the part of that person must be established by the petitioner and
moreover, if there are disputed questions of facts, the appropriate
remedy would be to approach the civil court of competent
jurisdiction was raised by the review petitioners and rightly
answered by this Court by observing that it is an undeniable fact
that compensation can be claimed by an aggrieved person under
the provisions of various laws enacted by the Union of India or
the States which is a remedy available in private law and that
compensation can be claimed in public law as well.
While
allowing the writ petition, this Court further observed as under:
“[6] ….. The purpose of awarding compensation
is to compensate the loss or injury suffered by
a person so as to make good to him, although
he cannot be compensated fully in terms of
money.
In other words, it is to mitigate his
hardship in terms of money. The quantum of
compensation will definitely depend upon the
facts and circumstances of each case, as no
straightjacket formula which will be applicable in
all cases, can be laid down by the court.
Compensation can be broadly divided into two
– one, a compensation that can be claimed in
private law and two, a compensation that can
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 13
be claimed in public law for violation of
fundamental rights. So far as the present case
is concerned, it falls in the second category, in
the sense that the compensation is being
claimed by the petitioner for the violation of his
fundamental
rights
and
therefore,
the
contention of the learned counsel appearing for
the respondents is devoid any merits and is not
acceptable to this court. …”
16.
If really, the review petitioners are aggrieved by the
awarding of compensation payable by them to the respondent,
they ought to have filed an appeal against the said findings and
the review would not maintainable.
17.
It is pertinent to note that challenging the order
dated 3.5.2018 passed in W.P.(C) No.365 of 2017, the review
petitioners have filed W.A.No.18 of 2018. However, for one
reason or the other, W.A.No.18 of 2018 has been withdrawn by
the review petitioners on 16.3.2022 with liberty to file a fresh. On
the contrary, facing with the notice in Contempt Case No.46 of
2022, the review petitioners have filed the present review petition
on 4.7.2022 after a lapse of nearly four months of the dismissal
of W.A.No.18 of 2018. The aforesaid factual scenario, clearly
establishes the attitude of the review petitioners in delaying the
payment of compensation to the respondent by filing writ appeal
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 14
first and then review petition by falsely stating that there is an
error apparent on the face of record. The approach adopted by
the review petitioners firstly filing a writ appeal and subsequently
withdrawing the same and then filing the review petition with a
gap of nearly four months alleging there is an error in the order
is not appreciable.
18.
As stated supra, if really the review petitioners are
aggrieved by the order dated 3.5.2018 passed in the writ petition,
they ought to have challenged the same by way of writ appeal.
19.
Under Order 47, Rule 1 CPC, a judgment may be
open to review, inter alia, if there is mistake or an error apparent
on the face of the record. An error which is not self-evident and
has to be detected by a process of reasoning can hardly be said
to be an error apparent on the face of the record justifying the
court to exercise its power of review under Order 47, Rule 1 CPC.
In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47, Rule 1 CPC, it is
not permissible for an erroneous decision to be reheard and
corrected. A review petition, it must be remembered has a limited
purpose and cannot be allowed to be an appeal in disguise.
20.
Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that review is not appeal in disguise. It follows, therefore, that
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 15
the power of review can be exercised for correction of a mistake
but not to substitute a view. Such powers can be exercised within
the limits of the statute dealing with the exercise of power. The
review cannot be treated like an appeal in disguise.
21.
In Meera Bhanja v. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury,
(1995) 1 SCC 170, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“8. It is well settled that the review proceedings
are not by way of an appeal and have to be
strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order
47, Rule 1, while dealing with similar jurisdiction
available to the High Court while seeking to
review the orders under Article 226 of the
Constitution, this Court in Aribam Tuleshwar
Sharma v. Aribam Pishak Sharma, (1979) 4
SCC 389 speaking through Chinnappa Reddy,
J.
has
made
the
following
pertinent
observations:
“It is true there is nothing in Article 226
of the Constitution to preclude the
High Court from exercising the power
of review which inheres in every court
of plenary jurisdiction to prevent
miscarriage of justice or to correct
grave and palpable errors committed
by it. But, there are definitive limits to
the exercise of the power of review.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 16
The power of review may be exercised
on the discovery of new and important
matter or evidence which, after the
exercise of due diligence was not
within the knowledge of the person
seeking the review or could not be
produced by him at the time when the
order was made; it may be exercised
where some mistake or error apparent
on the face of the record is found, it
may
also
be
exercised
on
any
analogous ground. But, it may not be
exercised on the ground that the
decision was erroneous on merits.
That would be the province of a court
of appeal. A power of review is not to
be confused with appellate power
which may enable an appellate court
to
correct
all
manner
of
errors
committed by the subordinate court.””
22.
In the case of Lily Thomas v. Union of India,
(2000) 6 SCC 224, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed and
held that the power of review can be exercised for correction of
a mistake but not to substitute a view. Such powers can be
exercised within the limits of the statute dealing with the exercise
of power.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 17
23.
In the case on hand, by filing MC No.4 of 2023, the
review petitioners contended that though the electrical accident
took place on 13.6.2016, no complaint about the accident was
ever reported to the authorities of the MSPDCL, nor to the
Churachandpur Police Station until the father of the respondent
reported the incident verbally to the Deputy General Manager,
MSPDCL only on 4.7.2016. However, soon after the report was
received though verbally on 4.7.2016, a field enquiry about the
electrical incident was conducted and thereafter a detail accident
report dated 11.7.2016 was submitted by the Deputy General
Manager, Churachandpur Division to the General Manager,
Electrical Circle-II, CMSPDCL. In the said report, it has been
mentioned that the said SBI building was once the control room
of 33/11 KV Tuibong, Sub-Station and although it was RCC
roofing, there was no steps or upstairs to climb the rooftop as it
was initially designed for control room. The existing 11 KC lines
were also the same line which was used when the control room
was functioning. However, the victim used a private ladder to
climb the rooftop for the purpose of his own private works without
any prior information to the concerned authority.
24.
Admittedly, the aforesaid plea and the report sought
to be filed are very well available with the review petitioners while
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 18
arguing the writ petition. For the purpose of consideration of the
review petition, the report filed along with MC No.4 of 2013 is
treated as part of the review petition. However, this Court is of
the view that the review petitioners have failed to refer the said
report while arguing the writ petition which was readily available
with them. It is not the case of the review petitioners that those
facts are not within their knowledge or could not be produced by
them at the time when the order was made in the writ petition. In
view of the above, an application for review would lie if the order
has been passed on account of some mistake. Thus, it is clear
that there is total failure on the part of the review petitioners in
defending the writ petition in proper manner. Therefore, under
the aid of review, now the review petitioners cannot sought to the
review the order dated 3.5.2018, as power of review can be
exercised for correction of a mistake but not to substitute a view.
25.
Under the Indian Electricity Act, 2003 and the rules
framed thereunder, it is bounden duty of the electricity authorities
to conduct periodical inspection of the lines maintained by them
and to take all such safety measures to prevent accident and
maintain the lines in such a manner that life and property of the
general public is protected. Though the review petitioner
contended that the State authorities have a policy of ex-gratia
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 19
payment for electrocution cases and the compensation awarded
in the order dated 3.5.2018 is exorbitant and if the aforesaid facts
as well as the provision of law were considered at the time of
hearing of the writ petition, the order dated 3.5.2018 might not
have been passed, the aforesaid are not grounds for reviewing
the order dated 3.5.2018. A blame has to be fastened on the
review petitioners in not properly defending the writ petition by
producing relevant records.
26.
Though the review petitioners contended that the
victim used a private ladder to climb the rooftop for the purpose
of his own private works without any prior information to the
concerned authority and therefore, the State authorities are not
held liable to compensation, the said issue cannot be gone into
in the review jurisdiction for the reason that the very point was
raised by the review petitioners in the writ petition and, this Court
held that since the respondent sustained injuries due to
electrocution, the respondent is entitled to compensation. Such
a finding arrived at by this Court is not reviewable. As stated
supra, if really the respondent State is aggrieved by the said
finding, they ought to have assailed by way of appeal not under
review.
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 20
27.
What can be said to be an error apparent on the
face of the proceedings has been dealt with and considered by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in number of decisions. An error is
an error which is a patent error and not a mere wrong decision.
An order or decision or judgment cannot be corrected merely
because it is erroneous in law or on the ground that a different
view could have been taken by the Court on a point of fact or law.
In any case, while exercising the power of review, the Court
concerned cannot sit an appeal over its judgment.
28.
This Court is of the view that no ground as
envisaged under Order 47, Rule 1 CPC has been made out for
the purpose of reviewing the order dated 3.5.2018 passed in
W.P.No.365 of 2017. Further, in view of the scope as discussed
above, if the submissions of the learned senior counsel for the
review petitioners is tested in the light of the materials available
on record including from the perusal of the order dated 3.5.2018
passed in W.P.No.365 of 2017, it would indicate that while
deciding the matter, all aspects of the matter has been duly
considered by the Court and findings have been given.
29.
The grounds and the decisions cited by the learned
senior counsel for the review petitioners do not relate to the
scope of review. The order under review has been passed by
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
P a g e | 21
the Court considering the facts, law and the arguments made and
also materials available on record. No error apparent on the face
of record could be pointed out by the learned senior counsel for
the review petitioners, hence, the decision in the case of
Rajender Singh, supra, relied upon by the learned senior
counsel for the review petitioners do not render any support.
30.
The review petitioners are trying to seek a re-
hearing of the writ petition which is not within the scope of review.
As stated supra, the learned senior counsel for the review
petitioners could not point out any error apparent on the face of
the record and the submissions made do not fall within the
parameters of Section 114 read with Order 47, Rule 1 CPC.
31.
Having considered the matter, this Court finds that
no grounds of review is made out.
The revision petition is
absolutely devoid of merits and is dismissed. No costs.
32.
In view of the dismissal of the Review Petition No.12
of 2022, the Contempt Case No.46 of 2022 is directed to be listed
on 15.05.2023 for passing further orders/compliance.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
Review Petition No. 12 of 2022 (Ref:- WP(C) No. 365 of 2017)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review