The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 06.2025 passed by coordinate bench of this Court in WP(C) No. 460 of 2024 while setting aside the in-charge appointment of some of the officers, the State authority was given liberty to consider the case of the Page 4 petitioners and the private respondents therein for appointment of fresh transfer and posting and also for in-charge appointment within a period of six weeks. [13] It is submitted at the bar that due to non-compliance of the order dated 19.06.2025, the petitioners therein has filed contempt petition and the same is still pending. [14] This Court has perused the order dated 19.06.2025 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 460 of 2024 and does not relate to the seniority list dated 15.12.2025. The order is simplicitor for giving liberty to the State to consider the case of the petitioners and private respondents therein for transferring and posting and also for in-charge appointment. [15] However, in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025, the substantive prayer is challenge to the seniority list dated 15.12.2021 and admittedly, there was some anomaly in the same and in compliance of the earlier order passed in WP(C) No. 460 of 2024 and in terms of the proposal dated 19.08.2025 submitted by the directorate to the Administrative Department, WP(C) No. 809 of 2025 was closed with the direction to the authority to consider on the proposal submitted by the directorate within two months time.…
15. 12.2021 cannot be considered as the same is admittedly held as defective by the department itself. [16] This Court has considered the materials on record and the application for review as observed earlier. [17] The application for review of the order dated 09.10.2025 in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025 will be treated as application for modification. Since the directorate has admitted in its letter dated 19.08.2025 that the seniority list dated 15.12.2021 is not updated and required review and rectification, this Court is of the view that if any in-charge appointment is made on the basis of the same, there is possibility of overlooking some eligible persons while making in-charge appointment. [18] Since the draft seniority list submitted by the directorate to the administrative department is said to be in rectification of defects Page 5 in the seniority of 2021, it will suffice that the State authority is permitted to make in-charge appointment for 3 (three) months on the basis of the draft seniority list submitted by the directorate to the administrative department. During the meantime, the administrative department shall make endeavour to pass appropriate order to the draft seniority list submitted by the directorate. [19] Accordingly, application is disposed of in terms of the above and this Court does not express any opinion on the merit of the draft seniority list submitted by the di…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No. 1-2
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Review Pet. No. 31 of 2025 with
MC(Review Pet.) No. 25 of 2025
State of Manipur & Anr.
…..Petitioner/s
- Versus –
Karam Lakshmi Devi & 54 Ors.
.... Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
Order
(Oral)
05.11.2025
[1]
Heard
Mr.
Th.
Sukumar,
learned
G.A.
for
the
applicants/petitioners and Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Gunabanta, learned counsel for the respondent/writ
petitioner.
[2]
By the present application under Section 114 of CPC, the
petitioner is praying for review of the order dated 09.10.2025 passed by
this Court in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025.
[3]
In WP(C) No. 809 of 2025, the writ petitioner challenged
the final seniority list dated 15.11.2021 of the Craft Instructor
(Engineering & Non-Engineering) in ITI, Manipur on the ground that the
same is not on the basis of the merit or on the basis of the date of birth,
when the incumbents are regularized on the same day vide order dated
16.12.2016.
[4]
During the course of hearing, Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned
G.A., refers to the letter dated 19.08.2025 submitted by the Joint
Director of Craftsmen and Training, Manipur to the Secretary (Skill,
Page 1
Labour, Employment & Entrepreneurship Department), Government of
Manipur (SLEE) proposing a draft seniority list on the ground that the
seniority list of 2021 is not updated till date and the same cannot be
acted upon without reviewing and rectifying the anomalous.
[5]
On the basis of submission, vide letter dated 19.08.2025
(supra), this Court disposed of the writ petition by granting two months
time to the State respondent to consider the proposal submitted by the
Directorate to the Administrative Department for review and rectification
of the impugned seniority list dated 15.12.2021 within a period of two
months. However, in para 13 of the order dated 09.10.2025, this Court
grant permission to the State Government to approach for clarification
for appointment of in-charge or otherwise if advised so. The order
dated 09.10.2025 is reproduced as:
“[1]
Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned sr. counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Gunabanta Meitei, learned counsel for
the petitioner and Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned GA on behalf
of the State respondent nos. 1 & 2.
[2]
By the present writ petition, the petitioner
has challenged the final seniority list dated 15.12.2021 for
the Craft Instructor (Engineering & Non-Engineering) in ITI,
Manipur on the ground that the same is not on the basis of
the merit or on the basis of the date of birth, when the
incumbents are regularized on the same day vide letter
dated 16.12.2016.
[3]
It is also stated that the initial appointment
on contractual/ ad-hoc basis was done after complying the
due process.
[4]
The learned sr. counsel for the petitioner has
pointed out to the contents of letter dated 19.08.2025
written by Joint Director of Craftsmen and Training,
Manipur to the Secretary, Skill, Labour, Employment &
Entrepreneurship Department, Govt. of Manipur for review
and rectification of the impugned seniority list dated
15.12.2021 on 2(two) grounds.
[5]
It is also submitted that the suggestions
made by the Department is pending with the State Govt.
[6]
The learned sr. counsel for the petitioner
submits that if the suggestions made by the Department is
approved by the State Government, the cause of the writ
petition will become infructuous and he submits that the
present writ petition may be disposed of at this stage with
an innocuous direction that the letter dated 19.08.2025 of
Page 2
the Department may be considered by the State Govt. and
pass an speaking order within a stipulated time.
[7]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned GA for the State
respondents submits that he has no objection in disposing
the writ petition by passing an innocuous direction to the
proposal submitted by the Department.
[8]
This Court has perused the materials on
record and the submissions made at the bar.
[9]
If the suggestions of the Department in its
letter dated 19.08.2025 is approved by the State Govt., the
cause of the writ petition will become infructuous.
[10]
In the circumstances, instead of issue notice
the present writ petition i.e. W.P. (C) No. 809 of 2025 is
disposed of at this stage by directing respondent no. 1 to
consider the proposal submitted by the Joint Director of
Craftsmen and Training, Govt. of Manipur for review and
rectification of impugned seniority list dated 15.12.2021
within a period of 2(two) months’ from the date of receipt
of a copy of this order.
[11]
It is made clear that this Court does not
express any opinion on the merit of the case.
[12]
The MC(W.P. (C)) No. 744 of 2025 is also
disposed of accordingly.
[13]
In case of any urgent exigency of
appointment of in-charge or otherwise, the State Govt. may
approach this Court for clarification.”
[6]
In terms of para 13 of the order dated 09.10.2025, the
State filed the present review petition seeking permission of this Court
for making in-charge arrangement in respect of Principal, Government
Women ITI, Takyel and Principal, Government ITI, Ukhrul as per rule
by appropriately modifying the order dated 09.10.2025 passed in
WP(C) No. 809 of 2025.
[7]
The relief sought in this review petition is reproduced
herein below:
“(i)
(ii)
to admit this Review Petition and call for records of
WP(C) No. 809 of 2025;
To allow the present petitioners to issue necessary
order of in-charge arrangement in respect of
Principal, Government Women ITI, Takyel and
Principal, Government ITI, Ukhrul as per rule by
appropriately modifying para 13 of the order dated
09.10.2025 passed in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025;
Page 3
(iii)
(iv)
[8]
To pass any other appropriate order or direction
which the Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper
in the facts and circumstances of the case;
In the Interim, to allow the present petitioners to
issue in-charge arrangement order in respect of
Principal, Government Women ITI, Takyel and
Principal, Government ITI, Ukhrul as per rule.”
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned G.A., submits that the State
Government may be permitted to make in-charge appointment on the
basis of 2021 seniority list.
[9]
On the other hand, Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior
counsel for the writ petitioner/respondents herein, submits that since
the department has admitted anomaly in seniority list of 2021, the same
is under review by submitting draft proposal to the administrative
department. It is urged that acting upon the seniority list of 2021 may
not proper, as it will amount to leave out some other eligible officers
because the list is not updated as admitted by the State authority itself
in the letter dated 19.08.2025.
[10]
It is also pointed out that the present application should
not be filed as a review but for the modification of the earlier order
dated 09.10.2025 and hence, the application is not maintainable in the
present form.
[11]
On perusal of the review petition filed by the petitioners, it
is seen that the State authority is not arguing for review of the order
itself, but is praying for modification in terms of para 13 of the order
dated 09.10.2025 whereby the State was given liberty to approach this
Court for in-charge appointment or otherwise. The application is for
only clarifications or modifications of some conditions without affecting
the main order. In the circumstances, this Court has considered the
present application as application for modification of the order dated
09.10.2025.
[12]
From the record, it is seen that vide order dated
19.06.2025 passed by coordinate bench of this Court in WP(C) No. 460
of 2024 while setting aside the in-charge appointment of some of the
officers, the State authority was given liberty to consider the case of the
Page 4
petitioners and the private respondents therein for appointment of fresh
transfer and posting and also for in-charge appointment within a period
of six weeks.
[13]
It is submitted at the bar that due to non-compliance of
the order dated 19.06.2025, the petitioners therein has filed contempt
petition and the same is still pending.
[14]
This Court has perused the order dated 19.06.2025
passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 460 of 2024 and does not relate to
the seniority list dated 15.12.2025. The order is simplicitor for giving
liberty to the State to consider the case of the petitioners and private
respondents therein for transferring and posting and also for in-charge
appointment.
[15]
However, in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025, the substantive
prayer is challenge to the seniority list dated 15.12.2021 and
admittedly, there was some anomaly in the same and in compliance of
the earlier order passed in WP(C) No. 460 of 2024 and in terms of the
proposal dated 19.08.2025 submitted by the directorate to the
Administrative Department, WP(C) No. 809 of 2025 was closed with
the direction to the authority to consider on the proposal submitted by
the directorate within two months time. The seniority list dated
15.12.2021 cannot be considered as the same is admittedly held as
defective by the department itself.
[16]
This Court has considered the materials on record and
the application for review as observed earlier.
[17]
The application for review of the order dated 09.10.2025
in WP(C) No. 809 of 2025 will be treated as application for modification.
Since the directorate has admitted in its letter dated 19.08.2025 that
the seniority list dated 15.12.2021 is not updated and required review
and rectification, this Court is of the view that if any in-charge
appointment is made on the basis of the same, there is possibility of
overlooking some eligible persons while making in-charge appointment.
[18]
Since the draft seniority list submitted by the directorate
to the administrative department is said to be in rectification of defects
Page 5
in the seniority of 2021, it will suffice that the State authority is
permitted to make in-charge appointment for 3 (three) months on the
basis of the draft seniority list submitted by the directorate to the
administrative department. During the meantime, the administrative
department shall make endeavour to pass appropriate order to the draft
seniority list submitted by the directorate.
[19]
Accordingly, application is disposed of in terms of the
above and this Court does not express any opinion on the merit of the
draft seniority list submitted by the directorate to the administrative
department. MC(Review Pet.) No. 25 of 2025 is closed.
[20]
Furnish a copy of this order to the learned counsel for the
parties in the course of the day.
JUDGE
Kh. Joshua Maring
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
Digitally signed
by KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2025.11.05
16:11:07 +05'30'
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review