The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
405. Mohinder Singh Gill pertains to reelection in a parliamentary constituency as regards a General Election. The parliamentary constituency concerned is 13-Ferozepore Parliamentary Constituency. Though re-election was held, the candidate concerned did not participate and the question as to whether personal hearing was given arose. In this factual backdrop, a Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court declared the law that in judicial review, action has to be judged by reasons stated while making the order and supplementary reasons in the shape of affidavits have to be excluded. To put it differently, Mohinder Singh Gill principle is to the effect that an impugned order should sustain itself from the basis of contents therein and it cannot be improved by way of affidavits or submissions in the hearing. To be noted, we are respectfully referring to Mohinder Singh Gill principle as ‘declaration of law’ rather than ratio as Mohinder Singh Gill was rendered by a Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court. [14] Reverting to the case on hand, the sole ground on which the claim of writ petitioner for ex-post facto approval of reimbursement of medical expenses in respect of treatment of his young twin children for respiratory disease in said hospital was negatived is that the said hospital is not in the list of empaneled hospitals in the Manipur Government list. Therefore, we have no hes…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KABORAMB Digitally signed by
KABORAMBAM
AM
SANDEEP SINGH
SANDEEP Date: 2026.01.13
10:21:00 +05'30'
SINGH
Sl. No. 4
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC (W.A.) No. 123 of 2025
Ref: Writ Appeal Filing No. WA/3176/2025
MC Filing No. MC(WA)/3178/2025
State of Manipur; & Ors.
Applicants
Vs.
Nepram Sonykumar
Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
(ORDER)
(Order of the Court was made by M. Sundar, CJ)
12.01.2026
[1]
Captioned Miscellaneous Case (MC) has been filed with a
Condonation of Delay (CoD) prayer qua 458 days delay in filing the
captioned State appeal being writ appeal (WA) vide Filing No.
WA/3176/2025 (along with a MC for stay being Filing No.
MC(WA)3178/2025) assailing ‘order dated 16.08.2024 made in W.P. (C)
No. 594 of 2023 by an Hon’ble Single Bench’ (‘impugned order’ for the
sake of convenience).
[2]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned State counsel, adverting to CoD
MC petition, more particularly paragraph 5.1 thereat submitted that the
delay in filing the State appeal is neither willful nor wanton but only
owing to time consumed at various stages of taking a decision regarding
filing the appeal. Learned State counsel adverted to adumbration of
calendrical sequence of events set out in paragraph 5.1 but it will suffice
to write that it is only a narrative of time consumed qua various stages
of bureaucratic procedures.
[3]
Issue notice
[4]
Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel present in Court accepts
notice for respondent (writ petitioner before Hon’ble Single Bench) and
learned counsel submits that delay not being wanton or willful is
immaterial as it is a clear case of what has been repeatedly described
by Hon’ble Courts as ‘file pushing’ and learned counsel also pointed out
that the main matter pertains to reimbursement of medical claim qua
treatment of young twin children of a serving Judicial Officer.
[5]
Be that as it may, Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned State counsel
as well as Mr. I. Denning learned counsel for ‘writ petitioner’ (to be
noted, ‘respondent’ is being referred to as ‘writ petitioner’ for
convenience) agreed to have the main WA (writ appeal) heard out
today, here and now.
[6]
In the light of the nature of the main matter, considering
other facts and circumstances of the case and owing to the fair stand
taken by both side in agreeing to have the main WA heard out today,
delay is condoned, CoD prayer is acceded to. To put it differently,
captioned MC is ordered as prayed for. There shall be no order as to
costs.
[7]
As regards the main WA, writ petitioner approached this
Court in and by way of W.P. (C) No. 594 of 2023 assailing an order
dated 05.07.2022 made by Director of Health Services, Manipur (2 nd
respondent before the Hon’ble Single Bench and ‘2nd Respondent’ shall
be referred to as ‘R-2’ and it is further to be noted that other
respondents shall also be referred to by similar abbreviations) wherein
and whereby R-2 informed learned District and Sessions Judge, Imphal
East, that ex-post facto approval for sanction for treatment of writ
petitioner’s twin children for respiratory distress at ‘Mothers Care
Children Hospital & Research Centre, Imphal’ (hereinafter ‘said hospital’
for convenience) cannot be acceded to as said hospital is not in the list
of empaneled hospitals qua Government of Manipur.
[8]
After full contest, Honble Single Bench in and by the
impugned order, acceded to the prayer of writ petitioner and directed
the State to release the admissible expenses (medical reimbursement)
as per law within a period of three months and had also made it clear
that interest @ 9% per annum will be payable if there is delay.
[9]
Notwithstanding myriad grounds, very many averments in
the WA, learned State Counsel predicated his campaign against the
impugned order on the primary ground that there was no reference by
the treating doctor concerned and there was no certification by the
Medical Board that the treatment in said hospital is imperative.
[10]
It was also argued by learned State counsel that in the
impugned order, a parallel had been drawn with regard to another case
of staff of Superintendent of Police, Senapati District, Manipur, having
taken treatment in the same said hospital but the facts are different as
that was a case of exceptional certification and referral from a
Government Hospital.
[11]
In response to the above submissions of learned State
counsel, learned counsel for writ petitioner adverting to the impugned
order of R-2 being order dated 05.07.2022 bearing Reference No.
P/6/2019(Return)-DHS, submitted that the solitary reason giving there
is that the said hospital is not included in the list of empaneled hospitals
qua Manipur Government.
[12]
This Court carefully considered the rival submissions.
[13]
At the outset, this Court reminds itself of the ratio laid
down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the celebrated and oft quoted case
law, i.e., Mohinder Singh Gill and Anr. Vs. The Chief Election
Commissioner, New Delhi and others reported in (1978) 1 SCC
405. Mohinder Singh Gill pertains to reelection in a parliamentary
constituency as regards a General Election. The parliamentary
constituency concerned is 13-Ferozepore Parliamentary Constituency.
Though re-election was held, the candidate concerned did not
participate and the question as to whether personal hearing was given
arose. In this factual backdrop, a Constitution Bench of Hon’ble
Supreme Court declared the law that in judicial review, action has to be
judged by reasons stated while making the order and supplementary
reasons
in the shape of affidavits have to be excluded. To put it
differently, Mohinder Singh Gill principle is to the effect that an
impugned order should sustain itself from the basis of contents therein
and it cannot be improved by way of affidavits or submissions in the
hearing. To be noted, we are respectfully referring to Mohinder Singh
Gill principle as ‘declaration of law’ rather than ratio as Mohinder
Singh Gill was rendered by a Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
[14]
Reverting to the case on hand, the sole ground on which
the claim of writ petitioner for ex-post facto approval of reimbursement
of medical expenses in respect of treatment of his young twin children
for respiratory disease in said hospital was negatived is that the said
hospital is not in the list of empaneled hospitals in the Manipur
Government list. Therefore, we have no hesitation in writing that the
State counsel now cannot improve the impugned order by stating that
prior clearance from Medical Board has not been obtained.
[15]
As regards distinction between the case of staff of
Superintendent of Police and the case on hand, fact remains that
treatment taken in the same said hospital by another Government
official, namely, staff of Superintendent of Police was approved whereas
a request by writ petitioner who is a serving Judicial Officer has been
negatived. As already alluded to supra, it is evident from the sole ground
qua impugned order of R-2 that said hospital is not empaneled in the
list of Manipur Government. The fact remains that said hospital though
not listed in the list of empaneled hospitals of the Manipur Government
has given treatment to family of another Government official and
reimbursement has been approved. This is the bottom line. Even on an
extreme demurer, even if the facts and circumstances of the case of
staff of Superintendent of Police and writ petitioner are different,
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shiva Kant Jha Vs. Union of India
reported in (2018) 16 SCC 187 has made it clear that medical
reimbursement cannot be negatived on the sole ground that particular
hospital is not empaneled and the real test is factum of treatment. In
the case on hand, that the twin children were given treatment in the
said hospital is not in dispute. This means that the factum of treatment
has not been put in issue at all and said hospital has not been
empaneled in the State Government list is the only ground.
[16]
Reverting to Shiva Kant Jha case, it is one where an
individual who is a beneficiary qua CGHS (Central Government Health
Scheme) being a retired Government employee submitted two sets of
medical bills for treatment for heart ailment in Fortis Escorts Hospital,
New Delhi and Jaslok Hospital, Mumbai for cerebral stroke and paralytic
attack. These claims were disallowed by CGHS and the mater travelled
to Hon’ble Supreme Court. It is in this context that Hon’ble Supreme
Court made it clear that it is settled legal position that a Government
employee during his lifetime or after his retirement is entitled to get the
benefit of medical facilities and no fetters can be placed on his rights.
It was also made clear that the real test is factum of treatment and the
right to medical claim cannot be denied merely because the name of
hospital is not included in the Government list. This has been articulated
by Hon’ble Supreme Court in paragraph 17 of Shiva Kant Jha which
reads as follows:
‘17. It is a settled legal position that the Government employee
during his life time or after his retirement is entitled to get the
benefit of the medical facilities and no fetters can be placed on his
rights. It is acceptable to common sense, that ultimate decision as
to how a patient should be treated vests only with the Doctor, who
is well versed and expert both on academic qualification and
experience gained. Very little scope is left to the patient or his
relative to decide as to the manner in which the ailment should be
treated. Speciality Hospitals are established for treatment of
specified ailments and services of Doctors specialized in a discipline
are availed by patients only to ensure proper, required and safe
treatment. Can it be said that taking treatment in Speciality Hospital
by itself would deprive a person to claim reimbursement solely on
the ground that the said Hospital is not included in the Government
Order. The right to medical claim cannot be denied merely because
the name of the hospital is not included in the Government Order.
The real test must be the factum of treatment. Before any medical
claim is honoured, the authorities are bound to ensure as to whether
the claimant had actually taken treatment and the factum of
treatment is supported by records duly certified by doctors/hospitals
concerned. Once, it is established, the claim cannot be denied on
technical grounds. Clearly, in the present case, by taking a very
inhuman approach, the officials of the CGHS have denied the grant
of medical reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to
approach this Court.’
(Underlining made by this Court for ease of reference and
for emphasis)
[17]
Reverting to the impugned order of R-2 which was
assailed by writ petitioner before Hon’ble Single Bench, as already
alluded to supra, the solitary ground on which the ex-post facto claim
of writ petitioner was negatived was that the said hospital (Mother Care
Children Hospital and Research Centre) has not been included in the list
of empaneled hospitals qua Manipur Government. This ground does not
find favour with this Court being sustained as it is clearly flattened and
floored by Shiva Kant Jha principle. Therefore, there is no difficulty in
writing that the impugned order of R-2 deserves to be interfered with
and this Division Bench is of the considered view that Hon’ble Single
Bench rightly interfered with the impugned order of R-2 and directed
reimbursement.
[18]
This Court, for the sake of convenience and clarity deems
it appropriate to scan and reproduce the impugned order of R-2 and a
scanned reproduction of impugned order as placed before us is as
follows:
[19]
This court finds that Hon’ble Single Bench vide paragraph
7 of the impugned order has respectfully followed Shiva Kant Jha
principle. We also find that the same paragraph 17 which has been
extracted and reproduced supra has been respectfully referred to by
the Hon’ble Single Bench also.
[20]
At the risk of repetition, as the factum of treatment is not
an issue and as the Hon’ble single Bench in the impugned order has
directed release of admissible expenses as per law, we find no reason
to interfere qua the impugned order of Hon’ble Single Bench.
[21]
Ergo, the sequitur is, captioned State writ appeal being
Filing No. WA/3176/2025 is dismissed and MC thereat for stay being
Filing No. MC(WA)/3178/2025 perish and the same are dismissed.
[22]
As it would be evident from the narrative thus far, as the
main WA was taken up in the admission stage itself with the consent of
both sides when the matter was listed for CoD MC hearing, Registry
shall now assign a number to the writ appeal as well as the MC for stay
thereat and thereafter furnish copies to the parties concerned. This shall
be done by the Registry by tomorrow, i.e., 13.01.2026. As already
alluded to supra, captioned State writ appeal being Filing No.
WA/3176/2025 and MC thereat bearing Filing No. MC(WA)/3178/2025
fail and the same are dismissed. To be noted CoD MC being MC (W.A.)
No. 123 of 2025 has been allowed as already alluded to supra overturn
(paragraph 6) in this order. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sandeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review