Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
Reserved on : 02.04.2026
Pronounced on : 08.06.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 08TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
WRIT APPEAL NO. 1989 OF 2025 (KLR-LG)
C/W
WRIT APPEAL NO. 833 OF 2025 (KLR-LG)
IN WA No. 1989/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
THE SPECIAL DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER,
BANGALORE DISTRICT,
KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALURU - 560 009.
3.
THE TECHNICAL ASSISTANT AND
DESIGNATED DDLR,
OFFICE OF DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALURU - 560 009.
REKHA R
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. I. THARANATH POOJARY AAG A/W
SRI. M.N. SUDEV HEGDE, AGA)
-2-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
AND:
1.
SRI. R. CHANDRU,
S/O. SRI. D. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
RESIDING NEAR
VENUGOPALASWAMY TEMPLE,
DEVASANDRA MAIN ROAD,
K.R. PURAM POST,
BENGALURU - 560 036.
2.
BRUHAT BENGALURU
MAHANAGARA PALIKE
MAHADEVAPURA RANGE,
BENGALURU - 560 048,
BY ITS COMMISSIONER.
3.
SRI. MACHI MADIWALARA
KSHEMABHIVRUDHI SANGHA (R),
NO. 26, BASAVANAPURA DHOBIGHAT,
NEAR MARIYAMMA TEMPLE,
SWATHANTHRA NAGAR,
VEERGO POST,
BENGALURU-560049.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ADITYA SONDHI SR. ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. KARTHICK V., ADVOCATE FOR C/R1)
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED U/S 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO CALL FOR RECORDS ON WP
NO.3148/2024 AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED:25.04.2025
THEREIN, THE SAID WRIT PETITION BE DISMISSED AND PASS
ANY OTHER ORDER OR ORDERS OR DIRECTION.
IN WA NO. 833/2025
BETWEEN:
SRI MACHI MADIWALARA
KESHMABHIVRIDHI SANGHA (R),
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SRI. MUNIRAJU
-3-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
NO. 26, BASAVANAPURA DHOBIGHAT,
NEAR MARIYAMMA TEMPLE,
SWATHANTRA NAGAR, VEERGO POST,
BENGALURU - 560 049.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. MARILINGE GOWDA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
M.S. BUILDING, AMBEDKAR VEEDI,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
THE SPECIAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
BENGALURU DISTRICT,
KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALURU - 560 009.
3.
THE TECHNICAL ASSISTANT AND
DESIGNATED DDLR,
OFFICE OF DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
KANDAYA BHAVAN,
BENGALURU - 560 009.
4.
BRUHAT BENGALURU
MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
MAHADEVAPURA RANGE,
BENGALURU - 560 048,
BY ITS COMMISSIONER
5.
SRI. R. CHANDRA,
S/O. SRI. D. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
RESIDING NEAR
VENGUPLALASWAMY TEMPLE,
DEVASANDRA MAIN ROAD,
K.R. PURAM POST,
BENGALURU - 560 036.
...RESPONDENTS
-4-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
(BY SRI. I. THARANATH POOJARY AAG, A/W
SRI. M.N. SUDEV HEGDE, AGA FOR R1 TO R3,
MS. PAVITHRA. N., ADVOCATE FOR C/R)
THIS WRIT IS APPEAL FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO CALL FOR
RECORDS IN W.P No.3148/2024 AND SET ASIDE THE
IMPUGNED ORDER DATED:25.04.2025 IN WP No.3148/2024
WITH COST AND ETC.,
THESE APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR JUDGMENT, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT IS DELIVERED/ PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M. NADAF)
These appeals, being W.A.No.1989/2025 by the
State and its instrumentalities and W.A.No.833/2025 by
respondent No.5 in the Writ Petition, calling in question
the order dated 25.04.2025 passed by the Writ Court in
W.P.No.3148/2024.
2.
The Writ Court vide impugned order allowed the
Writ Petition, set-aside the order dated 13.05.2009 passed
by the Deputy Commissioner (Annexure-E) and the order
-5-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
dated 01.09.2023 passed by the Technical Assistant to
Deputy Commissioner (Annexure-R) with further direction
in a time bound manner.
3.
The parties are referred to as per their ranking
before the Writ Court.
4.
Facts germane to file these appeals are as
under:
5.
At the outset, as per the rival contentions of
both the parties, we are called upon to deliberate upon the
issue of delay on the part of the State instrumentalities in
re-classification of mode of land from A-Kharab to BKharab, that too as per the contentions of the petitioner
without issuing any notice as contemplated under Rule 21
of Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966.
5.1
The petitioner filed the Writ Petition seeking following
reliefs:
"MAIN PRAYER
Wherefore, it is prayed that this Hon'ble
Court may kindly be pleased to:
-6-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
i.
Issue a Writ in the nature of certiorari or any
other writ or direction quashing the order
dated 13.05.2009 in No.LND(Poo)CR:47/07-08
passed
by
the
Deputy
Commissioner,
Bengaluru a copy of which is produced at
Annexure-E.
ii.
Issue a Writ of certiorari or any other writ or
direction quashing the order dated 1.9.2023
passed by the Technical Assistant to Deputy
Commissioner & Designated D D L R, office of
Deputy
Commissioner,
Kandaya
Bhavan,
Bengaluru 560 009, a copy of which is
produced at Annexure-R.
iii.
Grant such other reliefs, as this Hon'ble Court
deems
fit
and
proper
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case, in the interest of
justice and equity."
5.2
The petitioner claims that he is the absolute owner in
possession and enjoyment of 04 Acres 18 Guntas of
land including 04 Acres 09 Guntas of Kharab land in
Sy.No.26/1. The petitioner traces title based on
registered Sale Deed dated 25.11.2013 executed by
the erstwhile owner of the property.
5.3
The petitioner claims that the originally, the land to
an extent of 05 Acres and 04 Acres 09 Guntas of
Kharab land was granted to R.K.Muthukrishna in
-7-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
Sy.No.26
of
Basavanapura,
Bengaluru
South
Following
the
vide
grant,
K.R.Puram
order
dated
Saguvali
Chit
Hobli,
30.08.1966.
was
issued
(Annexures-B and C respectively). Subsequently, the
land was subjected to durasth and the extent was
corrected as 04 Acres 28 Guntas instead of 05 Acres
along with 04 Acres 09 guntas kharab land and the
land granted to petitioner's vendor was assigned a
fresh Sy.No.26/1 as per Annexure-D in the year
1983.
5.4
It was contended that on 13.05.2009, the then
Deputy Commissioner1 passed an order allotting an
extent of 01 Acre 20 Guntas of land in Sy.No.26 in
favour of
respondent
No.5
-
Bruhat
Bengaluru
Mahanagara Palike2 through an Official Memorandum
dated 08.07.2009. Aggrieved by the said act of the
then DC allotting the land which according to the
petitioner forms part in the land belonging to his
vendor which was conveyed to him subsequently
'DC', for short
the BBMP, for short
-8-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
under the aforesaid sale deed, filed a Revision before
the DC seeking to establish his title and possession in
question as well as other adjoining lands. After
initiation of the Revision, an inquiry was conducted
by the DC and upon detailed consideration of the
records and materials available, an order dated
24.11.2015 came to be passed as per Annexure-G,
unequivocally holding that the lands claimed and
held by the petitioner were not Government lands,
thereby recognizing the petitioner's right over the
said property.
5.5
It is further claimed that, following the DC's order,
the jurisdictional Tahsildar initiated appropriate steps
by addressing a communication to the Assistant
Director of Land Records3, requesting a formal
survey of 01 Acre 20 Guntas of land in Sy.No.26
which had been previously granted to BBMP. In the
midst of processing the above action, the petitioner
was constrained to file W.P.No.22154/2021 seeking a
the ADLR, for short
-9-
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
writ of mandamus to direct the concerned authorities
to remove the illegal entries made as "Sarkari Beedu
Banjara" in the column of the revenue records such
as the Karda and Pakka book, which adversely
affecting his title. The Writ Court vide order dated
23.12.2021, disposed of the Writ Petition directing
the ADLR to consider the contents of the letter dated
08.07.2019 issued by the Technical Assistant to the
DC and to pass appropriate orders in a time bound
manner.
5.6
As there was no compliance, the same forced the
petitioner to initiate Contempt proceedings by filing
CCC No.1090/2022. In the contempt proceedings,
the ADLR submitted a compliance affidavit and
placed on record a copy of the sketch showing
enjoyment dated 19.07.2023, marked as Annexure-N.
The same confirms the possession and cultivation of
04 Acres 28 Guntas of agricultural land, which
includes 04 Acres 09 guntas classified as Kharab land,
thereby
supporting
petitioner's
long
standing
- 10 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
occupation, as also evidenced by documents placed
at Annexure-K.
5.7
As the matter stood thus, the petitioner aggrieved by
the subsequent and arbitrary action of the Technical
Assistant to the DC and the designated Deputy
Director of Land Records4, who by means of order
dated 01.09.2023 proceeded to reclassify a portion
of land measuring 03 Acres 20 Guntas from 'A'
Kharab to 'B' Kharab, the petitioner contended that
this
reclassification
was
done
without
notice,
justification, or adherence to due process, and stated
that perhaps it appears to have been undertaken
solely to facilitate diversion and grant of the said
land in favour of respondent No.5. The said order
stated
supra
dated
01.09.2023
passed
by
the
Technical Assistant to DC and the DDLR and the
order passed by the DC dated 13.05.2009 were the
subject matter in the Writ Petition.
the DDLR, for short
- 11 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
5.8
Before the Writ Court, the petitioner contended that
the land was granted to his vendor by means of
Grant way back in the year 1966 and after durasth in
the year 1983, extent of land corrected along with
showing the adjacent land which is A-Kharab land
measuring 04 Acres 09 Guntas is in the cultivation of
the petitioner's vendor, the same was conveyed by
means of Sale Deed in the year 2013 and the
petitioner is enjoying the same without there being
any interference from any person. However, by
means
of
order
stated
supra,
there
started
interference by the BBMP as well as respondent No.5
and other State authorities.
5.9
He further contended that Annexure-K & N clearly
shows the continued possession and enjoyment of
the
petitioner
and
his
occupation.
In
these
circumstances, the orders passed are untenable.
However, the learned counsel for the Government,
learned counsel for the BBMP and learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.5 denied the rights of
- 12 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
the petitioner and supported the order stating that
what was granted was only 04 Acres 28 Guntas and
the lands were properly classified as per the records.
5.10 The Writ Court having found that the action of the
revenue authorities are deliberated and arbitrary in
reclassification of the petitioner's land and these
drastic and unlawful steps of reclassifying portion of
petitioner's holding from A-Kharab to B-Kharab was
only to facilitate and benefit respondent No.5, the
Writ Court following the Judgment of this Court in the
case
of
OTHERS5
MUNIYAPPA
and
VS.
NANJAPPA
TAHSILDAR
VS.
STATE
AND
OF
KARNATAKA6, held that the entire exercise of
reclassification of A-Kharab to B-Kharab was without
following due process of law and as such, the same is
illegal and unlawful. The Writ Court has held that the
records produced unambiguously demonstrate that
the land now sought to be appropriated in favour of
respondent No.5 was in fact part of the land already
(2003) ILR KAR 400
(2015) 2 KCCR 1449
- 13 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
acknowledged as being in possession and enjoyment
of the petitioner, which is evident from the Sketch
and durast proceedings following sub-division and resurvey clearly shows the petitioner's holdings from
the rest of the survey number. On this, the Writ
Court has held that the classification of land as AKharab denotes that although the land may not be
presently assessed to land revenue, it remains under
the possession and control of the land holder and
does
not
vest
in
the
State.
Therefore,
any
reclassification of such land into B-Kharab implying
its conversion into Government land cannot be
undertaken
by
executive
fiat
or
internal
correspondence. It must necessarily be preceded by
a detailed inquiry, wherein the landholder is afforded
full opportunity to be heard, as mandated by
principles of natural justice and settled judicial
precedents stated supra.
5.11 Having held so, the Writ Court concluded that the
action of the State authorities by means of impugned
- 14 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
order at Annexure-E and R are liable to be quashed,
passed the following:
ORDER
(i)
Writ Petition is allowed;
(ii)
The order dated 13.05.2009 passed in
No.LND(POO)CR:47/07-08
by
respondent No.2/Deputy Commissioner
as per Annexure-E is hereby quashed
and set-aside. Consequently, the order
dated 01.09.2023 passed by Technical
Assistant to Deputy Commissioner vide
Annexure-R is quashed and set-aside;
(iii)
The
respondent
Commissioner is
No.2/
Deputy
hereby directed to
restore the petitioner's name insofar as
3 acres 20 guntas of 'A' kharab in
Sy.No.26/1;
(iv)
This exercise shall be accomplished
within a period of eight weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this order.
It is this order passed by the Writ Court is called in
question in these appeals.
6.
Heard,
Sri.I.Tharanath
Poojary,
learned
Additional Advocate General assisted by Sri.M.N.Sudev
Hegde, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
State, Dr.Aditya Sondi, learned Senior counsel assisted by
- 15 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
Sri.Karthik.V, learned counsel for respondent No.1 in
W.A.No.1989/2025
and
Sri.Marilinge
counsel
for
the
appearing
Gowda,
appellant,
learned
Ms.Pavithra.N,
learned counsel appearing for caveator/ respondent and
Sri.I.Tharanath
Poojari,
learned
AAG
assisted
by
Sri.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned AGA for respondents 1 to 3
in W.A.No.833/2025.
7.
Though W.A.No.833/2025 is in the stage of
compliance of office objection, with consent of learned
counsel for the respective parties, it is heard finally with
W.A.No.1989/2025 filed by the State.
8.
Sri.I.Tharanath Poojari, learned AAG with all
vehemence submits that the Writ Court has erred in
holding that no notice was issued to the petitioner, as the
land belongs to Government, there is no necessity of
issuing notice to the petitioner, as such the impugned
order is unsustainable in law. Secondly, if the Writ Court
was of the opinion that there is no notice, it ought to have
remanded the matter to pass a fresh order, however the
Writ Court has quashed the entire order by allowing the
- 16 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
Writ Petition out-rightly closing the matter. Thirdly, the
Writ Court has not considered the detailed objection filed
by the State wherein notice was issued to BBMP for
payment of amount and accordingly, the BBMP has paid
the amount for the said land and the land after considering
the claim of respondent No.5 has been allotted for
construction of Dhobighat. Fourthly, it was contended that
the B-Kharab land is a Government land and the petitioner
is not entitled to be granted with said land, as such no
right flows in favor of the petitioner as contended in the
Writ Petition. The Writ Court without considering these
aspects of the matter has allowed the Writ Petition.
Accordingly, he sought to dismiss the Writ Petition.
9.
appearing
Dr.Aditya
Sondi,
for
contesting
the
learned
Senior
respondent/
counsel
petitioner
submits as follows:
9.1
Firstly, the entire action was contemplated against
the provisions contained in Rule 21 of the Karnataka
Land
Revenue
Rules
stating
that
before
any
reclassification, the same could have been done by
- 17 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
undertaking
petitioner
a
survey
with
due
and
other
affected
notice
persons.
to
the
Without
resorting to such a procedure as contemplated under
the Rules, any exercise done is unsustainable in law.
To buttress his argument, learned Senior counsel
relied on the judgment of coordinate bench of this
Court in STATE OF KARNATAKA AND OTHERS VS,
SRI.T.UMA SHANKAR AND ANOTHER7.
9.2
Secondly, learned Senior counsel submits that all the
rights were settled from 1966 to 1983, at a later
point of time, it is not amenable that too after 26
years to the DC (as he has passed the order on
13.05.2009) nearly after 40 years to DDLR (as he
has passed the order in 2023) to reclassify the lands,
as the said actions are barred by limitation.
9.3
Learned Senior counsel further submitted that in
cases where the delay is sought to be condoned by
offering the explanation of bureaucratic lethargy or
red-tapism must be one of the circumspection and
W.A.NO.1560/2024 disposed of on 17.03.2026
- 18 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
reluctance, the Court ought to loathe in accepting
such explanation as sufficient cause. The Court while
exercising constitutional powers, be very careful and
slow in condoning the delays on such reasons, and
exceptional instances where the explanation is found
to be genuine, reflective of reasonable vigilance and
promptitude
in
conduct,
and
free
from
gross
negligence, or casual indifference, should such an
explanation be accepted. In the case on hand, there
is no such explanation forthcoming for the delayed
action. The entire thing has already been settled in
favour of the vendors of the petitioner long back by
classifying the lands as A-Kharab way back in the
year 1983 and shown that the vendors of the
petitioner
were
in
possession
of
property
and
continuing. In that view of the matter, learned Senior
counsel contends that the unexplained bureaucratic
apathy & lethargy bars the authority from taking any
action of reclassifying the land at the belated point of
time.
- 19 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
9.4
It is further contended that in the Contempt Petition
which was filed for non-compliance of the order
passed by the Writ Court on the earlier point of time,
a
Sketch
and
report
was
submitted
stating
compliance with the order, which clearly shows and
put quietus to the long standing claim of occupation
by the petitioner and supported his claim and now it
is not available for the State Authorities to go back
from the same after considerable delay of time and
undo the things and create unrest, as the land is not
the Government Land and coming within the purview
of A-Kharab. To substantiate his argument, learned
Senior counsel placed reliance on the Judgment of
Supreme Court in SHIVAMMA (DEAD) BY LRS VS.
KARNATAKA HOUSIGN BOARD AND OTHERS8.
With this, sought to dismiss the Writ Appeals.
10.
Whereas, learned counsel for respondent No.5
in the Writ Petition, argued in line with the State
Government and submits that the land has been granted
2025 SCC ONLINE SC 1969
- 20 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
in favour of the respondent No.5 organization after
classifying the land as B-Kharab which is in accordance
with law and they are the beneficiaries belonging to
suppressed class and land has been granted for their
benefit
cannot
be
undone
at
this
point
of
time.
Accordingly, sought to allow the appeal at least with
respect to setting aside the grant made in their favor as
the same was prior to the petitioner purchasing the
property.
11.
Having given our anxious thought to the rival
submissions, we have perused the entire Writ appeal
papers in both the appeals as well as judgments relied on
by the parties.
12.
The point of limitation as raised by learned
Senior counsel for the petitioner is no more res-integra
with the conclusion of the point of law by the Supreme
Court in catena of cases and especially in the case of
SHIVAMMA
supra,
wherein
the
Supreme
Court
at
Paragraphs No.257 to 260 has clearly stated and held on
the lethargic actions of the State instrumentalities in
- 21 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
taking any actions without proper explanations for such
delayed actions. The said paragraphs reads as under:
257. We also wish to highlight that the High Court
applied the legal position incorrectly in the impugned
order and performed an exercise of “merit-hunting”. It
gave a prima facie relevance to the argument of the
respondent no. 1 on the grounds that the suit of the
appellant was not at all maintainable in the first place.
In paragraph 13 of the impugned order, the High
Court recorded that a semblance of right in favour of
respondent no. 1 swayed its mind to allow the
condonation of delay, and it accepted the same as a
“sufficient cause”. We hold such observations to be
erroneous and ex facie bad in law. Similar contentions
were rejected by this Court in State of Madhya
Pradesh v. Bherulal, (2020) 10 SCC 654, wherein the
appellant-State was seeking a condonation of delay of
663 days. This Court sternly noted that it will not let
the courts to be forums wherein the Government can
walk-in, when it desires, entirely ignoring the period of
limitation, and buttress reliance on cases of this Court
wherein it allowed condonation, employing its
discretionary powers, on merits or modalities of
peculiarities of those cases. Relevant paragraphs are
extracted below:
“3. No doubt, some leeway is given for the
government inefficiencies but the sad part is that
the authorities keep on relying on judicial
pronouncements for a period of time when
technology had not advanced and a greater leeway
was given to the Government […]
xxx xxx xxx
5. A preposterous proposition is sought to be
propounded that if there is some merit in the case,
the period of delay is to be given a go-by. If a case
is good on merits, it will succeed in any case. It is
really a bar of limitation which can even shut out
good cases. This does not, of course, take away
the jurisdiction of the Court in an appropriate case
to condone the delay.
6. We are also of the view that the aforesaid
approach is being adopted in what we have
categorised earlier as “certificate cases”. The
- 22 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
object appears to be to obtain a certificate of
dismissal from the Supreme Court to put a quietus
to the issue and thus, say that nothing could be
done because the highest Court has dismissed the
appeal. It is to complete this formality and save
the skin of officers who may be at default that such
a process is followed. We have on earlier occasions
also strongly deprecated such a practice and
process. There seems to be no improvement. The
purpose of coming to this Court is not to obtain
such certificates and if the Government suffers
losses, it is time when the officer concerned
responsible for the same bears the consequences.
The irony is that in none of the cases any action is
taken against the officers, who sit on the files and
do nothing. It is presumed that this Court will
condone the delay and even in making
submissions, straightaway the counsel appear to
address on merits without referring even to the
aspect of limitation as happened in this case till we
pointed out to the counsel that he must first
address us on the question of limitation.
7. We are thus, constrained to send a signal
and we propose to do in all matters today, where
there are such inordinate delays that the
Government or State authorities coming before us
must pay for wastage of judicial time which has its
own value. Such costs can be recovered from the
officers responsible.”
(Emphasis supplied)
258. The length of the delay is a relevant matter
which the court must take into consideration while
considering whether the delay should be condoned or
not. From the tenor of the approach of the
respondents, it appears that they want to fix their own
period of limitation for instituting the proceedings for
which law has prescribed a period of limitation. Once it
is held that a party has lost his right to have the
matter considered on merits because of his own
inaction for a long, it cannot be presumed to be nondeliberate delay and in such circumstances of the case,
it cannot be heard to plead that the substantial justice
deserves to be preferred as against the technical
considerations. While considering the plea for
condonation of delay, the court must not start with the
merits of the main matter. The court owes a duty to
- 23 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
first ascertain the bona fides of the explanation offered
by the party seeking condonation. It is only if the
sufficient cause assigned by the litigant and the
opposition of the other side is equally balanced that
the court may bring into aid the merits of the matter
for the purpose of condoning the delay.
259. We are of the view that the question of
limitation is not merely a technical consideration. The
rules of limitation are based on the principles of sound
public policy and principles of equity. We should not
keep the ‘Sword of Damocles’ hanging over the head
of the respondent for indefinite period of time to be
determined at the whims and fancies of the appellants.
260. From the above exposition of law, it is
abundantly clear that the High Court has erroneously
condoned a massive delay of 3966 days on account of
certain lapses at the administrative levels and of there
being no follow-ups in the proceedings, along with
finding certain merits in the case of the respondent no.
1 against the maintainability of the suit of the
appellant and that of the relief molded by the First
Appellate Court. We have no hesitation in stating that
such grounds are nowhere near to being “sufficient
cause” as per Section 5 of the 1963 Act. The High
Court lost sight of the fact that the precedents and
authorities it relied upon by it had delays of two-digits,
or even that of single-digit, more particularly the delay
in those cases was supported by sufficient cause. The
present case, however, stands on a very different
footing, owing to such an enormous delay. Hence, we
are not inclined to accept the condonation of the delay
by the High Court.
13.
The coordinate bench of this Court in the case
of STATE OF KARNATAKA VS. M.SHASHIDHAR9 has
considered the delay in taking appropriate action by the
State Government. Even in the said case, there was
drastic delay in taking action in filing the Writ petition
W.P.No.31978/2025 disposed of on 07.11.2025
- 24 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
against the order passed by the Tribunal. The coordinate
Bench of this Court in paragraph No.13 and 14 has held as
under:
"13. The doctrine of delay and latches should
not be brushed aside lightly. The writ Court, while
exercising power under Articles 226 is required to
weigh the explanation offered and the acceptability
of the same, since the pivotal amplification is, it is
exercising an extraordinary jurisdiction.
14. The State cannot claim any exception to
the
case
when there
is
delay and latches
in
approaching the Court, than a citizen - party/litigant.
The delay does bring in hazard and causes injury to
the lis. As the delay defeats all the rights. On
scrutiny of the entire case papers, we find no reason
to condone the inordinate delay. This Court, if it
ignores the obvious and enormous delay, will foster
injustice, as it is likely to affect others. A finality
attained cannot be permitted to be reopened if there
is unreasonable lapse of time. The unexplained delay
of six years four months is fatal to the case on hand.
On this count alone, the writ petition is liable to be
rejected, and is accordingly rejected."
14.
In these circumstances, the delay caused in
doing high handed acts of State Authorities undoing the
earlier settled position is highly arbitrary, erroneous and is
- 25 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
unsustainable in law. On this account only, the Writ
Appeals are required to be dismissed.
15.
We find force in the argument of learned Senior
counsel for the contesting respondent/ petitioner that
there
is
a
total
diversion
from
the
proceedings
incorporated under Rule 21 of Karnataka Land Revenue
Rules, 1966 by the authority before even reclassification of
the land. We are in complete agreement with the
judgment relied on by the learned Senior counsel in the
case of STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs T.UMA SHANKAR
supra, wherein the coordinate Bench of this Court upon
considerable deliberation on the provision of Rule 21 has
held that any actions giving a go-bye to the procedure
contemplated under said Rule is unsustainable in law.
16.
We have gone through the order passed by the
Writ Court. The Writ Court with all pains, empathetically
considered the entire case of the petitioner on the basis of
records placed, properly considered the same in its finding
especially at Paragraph Nos.9, 12, 14, 16 which reads as
under:
- 26 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
"9. In light of the above, a deeper and closer
scrutiny of the official records leaves no room for doubt
that
the
authorities,
having
realized
that
no
unencumbered or vacant land was available within
Survey No.26, resorted to a deliberate and arbitrary
reclassification of the petitioner’s land. In an apparent
attempt to make land available for the benefit of
respondent No.5, the authorities have taken the drastic
and unlawful step of reclassifying a portion of the
petitioner’s holding , specifically, 3 acres and 20 guntas
of 'A' kharab land to 'B' kharab. This reclassification is
not only factually and legally unsustainable, but also
appears to be a calculated effort to divest the petitioner
of his lawful holding under the guise of administrative
action. The petitioner contends that the classification of
the land as 'A' kharab had already been settled and
acknowledged by the authorities themselves, and that
such land, though termed kharab, remained in his
possession and was not subject to any competing claim
or public use.
xxxx
xxxx
12. On a detailed examination of records, more
particularly the sketch furnished by the respondent
officials in contempt proceedings evidenced at AnnexureN coupled with RTC which is evidenced at Annexure-K
and the durasth proceedings evidenced at Annexure-D, it
is clearly evident that petitioner owns a cultivable portion
measuring 4 acres 20 guntas and 3 acres 20 guntas of
'A'
kharab land. Time
and again, this
Court has
consistently held that 'A' kharab land is clearly attached
- 27 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
to the owners and the State has no control over 'A'
kharab lands.
xxxx
14.
Further,
the
RTC
for
Survey
No.26/1
categorically indicates that an extent of 3 acres 20
guntas is classified as 'A' kharab. This classification, as
consistently held by this Court in binding precedents
such as
Muniyappa vs. Tahsildar and
Others
and
Nanjappa vs. State of Karnataka, carries significant legal
implications. The classification of land as 'A' kharab
denotes that although the land may not be presently
assessed
to
land
revenue,
it
remains
under
the
possession and control of the landholder and does not
vest in the State. Therefore, any reclassification of such
land
into
'B'
kharab
implying
its
conversion
into
government land cannot be undertaken by executive fiat
or internal correspondence. It must necessarily be
preceded by a detailed enquiry, wherein the landholder
is afforded full opportunity to be heard, as mandated by
principles
of
natural
justice
and
settled
judicial
precedents.
xxxx
16. The impugned orders passed by the Technical
Assistant to the Deputy Commissioner and the Deputy
Director
of
Land
Annexures-E and
Records,
R,
are
which
therefore
are
produced
patently
at
illegal,
arbitrary, and unsustainable in law. These orders have
been passed in violation of the principles of natural
justice, without notice or hearing to the petitioner, and in
contravention of the settled legal position laid down by
this Court regarding the treatment of 'A' kharab lands.
The attempt to dispossess the petitioner of his land
- 28 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
under the guise of reclassification and subsequent grant
is manifestly malafide and cannot be permitted to
stand."
17.
though
We
having
have
no
considered
contra
the
opinion
entire
with
material,
respect
to
reclassification of the land, but the facts of the case when
viewed, particularly the grant in favor of respondent No.5
- Sri Machi Madiwalara Kshemabhivridhi Sangha (R) which
came to be made by means of order dated 13.05.2009,
allotting an extent of land measuring 01 Acre 20 Guntas in
favor of respondent No.5. The fact remains that the
vendor i.e., the original Grantee has not staked any
challenge to the order of grant of 01 Acre 20 Guntas and
the same remain as it is for a period of four years. This in
our considered opinion amounts to acquiescence to the
order passed by the State authorities. Though the land is
classified as A-kharab which is available to the adjacent
land which is granted in favor of the petitioner's vendor,
but the State being the sovereign and ultimate owner of
land, in exercise of its sovereign power granted the land
through
its
authorities
in
favor
of
appellant
in
- 29 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
W.A.No.833/2025. Since there was no challenge by the
petitioner's vendor and the same as we have stated above
comes within the purview of acquiescence, what could
have been conveyed by the vendor is the rest of the lands
remained after deducting 01 Acre 20 Guntas. The fact
remains that the petitioner became owner of the land only
on the basis of registered Sale Deed dated 25.11.2013.
18.
The Writ Court missed this point. Though the
Writ Court is right in all other aspect on reclassification of
the land, however in view of no challenge made by the
vendor and in view of the fact that the land has already
been granted prior to the purchase of land by the
petitioner, we find force in the argument of the learned
counsel for the appellant in W.A.No.833/2025 that the
land granted in their favor to an extent of 01 Acre 20
Guntas be saved. Accordingly, both the appeals require to
be allowed to that extent. However, we find no infirmity in
the order passed by the Writ Court in all other aspects.
19.
For the aforesaid reasons, we partly allow
both the appeals, setting aside the order passed by the
- 30 -
WA No. 1989 of 2025
C/W WA No. 833 of 2025
Writ Court only with respect to grant of land to an extent
of 01 Acre 20 Guntas in favor of the appellant in
W.A.No.833/2025 /respondent No.5 in the Writ Petition. In
all other aspects, the order of the Writ Court is confirmed.
With these observations, the Writ Appeals stand disposed
of modifying the order passed by the Writ court, thereby
saving the land granted in favor of respondent No.5 - Sri
Machi Madiwalara Kshemabhivridhi Sangha (R) to an
extent of 01 Acre 20 Guntas in Sy.No.26 of Basavanapura,
K.R.Puram Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk. Given the facts
and circumstances, no order as to costs.
20.
In view of disposal of the appeals, pending
interlocutory application/s, if any does not survive for
consideration and the same stand disposed of.
Sd/(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE
TKN
Ct: Vn
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review