Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$$
%
&% ' $ ()*
%
(
+
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"#"$%
&
'# $
(
&
)%' $* *%$
*
' $
*%$$
$ +
$
*
-2-
$,##
&
)
-
)
#
./ 0121/ .20 34/5/44/+ 1.60 233/27 2826901 1./ :;+8</91 =5
2>?;61127 +21/+ %' $* *%$ 3200/+ 69
/006=90
E./4/@A 1./
;+8/ 21
272@;486
C1./
20/ *
*%$$ @A 1./
5=4 @4/B61A C 4627
=;41D
=;41 2>?;611/+ 1./ 4/03=9+/91!2>>;0/+ 5=4
1./ =55/9>/0 3;960.2@7/ ;9+/4
/>16=9 $
* =5 4/B/916=9 =5
/>16=90 ' 29+ $
$ +
4 E
=44;316=9 2>1 $,## 5=4 @4/B61A
>1D
*
./
2@46+8/+
52>10
=5
4/03=9+/91 2>>;0/+ E20 E=4F698 20
=92029.2776
@=9+ =5
./
1./
>20/
24/
98292E2+6 E=4F/4 21
=B/49</91 .2+ 029>16=9/+
.28A272F0.<6
0 $ %% %%% ! 5=4 >=<37269291G0 +2;8.1/4 =9/
2<@.=+.696
23376>216=9
1./
1=
600;29>/ =5 @=9+
0;>.
1./
1.21
.4;016
>=<37269291
0;@<611/+
98292E2+6
/914/
=920292.2776
5=4
1 1.21 16</
1./ 4/03=9+/91 2>>;0/+
+64/>1/+ 1./ >=<37269291 1= 5;4960. 1./ +=>;</910 27=98 E61.
-3-
1./ 3.=1=8423.0
+=>;</910
=5
>>=4+6987A 1./ >=<37269291 5;4960./+ 1.=0/
/0361/ 1./ 2>>;0/+ +/<29+/+ 677/827 8421656>216=9
0 $ %%% ! 5=4 600;29>/ =5
0./ +/<29+/+
.28A272F0.<6 @=9+ 29+ 69616277A
0 "%% ! 1.4=;8. 3.=9/
./ 026+ >=9B/40216=9
E20 4/>=4+/+ @A 1./ >=<37269291 69 .60 <=@67/ 29+ ./
2334=2>./+ 1./
46</
=
=F2A;F12
=76>/ 29+ 7=+8/+ 1./ >=<372691 69
*%$% 5=4 1./ 25=4/</916=9/+ =55/9>/0
./4/251/4
1./ 233/77291! =76>/ >=9+;>1/+ 29 /914;01/+ <2.2H24 726+ 2
1423 29+ 244/01/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ 4/>=B/4/+ 1./ 12691/+
>;44/9>A
;@0/?;/917A
1./ 233/77291! =76>/ 726+ 2 >.248/
0.//1 2826901 1./ 2>>;0/+ 5=4 1./ 25=4/026+ =55/9>/0 @/5=4/ 1./
=;41
= 34=B/ 1./ >.248/0 7/B/7/+ 2826901 1./ 2>>;0/+
@/5=4/ 1./
E619/00/0 20
=;41 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 69 1=127 /I2<69/+ $%
0 $ 1= $% <24F/+ *' +=>;</910 20
*' 29+ 6+/91656/+ , <21/4627 =@:/>10 20
1./
I0 $ 1=
0 $ 1= ,
J
9 200/00</91 =5 =427 29+ +=>;</9124A /B6+/9>/
=;41 2>?;611/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 5=4 1./ >.248/0 7/B/7/+
2826901 ./4
69 1.60 233/27
./ 026+ :;+8</91 60 >.277/98/+ @A 1./ =F2A;F12
-4-
"
/24+ 7/249/+
3/>627 >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 233/77291!
=F2A;F12 29+ 1./ 7/249/+ >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 4/03=9+/91!2>>;0/+
3241 54=< ;48698 0/B/427 >=91/916=90
7/249/+
3/>627 >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 233/77291 346<2467A >=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./
:;+8</91 ;9+/4 1.60 233/27 0;55/40 54=< 3/4B/4061A 29+
677/82761A
069>/ 1./
=;41 .2B/ 5267/+ 2334/>621/ 1./
/B6+/9>/ 69 2 468.1 3/403/>16B/
/ >=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./ /B6+/9>/
=5 >=<37269291 29+ 1423 329>.292<2 E619/00/0 >21/8=46>277A
/012@760./+ 1.21 1./ 2>>;0/+ +/<29+/+ 677/827 8421656>216=9 29+
270= 4/>/6B/+ 1./ 02</ 54=< 1./ >=<37269291
./ 0/6H/4 =5
>;44/9>A 9=1/0 29+ 1./ >./<6>27 /I2<69216=9 =5 1./ .29+0 =5
2>>;0/+ >7/247A /012@760./+ 1./ 4/>=B/4A =5 12691/+ <=9/A
0;>. >64>;<0129>/ 1./ =55/9>/0 ;9+/4 1./
>1 >7/247A 34=B/+
@/A=9+ 277 4/20=92@7/ +=;@1 20 ./7+ @A 1./
=9G@7/
3/I
=;41
69 1./ >20/ =5
!"#$!%!& 29+ @A 1.60
=;41
* ' *
'
277=E 1./ 233/27
(
)
+!,%!$!%!&
*
>>=4+6987A ./ 342A0 1=
-5-
'
7/249/+ >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 4/03=9+/91
>=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./
=;41 251/4 </16>;7=;07A /I2<69698 1./
/B6+/9>/ =9 4/>=4+ 468.17A 2>?;611/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 69 2 E/77
4/20=9/+ :;+8</91 E.6>. +=/0 9=1 >277 5=4 29A 691/45/4/9>/ 21
1./ .29+0 =5 1.60
=;41
/ >=91/9+/+ 1.21 21 1./ =;10/1 1./
2>>;0/+ 60 9=1 2 3;@76> 0/4B291
069>/ 0./ E20 E=4F698 20
98292E2+6 0/4B291 =9 .=9=4246;<
;41./4 1./ +/<29+ 29+
2>>/3129>/ =5 @46@/ 60 9=1 21 277 34=B/+ 069>/ 1./ >=<37269291
0121/+ 1.21 1./ 2<=;91 E20 9=1 326+ 69 1./ =556>/ =5 2>>;0/+
29+ 1./ 02</ E20 326+ 69 2 .=1/7 E.67/ 2>>;0/+ 29+
>=<37269291 34=>//+698 9/24 1./ +==4 =5 .=1/7
;@0/?;/917A
1./ 233/77291! =76>/ >2;8.1 .=7+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ <2+/ ./4 1=
061 =9 2 >.264 69 2 .=1/7 29+ 12691/+ >;44/9>A 9=1/0 E/4/
4/>=B/4/+ 54=< 1./ 12@7/
9 0;>. >64>;<0129>/ 1./ 4/>=B/4A 60
9=1 34=B/+
/ 270= >=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./4/ E20 9= E=4F
3/9+/9>A
277/8/+
@A
1./
>=<37269291
;41./4
1./
>=<37269291 .20 2+<611/+ 1.21 ./ 29+ 2>>;0/+ .2+ @//9 1=
B246=;0 =556>/0 5=4 >=77/>16=9 =5 4/>=4+0 5=4 E.6>. 1./A 69>;44/+
/I3/90/0
0 0;>. 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 ;11/47A 5267/+ 1= 34=B/ 1./
8;671 =5 2>>;0/+
>>=4+6987A ./ 342A0 1= +60<600 1./ 233/27
-6-
#
.2B/ 86B/9 29I6=;0 >=906+/4216=9 @=1. =9 1./
0;@<6006=90 <2+/ @A 1./ 7/249/+ >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 4/03/>16B/
32416/0 29+ 1./ +=>;</910 2B2672@7/ =9 4/>=4+
,
0 >=;7+ @/ 821./4/+ 54=< 4/>=4+0 1= 34=B/ 1./
>.248/0 7/B/7/+ 2826901 1./ 2>>;0/+ 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 346<2467A
4/76/+ =9 1./ /B6+/9>/ =5
329>.
E619/00/0
<2.2H24! I $
5=4
$!>=<37269291
/914;01</91
0 * 29+
<2.2H24! I $
0/6H/4
29+ 4/>=B/4A =5 12691/+ <=9/A 20 3/4
#
9 >24/5;7 3/4;027 =5 1./0/ E619/00/0 2>>=4+698 1=
$
%
*%$%
+/<29+/+
1./
2>>;0/+
@/698
98292E2+6
0 $%%% ! 54=< .6< 5=4 600;29>/ =5
!1./
$ =9
E=4F/4
.28A272F0.<6
@=9+ 29+ 1./ 026+ >=9B/40216=9 +/<29+ E20 4/>=4+/+ @A .6<
69 .60 <=@67/ 3.=9/
./4/251/4
./ 7=+8/+ 1./ >=<372691
.=;8. 1./ 3.=9/ >277 +/12670 24/ 6+/91656/+ 29+ <24F/+ 21
I *'
1./ 02</ += 9=1 +60>7=0/ 1./ >=9B/40216=9 ./7+
@/1E//9 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ >=<37269291
$
+;4698 1./ 1423 =5 2>>;0/+
2<=;91
=;106+/
1./
.=1/7
29+
;41./4 61 60 0121/+ @A
0./ +/<29+/+ 1./ @46@/
0./
4/>/6B/+
./4/251/4 @20/+ =9 1./ 068927 69014;>16=9 =5
1./
02</
$ 1./
=76>/
>2;8.1 .=7+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ <2+/ ./4 1= 061 =9 2 >.264 69 1./
-7-
.=1/7 29+ 4/>=B/4/+ 1./ 12691/+ >;44/9>A 9=1/0 =5
1./ 12@7/
0 * 29+
0 "%% ! =9
@/698 1./ 0.2+=E E619/00/0 1.=;8.
2>>=<3296/+ 1./ >=<37269291 29+ 2>>;0/+
1./A .2B/ 9=1
E619/00/+ 1./ +/<29+ 29+ 2>>/3129>/ =5 @46@/ @A 1./ 2>>;0/+
>>=4+698 1= 1./< 1./A 27=98 E61.
$ 29+ 2>>;0/+ E/91 1=
1./ .=1/7 29+ 1./A 021 =9 2 @/9>. E./9 2>>;0/+ 29+
E/91 1=E24+0 1./ +==4 =5 1./ .=1/7
29+
$
$ 82B/ 2 068927 1= 1./<
=76>/ 29+ 0;@0/?;/917A 1./ 1423 E20 726+ =9 1./ 2>>;0/+
29+ 1./ 2<=;91 E20 0/6H/+ =9 1./ 12@7/ @A <2F698 1./ 2>>;0/+
1= 061 =9 2 >.264
/9>/ 61 60 >7/24 1.21
0 * 29+
E/4/ 270=
9=1 E619/00/+ 1./ +/<29+ =4 2>>/3129>/ =5 @46@/ @A 1./
2>>;0/+
$%
= +=;@1 1./ 4/>=B/4A =5 12691/+ >;44/9>A 9=1/0 =5
0 "%% ! E20 <2+/ =9 1./ 12@7/ =5 1./ 026+ .=1/7 21 1./
690129>/ =5 2>>;0/+ 29+ ./4 .29+0 E/4/ E20./+ E61. 0=+6;<
>24@=921/ 76?;6+ E.6>. 1;49/+ 691= 369F >=7=;4
.21 610/75
>299=1 @/ 2 84=;9+ 1= @/76/B/ 1.21 1./ 2>>;0/+ 4/>/6B/+ 1./
@46@/ 069>/ 1./
=76>/ <2+/ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 1= 061 =9 2 >.264 29+
<2+/ ./4 1= 372>/ 1./ >./<6>27 23376/+ >;44/9>A 9=1/0 =9 1./
12@7/ 29+ 4/>=B/4/+ 1./ 02</
;41./4 1./ =1./4 E619/00/0 6 /
-8-
0 J 1=
1.=;8. 0;33=41/+ 1./ >20/ =5 34=0/>;16=9 1./A 24/
9=1 29 /A/!E619/00/0 1= 1./ 69>6+/91
./ 69B/0168216=9 =556>/4!
$% >21/8=46>277A 2+<611/+ 1.21 1./ 4/>=B/4A 329>.292<2
E20 9=1 +42E9 21 1./ 03=1 =5 1423 29+ 1./ 02</ E20 +42E9 21
1./ 903/>16=9
$$
;9827=E
0 524 20 1./ 3/9+/9>A =5 1./ E=4F @/5=4/ 1./
2>>;0/+ 60 >=9>/49/+
$ 0121/+ 69 .60 /B6+/9>/ 1.21 ./ 29+
2>>;0/+ .2+ @//9 1= B246=;0 =556>/0 5=4 >=77/>16=9 =5 4/>=4+0 5=4
E.6>. 1./A 69>;44/+ /I3/90/0
./ 02</ >7/247A 4/B/270 1.21
1./ >=<37269291 .2+ 03/91 29 2<=;91 5=4 .2B698 69>;44/+ 1./
/I3/9+61;4/ 5=4 =@1269698 1./ +=>;</910 5=4 1./
@=9+ 29+ 21 1.21 16</
>=<37269291
.28A272F0.<6
1./ 2>>;0/+ 270= 2>>=<3296/+ 1./
./9 1./ >=<37269291 .6<0/75 2+<611/+ 1.21 ./
2>>=<3296/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ 03/91 <=9/A 5=4 =@1269698 1./
@=9+
1./4/ 60 9= ?;/016=9 =5 2>>;0/+ +/<29+698 677/827
8421656>216=9 1.21 1==
0 "%% ! 54=< 1./ >=<37269291
=B/4277 /I2<69216=9 =5 1./ /B6+/9>/
/9>/ =9
1./4/ 60 9= @/76/B2@7/
/B6+/9>/ 29+ >64>;<0129>/ 60 5=41.>=<698 =9 4/>=4+ 1.21 1./
2>>;0/+ /61./4 +/<29+/+ =4 4/>/6B/+ 1./ 677/827 8421656>216=9
54=< 1./ >=<37269291 20 277/8/+ @A .6<
-9-
$*
= +=;@1 1./
=5
=9G@7/
3/I
=;41 ./7+ 69 1./ >20/
;342
</4/ +/<29+ =4 0=76>61216=9
610/75 2<=;910 1= >=<<6006=9 =5 =55/9>/ ;9+/4
>1
/>16=9 ' =5
=E/B/4 69 1./ 6901291 >20/ 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 270= 5267/+ 1=
34=B/ 1./ +/<29+ =4 2>>/3129>/ =5 1./ @46@/ @A 1./ 2>>;0/+
@/A=9+ 4/20=92@7/ +=;@1
++616=9277A 1./ 2>>;0/+ @/698 29
98292E2+6 E=4F/4 29+ E=4F698 =9 .=9=4246;< 20 3/4 1./
/B6+/9>/ =5
'!
1./ 34=0/>;16=9 270= 5267/+ 1= /012@760.
1.21 0./ 60 2 3;@76> 0/4B291
$
./
=9G@7/
/
3/I
=;41 69 >20/ =5
.
"
)
4/3=41/+ 69 !%!
# + 726+ 1./ +6>1;< 1.21 1./ 34==5 =5 +/<29+
29+ 2>>/3129>/ =5 677/827 8421656>216=9 @A 2 3;@76> 0/4B291 20 2
52>1 69 600;/ @A 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 60 2
69 =4+/4 1=
/012@760. 1./ 8;671 =5 1./ 2>>;0/+ 3;@76> 0/4B291 ;9+/4
' 29+ $
$ + 6 29+ 66 =5 1./
$J
/
' *
./
=9G@7/
3/I
.
/>16=9
>1
=;41
1./
>20/
=5
4/3=41/+ 69 !%!+
,0# ./7+ 1.21 K2@0/9>/ =5 34==5 =5 +/<29+ 5=4 677/827
8421656>216=9 29+ </4/ 3=00/006=9 =4 4/>=B/4A =5 >;44/9>A 9=1/0
- 10 -
60 9=1 0;556>6/91 1= >=90161;1/ 0;>. =55/9>/ 29+ 1./ 34/0;<316=9
;9+/4
/>16=9 *% =5 1./
>1 >29 @/ +42E9 =97A 251/4 1./
+/<29+ 5=4 29+ 2>>/3129>/ =5 677/827 8421656>216=9 60 34=B/+
;41./4
1./
=9-@7/
3/I
=;41 69 32428423. $# ./7+ 20
;9+/4)!
+0
!
"
#
- 11 -
$"
3/I
1 60 0/117/+ 3=0616=9 =5 72E 726+ +=E9 @A 1./
=9-@7/
=;41 69 1./ 2@=B/ 026+ :;+8</910 1.21 1./ 34=0/>;16=9
<;01 /012@760. /2>. 29+ /B/4A >64>;<0129>/ 54=< E.6>. 1./
34=0/>;16=9 E2910 1./
=;41 1= +42E 2 >=9>7;06=9 =5 1./ 8;671
=4/=B/4
1./
=9-@7/
)'
'
(
)
+%
3/I
=;41
)'
)
1./
>20/
=5
)
4/3=41/+ 69
!%+&
+&! ./7+ 1.21 1./ 34==5 =5 +/<29+ >299=1 @/ 34=B/+
@A 1./ /B6+/9>/ =5 =1./4 E619/00/0 69 0;>. /B/91;2761A 1.=;8.
0;>. 4/>=B/4A 34=B/+ 1./ @/9/561 =5 +=;@1 0.=;7+ @/ /I1/9+/+
1= 1./ 2>>;0/+
/4/ 2>>/3129>/ =5 29A 2<=;91 277/8/+7A @A
E2A =5 +/<29+
E=;7+ 9=1 @/ 0;556>6/91 1= @4698
.=</ 1./ >.248/0 ;9+/4
$
/>16=90 ' 29+ $ =5 1./
9 1./ 2@=B/ 026+ :;+8</91 1./
@A 4/5/44698 1./ :;+8</91 =5
4/3=41/+ 69 !%+
842B/
+!
>1
=9G@7/
3/I
=;41
"%, ./7+ 1.21 0;036>6=9 .=E/B/4
>299=1 12F/ 1./ 372>/ =5 34==5 29+ 1./ 34=0/>;16=9
>299=1 255=4+ 1= 4/01 610 >20/ 69 1./ 4/27< =5 C<2A @/K @;1 .20
1= ;3842+/ 61 69 1./ +=<269 =5 C<;01 @/K 14;/ 69 =4+/4 1= 01//4
>7/24 =5 29A 3=006@7/ 0;4<60/ =4 >=9:/>1;4/
1 E20 ./7+ 1.21
- 12 -
1./
=;41 <;01 /90;4/ 1.21 <60>244628/ =5 :;016>/ 60 2B=6+/+
29+ 65 69 1./ 52>10 29+ >64>;<0129>/0 1E= B6/E0 24/ 372;06@7/
1./9 1./ @/9/561 =5 +=;@1 <;01 @/ 86B/9 1= 1./ 2>>;0/+
$'
3/I
.60 @/698 1./ 233/27 2826901 2>?;61127 1./
=;41 69 1./ >20/ =5 4 5
*
4/3=41/+ 69
6 )
!%!
/
&0+2 0;<<246H/+
1./ 3469>637/0 1= /I/4>60/ 1./ 3=E/4 @A 1./
691/45/4/ 69 1./ =4+/4 =5 1./
=9G@7/
33/7721/
=;41 1=
/006=90
=;41 69 32428423.
&
"
&
20 ;9+/4)
$7 %
'
&
&
"
'
(
&
&
*
&
)
+
&
&
(
)
=,
- 13 -
(
#
(
&
$#
(
,
;41./4
1./
=9G@7/
3/I
=;41 69 1./ >20/ =5
(
6 )
*
!%!"
&"" E.67/ 0;<<246H698 1./ 3469>637/0 69 +/27698
E61. 1./ 233/27 2826901 2>?;61127 69 32428423.
4/3=41/+ 69
= J* ./7+ 20
;9+/4)
$"! +
'
&
'
'
- &#. /-0/
2/3
67 &
6 7
'
6 7 #
- 14 -
6 7 #
'
6 7 #
)
6 7 #
,
$,
/9>/ >=77=>21698 1./ 3469>637/0 0;<<246H/+ 69 1./
2@=B/ :;+8</910 1= 1./ 52>10 29+ >64>;<0129>/0 =5 1.60 >20/
2< =5 1./ B6/E 1.21 1./
=;41 468.17A 2334/>621/+ 1./
/B6+/9>/ 29+ 2>?;611/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ E.6>. +=/0 9=1 >277 5=4 29A
691/45/4/9>/ 21 1./ .29+0 =5 1.60
=;41
>>=4+6987A
1= 3200 1./ 5=77=E698)
./
46<6927
33/27 60
,)
%
&
601 = ) $
=)$
)
(
34=>//+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review