Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
R
CNR: KAHC010469262025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.10339/2025
C/W
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.10314/2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.10321/2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.15550/2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.16275/2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.16338/2025
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.16367/2025
IN CRL.P No.10339/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
Digitally signed
by RUPA V
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
ABDUL JABBAR
S/O KUNHEEDU, BROTHER
OF DECEASED ASHRAF
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. TRRA-4
THRIKKOVIL ROAD
CHALIKKAVOTTOM
KANAYANNUR ERNAKULAM
KERALA 682 028.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. CLITON ROZARIO, ADV., FOR
SMT. MAITREYI KRISHNAN, ADV.,)
AND:
1.
MR. SACHIN
S/O RAJARAM
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS
R/AT KUDUPU VILLAGE
MANGALURU
DAKSHINA KANNADA.
2.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH MANGALUR RURAL
POLICE STATION, MANGALURU
DAKSHINA KANNADA DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARUNA SHYAM, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. SUYOG HERELE E, ADV., FOR R1
SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP FOR R2)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(1)(b) CR.PC (FILED U/S
483(1)(b) BNSS), PRAYING TO CANCEL THE BAIL ORDER
DATED 05.06.2025 IN CRL.MISC.NO.423/2025 PASSED BY THE
II ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE D.K. MANGALURU
(PLACED AS ANNEXURE-A). DIRECT HIS IMMEDITATE REARREST & ETC.
IN CRL.P NO. 10314/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
ABDUL JABBAR
S/O KUNHEEDU, BROTHER
OF DECEASED ASHRAF
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. TRRA-4
THRIKKOVIL ROAD
CHALIKKAVOTTOM
KANAYANNUR ERNAKULAM
KERALA 682 028.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. CLIFTON ROZARIO, ADV., FOR
SMT. MAITREYI KRISHNAN, ADV.,)
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
AND:
1.
MR. RAHUL
S/O RAMESH POOJARY
AGED ABOUT MAJOR
R/AT NO.3-18-158/4
NEAR PADAVU SCHOOL
KADRI, MANGALURU 575004.
2.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH MANGALURU RURAL P.S
MANGALUR, D.K.
3.
MR. K. SUSHANTH
S/O UMESH AMIN
AGED 25 YEARS
R/AT MAHALAKSHMI NIVASA
KUDUPU KATTE
NEAR KUDUPU SCHOOL
THIRUVALI, KUDUPU
VILLAGE AND POST
MANGALURU TALUK
D.K. – 575028.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARUNA SHYAM, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. RENSPRE PRITHESH D’SOUZA, ADV., FOR R1
SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP FOR R2
SRI. M.R. BALAKRISHNA, ADV., FOR R3)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(2) CR.PC (FILED U/S
483(3) OF BNSS), PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE BAIL
ORDER DATED 31.05.2025 IN CRL. MISC. NO.394/2025
AND CRL. MISC. NO.395/2025 PASSED BY THE II
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, D.K.
MANGALURU (PLACED AS ANNEXURE - A). CANCEL THE
BAIL GRANTED TO RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2. DIRECT THEIR
IMMEDIATE RE-ARREST & ETC.
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
IN CRL.P NO.10321/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
ABDUL JABBAR
S/O KUNHEEDU, BROTHER OF
DECEASED ASHRAF
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
R/AT NO. TRRA-4, THRIKKOVIL ROAD
CHALIKKAVOTTOM,
KANAYANNUR
ERNAKULAM,
KERALA - 682 028.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. CLIFTON ROZARIO, ADV., FOR
SMT. MAITREYI KRISHNAN, ADV.,)
AND:
1.
MR. DEEKSHITH
S/O DEVAPPA POOJARY
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS
R/AT 6-13/2/1, NIDDEL HOUSE
ALAPE, PADIL, MANGALURU
DAKSHINA KANNADA
DISTRICT-575028.
2.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH MANGALURU
RURAL POLICE STATION, MANGALURU
DAKSHINA KANNADA DISTRICT
REP. BY SPP HIGH COURT
BANGALORE-01.
3.
SANDEEP BASAVARAJAPPA HAVERI
S/O BASAVARAJ
AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS
R/AT 1-4/4, LOUIS COMPOUND
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
BYTHURLI, KUDUPU,
THIRUVAIL
DAKSHINA KANNADA – 575028.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARUNA SHYAM, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. RENSPRE PRITHESH D’SOUZA, ADV., FOR R1
SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP FOR R2
SRI. ASHWIN JOYSTON KUTINHA, ADV., FOR R3)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(2) CR.PC (FILED U/S
483(3) OF BNSS), PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE BAIL
ORDER DATED 05.06.2025 IN CRL.MISC.NO.442/2025
PASSED BY THE II ADDL.DIST. AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
D.K. MANGALURU (PLACED AS ANNEXURE -A). CANCEL
THE BAIL GRANTED TO RESPONDENT NO.1. DIRECT HIS
IMMEDIATE RE-ARREST & ETC.
IN CRL.P NO.15550/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
ABDUL JABBAR
S/O KUNHEEDU
BROTHER OF DECEASED ASHRAF
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. TRRA-4
THRIKKOVIL ROAD
CHALIKKAVOTTOM
KANAYANNUR ERNAKULAM
KERALA 682 028.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. CLIFTON ROZARIO, ADV., FOR
SMT. MAITREYI KRISHNAN, ADV.,)
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
AND:
1.
MR. ADARSH
S/O VIJAY KUMAR
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS
R/AT NO.1-45, MANDARA ROAD
NEAR KUDUPU TEMPLE, KUDUPU POST
AND VILLAGE, THIRUVAIL
DAKSHINA KANNADA DIST-575004.
2.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP. BY MANGALURU RURAL
POLICE STATION, MANGALURU
DAKSHINA KANNADA -575005
REP. BY SPP HIGH COURT
BUILDING, BANGALORE-01.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP FOR R2
R1 SERVED)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S.439(2) (FILED U/S.483(3)
BNSS) CR.P.C. PRAYING TO ALLOW THE PRESENT
PETITION AND CANCEL THE BAIL GRANTED TO
RESPONDENT
NO.1/ACCUSED
NO.18
IN
CRL.MISC.NO.426/2025 DATED 06.06.2025 ON THE FILE
OF THE II ADDL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE D.K.,
MANGALURU & ETC.
IN CRL.P NO.16275/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY MANGALURU RURAL POLICE STATION
REP. BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
HIGH COURT BUILDING
BENGALURU -560 001.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP)
AND:
1.
ADARSH
S/O VIJAYA KUMAR
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS
R/A NO. 1-45, MANDARA ROAD
NEAR KUDUPU TEMPLE
KUDUPU POST AND VILLAGE, THIRUVAIL
DAKSHINA KANNADA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. V.R. BALARAJ, ADV.,)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(2) CR.P.C. (FILED U/S
483 (3) BNSS) PRAYING TO CANCEL THE ORDER
GRANTING BAIL TO RESPONDENT / ACCUSED VIDE ORDER
DATED 06.06.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED II ADDL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, D.K. MANGALURU IN
CRL .MISC. NO.426/2025 FOR THE OFFENCE P/U/S 103(2),
115(2), 189(2), 191(1), 191(3), 240 R/W 190 OF BNS
2023 IN CR.NO.37/2025 REGISTERED BY MANGALURU
RURAL POLICE & ETC.
IN CRL.P NO.16338/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY MANGALURU RURAL POLICE
STATION, MANGALURU
REP. BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
HIGH COURT BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP)
AND:
1.
SACHIN
S/O RAJARAM
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS
R/AT KUDUPU VILLAGE
MANGALURU, D.K.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. ARUNA SHYAM, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. SUYOG HERELE E, ADV.,)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(2) CR.PC (FILED U/S
483(3) OF BNSS), PRAYING TO CANCEL THE ORDER
GRANTING BAIL TO RESPONDENT/ACCUSED VIDE ORDER
DATED 05.06.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED II ADDL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, D.K. MANGALURU IN CR.
MISC NO.423/2025 FOR THE OFFENCES P/U/S 103(2),
115(2), 189(2), 191(1), 191(3), 240 R/W 190 OF BNS
2023 IN CR NO.37/2025 REGISTERED BY MANGALURU
POLICE STATION & ETC.
IN CRL.P NO.16367/2025:
BETWEEN:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ASST. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
MANGALURU POLICE STATION
REP. BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
HIGH COURT BUILDING
BENGALURU -560 001.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. B.N. JAGADEESHA, SPP-I A/W
SRI. RANJITH KUMAR, HCGP)
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
AND:
1.
DEEKSHITH
S/O DEVAPPA POOJARY
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS
R/AT 6-13/2/1, NIDDEL HOUSE
ALAPE, PADIL, MANGALURU.
2.
SANDEEP BASAVARAJAPPA HAVERI
S/O BASAVARAJ
AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS
R/AT 1-4/4, LOUIS COMPOUND
BYTHURLI, KUDUPU
THIRUVALI, D.K-575028.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARUNA SHYAM, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. RENSPRE PRITHESH D’SOUZA, ADV.,
FOR R1 & R2)
--THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 439(2) CR.PC (FILED U/S
483(3) OF BNSS), PRAYING TO CANCEL THE ORDER
GRANTING BAIL TO RESPONDENT/ACCUSED VIDE ORDER
DATED 05.06.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED II ADDL.
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, D.K. MANGALURU IN CR.
MISC. NO.442/2025 FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE
UNDER SECTIONS 103(2), 115(2), 189(2), 191(1), 191(3),
240 READ WITH SECTION 190 OF BHARATIYA NYAYA
SANHITA, 2023 IN CR.NO. 37/2025 REGISTERED BY
MANGALURU RURAL POLICE & ETC.
THESE PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON
03.08.2026, COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER, THIS DAY, THE COURT
MADE THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
CAV ORDER
Criminal Petition Nos.16338/2025 and 10339/2025
are filed by the State and the next of kin of the deceased
respectively, seeking to cancel the order of bail dated
05.06.2025 passed in Crl.Misc.No.423/2025 by the II
Additional District and Sessions Judge, D.K., Mangaluru
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Sessions Court’).
Criminal Petition Nos.16367/2025 and 10321/2025
are filed by the State and the next of kin of the deceased
respectively, seeking to cancel the order of bail dated
05.06.2025
passed
in
Crl.Misc.No.442/2025
by
the
Sessions Court.
Criminal Petition Nos.16275/2025 and 15550/2025
are filed by the State and the next of kin of the deceased
respectively, seeking to cancel the order of bail dated
06.06.2025 passed in Crl.Misc.No.426/2025 passed by the
Sessions Court.
Criminal Petition No.10314/2025 is filed by the next
of kin of the deceased seeking to cancel the order of bail
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
dated
31.05.2025
in
Crl.Misc.No.394/2025
and
Crl.Misc.No.395/2025 passed by the Sessions Court.
2.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties
shall be referred to as follows:
a) The
petitioner
in
Crl.P.No.15550/2025,
Crl.P.No.10321/2025,
Crl.P.No.10314/2025,
Crl.P.No.10339/2025 shall be referred to as the
‘next of kin of the deceased’.
b) The
petitioner
in
Crl.P.No.16367/2025,
Crl.P.No.16275/2025 and 16338/2025 shall be
referred to as ‘the State’
c) The
respondent
No.1
in
Crl.P.No.10321/2025,
Crl.P.No.15550/2025,
Crl.P.No.10314/2025,
Crl.P.No.10339/2025
and
the
respondents
Crl.P.No.16367/2025,
Crl.P.No.16275/2025
in
and
16338/2025 shall be referred to as ‘the accused’.
3.
The brief facts leading to the filing of these
petitions are that on 27.04.2025 in a cricket match
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
organized by the ‘Amazing Friends Konguru, Kulashekara’,
the deceased-Ashraf came by raising the slogan ‘Pakistan,
Pakistan’. The accused and other people followed the
deceased-Ashraf and assaulted him resulting in his death.
Subsequently, a complaint was filed by one Sri.Deepak
Kumar and the police registered a FIR against the accused
and other persons for the offences punishable under
Section 103(2), 115(2), 189(2), 190, 191(1), 191(3) and
240 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for short ‘the
BNS’).
The accused were arrested and were remanded
into judicial custody.
The accused filed petitions under
Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023 (for short the ‘BNSS’) seeking to grant regular bail in
Crime No.37/2025. The Sessions Court considered the said
petitions and allowed the same. Being aggrieved, the next
of kin of the deceased as well as the State have filed these
petitions seeking cancellation of bail.
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
4.
Sri.Clifton D’Rozario, learned counsel appearing
for the next of kin of the deceased submits that as per the
guidelines of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
TEHSEEN S POONAWALLA Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND
OTHERS1, the victim(s) or the next of kin of the deceased
in cases of mob lynching shall be given timely notice of
any Court proceedings and the same shall be entitled to be
heard at the trial in respect of applications such as bail,
discharge, release and parole filed by the accused persons.
However, in the instant case, there was no notice to the
next of kin of the deceased and the non-issuance of such
notice vitiates the order granting bail. It is submitted that
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also directed the State
Governments to prepare a lynching/mob violence victim
compensation scheme and also provide for interim relief to
the victim or the next of kin of the victim, however, in the
instant case, no scheme for interim compensation has
been formulated by the State Government.
1 (2018) 9 SCC 501
Hence, the
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
State Government must be directed to formulate a scheme
for interim compensation to the victim or next of kin of the
deceased and also for grant of compensation to the next of
kin of the deceased in the instant case. It is further
submitted that the crimes in which the accused are
involved are heinous in nature and hence, the Sessions
Court ought not to have granted bail solely on the ground
of parity with other co-accused; or on the ground that the
name of the accused was not initially found in the FIR but
was subsequently implicated during the course of the
investigation; or on the ground that the accused did not
have any previous antecedents. It is also submitted that
in view of the procedural lapse by the Sessions Court, the
order granting bail may be set-aside and the accused may
be directed to surrender and the Sessions Court may be
further directed to re-consider the bail application on
merits after giving an opportunity to the next of kin of the
victim to file his objections. In support of his contentions,
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
he places reliance on the following decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court:
a) JAGJEET SINGH AND OTHERS Vs. ASHISH MISHA
AND ANOTHER2
b) NATIONAL
FEDERATION
OF
INDIAN
WOMEN
(NFIW) Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS3
c) Y Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND ANOTHER4
d) MANIK
MADHUKAR
SARVE
AND
OTHERS
Vs.
VITTHAL DAMUJI MEHER AND OTHERS5
e) KIRAN @ HOLO MAFATBHAI PARMAR Vs. STATE OF
GUJARAT6
f) SAGAR Vs. STATE OF U.P. AND ANOTHER7
Hence, he seeks to allow the petitions.
5.
Sri.B.N.Jagadeesh,
learned
State
Public
Prosecutor-I appearing for the State submits that the
Sessions Court has not considered the fact that the crime
2 (2022) 9 SCC 321
3 W.P.(Civil).Nos.719/2023.
4 (2022) 9 SCC 269
5 (2024) 10 SCC 753
6 SLP (Criminal) Diary No.32284/2025 dated
7 2025 SCC Online SC 2584
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
in which the accused are involved is heinous in nature and
solely on the ground of parity with co-accused, nonimplication in the FIR and lack of criminal antecedents, has
proceeded to grant bail to the accused.
It is submitted
that the crime committed by the accused is mob-lynching
due to which it is not necessary that the name of each
person has to be mentioned in the FIR and can be
implicated during subsequent investigation and in the
instant case, the chargesheet filed clearly indicates the
involvement of the accused, hence, the order of bail ought
to be set aside.
It is further submitted that as per the
guidelines of the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred supra,
the next of kin of the deceased ought to have been issued
timely notice specially when there is a hearing for bail
application of the accused and non-compliance of such
process vitiates the order of bail. It is also submitted that
the State has filed a memo along with documents
indicating the compliance of the directions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of TEHSEEN S POONAWALA
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
referred supra.
It is contended that if this Court is not
inclined to set aside the order of bail, then it may add an
additional condition directing the accused to present
themselves before the police station every month to avoid
the attempt of tampering the witness.
It is further
contended that the Sessions Court may also be directed to
dispose of the case within 6 months as per the guidelines
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of TEHSEEN S
POONAWALA referred supra. Hence, he seeks to allow
the petitions.
6.
Per contra, Sri.Aruna Shyam, learned Senior
counsel
appearing
for
Crl.P.Nos.10339/2025,
10321/2025
and
the
16338/2025,
10314/2025,
accused
in
16367/2025,
Sri.M.R.Balakrishna,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.3 in
Crl.P.No.10314/2025, Sri.Ashwin Joyston Kutinha, learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent
No.3
in
Crl.P.No.10321/2025 and Sri.V.R.Balaraj, learned counsel
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
appearing for the respondent in Crl.P.No.16275/2025
support the impugned order passed by the Sessions Court
and submit that the charge sheet in the instant case has
already
been
filed,
hence,
the
need
for
custodial
interrogation does not arise. It is submitted that the State
has challenged the order granting bail to the accused
Nos.4 and 11 by this Court before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and the same came to be rejected, hence, the
question of setting aside the order of granting bail does
not arise. It is further submitted that a detailed guidelines
may be issued directing the State to formulate a scheme
for interim compensation to the victim or the next of his
kin in cases involving mob violence/lynching and also
further direction may be issued to the Sessions Court to
issue notice to the victim or the next of his kin in cases of
mob lynching.
It is also submitted that setting aside of
the order of bail involves the liberty of the accused, hence,
it would not be appropriate at this stage to ask them to
surrender. Hence, they seek to dismiss the petitions.
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
7.
I have heard the arguments of the learned
counsel appearing for the next of kin of the deceased, the
learned State Public Prosecutor-I appearing for the State,
the learned Senior counsel and other learned counsels
appearing for the accused and meticulously perused the
material available on record.
I have given my anxious
consideration to the submissions advanced on both the
sides.
8.
The material on record indicates that a friends
club called the ‘Amazing Friends Konguru, Kulashekara’
organized a cricket play at Kallurti Temple, Kudupu, on
27.04.2025. On the said day, during the match at 3 p.m.,
the deceased-Ashraf came by raising a slogan ‘Pakistan,
Pakistan’. On seeing the deceased-Ashraf, various cricket
players, other audience along with the accused followed
him and the deceased-Ashraf ran on seeing the people
approaching him and fell on the center of the road. The
accused and the other people surrounded him at the
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
center of the road, kicked and assaulted him. The
deceased-Ashraf suffered blunt injuries on his body and
eventually succumbed to those injuries.
Subsequent to
the death of the deceased-Ashraf, based on the complaint
by one Sri.Deepak Kumar, the police registered a FIR
against the accused and other persons for the offences
punishable under Section 103(2), 115(2), 189(2), 190,
191(1), 191(3) and 240 of the BNSS. The accused were
arrested as per the FIR and were remanded to judicial
custody. The accused filed petitions under Section 483 of
the
BNSS,
seeking
to
grant
regular
bail
in
Crime
No.37/2025. The Sessions Court considered the said
applications
and
allowed
the
same
in
Crl.Misc.Nos.426/2025 and 442/2025 on the ground of
parity that the co-accused in another petition had also
been granted bail.
In Crl.Misc.No.423/2025, the petition
was allowed on the ground that the name of the accused
was not in the complaint or the FIR, but was subsequently
implicated during the course of investigation. Further, in
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
Crl.Misc.No.394/2025
and
Crl.Misc.No.395/2025,
the
petitions were allowed on the ground that the accused do
not have any criminal antecedents.
9.
To appreciate the various contentions raised by
the learned counsels, it would be useful to refer to the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
TEHSEEN S POONAWALLA referred supra. The relevant
portion is extracted below:
“15. At the very inception, while delving into the
rivalised submissions advanced at the Bar, it is
necessary to understand that a controversy of the
present nature deserves to be addressed with
enormous
sensitivity.
We
had
issued
certain
directions as an interim measure and there has
been
some
compliance
but
we
are
of
the
considered opinion that the situations that have
emerged and the problems that have arisen need
to be totally curbed. The States have the onerous
duty to see that no individual or any core group
take law into their own hands. Every citizen has
the right to intimate the police about the infraction
of law. As stated earlier, an accused booked for an
offence is entitled to fair and speedy trial under the
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
constitutional
and
statutory
scheme
and,
thereafter, he may be convicted or acquitted as
per the adjudication by the judiciary on the basis
of
the
evidence
brought
on
record
and
the
application of legal principles. There cannot be an
investigation, trial and punishment of any nature
on the streets. The process of adjudication takes
place within the hallowed precincts of the courts of
justice and not on the streets. No one has the right
to become the guardian of law claiming that he has
to protect the law by any means. It is the duty of
the
States,
as
Sundar v. State
has
of
been
stated
in Nandini
Chhattisgarh [Nandini
Sundar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2011) 7 SCC 547
: (2011) 2 SCC (L&S) 762] , to strive, incessantly
and consistently, to promote fraternity amongst all
citizens so that the dignity of every citizen is
protected, nourished and promoted. That apart, it
is the responsibility of the States to prevent
untoward incidents and to prevent crime.
18. Lynching is an affront to the rule of law and
to the exalted values of the Constitution itself. We
may say without any fear of contradiction that
lynching by unruly mobs and barbaric violence
arising out of incitement and instigation cannot be
allowed to become the order of the day. Such
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
vigilantism, be it for whatever purpose or borne
out
of
whatever
cause,
has
the
effect
of
undermining the legal and formal institutions of
the State and altering the constitutional order.
These extra-judicial attempts under the guise of
protection of the law have to be nipped in the bud;
lest
it
would
lead
to
rise
of
anarchy
and
lawlessness which would plague and corrode the
nation like an epidemic. The tumultuous dark
clouds of vigilantism have the effect of shrouding
the glorious ways of democracy and justice leading
to tragic breakdown of the law and transgressing
all forms of civility and humanity. Unless these
incidents are controlled, the day is not far when
such monstrosity in the name of self-professed
morality is likely to assume the shape of a huge
cataclysm.
It
is
in
direct
violation
of
the
quintessential spirit of the rule of law and of the
exalted faiths of tolerance and humanity.
19. Mob vigilantism and mob violence have to
be prevented by the Governments by taking strict
action and by the vigil society who ought to report
such incidents to the State machinery and the
police instead of taking the law into their own
hands. Rising intolerance and growing polarisation
expressed through spate of incidents of mob
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
violence cannot be permitted to become the
normal way of life or the normal state of law and
order in the country. Good governance and nation
building require sustenance of law and order which
is intricately linked to the preservation of the
marrows
of
our
social
structure.
In
such
a
situation, the State has a sacrosanct duty to
protect its citizens from unruly elements and
perpetrators
of
vigilantism
with
orchestrated
utmost
lynching
sincerity
and
and
true
commitment to address and curb such incidents
which must reflect in its actions and schemes.
24. Lynching and mob violence are creeping
threats that may gradually take the shape of a
Typhon-like monster as evidenced in the wake of
the rising wave of incidents of recurring patterns
by frenzied mobs across the country instigated by
intolerance and misinformed by circulation of fake
news
and
false
stories.
There
has
been
an
unfortunate litany of spiralling mob violence and
agonised horror presenting a grim and gruesome
picture that compels us to reflect whether the
populace of a great Republic like ours has lost the
values of tolerance to sustain a diverse culture.
Besides, bystander apathy, numbness of the mute
spectators of the scene of the crime, inertia of the
- 25 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
law-enforcing machinery to prevent such crimes
and nip them in the bud and grandstanding of the
incident by the perpetrators of the crimes including
in the social media aggravates the entire problem.
One must constantly remind oneself that an
attitude
of
morbid
intolerance
is
absolutely
intolerable and agonisingly painful.
40. In view of the aforesaid, we proceed to issue
the following guidelines:
A. Preventive Measures:
40.1. The State Governments shall designate, a
senior
police
officer,
not
below
the
rank
of
Superintendent of Police, as Nodal Officer in each
district. Such Nodal Officer shall be assisted by one
of the DSP rank officers in the district for taking
measures to prevent incidents of mob violence and
lynching. They shall constitute a special task force
so as to procure intelligence reports about the
people who are likely to commit such crimes or
who are involved in spreading hate speeches,
provocative statements and fake news.
40.2. The State Governments shall forthwith
identify
districts,
sub-divisions
and/or
villages
where instances of lynching and mob violence have
been reported in the recent past, say, in the last
five years. The process of identification should be
- 26 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
done within a period of three weeks from the date
of this judgment, as such time period is sufficient
to get the task done in today’s fast world of data
collection.
40.3. The Secretary, Home Department of the
States concerned shall issue directives/advisories
to the Nodal Officers of the districts concerned for
ensuring that the officers in-charge of the police
stations of the identified areas are extra cautious if
any
instance
of
mob
violence
within
their
jurisdiction comes to their notice.
40.4. The Nodal Officer, so designated, shall
hold regular meetings (at least once a month) with
the local intelligence units in the district along with
all Station House Officers of the district so as to
identify
the
existence
of
the
tendencies
of
vigilantism, mob violence or lynching in the district
and
take
steps
dissemination
of
to
prohibit
offensive
instances
material
of
through
different social media platforms or any other
means for inciting such tendencies. The Nodal
Officer shall also make efforts to eradicate hostile
environment against any community or caste
which is targeted in such incidents.
40.5. The
Secretary,
Director
Home
General
Department
of
of
Police/the
the
States
concerned shall take regular review meetings (at
- 27 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
least once a quarter) with all the Nodal Officers
and State Police Intelligence heads. The Nodal
Officers shall bring to the notice of the DGP any
inter-district coordination issues for devising a
strategy to tackle lynching and mob violence
related issues at the State level.
40.6. It shall be the duty of every police officer
to cause a mob to disperse, by exercising his
power under Section 129 CrPC, which, in his
opinion, has a tendency to cause violence or wreak
the havoc of lynching in the disguise of vigilantism
or otherwise.
40.7. The Home Department of the Government
of
India
must
coordination
take
initiative
the
State
with
and
work
in
Governments
for
sensitising the law-enforcement agencies and by
involving all the
stakeholders
to identify
the
measures for prevention of mob violence and
lynching against any caste or community and to
implement the constitutional goal of social justice
and the Rule of Law.
40.8. The Director General of Police shall issue a
circular to the Superintendents of Police with
regard to police patrolling in the sensitive areas
keeping in view the incidents of the past and the
intelligence obtained by the office of the Director
General. It singularly means that there should be
- 28 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
seriousness in patrolling so that the anti-social
elements involved in such crimes are discouraged
and remain within the boundaries of law thus
fearing to even think of taking the law into their
own hands.
40.9. The Central and the State Governments
should broadcast on radio and television and other
media platforms including the official websites of
the Home Department and Police Department of
the States that lynching and mob violence of any
kind shall invite serious consequence under the
law.
40.10. It shall be the duty of the Central
Government as well as the State Governments to
take steps to curb and stop dissemination of
irresponsible and explosive messages, videos and
other material on various social media platforms
which have a tendency to incite mob violence and
lynching of any kind.
40.11. The police shall cause to register FIR
under Section 153-A IPC and/or other relevant
provisions of law against persons who disseminate
irresponsible and explosive messages and videos
having content which is likely to incite mob
violence and lynching of any kind.
40.12. The Central Government shall also issue
appropriate
directions/advisories
to
the
State
- 29 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
Governments which would reflect the gravity and
seriousness of the situation and the measures to
be taken.
B. Remedial Measures:
40.13. Despite the preventive measures taken
by the State Police, if it comes to the notice of the
local police that an incident of lynching or mob
violence has taken place, the jurisdictional police
station shall immediately cause to lodge an FIR,
without any undue delay, under the relevant
provisions of IPC and/or other provisions of law.
40.14. It shall be the duty of the Station House
Officer,
in
whose
police
station
such
FIR
is
registered, to forthwith intimate the Nodal Officer
in the district who shall, in turn, ensure that there
is no further harassment of the family members of
the victim(s).
40.15. Investigation in such offences shall be
personally monitored by the Nodal Officer who
shall
be
duty-bound
to
ensure
that
the
investigation is carried out effectively and the
charge-sheet in such cases is filed within the
statutory period from the date of registration of
the FIR or arrest of the accused, as the case may
be.
- 30 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
40.16. The State Governments shall prepare a
lynching/mob
violence
victim
compensation
scheme in the light of the provisions of Section
357-A CrPC within one month from the date of this
judgment. In the said scheme for computation of
compensation, the State Governments shall give
due
regard
to
the
nature
of
bodily
injury,
psychological injury and loss of earnings including
loss of opportunities of employment and education
and expenses incurred on account of legal and
medical expenses. The said compensation scheme
must also have a provision for interim relief to be
paid to the victim(s) or to the next of kin of the
deceased within a period of thirty days of the
incident of mob violence/lynching.
40.17. The cases of lynching and mob violence
shall be specifically tried by designated court/Fast
Track Courts earmarked for that purpose in each
district. Such courts shall hold trial of the case on a
day-to-day basis. The trial shall preferably be
concluded within six months from the date of
taking cognizance. We may hasten to add that this
direction shall apply to even pending cases. The
District Judge shall assign those cases as far as
possible to one jurisdictional court so as to ensure
expeditious disposal thereof. It shall be the duty of
the State Governments and the Nodal Officers in
- 31 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
particular to see that the prosecuting agency
strictly
carries
out
its
role
in
appropriate
furtherance of the trial.
40.18. To set a stern example in cases of mob
violence and lynching, upon conviction of the
accused person(s), the trial court must ordinarily
award maximum sentence as provided for various
offences under the provisions of the IPC.
40.19. The courts trying the cases of mob
violence and lynching may, on application by a
witness or by the Public Prosecutor in relation to
such witness or on its own motion, take such
measures, as it deems fit, for protection and for
concealing the identity and address of the witness.
40.20. The victim(s) or the next of kin of the
deceased in cases of mob violence and lynching
shall
be
given
timely
notice
of
any
court
proceedings and he/she shall be entitled to be
heard at the trial in respect of applications such as
bail, discharge, release and parole filed by the
accused persons. They shall also have the right to
file written submissions on conviction, acquittal or
sentencing.
40.21. The victim(s) or the next of kin of the
deceased in cases of mob violence and lynching
shall receive free legal aid if he or she so chooses
and engage any advocate of his/her choice from
- 32 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
amongst those enrolled in the legal aid panel under
the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987.
C. Punitive Measures:
40.22. Wherever it is found that a police officer
or an officer of the district administration has failed
to comply with the aforesaid directions in order to
prevent
and/or
investigate
and/or
facilitate
expeditious trial of any crime of mob violence and
lynching, the same shall be considered as an act of
deliberate negligence and/or misconduct for which
appropriate action must be taken against him/her
and not limited to departmental action under the
service rules. The departmental action shall be
taken to its logical conclusion preferably within six
months by the authority of the first instance.
40.23. In terms of the ruling of this Court
in Arumugam Servai v. State of T.N. [Arumugam
Servai v. State of T.N., (2011) 6 SCC 405 : (2011)
2 SCC (Cri) 993] , the States are directed to take
disciplinary action against the officials concerned if
it is found that (i) such official(s) did not prevent
the incident, despite having prior knowledge of it,
or (ii) where the incident has already occurred,
such official(s) did not promptly apprehend and
institute criminal proceedings against the culprits.
- 33 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
41. The measures that are directed to be taken
have to be carried out within four weeks by the
Central and the State Governments. Reports of
compliance be filed within the said period before
the Registry of this Court.
42. We
may
emphatically
note
that
it
is
axiomatic that it is the duty of the State to ensure
that the machinery of law and order functions
efficiently and effectively in maintaining peace so
as to preserve our quintessentially secular ethos
and pluralistic social fabric in a democratic set-up
governed by rule of law. In times of chaos and
anarchy, the State has to act positively and
responsibly
constitutional
to
safeguard
promises
to
and
secure
the
its
citizens.
The
horrendous acts of mobocracy cannot be permitted
to inundate the law of the land. Earnest action and
concrete steps have to be taken to protect the
citizens from the recurrent pattern of violence
which cannot be allowed to become “the new
normal”. The State cannot turn a deaf ear to the
growing rumblings of its People, since its concern,
to quote Woodrow Wilson, “must ring with the
voices of the people”. The exigencies of the
situation require us to sound a clarion call for
earnest action to strengthen our inclusive and allembracing social order which would, in turn,
- 34 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
reaffirm the constitutional faith. We expect nothing
more and nothing less.”
10.
It would further be useful to refer to the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
JAGJEET SINGH AND OTHERS referred supra, the
relevant portion of the same is extracted below:
“35. We find ourselves in agreement with the
learned Senior Counsel for the appellants that the
High Court has completely lost sight of the
principles enumerated above, which conventionally
govern a court's discretion when deciding the
question whether or not to grant bail. Instead of
looking into aspects such as the nature and gravity
of the offence; severity of the punishment in the
event
of
conviction;
circumstances
which
are
peculiar to the accused or victims; likelihood of the
accused fleeing; likelihood of tampering with the
evidence and witnesses and the impact that his
release may have on the trial and the society at
large; the High Court has adopted a myopic view
of the evidence on the record and proceeded to
decide the case on merits.
36. The High Court has taken into account
several
irrelevant
considerations,
whilst
- 35 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
simultaneously ignoring judicial precedents and
established parameters for grant of bail. It has
been ruled on numerous occasions that an FIR
cannot be treated as an encyclopaedia of events.
While the allegations in the FIR, that the accused
used his firearm and the subsequent post-mortem
and injury reports may have some limited bearing,
there was no legal necessity to
weightage
to
the
same.
give
Moreover,
undue
the
observations on merits of a case when the trial has
yet to commence, are likely to have an impact on
the outcome of the trial proceedings.
37. Keeping all these factors cumulatively in
mind, we have no difficulty in answering Question
(B) also in the affirmative. It is held that the order
under challenge does not conform to the relevant
considerations.
C. Whether interference is warranted by
this Court
38. As a natural and consequential corollary to
the findings under Questions (A) and (B) above,
the impugned order of the High Court dated 10-22022 [Ashish Mishra v. State of U.P., 2022 SCC
OnLine
All
232]
(as
corrected
on
14-2-2022
[Ashish Mishra v. State of U.P., 2022 SCC OnLine
- 36 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
All 233] ) cannot be sustained and has to be set
aside. Ordered accordingly.
39. As a sequel thereto, bail bonds of the
respondent-accused
are
cancelled
and
he
is
directed to surrender within a week.
40. Having held so, we cannot be oblivious to
what has been urged on behalf of the respondentaccused that cancellation of bail by this Court is
likely to be construed as an indefinite foreclosure
of his right to seek bail. It is not necessary to dwell
upon the wealth of case law which, regardless of
the stringent provisions in a penal law or the
gravity
of
the
offence,
has
time
and
again
recognised the legitimacy of seeking liberty from
incarceration. To put it differently, no accused can
be subjected to unending detention pending trial,
especially when the law presumes him to be
innocent until proven guilty. Even where statutory
provisions expressly bar the grant of bail, such as
in cases under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1967, this Court has expressly ruled that after
a reasonably long period of incarceration, or for
any other valid reason, such stringent provisions
will melt down, and cannot be measured over and
above the right of liberty guaranteed under Article
21 of the Constitution (see Union of India v. K.A.
- 37 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
Najeeb [Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb, (2021) 3
SCC 713, paras 15 and 17] ).
41. We are, thus, of the view that this Court on
account of the factors like:
(i) irrelevant considerations having impacted the
impugned order granting bail;
(ii) the High Court exceeding its jurisdiction by
touching upon the merits of the case;
(iii) denial of victims' right to participate in the
proceedings; and
(iv) the tearing hurry shown by the High Court
in entertaining or granting bail to the respondentaccused;
can rightfully cancel the bail, without depriving
the respondent-accused of his legitimate right to
seek
enlargement
on
bail
on
relevant
considerations.
42. We
are
thus
inclined
to
allay
the
apprehension in the mind of the learned Senior
Counsel
for
the
respondent-accused
that
the
cancellation of bail by this Court shall amount to
denial
bail
to
the
respondent-accused
till
conclusion of the trial.
43. This Court is tasked with ensuring that
neither the right of an accused to seek bail pending
- 38 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
trial is expropriated, nor the “victim” or the State
are denuded of their right to oppose such a prayer.
In a situation like this, and with a view to balance
the
competing
rights,
this
Court
has
been
invariably remanding the matter(s) back to the
High Court for a fresh consideration. [Naresh Pal
Singh v. Raj Karan, (1999) 9 SCC 104, para 12 :
1999 SCC (Cri) 466; Brij Nandan Jaiswal v. Munna,
(2009) 1 SCC 678, paras 12 and 13 : (2009) 1
SCC (Cri) 594; Hari Om Yadav v. Dinesh Singh
Jaat, 2013 SCC OnLine SC 610, para 6.] We are
also of the considered view that ends of justice
would be adequately met by remitting this case to
the High Court for a fresh adjudication of the bail
application of the respondent-accused, in a fair,
impartial and dispassionate manner, and keeping
in view the settled parameters which have been
elaborated in paras 29 to 32 of this order.”
11.
It would also be useful to refer to the decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Y Vs. STATE
OF RAJASTHAN AND ANOTHER8, the relevant portion of
the said decision is extracted below:
8 (2022) 9 SCC 269
- 39 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
“8. This Court has, in a catena of judgments,
outlined the considerations on the basis of which
discretion
under
Section
439CrPC
exercised
while
granting
bail.
(Delhi
Admn.) [Gurcharan
Singh v. State
has
to
be
In Gurcharan
Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.), (1978) 1 SCC 118 :
1978 SCC (Cri) 41] this Court has held as to the
various parameters which must be considered
while granting bail. This Court held as follows :
(SCC pp. 127-28, para 24)
“24. … Even so, the High Court or the Court of
Session will have to exercise its judicial discretion
in considering the question of granting of bail
under Section 439(1)CrPC of the new Code. The
overriding considerations in granting bail to which
we adverted to earlier and which are common
both in the case of Section 437(1) and Section
439(1)CrPC of the new Code are the nature and
gravity of the circumstances in which the offence
is committed; the position and the status of the
accused with reference to the victim and the
witnesses; the likelihood, of the accused fleeing
from justice; of repeating the offence; of
jeopardising his own life being faced with a grim
prospect of possible conviction in the case; of
tampering with witnesses; the history of the case
as well as of its investigation and other relevant
grounds which, in view of so many valuable
factors, cannot be exhaustively set out.”
9. The
above
factors
do
not
constitute
an
exhaustive list. The grant of bail requires the
consideration of various factors which ultimately
depends upon the specific facts and circumstances
of
the
case
before
the
Court.
There
is
no
- 40 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
straitjacket formula which can ever be prescribed
as to what the relevant factors could be. However,
certain
important
considered,
inter
factors
alia,
that
relate
to
are
prima
always
facie
involvement of the accused, nature and gravity of
the charge, severity of the punishment, and the
character, position and standing of the accused
[see State of U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi [State of
U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi, (2005) 8 SCC 21 : 2005
SCC (Cri) 1960 (2)] ].
10. At the stage of granting bail the Court is not
required to enter into a detailed analysis of the
evidence in the case. Such an exercise may be
undertaken at the stage of trial.
11. Once bail has been granted, the appellate
court is usually slow to interfere with the same as
it pertains to the liberty of an individual. A
Constitution Bench of this Court in Bihar Legal
Support Society v. Chief Justice of India [Bihar
Legal Support Society v. Chief Justice of India,
(1986) 4 SCC 767 : 1986 SCC (Cri) 537] observed
as follows : (SCC p. 770, para 3)
“3. … It is for this reason that the Apex Court
has evolved, as a matter of self-discipline,
certain norms to guide it in the exercise of its
discretion in cases where special leave petition
are filed against orders granting or refusing bail
or anticipatory bail. … We reiterate this policy
- 41 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
principle laid down by the bench of this Court
and hold that this Court should not ordinarily,
save in exceptional cases, interfere with orders
granting or refusing bail or anticipatory bail,
because these are matters in which the High
Court should normally be the final arbiter.”
(emphasis supplied)
12. The above principle has been consistently
followed
by
Sarkar v. Ashis
this
Court.
In Prasanta
Chatterjee [Prasanta
Kumar
Kumar
Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC 496 :
(2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 765] this Court held as under :
(SCC p. 499, paras 9-10)
“9. We are of the opinion that the impugned
order [Ashish Chatterjee v. State of W.B., CRM
No. 272 of 2010, order dated 11-1-2010 (Cal)] is
clearly unsustainable. It is trite that this Court
does not, normally, interfere with an order passed
by the High Court granting or rejecting bail to the
accused. However, it is equally incumbent upon
the High Court to exercise its discretion
judiciously, cautiously and strictly in compliance
with the basic principles laid down in a plethora of
decisions of this Court on the point. It is well
settled that, among other circumstances, the
factors to be borne in mind while considering an
application for bail are:
(i) whether there is any prima facie or
reasonable ground to believe that the accused had
committed the offence;
(ii) nature and gravity of the accusation;
(iii) severity of the punishment in the event of
conviction;
(iv) danger of the accused absconding or
fleeing, if released on bail;
(v) character, behaviour, means, position and
standing of the accused;
(vi) likelihood of the offence being repeated;
- 42 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
(vii) reasonable apprehension of the witnesses
being influenced; and
(viii) danger, of course, of justice being
thwarted by grant of bail.
***
10. It is manifest that if the High Court does not
advert to these relevant considerations and
mechanically grants bail, the said order would
suffer from the vice of non-application of mind,
rendering it to be illegal.”
13. In Mahipal v. Rajesh
Kumar [Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar, (2020) 2 SCC
118 : (2020) 1 SCC (Cri) 558] this Court followed
the holding in Prasanta Kumar Sarkar [Prasanta
Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee, (2010) 14 SCC
496 : (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 765] and held as follows
: (Mahipal case [Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar, (2020)
2 SCC 118 : (2020) 1 SCC (Cri) 558] , SCC p. 126,
para 17)
“17. Where a court considering an application for
bail fails to consider relevant factors, an appellate
court may justifiably set aside the order granting
bail. An appellate court is thus required to
consider whether the order granting bail suffers
from a non-application of mind or is not borne out
from a prima facie view of the evidence on record.
It is thus necessary for this Court to assess
whether, on the basis of the evidentiary record,
there existed a prima facie or reasonable ground
to believe that the accused had committed the
crime, also taking into account the seriousness of
the crime and the severity of the punishment.”
14. Recently, a three-Judge Bench of this Court
in Jagjeet
Singh v. Ashish
Mishra [Jagjeet
Singh v. Ashish Mishra, (2022) 9 SCC 321] , has
- 43 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
reiterated the factors that the Court must consider
at the time of granting bail under Section 439CrPC,
as well as highlighted the circumstances where this
Court may interfere when bail has been granted in
violation
of
the
requirements
under
the
abovementioned section. This Court observed as
follows : (SCC para 27)
“27. We may, at the outset, clarify that
power to grant bail under Section 439CrPC, is
one of wide amplitude. A High Court or a
Sessions Court, as the case may be, are
bestowed with considerable discretion while
deciding an application for bail. But, as has
been held by this Court on multiple occasions,
this discretion is not unfettered. On the
contrary, the High Court of the Sessions Court
must grant bail after the application of a judicial
mind, following well-established principles, and
not in a cryptic or mechanical manner.”
15. It
is
worth
noting
that
what
is
being
considered in this case relates to whether the High
Court has exercised the discretionary power under
Section 439CrPC in granting bail appropriately.
Such an assessment is different from deciding
whether circumstances subsequent to the grant of
bail have made it necessary to cancel the same.
The first situation requires the Court to analyse
whether
the
order
granting
bail
was
illegal,
perverse, unjustified or arbitrary. On the other
hand, an application for cancellation of bail looks at
- 44 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
whether supervening circumstances have occurred
warranting cancellation.
16. In Neeru
Yadav v. State
of
U.P. [Neeru
Yadav v. State of U.P., (2014) 16 SCC 508 :
(2015) 3 SCC (Cri) 527] this Court held as follows
: (SCC p. 513, para 12)
“12. We have referred to certain
principles to be kept in mind while granting
bail, as has been laid down by this Court
from time to time. It is well settled in law
that cancellation of bail after it is granted
because the accused has misconducted
himself
or
of
some
supervening
circumstances warranting such cancellation
have occurred is in a different compartment
altogether than an order granting bail which
is unjustified, illegal and perverse. If in a
case, the relevant factors which should
have been taken into consideration while
dealing with the application for bail have
not been taken note of, or bail is founded
on irrelevant considerations, indisputably
the superior court can set aside the order of
such a grant of bail. Such a case belongs to
a different category and is in a separate
realm. While dealing with a case of second
nature, the court does not dwell upon the
violation of conditions by the accused or the
supervening
circumstances
that
have
happened subsequently. It, on the contrary,
delves into the justifiability and the
soundness of the order passed by the
court.”
17. In the present case, it is necessary to
determine whether the High Court while granting
- 45 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
bail
to
Respondent
2-accused
has
properly
exercised its discretion under Section 439CrPC by
following various parameters laid down by this
Court. A bare perusal of the impugned order
[Omprakash v. State
of
Rajasthan,
SCC
OnLine Raj 3499] passed by the High Court does
not suggest that the Court has considered any of
the relevant factors for grant of bail.”
12.
The learned counsels for the next of kin of the
deceased and the State contend that the guidelines issued
in the TEHSEEN S PONNAWALLA referred supra by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court clearly indicate that the victim or
the next of kin of the victim must be given timely notice of
any Court proceedings and he/she shall be entitled to be
heard at the trial in respect of applications such as bail,
discharge, release and parole filed by the accused persons.
In the instant case, it is not in dispute that the Sessions
Court has neither issued notice nor heard the next of kin
of the victim, while considering the application for regular
bail, hence, it is contended that as a result, the order of
grant of bail stands vitiated.
To consider the same, it
- 46 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
would be important to understand the distinction between
setting aside an order of bail and cancellation of bail. The
findings of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Y
referred supra indicates that in order to set aside an order
granting bail, the Court has to analyze whether the order
granting bail was illegal, perverse, unjustified or arbitrary,
whereas on the other hand, in order to cancel a grant of
bail,
it
needs
to
look
at
whether
supervening
circumstances have occurred warranting cancellation such
as if there was any violation of bail conditions.
In the
instant case, the case clearly falls within the first category
as there is no allegation against the accused for noncompliance of any bail conditions nor that he
has
committed any crime warranting such cancellation of bail.
The challenge to the order of bail, in the instant case, is on
the ground that the Sessions Court has failed to comply
with the procedure of issuing notice and hearing the next
of kin of the deceased.
- 47 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
JAGJEET SINGH AND OTHERS referred supra clearly
indicates that denial of the right of victim(s) or the next of
kin of the deceased to participate in the proceedings can
be a ground to cancel the bail without depriving the
respondent-accused
of
his
legitimate
right
to
seek
enlargement on bail on relevant considerations.
14.
The decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of SAGAR referred supra states that parity with
the co-accused cannot be the sole ground to grant bail and
the role of the accused in each case has to be looked into.
The said decision will not aid the learned counsel for the
next of kin of the deceased as though the ground of parity
cannot
be
mechanically
applied
to
co-accused while
granting them bail, the Court must investigate the role of
the accused.
However, in the instant case, the crime of
mob violence and lynching is collective in nature, and no
specific role can be assigned to an accused and the facts
- 48 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
and charges against the co-accused to whom bail was
granted by this Co-ordinate Bench and the accused in the
instant case are one and the same. Hence, the contention
that the ground of parity cannot apply to the accused, is
required to be rejected.
15.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid propositions of
law, I am of the considered view that the Sessions Court
has committed a grave error in failing to issue timely
notice to the next of kin of the deceased and also failed to
provide an opportunity to the next of kin of the deceased
to object the application seeking regular bail filed by the
accused.
However, I am not inclined to set aside the
order granting bail for the following reasons:
a) The charge sheet has already been filed – The
material
on
record
clearly
indicates
that
the
chargesheet in the instant case has already been
filed, hence, no question of custodial interrogation
would arise.
- 49 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
b) The Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has granted bail
after considering the objections of the next kin of the
victim
–
The
Co-ordinate
Bench
in
Crl.P.Nos.1258/2025,
1431/2025,
6850/2026,
1487/2026 and 14203/2025 has considered the
application filed by the accused for granting the
regular bail, also heard the objections of the next of
kin of the victim and proceeded to grant bail.
The
petitions in the aforesaid cases as well as the instant
case arise out of the same set of facts and charges.
Hence, denying bail to the accused herein would
amount to disparity.
c) The Hon’ble Supreme Court has rejected the appeal
filed by the State challenging the grant of bail to
accused Nos.4 and 11 – The SLP(Crl)No.13498/2026
filed by the State against the accused No.4 and
SLP(Crl)No.13907/2026 filed by the State against the
accused No.11.
It is to be noted that the grant of
- 50 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
bail to the accused No.4 by the Co-ordinate Bench of
this Court was without hearing the next of kin of the
deceased and the same has been affirmed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
d) Further delay in disposal of the cases - The Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
TEHSEEN
S
POONAWALLA
referred supra has clearly laid down the time limit of
6 months for disposal of cases involving mob
violence/lynching. Hence, setting aside the order for
grant of bail and ordering for re-consideration of the
same by the Sessions Court after hearing the next of
kin of the deceased would further delay the disposal
of the cases.
e) Liberty
to
be
curtailed
only
in
exceptional
circumstances - It is trite law that the liberty of an
individual must not be curtailed unless it is absolutely
necessary. In the instant case, though bail has been
granted without following the due procedure, neither
- 51 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
the petitioner nor the State are alleging that the
accused have violated the conditions of bail or have
committed any further crime.
Hence, I am of the
view that the liberty of the accused cannot be
curtailed merely on the ground of procedural lapse by
the Court specially when there is no allegation of
violation of bail conditions or misconduct.
16.
Insofar as the contention of the learned State
Public Prosecutor-I appearing for the State to include an
additional
condition
in
the
bail
conditions
to
make
themselves present before the Police Station to prevent
witness tampering is concerned, I am of the view that the
same is required to be rejected as there is no allegation
against the accused either for violation of the existing bail
conditions or for tampering of any witness.
17.
The learned counsel appearing for the next of
kin of the deceased also contends that the guidelines in
TEHSEEN
S
POONAWALLA
referred
supra
clearly
- 52 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
indicate that the State shall formulate a scheme for
computation of the compensation for the victim and the
said scheme must also have provision for interim relief to
be paid to the victim(s) or to the next of kin of the
deceased within a period of thirty days of the incident of
mob violence or lynching, however, no such scheme for
granting interim compensation has been formulated by the
State. The learned State Public Prosecutor-I for the State
has filed a memo along with documents indicating a
detailed point-wise compliance report on each of the
directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court under
paragraph 40 of TEHSEEN S POONAWALLA referred
supra, specifically indicating compliance in respect of
Crime No.37/2025 registered by Mangaluru Rural Police
station.
The relevant chart produced by the State is
extracted below:
S.N.
a.
Points
Compliance
Appointment
of
the
District Nodal Officer
and constitution of the
Special
Task
Force
District Nodal Officer has been
appointed and Special Task
Force has been constituted
vide
this
office
circular
- 53 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
(Para 40.1)
b.
c.
Identification
of
vulnerable
districts,
sub-divisions
and
villages (Para 40.2)
Issuance of advisories
and preventive measure
by
the
Home
Department and Police
Authorities (Para 40.3)
No.LAW(1)/16/2027
dtd:03.09.2018
Yes – Identified and report
already sent vide this office
letter No.LAW(1)/16/2027 dtd
05.09.2023
Yes – Preventive measures on
Mob Lynching has been issued
vide
this
office
Circular
No.LAW(1)/16/2027
dtd
03.08.2018
d.
Monthly meetings of the Conducted
Nodal
Officer
and
quarterly
review
meetings
by
the
Director
General
of
Police/Home
Department (Para 40.4
and 40.5)
e.
Patrolling in vulnerable Police patrolling in sensitive
areas
based
on areas is done regularly
intelligence and past
incidents (Para 40.8)
f.
Preventive
patrolling,
public
awareness
programmes
and
monitoring of Social
media platforms (Para
40.10)
g.
Registration
of
FIRs
against
persons
disseminating
inflammatory
content
(Para 40.11)
h.
Immediate registration
of FIR in the present
case, intimation to the
Nodal
Officer,
Supervision
of
Complied.
Circular
no:L&O/MISC/06/2026
dtd:07.02.2026 petainging to
guidelines for registration of
FIRs in cases arising out of
social media posts have been
issued.
The
mob
lynching
which
happened under Mangaluru
Rural PS limits on 27.04.2025
was first reported as UDR on
the
same
day.
During
- 54 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
investigation and timely interrogation, it was disclosed
filing of the chargesheet as mob lynching case, after
(Para 40.13)
which FIR was immediately
registered on 28.04.2025 and
taken up for investigation, was
timely completed and charge
sheet
was
submitted
on
25.07.2025
i.
Implementation of the
Victim
compensation
scheme,
including
payment
of
interim
relief
within
the
prescribed period (Para
40.16)
Government Order has been
issued vide No.HD 01 CRR
dtd:
27.09.2023.
However, in the present case
victim’s
compensation
is
rejected for the reasons cited
by District Legal Services
Authority.
j.
Conduct of expeditious
trial, witness protection
measures,
victim
participation in judicial
proceedings
and
provision of free legal
aid; and (Para 40.17 &
40.21)
Regarding
this,
letter
No.LAW(1)/16/2017-18
dtd:
20.08.2018 has been sent to
Government for taking action
at their end.
Free legal aid scheme details
are being shared with the
victims and their kins.
k.
Action taken, if any,
against officials for noncompliance with the
direction of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court (Para
40.23)
Police
Inspector
Sri.Shivakumar who was l/c of
Mangaluru
Rural
PS
was
suspended vide order dated
01.05.2025 for not reporting
the factual information to the
higher
officer
within
the
stipulated
time
and
for
negligence in registration of
FIR and at present department
enquiry has been initiated
against him
18.
The aforesaid table as well as the perusal of the
memo along with the documents indicate the compliance
- 55 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
of the specific guidelines along with the actions taken by
the State in its compliance. The Government Order No. HD
1 CRR 2023 dated 27.09.2023 at Annexure-7 along with
the memo indicates the compensation to be provided to
the victims or the next of kin of the victims. However, it is
to be noticed that the said order does not contain any
provision for grant of interim compensation to the victim
or the next of his/her kin as per the guidelines in the case
of TEHSEEN S POONAWALLA, referred supra. Hence, I
am of the considered view that the State is required to be
directed to formulate a scheme to inculcate the provision
for interim compensation to the victims or the next of their
kin in consonance with the guidelines in the case of
TEHSEEN S POONAWALLA, referred supra.
19.
Mob lynching represents a grave threat to the
rule of law, human rights, and social fabric, as it replaces
legal justice with brutal, collective lawlessness driven by
prejudice, intolerance and hate. To effectively curb this
- 56 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
alarming phenomenon, the Parliament in the BNS has
introduced Section 103(2), which explicitly criminalizes
mob-driven violence by stipulating that when a group of
five or more persons acting in concert commits murder on
the grounds of race, caste, community, sex, place of birth,
language, personal belief or similar factors, every member
of the group shall face stringent punishment, including the
death penalty or imprisonment for life, alongside a
mandatory fine.
20.
However, it is rightly contended by the learned
counsels that the procedure as laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of TEHSEEN S PONNAWALLA
referred supra, has not been followed by the Trial Court as
well as the Sessions Court and the other stake holders in
various cases. Hence, it would be appropriate to re-iterate
the
guidelines
issued
in
the
case
of
POONAWALLA referred supra as follows:
TEHSEEN
S
- 57 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
a) The State Government shall ensure that a Nodal
Officer is appointed in each District. Such Nodal
Officer shall be assisted by a DSP rank officer in the
District for taking measures against mob violence
and lynching. The said Officers shall constitute a
special task force to procure intelligence about the
people who are likely to commit such crimes or who
are
involved
in
spreading
hate
speeches,
provocative statements and fake news.
b) The State Government shall identify Districts, subdivisions and/or villages where instances of lynching
and mob violence have been reported in the recent
past i.e. 5 years and the said identification must be
completed within 3 weeks from the date of this
judgment.
c) The Secretary, Home Department of the State shall
issue appropriate directions to the Nodal Officers to
ensure extra vigilance and caution to be maintained
- 58 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
by the Officers in-charge of the police stations in the
identified areas.
d)
The State Government shall ensure that the Nodal
Officers conduct a review meeting i.e. once every
month
to
gather
intelligence
to
identify
the
existence of the tendencies of vigilantism, mob
violence or lynching in the District and take steps to
prohibit instances of dissemination of offensive
material through different social media platforms or
any other means for inciting such tendencies.
e) The Director General of Police/the Secretary, Home
Department of the State shall conduct regular
review meetings i.e. once in 3 months with all the
Nodal Officers and the State police intelligence
heads and the Nodal Officers shall bring to the
notice of the DGP with regard to any inter-district
co-ordination issues for devising a strategy to tackle
lynching and mob violence related issues at the
State level.
- 59 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
f)
The State Government shall ensure that the Police
Officers exercise their power under Section 148 of
BNSS, to disperse a mob, which in his opinion,
tends to cause violence or wreak havoc of lynching
in the guise of vigilantism or otherwise.
g) The Director General of Police shall issue a circular
to the Superintendents of Police with regard to
police patrolling in the sensitive areas to ensure that
anti-social elements involved in such crimes are
discouraged.
h) The State Government shall broadcast on radio,
television and other media platforms including the
official websites of the Home Department of the
State that lynching and mob violence of any kind
shall invite serious consequences under the law.
i)
The State Government shall take steps to curb and
stop dissemination of irresponsible and explosive
messages, videos and other material on various
- 60 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
social media platforms which have a tendency to
incite mob violence and lynching of any kind.
j)
The State Government shall direct the police to
register FIR under Section 196 of BNS and/or other
relevant provisions of law against persons who
disseminate irresponsible and explosive messages
and videos having content which is likely to incite
mob violence and lynching of any kind.
k) The State Government shall ensure that despite the
preventive measures, if it comes to the notice of the
police that an incident of mob violence or lynching
has taken place, then the jurisdictional police shall
immediately cause to lodge an FIR, without any
undue delay, under the relevant provisions of the
BNS and/or other provisions of law.
l)
The Station House Officer, in whose police station
the FIR is registered, shall ensure that the Nodal
Officer is informed of the said incident, who in turn
- 61 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
shall ensure that there is no further harassment of
the family members of the victim(s).
m) The Nodal Officer is duty bound to personally
oversee the investigation into such offences and
he/she shall ensure that the charge sheet in such
cases is filed within the statutory period from the
date of registration of the FIR or arrest of the
accused.
n)
The State Government shall formulate a victim
compensation scheme and ensure that the said
scheme shall contain provision for interim relief to
be paid to the victim(s) or to the next of kin of the
deceased within a period of thirty days of the
incident of mob violence/lynching.
o) The cases of lynching and mob violence shall be
specifically tried by the designated Court/Fast Track
Courts earmarked for that purpose in each District.
Such Courts shall hold trial of the case on a day-today basis. The trial shall preferably be concluded
- 62 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
within
six
months
from
the
date
of
taking
cognizance and the said time-limit shall also apply
to the pending cases.
p) The District Judge shall assign cases involving mob
violence as far as possible to one jurisdictional Court
to ensure expeditious disposal thereof.
It shall be
the duty of the State Governments and the Nodal
Officers to see that the prosecuting agency strictly
carries out its role in appropriate furtherance of the
trial.
q)
The Courts to set a stern example in cases of mob
violence
and
lynching,
upon
conviction of
the
accused person(s) must ordinarily award maximum
sentence as provided for various offences under the
provisions of the BNS.
r)
The Courts shall ensure that the victim(s) or the
next of kin of the deceased in cases of mob violence
and lynching shall be given timely notice of any
Court proceedings and he/she shall be entitled to be
- 63 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
heard at the trial in respect of applications such as
bail, discharge, release and parole filed by the
accused persons.
s) The Courts shall ensure that the victim(s) or the
next of kin of the deceased in cases of mob violence
and lynching shall be given sufficient opportunity to
file written submissions on conviction, acquittal or
sentencing.
t)
The Courts shall ensure that the victim(s) or the
next of kin of the deceased in cases of mob violence
and lynching shall receive free legal aid if he or she
so chooses and engage any advocate of his/her
choice from amongst those enrolled in the legal aid
panel under the Legal Services Authorities Act,
1987.
u) The Courts shall ensure that the victim(s) or the
next of kin of the deceased in cases of mob violence
and lynching shall, on an application by a witness or
- 64 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
by the Public Prosecutor in relation to such witness
or on its own motion, take such measures, as it
deems fit, for protection and for concealing the
identity and address of the witness.
v) The Nodal Officers appointed in each District shall
ensure that timely notice has been issued on the
victim(s) or the next of kin of the deceased with
regard to any Court proceedings and also provide
any assistance in order to ensure that the victim(s)
or the next of kin of the deceased are enabled to
make their submissions in the Court proceedings.
w) The State Government shall ensure that wherever
it is found that a Police Officer or an Officer of the
District administration has failed to comply with the
aforesaid directions in order to prevent and/or
investigate and/or facilitate expeditious trial of any
crime of mob violence and lynching, the same shall
be considered as an act of deliberate negligence
and/or misconduct for which appropriate action
- 65 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
must be taken against him/her and not limited to
departmental action under the service rules. The
authority of first instance before whom such a
departmental action is taken shall endeavour to
conclude the said proceedings within a period of 6
months.
x) The State Government shall take disciplinary action
against the officials concerned, if it is found that
(i)such an official(s) did not prevent the incident
despite prior knowledge, or (ii) where the incident
has already taken place, he/she has failed to
promptly
apprehend
and
institute
proceedings
against the culprit(s).
21.
In view of the aforesaid findings and the
guidelines to be followed by the Trial Court and Sessions
Court and other stake holders, I proceed to pass the
following:
- 66 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
ORDER
(i)
The Criminal petitions are dismissed.
(ii) The
Registrar
General/Registrar
(Judicial)
is
directed to circulate this order to all the Principal
District Judges and the Sessions Judges for
mandatory
compliance
of
the
guidelines
enumerated in the aforesaid order.
(iii) The State Government is directed to formulate a
scheme for grant of interim compensation to the
victim or the next of kin of the victim within 3
months
of
passing
of
this
order
and
file
compliance report before this Court.
(iv) The Registrar (Judicial) shall issue necessary
circular to the concerned branches in the High
Court with a direction to raise objections, if the
victim is not arrayed as a party in cases involving
mob violence or lynching.
(v) The Principal District Judges shall issue necessary
circular
to
the
concerned
branches
with
a
- 67 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44907
CRL.P No.10339/2025
AND CONNECTED MATTERS
CNR: KAHC010469262025
direction to raise objections, if the victim is not
arrayed as a party in cases involving mob violence
or lynching.
(vi) The Sessions Court shall endeavor to complete
the trial and pronounce the judgment in a time
bound manner
as stipulated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of the TEHSEEN S
POONAWALLA referred supra.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
(VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)
JUDGE
RV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review