Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:34061
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMP(M) No.2079 of 2025 a/w
CMP(M) Nos.316, 1047 & 1056 of 2026
Date of Decision: 10.08.2026
1. CMP(M) No.2079 of 2025
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…… Applicants
Versus
Sanjeev Kumar and another
…… Respondents
2. CMP(M) No.316 of 2026
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…… Applicants
Versus
Narsi and another
…… Respondents
3. CMP(M) No.1047 of 2026
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…… Applicants
Versus
Pawna Kumari and another
…… Respondents
4. CMP(M) No.1056 of 2026
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…… Applicants
Versus
Aruna Sharma and another
…… Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin C. Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the applicants
For the respondents
: Mr. Gobind Korla, Additional Advocate
General.
: Ms. Archana Dutt, Advocate, for respondent
No.1 in CMP(M) Nos.316 & 1047 of 2026.
Mr. Varun Rana, Advocate, for respondent
No.2 in CMP(M) Nos.316 & 1047 of 2026.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice (oral)
By way of the present applications, review is sought
of the judgment passed in CWPOA
No.6268/2020, titled,
Sanjeev Kumar Vs. State H.P. and others, decided on
1Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
06.09.2024, by the State. Firstly, the review application is barred
by 266 days.
2.
When the matter first came up on 31.12.2025, it was
noticed by us that the order, of which review is sought had
decided three more cases and the State was directed to seek
necessary instructions, whether the review had been filed in the
other cases. The State on 25.03.2026 had placed on record the
receipts of e-filing in the other cases, and resultantly the review
petitions had also been filed in the other cases also, which were
barred by over a year and 117 to 123 days respectively. The
review petitions in other three cases were only filed on 20.02.2026
and 22.06.2026, in pursuance of our observations.
3.
Counsel for the State submitted that there was a
proposal apparently for filing review petitions in all the four cases
since the order was passed only in one case, however, initially
only
one
review
petition
was
filed.
While
referring
to
communication dated 21.04.2025 (Annexure P-4), a letter from
The Principal Secretary(UD) to the Govt. of HP, addressed to the
Director of Urban Development, H.P. Palika Bhawan, Talland,
Shimla, he further submitted that the ground made out in the first
review petition, for condoning the delay is that against the
judgment dated 06.09.2024, the implementation had become
difficult because the pay re-revision Government Notifications
dated 24.09.2012 and 27.09.2012 were only issued in favour of 22
categories as detailed in the Notification of Clerks, however, the
pay scales of some categories including the Community
Organizers, who were the petitioners, had not been re-revised by
the Government for the said employees. It is thus submitted that it
is not a general review of pay scales as it had already taken place
on 01.01.2006, and the re-revision was only the prerogative of the
State.
4.
A perusal of the grounds for review would also go on
to show that after the judgment was passed on 06.09.2024,
advice had been obtained from the learned Additional Advocate
General, who had advised to file an SLP. One of the grounds on
which the petition was allowed was that the similarly situated
officials of the Municipal Council Sarkaghat had been granted the
benefits. Resultantly, information had been sought by the State as
to whether the Community Organizers were granted the pay scale
equivalent to that of Clerk and how same had been done contrary
to the pay scale issued by the Finance Department and whether it
had been withdrawn or not. In such circumstances, it has further
been pleaded that the said benefit had been withdrawn on
01.12.2020.
5.
A perusal of Annexure P-3(Colly) would go on to
show that there is a reference to the letter dated 22.01.2025,
whereby this action of the withdrawal was taken, which is
apparently post the decision dated 06.09.2024, which is sought to
be reviewed. It has also come on record that after the decision,
the State as such started taking action. In pursuance of the letter
dated
22.01.2025
Sagrkaghat
had
or
03.02.2025,
withdrawn
the
the
revised
Municipal
pay
Council,
scale
w.e.f.
01.12.2025.
6.
Similarly a perusal of the communication dated
20.12.2024 (Annexure P-2 Colly) would go on to show that the
Principal Secretary (UD) to the Govt. of H.P., had written a letter
to the Director of Urban Development H.P. Palika Bhawan,
Talland, Shimla. While dealing with the order passed, it was
stated there was no denial of the revision of pay scale to the
Community Organizer at Sarkaghat and nor any explanation has
been given to justify the discriminatory action and explanation was
sought as to how the pay scale equivalent to the Clerk had been
granted, contrary to the pay scale issued by the Finance
Department.
7.
The said communication was then followed up on
10.01.2025 (Annexure P-2 Colly), again asking for an explanation
as to how the pay scale equivalent to that of Clerk had been
granted, contrary to the order passed on 20.02.2024. A perusal of
the letter dated 22.01.2025, which is also on record, would go on
to show that the Additional Director, Urban Development, had
issued letters to the Executive Officer, Municipal Council,
Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. on the ground how the Community
Organizers working in the MCA Sarkaghat had been granted the
pay scale equivalent to the pay of Clerk and whether it was
withdrawn or not.
8.
Thus, all this would go on to show that after the
judgment was passed, the State Government swung into action
and we are of the considered opinion that for the purpose of the
review, this exercise cannot be permitted and it is not a ground to
review the judgment in question.
9.
It is to be noticed that the issue before the Bench had
passed the order was only simplicitor as to whether the
Community Organizers were to be treated on par with the Clerks
and granted the same pay scales as on an earlier occasion
apparently they had been granted the benefit. The Bench had
noticed that the post of the Community Organizers exists in the
Municipal Cadre, but Recruitment and Promotion Rules for that
category had not been framed. Thus, in such circumstances, it
was held that there is no valid and plausible reason as to how the
Community Organizers have been left out for the revision of the
pay and the comparison as such for the equality part with
Sarkaghat was one of the grounds. In sum and substance, the
principle was that there is no quantifiable data to show any
substantial disparity in the job profiles and once the pay scale has
been equalized, the benefit necessary had to flow as per the
Clerk’s scale. Resultantly, permission was given for revision to the
extent of the Clerks in terms of the notification dated 27.09.2012
and in the next revision, if allowed, to the Clerks on 1.1.2016.
10.
The petition had initially been filed before the
Erstwhile H.P. State Administrative Tribunal by way of OA No.182
of 2018, which was subsequently registered by this Court as
CWPOA No.6268 of 2020.
11.
Reply was filed on behalf of respondents No.1 to 3
through the Director of Urban Development. A perusal of the
same would go on to show that there is no denial that the benefit
of revised pay was granted to the Clerks and the Community
Organizers and there is an admission that the revised pay scale
was released to the MC Employees on 01.01.2006 vide
Government order dated 19.12.2009. The only defence is that in
the year 2012, the pay scale of some of the categories including
Community Organizers, had not been re-revised by the
Government. It has further been admitted as far as the parity of
the pay scale between the two posts is concerned, as submitted in
the para 4 of the preliminary submission but it might not be a strait
jacket formula for equating posts, in sum and substance as
pleaded in Para 4 of the preliminary submission of the written
statement and it was mentioned that re-revision has been allowed
in respect of various categories and most of the orders have been
issued on the basis of recommendations of a Cabinet Sub
Committee and it is an exercise of the powers conferred by the
proviso to Article 309.
12.
It was thus the plea that it was not a wholesome
parity in the common category/post of Clerk and the post of
Community Organizers. Thus, it would be apparently clear that in
the reply, there is no such stand taken by the State that the
revision as such of the pay of the Community Organizers or the
equivalence of the pay scales to the post of Clerks, was wrong in
any manner and now after the decision the benefit, which had
been granted in the year 2006 is now been questioned as to how
the Community Organizers had got the same pay scales as the
Clerks.
13.
In these circumstances, the matter was decided on
the basis of material, which was already placed on record, it is not
in the purview of the review jurisdiction, as such, for the State to
take a fresh stand by placing documents on record, which had
been decided on the basis of the reply filed through the Director of
Urban Development. Thus, the State is bound by its own stand
taken and now cannot turn around to contend to the contrary.
14.
In such circumstances, we do not find any plausible
reason either to condone the delay at this belated stage in filing of
the review petitions and in view of the said observations, there is
no plausible reason to interfere with the order passed by the Coordinate Bench.
15.
Thus, there is no ground to review the order dated
06.09.2024. Resultantly, the delay applications and the review
applications are dismissed.
( G.S. Sandhawalia )
Chief Justice
August 10, 2026 (Kiran)
( Bipin Chander Negi )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review