Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 15443 of 2024
Decided on: 24th February, 2026.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------State of H.P. & Ors.
…..Petitioners
Versus
Binu Ram
.....Respondent
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioners:
Ms. Seema Sharma, Deputy Advocate
General.
For the Respondent:
Ms. Tanu Sharma, Advocate.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Learned counsel for the respondent submits that in light
of the impugned order passed by the learned Appellate Authority
under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, the respondent does not
intend to file any separate reply to the writ petition and will reiterate
the findings recorded in the impugned order.
In view of the above, and with the consent of learned
counsel for the parties, the matter has accordingly been heard at this
stage.
2.
The respondent was employed as a daily wage
Chowkidar with the petitioners–Forest Department in the year 1998.
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
His services were regularized as Chowkidar on 25.08.2006. He
retired upon attaining the age of superannuation on 31.10.2017. The
last wages drawn by the respondent as on 31.10.2017 were Rs.
23,500/-. Gratuity was not paid to the respondent by the
petitioners/employers. The respondent accordingly lodged his
gratuity claim before the competent authority.
The Controlling Authority-cum-Labour Officer, Kullu,
adjudicated the claim in respondent’s favour on 15.11.2022. The
respondent was held entitled to Rs. 2,47,457/- towards gratuity. For
computing the gratuity payable to the petitioner, his last drawn
wages were taken as Rs. 23,500/-. Statutory interest was also held
payable by the employer. The employer assailed the order dated
15.11.2022 before the Appellate Authority. The ground urged before
the Appellate Authority, which is also reiterated in the present writ
petition, essentially pertains to the gratuity payable to the respondent
vis-à-vis the service rendered by him on daily wage basis. According
to the employers/petitioners, the respondent served on daily wage
basis from the year 1998 up to 24.08.2006, therefore, gratuity for the
said period was to be computed under the Payment of Gratuity Act,
and for the remaining period, gratuity was to be calculated in
accordance with the Central Civil Services (CCS) (Pension) Rules,
1972. The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal on 20.04.2024
as under: -
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
“The Appellant/Employer has deposited an amount of Rs.
1,26,231/- vide demand draft No. 125361, dated 15.05.2023 as
determined and ordered to be paid by the Controlling Authority
with the appeal. The amount of Rs. 1,26,231/- along with the
interest accrued will be paid to the Respondent/Claimant as and
when
application
for
the
same
is
received
and
the
Appellant/Employer is further directed to pay balance amount of
gratuity amounting to Rs. 10,139/- (Rs. 1,36,370/- (-) Rs.
1,26,231/-) to the Respondent/Claimant alongwith simple interest
@ 9% from the date of filing application till the payment is actually
made.
These directions are made on the basis of service details
stated by the Appellant/Employer and available in the case file and
if some changes have taken/take place on about; service
particulars, last wages/salary drawn, payments made on account
of payment of 'Gratuity' or inadvertent arithmetical calculation
errors
are
circumstances
identified,
these
subsequently,
directions/orders
therefore
in
such
shall
stand
modified
subject
to
provisions
accordingly.
These
payments
are
further
contained in Section-2(h) (i) of the Act, if any change in the status
of Claimant or family members takes places till the payments are
actually made.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed. Announced during
the proceedings on 15 day of March, 2024 (in the presence of the
parties) and detailed orders are given/communicated as follows:”
3.
The
impugned
order
records
that
the
employers/petitioners have already paid a sum of Rs.1,21,226/- to
the respondent towards gratuity for the regular service rendered by
him. It has further been held that the daily wage service rendered by
the respondent from 1998 till 24.08.2006 could not be ignored while
computing the gratuity payable to him.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
In the aforesaid background, the employers/petitioners
have instituted the present writ petition.
4.
In support of impugned order, learned counsel for the
respondent has placed reliance upon the judgment in Bindumati vs.
State of H.P. & Ors2. Learned Deputy Advocate General has fairly
admitted that the point raised in this petition was also in question in
Bindumati2 and further that the decision in Bindumati2 has been
accepted by the respondents therein and stands implemented.
Relevant portion from the said decision is as under: “4. Indisputably, the petitioner had been sanctioned
gratuity in the sum of 1,08,567/- by respondent No.3 on 19.04.2023
for the ₹4,21,068/- was sanctioned in regular service rendered by
her. Further, under office order dated 08.02.2024, a sum of
4,21,068/- was also sanctioned in petitioner's ₹4,21,068/- was
sanctioned in favour as differential amount of gratuity for about 23
years 04 months of daily waged service discharged by her. Both the
orders passed in this regard by respondent No.3 under the Payment
of Gratuity Act, 1972 were accepted by the respondent Department.
The remedy of appeal etc. was not availed against the aforesaid
orders. That being the position, the respondent No.5’s taking
objections by putting forth the Finance Department’s letter dated
31.12.2020
is
beyond
comprehension.
CWP No. 4632/2025 decided on 07.11.2025
Respondent
No.5’s
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
objections were irrelevant when the respondent department had
accepted the orders passed by the Competent Authority more
particularly the order dated 08.02.2024. Furthermore, in terms of the
office letter dated 31.12.2020, the Finance Department had advised
the Administrative Department to agitate the orders passed in
particular given situation before the Higher Appellate Authority within
the prescribed time limit. As noticed previously, in the instant case
no appeal was filed by the respondent department against the orders
passed by adjudicating authority. The order dated 08.02.2024
passed by the adjudicating authority having attained finality was
required to be given effect to by respondent No.5. It is also relevant
to take stock of the fact that respondents No. 1 to 3 (concerned
department) have not even contested this writ petition. Rather a
statement was made in this regard on their behalf on 20.08.2025
that they do not intend to file any reply. The petition has been
opposed only by respondents No. 4 & 5 i.e. the Treasury
Department.
The
objection
of
Treasury
Department
is
not
maintainable in the background of given factual situation.
5. It needs to be noticed that in Net Ram Sahu versus
State of Chhattisgarh3, the Hon'ble Apex Court had held that
having regularized services of appellant (therein), State had no
justifiable reason to deny benefit of gratuity to appellant which was
2018 (5) SCC 430.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
his statutory right; Question as to from which date services were
regularized was of no consequence for calculating total length of
service for claiming gratuity once services were regularized. It was
further held that Payment of Gratuity Act being a welfare legislation
is meant for benefit of employees who serve their employer for long
time and, it was duty of State to pay gratuity to employee rather than
deny benefit on some technical ground and force an employee to
approach Court to get his genuine claim. Portion from the decision,
relevant to context is as follows: “16. In our considered opinion, once the State regularized the
services of the appellant while he was in State services, the
appellant became entitled to count his total period of service for
claiming the gratuity amount subject to his proving continuous
service of 5 years as specified under Section 2A of the Act which,
in this case, the appellant has duly proved.
17.
In the circumstances appearing in the case, it would be the
travesty of justice, if the appellant is denied his legitimate claim of
gratuity despite rendering “continuous service” for a period of 25
years which even, according to the State, were regularized. The
question as to from which date such services were regularized
was of no significance for calculating the total length of service for
claiming gratuity amount once the services were regularized by
the State.
18. It was indeed the State who took 22 years to regularize the
service of the appellant and went on taking work from the
appellant on payment of a meager salary of Rs.2776/- per month
for 22 long years uninterruptedly and only in the last three years,
the State started paying a salary of Rs.11,107/- per month to the
appellant. Having regularized the services of the appellant, the
State had no justifiable reason to deny the benefit of gratuity to
the appellant which was his statutory right under the Act. It being
a welfare legislation meant for the benefit of the employees, who
serve their employer for a long time, it is the duty of the State to
voluntarily pay the gratuity amount to the appellant rather than to
force the employee to approach the Court to get his genuine
claim.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
19. In view of the foregoing discussion, we cannot agree with the
reasoning and the conclusion arrived at by the High Court which is
legally unsustainable. It is really unfortunate that the genuine
claim of the appellant was being denied by the State at every
stage of the proceedings up to this Court and dragged him in
fruitless litigation for all these years.
20. Indeed, this reminds us of the apt observations made by the
Chief Justice M.C. Chagla (as he then was) in the case of Firm
Kaluram Sitaramv. Union of India. The learned Chief Justice in his
distinctive style of writing while deciding the case between an
individual citizen and the State made the following pertinent
observations:
“19. Now, we have often had occasion to say that when the
State deals with a citizen it should not ordinarily reply on
technicalities, and if the State is satisfied that the case of
the citizen is a just one, even though legal defences may be
open to it, it must act, as has been said by eminent Judges,
as an honest person.”
21. These observations apply in full force against the State in this
case because just case of the appellant was being opposed by
the State on technical grounds. As a consequence, the appeal
succeeds and is allowed. Impugned judgment/order passed by
the High Court (Single Judge and Division Bench) are set aside
and the orders of the Controlling Authority and Appellate Authority
are restored with cost of Rs.25,000/- payable by the State to the
appellant. Cost to be paid by the State along with the payment of
gratuity amount.”
Though the above decision has been referred to the
Larger Bench in Dhansai Sahu versus State of Chhattisgarh and
another,4 however, it is also settled principle of law that decision
referred to Larger Bench continues to govern until decision of the
Larger Bench (Reference: Rajnish Kumar Rai versus Union of
Civil Appeal No. 564/2020, order dated 21.08.2024.
( 2026:HHC:4267 )
India and another 5 and Ashok Kumar and another versus UOI
and another6).”
As can be deciphered from the impugned order, the
sole ground taken by the employers before the learned authorities
below was to draw a distinction between the service rendered by the
respondent as a daily wager vis-à-vis the service rendered by him as
a regular employee for the purpose of computation of gratuity
payable to him. In view of the law in force at present, the issue
involved stands decided in favour of the respondent by the Hon’ble
Apex Court. The law laid down in Net Ram Sahu3, as observed,
continues to hold the field, hence, the computation of gratuity
payable to the petitioner for the service rendered by him with the
petitioners under the impugned order calls for no interference. No
other ground was urged. In view of above, the present petition is
dismissed. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
24th February, 2026
(Rohit)
2023 (14) SCC 782
2012 (11) SCC 321)
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review