Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMP(M) No.2400 of 2025
Date of Decision : 24.02.2026
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…… Applicants/ Appellants
Versus
Anuj Kumari
…… Respondent
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Applicants
For the Respondent :
: Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with
Mr. Varun Chandel, Additional Advocate
General.
Nemo.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice (oral)
The present appeal against the judgment of learned
Single Judge, passed in Civil Writ Petition No.575 of 2023, decided on
01.09.2023, has been preferred after an inordinate delay of 709 days,
as per the applicants/appellants.
2.
Learned Additional Advocate General has relied upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Manipur and others
vs. Koting Lamkang, (2019) 10 SCC 408 to submit that the delay is
liable to be condoned, since the principles laid down in the said
judgment, as such, was that the State Government’s functioning could
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
result in injustice to the institutional interest where individual officer fails
to act responsibly.
The appeals, if
individual interest, those who
filed by the State are lost for
are at fault, will not usually be
individually affected. It is thus contended that costs can be imposed
upon the State to condone the delay as is done in the said case, as
the learned Single Judge has directed consideration for compassionate
appointment keeping in view the fact that the death of the husband of
the respondent/writ petitioner had occurred during service at the age of
40, way back in the year, 2017 and, therefore, consideration as per the
Policy framed in the year, 2019 was not correct. Rejection on that
ground on 23.07.2021 (Annexure P-9) had been wrongly quashed and
fresh consideration has been directed in terms of prevailing Policy at
the relevant time from the date of death of the husband of petitioner in
accordance with law within a period of six weeks, while placing reliance
upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court, in State of
Madhya Pradesh and others vs. Ashish Awasthi, (2022) 2 SCC
157.
3.
A perusal of the application would go on to show that
after decision in the case on 01.09.2023, the respondent had also
downloaded a copy of the judgment from the official website and the
same was sent to E-1 Branch of the Office of the applicants. Learned
Additional Advocate General had also applied the certified copy of the
judgment on 04.10.2023 expeditiously and the same was supplied on
16.10.2023 and received by the Law Branch of the applicants, on
17.10.2023. The matter had been taken up for further direction on
17.10.2023. However, no directions were received w.e.f. 17.10.2023
till 04.07.2024 a period of 09 months. Again, a request was made and
only after a period of 11 months on 25.09.2024, the Government asked
for providing original case alongwith relevant documents. The approval
was thereafter given only on 09.05.2025 to file the appeal a period of
one year after the second request had been received which goes to
show that it was gross negligence and inaction on the part of the State
while dealing with the case of compassionate appointment, for which
the writ petitioner, as such, was fighting for consideration for
appointment on the death of her husband at the young age of 40 years,
who had already rendered service upto 17 years.
4.
We are also referring and touching the merits of case,
keeping in view the fact that in Sheo Raj Singh (deceased) through
LRs. and others vs. Union of India and another, 2023(10 SCC 531,
it has been held that while deciding such application, the merits of the
claim may also be considered and whether such policy issue is to be
affected. It is to be further noticed that we have already, in principle,
decided in LPA No.797 of 2025, titled State of Himachal Pradesh
and another vs. Sarita Devi keeping in view the law laid down by the
Apex Court in a three Judge Bench judgment in, State of Madhya
Pradesh and others vs. Amit Shrivas 2020(10) SCC 496, that the
date of demise is to be seen unless subsequent policy is made
applicable retrospectively. We also made reference to the judgment of
the Apex Court, in State of Karnataka vs. Bheemesh, 2021(20) SCC
707, wherein it has been held that the only fixed factor is the date of
death that does not change and, therefore, on account of the fact that
the date of the application and the date of the consideration of the
policy would be different, the differential treatment should not be given
to the employees. The relevant Paragraph reads as under:“20. The important aspect about the conflict of opinion is
that it revolves around two dates, namely, (i) date of death
of the employee; and (ii) date of consideration of the
application of the dependant. Out of these two dates, only
one, namely, the date of death alone is a fixed factor that
does not change. The next date, namely, the date of
consideration of the claim, is something that depends upon
many variables such as the date of filing of application, the
date of attaining of majority of the claimant and the date on
which the file is put up to the competent authority. There is
no principle of statutory interpretation which permits a
decision on the applicability of a rule, to be based upon an
indeterminate or variable factor. Let us take for instance a
hypothetical case where 2 government serviant dies in
harness on 1-1-2020. Let us assume that the dependants of
these 2 deceased government servants make applications
for appointment on 2 different dates say 29-5-2020 and 2-62020 and a modified Scheme comes into force on 1-62020. If the date of consideration of the claim is taken to be
the criteria for determining whether the modified Scheme
applies or not, it will lead to two different results, one in
respect of the person who made the application before 1-62020 and another in respect of the person who applied after
1-6-2020. In other words, if two employees die on the same
date and the dependants of those employees apply on two
different dates, one before the modified Scheme comes into
force and another thereafter, they will come in for
differential treatment if the date of application and the date
of consideration of the same are taken to be the deciding
factor. A rule of
interpretation which produces different results, depending
upon what the individuals do or do not do, is inconceivable.
This is why, the managements of a few banks, in the cases
tabulated above, have introduced a rule in the modified
scheme itself, which provides for all pending applications to
be decided under the new/modified scheme. Therefore, we
are of the considered view that the interpretation as to the
applicability of a modified Scheme should depend only
upon a determinate and fixed criteria such as the date of
death and not an indeterminate and variable factor.”
5.
In such circumstances, we are of the considered opinion
that even on merits also the State does not have a case. In Koting
Lamkang’s case (supra), we notice that delay in filing the regular first
appeal (RFA) was shown to be 44 days, which was before a wrong
forum and delay in fact, was 312 days. It was accordingly held that if
the main appeal was not heard, it would affect public interest as it was
a strategically sensitive case involving security of the State which
should not be non suited
on the ground of delay.
The decree in
question if executed would require the Director General of Police and
the Commandant of the 8th Battalion of the Manipur Rifles to vacate
and handover the land in dispute which was projected to be an area of
strategic importance by the applicant. It is in such circumstances, the
application had been allowed subject to payment of costs of
Rs.50,000/- by the appellant.
6.
The present case as such would go on to show that the
benefit as such would not be liable to be granted, especially keeping in
view the law laid down, time and again, by the Apex Court in Oriental
Aroma
Chemical
Industries
Ltd.
vs.
Gujarat
Industrial
Development Corporation and another, (2010) 5 SCC 459 and
Chief Postmaster General and others vs. Living Media India Ltd.
and
another,
(2012)
SCC
and
elaborated
in
Esha
Bhattachargee vs. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar
Academy, (2013) 12 SCC 649.
7.
Recently, in Special Leave Petition (c) Diary No.54941 of
2025, the Managing Committee of Namatara Girls High School, after
considering the earlier judgment in Collector, Land Acquisition,
Anantnag vs. Mst Katiji, (1987) 2 SCC 107 and G. Ramegowda vs.
Land Acquisition Officer, (1988) 2 SCC 142, the Apex Court again
did not permit the condonation of delay of eight years while placing
reliance upon the judgment passed in University of Delhi vs. Union
of India, (2020) 13 SCC 745 and Pathapati Suba Reddy vs.
Collector (LA) (2024) 12 SCC 336. Resultantly, it has been held that
condonation of delay cannot be claimed as a matter of right and the
explanation given as such, was a lame excuse and no case was made
out for exercising the jurisdiction and the Courts cannot help a litigant,
who is itself under the shackles of bureaucratic indifference being the
Government.
8.
In such circumstances, we do not condone the delay, as
such, and dismiss the application.
Resultantly, the appeal is also
dismissed.
( G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
February 24, 2026 (KS/ST)
( Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review