Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Review Petition No. 22/2026.
Decided on: 25.05.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------State and another
…..Petitioners
Versus
Dr. Ashish Sharma
.....Respondent
------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Y.P.S. Dhaulta, Additional
Advocate General.
For the Respondent:
Mr. Rajnish Maniktala, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Dinkar
Bhaskar, Advocate.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
State
of
H.P.
through
Principal
Secretary
(Personnel) as also Principal Secretary (Animal Husbandry),
Himachal Pradesh seeks review of Ashish Sharma versus
State of H.P and another2. The said writ petition was
decided
on
the
strength
of
office
instructions
dated
25.10.2024 issued by Director, Animal Husbandry, H.P.;
alongwith office instructions dated 25.10.2024 an office
letter issued by Secretary, Animal Husbandry, Government
of H.P. on 18.10.2024 had also been
appended. The writ
petition was decided as under:This writ petition has been filed for grant of following
substantive reliefs:1
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
CWP No.9886/2024, decided on 21.05.2025.
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
“(A)
That the respondents may be directed to
consider the contractual service put in the by the
petitioner as Veterinary Officer in the Department
of Animal Husbandry, Government of Himachal
Pradesh with effect from 16.03.2006 to 15.09.2012
on contract basis, towards total length of service
put in by the petitioner as Himachal Pradesh
Administrative Service Officer for the purposes of
grant of four tier pay scales in accordance with
notifications placed on record as Annexure P-7, P-8
and P-9.
(B)
That after considering the contractual
service of petitioner for grant of four tier pay scale
as aforesaid, the respondents may be directed to
fix the pay of petitioner in terms of the applicable
notifications placed on record.
(C)
That after grant of four tier pay scale to
the petitioner and consequent fixation of pay, the
respondents may be directed to grant him all the
arrears of his pay along with interest 9% per
annum.”
2.
Respondents have not filed reply to the writ
petition, however, on 02.05.2025 office instructions
dated 25.10.2024 from the Director Animal
Husbandry, Himachal Pradesh were placed on
record. As per these office instructions, the Secretary
(Animal Husbandry) to the Government of Himachal
Pradesh, had granted benefit of four tier scale to the
petitioner on notional basis from the date of his
appointment
on
contract
basis.
Further
consequential actions, including fixation of pay in the
matter were required to be carried out at the end of
the
Principal
Secretary
(Personnel)
to
the
Government of Himachal Pradesh. Copy of the office
order dated 18.10.2024 issued by the Secretary
(Animal Husbandry) to the Government of Himachal
Pradesh has also been appended alongwith the office
instructions.
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
submits that office instructions dated 25.10.2024
alongwith office letter dated 18.10.2024 have
redressed the grievance of the petitioner, therefore,
direction be issued to respondent No.1 to issue
necessary
and
consequential
orders
based
thereupon, including the pay fixation order.
4.
Keeping in view the instructions memo dated
25.10.2024 from the Director Animal Husbandry,
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
Himachal Pradesh and also office letter dated
18.10.2024 from the Secretary (Animal Husbandry)
to the Government of Himachal Pradesh, this writ
petition is disposed of by directing respondent No.1
to do the needful in terms of aforesaid
instructions/letter including re-fixing the pay of the
petitioner within a period of four weeks. Liberty,
however, is reserved to the petitioner to seek
appropriate remedy, in accordance with law, for
redressal of his surviving grievances, in case
necessity so arises in future.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
also to stand disposed.”
2.
The State Personnel Department and Animal
Husbandry Department now seek review of above decision
on the ground that the Director, Animal Husbandry was not
the respondent in the writ petition and
not competent to
have issued office instructions dated 25.10.2024 at his own
level without consulting the petitioner departments. Learned
Additional Advocate General has also submitted that reply
was not called for in the main writ petition. Learned Senior
Counsel for the respondent
submits that the writ petition
had been repeatedly listed but respondent did not file reply.
Thereafter on the basis of their own instructions placed on
record, the writ petition was disposed of.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the case file.
4.
Counsel
During hearing of the case, learned Senior
for
the
respondent
placed
on
record
office
instructions dated 25.10.2024 issued by the Director, Animal
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
Husbandry, H.P. as also the office letter dated 18.10.2024
from
Secretary
(Animal
Husbandry)
to
the
Principal
Secretary (Personnel), Govt. of H.P. lt is based upon these
two documents that
Ashish Sharma2 was disposed of
taking note of submission made by learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner.
4(i).
In view of nature of contention raised in this
petition by the review petitioners, it would be appropriate to
first extract hereinafter office letter dated 18.10.2024 that
was addressed by the Secretary (Animal Husbandry),
Government of H .P. to the Principal Secretary (Personnel),
copy endorsed to Director, Animal Husbandry:“Subject:
Representations of Dr. Charanji Lal,
HPAS-2011, Dr. Ashish Sharma, HPAS2012, Dr. Amit Guleria, HPAS-2012 and
Dr. (Maj. Retd.) Avaninder Kumar, HPAS2014 regarding benefits of 4-Tier Pay
Scale as per judgment dated 02.03.2023
passed by the Hon’ble High Court in CWP
No.1599/2020
alongwith
other
connected matters.
Sir,
I am directed to refer to your letters No.
Per(A-IV)-B(3)-7/2011 dated 02.07.2024 and Per-IVB003-14/2023 dated 05.07.2024, on the subject
cited above and to say that in compliance to
judgment dated 02.03.2023 of Hon’ble High Court,
passed in CWP No.1599/2020- Pankaj Lakhanpal Vs
State of H.P. and other connected matters, the
benefits of fourtier pay scale to the Veterinarians of
Animal Husbandry Deptt. were granted on notional
basis from the date of appointment on contract basis
and on actual basis from the date of appointment on
regular basis, vide letters Nos. AHY-B(15)-30/15-P-IV
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
dated
08.12.2023
&
AHY-B(7)-1/2023
dated
24.07.2024 (copies enclosed).
Keeping in view the above facts, the
representations of Dr. Charanji Lal, Dr. Ashish
Sharma, Dr.Amit Guleria and Dr. Avaninder Kumar
have been considered and it has been decided to
grant same benefits of four tier pay scale
on
notional basis from the date of appointment on
contract basis for the service tendered in Animal
Husbandry Deptt. on contract basis in favour of
above mentioned HPAS Officers, whose service detail
in Animal Husbandry Deptt. is as under:S.
Name of Vety.
Officer
Date of
appointm
ent on
contract
basis
Dr. Charanji Lal
(HPAS-2011)
11.04.200 06 year 11.10.2
months
Dr. Ashish
Sharma (HPAS2012)
16.03.200 06 year 15.09.2
months
Dr. Amit Guleria
(HPAS-2012)
07.09.200 05 year 15.09.2
08 days 012
Dr. Avaninder
(HPAS-2014)
27.11.201 11
27.10.2
months 014
06 days
No.
Service
rendere
d in the
Deptt.
Date of
leaving
the
Deptt.
You, are therefore, requested to take
further necessary action in the matter accordingly.”
4(ii).
The above office letter as communicated to the
Director, Animal Husbandry, H.P. led the latter to furnish
following office instructions to the office of learned Advocate
General of H.P. vide office letter dated 25.10.2024 by
appending therein letter dated 18.10.2024:-
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
“Subject:
CWP No.9886/2024 titled as –Dr.Ashish
Sharma Vs. State of H.P.
Sir,
Kindly refer to your office letter No.CWP
9886/2024-61670, dated 01/10/2024, the copy of
which is addressed to the Principal Secretary
(Personnel)
and
Principal
Secretary
(Animal
Husbandry) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh,
on the subject cited above.
In this connection, it is submitted that
vide letter No.AHY-B(150-24/2022, dated 18/10/2024
(copy enclosed), the respondent No.2 i.e. Secretary
(A.H.) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh has
granted the benefit of four tier pay scale on notional
basis from the date of appointment on contract basis
for the service rendered by the petitioner i.e. Dr.
Ashish Sharma in the Animal Husbandry Department
on contract basis as granted to the petitioners in CWP
No.1599/2020- Pankaj Lakhanpal & others Vs. State
of H.P & others and other connected matters The
further action in the matter regarding fixation of the
pay of the petitioner is to be taken by the Principal
Secretary (Personnel) to the Government of Himachal
Pradesh, as such the relief claimed by the petitioner
has been granted to him.
The Hon’ble Court may kindly be
appraised accordingly, please.”
4(iii).
Alongwith review petition, the petitioner has
placed on record office letter dated 23.11.2024 at Annexure
R-7 from Secretary, Animal Husbandry to the Secretary
(Personnel) to the Govt. of H.P. conveying approval of the
government for grant of 04 tier pay scale to several persons
including
the present petitioner, copy of this office letter
had also been endorsed to the Director, Animal Husbandry.
4(iv).
In view of the office instructions placed on record
by the respondent
in Ashish Sharma2, the decision
rendered in the said case on 21.05.2025 cannot be set to
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
be falling within any of the para-meters eliciting review
jurisdiction. The grounds set out by the petitioner do not fall
within the ambit of review powers.
The principles for reviewing a decision were
summed up in Sanjay Kumar Agarwal Versus State Tax
Officer (1) and another3 as under:“16. The gist of the aforestated decisions is that:
16.1. A judgment is open to review inter alia if there
is a mistake or an error apparent on the face of the
record.
16.2. A judgment pronounced by the court is final,
and departure from that principle is justified only
when circumstances of a substantial and compelling
character make it necessary to do so.
16.3. An error which is not self-evident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be
said to be an error apparent on the face of record
justifying the court to exercise its power of review.
16.4. In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47
Rule 1 CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous
decision to be "reheard and corrected".
16.5. A review petition has a limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise".
16.6. Under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot
be permitted to reagitate and reargue the questions
which have already been addressed and decided.
16.7. An error on the face of record must be such an
error which, mere looking at the record should strike
and it should not require any long-drawn process of
reasoning on the points where there may conceivably
be two opinions.
16.8. Even the change in law or subsequent
decision/judgment of a coordinate or larger Bench by
itself cannot be regarded as a ground for review.”
Further, in Malleeswari Versus K. Suguna
and another4, Hon’ble Apex Court held that review
(2024) 2SCC 362
2025 SCC Online SC 1927
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
jurisdiction cannot be assumed unless it is conferred by law
on the authority or the Court. Power of review is different
from the appellate power. Following limitations were laid
down for maintaining the finality of judicial decisions:“15.1 The review proceedings are not by way of an
appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope
and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC5.
15.2 Review is not to be confused with appellate
powers, which may enable an appellate court to
correct all manner of errors committed by the
subordinate court6.
15.3 In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47
Rule 1 of CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous
decision to be reheard and corrected. A review
petition, it must be remembered, has a limited
purpose and cannot be allowed to be an appeal in
disguise7.
15.4 The power of review can be exercised for the
correction of a mistake, but not to substitute a view.
Such powers can be exercised within the limits
specified in the statute governing the exercise of
power8.
15.5 The review court does not sit in appeal over its
own order. A rehearing of the matter is
impermissible. It constitutes an exception to the
general rule that once a judgment is signed or
pronounced, it should not be altered9.
Hence, it is invoked only to prevent a miscarriage of
justice or to correct grave and palpable errors10.”
It was further held that though through a review
application, an apparent error of fact or law is intimated to
the Court, but no extra reasoning is undertaken to explain
the said error. The intimation of error at the first blush
(1995)1 SCC 170
(1979) 4 SCC 389
(1997) 8 SCC 715
(2000) 6 SCC 224
(2009) 14 SCC 663
AIR (1963) SC 1909
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
enables the Court to correct apparent errors instead of
higher court correcting such errors. At both the stages,
detailed reasoning is not warranted. Distinction between
power of review and appellate power as also the power &
scope of review jurisdiction was summed up as under:“17.1 The ground of discovery of new and important
matter or evidence is a ground available if it is
demonstrated that, despite the exercise of due
diligence, this evidence was not within their
knowledge or could not be produced by the party at
the time, the original decree or order was passed.
17.2 Mistake or error apparent on the face of the
record may be invoked if there is something more
than a mere error, and it must be the one which is
manifest on the face of the record 11. Such an error is
a patent error and not a mere wrong decision12. An
error which has to be established by a long-drawn
process of reasoning on points where there may
conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said to be
an error apparent on the face of the record13.
17.3 Lastly, the phrase ‘for any other sufficient
reason' means a reason that is sufficient on grounds
at least analogous to those specified in the other two
categories14.”
Applying the above principles to the facts of the
instant case, in view of the fact that issuance of instructions
on the basis of which Ashish Sharma2 was decided, is
matter of record, it cannot be said that there is any error
apparent on record in the judgment that requires to be
reviewed.
(1955) 1 SCR 1104
AIR (1954) SC 440
AIR (1960) SC 137
1922 SCC Online PC11; AIR (1954) SC 526
( 2026:HHC:19438 )
For the foregoing reason, no case to review the
judgment is made out. Accordingly, petition is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, to also stand disposed of.
May 25, 2026
yogesh
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review