The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In the result, we do not find any perversity in the impugned judgment and in absence of substantial and compelling reason, no ground exists to interfere with the findings of acquittal recorded by the Trial Court and therefore, in our view, the Trial Court was justified in acquitting the accused.
19. With the observations as aforesaid, no case is made out to grant leave to appeal. Accordingly the appeal stands dismissed at the admission stage. (ILESH J. VORA,J) (R. T. VACHHANI, J) Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST ACQUITTAL) NO. 2169 of 2026
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
PRASHANT @ MUKESH BAPU LALA PIMPLE & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR LB DABHI APP for the Appellant
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 21/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
Here is the Appeal by the State under Section 419 of the Bharatiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (corresponding section 378
of
Cr.P.C.) against the judgment and order of acquittal.
2.
Being dissatisfied by the judgment and order passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Surat, passed in Sessions Case No.495 of 2021 and
227 of 2023, dated 02.12.2025, acquitting the accused in number 4,
from the offences punishable under Sections 302, 212 and 114 of
the IPC as well as under Section 135 of the Gujarat Police Act, the
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
State has preferred instant appeal.
3.
We have heard Mr. L. B. Dabhi, learned APP for the appellant –
State.
4.
Brief facts giving rise to file the present Appeal are that, the
respondents accused were tried and prosecuted for the act of
murder allegedly caused by respondent no. 1. The deceased Rohit
was having soft corner with the sister of accused Prashant Lala. On
this issue, there was quarrel arose between them and later on,
matter was settled amicably. However, on the said issue, the
accused Prashant had called upon the deceased Rohan on
07.02.2020 at about 8-30 pm at the place of offence and was
stabbed to death by inflicting knife injuries on all over the body.
The friends of the accused No. 1, who were present were arraigned
had given shelter to him, as a result, the accused nos. 2 to 4 as well
as accused no. 1 were arrested in the alleged offence. After the
incident, someone had informed the father of the deceased PW-11
about the incident. He went to the place of incident and then, at the
hospital, where deceased brought dead. The PW-11 father lodged
an FIR after receiving the necessary inputs about the causing death
to his son by the accused. After the registration of the offense with
the Udhna Police Station, Surat, the I.O proceeded to investigate
the case and during the investigation, he recorded the statement of
the witnesses, sent the dead body for postmortem, prepared a spot
panchnama, arrested the accused, recovered and seized the weapon
knife allegedly used in the crime at the discovery panchnama, sent
the seized articles to the FSL for Forensic Science Analysis and at
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
the end, the accused came to be chargesheeted for the offences as
referred above. It is relevant to note that on the basis of
supplementary chargesheet filed against the accused no. 4, the two
Sessions Cases for the same offence had been committed to the
Court of Sessions at Surat.
5.
The learned Sessions Judge framed charges to which the accused
pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
6.
In order to prove the charge, the prosecution has examined as many
as 28 witnesses and relied on 30 exhibited documents.
7.
On conclusion of oral evidence, the Trial Court recorded further
statements of the accused as provided under Section 313 of the
Code, wherein, they claimed their innocence and stated that they
have been falsely implicated in the offence.
8.
The learned Sessions Judge, after appreciating and examining the
oral as well as documentary evidence, acquitted the accused herein
for the offences with which they were charged, on the following
grounds:
(i)
The eye-witnesses PW-12 and 25 namely Yash Gaikwad
and Sachin have not supported to the case of the prosecution
and after declaring them hostile, during the crossexamination, they have not supported the case of the
prosecution. Even, the father of the deceased PW-11, did not
have supported on the material aspect of the prosecution
case.
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
(ii)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
Recovery and discovery, as narrated in the panchnama Exh.
78 having not been proved in terms of Section 27 of the
Evidence Act. The panchas of discovery panchnama of the
weapons have not supported to the case of the prosecution
and the I.O failed to depose the exact words disclosed by the
accused as well as the contents of the panchnama Exh. 78.
9.
In such circumstances, the Trial Court while acquitting the accused,
held and observed that the prosecution has miserably failed to
prove the charge against the accused by leading cogent and
convincing evidence.
10.
Mr. L.B. Dabhi, learned APP learned APP appearing for and on
behalf of the State, assailing the judgment and order of acquittal,
has submitted that the findings of acquittal are contrary to law and
evidence on record and the findings recorded are palpably
erroneous and based on the irrelevant material; that the Trial Court
failed to appreciate that merely because witnesses have been
declared hostile, the entire case does not stand effaced from the
record and the portion of the evidence, which is otherwise reliable
and finds corroboration, can always be taken into consideration and
therefore, the evidence of hostile witnesses having not been
properly appreciated; that, after the incident, the principal accused
was absconded of the place of occurrence and the other accused
had given shelter to him, which conduct is required to be evaluated
under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, alongside the medical
evidence and recovery of incriminating articles, formed a vital link
completing the chain of circumstances to prove the involvement of
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
the accused herein; thus, the trial Court ought not to have discarded
the prosecution case in its entirety; the evidence of the IO to prove
the disclosure statement of the accused is reliable, however, the
trial Court discarded the evidence of IO in a mechanical manner;
the forensic evidence pointing towards the involvement of the
accused having been ignored and discarded; while recording the
acquittal, the trial Court has placed undue emphasis upon minor
contradictions and omissions, which has no bearing on the case of
the prosecution; that the learned trial Court failed to appreciate the
evidence on touchstone of probabilities arising from the proved
circumstances and ignored the material circumstances on technical
consideration without examining their cumulative probative force.
11.
In such circumstances, the learned State counsel has vehemently
argued that this is a fit case to grant leave to appeal and by
admitting the appeal, the Court may call for the records and grant
an opportunity to hear the appeal on merits.
12.
In the present case the issue falls for our consideration as to
whether the trial Court was justified in acquitting the accused and
the permission to file an appeal is required to be granted or not?
13.
We have carefully examined the oral as well as documentary
evidence and perused the findings of acquittal rendered by the Trial
Court.
14.
Before proceeding to address the rival submissions, we would like
to place on record the scope of interference in an appeal against the
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
acquittal and when the same is justified. In exceptional cases,
where there are compelling circumstances and the judgment under
appeal is found to be perverse, the appellate court can interfere with
the judgment of acquittal. The Appellate Court should bear in mind
the presence of innocence of the accused and further that, the trial
Court’s acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence.
Interference in a routine manner, where the other view of possible
should be avoided, unless there are reasons for interference.
15.
In the facts of the present case, there is no dispute on the issue that
the death of the deceased Rohit was culpable homicide. In the
present case, on the basis of suspicion about the relations of the
deceased with the sister of the principal accused, the deceased
Rohit was called upon by the accused at the place of incident and
during the altercation, he was done to death by stabbing multiple
times with the weapon knife by the accused Prashant. The father of
the deceased PW-11 had denied the factum of incident and the
involvement of the accused in the crime. He has stated in his
deposition that, his son had suffered injuries in a motor accident.
The friends of the accused as well as the deceased namely – PW12, 13 and 25, have not supported to the prosecution case. Even in
their cross-examination, they have not admitted the factum of
incident as well as involvement of the accused. In such
circumstances, admittedly, in order to prove the charge, there is no
direct evidence on record against the accused.
16.
So far as circumstantial evidence is concerned, the prosecution
mainly relied on the recovery and discovery panchnama Exh. 78
R/CR.A/2169/2026(GJHC240669812026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 21/09/2026
and the Forensic Science evidence. The panchas of the discovery
panchnama have been declared hostile. The IO in his deposition,
failed to prove the contents of the panchnama and the voluntary
statement disclosed before him by the accused. In such
circumstances, the circumstances as relied having not been proved
by cogent evidence and therefore, the circumstances cannot be
taken into consideration to infer that the crime has been committed
by the accused and none else.
17.
In such circumstances, the charges against the accused are not
proved by direct as well as circumstantial evidence.
18.
In the result, we do not find any perversity in the impugned
judgment and in absence of substantial and compelling reason, no
ground exists to interfere with the findings of acquittal recorded by
the Trial Court and therefore, in our view, the Trial Court was
justified in acquitting the accused.
19.
With the observations as aforesaid, no case is made out to grant
leave to appeal. Accordingly the appeal stands dismissed at the
admission stage.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
P.S. JOSHI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review