Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST ACQUITTAL) NO. 2156 of 2026
==========================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
KISHANJI S/O. PRAVINJI SHANKARJI THAKOR
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR ROHAN H RAVAL ADDITIONAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the
Appellant(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 21/09/2026
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI)
1.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the judgment and order
dated 25.03.2026, passed by the learned Sessions Judge,
Mehsana in Sessions Case No.87 of 2025, acquitting the accused
under Section 103(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (for short,
‘BNS’), 2023, the present appeal under Section 419 of the
Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita (for short, ‘BNSS’), 2023 has
been preferred by the appellant – State.
2.
The brief facts of the case are as under:
2.1
It is the case of the prosecution that the deceased – Pravinji
Shankarji Thakor, aged 45 years, is the father of the respondent
accused. On 04.07.2025, between 20:00 and 21:00 hours, a
dispute arose between the deceased and the accused over food in
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
Indirapara Village, Moje Malosan. During the quarrel, the
accused got agitated and beaten the deceased with a hammer on
his chest due to which the ribs of the deceased’s chest inside
were broken, thereby causing death due to serious injuries.
2.2
The complainant namely Vishnuji Shankarji Thakor has
lodged an FIR registered at Ladol Police Station, Mehsana on
05.07.2025 vide FIR No.11206079250115/2025 against the
accused for the offences punishable under Section 103(1) of the
BNS, 2023.
2.3
The
Investigating
Officer
upon
completion
of
the
investigation, laid charge-sheet and Criminal Case No.1444 of
2025 was registered before the learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Vijapur and upon committal, the charge was framed
at Exh.4 by the learned Sessions Court, Mehsana.
2.4
The prosecution has examined 10 prosecution witnesses
and relied upon 27 documentary evidences. The witnesses
claimed to have supported the case of the prosecution, despite
the learned Sessions Court by way of the impugned judgment
and order dated 25.03.2026 passed under Sessions Case No.87
of 2025 acquitted the respondent – accused herein. Hence, the
present appeal has been preferred by the complainant.
3.
Submissions made on behalf of the appellant are as under:
3.1
It is submitted that the learned Sessions Court has made a
grave error by not appreciating the medical evidence rendered by
Doctor Subhash Bhalabhai Patel (PW-8, Exh-23) and the post-
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
mortem report at Exh.27, which clearly establishes the fact that
the deceased died on account of severe internal injuries and
respiratory failures caused by multiple rib fractures given by the
accused with a hammer corresponding to severe kick and fist
blows.
3.2
It is submitted that although the first informant, namely,
Vishnuji Shankarji Thakor (PW-5, Exh.17), the wife of the
deceased Jamnaben (PW-6, Exh.19) and Jagdishji Pravinji
Thakor (PW-7, Exh.20) have turned hostile by not supporting the
prosecution case, the learned Sessions Court has overlooked by
discarding their evidence in its entirety. It is submitted that it is
well settled that the evidence of the hostile witnesses does not
become wholly inadmissible, and that the portion thereof which
supports the case of the prosecution can and ought to be relied
upon. It is submitted that, in the present case, the evidence of
the said witnesses, to the extent it corroborates the presence of
the respondent-accused at the scene of crime, ought to have
been accepted and acted upon by the learned Sessions Court.
3.3
It is further submitted that the learned Sessions Court
failed to appreciate the significance of the prompt intimation
furnished by the Hospital at Exhibit-31, which was duly
recorded by Assistant Sub-Inspector Kumudsinh Rajendrasinh
(PW-9, Exh-30), and which specifically records that the deceased
had been assaulted. It is submitted that the said intimation,
being free from any afterthought, lends further credence to the
case of the prosecution and ought to have been given due
weightage by the learned Sessions Court.
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
3.4
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
It is further submitted that the Investigating Officer,
Gajendrasinh Ajitsinh Solanki (PW-10, Exh-34), has fully
supported the case of the prosecution, and that his testimony,
coupled with the other evidence on record, completes the chain
of circumstances pointing towards the guilt of the accused.
3.5
It is further submitted that the incident occurred inside
the residential premises of the deceased during the night hours,
and that it is an admitted position that the accused was present
in the house at the relevant time when the deceased sustained
the fatal injuries. It is submitted that, in such circumstances,
the burden lay upon the accused to offer a plausible explanation
regarding the manner in which the deceased sustained the fatal
injuries, which burden the accused has failed to discharge, and
the learned Sessions Court erred in overlooking this material
aspect.
3.6. It is submitted that, having regard to the cumulative effect
of the medical evidence, the partly corroborative testimony of the
hostile witnesses, the hospital intimation, and the evidence of
the Investigating Officer, the prosecution has been able to
establish a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances
conclusively pointing to the guilt of the respondent-accused. It is
submitted that the findings recorded by the learned Sessions
Court are perverse, contrary to the evidence on record, and
resulted in a miscarriage of justice, and that the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal is, therefore, unsustainable in
law and deserves to be quashed and set aside, and the accused
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
deserves to be convicted and suitably sentenced for the offence
with which he stands charged.
4.
We have heard the learned APP for the State at the stage of
admission and carefully examined the oral and documentary
evidences adduced before the learned Sessions Court.
- Evaluation of the Evidence of the Complainant and the other
Witnesses (PW-5, PW-6 and PW-7):
5.
The evidence of the complainant, Vishnuji Shankarji
Thakor (PW-5, Exh-17), the wife of the deceased, Jamnaben
Pravinji Thakor (PW-6, Exh-19), and the son of the deceased,
Jagdishji Pravinji Thakor (PW-7, Exh-20), when read together,
discloses a consistent version to the effect that the deceased was
a person of intemperate habits and that on the relevant night,
the deceased had consumed liquor and engaged in some
altercation within the house, thereafter he went to sleep and was
found unresponsive the following morning. None of the said
witnesses have any knowledge as to the actual cause of his
death. All three witnesses have specifically and categorically
deposed that there was no altercation between the deceased and
the respondent-accused over food, and that it is not the case
that the respondent-accused assaulted the deceased by kicks or
fist blows resulting in his death.
5.1
Despite detailed cross-examination on the material facts of
the prosecution case, none of the said witnesses have furnished
even a shred of evidence connecting the respondent-accused
with the assault upon the deceased, and all three were, in the
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
circumstances, upon request of the learned APP, rightly declared
hostile to the prosecution.
5.2
Though it is settled law that the evidence of a hostile
witness does not stand wholly effaced and the portion thereof
supporting the prosecution may be relied upon, this Court, on a
close reading of the depositions of PW-5, PW-6 and PW-7, finds
no such supporting thread. On the contrary, being the persons
in closest proximity to the deceased - his brother, wife and son,
their affirmative and consistent denial of any assault by the
respondent-accused, coupled with their attribution of the
deceased's habitual intemperance, materially weakens rather
than advancing the prosecution case. Their evidence, therefore,
furnishes no basis whatsoever to connect the respondentaccused with the death of the deceased.
-Evaluation of the medical and scientific evidences:
6.
The evidence of Dr. Subhash Bhalabhai Patel (PW-8, Exh-
23), the Medical Officer who conducted the post-mortem
examination of the deceased, Pravinji Shankarji Thakor, read
together with the post-mortem notes at Exhibit-27, discloses
that upon internal examination the deceased was found to have
sustained fractures of the third, fourth and fifth ribs on the right
side and the third to seventh ribs on the left side, with
associated injuries to the lobes of both lungs, resulting in
accumulation of approximately 500 ml of blood in the right
thoracic cavity and approximately 1 litre of blood in the left
thoracic cavity. Viscera samples were duly preserved and
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
forwarded for chemical analysis vide the forwarding memo at
Exhibit-26, and upon receipt of the Forensic Science Laboratory
report (Exhibit-29), which disclosed no presence of alcohol or
chemical poison, the witness confirmed the final cause of death
as cardio-respiratory failure on account of hemorrhagic shock
resulting from the said internal chest injuries.
6.1
The Medical Officer has further deposed that such fracture
of the rib cage is consistent with a person being subjected to
forceful kicks and fist blows, and that the death of the deceased
in the present case occurred on account of the fracture of the
ribs and the consequent lung injury, thereby conclusively ruling
out the theory of natural death. This Court finds the said
testimony to be natural, consistent, and duly corroborated by
the post-mortem notes and the Forensic Science Laboratory
report. Being an independent expert witness with no conceivable
interest in the outcome of the proceedings, there is no reason to
disbelieve him. This Court, therefore, concurs with the finding of
the learned Trial Court that the death of the deceased was
homicidal in nature, caused by blunt force trauma to the chest.
6.2
It is, however, clarified that the aforesaid finding is
confined to the nature and cause of death alone and does not
extend to the question of identity of the assailant or the
culpability of the respondent-accused, which shall be considered
upon appreciation of the evidence of the remaining material
witnesses.
7.
The evidence of Chiragkumar Dashrathlal Patel (PW-3,
Exh-12), the Forensic Science Laboratory Officer, discloses that
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
pursuant
to
the
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
telephonic
message
received
from
the
Investigating Officer, P.I. Shri G.A. Solanki, at 14:44 hours on
05.07.2025, regarding registration of the offence at Ladol Police
Station (Part-A, Crime Reg. No.120607925011525), the said
witness conducted forensic examination of the scene of offence
between 15:45 hours and 16:45 hours on the same day.
7.1 Upon inspection of the said premises, the witness has
candidly deposed that no suspicious stains, marks, or articles
connected with the incident were found at the scene, and the
spot panchnama/inspection report prepared to the said effect
has been produced at Exhibit-14.
7.2 This Court finds that the evidence of the FSL Officer, being
that of an independent scientific witness, is not shown to suffer
from any infirmity, and there is no reason to disbelieve the same.
However, the said evidence, far from corroborating the case of
the
prosecution,
records
a
conspicuous
absence
of
any
bloodstains, marks or incriminating articles at the very spot
where the fatal assault is alleged to have taken place, a
circumstance which does not tilt easily with the prosecution's
case of a violent assault involving kicks and fist blows of
sufficient force to fracture multiple ribs. This aspect shall be
considered along with the other evidence on record while arriving
at
the
final
conclusion
regarding
respondent-accused.
the
culpability
of
the
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
-Evaluation of the evidence of the Police Personnel and I.O.’s:
8.
The evidence of Kumudben Rajendrasinh (PW-9, Exh-30),
who was posted as P.S.O. at Ladol Police Station on 05.07.2025,
discloses that upon receipt of information from one Ranjitsinh
Thakor of Biliya village at 07:10 hours regarding an assault
upon Pravinji Shankarji Thakor of Malosan village, the said
witness recorded the telephonic entry at Entry No.76/25 and
forwarded the same to A.S.I. Pravinbhai Babubhai, vide the entry
produced at Exhibit-31. This Court finds that the said witness
has
merely
recorded
the
hospital/telephonic
entry
and,
admittedly, has performed no further investigative role in the
matter. The evidence of this witness, therefore, is formal in
nature and does not carry the prosecution case any further, one
way or the other.
8.1
The evidence of the Investigating Officer, Gajendrasinh
Ajitsinh Solanki (PW-10, Exh-34), who was posted as P.I. at
Ladol Police Station on the relevant date. As per the investigation
undertaken by him, he firstly recorded the inquest panchnama
(Exh-7) of the deceased pursuant to the report of the Executive
Magistrate (Exh-35). After that, he undertook recording of the
complaint at the instance of the complainant, Vishnubhai
Shankarbhai Thakor (Exh-18), and registration of the offence
under Section 103(1) of the B.N.S. along with recording of
statements of the material witnesses. Thereafter, he prepared
the panchnama of the scene of offence (Exh-16) and the
panchnama for seizure of the clothes of the deceased (Exh-32)
and of the accused (Exh-21). After obtaining of the post-mortem
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
notes and medical certificate (Exh-27 and Exh-28); receipt of the
spot inspection report (Exh-14) and the site plan (Exh-9 to Exh11); he arrested the accused on 05.07.2025 (Exh-38); forwarding
the Muddamal for forensic examination (Exh-39) and receipt of
the FSL reports pertaining to the toxicology, biology and serology
divisions
(Exh-40
to
Exh-44);
and,
upon
culmination
of
investigation, he filed the charge-sheet against the accused.
8.2
This Court finds that the evidence of the Investigating
Officer is essentially formal and procedural in character, being
confined to a reiteration of the steps of investigation undertaken
by him and a repetition, in his deposition, of the statements
earlier furnished to him by the complainant and other witnesses
during investigation. Such evidence, being merely corroborative
of the investigative process and not being substantive evidence of
the guilt of the respondent-accused, cannot, by itself, fill the
gaps left by the complainant and other witnesses who have not
supported the case of the prosecution on the material aspect of
identity and culpability. The evidence of the Investigating Officer,
therefore,
does
not
materially
advance
the
case
of
the
prosecution any further than what has already been considered.
9.
Upon cumulative appreciation of the entire evidence on
record, this Court finds that while the medical evidence of Dr.
Subhash Bhalabhai Patel (PW-8) conclusively establishes that
the deceased died a homicidal death on account of fracture of
the ribs and consequent internal chest injuries, the prosecution
has failed to establish, through any cogent or reliable evidence,
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
that it was the respondent-accused who inflicted the said
injuries upon the deceased.
10.
The complainant (PW-5) and all the eyewitnesses from the
household of the deceased have turned hostile and have
furnished
no
evidence,
even
remotely,
connecting
the
respondent-accused with the assault. The panch witnesses have
merely identified their signatures on the panchnamas without
supporting the substantive facts of the prosecution case. The
FSL Officer's spot inspection revealed no incriminating stains,
marks or articles at the scene of offence; and the evidence of the
police witnesses, being formal and investigative in character,
does not fill this vital gap, in absence of direct and corroborative
evidences
implicating
the
respondent
–
accused,
further
mitigates against the prosecution version.
11.
With regard to the submissions advanced by the learned
APP that the incident in question had taken place in proximity of
house of the accused along with the deceased, however, nothing
sort of any such material had been placed on record. Apart from
that, even considering Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act,
initially, the burden lies on the prosecution to successfully prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt and it is only after that, the
burden of proof would shift under Section 106 of the Indian
Evidence Act to rebut the same. Thus, a presumption cannot be
drawn
to
the
accused,
in
absence
of
material
witness/substantial evidence produced by the prosecution, as
held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Anees v. The
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
State Govt of NCT, reported in 2024 LiveLaw (SC) 344.
12.
At this juncture, it is apt to refer the judgment of the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court,
in
the
case
of
Tulasareddi
@
Mudakappa & Anr. v. The State of Karnataka & Ors., 2026 INSC
67, the relevant paragraphs of which read as under:
“26. At this stage, we would like to refer the decisions rendered
by this Court on the aspect of interference of Appellate Court in
the appeal filed by the State challenging the acquittal of the
accused recorded by the Trial Court.
27. In the case of Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar v. State of
Karnataka this Court held in paragraphs 39 to 42 as under:
39. This Court in Rajesh Prasad v. State of Bihar [Rajesh
Prasad v. State of Bihar,(2022) 3 SCC 471 : (2022) 2 SCC
(Cri) 31] encapsulated the legal position covering the field
after considering various earlier judgments and held as
below : (SCC pp.482-83, para 29)
“29. After referring to a catena of judgments, this Court
culled out the following general principles regarding the
powers of the appellate court while dealing with an
appeal against an order of acquittal in the following
words: (Chandrappacase [Chandrappa v. State of
Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415 : (2007) 2 SCC (Cri)325],
SCC p. 432, para 42)
‘42. From the above decisions, in our considered view,
the following general principles regarding powers of the
appellate court while dealing with an appeal against an
order of acquittal emerge:
(1)
An appellate court has full power to review,
reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which
the order of acquittal is founded.
(2)
The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 puts no limitation,
restriction or condition on exercise of such power and
an appellate court on the evidence before it may reach
its own conclusion, both on questions of fact and of
law.
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
(3)
Various expressions, such as, “substantial and
compelling reasons”, “good and sufficient grounds”,
“very strong” circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”,
“glaring mistakes”, etc. are not intended to curtail
extensive powers of an appellate court in an appeal
against acquittal. Such phraseologies are more in the
nature of “flourishes of language” to emphasise the
reluctance of an appellate court to interfere with
acquittal than to curtail the power of the court to
review the evidence and to come to its own conclusion.
(4)
An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in
case of acquittal, there is double presumption in
favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption of
innocence is available to him under the fundamental
principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person
shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved
guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the
accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption
of his innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and
strengthened by the trial court.
(5)
If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the appellate court should
not disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the
trial court.’
40. Further, in H.D. Sundara v. State of Karnataka [H.D.
Sundara v. State of Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581 : (2023) 3
SCC (Cri) 748] this Court summarised the principles
governing the exercise of appellate jurisdiction while dealing
with an appeal against acquittal under Section 378 CrPC as
follows : (SCC p. 584, para 8)
“8..… 8.1.
The acquittal of the accused
strengthens the presumption of innocence,
further
8.2. The appellate court, while hearing an appeal against
acquittal, is entitled to reappreciate the oral and
documentary evidence,
8.3. The appellate court, while deciding an appeal against
acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is required to
consider whether the view taken by the trial court is a
possible view which could have been taken on the basis of
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
the evidence on record,
8.4. If the view taken is a possible view, the appellate court
cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground that
another view was also possible, and
8.5. The appellate court can interfere with the order of
acquittal only if it comes to a finding that the only
conclusion which can be recorded on the basis of the
evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused was
proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no other conclusion
was possible.”
41. Thus, it is beyond the pale of doubt that the scope of
interference by an appellate court for reversing the judgment
of acquittal recorded by the trial court in favour of the
accused has to be exercised within the four corners of the
following principles:
41.1. That the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent
perversity,
41.2. That the same is based on a misreading/omission to
consider material evidence on record, and
41.3. That no two reasonable views are possible and only the
view consistent with the guilt of the accused is possible from
the evidence available on record.
42. The appellate court, in order to interfere with the
judgment of acquittal would have to record pertinent
findings on the above factors if it is inclined to reverse the
judgment of acquittal rendered by the trial court.
xxx xxx xxx
29. From the aforesaid decisions rendered by this Court, it can
be said that if two reasonable conclusions are possible on the
basis of the evidence on record, the Appellate Court should not
disturb the findings of acquittal recorded by the Trial Court.
Further, if the view taken is a possible view, the Appellate Court
cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground that
another view was also possible. The following principles have to
be kept in mind by the Appellate Court while dealing with the
appeals against an order of acquittal:
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
13.
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
(a)
whether the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent
perversity,
(b)
whether the judgment is based on misreading/omission
to consider the material evidence on record,
(c)
an order of acquittal is to be interfered with only when
there are “compelling and substantial reasons” for
doing so. If the order is “clearly unreasonable”, it is a
compelling reason for interference.’
(d)
the appellate court, while deciding an appeal against
acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is required
to consider whether the view taken by the trial court is
a possible view which could have been taken on the
basis of the evidence on record,
(e)
if the view taken is a possible view, the appellate court
cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground
that another view was also possible, and
(f)
the appellate court can interfere with the order of
acquittal only if it comes to a finding that the only
conclusion which can be recorded on the basis of the
evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused
was proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no other
conclusion was possible.”...
In a nutshell, the learned Sessions Court rightly held that
the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt. Its finding
proceeds upon a proper and careful appreciation of the
deposition of the material witnesses, and cannot be said to be
perverse or contrary to the material available. This Court,
accordingly, finds no ground warranting interference with the
reasoning of the learned Sessions Court on this part of the case.
14.
In the result, the present appeal sans merit and deserves
to be dismissed and accordingly, it is dismissed.
R/CR.A/2156/2026(GJHC240660822026)
15.
ORDER DATED: 21/09/2026
The impugned judgment and order of acquittal dated
25.03.2026 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Mehsana in
Sessions Case No.87 of 2025 stands confirmed.
16.
Record and proceeding, if any, be remitted to the
concerned Court.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
PARMAR KRISH/16
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review