Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST ACQUITTAL) NO. 2233 of 2026
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
sd/-
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
sd/-
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
no
==========================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
KANUBHAI DALABHAI BARIA & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR LB DABHI ADDITIONAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the Appellant(s) No.
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 12/10/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI)
1.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the judgment and order
dated 19.04.2025 passed by the learned 4 th Additional Sessions
Judge, Limkheda at Dahod in Sessions Case No.53 of 2023,
whereby the learned Sessions Judge, acquitted the accused from
the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201, 34, 120(B) of
the Indian Penal Code, (for short, ‘I.P.C.’) 1860, the present
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
appeal under Section 419 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita (for short, ‘BNSS’), 2023 has been preferred by the
appellant herein.
2.
For brevity and convenience, parties are referred to as per
their original status before the learned Sessions Court.
2.1
Brief facts of the case are as under:
3.
The complainant, Mukeshbhai Ramanbhai Bariya, is a
resident of Chundadi, Dungarbhit Faliyu, Taluka Singvad,
District Dahod. Ramanbhai Sonabhai Bariya (for short, ‘the
deceased), was his father. According to the prosecution, on
15.12.2022, at about 18:00 hours, the complainant and his
relative, Sureshbhai Kanubhai Bariya, went to village Borgota to
buy milk and thereafter they returned and sat in the house of
Sureshbhai Kanubhai Bariya, which was situated at a distance
of about thirty feet from the house of Kanubhai Dalabhai Bariya.
At about 19:30 hours, the complainant saw, in the light, his
father, along with Rameshbhai Kanubhai Bariya and Saburbhai
Dalabhai Bariya, coming out of the house of Kanubhai Dalabhai
Bariya, with Saburbhai Dalabhai Bariya carrying a stick in his
hand. Thereafter, the complainant heard the shout of his father
from the direction of the canal, at a distance of about 100 mtrs.
from the house of Sureshbhai Kanubhai. He rushed towards the
canal and heard the sound of someone running through dry
leaves towards the eucalyptus trees, but nothing could be seen
even with the aid of his mobile torch. The complainant then
informed his mother, Mangliben, and his brother, Sureshbhai,
and, upon inquiry, found that the deceased had not reached
home. In the course of the search, the complainant and his
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
family members did not find Rameshbhai Kanubhai Bariya,
Saburbhai Dalabhai Bariya and Kanubhai Dalabhai Bariya at
their houses, and inquiry at the house of his paternal uncle,
Fulsinghbhai Sonabhai Bariya, also yielded no trace of the
deceased.
3.1 On the following morning, at about 06:00 hours, the
complainant, his brother Sureshbhai Ramanbhai Bariya and his
mother went to the canal and found the dead body of the
deceased submerged in the water. Sureshbhai Ramanbhai
Bariya gave an information of accidental death at Randhikpur
Police Station. When the body of the deceased was taken out of
the water, injuries were noticed on the head, from which blood
was oozing. The post-mortem examination was conducted, and
the doctor opined that the death was caused by injuries
sustained on the head. Thereupon, the complainant lodged the
complaint on 19.12.2022 at Randhikpur Police Station against
Rameshbhai Kanubhai Bariya, Saburbhai Dalabhai Bariya and
Kanubhai Dalabhai Bariya, all being residents of Chundadi,
Dungarbhit Faliyu, Taluka Singvad, District Dahod, alleging that
the three accused, in pursuance of a pre-planned design, had
killed his father and thrown the body into the canal. The motive
alleged was that the three paternal uncles of the deceased, who
were issue-less and were being maintained by the family of the
deceased, owned land which, in the event of the deceased being
eliminated, would devolve upon Kanubhai Dalabhai Bariya and
his sons.
3.2 On the basis of the said complaint, an offence came to be
registered
at
Randhikpur
Police
Station
Part-A
G.R.
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
No.11821001220297 of 2022 for the offences punishable under
Sections 302, 201, 120(B) and 34 of the Indian Penal Code (for
short, ‘I.P.C’), and the investigation was entrusted to the
Investigating Officer.
3.3
In the course of investigation, the accused were arrested,
Panchnamas were drawn, and the statements of the concerned
witnesses were recorded. On finding sufficient material against
the accused, the Investigating Officer filed the charge-sheet on
15.03.2023
before
the
learned
Additional
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate, Limkheda, which was registered as Criminal Case
No.1107 of 2023, and summons were issued to the accused.
Upon appearance of the accused and after ensuring compliance
with the supply of copies of the police papers, the learned
Magistrate, finding that the case was exclusively triable by the
Court of Sessions, committed the case under Section 209 of the
Criminal Procedure Code (for short, ‘Cr.P.C.’), 1973 by order
dated 31.05.2023 to the learned Additional Sessions Court,
Limkheda, where it was registered as Sessions Case No.53 of
2023. The learned Sessions Court, after hearing the learned
advocates for the parties on the point of charge, framed the
charge against the accused at Exhibit 6 for the offences and the
accused were pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried, and
their pleas were recorded at Exhibit 7.
3.4
In support of its case, the prosecution examined witnesses
and produced documentary evidence, and the evidence was
closed by a pursis at Exhibit 57. The further statements of the
accused under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. were recorded, wherein
they denied the incriminating circumstances appearing against
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
them and claimed that they were innocent and had been falsely
implicated. Upon conclusion of the trial and after hearing the
learned Additional Public Prosecutor and the learned advocate
for the accused, the learned Sessions Court, by the impugned
judgment and order, acquitted the accused from the offences
punishable under Sections 302, 201, 34, 120(B) of the I.P.C..
3.5
Being aggrieved, the appellant has preferred the present
appeal.
4.
Submissions made on behalf of the appellant are as under:
4.1
It is submitted that the impugned judgment and order of
acquittal passed by the learned Sessions Court is erroneous,
contrary to the evidence on record and against the settled
principles of criminal jurisprudence. It is submitted that the
offence was committed in the secrecy of the night, and direct
eye-witness evidence is rarely available in such cases. The case
rests on circumstantial evidence, and the learned Sessions Court
ought
to
have
appreciated
whether
the
prosecution
had
completed the chain of circumstances, instead of insisting upon
primary or ocular evidence.
4.2
It is submitted that the learned Sessions Court rightly
concluded on Issue No.1 that the death of the deceased was
homicidal and not accidental. However, while dealing with the
remaining aspects of the evidence, the learned Sessions Court
erroneously disbelieved the prosecution case on the basis of a
solitary admission elicited in the cross-examination of the
Medical Officer, namely Dr. Manishkumar Tulsibhai Kharadi
(PW-10, Exh.40), that such an injury could possibly result from
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
an accidental fall on a hard surface. It is submitted that the said
witness had categorically deposed in his examination-in-chief
that the death was caused by excessive haemorrhage due to
head injury and not by any other injury. A positive and
categorical expert opinion could not have been discarded on the
strength of a hypothetical suggestion given in the crossexamination, particularly when the defence put only a few
questions to the witness, which did not dilute his opinion. The
defence
also
failed
to
establish
any
other
circumstance
supporting the theory of accidental fall.
4.3
It is further submitted that the case of the prosecution
does not rest on the theory of "last seen together" alone, but the
entire
chain
of
circumstances
stands
established.
PW-2
Sureshbhai Ramanbhai Baria (Exh.12), son of the deceased, had
seen the deceased in the company of the respondent-accused,
and shortly thereafter the shout of the deceased was heard from
the direction of the canal. The learned Sessions Court has,
however, placed undue emphasis on minor contradictions in the
depositions of PW-1 Mukeshbhai Ramanbhai Baria (Exh.10),
PW-2 Sureshbhai Ramanbhai Baria (Exh.12), PW-3 Mangaliben
Ramanbhai Baria (Exh.14), PW-5 Ashwinbhai Ramanbhai Baria
(Exh.17) and PW-6 Meenaben Sureshbhai Baria (Exh.18). Merely
because these witnesses are family members of the deceased,
their testimony could not have been discarded in its entirety,
and the approach of the learned Sessions Court is contrary to
settled principles of law.
4.4
It is submitted that the initial information of accidental
death and the subsequent registration of the complaint for the
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
offence of murder stands fully explained by the facts and the
evidence of the witnesses, since the offence was not detected at
the first instance and the complaint was lodged only after the
post-mortem opinion. As regards motive, it is submitted that the
same pertained to a dispute over agricultural land, and the
learned Sessions Court erred in holding that the absence of
motive was fatal to the prosecution. In any event, absence of a
conclusively proved motive is not fatal where the other
circumstances form a complete chain.
4.5
In conclusion, it is submitted that the learned Sessions
Court has applied an erroneous standard of proof, and when the
prosecution has established the complete chain of circumstances
pointing solely towards the guilt of the respondent-accused, the
impugned
judgment
and
order
of
acquittal
is
perverse,
unsustainable and deserves to be quashed and set aside, and
the respondent-accused deserve to be convicted for the offences
with which they were charged. Therefore, it is submitted to allow
the present appeal.
5.
We have heard learned APP for the State, at the stage of
admission,
and
carefully
perused
the
oral
as
well
as
documentary evidences adduced before the learned Sessions
Court.
6.
Since the learned Sessions Court has recorded a finding on
Issue No.1 that the death of Ramanbhai Sonabhai Bariya was
homicidal, this Court has, at the outset, re-appreciated the
evidence of PW-9 Dr. Manishkumar Tulsiprasad Kharadi,
Medical Officer, Singvad (Exh.40), who conducted the postmortem examination on 16.12.2022. The post-mortem notes
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
were proved at Exh.42. The body was identified by the son of the
deceased, Sureshbhai Ramanbhai Bariya.
6.1
The Medical Officer noted six ante-mortem injuries. Injury
Nos.1 to 4 were lacerated wounds on the head, of which injury
Nos.1 and 2 were interconnected, and injury Nos.5 and 6 were
abrasions over the right shoulder and the nose. On dissection, a
skull fracture 11 cm in length was found on the left side of the
head, with clotted blood and a subarachnoid haemorrhage over
both sides of the head. The remaining internal organs were
normal.
6.2
After perusing the FSL reports (Exhs.43 and 44), the
Medical Officer categorically opined that death was caused by
excessive bleeding resulting from the head injuries, and not by
any other injury. He further stated that the injuries were
grievous in nature and sufficient in the ordinary course to cause
death.
6.3
In cross-examination, the Medical Officer admitted that
such injuries could possibly result if a person accidentally fell
into a canal, or jumped into it with the intention of committing
suicide, and struck a hard and blunt object. This Court is of the
view that the said admission indicates only a possibility, which
cannot displace the positive opinion of the expert founded on the
nature, number and location of the injuries. The burden cast on
the defence to show that the opinion is erroneous or contrary to
medical jurisprudence, nor has it led any evidence to establish
the plea of accidental fall or suicide, as the entire burden rests
on the prosecution to prove its stance beyond doubt.
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
6.4
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
In view of the above, the finding of the learned Sessions
Court on Issue No.1 that the death was unnatural and
homicidal, amounting to culpable homicide, is just and proper,
and this Court finds no reason to interfere with it.
6.5
The above findings are confined to the injuries and the
cause of death. The question of the involvement of the
respondent-accused, including the circumstance of "last seen
together", is to be examined separately.
7.
Having held that the death of the deceased was homicidal,
the only question that survives is whether the prosecution has
proved, by a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances,
that it was the respondent-accused who caused the death. The
case being admittedly one of circumstantial evidence, and the
impugned judgment being one of acquittal, this Court is
conscious of the limited scope of interference under Section 378
(New Section 419 of the BNSS) of the Code. Interference is
warranted only if the view taken by the learned Sessions Court is
perverse or wholly unreasonable; it is not warranted merely
because another view is possible.
8.
The evidence of PW-1 Mukeshbhai Ramanbhai Bariya
(Exh.10) is the sole basis for the circumstance of "last seen
together". He deposed that his father went towards the canal
with Rameshbhai Kanubhai Bariya and Saburbhai Dalabhai
Bariya, the latter carrying a stick, and that shortly afterwards he
heard his father's shout. On rushing to the canal, he saw no
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
one, even with the aid of his mobile torch. He candidly admitted
that he did not see anyone assault his father. No witness saw the
deceased and the respondent-accused standing together near
the canal, and nothing incriminating was recovered from the
house of any respondent-accused.
8.1
Further, the learned Sessions Court as transpires, has
rightly concluded that the case is devoid of direct evidence and
that the circumstance of "last seen together" rests solely on the
testimony of PW-1, the complainant. He claims to have seen the
deceased proceeding towards the canal with Rameshbhai
Kanubhai Bariya and Saburbhai Dalabhai Bariya, the latter
holding a stick, and to have heard the shout of his father shortly
thereafter. He further claims to have conveyed these facts to his
mother, his brother and the other prosecution witnesses. The
fact of the death of the deceased, who was found in the canal
with head injuries, is not in dispute. The real question is who
caused the injuries, and on that question no witness has come
forward to state how, in what circumstances and by whom they
were inflicted. It is significant that when the information of
accidental death was lodged on 16.12.2022 by PW-2 Sureshbhai
Ramanbhai Bariya (Exh.12), no mention was made of the
deceased having been seen with the respondent-accused. The
complaint implicating them was lodged only on 19.12.2022, four
days after the incident and after the post-mortem opinion. It is
only after lapse of time, the same fact appears to have been
manipulated, concocted later on which do not find any legs to
stand.
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
9.
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
As regards the head injuries, this Court has already held
that the death is homicidal on the strength of the Medical
Officer's categorical opinion. At the same time, the nature of the
death is distinct from the question of who caused it. The opinion
of the Medical Officer is silent on the identity of the assailant. No
weapon was recovered at the instance of any respondentaccused. The FSL report did not connect them with the crime.
The stick allegedly carried by Saburbhai Dalabhai Bariya was
never seized or linked to the injuries.
10.
It further transpires that the prosecution also failed to
establish the motive. The allegation that the respondent-accused
wished to grab the land of the three issueless uncles is not
supported by any evidence of a dispute, civil litigation or even a
quarrel between the parties over such land. In fact, PW-1 denied
that there was any such dispute between his father and
Fulsinghbhai. Admittedly, the parties were not on speaking
terms on account of an altogether different matter, namely the
sale of a damaged car. While absence of motive is not fatal where
the chain of circumstances is complete, in a case based wholly
on circumstantial evidence, the failure to prove a motive which
the prosecution itself has alleged weighs against it.
11.
The submission of the learned APP that the learned
Sessions Court discarded the evidence of the family members of
the deceased solely on account of their relationship cannot be
accepted. The learned Sessions Court has expressly held that the
evidence of related witnesses is not to be rejected for that reason
alone, but must be scrutinized closely. On such scrutiny, the
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
contradictions noted above are not minor; they relate to the very
genesis of the prosecution case. The circumstances relied on are
not conclusive, and there is no evidence placing the respondentaccused at the scene of the offence at the relevant time. Nor does
the evidence indicate that their mobile locations coincided with
those of the deceased at the relevant time.
12.
Thus, the whole case of the prosecution rests on the
circumstantial evidence; however the prosecution has failed to
place on record any such circumstances to link the chain so as
to surface the implication of the accused in commission of the
crime in question. It is pertinent to note that even as per the
case of the prosecution, in absence of any motive, that itself is
sufficient to dislodge the case of prosecution if other proven
circumstances could form a chain so complete as to indicate that
in all human probability it is accused and no one else who
committed crime yet, in a case based on circumstantial evidence,
motive plays an important part.
13.
Now, reverting back to the facts of the present case,
nothing sort of any such material seems to be placed on record
to indicate as to motive behind the commission of the offence in
question and therefore, admittedly the whole case rests on the
circumstantial evidence and considering the way in which the
entire incident have been described, followed by the investigation
carried out by the IO and to convict the accused in absence of
any direct evidence though dealing with the case based on
circumstantial evidence, the important aspect which requires to
be considered are such as (i) whether circumstances relied by
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
prosecution have been proved beyond reasonable doubt; (ii)
whether
those
circumstances
are
of
a
definite
tendency
unerringly pointing towards guilt of accused; (iii) whether those
circumstances taken cumulatively form a chain so far complete
that there is no escape from conclusion that within all human
probability crime was committed by accused; (iv) whether they
are consistent only with hypothesis of accused being guilty; and
lastly (v) whether they exclude every possible hypothesis except
one to be proved.
14.
In a case of circumstantial evidence, the chain is required
to be completed as mandated under the law so as to indicate the
guilt of the accused while discarding any other theory of the
crime. If one of the link goes missing and not proved, in view of
the settled law on the point, the conviction is required to be
interfered with. At this stage, with profit, we may refer to the
decision in case of Laxman Prasad Alias Laxman (supra) where
the Hon’ble Apex Court after referring to Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra [(1984) 4 SCC 116] and
Shailendra Rajdev Pasvan vs. State of Gujarat [(2020) 14 SCC
750] has quashed the conviction by making observations in
paragraph 2 to 4 as under:
“2. The present one is a case of circumstantial evidence.
The prosecution led evidence to establish three links of the
chain: (i) motive, (ii) last seen, and (iii) recovery of weapon
of assault, at the pointing out of the appellant. The High
Court, while dealing with the evidence on record, agreed
with the finding of motive and the last seen, however,
insofar as the recovery of the weapon of assault and
bloodstained clothes were concerned, the High Court in
para 18 of the judgment held the same to be invalid and
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
also goes to the extent to say that the recovery which has
been made does not indicate that the appellant has
committed the offence. Still, it observed that looking to the
entire gamut and other clinching evidence against the
appellant of last seen and motive, affirmed the conviction.
3.
We do not find such conclusion of the High Court to
be strictly in accordance with law. In a case of
circumstantial evidence, the chain has to be complete in all
respects so as to indicate the guilt of the accused and also
exclude any other theory of the crime. The law is well
settled on the above point. Reference may be had to the
following cases:
(i) Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra,
(ii) Shailendra Rajdev Pasvan v. State of Gujarat.
4. Thus, if the High Court found one of the links to be
missing and not proved in view of the settled law on the
point, the conviction ought to have been interfered with.”
15.
We would like to place on record the scope of interference
in an appeal against the acquittal and when the same is
justified. In exceptional cases, where there are compelling
circumstances and the judgment under appeal is found to be
perverse, the appellate court can interfere with the judgment of
acquittal. The Appellate Court should consider the presence of
innocence of the accused and further that, the trial Court’s
acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence. Interference
in a routine manner, where the other view of possible should be
avoided, unless there are reasons for interference, as the same
has been laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of
Tulasareddi @ Mudakappa & Anr. v. The State of Karnataka &
Ors., 2026 INSC 67.
R/CR.A/2233/2026
(GJHC240610452026)
16.
JUDGMENT DATED: 12/10/2026
In a nutshell, even where two views are reasonably possible
on the evidence, the view favorable to the accused must be
adopted, and the presumption of innocence, strengthened by a
judgment of acquittal, is not to be disturbed lightly. The view
taken by the learned Sessions Court that the prosecution failed
to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the respondent-accused
caused the death is a plausible and reasonable one, and it is
neither perverse nor contrary to the evidence. The chain of
circumstances is incomplete, and the respondent-accused are
entitled to the benefit of doubt.
17.
In view of the foregoing, the present appeal sans merit and
deserves to be dismissed and accordingly, it is dismissed.
18.
The impugned judgment and order dated 19.04.2025
passed by the learned 4th Additional Sessions Judge, Limkheda
at Dahod in Sessions Case No.53 of 2023 stands confirmed.
19.
Record and proceeding, if any, be remitted to the
concerned Court.
sd/(ILESH J. VORA,J)
sd/(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
PARMAR KRISH/12
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review